Transcript of #695 - Happiness Expert Dr. Arthur Brooks

01:43:46 115 min read 52 views Published 4 days ago

Copy link
Episode summary

In this episode of This Past Weekend, Theo Von talks with social scientist Arthur Brooks about his book The Meaning of Your Life. Brooks argues that happiness is not a feeling but rests on three elements: enjoyment, satisfaction from accomplishment through struggle, and meaning.

He explains why pursuing success and wealth often leaves people unfulfilled, and why screens and social media can erode connection and a sense of purpose. The conversation covers practical habits such as avoiding phones during the first and last hour of the day and eating with others, along with his framework of three questions about coherence, purpose and significance.

Listeners will hear how these ideas apply to everyday life.

In this episode Theo Von, Arthur Brooks

This transcript of the episode with Dr. Arthur Brooks on meaning and happiness was made with HappyScribe's technology, the same behind its AI meeting assistant.

Arthur Brooks00:00:00

Today's guest is an author and a social scientist; he's a professor at Vanderbilt and a senior fellow at the Harvard Business School, known for his popular class "Leadership and Happiness." He's here discussing his new book, "The Meaning of Your Life," which is available now. I had a great time with today's guest, Dr. Arthur Brooks.

Theo Von00:00:24

Shine on me, and I will find a song I will sing about you.

Arthur Brooks00:00:38

Well, the whole idea of, you know, Jesus carrying the cross—that has this incredible imagery, that idea that each one of us has to take up our cross and carry it. I mean, you woke up heavy today.

Theo Von00:00:47

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:00:48

You were carrying your cross.

Theo Von00:00:49

Yes, yes.

Arthur Brooks00:00:49

And that has meaning, but you—and the whole modern therapeutic culture says, "Theo, you've got to get rid of that feeling. That's a pathology." No, it's not. It's an opportunity. That's what that is. That means something. And then we can actually kind of get to the deep meaning of what that is, that can actually help you learn and grow.

Theo Von00:01:06

Amen.

Arthur Brooks00:01:07

And to say, "Man, there's suffering today," okay, bring it on. Put me in, coach.

Theo Von00:01:11

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:01:11

Right?

Theo Von00:01:13

Um, Arthur C. Brooks, thank you so much for joining us. I know that you are an author, a social scientist, and a professor, is that fair to say?

Arthur Brooks00:01:23

That's right. And I've been teaching the last 7 years full-time at Harvard, and I just—I just switched out to Vanderbilt here in Nashville, Tennessee, where we're taping this today.

Theo Von00:01:30

Thanks. Welcome.

Arthur Brooks00:01:31

Yeah, thank you.

Theo Von00:01:32

You have a new book, "The Meaning of Your Life: Finding Purpose in an Age of Emptiness." And one thing that I even just loved about the title is it's the meaning of your life, right? It's not like this—this huge thing of like, "Oh, the meaning of life."

Arthur Brooks00:01:48

Yeah, everybody has the same meaning to life, and I'm going to lay it on you. No.

Theo Von00:01:51

Right. It's the meaning of—

Arthur Brooks00:01:51

I want to lead you to find the meaning of your life.

Theo Von00:01:54

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:01:54

Yeah. I'm a trail boss. I'm a sherpa in this book. And it's basically the brain science and behavioral science that shows that all of us, when we use our brains right, and we stop doing a bunch of dumb things, and we start doing a bunch of old things, old-fashioned things, that we can find the meaning of our lives. And I'm not going to tell you what it is because I don't know. I mean, some days I don't know what the meaning of my life is.

Theo Von00:02:16

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:02:16

I mean, I'm on this journey myself because I'm, like, beaten up and suffering too.

Theo Von00:02:21

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:02:21

Right?

Theo Von00:02:22

Amen, bro. Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:02:23

Yeah.

Theo Von00:02:24

Yeah, even today, it was just like, man. I was, like, praying right before I—like, probably 11 minutes ago I was praying. I was just like.

Arthur Brooks00:02:29

What were you praying?

Theo Von00:02:30

I was just like, "God, just let me have some confidence in myself."

Arthur Brooks00:02:33

Yeah.

Theo Von00:02:33

You know, "Let me have some peace today."

Arthur Brooks00:02:35

Yeah.

Theo Von00:02:36

Um, "Let me not feel this pressure that everything has to be perfect."

Arthur Brooks00:02:42

Yeah.

Theo Von00:02:42

And that this pressure that I don't know what I'm doing.

Arthur Brooks00:02:47

Mm-hmm.

Theo Von00:02:48

You know?

Arthur Brooks00:02:48

You know, it's funny because.

Theo Von00:02:49

So a little more agency.

Arthur Brooks00:02:50

Yeah.

Theo Von00:02:50

I think I was just looking for a little bit more real agency and not just, like, frenetic energy like, "I'm, you know, I'm going to have another coffee and I'll be ready."

Arthur Brooks00:02:59

Yeah, and I'll be all set.

Theo Von00:02:59

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:03:00

But there's, you know, whatever, 2, 3 million people, whoever will watch this episode of the show, the assumption is—and this is a huge thing for them to understand—they think, "If I had Theo Von's life, it would be so awesome and everything would be good."

Theo Von00:03:12

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:03:12

That's a lie. That isn't true. That's not how life works at all. You know, it's like we say in my business, "Woe be to the man whose dreams come true and he finds he had—he finds he had the wrong dreams." Because you always have the wrong dreams.

Theo Von00:03:26

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:03:26

You know, you always think, "If I hit the lottery." But we know people who hit the lottery, they wind up miserable. It's a huge problem. I mean, and people who—where their worldly dreams come true, it's a big burden. It's a big problem. The stakes get higher. And then the guy was like, "I'm not going to hit the lottery. I'm not going to be CEO. I'm not going to be a billionaire." Okay, whatever. I guess I'll just go to the park and play with my kid.

Theo Von00:03:48

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:03:49

He hit the lottery. He won!

Theo Von00:03:51

He won.

Arthur Brooks00:03:51

He won. And then you got to figure, "Okay, all right, well, the die is cast. Theo Von is Theo Von. Arthur Brooks is Arthur Brooks. Good. So what are we going to do with it?"

Theo Von00:04:00

What are we going to do with it?

Arthur Brooks00:04:01

And the only thing that we can do on the day that's heavy is go love somebody else.

Theo Von00:04:05

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:04:05

Is to go serve somebody else. That's all there is.

Theo Von00:04:09

Amen, man. Yeah, even when you came in, you just asked me what was going on, like, genuinely, man, I just appreciated that. You know? Sometimes it's what I need. Like, last time I was even calling my brother, like, and he was busy with his kids, but I just wanted to have a moment where he, like.

Arthur Brooks00:04:20

Yeah.

Theo Von00:04:21

You know, just, like, told me everything was going to be okay.

Arthur Brooks00:04:24

You know, there's a funny thing. There's this Catholic saint from the year 13 something. She's the first woman ever published in English. Her name is Saint Juliana of Norwich. And that, like, there's a.

Theo Von00:04:35

Saint Juliana of Norwich?

Arthur Brooks00:04:37

Of Norwich.

Theo Von00:04:37

Okay.

Arthur Brooks00:04:38

In Great Britain. And these troops, these enemies were closing in, and it was a huge thing. And she wrote in her journal, "All will be well, and all will be well, and all manner of things shall be well." You got to have faith, right? And you got to offer up the suffering. You have to, you know, say, "I'm going to love somebody right now, and then all will be well." What does it mean for it to be well? That I won't actually have any discomfort or suffering or heaviness anymore? No, because that's your lot, man. I mean, there's suffering in your life.

Theo Von00:05:08

Yeah, and there's suffering everywhere.

Arthur Brooks00:05:10

Yeah.

Theo Von00:05:10

There's—and there's so much. There's a ton of suffering, and a lot of that is, is, is part of life.

Arthur Brooks00:05:15

It is. And it's actually weird because that's one of the things I study, is that people who have a lot of suffering, they have a lot of meaning too. They have a deep sense of life's meaning. You get, like, 90 years to figure out how to live with your suffering. If you're lucky.

Theo Von00:05:33

Oh, that's so interesting, man. Yeah, it's, it's, it's, it's interesting that, that your book came into my life at this moment. You know, a lot of times I've had a fear of missing out recently. Like, I have a lot of FOMO, but even more so it's become a fear of missing out on myself.

Arthur Brooks00:05:53

Mm-hmm.

Theo Von00:05:54

You know, it's not like.

Arthur Brooks00:05:55

Mm-hmm.

Theo Von00:05:56

I keep thinking it's like, "Oh, I'm missing this game that I'm seeing," or, "I'm missing these people doing this." And there's some of that.

Arthur Brooks00:06:01

Mm-hmm.

Theo Von00:06:02

But it's—there's this deeper thing that feels to me sometimes, like, "Man, I'm missing out on some opportunity of me or some."

Arthur Brooks00:06:12

There's something deeper. There's something deeper, and you can't get it.

Theo Von00:06:14

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:06:14

You can't quite get it, right?

Theo Von00:06:15

Yes. And I can't quite.

Arthur Brooks00:06:16

You can't focus in on it. You don't—it's like, "What is it?" And then you're distracted, and then it goes away, and it's like, "Oh, I missed it again."

Theo Von00:06:22

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:06:22

Another day won't bye.

Theo Von00:06:23

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:06:24

That feeling?

Theo Von00:06:24

Yes. And so what made you write this book.

Arthur Brooks00:06:27

Yeah.

Theo Von00:06:27

Now?

Arthur Brooks00:06:28

So I teach classes in the science of happiness. So the past 7 years, I've been full-time teaching a class in the science of happiness at Harvard, and it's super popular. It's, like, the most popular elective at the Harvard Business School. So, like, I have hundreds of people on the waiting list for this thing because they want to be happier. They know how to make money.

Theo Von00:06:43

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:06:44

But—but they know how to be successful, but they don't know that the ultimate startup is your life, that you're the CEO of the enterprise of you incorporated, and you're responsible for it. And that means taking risks where you should in, in, in, in return for explosive rewards. But how are they denominated? Not money or power or pleasure or fame or Instagram followers or anything stupid. No. It's love and happiness. And—and people don't know how to get that. So I've been talking about that. So, so scientifically, happiness isn't a feeling at all. Feelings are evidence of happiness.

Kind of like the smell of the turkey is evidence of your Thanksgiving dinner.

Theo Von00:07:18

Okay, so the smell.

Arthur Brooks00:07:19

That's feelings.

Theo Von00:07:19

So the smell of the turkey is evidence of the Thanksgiving dinner.

Arthur Brooks00:07:22

That's right. And your feelings of happiness are evidence of happiness.

Theo Von00:07:25

Okay.

Arthur Brooks00:07:26

So don't ever go for feelings. Big mistake that everybody makes in trying to find something big in their lives is, like, "I want that feeling. I hope I feel happier tomorrow." Big mistake. Your—your feelings lie all—when you woke up this morning and you—and you didn't—I woke up this morning, I felt bad too.

Theo Von00:07:40

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:07:40

And, and you're like, "Is God here?" And, and, you know, "Okay, get it back." If I actually said, "Okay, my feelings are authentic," I would have really questioned a lot of things in my life. But my feelings are—are the activity, are biochemical activity in my brain, in the limbic system of my brain. It's a bunch of signals saying that there's threats and opportunities. That's all emotions are. And they lie constantly. They lie to.

Theo Von00:08:06

They lie constantly?

Arthur Brooks00:08:07

Constantly. Your—your feelings are not to be trusted. Now, they're worth listening to, but don't trust them as the authentic truth. The problem with a lot of young people today is a lot of young adults today are told that the only thing authentic about them are their feelings, which is why all that safe spaces and, and "I'm offended" and, and, you know, all that nonsense that's based on the feelings-based culture, which is a culture of lies.

Theo Von00:08:28

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:08:28

That's what it comes down to.

Theo Von00:08:29

Amen.

Arthur Brooks00:08:30

And so what do we want to look for if it's not feelings? We want to look for something that's really tangible. Sort of the—you know, the macros when you're trying to eat, right? Protein, carbohydrates, and fat.

Theo Von00:08:37

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:08:38

That's food. Happiness has three macronutrients. The things that we really got to go for are enjoyment, to enjoy our lives. Not the same thing as pleasure. I've made that mistake. You know, there's a reason I drink zero alcohol today. It's because I made the mistake of confusing pleasure and enjoyment.

Theo Von00:08:54

Yeah, I've done that a lot.

Arthur Brooks00:08:55

Yeah, for sure. I mean, it's anybody who's been addicted, they know exactly what that's all about.

Theo Von00:08:58

Okay.

Arthur Brooks00:08:59

You know, the—the pleasure is not the road to happiness. Pleasure is the road to rehab.

Theo Von00:09:02

Okay.

Arthur Brooks00:09:03

Now, there's nothing—there's nothing wrong with pleasure, but it's incomplete. You got to add people and memory to it so you can manage your pleasures and they don't manage you. That's enjoyment.

Theo Von00:09:12

Okay.

Arthur Brooks00:09:12

The second macronutrient is satisfaction, and that's the joy of an accomplishment with struggle.

Theo Von00:09:17

Okay, so the first one is.

Arthur Brooks00:09:19

Enjoyment.

Theo Von00:09:19

Enjoyment?

Arthur Brooks00:09:20

Not pleasure. Enjoyment, right?

Theo Von00:09:21

Not pleasure. Enjoyment. And the difference between those two, one more time?

Arthur Brooks00:09:23

Is pleasure plus people plus memory equals enjoyment.

Theo Von00:09:27

Okay.

Arthur Brooks00:09:27

So it's got to be conscious and memorable. So that's why when you're doing something really pleasurable and you're doing it alone, you're probably doing it wrong.

Theo Von00:09:34

Got it.

Arthur Brooks00:09:35

That's why people are so critically important. You almost never really enjoy if it's not addictive, like walking in the woods or saying your prayers, good.

Theo Von00:09:42

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:09:42

But anything that actually is pleasurable, like what you eat, what you look at, what you use, if you're—that's the reason that, you know, that a beer company doesn't do an ad, you know, a beer ad for a dude alone in his apartment pounding a 12-pack.

Theo Von00:09:57

Yeah, yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:09:57

It's like, "That doesn't look good in the ad."

Theo Von00:10:00

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:10:00

And the reason is because it's pleasure, not enjoyment. They show the guy with his buddies, right? Because it's pleasure, it's beer plus people he loves plus memories that they're making together. That's enjoyment.

Theo Von00:10:11

Got it.

Arthur Brooks00:10:11

That's the recipe.

Theo Von00:10:12

So the first one is enjoyment.

Arthur Brooks00:10:13

Right.

Theo Von00:10:14

And you'll get enjoyment if you include other people.

Arthur Brooks00:10:16

Yeah. And making a memory. So it's really conscious.

Theo Von00:10:19

Got it.

Arthur Brooks00:10:19

So that you can—you can—enjoyment is permanent. And when you remember it, it's permanent. You know, it's like when I—when I was a kid, you know, my mom was a good cook, and, and we had Thanksgiving at our house every year, just like all of us did, right? You probably did too.

Theo Von00:10:31

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:10:31

And every year we'd open up the oven, and it'd be a beautiful turkey. My dad would be like, "Get the camera."

Theo Von00:10:36

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:10:37

And we would take a—it's like we have 30 turkeys in the same oven, and we don't even—but the whole point was he was trying to make it memorable.

Theo Von00:10:43

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:10:43

And that's what Thanksgiving dinner was all about. That's your life. So it's like, yeah, yeah, there's going to be pleasure. But if you start doing something for pleasure and you take it away from people and memories, you're going to be an addict.

Theo Von00:10:54

Right. So if you're just sitting in your apartment just playing with your turkey or whatever.

Arthur Brooks00:10:58

Yeah, exactly right. Or if you're sitting in your apartment all alone and you're isolated and you're gaming.

Theo Von00:11:03

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:11:03

Or—or you're looking at pornography because nobody looks at pornography with a bunch of friends.

Theo Von00:11:08

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:11:08

You know, all these things are so bad.

Theo Von00:11:10

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:11:11

You know, that's the reason they're so bad, because they take pleasure away from it and they make them not part of enjoyment, which means they lead to addiction, not to happiness.

Theo Von00:11:18

But we feel like that's not the truth, right?

Arthur Brooks00:11:20

Yeah, because your brain, your ancient brain, which is the same as it was 250,000 years ago, lies to you. And all your brain cares about is you actually getting these rewards that will make you more likely to get mates, more likely to get calories, more likely to survive. Mother Nature, she doesn't care if you're happy. She doesn't care at all. And so she'll lie to you and make you follow your animal impulses.

Theo Von00:11:41

Got it.

Arthur Brooks00:11:42

And that—and so all the stuff that we're really good at today, you know, opiates, alcohol, or pornography, all it is is a way to supercharge the impulses, the animal impulses that we naturally have.

Theo Von00:11:53

So it's kind of a hijacking of those.

Arthur Brooks00:11:55

Completely.

Theo Von00:11:56

Right. And there's a much more dense and meaningful way to get those.

Arthur Brooks00:12:00

Yes, for sure. And the way to get that such that it's—it's deeply fulfilling but not addictive is to make sure that you're getting, you know, the experience the way that it was intended. So don't, like, refine it. I mean, we have natural endorphins in our brain so that when we get injured, we're actually able to function and run away from the predator and not be completely debilitated by the pain. That's what endorphins are for. Well, when we figure out chemically what they're all about in the brain, and then we refine them and produce them, they turn into fentanyl. I mean, that's what—that's what heroin is.

Theo Von00:12:30

I see.

Arthur Brooks00:12:30

That's what—that's what opiates are. Pornography, it—it shears off the—the, you know, the physical aspect of a sexual relationship between people who are in love. And it—all it does is it just preserves that particular part. It's the fentanyl. It's fentanyl for sex.

Theo Von00:12:45

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:12:45

And that's the reason it's.

Theo Von00:12:46

It's like weaner fentanyl or whatever.

Arthur Brooks00:12:48

It's just super addictive.

Theo Von00:12:49

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:12:50

It's a—it's supposed to be addictive.

Theo Von00:12:52

Right. So they're just high—so a lot of that is the hijacking of just a simple moment.

Arthur Brooks00:12:56

Yeah.

Theo Von00:12:56

To kind of trick your system, really.

Arthur Brooks00:12:58

That's right. And so if you make it social and memorable, you'll go to the real thing.

Theo Von00:13:01

Got it.

Arthur Brooks00:13:02

Right? That's what it comes down to. Then it's enjoyment, and that enjoyment is a beautiful part of life.

Theo Von00:13:06

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:13:06

That's a beautiful part of life. But any of us who've actually really, really struggled with addictive behavior.

Theo Von00:13:11

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:13:11

It's because we got that wrong.

Theo Von00:13:13

Got it.

Arthur Brooks00:13:13

Right? And some people are genetically more—more prone to that than other people. Did you have alcoholism in your family?

Theo Von00:13:19

Yeah, we got it.

Arthur Brooks00:13:20

Yeah, so do we.

Theo Von00:13:21

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:13:21

It's a Brooks disease.

Theo Von00:13:22

Is it?

Arthur Brooks00:13:22

Yeah, for sure.

Advertisement00:13:23

Yeah. Is your girlfriend or wife impossible to shop for, and you never know what to get her? Or maybe your own wardrobe is getting a little worn down, and it's time to refresh. Well, I'm here to tell you about Fabletics. They've got something for everyone: men's, women's, accessories, holiday styles, and everyday essentials all in one place. Right now, you can get 70 to 80 percent off your order as a new VIP.

You're unlocking incredible value the moment you sign up. And as we head into the holidays, has your partner been begging you to match for the Christmas season? "We got a match, but you always said no." Well, Fabletics has holiday-themed onesies so you can cozy up under the tree in style. God, that's nice. Black Friday is coming up. Could be the perfect time to restock your wardrobe or grab those onesies. Shop now at fabletics.com/weekend to get 70 to 80 percent off everything when you sign up as a new VIP.

Take a quick style quiz and be sure to select weekend when prompted to unlock this offer. The best styles sell out fast, so don't wait. Again, that's fabletics.com/weekend for 70 to 80 percent off everything as a new VIP. You know, I want to tell you about something that's been on my mind lately. It's when you sign up for something online and they ask you for your phone number. Next thing you know, you're getting spam calls and spam texts all the time.

Heck, I gave my number to a chef once, and next thing you know, he's calling me in the—in the middle of the night, asking me about my carrot or whatever. Trying to see my carrot or whatever, man. What? That's why I started using Glacier, a mobile security app co-founded by former U.S. intelligence professionals. With Glacier, you keep the same number all your family and friends have, but change it for everyone else with the tap of a button. Basically, they create a burner number for you so you don't always have to give out the real thing.

It's really that simple. Open the app, tap connect, and you're done. Take your privacy back today and download Glacier on the App Store or Google Play, or get 20 percent off your first three months at my exclusive link, theglacierapp.com/tpw, and use code TPW at checkout. Again, that's theglacierapp.com/tpw and use code TPW at checkout for 20 percent off your first three months.

Remember, privacy isn't paranoia; it's protection. I—I think, you know, back in the day, they—they had to have a whole séance, really, to get you as rocked up as Blue Chew gets you. I think that's probably what the Salem witch trials were about. They saw a lot of local dudes was really broomsticking out there, and they knew them fellas was drinking potions. Yeah, hell, man. But you don't need any magic with Blue Chew Gold. It has four powerful ingredients that make that dong go from dangling to dinging, baby.

If you know what I mean, abracadabra, baby erection. It's got two ingredients for arousal and two ingredients that get you hard. Everything is done online, and it's delivered straight to your door. There's a reason Blue Chew is the number one brand for better sex. Experience it yourself at bluechew.com. And we've got a special deal for our listeners right now. When you buy two months of Blue Chew Gold, you get the third free with promo code THEO. That's promo code THEO.

You will also receive an additional 10 percent off plus free overnight shipping on your first order. Visit bluechew.com for more details and important safety information. We thank Blue Chew for sponsoring the pod and the bedroom. What's the second macronutrient of happiness?

Arthur Brooks00:17:40

Satisfaction. Now, satisfaction is the joy you get from an accomplishment with struggle. And this is super weird because only Homo sapiens want to suffer. We want to suffer for our accomplishments because that's how we know what they're worth.

Theo Von00:17:53

Okay, so only Homo sapiens want to suffer.

Arthur Brooks00:17:55

Yeah. My dog doesn't want to, like, struggle for his rewards. He'd eat lying down, right?

Theo Von00:18:00

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:18:00

They want the easiest path to absolutely everything because they don't have moral aspirations. But you and I, we—we actually, we don't know if something is actually worthwhile unless we gave something up for it. And that's why struggle is so critically important. And that's why we teach our kids, you know, good things come to those who wait. Defer your gratifications. Don't eat before dinner. Study really, really hard, even though you're not going to like it, so you can get good grades. Because then you learn this lesson that things are—that the reward is way sweeter, the accomplishment is meaningful to you when you've actually struggled for it.

And that's one of the biggest problems that we have today, is we're teaching people that struggle and sacrifice is stupid. That all that does is it ruins, like, the sense of accomplishment that people got.

Theo Von00:18:41

And where are we teaching that at, or where are you seeing a lot of this being taught?

Arthur Brooks00:18:44

I see this taught with sort of the immediate gratification that comes around from tech and social media, for sure, but also in the therapeutic—the therapeutic industrial culture that we've got that says that if you're suffering from something, it's evidence that there's a pathology.

Theo Von00:18:57

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:18:57

That's wrong. I mean, I teach my students, it's like, you're studying at Harvard. If you're not depressed and anxious, you need therapy.

Theo Von00:19:02

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:19:03

You know, it's hard. And you're doing a hard thing on purpose. Of course you're suffering. Good.

Theo Von00:19:07

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:19:07

I mean, I don't go to the gym, and you don't go to the gym going, "This is going to feel so good." No, it's going to hurt. That's kind of the point. But the whole—but life is a gym.

Theo Von00:19:16

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:19:17

You know, you put yourself in front of hard things, and you're going to suffer for those hard things because you want the sweetness that comes as a reward for what you get in—in—in return for the struggle is what it comes down to.

Theo Von00:19:28

Yeah, yeah. It feels like some time—some point along the way, we forgot the value of the squeeze.

Arthur Brooks00:19:34

Yeah.

Theo Von00:19:34

Is what makes us love the juice.

Arthur Brooks00:19:37

Totally. And that's absolutely the case. It's so funny that we actually—we—we fail to realize this kind of thing. But in—in a culture of immediate gratification.

Theo Von00:19:46

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:19:47

We're not going to have any struggling. And so we start to lose the reps. We start to lose the ability. We get in kind of a doom loop where I don't suffer, and so I'm no longer able to suffer, and so I try less to suffer. And what happens? I get less and less and less and less satisfaction from life. Life is just like, "Eh, whatever. Why should I even try?" And you find that people are just, like, not striving in the same way that they would have before because they can actually get a payoff without any struggle, and they don't want the struggle naturally. But that's the wrong approach. Like, it's funny because, again, the animal impulses lie.

Theo Von00:20:19

The animal impulses lie.

Arthur Brooks00:20:20

Mother Nature lies all the time. And she says the easy path is the best path because in, you know, 250,000 years ago, all of humanity lived in bands of hunter-gatherers of 30 to 50 individuals. And if you could actually sit down and not work better because you're saving your energy, if you could get more calories, get them, right, under all circumstances. But that's not the case today.

Theo Von00:20:42

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:20:42

And so the result is we actually have to put friction back into our lives and not listen to Mother Nature who says, "Take the easy path." Don't take the easy path. Take the hard path.

Theo Von00:20:50

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:20:50

And this is one of the things that we find. I talk to a lot of young men.

Theo Von00:20:53

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:20:53

I mean, I get tons of unsolicited email from young guys. "I just graduated from college. I got nothing to do. I'm living with my mom. I'm having a hard time finding a job or even looking for a job.

Theo Von00:21:04

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:21:05

I'm smoking a lot of weed. I'm gaming all the time. You know, what do I do?" And my answer is always, "Go do a hard thing." You know, even if it's a hard thing, it's like, "Get up before dawn every day for the next month."

Theo Von00:21:17

Your life will change.

Arthur Brooks00:21:18

I mean, if—if the sun is up every day when you get up, you've lost the first battle.

Theo Von00:21:21

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:21:22

Right? And—and there's a whole bunch of neuroscience on this too. It talks about productivity and focus and happiness. The Indians call that the Brahma Muhurta, which in Sanskrit means the creator's time.

Theo Von00:21:33

Brahma Muhurta?

Arthur Brooks00:21:34

B-R-A-H-M-A M-U-H-U-R-T-A. Brahma Muhurta.

Theo Von00:21:41

Bring that up and keep that other page open for me. I do want to read that really fast.

Arthur Brooks00:21:44

There you go. The time of Brahma or the creator's time. It's the sacred pre-dawn window in Vedic tradition in Ayurveda.

Theo Von00:21:51

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:21:52

And I—I learned this. I go to India a lot. But when I go to India, I have Hindu teachers in—in the south of India. I've also worked for the last 13 years with a Dalai Lama, which has been really, really helpful for me. But the result of it is I've been able to incorporate a lot of that Vedic physics, all that, you know, ancient Indian wisdom into my own work as a scientist in the West and as a Catholic. It's made me a better Catholic.

Theo Von00:22:13

That's fascinating. And I find that so many of the faiths overlap in—in a lot of ways.

Arthur Brooks00:22:21

Yeah.

Theo Von00:22:21

With some of the core principles.

Arthur Brooks00:22:23

Many of the same core principles. Many differences, of course.

Theo Von00:22:26

And not so much in some of their lore and truths.

Arthur Brooks00:22:28

Right.

Theo Von00:22:29

To the—to the faiths themselves.

Arthur Brooks00:22:31

Right.

Theo Von00:22:31

But in—in the principles.

Arthur Brooks00:22:33

For sure.

Theo Von00:22:33

Oh.

Arthur Brooks00:22:33

And—and a lot of the things, you know, the intense love for the divine, the search for life's deepest meaning, and different ways to actually do that. And I've learned a tremendous amount about my own prayer life by actually sitting in—in meditation with the Tibetan Buddhist monks.

Theo Von00:22:46

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:22:46

Even though I'm not a Buddhist. I'm not a—no, I'm not a—and the Dalai Lama's not a Catholic. But we've shared these ideas with each other an awful lot. And he's a man of great wisdom and love and compassion.

Theo Von00:22:57

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:22:57

And it's made me—I think it's made me a better Christian man.

Theo Von00:23:00

Amen.

Arthur Brooks00:23:00

Yeah.

Theo Von00:23:01

Well, even when Bishop Barron was on, you know, he was talking about how he would sit in front of this statue in the morning and just repeat a mantra for a long time.

Arthur Brooks00:23:10

Right.

Theo Von00:23:11

I remember how long.

Arthur Brooks00:23:11

That's his holy hour.

Theo Von00:23:12

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:23:12

Which is what the Indians call the Brahma Muhurta.

Theo Von00:23:15

Oh, I didn't even know exactly that.

Arthur Brooks00:23:16

Yeah.

Theo Von00:23:16

That it brings us back to that.

Arthur Brooks00:23:17

Yeah.

Theo Von00:23:18

But when—when he was saying that, I was like, "Oh, well, that's just a medit—that's meditation," right?

Arthur Brooks00:23:22

Yeah.

Theo Von00:23:23

It's like creating a pattern within yourself. It's a lot of—so much is action, right? It's like.

Arthur Brooks00:23:28

Yeah.

Theo Von00:23:28

When I'm sitting sedentary and when I'm just scrolling on my phone, when I'm just doing things that are sedentary, I'm just stuck in my thoughts.

Arthur Brooks00:23:33

Right.

Theo Von00:23:34

It's not action. And action, when I can put action with something.

Arthur Brooks00:23:39

Mm-hmm.

Theo Von00:23:39

I don't know, it creates a lot more meaning. I'm noticing for me in my own life, even that's why I notice in my gratitude list, it's like, "Well, let me create even a visual action with it if I am sitting here."

Arthur Brooks00:23:49

Right.

Theo Von00:23:49

Kind of in a meditative state and walk and writing out things I'm grateful for. Like, if I'm—I'm thinking, "Oh, I'm so grateful for my sister," then I will think of things, of active moments.

Arthur Brooks00:23:58

Mm-hmm.

Theo Von00:23:58

Where I've seen her smile or.

Arthur Brooks00:24:00

Right.

Theo Von00:24:00

Seen her, like, laugh or jokes she tells. So it's just like, even if I'm just remembering actions.

Arthur Brooks00:24:06

Right.

Theo Von00:24:06

Or attaching actions to thoughts.

Arthur Brooks00:24:09

Yeah, for sure.

Theo Von00:24:09

Right? It—it just helps make things more real.

Arthur Brooks00:24:11

For sure. Look, I mean, it's like an unsupervised mind is a dangerous business, right? And—and one of the—the whole thing about actually disciplining the mind first thing in the morning comes a lot along with disciplining the body. That's why I recommend to all of my students that they have morning protocols. And doing something that you know is going to set yourself up for success. Because I wake up and unsupervised, I'm like, "I'm all alone."

Theo Von00:24:36

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:24:36

I'm all—you know that feeling where you wake up and you're like, "It's real dark. It's real in here."

Theo Von00:24:42

Oh, yeah. I feel like a missing person.

Arthur Brooks00:24:43

But I have.

Theo Von00:24:44

But you feel like—you feel like you've been in deep space all night long. And that there's a profound aloneness to it, right?

Arthur Brooks00:24:53

Well, if I don't create a little bit of structure and create some points of structure, then it's just one big whatever.

Theo Von00:25:02

It's.

Arthur Brooks00:25:03

It's just—it's a—it's a—it's a—it's a sunrise and sunset of whatever.

Theo Von00:25:07

That's exactly right. That's exactly right. You have to put together the architecture to be—to be the person that you want to be.

Arthur Brooks00:25:13

Right. A lot of my life is filled with a lot of stimulation, though, where it's like.

Theo Von00:25:18

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:25:18

Things look fun. You get to go do all these fun things, and it is fun. But it's like.

Theo Von00:25:22

It's distraction.

Arthur Brooks00:25:23

It's—a lot of it is distraction, even though it's great.

Theo Von00:25:26

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:25:26

It is distraction in the end from just my relationship with me.

Theo Von00:25:30

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:25:31

And—and—and maybe what more do I want for myself, like in a human sense or I don't know. It's just, yeah, it's a distraction from my relationship with myself and—and what things might be very important to me that I'm putting on the side just because I'm—because it's—some things are fun. I want to read what the—can you bring that up with the—the Vedic—the Bar—how do you say it?

Speaker 300:25:58

About the Brahma?

Arthur Brooks00:25:59

The Brahma Muhurta?

Theo Von00:26:00

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:26:00

Yeah. Brahma Muhurta is a sacred pre-dawn period in Vedic tradition and Ayurvedic practice. Let me see. In traditions highlighted by teachers like Sadhguru, it is considered a time when an individual can act as a creator of their own state of mind and energy. So yeah, it's like—it's like swabbing your decks, washing your decks.

Theo Von00:26:23

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:26:23

Seeing what's going on.

Theo Von00:26:24

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:26:24

And preparing yourself.

Theo Von00:26:25

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:26:25

Oh, when I have those days where I get up and I'm popping and I get to my meeting and I get my workout done, dude, by 9:30, I am the king.

Theo Von00:26:35

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:26:36

Anything's possible.

Theo Von00:26:37

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:26:38

But your brain chemistry is not the same every day when you wake up. I mean.

Theo Von00:26:42

Right. So I have to take control of it.

Arthur Brooks00:26:44

Yeah, yeah. So that's right. That's why you got to have protocols that actually will get you back to a baseline, reliably get you back to a baseline. You're not going to be perfect. I mean, I slept like garbage last night.

Theo Von00:26:52

Yeah, see.

Arthur Brooks00:26:52

I mean, I was sleeping it up. Yeah. I mean, I'm on tour.

Theo Von00:26:55

I must have slept like a damn farm animal or whatever.

Arthur Brooks00:26:57

Oh, man. It's like I.

Theo Von00:26:58

I slept like a farm animal in the city.

Arthur Brooks00:27:02

You know, it's like that old joke. I slept—I slept like a baby. Every two hours, I woke up crying.

Theo Von00:27:06

Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And reaching out for—for breasts or whatever.

Arthur Brooks00:27:10

It's bad. You know, I'm on tour every—almost every week, 48 weeks a year.

Theo Von00:27:14

Are you?

Arthur Brooks00:27:14

Yeah. I mean.

Theo Von00:27:15

And you're like traveling and speaking?

Arthur Brooks00:27:17

Yeah. Speaking—speaking—speaking to media. So I'm doing speaking to media because there's, you know, a lot of people want to hear about happiness.

Theo Von00:27:22

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:27:22

But the result of it is, you know, I'm not with my wife. I'm—I'm—I'm in hotels. And, you know, it's okay, but it's kind of lonely.

Theo Von00:27:30

Oh, yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:27:31

But you got to have a protocol so you can become human again. I—I wanted to come see you today. I'm super pumped to come see you today.

Theo Von00:27:38

Thanks.

Arthur Brooks00:27:38

I got to be my best self, right?

Theo Von00:27:40

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:27:40

And you were thinking about that even before we hadn't met before. And you're like—and—and so the protocols, actually, that we can actually have the discipline. It's funny because, you know, there's this guy, Admiral McRaven. Remember he gave that famous speech called "Make Your Bed"? Remember this a few years ago, like 2005?

Theo Von00:27:55

Bring him up because I feel like.

Arthur Brooks00:27:57

William McRaven.

Theo Von00:27:58

He was the.

Arthur Brooks00:27:59

Jordan—Jordan Peterson kind of became the guy that did that.

Theo Von00:28:01

Yeah, yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:28:02

For—for sure. He gave a speech. This guy gave a speech at the University of Texas at Austin called "Make Your Bed." And the whole point was you want to get started on something good that was have a protocol that's practical and specific that will set you on the right path. Now, making your bed is great, but the whole point that we're talking about here is, like, make your bed in a metaphysical sense.

Theo Von00:28:21

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:28:21

Like really good things. Get up, pump the iron, go to mass, say your prayers, do your gratitude list. You know, do—do the things that you actually need to do to get your brain and this neurophysiologically into the right possible space, notwithstanding the fact that you slept like garbage, you went to sleep feeling sad, you woke up feeling a lack of the presence of God, and, you know, the biology isn't there for you. So you got to have a way to get it back.

Theo Von00:28:46

Yeah. Yeah. It says right here, "If you want to change the world, start off by making your bed. If you have a miserable day, you will come home to a bed that is made, that you made, and a made bed gives you encouragement that tomorrow will be better."

Arthur Brooks00:28:57

It's a metaphor.

Theo Von00:28:58

I agree.

Arthur Brooks00:28:59

It's a metaphor.

Theo Von00:28:59

Well, let's just getting up.

Arthur Brooks00:29:00

Yeah.

Theo Von00:29:00

It's like getting up. I go in the kitchen. A lot of times, I'll leave my dishes out from dinner. And so then in the morning, the first thing I'll go do is go and put them up, start the dishwasher. It's like.

Arthur Brooks00:29:07

Yeah.

Theo Von00:29:08

That's the first thing. Then I'll—and I keep earplugs in too for the first, like, probably 90 minutes of the day.

Arthur Brooks00:29:14

Do you look at your phone in the first hour?

Theo Von00:29:15

Dude, if I do, I wait until I'm rolling my legs out. That's usually, like, probably about 50 minutes that I've been awake, and then I'll respond to texts.

Arthur Brooks00:29:22

Yeah.

Theo Von00:29:22

But it's just for communication.

Arthur Brooks00:29:24

Yeah.

Theo Von00:29:25

Because.

Arthur Brooks00:29:25

I recommend actually the whole first 60 minutes without the device.

Theo Von00:29:28

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:29:29

For neurocognitive programming. And if you don't do that, if you actually don't, you'll—you'll be better focused and you'll have better mood and productivity for the whole day.

Theo Von00:29:37

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:29:38

Because you won't get the hijack. You know, this—it's the kind of thing where it's like, okay, if you can go the whole when you're—when things are really, really rough, if you do a bad habit in the first hour, you're going to do it for the rest of the day.

Theo Von00:29:48

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:29:48

And the whole day is written off, right? But if you don't do it for the first hour of the day, you're programmed, you're path-dependent toward the better self. And so one of the things that—that we all should actually do is don't look at it in the first hour. I mean, look at it. Nothing's on fire in the business, okay? Then not for the first hour. While you eat, because your brain actually wants you to eat with other people. And if you have your phone on the table, it interrupts the neurochemicals that you need to connect to the other person.

Theo Von00:30:13

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:30:14

And then last hour of the day. So you're looking at a real physical book. You're not getting blue light. If you're—you know, people who are watching us who live with somebody else, like a spouse or, you know, somebody they love, they can connect with them better. That's really just those three things. It'll change your life.

Theo Von00:30:28

Yeah. Oh, well, I mean, I—I was even thinking last night I was reading your book before I was going to sleep, and I was looking and I was thinking, like, there—there's certainly been times where I will replace my sense of self, like, with a sense of screen, right?

Arthur Brooks00:30:42

Yeah, yeah.

Theo Von00:30:43

It's like how I feel.

Arthur Brooks00:30:44

That's the simulation. That's the matrix.

Theo Von00:30:46

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:30:46

That's what—and—and there's actually we know how that affects the brain. So your brain has two hemispheres, the left and the right. The left hemisphere is what you're using when you're looking at tech. That's a simulation of the experiences in the right hemisphere, which is all, like, love and mystery and meaning. And so dating on the apps is a—is a—is a simulation of actual courting. Your social media is an actual simulation of friendship. Gaming is a simulation of actual real-life accomplishment. And we're living in a simulation.

That's what the whole thing is, like. And your brain knows the difference.

Theo Von00:31:20

So that's why it feels more like a simulation, because everything that is—that was once more tangible.

Arthur Brooks00:31:25

Yeah.

Theo Von00:31:26

And interactive and actually human, we are simulating it now.

Arthur Brooks00:31:29

Exactly right.

Theo Von00:31:30

So—so when people say we're living in a simulation, some people think it's like, oh, this everything is a computer and it's gigabytes and everything.

Arthur Brooks00:31:36

No, that's not what I mean.

Theo Von00:31:37

That's not what you mean.

Arthur Brooks00:31:38

We're simulating in real-life love.

Theo Von00:31:40

Right. So that's.

Arthur Brooks00:31:40

That's what we're simulating.

Theo Von00:31:41

And that's why we feel like we're living in a simulation.

Arthur Brooks00:31:43

Yeah.

Theo Von00:31:43

Because in that way, it's truly a—like a literal simulation. Not like Elon Musk says there's a 90% chance that this is a simulation run by aliens. I don't know.

Arthur Brooks00:31:53

Right.

Theo Von00:31:53

I don't know. But this is simulating what our brains really want, which is we're made for you. There's a reason we're not doing this on Riverside.

Arthur Brooks00:32:01

Yeah.

Theo Von00:32:01

There's a reason we're not doing this online, like a Zoom right now, because we're having a human connection right now that we can't get otherwise.

Arthur Brooks00:32:07

Mm-hmm.

Theo Von00:32:07

It would be a simulated conversation between Theo and Arthur if we actually did it online.

Arthur Brooks00:32:12

Right.

Theo Von00:32:12

And it wouldn't be as good.

Arthur Brooks00:32:13

Right.

Theo Von00:32:13

Because it would be a left brain simulation for the right brain connection between friends.

Arthur Brooks00:32:17

Got it. And this is super important for me to even just—just make sure I'm clear on. So because a lot of people here, you hear stuff like that Elon says, and you see all these things like, "We're living in a simulation." And like, you know, I was on, you know, I was on 70 grams of mushrooms.

Theo Von00:32:31

That's a trippy, man.

Arthur Brooks00:32:32

And I could see the numbers at the on the, you know, in the light on the wall. Like, you hear a lot of that, right?

Theo Von00:32:36

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:32:36

Like, you hear a lot that. And but as we're seeing—hearing, seeing, like, clips saying this and hearing this in our world, if at the same time we are simulating things that are very real, like instead of meeting somebody and having to ask them out and having a real moment with them, you are just swiping left to right.

Theo Von00:32:54

That's right.

Arthur Brooks00:32:55

That's why it feels that way when we.

Theo Von00:32:57

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:32:57

Hear those—when we hear those things saying we're living in this, like, in the matrix, that's why it feels that way, right?

Theo Von00:33:02

It's a digital curve fit for the thing you actually want to see, want to experience.

Arthur Brooks00:33:07

Got it.

Theo Von00:33:07

You're getting a virtual experience instead of a real experience.

Arthur Brooks00:33:11

Got it. And one thing that I—that I really loved about your book is when you say that one thing that cannot be simulated is meaning.

Theo Von00:33:20

And that's the third macronutrient of happiness. And that's the hard one.

Arthur Brooks00:33:23

Oh, right there, bro.

Theo Von00:33:24

Man.

Arthur Brooks00:33:24

Is that how we pulled up at that?

Theo Von00:33:25

Nice. Nice. See that corroboration?

Arthur Brooks00:33:27

Let's go.

Theo Von00:33:29

So the—so meaning is the third macronutrient, and that's the hardest. That's what's missing today. So before we go down, so just tell me the first two again.

Arthur Brooks00:33:37

Enjoyment, satisfaction.

Theo Von00:33:39

And those are the macronutrients of happiness.

Arthur Brooks00:33:41

The first two macronutrients. There's three.

Theo Von00:33:43

Got it.

Arthur Brooks00:33:43

Because remember, food is protein, carbohydrates, and fat.

Theo Von00:33:46

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:33:46

Happiness has three also.

Theo Von00:33:48

Got it.

Arthur Brooks00:33:48

It's not—it's—it's a coincidence, right?

Theo Von00:33:50

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:33:51

So—so enjoyment, super important. You got to enjoy your life. Satisfaction, that's like you got to take a deep sense of satisfaction in your accomplishments for sure, which means you got to have stuff to do: goals, direction, progress. And the third, the hard one, is the meaning of life, because that's the why of your existence.

Theo Von00:34:08

Man, you hit—you hit that third one as a meaning.

Arthur Brooks00:34:10

Yeah. That's the why of ex—and that's the one I didn't—that's so hard to write about because it's so philosophical. So it turns out that the meaning of life, the fact that we have walked into since 2008, I've been—I've been keeping data on this forever.

Theo Von00:34:23

Okay.

Arthur Brooks00:34:23

That since 2008, people have been progressively more and more likely to say, "My life feels meaningless." That's not coincidentally when we started to actually have screens take over our individual lives.

Theo Von00:34:34

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:34:34

Why? Because that's when we started to walk into the matrix. That's when our brains started to work differently.

Theo Von00:34:39

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:34:39

And that's where.

Theo Von00:34:40

A sense of screen and not a sense of self.

Arthur Brooks00:34:41

Yeah. And so that meaning of life, that lies behind the explosions in depression and anxiety and loneliness that—that we actually see. I mean, you—when you read the news, it's like, okay, why are so many young people depressed and anxious? And depression is up by 3X since 2008 for people under 30.

Theo Von00:34:57

Oh, one out of six people are on antidepressants.

Arthur Brooks00:34:59

It's—it's insane.

Theo Von00:35:00

And a higher percentage of that in college.

Arthur Brooks00:35:03

For sure. And the—actually, here's the weird part, Theo, is that ordinarily you see mental suffering for people who have less privilege and less education. It's more likely if you have education, have high levels of education, gone to college.

Theo Von00:35:14

Wait, so say that again. So people that have more education.

Arthur Brooks00:35:18

People who have more—that have—have more years of education are more likely to be depressed.

Theo Von00:35:22

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:35:22

And they're more likely to be anxious. So depression, 3X.

Theo Von00:35:26

That makes me feel pretty good, honestly.

Arthur Brooks00:35:27

I know, man.

Theo Von00:35:28

Well, that's.

Arthur Brooks00:35:28

But so that's.

Theo Von00:35:29

You went to college, but still. I mean, it's like.

Arthur Brooks00:35:30

So it's like, yeah.

Theo Von00:35:31

So look, there's still a way out of all this.

Arthur Brooks00:35:33

Yeah, yeah. So and.

Theo Von00:35:34

It's a blippy.

Arthur Brooks00:35:34

Anxiety is up by 2X. So everybody's like, okay, it's because the boomers made all the houses really super expensive and we're wrecking the environment. There's too much income inequality. That's all nonsense. Those might be problems. Everybody's got to decide for themselves whether those are problems, but they're not new problems. There's nothing new about the fact that, you know, something's wrong with the environment or—or stuff is getting expensive. There's—I mean, I kind of remember—I remember the '70s. It was way worse. Everything was way worse. You—you had to roll up your windows when you drove through LA because it was too smoggy.

Theo Von00:36:05

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:36:05

And, you know.

Theo Von00:36:06

That's a good point.

Arthur Brooks00:36:07

18% inflation.

Theo Von00:36:09

Well, even if you go back to feudal times, it's like.

Arthur Brooks00:36:12

Yeah, way worse.

Theo Von00:36:12

You could be walking down the street and somebody would shit out their window and it would hit you.

Arthur Brooks00:36:16

I know. I know. It's like, yeah, a third of the population died of the Bubonic Plague. Bummer.

Theo Von00:36:20

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:36:20

Right? No, good old days. What are you talking about?

Theo Von00:36:23

Because I will romanticize stuff like, oh, it was so, you know.

Arthur Brooks00:36:26

Oh, so good. I got a—my son got a blister and he died of sepsis.

Theo Von00:36:30

Oh, my gosh.

Arthur Brooks00:36:30

Like, what? Like, uh-oh, toothache. You're going to die.

Theo Von00:36:34

Yeah, dude.

Arthur Brooks00:36:35

Oh.

Theo Von00:36:35

You'd have three or four funerals a week to go to.

Arthur Brooks00:36:37

Oh, yeah, completely. And, you know, half your kids would die.

Theo Von00:36:39

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:36:39

I mean, it's like.

Theo Von00:36:40

Abraham Lincoln, the president, Abraham Lincoln, all three of his kids died by the age of, like, 22.

Arthur Brooks00:36:45

Oh, yeah. Well, one of them was playing—no, that was Calvin Coolidge. His son was playing tennis at the White House, forgot his socks.

Theo Von00:36:51

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:36:51

I kid you not. Got a blister on the back of his heel and died of an infection.

Theo Von00:36:56

Ugh.

Arthur Brooks00:36:56

The president's son. So I'm like, romanticizing the old days is completely absurd. Oh, we're bringing it up. Cal—Calvin Coolidge, Silent Cal.

Theo Von00:37:04

Calvin Coolidge's younger son, Calvin Coolidge Jr., on June 30th, 1924, Calvin Jr. played lawn tennis on the White House South grounds with his brother John without wearing socks. A blister formed on his toe. He was moved to Walter Reed Army Hospital, where doctors could not stop the infection because antibiotics like penicillin had not yet been discovered and made available. He passed away. Wow.

Arthur Brooks00:37:27

And people are like, oh, man, old days were so much. No, that's actually wrong. The reason that we have this explosion of depression and anxiety is because people don't know the meaning of their life, and they're not even looking. And they're paralyzed from looking because they're using their brains wrong because they're staring at the screen all day long.

Theo Von00:37:42

And—and before we go too much deeper, can you define meaning for people?

Arthur Brooks00:37:45

Yeah, for sure, because it sounds so philosophical. It's like a New Yorker cartoon. What's the meaning of life, right?

Theo Von00:37:51

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:37:51

So.

Theo Von00:37:51

And this is also about what's—yeah. And—and you—but the book—but I did love it, and I'll reiterate is that it's your meaning, right?

Arthur Brooks00:37:58

Right. You're right. Exactly right. And it's the answer to three big why questions in your life. So—so we'll go through the big three why questions.

Theo Von00:38:06

So meaning answers three big why questions.

Arthur Brooks00:38:08

Yeah.

Theo Von00:38:08

Oh, wow.

Arthur Brooks00:38:08

Yeah, because meaning is always about the why of life. You—have you had Simon Sinek on your show before? Do you know who he is? Simon Sinek, he wrote a book called Start with Why.

Theo Von00:38:16

We've not had him.

Arthur Brooks00:38:16

He's fantastic. And—and why is fundamentally about meaning. It's like, why? You know, those days when you wake up, it's dark. Simon Sinek, he's great. I've been working with him for years. And—and you're like, why? Lord, why? Right? That's a meaning—that's a cry for meaning, right? The first big why question is why—why does all this stuff happen? That's—you know, that's called coherence. You got to have some sort of a theory about why things happen the way that they do. I believe that things happen the way they do because of the mind of God and because of the laws of science. And those things work together. That's my coherence theory.

That's my why about why things happen the way they do. Paranoid conspiracy theories are a coherence—are a way to find coherence. It's like because shadowy forces are doing things behind the scenes, right?

Theo Von00:38:58

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:38:58

But that's a why. That's a—that's—that's number one.

Theo Von00:39:01

So—but—but—but any of those are okay. You just have to have a why?

Arthur Brooks00:39:04

You got to have a why that actually makes sense to you, that you actually believe.

Theo Von00:39:07

Got it.

Arthur Brooks00:39:07

That you think actually kind of holds water is the way this works.

Theo Von00:39:11

But we used to have a—a—we used to have a news—kind of a news system, I feel like.

Arthur Brooks00:39:15

Yeah.

Theo Von00:39:15

In America.

Arthur Brooks00:39:16

Yeah.

Theo Von00:39:16

Or it used to feel like we had a news system in America that we believed and trusted.

Arthur Brooks00:39:20

Yeah.

Theo Von00:39:21

So I feel like when that sort of dissolved, then it made probably the why a lot.

Arthur Brooks00:39:25

It made coherence worse.

Theo Von00:39:27

It made coherence.

Arthur Brooks00:39:27

It made coherence a big problem for people.

Theo Von00:39:29

It made coherence a big problem because you—that's a huge thing. You don't know what is real anymore.

Arthur Brooks00:39:34

Why things are happening.

Theo Von00:39:35

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:39:35

Why are these things happening? It's like, well, well, the—the—the mainstream media said, and you're like, yeah, right. Yeah, right.

Theo Von00:39:42

Yeah, the last thing I'm going to trust is them. They're like the, you know, they're the.

Arthur Brooks00:39:45

Yeah, it's obfuscation and, you know, it's like biased whatever. For sure, it's a big problem.

Theo Von00:39:50

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:39:50

Right? I mean, I think we all understand that at this point. And—and by the way, that's going to lead to good things. You know, it's like I—I do a lot of mainstream media, and we all do a lot of mainstream media. I think it's actually getting better as a result of the fact that people are more skeptical.

Theo Von00:40:02

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:40:03

At this point. But it hurts in the meantime because it—it ruins the sense of coherence, the—the through line about why things are happening the way that they are. That's number one.

Theo Von00:40:11

Right. So that's one of the issues that why we're having trouble with meaning right now is because things feel incoherent.

Arthur Brooks00:40:17

You don't know who you can trust.

Theo Von00:40:18

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:40:18

You just don't know who you can trust. The second is purpose, which is why am I doing what I'm doing? And that's the question you started with today. It's like, why am I doing this? I mean, it's got to be perfect, but why? You know, that's this—the—that means goals, direction, and—and the ability to make progress. And when life feels feudal, like this is dumb, that—that means that you're—you're lacking a sense of purpose. You're lacking a sense of direction in your life.

Theo Von00:40:44

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:40:44

And, you know, it's funny because experiments on, like, undergraduate students in college show that you can dramatically raise their sense of meaning and happiness by giving them an arbitrary goal, which gives them more purpose. Like, you're getting a B minus in calculus. We're going to get a B plus for you in calculus. And you set them up on a protocol, which is why the morning protocols.

Theo Von00:41:02

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:41:02

We talked about.

Theo Von00:41:03

As a—as a professor, you mean?

Arthur Brooks00:41:04

Yeah, as a professor. Like, campus counseling will do this an awful lot. Like, we're going to raise your grade by one full letter grade. And just that gives them a sense of purpose, and they start getting more disciplined. They start getting happier.

Theo Von00:41:16

You mean you're going to raise the goal of their grade?

Arthur Brooks00:41:18

Yeah. The—you got—they need a goal, and that gives them a sense of purpose. Even a—like an arbitrary, dumb little purpose like that really helps people an awful lot.

Theo Von00:41:26

Are there easy ways for us to do that for ourselves?

Arthur Brooks00:41:29

Yeah. To set, you know, basic goals about ways in—in small ways you want to get better.

Theo Von00:41:33

Okay.

Arthur Brooks00:41:33

I want to get—so, you know, for example, purpose in recovery is one day at a time.

Theo Von00:41:38

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:41:39

It's like, today I'm not going to drink.

Theo Von00:41:41

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:41:41

And that's a doable goal, and that gives you a—a sense of purpose. Now, that's—you need more than that, but that's really super helpful.

Theo Von00:41:48

Right. That's a huge thing.

Arthur Brooks00:41:49

It's like people.

Theo Von00:41:50

It's a huge thing.

Arthur Brooks00:41:50

People say, "I can't—oh, I don't get to drink for the rest of my life." I don't know if you get to drink for the rest of your life. I'm just saying you can't—like, can you not drink for today? Yeah, exactly. And, you know, there's a funny thing in my—in my world. You know, we ask a lot, for example, what is the psychology behind the fact that diets always fail? So almost any diet works: low fat, low carb, low whatever, man. I mean, it's like fasting, keto, caveman, whatever.

Theo Von00:42:15

Yeah. Sleep and beauty diet, having a tapeworm.

Arthur Brooks00:42:18

They all work, but they don't work in the long run. Now, the reason they all work in the short run is you can make it today not eating what you want because the scale is going to go down. But when you hit your goal, the reward is never getting to eat what you like ever again for the rest of your life. Congratulations.

Theo Von00:42:33

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:42:33

That's a big problem. That just destroys purpose.

Theo Von00:42:36

Oh, yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:42:37

Purpose is everything. You just don't have any more goals. You don't have any more direction. You can't make any more progress. And so it's obliterated. It's depressing, as a matter of fact. People hit their goals and get really, really depressed and, like, eat a whole cake.

Theo Von00:42:48

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:42:49

Right?

Theo Von00:42:50

Oh, yeah, dude. Somebody sent me a cake, dude. And, bro, if.

Arthur Brooks00:42:55

Did you eat the whole cake?

Theo Von00:42:56

I didn't plan on it, dude, but I woke up in the middle of the night. I wasn't doing well and I ate half that.

Arthur Brooks00:43:01

You ate the half.

Theo Von00:43:01

Bro, I ate it standing up.

Arthur Brooks00:43:03

What kind of cake was it?

Theo Von00:43:04

I don't even know. Dude, it was dark.

Arthur Brooks00:43:06

And it was.

Theo Von00:43:07

I ate it standing up, Arthur.

Arthur Brooks00:43:09

Oh, yeah, yeah. No, I'm not.

Theo Von00:43:11

I mean, who is that?

Arthur Brooks00:43:12

It's me too.

Theo Von00:43:13

But then I was so jacked up on sugar, I couldn't sleep.

Arthur Brooks00:43:15

I know.

Theo Von00:43:16

Now I'm furious with myself. Now I go buy a vape, dude.

Arthur Brooks00:43:19

Now you're full of self-loathing.

Theo Von00:43:20

Oh, now it's 4:00 a.m., dude. And I'm like, I can't live like this anymore.

Arthur Brooks00:43:26

And, you know, here's the irony. It's like there's like 200 people that are listening to this conversation right now at 3:00 in the morning standing up eating a cake.

Theo Von00:43:33

It is true, bro. Yeah. And honestly, and somehow I'm envious of them.

Arthur Brooks00:43:39

Oh.

Theo Von00:43:39

Oh.

Arthur Brooks00:43:40

No, I get it. You know, so this is a.

Theo Von00:43:42

But so where.

Arthur Brooks00:43:42

Now, that's the problem with progress.

Theo Von00:43:43

Where are we?

Arthur Brooks00:43:43

That's progress. You know, progress means that you actually make goals, and they're achievable goals, and you know what they are. And that's one of the big parts of meaning in life. Purpose is part of meaning in life.

Theo Von00:43:53

Okay. And—and—but so that's.

Arthur Brooks00:43:55

That's why you're doing what you're doing.

Theo Von00:43:56

Got it.

Arthur Brooks00:43:56

Because that's my purpose. For today, at least.

Theo Von00:43:58

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:43:59

For today, at least. Now, it doesn't have to be like, I want to be president of the United States. I want to save 7 million children. No. It might be as simple as I'm going to be kind to my wife today. I am going to do one good act for somebody today. I'm going to love somebody who needs my love today.

Theo Von00:44:16

Yeah, including myself.

Arthur Brooks00:44:18

Yep.

Theo Von00:44:18

Sometimes.

Arthur Brooks00:44:19

Yep.

Theo Von00:44:19

That's a big one, dude.

Arthur Brooks00:44:20

Exactly right. I'm not going to eat that cake tonight.

Theo Von00:44:22

Yeah. I'm going to.

Arthur Brooks00:44:24

We'll see.

Theo Von00:44:24

Yeah, we'll see.

Arthur Brooks00:44:26

It's like, don't send Theo a cake, folks.

Theo Von00:44:28

Well, dude, yeah. And when people send a cake, I can't even—and sometimes I'll even curse them or whatever.

Arthur Brooks00:44:34

I know, I know.

Theo Von00:44:34

I'll curse them.

Arthur Brooks00:44:35

I know because they think they're doing something so good for you, but you have no impulse control in the middle of the night.

Theo Von00:44:39

That's true.

Arthur Brooks00:44:39

That's when your willpower is gone.

Theo Von00:44:40

Dude, I ate fricking 17 peanut butter cups one night.

Arthur Brooks00:44:43

That sounds so good.

Theo Von00:44:44

I ate 17 peanut butter cups one night in my 40s.

Arthur Brooks00:44:48

Oh, yeah. Don't—look, I'm in my 60s.

Theo Von00:44:50

Oh, yeah, wolf.

Arthur Brooks00:44:50

There's.

Theo Von00:44:51

So it doesn't get better?

Arthur Brooks00:44:52

Well.

Advertisement00:44:53

Thanks art. You guys know I love Acorns, the financial app where you can invest your spare change from transactions into the market and grow it over time. Well, they're trying a new idea I want to tell you about, and it's pretty cool. It's called Invest My Tips. If you're someone who gets tips as part of your job, like a hair stylist or a tattoo artist or a mover, you can set up an Acorns account, get a QR code, then customers scan that to tip you.

Whatever they tip gets invested for you immediately. Plus, it adds up. $15 a day invested over 40 years could grow to around $1 million. And if you're the customer, you don't even need an account of your own. Tipping is as simple as it is today, except now your tip helps someone save for their future. So now I'm thinking about all the jobs out there where you could use this. Maybe somebody rakes your yard up and bam, you tip them, hit that QR code, help build their future.

Or maybe somebody, um, is delivering ice to your house. You got a warm house, and you—you need some ice. And then you hit them with that QR code tip. Or it could even be your grandmother. She hits you with that healthy hug, bam, bless her bank account. So let's give a shout out to everyone working for tips out there. The people part of our community that we trust and come back to time after time. Next time you tip someone, ask if they have the Acorns code.

Help the people you trust in your community to not just get through the week, but build for their future with Acorns Invest My Tips. You can sign up for it yourself at acorns.com/theo-tips.

Paid, non-compliant endorsement. Compensation provides incentives to positively promote Acorns. Investing involves risk. Acorns Advisors LLC, an SEC registered investment advisor. View importance and disclosures at acorns.com/theo.

Theo Von00:46:57

And so that is the second, um, question.

Arthur Brooks00:46:59

Yes.

Theo Von00:47:00

The second why question is, uh, why am I doing the things that I'm doing?

Arthur Brooks00:47:04

Right. Exactly.

Theo Von00:47:05

And if you ask yourself that question, you'll be able to establish some sense of purpose with yourself.

Arthur Brooks00:47:08

That's right. That's right.

Theo Von00:47:09

Okay.

Arthur Brooks00:47:09

If you basically say, "I am doing what I'm doing because—because XYZ, because I want to lose some weight, because I want to get better grades, because I want to be a more loving person, because I want to get to the end of the day not having used alcohol."

Theo Von00:47:20

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:47:21

Right? That's the person that I want to be. And you got to see that better person, that better version of yourself. Say, "That's—that's me at the end of the day going, yep, still not drinking. That's good."

Theo Von00:47:32

So to visualize it too will help you.

Arthur Brooks00:47:33

Super important. Super important. That visualization is—I mean, that's how—that's how this idea of manifestation actually works. There's nothing—no gears in the universe that are turning. Although I do believe in the power of prayer.

Theo Von00:47:44

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:47:44

I do honestly believe to—I believe that it's a good thing to say, "What is—I'm going to visualize 11:00 p.m. Theo going to sleep, not having done the things he didn't want to do, and now I'm going to pray that God will give me the strength and grace to become that person."

Theo Von00:48:01

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:48:02

That's how purpose—that's how you can—you can bring purpose, you know, to your real life.

Theo Von00:48:06

That even feels cool when you say it. I mean, I—I feel like there's a sense of, um, say that one more time. Say that part one more time.

Arthur Brooks00:48:12

So, okay, so you got—purpose means you got goals and direction. And your goal—your direction is toward a goal that is something good, right? It's got to be something tangible, something that you can actually put a pin in, not something like, "The universe is perfect."

Theo Von00:48:26

Right. Or, "I want to be a millionaire."

Arthur Brooks00:48:27

Yeah.

Theo Von00:48:28

Or a jillionaire.

Arthur Brooks00:48:29

Yeah. It's just—it—no, no. It's, um, it's—it's something really tangible, something really meaningful to you. And it might be as something as simple as, "At the end of this day, I will not have done this, and I will have done that. And I'm going to imagine myself at the end of the day and how I'm going to feel when that has actually come true."

Theo Von00:48:45

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:48:46

And visualize that actually you understanding yourself as having achieved that goal. Nothing audacious. Nothing—somebody else would be like, "Holy mackerel, you did that in one day?"

Theo Von00:48:55

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:48:56

No. It's something realistic that you can achieve.

Theo Von00:48:58

So I would just think like, "Okay, so today if I make it to bed like, like, um, tonight I would like to make it to bed by 10:00 p.m., right?"

Arthur Brooks00:49:04

Yeah.

Theo Von00:49:04

So that could be my thing. And it's.

Arthur Brooks00:49:06

Sober.

Theo Von00:49:06

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:49:06

Stone cold sober.

Theo Von00:49:07

Stone cold sober.

Arthur Brooks00:49:08

Having worked out, having done my job, having done a good podcast, having, you know, fed my body in the right way, having had a couple of conversations and told a couple of people I love them.

Theo Von00:49:17

But now we're—is that stacking too much on, or do you think that's an okay basic day?

Arthur Brooks00:49:21

That's a good basic day.

Theo Von00:49:22

Okay, good.

Arthur Brooks00:49:22

Yeah, because you've actually fed your needs.

Theo Von00:49:24

Got it.

Arthur Brooks00:49:24

Body, soul, work, relationships, in a very—in a very, you know, very modest way.

Theo Von00:49:31

Got it.

Arthur Brooks00:49:31

You know, you didn't call 63 people and say, "I love you."

Theo Von00:49:33

Right. Called a couple of buddies, checked in.

Arthur Brooks00:49:36

Yeah.

Theo Von00:49:36

Listened to them.

Arthur Brooks00:49:37

Exactly right.

Theo Von00:49:37

Um.

Arthur Brooks00:49:37

And then you figure it out, and then—and then you say, "Okay, but—" and I really want that. I see myself doing that. And then you—then you get help. And the way that you—a good way to get help is to say, "Lord, help me make it to that point."

Theo Von00:49:48

Help me make it to that point.

Arthur Brooks00:49:49

Yeah. Help me—it's like, "Be with me until 10:00 p.m. tonight when I'm looking back on that in this way."

Theo Von00:49:53

Mm-hmm. I like that. So, God, help me be—get to 10:00 p.m. tonight. I would like to be able to make it through my day healthily. I would like to be able to take care of my body, my mind, and my soul. Um, I would like to be able to be of service to others. Um, show me examples of ways I can do that. Um, and I would like to get to bed sober, and I would like to get to bed at a decent time tonight.

Arthur Brooks00:50:13

Right.

Theo Von00:50:13

Please be with me until I can get there.

Arthur Brooks00:50:15

Yeah. There's an—there's an ancient, ancient, ancient Catholic prayer that—that—that a lot of priests will pray. And they'll say, "Night has no terror for me sleeping under God's wings."

Theo Von00:50:24

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:50:26

Right?

Theo Von00:50:26

Dang.

Arthur Brooks00:50:27

Yeah.

Theo Von00:50:27

Well, that's a fricking holiday in of the Lord, brother.

Arthur Brooks00:50:29

Yeah. It's too good. It's so good. It's so good.

Theo Von00:50:31

It's nice.

Arthur Brooks00:50:32

So—and then—and then the last of the why questions is, "Why does my life matter? Why does my life matter? And to whom?"

Theo Von00:50:39

And to whom?

Arthur Brooks00:50:39

Yeah. And to whom? Because it has to matter to someone. It's like, "Why does my life matter?" It's going to be like, "Because," you know, something cosmic. No, it's because my mom loves me, because my friends care about me, because God is somebody who's taking care of me. That's the significance question. And you got to have an answer to that. And a lot of people today, they're like, "I don't know why my life matters, and I don't know to whom my life matters."

Theo Von00:51:02

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:51:02

Establishing that is critically important. If you don't know, that's going to be a problem.

Theo Von00:51:06

So significance is the—is the answer to the question, "Why does my life matter and to whom?"

Arthur Brooks00:51:10

That's right.

Theo Von00:51:11

Okay.

Arthur Brooks00:51:11

That's right. And that's getting harder and harder to answer, especially when we're mediating our relationships through screens. It's like, "Why does my—why does my life matter and to whom?" And if it's like all the people I'm dealing with over the entire course of the day are 12 hours through social media, I'm not quite sure that my life does matter.

Theo Von00:51:28

Why does that—why does this so much create this? Oh, because this is a simulation.

Arthur Brooks00:51:33

Yeah.

Theo Von00:51:33

And it's not real.

Arthur Brooks00:51:34

Exactly right. It's very hard for me to deny—for us to deny each other that we matter to each other right now because we're looking into each other's eyes.

Theo Von00:51:41

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:51:42

And we're brothers right now.

Theo Von00:51:43

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:51:43

That's the way life's supposed to work.

Theo Von00:51:45

Got it.

Arthur Brooks00:51:46

But if I'm looking at, you know, it's like, "Hey, Theo," and like, "Text, text, text, text, text, text." I don't know. I don't know what else you're doing. I don't even know if it's you.

Theo Von00:51:53

Oh, that's the craziest.

Arthur Brooks00:51:54

Uh-huh. And that's how the simulation works. Is it real? Is it not real? That matrix effect actually destroys significance. Our brain is not made to—to—and there's a lot of neurochemistry in this. There's a—a neuropeptide in the brain called oxytocin. You ever heard of oxytocin?

Theo Von00:52:11

Oh, yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:52:11

Yeah, yeah. It's the love molecule. And it's how we connect with each other, how you connect with your baby, how you connect with your friends, how—how people who are in love connect with each other very, very deeply for deep friendship.

Theo Von00:52:21

Okay.

Arthur Brooks00:52:22

You don't get it through a screen. Almost nothing. Almost nothing. And so neurochemically, we're not getting the link that we're evolved to actually get to connect with each other as human beings, and that destroys the sense of significance.

Theo Von00:52:34

And is that true? Bring that up.

Arthur Brooks00:52:36

Oxytocin? Yeah. Oxytocin, a natural peptide hormone and neuropeptide.

Theo Von00:52:42

Um, it's often nicknamed the love hormone or cuddle hormone. It influences social recognition, trust, romantic attachment, and mother-infant bonding. Wow.

Arthur Brooks00:52:53

And the new research on Zoom screen, for example, we wanted to know during COVID.

Theo Von00:52:57

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:52:58

How much do we actually get when we're disconnected and we're talking on FaceTime and Skype and—and over the Zoom screen? And the answer is not very much.

Theo Von00:53:05

Um, when prolonged social isolation settles in, the body's hormonal systems undergo a profound shift. Social—social isolation essentially hijacks the oxytocin system by driving down its baseline production and allowing stress hormones to dominate the brain. So that comes from social isolation. So it, uh, it hijacks the oxytocin system by driving down its baseline production and allowing stress hormones to dominate the brain. So not only do you have lower oxytocin, but it.

Arthur Brooks00:53:36

When you're only on screens and not in person.

Theo Von00:53:38

When you're only on screens and not in person. But scientifically, it allows more stress in.

Arthur Brooks00:53:43

For sure. I mean, basically you said that—that—that space man's going to get filled by something.

Theo Von00:53:48

But so the enemies are at the gates, and we're—we—we—we're—we're—we're the gate—we're the enemies and the gates.

Arthur Brooks00:53:53

Yeah. Did—did Bishop Baron—Bishop Bee, when he's on the show, did he teach you the—the—did he teach you the St. Michael prayer?

Theo Von00:54:00

Um.

Arthur Brooks00:54:01

This is a great prayer. So St. Michael the Archangel is one of the three archangels in the Old Testament.

Theo Von00:54:05

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:54:05

And he's believed by Catholics to actually fight the devil. But that's how he talks about it. St. Michael the Archangel, defend us in battle. Be our protection against the wickedness and snares of the devil. May God rebuke him. We humbly pray and do not do thou. O prince of the heavenly host, you know, and—and it talks about, you know, cast into hell Satan who prowls about the world seeking the ruin of soul.

Theo Von00:54:29

Wow.

Arthur Brooks00:54:29

Okay. Good manly stuff, right?

Theo Von00:54:31

We need that right now.

Arthur Brooks00:54:32

We need that right now. But—but look, okay, even if people are watching us, they don't believe literally in Satan. They don't believe in the hijacking of souls. They don't believe in all this stuff. There are problems out there. And you need the sword and shield.

Theo Von00:54:43

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:54:44

You need the defense.

Theo Von00:54:45

Oh, Satan is lurking, bro. Satan these days has cleats on, dude.

Arthur Brooks00:54:49

Yeah.

Theo Von00:54:50

He is active, bro.

Arthur Brooks00:54:51

Yes.

Theo Von00:54:51

That is the realest thing that—that's become more real than ever.

Arthur Brooks00:54:55

And you're just like—if you're looking at your phone all day long, you're wandering into battle unarmed and naked.

Theo Von00:55:01

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:55:01

That's what you're doing. It's like, good luck to you.

Theo Von00:55:04

And most who—like, a lot of, like, the—it's just—it's—it's—there's a lot of ill out there that's coming through the phone, and it's designed, um, it's designed to ruin you.

Arthur Brooks00:55:17

Yeah.

Theo Von00:55:17

I think a lot of it is—it's designed to ruin you.

Arthur Brooks00:55:20

I think that more than anything else, it's designed to leave you vulnerable. It's designed to disarm you.

Theo Von00:55:26

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:55:26

It's designed to leave you completely defenseless.

Theo Von00:55:30

The devil is here. And it's like, uh.

Arthur Brooks00:55:32

And that ruins the sense of significance. The whole—this gets back to who loves me, why does my life matter, and to whom? And it's like, I don't know. No. So people who are isolated, get this. So we talked about this a little bit before. Isolation.

Theo Von00:55:49

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:55:49

Right? Why isolation is so critically important. This is why all of this leads to loneliness is because of isolation. Not because of solitude.

Theo Von00:55:56

And so just so we're—just so we're—just so I'm making sure that we're locked in here. How—and how this is—let's—how does—how is this affecting significance?

Arthur Brooks00:56:02

So significance is why your life matters and to whom.

Theo Von00:56:06

Okay.

Arthur Brooks00:56:06

It's all about love. It's all about the people who value you, people who love you, people who care about you.

Theo Von00:56:11

And one of the main people needs to be you.

Arthur Brooks00:56:13

Got to be you. And—

Theo Von00:56:14

And—and a lot of you gets, um, a—a lot of you gets hijacked when, um, when we're on our screens and we're not actually on ourself.

Arthur Brooks00:56:23

Yeah. It's almost as if you lost yourself, that you don't know yourself. You're not—so it's a funny thing. So I'll—I'll say to people, "Okay, put down your phone for the first hour of the day. Do the Brahma Muhurta, that first hour, starting, you know, 48 minutes before dawn, and—and go for that walk without your device, without—without headphones, just hearing the crunch of gravel beneath your feet and watching the sun come up. You will know you because you're going to be with you."

Theo Von00:56:48

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:56:49

Right? And—and but if you're not, you're—I mean, it's like—so there's a—a—a Vietnamese Buddhist monk who died two years ago named Thich Nhat Hanh. Very—has a.

Theo Von00:56:58

Thich Nhat Hanh?

Arthur Brooks00:56:59

Thich Nhat Hanh. Have you heard of him?

Theo Von00:57:00

Uh-uh.

Arthur Brooks00:57:01

Oh, yeah. He's—he had the, you know, the Plum Village movement, which was a lot of Westerners actually got into it.

Theo Von00:57:06

Oh, really?

Arthur Brooks00:57:06

Thich Nhat Hanh.

Theo Von00:57:06

Rip Thich Nhat.

Arthur Brooks00:57:07

Yeah, yeah. He's—he was—and he's—he wrote—his most famous book was called The Miracle of Mindfulness. That starts off with his description of washing the dishes. And when you're washing the dishes, you should be washing the dishes and thinking about washing the dishes and fully present while you're washing the dishes. Because if you don't, you're not there.

Theo Von00:57:24

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:57:25

You're missing your life. And we're missing our lives. And you're missing your life. So if you're really not missing your life in that first hour of the day, you're there for you. You care about you. You're fully showing up is what it comes down to.

Theo Von00:57:40

If while washing dishes, we think only of the cup of tea that awaits us, thus hurrying to get the dishes out of the way as if they were a nuisance, then we are not washing the dishes to wash the dishes.

Arthur Brooks00:57:52

What's more, we're not alive during the time we're washing the dishes.

Theo Von00:57:56

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:57:56

That's the thing, isn't it?

Theo Von00:57:57

Yeah. It's just about being—like, having a sense of presence. Um, before we move forward, uh, how—let's—uh, can—how can we tie a bow on, uh, significance?

Arthur Brooks00:58:07

So signi—to lock it down and say, "Okay, I—if I'm with—if I'm with somebody who—if I'm with my wife and—and every time I'm with her, she's scrolling her phone. She's not actually with me, and I don't know if she loves me."

Theo Von00:58:21

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:58:22

And that's—that destroys my sense of significance. If every time I'm by myself, I'm scrolling my phone, I'm not with me.

Theo Von00:58:30

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:58:30

And I'm not even significant to me.

Theo Von00:58:33

That's—and that's what it feels like right now.

Arthur Brooks00:58:35

Sure does.

Theo Von00:58:36

You just start to feel like this.

Arthur Brooks00:58:38

Who am I? I'm—I'm nothing. I'm a simulation of me.

Theo Von00:58:43

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:58:44

That's super heavy when you think about it. I don't want to be a simulation of me. I want to be me.

Theo Von00:58:49

Right.

Arthur Brooks00:58:50

Right? I mean, for all the problems that I've actually got and all the dumb stuff that I've actually—I—I want to at least I get one life. Why am I missing it? You know, why am I simulating it? Why am I running it like some sort of weird blooper reel? What—what's the deal? How stupid is that? What am I trying to distract myself from?

Theo Von00:59:07

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:59:08

And the answer is I don't—I don't know. I don't know. I'm just doing it. And that's no way to live.

Theo Von00:59:14

No, it's no way to live. And it's—I mean, I—it's certainly—it's where I find myself a lot of times. It's like, um.

Arthur Brooks00:59:19

Yeah.

Theo Von00:59:20

And also, I don't even notice how it just happens over and over again.

Arthur Brooks00:59:23

Yeah, I know.

Theo Von00:59:24

And the main—it's just like, oh, it's just another rerun of the same.

Arthur Brooks00:59:27

Yeah.

Theo Von00:59:28

Like me finding these little things that I feel like meant something and they don't, and then I just keep going.

Arthur Brooks00:59:33

Yeah. It's a doom loop, actually. It's—and what the problem is that we're very bad at boredom.

Theo Von00:59:36

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks00:59:37

And, you know, life until relatively recently was pretty boring. Your great-grandfather, they were plowing fields three generations ago, right?

Theo Von00:59:44

Oh, I'm sure, dude. They used to smoke, I know.

Arthur Brooks00:59:47

Yeah, yeah. And they were.

Theo Von00:59:48

You got to grow it.

Arthur Brooks00:59:49

And—and they were—and—and, you know, moment to moment, your great-great-grandfather was basically looking at a mule's butt.

Theo Von00:59:55

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks00:59:56

Right? No headphones, no podcast, not even yours or mine, right?

Theo Von01:00:00

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:00:00

But his life wasn't boring. Now you can wipe out every moment of boredom, moment to moment over the course of your life, but life is profoundly boring. See, this is the thing, man. This is the irony. If you try to wipe out your boredom moment to moment, your life is going to be grindingly boring.

Theo Von01:00:17

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:00:17

That's the irony of life. If you're not going to be alive, you're going to be dead.

Theo Von01:00:22

Wow.

Arthur Brooks01:00:22

That's what happens.

Theo Von01:00:23

And we're missing out on being alive.

Arthur Brooks01:00:25

We're zombies. We're walking dead.

Theo Von01:00:26

And so the things that we can do are we can find some coherence, right? Find things that make sense to us, that we believe in, that are sure to us.

Arthur Brooks01:00:33

Mm-hmm.

Theo Von01:00:33

And sometimes if you can't find those in the media, you have to find those in, um, personal relationships.

Arthur Brooks01:00:39

Right.

Theo Von01:00:39

And like, um, just things that are very sure to you.

Arthur Brooks01:00:41

Right.

Theo Von01:00:41

Right?

Arthur Brooks01:00:42

Your spiritual life.

Theo Von01:00:42

Your spiritual life.

Arthur Brooks01:00:43

Super important because that's—man, that gets real real fast.

Theo Von01:00:46

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:00:47

If you're basically like—if you're going to like before at that 10:00 p.m. hour, you're down on your knees, life gets real very fast.

Theo Von01:00:53

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:00:54

Yeah. And a lot of people, it's like, uh, what? Like my grandfather? Yep. Like your grandfather.

Theo Von01:01:00

And sometimes it's like people will say like, um, or I'll—people will say to me like, "Man, I just want to help other people."

Arthur Brooks01:01:07

Yeah.

Theo Von01:01:07

People say that a lot of times. And—and I think about that a lot too. And it's like, but one—one way I think that we can do that is by praying for others. It's like the giving of myself and my energy and my time with God.

Arthur Brooks01:01:20

Yeah.

Theo Von01:01:20

It's like me wanting to focus that onto someone else.

Arthur Brooks01:01:23

For sure. That's a—that's an ancient truth. What you just articulated.

Theo Von01:01:26

Is it?

Arthur Brooks01:01:27

Yeah, for sure. I mean, the monastic tradition is that the—the monks and the nuns that would be cloistered, meaning that they never go out, their whole job was praying for others.

Theo Von01:01:36

Wow.

Arthur Brooks01:01:37

Full-time, man. Full-time praying for other people because we believe, you know, Christians believe that intercessory prayer is a real thing.

Theo Von01:01:44

Oh.

Arthur Brooks01:01:44

That intercessory prayer actually works.

Theo Von01:01:46

Intercessory?

Arthur Brooks01:01:47

Intercessory prayer. You're interceding for somebody else. You're asking God for something for them is what it comes down to.

Theo Von01:01:53

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:01:53

That's super powerful. Now, I don't know.

Theo Von01:01:56

And how long do they pray for it? Is it for all the time?

Arthur Brooks01:01:57

Yeah, yeah. Like—like a lot of the day.

Theo Von01:01:59

Oh my God.

Arthur Brooks01:02:00

A lot of the day.

Theo Von01:02:00

We don't even have for lunch during that or whatever.

Arthur Brooks01:02:02

I know. It's like eating a corn dog and praying for Theo Von. So.

Theo Von01:02:06

Yeah, dude. Here it is over there praying for, uh, Kyle Larson or something.

Arthur Brooks01:02:11

Right.

Theo Von01:02:12

Dude, there's having chips on your lip.

Arthur Brooks01:02:13

No, but it's like—and it's funny because, you know, I know a lot of laypeople, you know, who are—who are not living in religious communities who will have a list of people they pray for every single morning.

Theo Von01:02:22

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:02:23

And actually start their day praying for a list of other people. And I try to do that too. I try to pray for other people every single day and people who—and then the last one is always like, "And Lord, I'm praying for all the people who asked me to pray for them, but I forgot."

Theo Von01:02:34

Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. You got to bundle it.

Arthur Brooks01:02:37

You got to bundle it.

Theo Von01:02:38

Sometimes you have to bundle it, man.

Arthur Brooks01:02:39

I know. But that's really powerful.

Theo Von01:02:41

And God gets that prayer and He's like, "Oh God, I got to."

Arthur Brooks01:02:43

That one again.

Theo Von01:02:44

This one bundled.

Arthur Brooks01:02:44

I know. It's like lame.

Theo Von01:02:46

It's lame.

Arthur Brooks01:02:48

But that's a big deal what you just said. That's a real—that's a real thing.

Theo Von01:02:52

So that's the first one is having co—things that are creating coherence for yourself, right? Things that have meaning.

Arthur Brooks01:02:56

Right. And things that really help you understand why things happen in the world.

Theo Von01:03:00

Got it.

Arthur Brooks01:03:00

Right? The second is making sure that you've got direction in your life.

Theo Von01:03:03

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:03:03

And the third thing is knowing who loves you and why.

Theo Von01:03:05

Got it.

Arthur Brooks01:03:06

That's—and if you do that, you've got meaning. Now, here's a test.

Theo Von01:03:09

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:03:09

To see that kind of bundles all that stuff together. And so it really scientifically validated. I've been giving this test for 30 years.

Theo Von01:03:14

It is—it's very scientifically validated?

Arthur Brooks01:03:16

Yeah. So in other words, we've tested all this stuff. It's in a lot of research, et cetera. Those three—the why questions are super scientifically validated.

Theo Von01:03:23

Got it.

Arthur Brooks01:03:23

There's a guy named Mike Steger who's a—who's a, uh, psychologist and in Colorado. And he's done—he's published, you know, books and academic journal articles on why this works, et cetera.

Theo Von01:03:33

Okay.

Arthur Brooks01:03:33

But I have a two-question exam that I give my students to see where they are on that that makes it easier. And if they're struggling, then they—they don't need to look for the meaning of life. They need to look for the answers to these two questions.

Theo Von01:03:45

Okay.

Arthur Brooks01:03:45

Right? Question number one is, why are you alive? And—and the way to answer that is like, who made me or for what reason? Maker and mission.

Theo Von01:03:53

Okay.

Arthur Brooks01:03:54

So—and—and—and by the way, you can't Google that.

Theo Von01:03:56

So wait, why are you alive?

Arthur Brooks01:03:57

Why are you alive? I mean, why are you walking the earth?

Theo Von01:03:59

And that's a question I need to ask myself when.

Arthur Brooks01:04:01

Yeah. And you—you need to start contemplating that question and maybe thinking about it during your holy hour, first thing in the morning when you're out for that walk.

Theo Von01:04:09

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:04:09

Is thinking, why am I alive? Who did create me and for what purpose am I alive? Because here's the thing, you have been created for a purpose.

Theo Von01:04:16

Amen.

Arthur Brooks01:04:16

Absolutely. But it's obscured, especially on the hard mornings. Like that's when it's hard because that's when old scratch is bothering you, right?

Theo Von01:04:26

When the devil starts weighing in too.

Arthur Brooks01:04:27

That's old scratch.

Theo Von01:04:28

Is that the devil?

Arthur Brooks01:04:29

Yeah.

Theo Von01:04:29

Dang. What the heck? That's his nickname.

Arthur Brooks01:04:32

You're Southerner. You're from Louisiana, aren't you?

Theo Von01:04:33

Yeah, dude.

Arthur Brooks01:04:34

That's an old Catholic Louisiana deal.

Theo Von01:04:36

Old scratch.

Arthur Brooks01:04:37

Old scratch. Not bad, right?

Theo Von01:04:38

God, yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:04:39

Yeah. When he's got his old pitchfork out and he's, you know, distracting you from the things that matter.

Theo Von01:04:43

Poof.

Arthur Brooks01:04:44

So, okay, who created me and for what purpose? And let's give that some thought. Second question is, what would I die for right now happily?

Theo Von01:04:53

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:04:54

It's a funny thing because two of my kids are US Marines. Two of my three kids are Marines.

Theo Von01:04:57

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:04:58

And one of the things that you find is when people come out of combat roles in the military that are—that they're—and they—they can have problems, right? I mean, there's PS—PTSD and, you know, all this stuff. But they're happier because they have answers, especially to that second question. You know, my son was a scout sniper in the Marine Corps. That's a hard job. That's a—that's a—an elite job. And—and I said, "So what would you die for after he came out of the Marines?" 23, married with a kid, right? He said, "Easy. I signed a contract with the government for that question, you know?

I would die for my faith and family, obviously, but I would die for my fellow Marines in the United States of America." Boom.

Theo Von01:05:35

So he had his answer.

Arthur Brooks01:05:36

Mike dropped. He had an answer. And he was fundamentally happier because that was defining of his sense of meaning in life, whether he was thinking about meaning and all this esoteric, psychological.

Theo Von01:05:46

Or whatever he had.

Arthur Brooks01:05:47

Neuroscience nonsense.

Theo Von01:05:48

He had something foundational.

Arthur Brooks01:05:49

Foundational. It's like, "Why—why are you alive?" Carlos says, "Because God made me to serve others."

Theo Von01:05:55

Carlos who?

Arthur Brooks01:05:55

Carlos Brooks, my son.

Theo Von01:05:56

Oh, that's his name?

Arthur Brooks01:05:57

Yeah. Yeah.

Theo Von01:05:58

Oh, shout out Carlos Brooks. Bring up a picture of him.

Arthur Brooks01:06:00

Good old Carlos Brooks. Is he on—is he on the internet? There he is.

Theo Von01:06:03

That's him?

Arthur Brooks01:06:04

That's him.

Theo Von01:06:05

Jeepers, dude.

Arthur Brooks01:06:06

That's my son.

Theo Von01:06:07

And he's like, bro, if he's fricking—bro, if he's mowing the lawn with that.

Arthur Brooks01:06:10

I know.

Theo Von01:06:12

Yeah. Tell him, uh, that's awesome. Oh, that's awesome.

Arthur Brooks01:06:14

Yeah, that's great.

Theo Von01:06:14

Thank you for your service, sir.

Arthur Brooks01:06:15

Absolutely. And his little sister now is an officer in the Marine Corps. She's a—she's a second lieutenant out at KVA, Hawaii right now.

Theo Von01:06:21

Ooh, that's a beautiful place to be for her, huh?

Arthur Brooks01:06:23

Yeah, yeah, yeah. She's 4'11". He's 6'5".

Theo Von01:06:26

So he, uh.

Arthur Brooks01:06:27

And he has to salute her because she's an officer.

Theo Von01:06:30

Really?

Arthur Brooks01:06:31

Well, he's not active duty, but he gave her her first salute.

Theo Von01:06:35

Perfect.

Arthur Brooks01:06:35

That was a very beautiful moment.

Theo Von01:06:37

He gave her her first salute?

Arthur Brooks01:06:38

Yep. As an officer. She was commissioned, um, uh, a year ago in Providence, Rhode Island, after she graduated from college. And she took her first salute from her older brother.

Theo Von01:06:46

Oh, that's awesome, man.

Arthur Brooks01:06:48

It was really great. But, you know, his—he's got answers to his questions. Why did—why are you alive? Because God made me to serve others.

Theo Von01:06:53

Right.

Arthur Brooks01:06:53

For what would you give your life? For my faith, family, for fellow Marines in the United States of America? There—there it is. There it is. First salute.

Theo Von01:07:01

Oh, that's cool, dude. That's beautiful, dude.

Arthur Brooks01:07:06

Yeah. Yeah, yeah.

Theo Von01:07:07

And what is her name?

Arthur Brooks01:07:08

She's a tall Marina.

Theo Von01:07:09

Marina.

Arthur Brooks01:07:10

Marina. She's—she's, uh, she was born in—in, um, in Fuzhou, China.

Theo Von01:07:15

Ooh.

Arthur Brooks01:07:15

We—we adopted her in 2004 at the age of 16 months. She had been abandoned at 12 hours old.

Theo Von01:07:21

No.

Arthur Brooks01:07:21

In a—on a park bench in China.

Theo Von01:07:24

Aw.

Arthur Brooks01:07:25

Parking. No, it was good, man. She's—she's tough. She's tough one.

Theo Von01:07:28

Yeah, it's a good—yeah. Look, I mean, look, if you spend a night out in a park, I'm slipping some parks, dude. You know what I'm saying?

Arthur Brooks01:07:35

At 12 hours old?

Theo Von01:07:36

Hey, not at 12 hours, bro, but maybe, you know what I mean.

Arthur Brooks01:07:39

No, she's—she's tough as nails, man.

Theo Von01:07:40

A couple thousand hours.

Arthur Brooks01:07:40

She's tough as nails. She's so strong and so good, and she loves me, and I love her.

Theo Von01:07:44

Aw.

Arthur Brooks01:07:44

Yeah.

Theo Von01:07:44

Blessings. Thank you for your service.

Arthur Brooks01:07:46

My Lord. Yeah.

Theo Von01:07:47

Marina, um.

Arthur Brooks01:07:48

My baby.

Theo Von01:07:49

Thank you.

Arthur Brooks01:07:49

My baby forever.

Theo Von01:07:50

Yeah, huh?

Arthur Brooks01:07:51

And lethal.

Theo Von01:07:53

Lethal babies, dude.

Arthur Brooks01:07:54

Yeah.

Theo Von01:07:55

That's what—that's what we need more of.

Arthur Brooks01:07:56

I know.

Theo Von01:07:57

We need more lethal babies for us.

Arthur Brooks01:07:59

Yeah, yeah, yeah. But that's why people in the military, by the way, and that's one of the things that I recommend to a lot of young men who have no answers to these questions, I recommend the military.

Theo Von01:08:07

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:08:07

Because the military helps you find answers to these questions.

Theo Von01:08:10

Just adding structure to yourself because things can get really unstructured.

Arthur Brooks01:08:15

Yeah.

Theo Von01:08:15

You know, things can get extremely unstructured.

Arthur Brooks01:08:17

Yes. Yeah. And for you and me too. I mean, who knows if we would have been better off?

Theo Von01:08:20

Dude, when I leave out of here, I could go la—you know, I'm saying there's nothing—it's just me that's going to keep me going for the rest of the day.

Arthur Brooks01:08:27

Right.

Theo Von01:08:27

Like there's things, you know, I have responsibilities to my coworkers and—and we'll do some stuff together, but it's like, yeah, it's—and I'm sure it's the same for a lot of people. It's like, um, yeah, they have to be the ones to keep themselves going. Um, and I think if I can create more of a relationship with myself, then it's more of there's something to keep going.

Arthur Brooks01:08:47

Right.

Theo Von01:08:48

Because otherwise you can fall in, I'm just this sort of like thing.

Arthur Brooks01:08:51

That's right.

Theo Von01:08:52

I'm this re—I'm this repeating thing.

Arthur Brooks01:08:53

Yeah. So thinking about those questions is critical because what that does is it opens up your brain.

Theo Von01:08:58

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:08:59

So the meaning of your life will find you. It's the cheat code.

Theo Von01:09:02

Okay. So I want to say those again. And those questions are.

Arthur Brooks01:09:04

The questions are, number one, why are you alive? Like who made you for what purpose? Like why are you alive? Like why are you walking the earth? I don't know. Random. Right? No, it's more than that. But if you don't think about it, and—and again, it might take years.

Theo Von01:09:18

Right. But you have to plant seeds. That's the other thing about talking with yourself and have a relationship with yourself.

Arthur Brooks01:09:22

Mm-hmm.

Theo Von01:09:22

I noticed for me, it's like it's—it'll plant a little seed. I'll start something and it might not be anything for a little bit.

Arthur Brooks01:09:29

That's right.

Theo Von01:09:30

And then it'll come back around when I have some space or when I have some peace or when I'm.

Arthur Brooks01:09:33

That's right.

Theo Von01:09:34

Rested. It's like, oh, okay.

Arthur Brooks01:09:36

That's right. That's right. That's right. And then.

Theo Von01:09:38

Because your brain will do a lot of the work for you.

Arthur Brooks01:09:40

That's right. And you know, that has been fundamental to my life. I mean, it—there are different points in my life when I felt very desperate.

Theo Von01:09:46

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:09:47

Really lost, as a matter of fact. And—and by the way, that doesn't stop. I mean, the last time I was very desperate was 55. I was retiring from this big job. I was super burnt out. I didn't know what I was doing. And so I went on a—a pilgrimage. I walked hundreds of miles across northern Spain.

Theo Von01:10:03

I was going to say a pill.

Arthur Brooks01:10:04

Nah, pilgrimage.

Theo Von01:10:05

Oh, yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:10:06

Pilgrimage.

Theo Von01:10:07

But that's how things have changed right there.

Arthur Brooks01:10:08

Yeah.

Theo Von01:10:08

It used to be people would go on a pilgrimage.

Arthur Brooks01:10:10

I know.

Theo Von01:10:11

Now they go on a pill.

Arthur Brooks01:10:13

I recommend the pilgrimage.

Theo Von01:10:14

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:10:14

And—and I just thought, you know, why am I alive and for what would I give my life?

Theo Von01:10:18

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:10:18

Why am I alive and for what would I give my life?

Theo Von01:10:20

Why am I alive and for what will I give my life? It's a tough thing to answer, kind of.

Arthur Brooks01:10:24

It is. It is. And sometimes you just have an understanding, a deep understanding of it. And you ask for the grace, if you're religious, to—to—to put this—put the understanding of these questions on my heart. Put these like grant me this wisdom.

Theo Von01:10:35

And so—so that's something I could ask God to do because it's like.

Arthur Brooks01:10:38

Yeah.

Theo Von01:10:38

I don't even know if I know those answers.

Arthur Brooks01:10:40

Yeah. I know. And you—and—and for sure, of course. I mean, it's hard. I mean, and those answers change over the course of your life, for sure. But that led me to, I mean, now, I mean, my purpose, my mission is to lift people up and bring them together in bonds of happiness and love using science and ideas.

Theo Von01:10:57

Okay.

Arthur Brooks01:10:58

That's my mission in life. I came up with that on the pilgrimage.

Theo Von01:11:01

Wow.

Arthur Brooks01:11:02

Asking those questions. You know, and—and—and I feel like that—that information was granted to me because I was in the space to actually get that. But if you don't—if it's like, you know, the way to not be in the space.

Theo Von01:11:13

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:11:14

I mean, it should—and hours pass and days pass and—and—and your life passes.

Theo Von01:11:20

Okay. So I want to say those again. Uh, and those questions are.

Arthur Brooks01:11:24

Number one, ask yourself, why am I alive?

Theo Von01:11:26

So why am I alive? And how do we ask ourselves it? Because you don't want to ask yourself in a way that's negative that puts you in a negative space.

Arthur Brooks01:11:32

Not—not as if, you know, I might as well be dead.

Theo Von01:11:34

Right.

Arthur Brooks01:11:34

But I'm alive. There's a reason.

Theo Von01:11:36

Right.

Arthur Brooks01:11:37

And I want to know what it is. And the two parts are who created me and number two is for what purpose.

Theo Von01:11:43

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:11:43

Now, that doesn't have to be religious like me or you. We—we do our own thing, right? I like my way.

Theo Von01:11:49

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:11:49

But there's got to—there's got to be an answer to that. There's got to be an answer to that. But the second one is, you know, like this, it gets real fast when you say, for what would I die? Like what? Because a lot of people are like, I don't know why I'm alive and I don't have any idea what I'd die for. What a way to—how the hell would I live?

Theo Von01:12:08

Right. Right. Because if you don't have something you would die for, then, uh, then what are you living for, right?

Arthur Brooks01:12:13

Correct. Correct.

Theo Von01:12:14

Right. There's not a real purpose. So—and I think some of us have some basic things, right? Like you, if you have a family or if you have children, those will give you some—some severe purpose. Sometimes it could be work. If you have a work that you're passionate about and you feel like it's helping the world.

Arthur Brooks01:12:28

Right. If you have kids, most people would die for their kids.

Theo Von01:12:30

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:12:31

Most people really would die for their kids. Um, would you die for your friends? Would you die for your country? Would you die for your faith? Would you die for your ideas? Would you die for a stranger? I mean, it's really worth thinking about that, right?

Theo Von01:12:42

Right.

Arthur Brooks01:12:42

Because, you know, I—I don't know. I don't know. But there's sometimes when I feel more like I would and—and—but—but the act of doing that, what that does is, as a scientific matter, is it—it opens up the aperture to meaning by actually activating the right hemisphere of your brain.

Theo Von01:12:59

So it opens up the aperture to meaning by opening up the right side of your right hemisphere.

Arthur Brooks01:13:02

Yeah. The right hemisphere of your brain.

Theo Von01:13:04

Which is where meaning is calculated.

Arthur Brooks01:13:06

This is—this is where we—this is where we process issues of meaning.

Theo Von01:13:09

Okay.

Arthur Brooks01:13:10

Is in the right side of our brain. That's where intuition happens, mystery, love, happiness, all the stuff that—the quiet questions of life.

Theo Von01:13:16

Wow.

Arthur Brooks01:13:16

Like, you know, the how to and what is what you're doing all day long. You know, you're doing your podcast and it's a really technical thing and you got all these stuff, all these, you know, how to and what questions to answer.

Theo Von01:13:24

That's your left brain.

Arthur Brooks01:13:25

But it's going to be really depressing if you don't ask the why question first. Why am I doing the podcast?

Theo Von01:13:30

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:13:31

Why am I doing that podcast? And the answer is to help a whole bunch of people, to entertain and help people, right? Because I want to make my living.

Theo Von01:13:39

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:13:39

And those are—that's really important. Why is way more important. All the important stuff is on the right. All the technical stuff is on the left.

Theo Von01:13:45

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:13:46

And people are on the left side. Anytime you're looking at your phone, you're on the left side.

Theo Von01:13:50

Got it. Well, we've also—the—all of our—the owners of so many of these, uh, tech companies and a lot of these sort of tech oligarchs, and I'm not blaming them, but it's like they are all left—they seem very left brainish.

Arthur Brooks01:14:07

Yeah. They're—yeah, they are.

Theo Von01:14:08

There's—there's just all these tech lords and a lot of—there's a lot of like, you know, these tech lords nowadays, people say that term, but, uh, they all have sort of this, you know, it feels a lot of times like an autism, like where they don't know how to create, like they're trying to connect us more than ever, right?

Arthur Brooks01:14:24

Mm-hmm.

Theo Von01:14:25

But it's not working.

Arthur Brooks01:14:26

Right.

Theo Von01:14:27

And I don't even know if some of them possess, you know, I believe a lot of them have like an autism, like a techism or whatever.

Arthur Brooks01:14:32

Mm-hmm.

Theo Von01:14:33

And that they don't even know how to process. They're just going to keep trying.

Arthur Brooks01:14:37

Yeah.

Theo Von01:14:37

It's like they're just trying to like find the exact formula. It's like, motherfucker, it's a hug.

Arthur Brooks01:14:43

Yeah.

Theo Von01:14:43

You know what I'm saying?

Arthur Brooks01:14:44

Yeah.

Theo Von01:14:44

It's—there's—there's two equa—it's like four equations.

Arthur Brooks01:14:47

I know.

Theo Von01:14:47

You're two arms and my two arms. It's like there's nothing. You know what I'm saying? Like.

Arthur Brooks01:14:51

I do. I do. I know exactly what you're saying. And—and—and one of the biggest problems that we have, and if you back up a couple hundred years to they talk about the enlightenment. The enlightenment was this idea that there's a solution to every human problem, that science is going to come up with a solution to every problem. That was a belief in the enlightenment, that a kind of a religion of scientism. It's completely wrong.

Theo Von01:15:11

Okay.

Arthur Brooks01:15:11

It's completely wrong. And it has everything to do with the fact that scientism and science and technological solutions are the solutions to complicated problems, not the complexities of the right hemisphere, which is all the why stuff, the things you can understand, but you can't solve. I'll give you an example. All of your human relationships, they're not complicated problems like writing software or putting together a jet engine or even building a toaster. Your relationships are complex problems that you'll never solve, but they're easy to understand.

Theo Von01:15:40

Okay. Wait. Say that stuff again.

Arthur Brooks01:15:41

So complicated problems that tech is really good at solving are problems that are hard to figure out, but once you do, they're solved. That's not the same as complex problems, which are really easy to understand and impossible to solve. My marriage is incredibly complex. It's my most complex problem.

Theo Von01:16:00

Right. Love is a complex problem.

Arthur Brooks01:16:01

Because it's completely—it's like, you know, your cat is a complex problem.

Theo Von01:16:04

Right.

Arthur Brooks01:16:04

That's why you love your hood.

Theo Von01:16:06

Being a ch—oh, all these—

Arthur Brooks01:16:07

Yeah. A mechanical cat is a complicated problem, which is why you don't love your—your mechanical cat.

Theo Von01:16:11

Right.

Arthur Brooks01:16:12

Right? And so if the tech guys and the whole culture are saying there's a complicated technological solution to all of our deep human needs, they're going to keep giving us mechanical cats.

Theo Von01:16:22

Right.

Arthur Brooks01:16:23

And that's why we feel so empty when we spend all day scrolling is because there's one mechanical cat after the other and we want a real cat.

Theo Von01:16:29

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:16:30

That's what it comes down to.

Theo Von01:16:31

Who don't want a little cat?

Arthur Brooks01:16:33

Cat's warm.

Theo Von01:16:33

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:16:34

You don't know what it's going to do.

Theo Von01:16:35

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:16:35

It's alive. It's a—it's a creature.

Theo Von01:16:37

Oh, yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:16:38

And the—and the machine, it's like, it's—it approximates a cat. It doesn't poop.

Theo Von01:16:42

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:16:43

No litter box.

Theo Von01:16:44

Right.

Arthur Brooks01:16:44

Don't have to feed it. Just kind of plug it in. It's better than a cat. No. It's completely inadequate.

Theo Von01:16:50

Right.

Arthur Brooks01:16:50

It's totally inadequate. And so all of these tech solutions. So yeah, social media is going to wipe out loneliness. Every hour you spend on social media, you will get lonelier because your brain knows the difference.

Theo Von01:17:02

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:17:03

That's the—it's like social media, which has its place and is not going away, and it can do a lot of good, but it's basically the junk food of our social lives.

Theo Von01:17:12

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:17:12

You know, if you're really hungry and you're coming home from a gig and—and you pass like a fast food place and you're like, "Yeah, it's going to be good." And you stop in and—and it is good, right? You get all your calories, but you get hungry really fast later because it doesn't meet your nutrient needs. And so you can binge and get both malnourished and obese at the same time.

Theo Von01:17:33

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:17:33

If you eat stuff that's high in calories and low in nutrients, social media is high in calories and low in nutrients.

Theo Von01:17:39

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:17:39

Which means that we'll binge it and get lonelier and lonelier and lonelier.

Theo Von01:17:43

Our soul just has a lot of fat on it.

Arthur Brooks01:17:44

And the reason is because it's a simulation of what we actually want.

Theo Von01:17:46

Wow.

Arthur Brooks01:17:47

Fast food is a simulation for the nutrient-dense foods that our bodies need.

Theo Von01:17:51

So why can't we quit it right now? What's going on?

Arthur Brooks01:17:53

Because we're super addicted.

Theo Von01:17:55

Okay. Got it. So we are addicted, but also there's this element of the devil is creating it.

Arthur Brooks01:18:00

Yeah.

Theo Von01:18:01

It feels like—like they are sharpening the spear every single day.

Arthur Brooks01:18:05

Yeah. Well, it's all—it's also—here's an interesting thing. So you've dealt with, you know, we—we understand how addiction to substances work.

Theo Von01:18:11

Oh, yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:18:12

Substance addiction is always the solution to a problem that winds up creating a catastrophe.

Theo Von01:18:17

Okay. Wait. So substance abuse—substance addiction.

Arthur Brooks01:18:21

Yeah. Is always a solution to a problem.

Theo Von01:18:23

Is always a solution to a problem.

Arthur Brooks01:18:25

But it always creates a bigger problem.

Theo Von01:18:26

But it always creates a bigger problem.

Arthur Brooks01:18:27

Right. So for example, people who are anxious are in danger. Everybody watching us who has not—not clinical, you know, generalized anxiety, no, no, no, who has an anxious job, who's an anxious person.

Theo Von01:18:37

Yeah. Like real anxiety, like something, you know, like.

Arthur Brooks01:18:39

Which is unfocused fear.

Theo Von01:18:41

Right.

Arthur Brooks01:18:41

Right? That's anxiety. You're in danger for alcohol abuse. And there's a reason for that. We actually understand that—that you're the alcohol—I mean, anxiety, it stimulates the amygdala, which is the part of your brain for fight or flight.

Theo Von01:18:53

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:18:54

And—and you don't like it, right? And it's chronic and it's uncomfortable. You'll cut the connection with your conscious brain, with your prefrontal cortex, with alcohol. Alcohol snips that connection. So you're stressed up, but you don't know it. And that's the reason that when you're really stressed out, like really stressed out, two drinks and you're a new man.

Theo Von01:19:11

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:19:11

And then another six drinks and you're the best version of yourself. And then—and then after that, you don't remember anything. So the problem with that is that then it will rebound. It will create a much bigger problem with escalation and—and—and all the things that we understand that are attendant on that. If you're lonely, opiates solve that problem because they feel like love.

Theo Von01:19:29

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:19:30

Opiates feel like love and they hit some of the same receptors as oxytocin, as a matter of fact. The problem is that they create addiction and destroy your relationships in the end. The reason that we're using social media addictively is because we hate boredom. It's boring and it—and it wipes out boredom. But what it does is it creates the most boring possible life. That's the irony. It's just like—it's just like alcohol.

Theo Von01:19:53

Right.

Arthur Brooks01:19:53

It's like I'm feeling stressed out and so I wipe out momentary stress and all I get is like the most stressed out, horrible life ever.

Theo Von01:20:01

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:20:01

That's—it's the same thing. We're wiping out a little problem. We're creating a catastrophe. That's how old scratch works, by the way.

Theo Von01:20:07

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:20:07

Right?

Theo Von01:20:08

That's the devil.

Arthur Brooks01:20:09

Uh.

Theo Von01:20:10

The devil's active.

Arthur Brooks01:20:11

Here's the thing about it too. It's so funny. Nobody says the secret to my happiness is social media.

Theo Von01:20:17

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:20:17

Just like nobody says, you know, the secret to my happiness, meth.

Theo Von01:20:21

Right.

Arthur Brooks01:20:22

Like words never uttered.

Theo Von01:20:24

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:20:24

And a lot of people use meth.

Theo Von01:20:25

Yeah, dude.

Arthur Brooks01:20:26

Yeah.

Theo Von01:20:27

I never got to use it. I never—I don't think I would have liked it. I don't like doing a lot of, uh, auto body type of shit.

Arthur Brooks01:20:35

Yeah. It's actually more addictive than cocaine because it actually boosts—it's the substance that we know of that boosts dopamine the most.

Theo Von01:20:42

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:20:42

Crystal meth is a 10X of your dopamine.

Theo Von01:20:46

Dang.

Arthur Brooks01:20:47

It's like supercharge.

Theo Von01:20:49

Dude, it's crazy. They gave it like crystal meth. They gave it as like a kind of a cool name to have overall.

Arthur Brooks01:20:54

I know.

Theo Von01:20:54

You know? Um.

Arthur Brooks01:20:56

So that's the problem with tech.

Theo Von01:20:58

Yeah. I don't know if I feel like there's a solution.

Arthur Brooks01:21:01

There is. There is. There absolutely is. But it requires commitment. We don't need, you know, a massive 12-step program.

Theo Von01:21:07

Okay.

Arthur Brooks01:21:07

I don't think for social media. What we need is—is people to—it's funny because when people stop using, they—there's three things that they always do, right? And they stop using. Number one is that they get pissed. That's the first thing that happens. Get pissed off. This thing is—is—is ruining my life. This thing is sucking out my soul and I don't want to live this way and it's not right. They get angry. You got to get mad enough. You know that feeling?

Theo Von01:21:33

Right. So you have to get upset that you're using this.

Arthur Brooks01:21:35

You got to get furious. You need to be in a rage about that.

Theo Von01:21:38

Like when—yeah. Like what kind of bottom do people have to hit? Like you know what I'm saying? Do you need to sit, you know, like.

Arthur Brooks01:21:43

People's bottoms are different. So set with alcohol abuse, 70% of people who stop using, stop using before they hit rock bottom and have to go to rehab.

Theo Von01:21:51

Amen.

Arthur Brooks01:21:52

So 70%, this is really, really good news. I never went to rehab.

Theo Von01:21:55

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:21:55

I never went—never had to go to rehab. But boy, was my life a mess. And so I—but I was in—I was in the 70%. I could have—I could have taken that elevator down many more floors.

Theo Von01:22:04

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:22:04

Right? So most people, but I—I was so mad. I was so mad at what it was doing to my life, what it was doing to my marriage, what it was doing to my relationship with God. It was tearing me—it was tearing apart my relationships. And I wasn't going to put up with this. Step one. Step two is actually understanding the science of what's actually going on sufficiently that you can actually engage in what the—the medical intervention that's appropriate, right? I mean, you actually have to do something about it, do something tangible about it, which might involve a 12-step program, but usually it has to do with like going to the doctor and saying, "I got a problem here."

Theo Von01:22:38

For alcoholism, you mean?

Arthur Brooks01:22:39

Yeah. Or alcoholism or any drug abuse or any addiction, by the way.

Theo Von01:22:41

But are you talking about a screen addiction to screen too?

Arthur Brooks01:22:43

That is—it's really important that we actually have an intervention. You know, the second step is actually intervening and changing our behavior.

Theo Von01:22:50

Okay. So the first step is hitting a bottom, recognizing getting angry.

Arthur Brooks01:22:53

Getting angry. The second is intervening in the process of using.

Theo Von01:22:57

So you have to intervene for yourself.

Arthur Brooks01:22:58

Yep. And the third is you got to live in a new way. You got to live in a new way. I mean, it's like you got to get new friends. And—and you know, it's funny because one thing that alcoholics always do that's really interesting.

Theo Von01:23:08

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:23:09

Is they try to go to step three first and they'll like move. Hey, man, if I move, then all these stimuli and all these kind of loser friends that I've got and all that, it never works.

Theo Von01:23:18

Yeah. It never works.

Arthur Brooks01:23:19

Because you didn't do one and two.

Theo Von01:23:20

Right.

Arthur Brooks01:23:20

You didn't do actually the—the you didn't get mad enough and you didn't actually intervene. But then you do have to live in a new way. And—and so that's what we need to do with these screen addictions. People need to say, "I'm tired of this sucking out my soul. I'm tired of this actually taking over my life. I'm tired of missing my life."

Theo Von01:23:37

And I—I feel like you almost hope you hit a rock bottom with it. You know, um, I heard my friend, uh, Jay the other day shared at a meeting. He's like, um, and this was about addiction like in, uh, drug and alcohol, but not, uh, screen addiction, but he just said rock bottom is when you break your own heart.

Arthur Brooks01:23:51

Yeah. I know.

Theo Von01:23:52

And I thought that that was pretty profound. It was like.

Arthur Brooks01:23:55

Just this deep disappointment in you.

Theo Von01:23:57

Yes. And how like and like will we get there where we are like we're just fed up. We're like this isn't feeding anything anymore. These are just empty calories.

Arthur Brooks01:24:08

Yes.

Theo Von01:24:08

Um, for a desperate soul.

Arthur Brooks01:24:09

We will because people do. And then we will and we do. And it turns out that the second part of the intervention is easier, much easier.

Theo Von01:24:16

So the first one is over is, uh, getting up.

Arthur Brooks01:24:18

It's like acknowledging I got a big problem.

Theo Von01:24:20

The second one is an intervention.

Arthur Brooks01:24:21

And the intervention, it turns out there's just those three steps, that science-based things that we talked about before. First hour, meals, last hour. That in 42 days, your life is different.

Theo Von01:24:31

So what are you saying you're going to that will help you stay off your screen?

Arthur Brooks01:24:34

Yeah. It'll make it so that when you use your screen, you're using it as a tool and you're not using it as a way to actually pacify yourself. You're not using it to hypnotize yourself. You're not using it to miss your life.

Theo Von01:24:44

Got it.

Arthur Brooks01:24:44

So it's not the kind of thing where you won't think of it in every single moment. So if you don't use it the first hour of the day, after about it takes about six weeks. Most and that's a rule of thumb. Your results may vary, right? It might be less, it might be more. But the whole point is a few weeks and what you'll find is that you won't think of it all the time when you're not doing something else.

Theo Von01:25:01

Mm-hmm.

Arthur Brooks01:25:01

Like when you're waiting at the light, light's kind of taking a long time. It's like, "Eh, nothing." Right? That's because you don't want your mind to wander. You want to keep the mind wandering. It's called the default mode network in your brain.

Theo Von01:25:11

Okay.

Arthur Brooks01:25:11

You want to keep it off. That mind wandering is really uncomfortable and that's why we do it, right? Okay. You won't you'll you'll get out of the habit of distracting yourself all the time.

Theo Von01:25:20

Got it.

Arthur Brooks01:25:21

Which is important. You'll also get more oxytocin because you're eating with other people and you're not having your phone on the table. We're evolved to eat with other people.

Theo Von01:25:30

So you're saying that the actual intervention for self is spending time with yourself in the morning.

Arthur Brooks01:25:34

Right.

Theo Von01:25:34

Have an experience for an hour. Uh, eat.

Arthur Brooks01:25:37

Together with others.

Theo Von01:25:38

Eat together with others.

Arthur Brooks01:25:39

With no phone even on the table.

Theo Von01:25:40

With no phone on the table. So you're engaging in humanity.

Arthur Brooks01:25:42

Mm-hmm.

Theo Von01:25:43

Um, and you have a connection.

Arthur Brooks01:25:44

Right.

Theo Von01:25:44

And then the last hour.

Arthur Brooks01:25:45

Third is last hour of the day. And the phone should never be in the bedroom.

Theo Von01:25:48

Got it.

Arthur Brooks01:25:48

Never. If it's the last hour or the first hour, you don't have it, you don't need it in the bedroom. It's plugged in downstairs.

Theo Von01:25:53

Yeah. It's a phone in your bed. You're you're supposed to have your spouse in there.

Arthur Brooks01:25:56

I know.

Theo Von01:25:57

I know people that'll sleep with their phone and won't even sleep with their own spouse.

Arthur Brooks01:26:00

I know. Well, I know people who are, you know, it's like the saddest thing is a spouse, you know, two spouses lying in their beds, you know, scrolling their individual Instagram until they fall unconscious.

Theo Von01:26:08

And they don't even like each other's shit.

Arthur Brooks01:26:10

It's they're not even laughing at each other's funny memes.

Theo Von01:26:13

Dude, that's the worst, bro. You're you're laying there and your wife posts something you're like.

Arthur Brooks01:26:17

It's not funny. Yeah. So it's it's yeah. No, it's sad actually. And so.

Theo Von01:26:21

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:26:22

I mean, you can save a ton of marriages if you just have like read to each other from a real book and then stare into each other's eyes for oxytocin. Nighty night, man. You'll wake up more in love than you went to sleep. But you won't you're missing your marriage. It's it's just those three things. That's the intervention. And then you got to live in a new way where you're actually engaging in life and love and beauty and pain and life.

Theo Von01:26:47

Right. If there's something on the side it's like say you have something on the scale that's heavy, right? Like it's like, "Oh, this thing's too heavy for me. I'm tired of this like feeling checked out. I'm tired of this phone addiction. I'm tired of this." Like it could be alcohol, whatever it is, whatever this thing is. Yeah. You have to put something on the other side of the scale. So you can't you have to replace it kind of with something.

Arthur Brooks01:27:03

You got to do it. Otherwise, you know what? I mean, I'm sure you know what a dry drunk is, right?

Theo Von01:27:07

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:27:08

A dry I mean, for everybody who doesn't know, a dry drunk is somebody who doesn't replace the alcohol with something that's positive. They don't get to the bottom of what you're actually trying to the need that you're trying to meet.

Theo Von01:27:18

Right.

Arthur Brooks01:27:19

I mean, you're remember you you you you use alcohol abusively because you're trying to solve a problem. So you get rid of the alcohol without solving the problem, you're just going to be like a mean guy. Just that's called the dry drunk syndrome.

Theo Von01:27:32

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:27:32

And we could be dry social media users or something, you know, dry screen addicts or something.

Theo Von01:27:37

Right. You're just standing around looking for something. Yeah. To be like.

Arthur Brooks01:27:39

Monkeys on your back, you know, you're super nervous all the time. You're uncomfortable with yourself. You're bored.

Theo Von01:27:45

Yeah. You don't even you just feel less human. And I and I'm I'm amazed that you think that it's repairable, that you believe that there's another that there's a way out of this.

Arthur Brooks01:27:54

Yeah.

Theo Von01:27:54

Sometimes it feels like there's not.

Arthur Brooks01:27:56

Yeah. But there is. And I've actually seen it with a lot of young people who are actually developing and using these protocols. Once again, it comes back to structuring the architecture of your own life the way that you want to live.

Theo Von01:28:05

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:28:05

Taking back your own brain. I mean, again, it's not easy. If it were easy, everybody would do it. You know, there are actually studies now that show that teenagers would literally pay for there to be no social media.

Theo Von01:28:16

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:28:16

As long as nobody had it. They don't want to be the only ones who had it because they don't want to be alone on Gilligan's Island. They they they want nobody to have it. They would literally pay. I think it's like 35 bucks or something that they say they would pay on average to get obliterate it, right? There's a there's a good study here, right?

Theo Von01:28:31

A study led by researchers examining how much people value social media versus a world without it. When asked about individual use, participants typically said they would need to be paid, uh, 59 around $59 to go without it to deactivate their accounts. And however, when asked about a collective deactivating scenario, many users would actually pay to get rid of the platforms.

Arthur Brooks01:28:51

Yeah. They would pay an average of $28 to deactivate a social media platform and 10 bucks to globally deactivate Instagram.

Theo Von01:29:01

God.

Arthur Brooks01:29:01

You want to get rid of both? 38 bucks. Deal.

Theo Von01:29:04

Dude, how nice would it be? Imagine what it would be like.

Arthur Brooks01:29:06

Yeah. And and you know, that's what a lot and these are teenagers who are saying this. It's not like you and me, you know, grown-up guys.

Theo Von01:29:13

Because then you got to be like around somebody. Like if you want to see people, uh, if you want to see you had to go see them, dude. You had to hope they were somewhere.

Arthur Brooks01:29:23

I know.

Theo Von01:29:23

Remember that?

Arthur Brooks01:29:24

I know. I know. And so what happens is when young people do that, they'll have a they'll collectively do that. Groups of friends will do this. You see this on campuses and they get so much happier. And what are they doing at night after they after Saturday night when they come back from a party? They're just like BSing. They're having those conversations, those late-night dorm conversations.

Theo Von01:29:42

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:29:42

They're not waiting for the YouTube algorithm to deliver them some anesthetizing algorithmically derived information they didn't seek. It's so depressing.

Theo Von01:29:53

And you reminisce, bro.

Arthur Brooks01:29:54

Yeah.

Theo Von01:29:55

Dude, laying like if my friends would sleep over, we'd do a sleepover or something, bro.

Arthur Brooks01:30:00

I know. And you know.

Theo Von01:30:01

And we was reminiscing.

Arthur Brooks01:30:02

But you know the.

Theo Von01:30:03

And we could lie to each other.

Arthur Brooks01:30:04

I know. And you know, think about right now.

Theo Von01:30:06

Remember I'm not hold on.

Arthur Brooks01:30:07

We're having a conversation right now and it's so awesome. I'm just enjoying it so much. Want to know why?

Theo Von01:30:12

Why?

Arthur Brooks01:30:13

Because we're talking about real things in real time and that's life and life.

Theo Von01:30:17

Well, dude, remember when you could lie to your friends, bro? Remember that?

Arthur Brooks01:30:23

Tell me a lie you told your friends.

Theo Von01:30:25

Oh, dude, I remember, bro. So, we had to go like we was doing, uh, I don't know if it was Boy Scouts or if it was just like.

Arthur Brooks01:30:31

You were a Boy Scout?

Theo Von01:30:32

Uh, it might have just been some pedophiles in the area. Nonetheless, we were going camping. And right when we got there, I remember telling everybody like, "Man, I just can't even believe that." And like, what happened? I was like, "Did y'all see that Jay Leno had died?" And they're like, "What?" Even the dads and kids and everybody was like, "What?" And I was like, "Yeah, Jay Leno died." And they're like, "Oh, man."

Arthur Brooks01:30:52

You spread a rumor, a local rumor.

Theo Von01:30:54

So for so for the next two nights, we're out in the woods and stuff and everybody thought Jay Leno had died. So, I'd hear them sit up and talk about it at night and I would be in my tent, bro, like laughing at a level that came from like I can't even tell you.

Arthur Brooks01:31:08

Because there was no internet access.

Theo Von01:31:09

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:31:10

There was no way to fact-check that. Like we're like fact-checking me in real time right now, right? Like nuh-uh.

Theo Von01:31:14

No. And I and I knew that when they got home, he was going to be alive for them. And that was awesome, too.

Arthur Brooks01:31:19

That's pretty funny.

Theo Von01:31:20

I was like, "Damn, bro."

Arthur Brooks01:31:21

That was like real life.

Theo Von01:31:22

Not only am I having so much fun right now, but you guys are going to get Jay Leno back.

Arthur Brooks01:31:26

Oh, it's so great. It's like resurrected.

Theo Von01:31:30

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:31:31

The reincarnation of Jay Leno.

Theo Von01:31:34

Oh, dude. Oh, God, bro.

Arthur Brooks01:31:37

Yeah, that's great. So, so this is so so that's the protocol. That's the protocols. One, two, three, right? And no phone in the there shouldn't be, by the way, any phones in classrooms any place in America. That's completely insane. That's total that's nuts.

Theo Von01:31:49

But at a certain point, though, it's obvious that there are bigger entities out there who want us to they want this.

Arthur Brooks01:31:55

You know, sort of. I think that what's happening is we're finding our way. I know a lot of these guys, and you do, too. They want the best for their kids, and they don't want to get sued to kingdom come, and and they don't want the worst for our kids either. But we kind of people develop stuff, and you know, we've got this dynamic economy where people invent things they think are cool, and it turns out that, well, they're dangerous, too, and we're going to figure it out. And you know, when you meet these guys, they're they're they're good dudes. They're good people, and and they want the best. And it's not just like profit at any cost.

You have to not know them to think that it's profit at any cost.

Theo Von01:32:29

I don't know. Some of them you start to wonder if they're even people sometimes. I start to wonder. And you I start to wonder like do they care about anything other than profit at any cost? Sometimes what I think that they've created is something that they can't control anymore.

Arthur Brooks01:32:44

Yeah. And that's a common thing.

Theo Von01:32:46

And they don't want to admit that.

Arthur Brooks01:32:47

That's right. No. And look, I mean, there were people who who, you know, developed tobacco products or people who developed the automobile, and there were unintended consequences of those things, and and we figured it out.

Theo Von01:32:58

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:32:59

We figured it out. And we're going to figure this one out, too. I'm I'm super optimistic about that. I just don't want to lose a generation in the meantime.

Theo Von01:33:04

I love that. No, I love hearing that because it's like that's the thing that we do need to hear is that there is optimism out there.

Arthur Brooks01:33:09

Yeah. No, no, I'm very optimistic about it because humans are great at figuring stuff out, you know. It's not like the end of civilization. We're going to be all right. We're going to be all right.

Theo Von01:33:19

Yeah. The best thing used to be, though, dude, when it was like you if you wanted a story, you had to go to your buddy to get it, dude.

Arthur Brooks01:33:25

I know. I know.

Theo Von01:33:25

And that was the guy who told the story. And that's what added so much like it added of so much value to me.

Arthur Brooks01:33:32

And it was it was this. And it was oxytocin and it was friendship and it was love and it was good.

Theo Von01:33:37

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:33:37

And now what is it? We're actually just getting it virtually, electronically. Just the facts. Just the facts. Just the facts. Left brain. Left brain. Left brain.

Theo Von01:33:45

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:33:45

Which is of course a simulation of fellowship and goodness and love. That's what it comes down to. So that's you know that's the that's the inter that's the the way that we get in that's the way that we um the cessation method is actually getting into that. That's the the way that we can actually solve the problem. But then we have to live in a different way because we got to live the rest of our lives. And that comes back to living like your great-grandfather. My great-grandfather was Leroy Brooks. He plowed the fields in Olathe, Kansas.

Theo Von01:34:14

Oh, yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:34:15

Yeah.

Theo Von01:34:16

Beautiful out there.

Arthur Brooks01:34:17

He he he married Mary Ellen Janes, the the the sheriff's daughter. Her father had been strung up by Quantrail's raiders, you know, like Frank James and those guys. Strung him up. He was he didn't kill him because they were too drunk to tie his hands.

Theo Von01:34:32

Dang.

Arthur Brooks01:34:32

He let himself down, got married, had kids. I'm alive today because of liquor.

Theo Von01:34:36

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:34:38

Also, not unfortunately not dead because of liquor.

Theo Von01:34:41

That's true.

Arthur Brooks01:34:41

It has a complicated relationship in our lives, doesn't it? But but he was, you know, he was fully alive, bored moment to moment, and completely engaged in his life.

Theo Von01:34:51

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:34:51

Kids, grandkids, strong Christian guy, married 60 years. I guarantee you his life was not boring. He did not say on his deathbed, "Honey, that was boring."

Theo Von01:35:00

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:35:00

Because it wasn't. And so that's and then how did he live? He lived with nature. He lived with beauty. He lived with his faith in God. He lived in love with his wife. He was fully alive and completely engaged in his life.

Theo Von01:35:14

We lived with all the real things that it's like we see clips of and we share them and we say, "Well, this is real. This means something." But we're not like um we don't have a tan like a uh we don't have a true relationship with it sometimes.

Arthur Brooks01:35:27

Yeah. And so we need to we need to go back and do those things on purpose whereas there was no other choice. You know, people send out those internet clips now of how people lived in like the late 70s or 80s or something like that. That was my childhood.

Theo Von01:35:41

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:35:41

And it was like ride our bikes and and and if you got a call home, you got to find a payphone, but you probably don't. Your mom's like, "Make sure you're home before nightfall." And she didn't know any idea where you were or what you were doing. And you're at the arcade playing pinball and and these kids who are like 17 years old are feeling sentimental about my childhood because they know it was real.

Theo Von01:36:02

There was something real in it.

Arthur Brooks01:36:03

Something real in it, right?

Theo Von01:36:04

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:36:04

And that's key is to actually live in this old-fashioned way, falling in love, right? Seeking the beauty in life.

Theo Von01:36:12

That's a big one right there.

Arthur Brooks01:36:14

Huge.

Theo Von01:36:14

Finding some love out there.

Arthur Brooks01:36:15

Huge. And that means in real life, you know, for the guys who are watching us right now with an love is real. Love is a real thing. Oh, man. That's my next book is called Falling in Love and Staying in Love. The Science of Falling in Love is so heavy.

Theo Von01:36:29

Is it?

Arthur Brooks01:36:29

It's amazing what happens to your brain. It's completely indescribable. It's like a total miracle. Have you ever been in love?

Theo Von01:36:36

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:36:37

How many times?

Theo Von01:36:38

Probably three times.

Arthur Brooks01:36:40

Your heart broken any of those times?

Theo Von01:36:42

Yeah, my shit was pretty banged up, but some of it was my own fault. But yeah, dude, when it was good, it was good. I think I was always part of me was afraid to be all the way there.

Arthur Brooks01:36:51

Did you were you always the reason that it broke up that it broke up?

Theo Von01:36:54

Probably in some ways or something. Like I just I don't know. I never had a good the foundation for of it for me wasn't great, but I think it's I do like yeah the moments where you felt like connected man it's really nice.

Arthur Brooks01:37:09

It's like 4th of July inside your head and we actually know I mean the chemistry is actually there. We've evolved the chemistry to bond to each other and find your person to find your soulmate. Human beings are made uh we call it pair bond mating. It's just a kind of a clinical way to say falling in love with your person for the rest of your life. And the goal is the deepest possible friendship. Deepest possible friendship. That's the union of your right hemispheres.

Theo Von01:37:34

It is.

Arthur Brooks01:37:34

Oh, totally.

Theo Von01:37:35

So that's right hemisphere stuff. That's meaning stuff.

Arthur Brooks01:37:37

Totally. My my wife and I it's like when we're in the zone when we're really clicking it's because I mean she's finishing my sentences.

Theo Von01:37:44

Damn.

Arthur Brooks01:37:44

And uh and when we're understanding each other at a deep intuitive level, it's not like, "Yeah, I can I you know, I understand the meaning of those particular words." No, it's just it's this deep intuitive understanding.

Theo Von01:37:55

We're right there.

Arthur Brooks01:37:56

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That's two right hemispheres beating as one.

Theo Von01:37:59

Damn. Oh, it sounds Yeah. Sounds like you're going to get arrested.

Arthur Brooks01:38:03

It doesn't sound like romantic. I know. But you know, but it's but that's really really I mean it's that will lead you to meaning. Falling in love and letting yourself fall in love. And that's you know, it's very hard on apps to do that.

Theo Von01:38:13

Oh, yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:38:14

62% of couples today meet on the apps. Some are better than others. I've actually done a bunch of work with Bumble. I like those guys because they're trying to add more human friction into the algorithm. So, it's not just z z z z z, you know, they're trying to find ways to get people out on real human dates faster. And that's the way it's going to have to be. And once again, we'll solve these problems like that.

Theo Von01:38:35

So, you think a lot of it is just kind of a fine-tuning of this errant ways that we've gone?

Arthur Brooks01:38:39

Yeah. For well, I mean, we're not going to throw our phones in the ocean. It's just not going to happen, right? I mean, we're not we're that ship has sailed and so we're going to have to figure it out. It's like people said we'll never be happy again because of the telephone. I mean, there was an article early on in the telephone where people like people are going to stay in their houses. Somebody's just going to hold a phone up at the church and people are going to listen in their houses. They're not going to see each other anymore. It's the death of civilization. No. No. It's just a tool. What's going to have to happen is we figure out that the internet and especially social media and small screens are nothing more than a tool.

They got to go from entertainment to tool. Here's the here's the way to think about it, Theo. If any device or technology is substituting for your in-person relationships, it's going to make you miserable and ruin your life.

Theo Von01:39:24

There you go.

Arthur Brooks01:39:24

If it's a complement, if it actually connects you to other people, it's good. It's a tool.

Theo Von01:39:29

Welcome.

Arthur Brooks01:39:29

Use it and go forth and you know, be be at peace.

Theo Von01:39:33

Yeah. So, yo, I mean, I just Yeah. I mean, yeah. I mean, there's so many good like like nuggets in this conversation of just ways to evaluate where you're at to begin to have a little bit more of a relationship with yourself.

Arthur Brooks01:39:45

Yeah.

Theo Von01:39:46

Right? Which is so key.

Arthur Brooks01:39:47

Yeah. Um, love yourself and others.

Theo Von01:39:49

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:39:50

Don't distract yourself from yourself. Don't lose yourself. Don't simulate yourself. Real life. And and that's, by the way, when you're not feeling good, that's hard.

Theo Von01:40:02

Yeah.

Arthur Brooks01:40:03

When you wake up and you're like, "No, no, I don't want me. I don't want to be with me."

Theo Von01:40:06

But some of those are the days you got to work through. It's like I know that if I put in the effort right now, then hopefully it'll pay off, you know, that tomorrow will be easier. It's like, you know what I'm saying? Some of the things you start to know and it's just the next foot in front of the other. It's like my buddy Mark Dowell says, it's just like, can I take this next step for myself right now? And that is a truth, right? Whatever's going on in here, if it's not thought, then it's like um, it's like cuz you ever you ever notice sometimes in your brain like I've really started to notice sometimes my brain is just rattling and and I'm rarely thinking.

I feel like I feel like I'm thinking, but it's not thinking. It's something else. Like yeah, it's sort of chatter. It's not deep in its own way. And what's actually this is the hemispheric lateralization problem. Your right brain is not engaged at all. All you're doing is just like kind of information. It's like a ticker tape. It's like the it's like the crawl on CNN headline news. And it doesn't have any content. That's how we feel. Yeah. Sure. Absolutely. That's where we are. We got to get back into the big picture. Oh, yeah. You got to be alive. Fully alive.

There's this guy in the in the early church. There was a saint in the 4th century named St. Irenaeus. Great name, right? We got a name boy as Irenaeus again. And he said, "The glory of God is a man fully alive." Wow. That's what he wanted. The glory of God. What does God want? He wants you miserable. He wants you happy. He wants all of you. What he doesn't want is this degraded version of you that's like getting filtered through a screen. Yeah. Like bring it on and bring it on. And so this is, you know, like this thing early in the morning I'll do this like there was this old preacher named Norman Vincent Peel back in the day.

Norman Norman Vincent Peel and he used to have this thing called a power of positive thinking. He was like one of those old Protestant guys, right? And he used to say every day when you wake up, you can actually get these recordings. They all sounded like that back in the day. Every day when you wake up, he says, "Say the psalm. This is the day that the Lord has made. I will rejoice and be glad in it." Yeah. But there's more to it than that. I say wake up and say, "I'm also so grateful for all the trouble I'm going to face this day because I'm going to learn and I'm going to grow and I'm going to feel somebody else's pain and I'm going to get the meaning of my life.

Bring it on. Amen. Bring it on, man. How do I be a warrior? How do I start to just how do I have that relationship with myself? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. All of it. All of it. All of it. I want it all. I want it all. At the end of the day, you want some of it or you want all of it. This is Yeah. You here for the Yeah. I want the I don't want to scoop. I want the Sunday. Dr. Brooks, you have your uh new book, The Meaning of Your Life. Um, Finding Purpose in an Age of Emptiness. And uh, thank you, man. Thank you so much for coming and talking about it. I love being with you.

Yeah, I've enjoyed it. Do love to do it again sometime. You're uh, you have very, very, very, very special soul. Oh, thanks, dude. Yeah, I feel lucky to be alive um, most of the time. And when I don't feel that way, I got to find a way to get back to that way. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, you you run super deep. You run super deep. And that's got that's got cost. That's got a cost to it. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I'm grateful I have days like this where I can talk with somebody and like, you know, I mean, if anything, I feel way better now than I did when I started. Yeah, man. Let's do it again. What a blessing.

Yeah. Thank you. We'll do it again. Thank you, Dr. Brooks. Thank you. Doors. Now I'm just floating on the breeze and I feel I'm falling like these leaves. I must be cornerstone. Oh, but when I reach that ground, I'll share this piece of mind I found. I can feel it in my bones. But it's going to take a little.

Episode description

Dr. Arthur Brooks is a social scientist, author and professor known for teaching the Science of Happiness at Vanderbilt and Harvard Business School. His new book “The Meaning of Your Life” is available now everywhere. 

Dr. Brooks joins Theo to talk about what makes a meaningful life, why chasing success can feel unfulfilling, and the questions that can help us figure out what true happiness looks like.

Dr. Arthur Brooks: https://www.instagram.com/arthurcbrooks/ 

-------------------------------------------------

Tour Dates! https://theovon.com/tour

New Merch: https://www.theovonstore.com

-------------------------------------------------

Sponsored By:

Celsius: Go to the Celsius Amazon store to check out all of their flavors. #CELSIUSBrandPartner @CelsiusOfficial https://amzn.to/3HbAtPJ 

Acorns: Learn more about Invest My Tips at http://Acorns.com/TheoTips 

Blue Chew: Discover your options at http://BlueChew.com! Buy two months and get the third for FREE with promo code THEO.

Glacier: Privacy isn't paranoia. It's protection. Get 20% off your first 3 months at http://theglacierapp.com/TPW and use code TPW at checkout. #ad

Fabletics: Shop now at http://Fabletics.com/WEEKEND to get 70–80% off everything when you sign up as a new VIP.

-------------------------------------------------

Music: “Shine” by Bishop Gunn Bishop Gunn - Shine

------------------------------------------------

Submit your funny videos, TikToks, questions and topics you'd like to hear on the podcast to: tpwproducer@gmail.com

Hit the Hotline: 985-664-9503

Video Hotline for Theo Upload here: https://www.theovon.com/fan-upload

Mail stuff to: 

ATTN: TPW

PO BOX 40137

Nashville TN 37204

------------------------------------------------

Find Theo:

Website: https://theovon.com

Instagram: https://instagram.com/theovon

Facebook: https://facebook.com/theovon

Facebook Group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/thispastweekend

X: https://twitter.com/theovon

YouTube: https://youtube.com/theovon

Clips Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/TheoVonClips

Shorts Channel: https://bit.ly/3ClUj8z

------------------------------------------------

Producer: Zach https://www.instagram.com/zachdpowers

Producer: Trevyn https://www.instagram.com/trevyn.s/ 

Producer: Nick https://www.instagram.com/realnickdavis/

Producer: Andrew https://www.instagram.com/bleachmediaofficial/ 

Producer: Halston https://www.instagram.com/halstonrays/ 

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices