20/20 New

Transcript of The Scream Murder, Episode 6: The Night Of

46:05 29 min read 45 views Published 5 days ago

Copy link
Episode summary

In the final episode of The Scream Murder, host Connor McCarthy speaks with Tori Adamchick, one of two men sentenced to life without parole for the killing of Cassie Jo Stoddart in Pocatello. Tori says he stabbed her and describes his childhood, his sexuality and the tape the teenagers made.

The episode examines why the crime happened, whether teen killers can become adult psychopaths, and whether life without parole is fair for minors. Listeners also hear from Cassie's mother and from legal experts who argue for and against second chances for juvenile offenders.

In this episode Connor McCarthy, Tori Adamchick

This final episode of The Scream Murder about Cassie Stoddart's murder was made with HappyScribe's automatic transcription of recordings.

Advertisement00:00:00
Connor McCarthy00:01:13

It's been 20 years since Cassie Jo Stoddart's murder, and Tori Adamchick has decided to drop the lies and tell his part of the story. Starting with the night that has haunted the town of Pocatello ever since.

Tori Adamchick00:01:27

I saw a guy up the stairs, and I could feel my heart start to race, and we knew which room Cassie was in.

Connor McCarthy00:01:44

This is the final episode of "The Scream Murder: A True Teen Horror Story Podcast."

Speaker 400:01:51

We left off the last episode of this podcast talking to Brian Draper and Tori Adamchick 20 years after the murder. They're both sentenced to life in prison without parole, and Connor spent months basically getting to know these guys and getting them to talk. And we wanted to, right now, dive into what Tori told you, right off the bat when you first talked to him.

Connor McCarthy00:02:16

Is there anything that's off-limits for you?

Tori Adamchick00:02:20

No, because, like, literally, the only shameful thing that I've really done with my life is stab Cassie. I admitted to everything I'd done except stabbing Cassie, because that was the one thing I couldn't admit to. So I just continued to tell a lie and make everything worse with a lie, instead of taking responsibility for what I had done.

Speaker 400:02:55

This is basically the first time in public he has ever gone this far with admitting what he had done. Because if you remember, Brian was the one who said to police that they did this. He had never admitted this.

Connor McCarthy00:03:07

Never, never. So I didn't know how guarded he was going to be, how open he was going to be. He definitely was cautious and had hesitation. And then when I finally get him on the phone to talk about, you know, his life, this is where we started. So right out of the gate, he takes full responsibility for his part in the crime, and that's the first time that we know of that he had ever done that and spoke about Cassie directly like that.

Speaker 400:03:33

So I just want to take a second and get a little deeper, maybe a little behind the scenes with what it took to get these interviews with Brian Draper and Tori Adamchick. You know, you are doing this with the full knowledge of what they did and how evil this murder was.

Connor McCarthy00:03:48

Yep.

Speaker 400:03:48

But you kind of have to almost set that aside.

Connor McCarthy00:03:51

Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, these are now 35-year-old men. We had just we had been watching and learning about this crime, and they are teenagers. For them to appear on a screen and seeing them as adults was it was startling, to be honest. But I had to I had to show them some patience and some courtesy, for lack of better word, because, you know, we wanted to get to the truth, but I also wanted to make sure that we never forgot Cassie, and that is the reason why we were talking.

And it was it was it was difficult, knowing the crime that they committed and me having a 12-year-old daughter who was not that much younger than how old Cassie was when she was killed. So that was that was difficult, the crime that they had perpetrated. And being a parent myself, it just it, you know, is an emotional level that you have to try to set aside and just get to the core of the truth on why this happened.

Speaker 400:04:51

But then he not only, for the first time in public, admitted his role, he went into more detail about that night.

Connor McCarthy00:04:59

He did.

Speaker 400:04:59

When you hear from them and what he said about that right here.

Tori Adamchick00:05:04

It was something we were talking about. It wasn't until Matt actually left the house that it started to get really real, like it started to become a possibility.

Speaker 400:05:20

Okay, what he's talking about there is the night of the murder. Cassie had been house-sitting, and her boyfriend, Matt, that's the Matt he's referring to, was at the house with her.

Connor McCarthy00:05:31

Yeah, and where they are at this point, they are in the basement. And this is what he said happened next.

Tori Adamchick00:05:38

I followed Brian up the stairs, and I could feel my heart race, start to race. And we knew which room Cassie was in. He told me to go into that room. I told him no, and he walked into the doorway of the living room where she was at. And at that point, I basically knew it was going to happen, but I felt like I couldn't do anything about it.

My memories of what my actions were, I stabbed her twice. And I let I didn't stop Brian from attacking her in the first place. Brian had attacked her, and I followed that up when he told me that she wouldn't die by walking in that room and stabbing her myself.

Like, the one thought was, I guess this is what we came to do, and I forced myself to do it. Brian changed his story a few times, and he ended up doing what I did, which was trying to blame everything on me, as I was blaming everything on him. And so it took us both a while to own up to what we did.

Speaker 400:07:18

When you talked to Brian, he was even less willing to talk about the night of, but he did talk in detail about Cassie and the remorse he felt.

Connor McCarthy00:07:28

When you think about Cassie, what do you think?

Speaker 500:07:32

Just the older I get, like, the younger she gets, you know? Like, she was just a little kid, you know? And, like, she had her whole life ahead of her, and it doesn't matter how much time passes, like, that pain doesn't go away. And that's what I tell these guys, man. Like, like, the TV shows and, like, things like that and, like, like, movies, like, they don't explain, like, what you take and what the consequence.

And it. Like, where I'm at, if I'm in prison on the outside, like, that's never going to go away. It's something that I I don't know. When I think of Cassie, I think of a little girl, man. Like, it sucks. Because I see little girls here and visiting, and I just can't imagine ever hurting someone like that, and I did. And it's just, I don't know.

That's what I'll say, bro. But that's a hard question. I, like, when you're a kid, like, you don't understand shit about the world and about life, and you don't understand anything. And, like, everything was a movie. It was a joke. Everything was just imagination and fantasy, and there was no real consequence to anything until that happened. And then everything became real, and literally living in an area that I've fought so hard to climb out of over the years. But there's one part of that nightmare that will never go away, and that's that she's dead.

That's never going to go away. And that night will never go away.

Connor McCarthy00:09:27

Yeah, I mean, I and speaking with Brian, he wanted to highlight the things that he was able to do on the inside because of what he had done, and that he is stuck at the worst decision he had ever made. And he is never going to get out of prison, is how he's looking at it. And, yeah, that remorse, he was you can see in the video, there were tears in his eyes. Now, there were debates about, you know, was it performative early on, 16-year-old Brian. But I did feel in that moment that it was genuine, there was genuine remorse, whether it was taking a life or remorse for himself that he is where he is today.

But that's as close to the night of that he would get. And I didn't push him on it.

Speaker 400:10:12

Also, what hangs over all of this is the question of, why Cassie? They were all friends.

Connor McCarthy00:10:20

All friends, yeah.

Speaker 400:10:21

And she was, you know, a perfectly normal, regular, not a mean girl in high school. You know, why did they pick her out of the crowd? Was it just, oh, we knew she was going to be home alone, like they said on the tape? Or was there something deeper? And you asked Tori about that.

Connor McCarthy00:10:37

Yes. Maybe you can talk to me. One thing that you haven't described, and this is something we're still trying to kind of get to the core. You know, why someone like Cassie? Why Cassie?

Tori Adamchick00:10:56

Yeah, that I can only explain through luck. Not like, you know, lucky I won the lottery, but I mean, like, luck in the terms of how events fall into place, you know? It's like, if Cassie wouldn't have been babysitting that night, it definitely wouldn't have happened. There's a there's, like, a million events that just fell into place to make it, to make the opportunity available. And me and Brian just were looking for an opportunity at the time when an opportunity came available.

That's why Cassie's death is tragic, is because she just was the unlucky one to be alone when me and Brian knew she was alone. And me and Brian were talking about killing somebody a week before that happened.

Advertisement00:11:51
Connor McCarthy00:13:04

What was Cassie like?

Tori Adamchick00:13:08

Cassie was a school friend, mostly. I knew her a little bit outside of school, but mostly we'd hung out in classes we had together. She was more outgoing than I was, so she could she helped me to feel comfortable around about myself around her. But I can't say what it was that really made us friends, though, other than I guess we just both liked each other and made each other laugh.

Connor McCarthy00:13:52

It's probably hard to talk about because she seemed like she was a good she was a friend.

Tori Adamchick00:13:59

Yeah, she was. Yeah, I really just don't know how I couldn't see the basic empathy that I owed to her as what every human being deserves.

Connor McCarthy00:14:16

It doesn't make any sense. He describes Cassie as just being a supportive friend and who, in some ways, understood that Tori was going through something. He said that she tried to bring him out and encourage him to be himself. She was just she was nothing but kind and supportive. I didn't get the sense that they were close. You know, when he said she was a school friend, that means there wasn't a lot of socializing. So, like we had said in a previous episode, we think they were closer to Matt, and that was more of a reason of why they showed up at the house in the first place.

But this is, in some ways, not a good enough answer.

Speaker 400:14:55

No. There's no good answer.

Connor McCarthy00:14:57

No, there's no good answer.

Speaker 400:14:58

But that's not even close to a good answer.

Connor McCarthy00:15:00

She just happened to be the unlucky one while we were plotting a murder, and it was he's essentially saying it was just a good opportunity because of the circumstances that fell into place. In that video, you can see, though, there is a point when he mentions he didn't show any empathy. There's a pause. I can see he shakes his head, and then he says that. And it's like, I did see in that moment, it felt like there was a real moment of remorse that it is that was just spinning in his head, if he can even see how grotesque that action was.

And I think maybe today, as an adult looking back, I found it to be genuine, not that it excuses anything.

Speaker 400:15:42

Two things can be true. He can be sorry, and he can also deserve to be in prison for the rest of his life.

Connor McCarthy00:15:48

So, like, I had asked Brian Draper to tell me a little bit about his childhood. Since we've heard from everybody else telling us about it, we wanted to hear from him directly. I asked Tori to go through how he thinks of his childhood and going into the teenage years, and some surprising things come out of this conversation.

Tori Adamchick00:16:08

So, my 16th year was split between the last three months of my free life and the first nine months of my life in prison. Before my arrest, I had an uneventful life. I didn't read. I didn't have any talents to speak of, and everything was done for me in way of responsibilities.

I had started a dark thinking pattern or started getting into a dark place when I don't know. You know, I can't pinpoint it, but it probably accumulated from three things. School was just an awkward, awkward situation for me, which is not uncommon experiences, but very real and debilitating at the time.

And these anxieties were compounded by the shame and loneliness of being gay and lost in a heterosexual world. I was scared that someone would find out. All my friends were straight. All my family that I know are straight. Like, I didn't know one person, not even, like, a distant, you know, like, family friend or anything, anybody who was openly gay.

This, unfortunately, made me angry, but it's no excuse for what I did and the choices I made.

Connor McCarthy00:17:55

What I found most interesting about what Tori just said, coming out, I talked to Shannon, his mom, about it. And this is a surprising turn in the story and, you know, what she was pretty open about as who she was then and who she is now. You know, when I asked him how he looks back at that 16-year-old, and he said that he was going he was a kid going through a crisis, do you know what he was talking about?

Speaker 200:18:25

I don't know if he was just beginning to realize it, but he was definitely I don't know if he'd already realized. I don't know how old it was, but Tori is gay. And he really struggled with that. When Tori told me we were in prison, he's like, I've been meaning to tell you this for years, Mom. I know I've never known how to tell you this. It was, like, the hardest thing for him to tell me, that he was gay. And I just said, Tori, after everything we've been through, this is small potatoes.

It meant nothing to me, but I can't say that would have been the case before all this. I would have not been happy. This changed me a lot. I will be perfectly honest. I thought I was a great mother. I really did. I thought, oh, my gosh, I'm doing everything right. Very actively involved with my kids. And then suddenly all those credentials are taken away. Tori's arrested. It's like, I can't parent anybody. I failed at that job.

Connor McCarthy00:19:27

I mean, it all goes back to who they thought they were, the family they thought they had, and the people they thought they were, you know, raising to, you know, the reality of it all.

Speaker 400:19:38

Yeah, the total before and after.

Connor McCarthy00:19:40

Brian and Tori found themselves in a crisis, as they would describe it. You know, being a ghost in high school or not being to be your true self, these are not extraordinary teenage experiences. I mean, millions of kids are ghosts who girls or, you know, coming out to your parents. It's a challenge that I think so many people can relate to, and it doesn't lead to murder.

Speaker 400:20:09

Right.

Connor McCarthy00:20:10

And then when you get to the heart of it, yes, they were in crisis. Was it unusual? No.

Speaker 400:20:16

Right. There's, you know, kids all over the world going through the same thing. They don't kill anybody, and this is no excuse for what they did.

Connor McCarthy00:20:23

Exactly.

Speaker 400:20:23

In any way, shape, or form.

Connor McCarthy00:20:25

They both were they're teenagers who couldn't be with the person they wanted to be with, and that was an absence. And as a result of it, it turned into these, like, violent this violent, angry individuals that, unfortunately, it just snowballed into this, what happened on September 22nd.

Speaker 400:20:47

So the other thing that sort of you want to ponder here is the tape that they made. You know, it's sort of been threaded throughout this podcast. It was threaded throughout the documentary series. And it's one of the things that makes this case so bizarre and so hard to forget. What did you ask them about why they did this tape?

Connor McCarthy00:21:16

Well, I think there was so much debate on the reason for its existence. Was this in preparation of making a movie? Was it the fact that Brian just always had a camera and he was always around and he just captured everything, including the plotting and execution of a murder? But the only people that could answer that question, Brian and Tori. Yeah. If you're okay with talking about it, why did you make that video?

Tori Adamchick00:21:50

It was Brian's camera. And he was in the habit of carrying it around with him and filming before this video was made. And so it as naturally as it could have, it just was us documenting what we were thinking and planning. But by being on camera, I was just aware of that, so I acted a little differently than how I would have off camera, if that makes sense.

And I didn't object to it. And anybody who's watched that video can tell it's blank stupid. There's, like, no organization to it. We rewind it and record it over stuff we had previously recorded. There wasn't any plan for that video. It was just the camera was there while we were doing this stuff.

And so it happened to be made just out of that those facts alone.

Speaker 400:23:02

So, you know, Tori says he was playing sort of a character. We were just documenting. I mean, it was pretty horrific stuff what they were documenting. But then Brian also had a take on it. And this is something we want to just explore a little deeper here.

Connor McCarthy00:23:18

Yeah, this is Brian on the tape.

Tori Adamchick00:23:20

We were largely playing characters. We were playing dress-up, and we were able to we were able to be characters that we wanted to be and people that we wanted to portray. So we didn't I don't think it was really genuinely me or him on the tape or in how we talked. It was just we were posturing and blustering with each other. And it was largely, like, we never sat down and had, like, existential conversations about why we were doing this. Like, that never happened because at the time, I don't think I had the understanding of why I was involved in this either.

It was just kind of like, well, I don't know. It's one of those weird things where I wasn't able to really go into my own mind and, like, introspection and really understand what was going on. But because everyone has, like, underlying, like, motives for why they do things. And when I was 16, I didn't understand my motives.

Speaker 400:24:14

I didn't understand my motives.

Connor McCarthy00:24:16

They both said they were, in some ways, playing characters.

Speaker 400:24:20

Yeah.

Connor McCarthy00:24:20

Or, you know, it was a heightened version of them, exaggerated version of them, of the dark thoughts that they were having. The issue there is they killed Cassie. They went through with it. So this elevated character that they were playing, you know, on TV, that was the real-life version too.

Speaker 400:24:46

You know, you contrast this very sober examination of this question 20 years later by these 35-year-old men. But if you contrast that with the kids we saw on that tape, it's very different. They were happy to be doing what they were doing. And this looking back has to be in the seen in the context of the tape itself, where they were downright gleeful, it seemed, at times.

Connor McCarthy00:25:14

Yeah. We've had a lot of people talk about that tape, including Brian and Tori themselves. But we decided we wanted to go to someone on the outside, an expert in child psychology. And that was Lawrence Steinberg, who is a professor of psychology and neuroscience at Temple University. We had him watch the tape without anything else, any other information, and to see what he was able to gather from that tape.

Speaker 400:25:41

The most striking thing in their conversations is the callousness and the lack of emotionality. There's a second part of it that has to do with their desire to be famous for this, right? They're going to be the worst killers ever.

Connor McCarthy00:25:58

That's going to be murdered.

Tori Adamchick00:26:00

Like, let's see, Ted Bundy, like the Hillside strangler, the Zodiac Killer.

Connor McCarthy00:26:06

No. Those people are more amateurs compared to what we're going to be.

Speaker 400:26:10

So the dynamic between Brian and Tori is one where, I think, at the most fundamental level, they're supporting each other. So it may not be that important to decide who is the leader, who's the follower. I mean, they both are clearly playing off each other in ways that increases the likelihood of this happening. And I think it'd be much less likely to have happened had this been a single individual with this fantasy than two boys planning this thing together.

Connor McCarthy00:26:44

Then how are we supposed to express ourselves?

Tori Adamchick00:26:45

Good and bad.

Connor McCarthy00:26:47

We're bad.

Tori Adamchick00:26:49

We are bad.

Connor McCarthy00:26:50

That sounds so shitty.

Tori Adamchick00:26:51

We're evil. That sounds even shittier.

Connor McCarthy00:26:54

We're not okay. They were sick psychopaths who got good pleasure of killing other people.

Speaker 400:27:00

And for some individuals, these traits stay stable over time, and they evolve into adult psychopathy.

Connor McCarthy00:27:08

Psychopathy. You know, that's the first time I think we've heard anyone use that term, which is loaded. So I asked him, just define that in general terms, what that means to be a psychopath.

Speaker 400:27:21

It's, in some senses, a subset of antisocial personality disorder. And psychopaths tend to be callous and unemotional. They have difficulty empathizing with others. They are very calm and collected. So if I were to approach you from behind and you didn't know I was there, and I touched you on the shoulder, you would probably startle in some ways. And people who are psychopaths often don't startle. That's how calm and cool they are. There's a debate within the field about how good we are at identifying juveniles who are going to become adult psychopaths, whether we can give people tests that are reliable enough to make accurate predictions about the future.

And in general, I think most people in the field believe that we can't do it. We certainly can't do it with 100% reliability.

Connor McCarthy00:28:16

So in what Lawrence Steinberg is talking about, is there a separation between the juvenile actions, and does that carry into adulthood? And I asked Brian about that, to look at himself at 16 and who was that kid who's obsessed with violence. And this is what he had to say about that.

Tori Adamchick00:28:34

I feel like there's two people that there was the kid I was that brought me here and that I committed that crime, and then there's who I am now. And I feel like I'm serving a punishment that belongs to him, not me. I feel like all the parts that made of me at 16 were, like, disassembled, and then they changed on their own as I got older.

Speaker 400:28:59

So Brian's talking there about his punishment, life in prison without the possibility of parole. Both he and Tori, Adam Check, got that same sentence. And there is a divide in the country over whether that sentence is appropriate for a teenager, a minor. Should a minor be sentenced to life in prison without parole? In fact, in 2012, the Supreme Court ruled that mandatory juvenile life without parole sentences violate the Eighth Amendment. It's a cruel and unusual punishment. And 27 states ban it.

The court held in that decision, Miller versus Alabama, that juveniles didn't have the same capacity as adults. Their decision-making wasn't fully formed. The brains themselves weren't fully formed. And we do make allowances in the law for minors.

Connor McCarthy00:29:52

Yeah. I mean, there's this idea that regardless of the crime, however heinous it is, some people view it as juveniles are not as morally responsible as adults because the brain is still forming. In particular, the teenage male brain is still forming. And some say don't complete forming until 25. Now there are studies saying up to 32. So they don't have as much control of their capacities. And that's why they would say, OK, well, because of that, the cruel and unusual punishment argument is in play here.

But, you know, for Brian and Tori, this is a tricky idea. It was premeditated. They committed a crime against a minor, and then there was attempted cover-up. Both the Drapers and the Adam Checks believe that at some point, they should have at least the possibility of a review. Right now, there is no parole board. There is no review. No one is going to talk to them about any release until the day they die.

Speaker 400:30:57

Add to that the fact that the law already makes distinctions for juveniles. They can't drink alcohol. They can't vote. They can't serve in the military. So there is a school of thought that says that we're already making some exceptions. We recognize that juveniles can't do certain things. And we spoke to James Fox, who's a criminal justice expert who has long advocated for criminal justice reform.

Speaker 500:31:26

When you look at juvenile killers, some of the crimes are horrific, but they're not necessarily hardened criminals. And the reasoning behind the Supreme Court decisions made lots of sense that juveniles may they may look like adults, dress like adults, talk like adults, and even kill like adults, they think like children. They don't have the same level of maturity. Adults often kill for clear-cut reasons: jealousy, profit.

Kids, well, they often kill for no reason at all or trivial reasons. A leather jacket, a pair of sneakers, a challenging glance, emulating a movie are no reason at all. So even though they may commit the most heinous of crimes, they are not as morally responsible as adults.

Connor McCarthy00:32:20

If you agree with the idea that, you know, they're not as morally responsible, the brain wasn't fully formed, then that should apply to every case. But I think even in the Supreme Court said there are exceptions.

Speaker 400:32:37

There are exceptions.

Connor McCarthy00:32:37

There are exceptions. This is a tough one to address. As much as Kerry, Brian's father, as much as he advocates for Brian to have some review in the future to show that he's remorseful, that he's changed his ways, that he's been a good model prisoner over the last 20 years, he still struggles with the fact that Cassie's never going to get a second chance.

Kerry Draper00:33:06

What people want more than anything is the opportunity to prove themself worthy of a second chance. If you take that off the table, what is life? What is the point? Why not the death sentence? What is the point? You're just making him wait to die in prison. Does that what does that do?

It just prolongs suffering. It just extends it. You're just spreading it out over more years, more torture, more suffering. But at the same time, I will tell you tell you straight that do I struggle with that question? I do because I think immediately about Cassie's family. Cassie will not get a second chance, and that's my family's fault.

Connor McCarthy00:34:10

So even his even Brian's strongest advocate is still unsure what the right answer is in this situation. And the judge, Judge McDermott, when he addressed them after sentencing them, he gave a very specific reason. There was evidence, a lot of evidence, overwhelming evidence, that they were going to commit more crimes. And that is his justification is saying, I don't see a reform in behavior because of the extent of their plotting and planning to commit more murders.

Speaker 400:34:42

The standard outlined by the Supreme Court was irreparable corruption. And irreparable corruption was the standard applied to Tori and Brian. And according to the Appeals Court, they met that standard. So here's James Fox again.

Speaker 500:34:59

In 2012, in the Miller decision, the Supreme Court ruled that mandatory life without parole was unconstitutional in the case of juvenile offenders. They did not rule that the decision should apply retroactively. I think it should. And many states, including my own Massachusetts, have decided that the concept that juveniles should be treated differently than adults, that they're not the same as adults, should be retroactive.

Other states, like Idaho, have not made it retroactive. And I think that's unfortunate.

Speaker 400:35:42

So there will be no parole for Brian and Tori. They're in there till the day they die. They have now spent more time in prison than out of prison. And you talked to them about just the day-to-day in there.

Connor McCarthy00:35:55

Yes.

Speaker 400:35:56

They grew up in there, basically.

Connor McCarthy00:35:57

They grew up in there. Yeah. Tori asked me early on when I talked to him, he's like, have you ever been inside of a prison? And I said, no, I have not. And I wanted to find out what it was like because I think this will illustrate part of the punishment so people can see this is what happens. This is what you get when you commit first-degree murder. How do you describe your physical surroundings to someone who hasn't been in where you live?

Tori Adamchick00:36:32

Prison is just a series of hallways and confined spaces, really, like dayrooms are way too small for the amount of people that are in them. Cells are basically the size of a small bathroom. An example I give to people is I just ask them to imagine having to live with your neighbor in your bathroom for hours on end and then just imagine the problems that are going to arise under those circumstances.

It's just a reminder, but everything's a reminder. Like waking up in the morning is a reminder. It's not something that you walk away from, like I'm just stuck at that worst decision I made. If you believe my life is worth redeeming, give me a pathway to redeem myself. If you don't think my life is worth redeeming, then just go the other route and go full force with it.

Speaker 400:37:45

Wow. He says go full force.

Connor McCarthy00:37:48

Yeah.

Speaker 400:37:48

You talked to him. What do you think he means by go full force?

Connor McCarthy00:37:51

Capital punishment.

Speaker 400:37:52

Execute him.

Connor McCarthy00:37:53

Execute him. Yeah. I mean, that's a heavy, heavy moment from Tori just looking at the reality of it. Like, if you're not going to give me the ability to do anything, to put some good back into society, in any way to redeem what I did to Cassie, what is the point of me sitting in this cell for the next 50 years?

Speaker 400:38:13

I guess that's the kind of philosophy that can come from sitting in prison for 20 straight years, having a lot of time to think about what you did.

Connor McCarthy00:38:21

I mean, they could seemingly spend 65 years inside a prison. They have not left that prison in years when they were transferred there. Brian was transferred there at 18, and he has lived in that same facility ever since. They, in fact, Brian and Tori are in the same prison. And they are kept separate intentionally. I think that's policy. If there are two people that are part of the same crime, they don't want them to be mingling too much. But there are a few opportunities where they see each other.

Speaker 400:38:54

Do they exchange words? Have they said anything?

Connor McCarthy00:38:57

Brian said he saw him one day, and he said he walked up and he said, Tori. And he said Tori turned around and didn't recognize him at first. And then he said they had a conversation. I think part of it is there is there's some debate on who did what, when. And Brian said that was still there. Tori said there's still a debate on where the responsibility lies.

Speaker 400:39:22

So they have this out in the prison yard.

Connor McCarthy00:39:24

They had this conversation about it. And, you know, what Brian said is there is no bond.

Tori Adamchick00:39:34

Nothing, man. I know this is going to be an underwhelming answer, but Tori and I are completely separated. I don't feel anything different for him than I would for anyone else here. I don't have an association to him anymore. I think, like, time has done its thing, and we've grown. And I don't have any animosity towards him. I don't have any hatred towards him. I think that, you know, he's living his own life. I don't understand him. I never have. But I'm at the point now where I don't need to.

I don't care. I don't not caring is not the right word. I don't need to understand him anymore. I don't feel a need to engage in his life. I think that he has his own life. I have my own life. We're adults now. The kids we were are gone, and that bond is gone. That's how I see it.

Connor McCarthy00:40:23

So on the last day that I was with Kerry Draper, Brian's father, he took me out to the prison where Brian's been incarcerated since he was 18 years old. And as we sat out there, he was just gazing out into, you know, into the concrete boxes, the roof in the distance where his son lives. And he said this to me about where he is today and where his son is today.

Kerry Draper00:40:50

I take responsibility for my children. I raised them. If anybody could have prevented it, it would have been me. And I didn't. I'm to blame as much as he is. He was a kid. Without a doubt, I would trade my time for the freedom of my son.

If I could walk in there and he could walk out, if I could spend the rest of my life in there, I would in a moment if he could come out.

Connor McCarthy00:41:37

He's going to live with that for the rest of his life. I mean, in no way should he take any responsibility for it. I understand. I'm a parent. I understand his sentiment. But I think it's he's taking on too much of a burden, unfortunately. Yeah. You do take responsibility for your children. And you wonder if I did something or I didn't do something that sent them on that path. And it's impossible to know the answer. If anything that you did somehow just turned them.

Speaker 400:42:04

Or didn't do.

Connor McCarthy00:42:05

Or didn't do.

Speaker 400:42:05

Yeah.

Connor McCarthy00:42:06

Just turned them in that direction. It's he's just a tragic figure. And just the burden that he's carrying every day is unbelievable.

Speaker 400:42:15

I'm glad you played that clip of Kerry visiting Brian in prison. He can go there, like you said, every Sunday and visit with his son. When I met with Anna Stoddard, Cassie's mother, we talked about this. And she and I went to Cassie's grave. And she said very clearly they should be in prison for the rest of their lives. And their parents can go visit them while they're in prison.

I have to go to a graveyard to go see my daughter. That's what Anna Stoddard said. So while I do feel and I think anybody watching that would feel some sympathy for him, let's not forget that Anna Stoddard's daughter, Cassie, is in a graveyard. There's no visiting her.

Connor McCarthy00:43:03

Yeah. No arguing that.

Speaker 400:43:06

So one person, Cassie Jo Stoddard, has been absent from this story. And she kind of hovers over this whole thing. It's her murder. She's the one with no future. And when you think about Cassie Jo, 16 years old, what were we saying about her? She was nice. Everybody liked her. She was good at drawing. It's kind of a thin story because the story was just starting. So Cassie didn't have much of a story or a past. But what she did have was possibilities. She had a future.

She wanted to go to college. She wanted to be a lawyer. She wanted to be a prosecutor. Would she have kids by now? Would she have had a good life, a bad life? Those are the possibilities that she had, the future that she had, uncharted. And her absence is kind of felt throughout this because it was all taken away by Brian and Tori. And I think that's something to remember is that they have, as grim as it is, a life.

But she doesn't. And they are the ones that took that away.

Connor McCarthy00:44:15

We both felt that the only appropriate way to end this series is to hear from the person who loved Cassie the most. And that was her mother, Anna, who unfortunately passed away in 2022. Here's a little bit more of her impact statement from 2007.

Anna Stoddard00:44:32

My name is Anna Stoddard, and I'm Cassie's mom. We don't get to see Cassie anymore. Christy doesn't have her sister anymore. My granddaughter doesn't have her aunt Cassie. There's a big, big, big, huge empty spot in our lives. And that spot's going to be there forever, that empty spot. You may have killed my daughter, but you will never take away from me and my family the memories and the time that we had together with Cassie. She will live in our hearts forever.

Advertisement00:45:12
Episode description

In the final episode of The Scream Murder: A True Teen Horror Story, twenty years after Cassie's murder, Brian Draper and Torey Adamcik relive that Friday night.

For more from 20/20, check out 20/20 True Crime+. Subscribers get ad-free episodes, early access to new series, exclusive bonus content, and hundreds of episodes from the 20/20 true crime vault. Visit ⁠apple.co/2020truecrime⁠ to subscribe now. Terms apply.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices