This episode of 20/20's After Show revisits the disappearances of Josette Wright and Robin Murphy in Carmel, New York, in the 1990s. Host Deborah Roberts speaks with journalist Paul Solotaroff about the staging of Josette's remains, the convictions of two men later overturned, and the role of psychics in the search.
Sarah, who testified in DePepo's third trial, describes her childhood abuse and her fears as Howard Gombert nears release. Listeners will hear how a new task force is revisiting the case and what the guest argues should happen next.
In this episode Deborah Roberts, Paul Solotaroff
This episode about the Putnam County girls was made with HappyScribe's audio transcription technology, the same tool behind this page's transcript.
Ads in this audio differ from the text. Tap the sentence you're hearing to follow along.
Synced: the text now follows the audio.
The following contains descriptions of sexual assault, which may be disturbing to some.
Hello everybody, welcome to 20/20 The After Show. I'm Deborah Roberts, and it's good to have you with us. Today we have a fascinating story, an intriguing story, where we are going to take you, of course, behind the scenes and have a second look at our latest 20/20 episode from Friday night. This is a story that most of us around here haven't been able to shake. A story of heartbreak, of uncertainty, all that gripped a small community upstate New York. The disappearance of two young girls who vanished within months of each other from the same small town, Carmel, New York.
The kind of small town where people know each other, and it's a very neighborly place, and kids wander around to each other's yards. That was until 12-year-old Josette Wright and 17-year-old Robin Murphy went missing. Well, as you can imagine, these cases shook the entire community, leaving people wondering if there could be a killer or killers living amongst them. Well, investigative journalist Paul Solitarov wanted to know the answer to those questions as well. He's a longtime writer, a senior writer for Rolling Stone magazine, a podcaster.
He was also a part of our program on Friday night on 20/20. Paul, so great to have you with us.
I'm honored and privileged to be here, Deborah.
And I should say that you're also the host of "Bone Valley" season six, "The Devil's Quarry 2." And you said in that podcast that these stories pierce at your heart. Tell me what led you to the story of these two young girls, and what was it about it that just haunted you?
So what brought me to Putnam County was convictions of two young men, Anthony DePepo and Andy Krivec. And when Josette went missing on October 3rd, 1994, six months after she disappeared, the second beautiful young girl, Robin Murphy, went missing.
Well, tell me a little bit first. Let's talk about these girls. Because first, as you said, Josette goes missing, and we talk about in our piece, 17-year-old Robin. So let's talk about her case, because she was last seen getting ready to meet her boyfriend in the spring of 1995. They were going to meet at a Burger King where he worked. In our piece, you tell us how Robin was a kid with big ambitions, and in this small town, she wanted to get out of this town. She wanted to be a punk rocker. Tell us what you learned about her.
So Robin was one of those kids who would have fit right in, in Tompkins Park in Greenwich Village.
She had a big spirit.
She did, but she was such an off-center kid. She loved goth. She loved vampire movies. She was a kid who styled herself after the fashion of Anne Rice novels, and who couldn't wait to get as far from Putnam County as her legs would carry her. So at 16, she drops out of high school, not because she can't do the work, but because the work bores her stiff, and goes to work full time at the shop rate.
She goes missing. The case is basically just goes cold. I mean, the case still remains unsolved to this day. And as you might imagine, her mother was just racked with, you know, pain and I'm sure all kinds of questions. She was so desperate over the years. She would even reach out to psychics. There was a medium who was involved. Police actually spent some time with this medium at one point who thought he knew something and could help place and find the body. With no other leads, police actually did spend a little time and pay attention to this guy.
And there was a tip that prompted them to search in a flooded mine. And I know that there are a lot of people who would find this just absolutely bizarre, but many people, and I've found this in my reporting too, many times families are very desperate. You know, they are willing to hear what somebody who claims to be clairvoyant might have to say. Have you found that in investigating stories too, that oftentimes families will turn to either a psychic or someone whom they think might be able to help, absent any other clues or progress?
It was the mom, Judy Murphy, who went out and beseeched these television psychics who she'd seen on the Sally Jessie Raphael show, Laurie Kovich.
But what was so interesting is in this small town, at that time, no more than 30,000 people, a small town. And how coincidental that two girls would go missing. You know, six months before Robin went missing, 12-year-old Josette Wright, as we said, had vanished from the same town. And two teenagers are eventually investigated and convicted for Josette's murder, Anthony DePepo and Andrew Krivec. These were guys who were on the radar of police because of, you know, maybe minor drug involvement.
Police knew about them. What made them become suspects in a murder?
Well, let's background just a little bit. Josette's remains were found in a shallow grave, very elaborately staged. And let me just say something about the staging of Josette's remains. When these two hunters pulled up a patch of earth and found the skeleton and the skull of Josette Wright, what they found was her hands were bound behind her in an extremely elaborate way, so that the knot that connected her hands bound behind her to her throat, a noose around her throat, which also attached to one of her legs.
Meaning she had the freedom, barely, to walk into those woods with her murderer, but not the freedom to kick or resist or she would have strangled herself. The second important detail was that her underwear, her soiled underwear, had been stuffed down her windpipe, and her bra--remember, this is a 12-year-old girl--had been tied around her eyes as a blindfold. So elaborately bound, gagged, and blindfolded.
It was clearly the work of a practiced sadist.
Yet a teenage girl actually did come forward and say that she had seen these two assault and kill Josette in a van. So when you have eyewitness testimony, it's sort of hard to ignore that.
It is, except when you are trying to rape and murder a minor. You would expect in a violent crime scene to find several things. One, physical forensic evidence that the two alleged killers had left behind. Skin cells, blood, semen, hairs, any trace of their DNA.
That was a big question. People wondered about that. She stands by her story even today, but there were big questions about this case, as you say, and whether these two could have actually done this. And over the years, more questions and hearings and trials, and after spending roughly two decades in prison, after several appeals, and we reported this in our piece in 20/20, both DePepo and Krivec had their convictions overturned within a few years of each other. Both acquitted of raping and murdering Josette at retrial.
While that was obviously great news for them, there must have been, I mean, this must have been just devastating all those years though. I mean, talk about the impact for these two men to have spent all those years in prison, even though they were eventually freed.
So when you go to prison, you wear what is called the jacket. Your jacket is your conviction, whatever the nature of that conviction is.
Whether sexual assault or murder or whatever.
Exactly right. The biggest bullseye on anybody's back in not just prison, Deborah, there is a special place in hell in New York State called up top. It is the jails at the Canadian border, Attica, Western, Dannemora. That is where the worst of the worst are sent. And here go these two with no violent history, with no significant criminal history. They somehow have to convince killers, serial rapists, that they didn't do this thing.
Both of them do that, but then the miracle happens. Anthony DePepo, ninth grade dropout, goes to the law library, teaches himself how to read the law. That was Anthony DePepo.
Well, we want to talk more about that, because things did change for these two. And it's just, I mean, it's fascinating when you talk about how he educated himself and advocated for himself, but also there was a key voice that spoke up and played a pivotal part in this trial. So we're going to take a break. Don't you go anywhere, and don't you go anywhere, because we're going to come back and you're going to hear an emotional story from someone who really changed everything in this case. So stay with us.
Welcome back to 20/20, The After Show. I am here with investigative journalist Paul Solitarov, host of the Devil's Quarry 2 podcast. And we're talking about the case in upstate New York of two young girls who vanished from the same small town just a little more than an hour north of New York City. One of them was eventually found dead, the other still missing 30 plus years later. I also want to bring in a woman who testified in Anthony DePepo's third trial, because there were lots of questions about whether the two men who had been charged with this murder were guilty.
Her name is Sarah. And the jury would ultimately find him not guilty of raping and murdering Josette. It rendered the felony murder charge null and void. And Sarah was a part of our story on 20/20 last Friday night, where she just so courageously shared the details of the horror that she has had to endure after a sexual assault. She talked to John Quiñones. Sarah, thank you so much for being with us.
Thank you so much for having me here.
I was so touched by your, as I said, your bravery, your honesty, and just by your being able to revisit something like this and being willing to revisit something so horrific with us. You grew up in Connecticut, and when you were around seven years old, a man named Howard Gombert came into your life. He was in his 30s. He was dating the best friend of your mom. And one day he offers to take you swimming, and you say he brought darkness into your life. How so? Tell us about it.
So I actually had a plan to go spend the week with my mom's best friend. She was like another aunt to me. It was right around summer break. And I spent time with her regularly. So my family was like, yeah, sure, no problem. I don't think anyone realized though that he was not just an abusive man towards her, but he was a predator. And I had slept over the house. We were supposed to all three of us go swimming.
And Jane at the time, she wasn't feeling up to going with us, so she stayed home. And yeah, he took me to a couple of different places. We went to Kmart that day. We had picked out a bathing suit. Then we went to his father's house.
What kind of a bathing suit did he pick out for you? Because this was really shocking to me.
Yes. The bathing suit that he had picked out was a leopard print two-piece bathing suit.
For a seven-year-old.
Yes. And it wasn't like, you know, like there's some tan keenies that are covering. They look more like a one-piece. No, it was not. It was most definitely a very small bathing suit, something that wasn't appropriate for someone my age. But yeah, so after that, we had gone to his father's house. And then we were supposed to go to Swans Pond, but we went around the back, like took a back road there.
And we were there, but you could see the beach across from where he had brought me. Like he brought me into the woods. Definitely knew where we were going, because the area that he had brought me to was like a perfect cutout of trees. It was almost like he'd been there before. But then after everything had happened, he brought me to these rocks that we had jumped off of, across from the beach at Swans Pond. And it was such a bizarre experience afterwards.
Like I felt so out of touch with myself, I guess. I remember like jumping off the rocks into the water and just not wanting to swim back, because I felt like the water was the safest place for me at that moment. And seeing like all those families across, like having fun and.
You told us in the piece so emotionally about how he had assaulted you, how he sexually abused you. And I'm just wondering, at that time, you said that you were in the water, you didn't want to come back, you felt like you wanted to separate yourself. Could you make any sense of what had happened to you at seven years old at that moment?
I couldn't, not really. I just knew that I was scared and in pain, and I had been threatened. And I knew, like in that moment, I thought it was real. I thought what he was saying, he would do. And I just had to listen to it. It's almost like that day, like a part of me, a part of me got silenced.
Because he tried to silence you. He told you not to say anything to anybody and that he would hurt you. And you told us how you really believed that. You eventually told a friend, and Gombert was ultimately convicted of sexually assaulting you, and he was sent to prison. Did you feel safer at that moment?
When I had told someone, at that point, I don't, honestly, I don't remember myself, but so I've been told, when I had told someone, he had already gotten in trouble with what he had done to Jane. So he was like away. So I, as a grown woman, I'm assuming I felt safe at that point. But to be honest, I don't remember a significant amount right after everything happened.
A lot of it, you know, I don't know, I probably chose to forget, but.
Understandably. You say he took your innocence, but you will not let him win and make you feel like a victim. That's powerful stuff. How were you able to find your way to that place in life?
Oh, it's been a long journey. I started with a therapist through a safe haven program in Connecticut, which is a pretty amazing program that they have there. And it's just been one heck of a journey between learning how to really cope and process everything that's happened to me and the things along the way that have happened because of decisions that I've made based on prior experiences.
But understandably, understandably, because you were a traumatized woman who had been injured so badly as a child. Sarah, years later, as you're coping and trying to put your life together, you actually were brought into the Anthony DePepo case. And the defense was seeking to point to Howard Gombert as an alternate suspect. Prosecutors maintained that he was not involved. You did take the stand. Tell me about that and your decision to do it.
When I first heard about Andy and Anthony's position, I was blown away. And I was just, I was heartbroken because the things that I was hearing, the reason that they reached out to me was because of, unfortunately, the similarities in my case and the way that Josette was found. He had taken his tank top off, and he had shoved it into my mouth. And then he had held my hands in front of me during it.
So when he was on top of me, yeah. So it was very similar to the way that she had been found, between like how she was bound. And I decided that I knew it would be difficult, but if I could find some type of silver lining in this awful experience, then I want to help. If me speaking out and saying my story could help these two men get out of prison, you know, they were young guys at the time, why wouldn't I?
DePepo, as you said, did have that third trial, and ultimately he was found not guilty. Later, Andrew Krivac was, he remained in prison, but he was later released. Now Gombert, he's never been charged. He's serving his final months of a 30-year sentence, and he is set to be released. The man who assaulted you is very close to getting out of prison. How are you processing that?
I've thought about this for a long time, and I let it consume me. Just like the fear of it and always feeling like I needed to watch my back and learn how to protect myself. And after going through so much therapy and having the life experiences, I'm a different person now. I was a scared little girl at that time. And yes, that little girl still exists in me. So there is still a fear.
But I'm also an angry woman. I am also a woman who needs him to know that it's not over. There's no way you're going to just walk free and that's the end of the story. It can't be, because I have little ones in my life. I have nieces, and it terrifies me to think like he could be anywhere near them. Like he shouldn't even be breathing the same air as them. Why is this still a thing?
Why are we still allowing people that hurt little children to walk free? Like that's insane to me. So I'll keep fighting against it.
Well, you're an inspiration to so many people, and clearly you made such a huge impact on the lives in this case. Sarah, thank you so much for taking some time and for bravely showing up and sharing your story with us. We really appreciate it.
Thank you so much for having me. I really appreciate you guys being able to share the story.
Well, you're somebody we won't forget, that's for sure. Well, we're going to take a quick break. And when we come back, Paul is going to share some revealing details about his correspondence with the man that Sarah just described with Gombert from prison. So stay with us.
Welcome back to 20/20, The After Show. I am joined still by investigative journalist and host of the latest installment of the Bone Valley Podcast, Paul Solicharov. Paul was talking with me about this case that he has just dug into upstate New York, two convictions that were overturned and eyes on Howard Gombert, who was sent to prison for assaulting a young girl. He was brought up in Anthony DePepo's trial as a defense strategy as an alternate suspect. He has not been charged in that case, and he may very well be coming out of prison in the next few months.
Paul, you actually spoke to Gombert over the phone in prison. What was that like? Why would he agree to talk with you?
Because he can't help himself, Deborah. So before I got on the phone with Gombert, I had a long talk with myself in the mirror in which I said, listen, you, he is going to provoke you. He is going to press buttons. Do not rise to the bait. Let the man talk. Just continue to ask questions. And that lasted about seven minutes, Deborah. I was and remain so enraged, so haunted, not so much by what he did, but by the suffering that lives on in his.
You questioned him, and things got heated between the two of you. Did you expect that?
I did everything in my power to prevent it. But Deborah, I run hot. And you can't do what I do if there isn't this intense need to do one thing. And that is to bully the bullies of the world.
Yeah, he has denied any involvement in this murder. In a statement to ABC News, the Putnam County District Attorney says Howard Gombert is a reprehensible person who's committed reprehensible acts. However, there was always insufficient evidence to charge him with the death of Josette Wright. That was the statement that we had from Putnam County. They did not comment on Robin's disappearance other than to say that the case is still open. They're still making efforts to try to solve her disappearance. It's ongoing. But I will say, and you alluded to this earlier, a new task force has been formed to look back into Robin's disappearance and Josette's rape and death.
You had a lot to do with that, no doubt. You know, you're digging into the story. What do you see potentially happening? What would you like to see happen?
Oh, the question I've waited all day for. Deborah, there is absolutely no hope of justice in Putnam County organically. It must come from without. And so I am asking, pleading, beseeching your viewers, as I have beseeched, pled, and begged the listeners of Bone Valley to call, write, and otherwise express their outrage to two women.
Tish James, the Attorney General of the State of New York, and her boss, Governor Kathy Hochul, they have in their power the latitude to appoint a special prosecutor to go in and dig up these cases from the very beginning.
We will keep following this story. And I know, Paul, you're going to stay on it. And we thank you so much for being a part of our broadcast and for being a part of this podcast today. And thanks to all of you for choosing to spend some time with us today. If you know someone who has experienced sexual abuse or assault, help is available. Speak with somebody today at the National Sexual Assault Hotline at 800-656-HOPE, or you can text HOPE to 64673. And of course, you can find 20/20 on Friday nights on ABC, and you can stream episodes just like this one anytime on Disney Plus and Hulu.
Thanks so much, everybody, and take care.
A woman speaks out about her assault. Journalist and "Bone Valley" host Paul Solotaroff joins her to discuss the haunting details.
To get ad-free episodes, early access to new true crime podcasts, and exclusive bonus episodes, subscribe to 20/20 True Crime+ on Apple Podcasts. Click here to start your free trial today. Terms apply.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices