Transcript of #357 Payne Lindsey - “He Was the First Monster I Ever Really Encountered”

03:57:57 164 min read 0 views Published about 7 hours ago

Copy link
Episode summary

This episode covers how Payne Lindsey, creator of the true-crime podcast Up and Vanished, became an amateur investigator. He describes starting with the 2005 disappearance of Georgia teacher Tara Grinstead, how a small-town community reacted as his weekly episodes aired, and the surprise arrest of a man who reportedly confessed while on painkillers, a confession the guest argues was flimsy.

He also discusses confronting suspects, working with state investigators in Georgia and Colorado, and cases in Montana and Alaska. Listeners will hear how he handles risky encounters and the ethical choices involved in true-crime reporting.

In this episode Shawn Ryan, Payne Lindsey

This episode on Payne Lindsey's Up and Vanished investigations was made with the same technology HappyScribe uses for its Google Meet note taker.

Advertisement00:00:00
Payne Lindsey00:01:51

Payne Lindsay.

Shawn Ryan00:01:53

Sure.

Payne Lindsey00:01:53

Shawn Ryan.

Shawn Ryan00:01:53

Welcome to the show, man.

Payne Lindsey00:01:55

So, dude. Nice, nice shades.

Shawn Ryan00:02:00

Okay, the story is my buddy bet me 50 bucks I wouldn't put them on. So I'm trying to collect. So.

Payne Lindsey00:02:09

Gotcha.

Shawn Ryan00:02:10

There you go, man.

Payne Lindsey00:02:11

50 bucks, richer.

Shawn Ryan00:02:13

Yep.

Payne Lindsey00:02:13

So I came to collect.

Shawn Ryan00:02:15

Well, dude, you've been digging up some crazy shit. Like, whoa. Going through the outline is like, damn, dude. So we got a lot of stuff to cover.

Payne Lindsey00:02:26

We do.

Shawn Ryan00:02:26

All right. I'm going to give you a very brief introduction here. Payne Lindsay, you're the creator and host of Up and Vanished, the true crime podcast that reopened the 11-year-old case of Tara Grinstead, led to two arrests within six months of its first episode, and became one of the most downloaded true crime podcasts of all time with more than 250 million downloads. It's insane.

Payne Lindsey00:02:54

It's actually, I mean, for being technical, it's like 800 million, I think, now.

Shawn Ryan00:03:00

800 million?

Payne Lindsey00:03:01

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan00:03:03

That's like everybody in the country watched it two and a half times.

Payne Lindsey00:03:07

Maybe.

Shawn Ryan00:03:08

Shit, that's a lot. You had no police files, no training, and a $100 microphone. You've since investigated a case on the Black Feet reservation in Montana, two cases in Noma, Alaska, and dozens of others. You've spoken to serial killers, traced the origins of COVID, and explored UFOs. In 2016, you co-founded Tenderfoot TV, now one of the biggest independent podcast studios in the country, with over 30 original shows, 600 episodes, more than 400 million downloads, and this year's Podcast of the Year at the Andes.

That is... When did you start this?

Payne Lindsey00:03:50

2016.

Shawn Ryan00:03:51

Damn, dude.

Payne Lindsey00:03:52

This was not part of the plan. This was just, uh, I just kept working afterwards, to be honest.

Shawn Ryan00:03:58

Really?

Payne Lindsey00:03:58

Yeah. I mean, I thought podcasts, I'm like, they don't make money, right? It's not a career move.

Shawn Ryan00:04:05

What were you doing before this?

Payne Lindsey00:04:07

I was a freelance filmmaker, just broke, living with my brother.

Shawn Ryan00:04:11

Yeah?

Payne Lindsey00:04:11

Yep.

Shawn Ryan00:04:12

Is your brother involved in this?

Payne Lindsey00:04:14

Uh, he's worked for me off and on, or I've given him a free job when he's needed it. But yeah, I mean, he was there from the inception, when everyone thought it was pretty crazy that I was trying to go solve an unsolved disappearance in South Georgia and make a podcast about it. They thought I was a little, a little nuts, I think, at first.

Shawn Ryan00:04:35

Well, I mean, how did that pop on your radar? And like, what was the passion behind it?

Payne Lindsey00:04:42

I mean, it was, honestly, it was pretty simple. I mean, I grew up watching Unsolved Mysteries. That's my jam. I've always been fascinated about things.

Shawn Ryan00:04:50

Like old TV show Unsolved Mysteries.

Payne Lindsey00:04:52

Oh, yeah, exactly. I mean, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun. Yeah, I mean, I still have reruns playing sometimes. It's just an easy background listen. But I had just watched The Jinx on HBO. It was a true crime documentary where the filmmakers essentially caught the bad guy. And I'd never seen something like that, where a documentarian essentially flipped the cameras around on themselves and caught this guy admitting to killing this woman.

And I was like, what, how does someone get into doing that, exactly? Like, what's the path? Did they just decide one day, I'm going to do this? And I was like, I think so. So I'm going to do that. I'm going to do my own documentary called Up and Vanished, and I'm going to find the coldest case in Georgia, and I'm going to go try to solve it. And since I don't have any money or resources, I'm just going to do a proof of concept first.

So I'll do a podcast. And then the podcast itself became its own thing. But at first, it was just going to be like a proof of concept, just an example. But then it became the whole thing. And I, yeah, I couldn't have imagined the impact it would have had in real life back then.

Shawn Ryan00:06:23

800 million downloads, man?

Payne Lindsey00:06:25

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan00:06:26

800 million downloads? Like, what?

Payne Lindsey00:06:30

Yes. Yeah.

Shawn Ryan00:06:31

That's a lot.

Payne Lindsey00:06:32

Yes.

Shawn Ryan00:06:33

On one series?

Payne Lindsey00:06:35

Yes.

Shawn Ryan00:06:37

That's insane.

Payne Lindsey00:06:41

It is. Thinking about it, yeah. I mean, I thought 10,000 downloads was a lot back then. I mean, it is a lot. Yeah, I didn't.

Shawn Ryan00:06:51

That's like.

Payne Lindsey00:06:52

I think, I think, I think 10,000 downloads, if you get 10,000 downloads a month, I think it's either the top 10% or the top 1% of podcasts.

Shawn Ryan00:07:02

I believe that.

Payne Lindsey00:07:04

Yeah, I remember the first week, episode one, season one, 2016, in seven days, I had 5,000 downloads. And I was like, holy shit. I mean, that's more friends than I have on Facebook, so I'm doing something.

Shawn Ryan00:07:20

Right on.

Payne Lindsey00:07:20

But I never knew what the ceiling would be. I was like, what even is the audience of a podcast? How big is that even, you know?

Shawn Ryan00:07:29

Shit, dude. I mean, there's like 320 million people in the US.

Payne Lindsey00:07:35

Damn, so I guess you're right. The math was kind of correct there.

Shawn Ryan00:07:37

Yeah. It's over everybody in the country would have listened to it over twice.

Payne Lindsey00:07:43

I think the same people were just listening to it over and over again.

Shawn Ryan00:07:46

A couple thousand times. Damn, that's insane. So how did Tara pop on your, how did she pop on your radar? There's the coldest case.

Payne Lindsey00:07:56

Yeah, I mean.

Shawn Ryan00:07:57

So you're from Georgia.

Payne Lindsey00:08:00

The Georgia Bureau of Investigation had a top 10 list of unsolved crimes. And the very first one on their list, number one, was the disappearance of Tara Grinstead, which at that time, it happened about 11 years before that. And just the circumstances by themselves were bizarre. They had no clue what happened to her. Her keys and her phone were missing. Her car was in the driveway. Front door was locked.

And there was a latex glove in the yard. And they had no clue what happened. How does that happen? Was my first question. How does 10 years of investigating not deliver some sort of, something with some evidentiary value here? And I just started poking around. And I didn't expect to actually end up investigating it for real.

Shawn Ryan00:09:01

Who was she?

Payne Lindsey00:09:02

She was a schoolteacher. And she was a former pageant queen.

Shawn Ryan00:09:07

Beauty queen. When did she disappear?

Payne Lindsey00:09:10

2005, October.

Shawn Ryan00:09:14

And you started in 2016, so this is.

Payne Lindsey00:09:17

So about a decade afterwards.

Shawn Ryan00:09:20

So what's the story? And that caught your interest, or you were just, you just, it was a challenge. Like, I'm taking the coldest case.

Payne Lindsey00:09:27

It was kind of a challenge, for sure. But I think that there were, to me, there was a lot of unclosed loops. She did have associates in her life that were men that had never been cleared. I mean, law enforcement had always said that no one's been cleared in this case. They never labeled a person of interest or suspect, but there were acquaintances that had some odd stories. So there was a place to start there.

But even as I went down that road, it would always kind of end up nowhere. And it seemed like the general direction that everyone had been looking in the known people in her life, that it maybe had nothing to do with them at all. And I just started talking to people. And then people in a tiny town in South Georgia.

Shawn Ryan00:10:21

How many people? It's like 3,000 people?

Payne Lindsey00:10:23

3,000 people. Then those same 3,000 people start hearing their buddy or their neighbor talking. And then that kind of inspires more people to start talking, or someone's getting pissed because, hey, they're saying that about me. And it really just created this tense atmosphere. If you want to talk about shaking the trees, that's what it did. And it did it pretty quickly and abruptly. And I think people weren't even prepared for what this was.

There wasn't really a blueprint for this. Like, I don't think anyone knew, what do you mean a podcast? Yeah, tune into this, send me the link. It was like the first.

Shawn Ryan00:11:04

You were doing a podcast?

Payne Lindsey00:11:05

Yeah, so actually the first time I, when I put out the first episode, I actually bought Instagram ads and ran them locally in Osilla and let people know that this was coming out. And I was really trying to drum up interest from people who obviously know this story and care about Tara and wanting to know what happened to her. And I think that that caught on pretty quickly. And then from there, it grew to the state of Georgia.

And it just, at a certain point, I think the temperature got hot enough and new information that otherwise was being held secret just started popping out. And everyone was responding in real time. And so it was a very bizarre seat that I was in, because each week I was putting out a new episode.

Shawn Ryan00:12:02

So you, okay. So you have zero investigative background, right?

Payne Lindsey00:12:08

Zero.

Shawn Ryan00:12:09

Nothing.

Payne Lindsey00:12:09

Nothing.

Shawn Ryan00:12:10

No former law enforcement, nothing like that, no schooling, nothing.

Payne Lindsey00:12:16

No.

Shawn Ryan00:12:16

You decide you're going to go into true crime. You look for the coldest case around where you live.

Payne Lindsey00:12:24

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan00:12:24

It's in a town of 3,000 people, word travels fast. I mean, and you know this teacher who was a beauty queen disappeared and there's a latex glove.

Payne Lindsey00:12:34

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan00:12:35

That's pretty much it?

Payne Lindsey00:12:37

That's, when you put it that way, yeah, I can see why some people were probably pissed that I came down there. Yeah, I mean, yeah, I had no investigative experience. All my experience came from documenting people. I've been a storyteller my whole life. And I was like the quiet kid observing people. And so I only applied that. I really never even pictured myself investigating it.

I guess it seems obvious in hindsight that that's what I would be doing, but it wasn't like I set out to be some Sherlock Holmes or something. I just was telling the story, then all of a sudden the story became about this case that was unfolding and that I was in the front seat of the investigation of and was part of this podcast and this internet community that was even spawning the suspects to talk.

And I'm getting subpoenas and stuff now. I'm in the middle of something. And I realized, okay, this is not what I set out to do. So I had to make a decision. I remember.

Shawn Ryan00:13:57

You're getting subpoenas?

Payne Lindsey00:13:58

Yeah, they wanted to know the IP addresses of people who were on our discussion board. And they wanted to know everything.

Shawn Ryan00:14:06

So did they close the case and reopen it? Or was it just, oh, no, it's open, but nobody gives a shit and we're not doing anything about it?

Payne Lindsey00:14:13

Well, it's the ongoing investigation.

Shawn Ryan00:14:15

Oh, the ongoing, yeah.

Payne Lindsey00:14:16

Yeah. Which, I mean, I've since learned that that's just kind of a blanket thing.

Shawn Ryan00:14:23

Yeah. If it's just sits in a filing cabinet.

Payne Lindsey00:14:25

Yeah. But I also learned in the first couple of weeks that there was something strange going on. By episode three, I was actually underneath a house in a crawlspace, digging based on a tip that I received that there may be a body in here. It was obviously a long shot, probably nothing, but I'll check it out. I drove back to Atlanta that same day. When I got back, I got a call from one of the PIs that I was working with, who worked on the case a long time ago.

And he said that the GBI was there at the same place I was just at, digging in the same spot. And I was like, wait a minute, how did they know about this? Are they following my leads now? What is happening?

Shawn Ryan00:15:14

Oh, so they, I thought you meant, so it wasn't like they were there five, ten years ago.

Payne Lindsey00:15:20

No, they were there like right after.

Shawn Ryan00:15:22

Five hours later.

Payne Lindsey00:15:23

Yeah. And that really threw me because I had told.

Shawn Ryan00:15:28

They're worried you're going to humiliate them and solve a case with basically no resources. And the Georgia Bureau of Investigation is following your fucking.

Payne Lindsey00:15:39

I guess. I mean, that's how it looked to me as well. Yeah, I mean, it went from them not doing anything, at least visually from my perspective, to I go search underneath the house and then they're there too. And I was like, holy shit, man. This is concerning. I felt weird about it because it was the first time I felt like I was being pulled into the center of something that was very unfamiliar to me.

Shawn Ryan00:16:14

Okay, where do you start with this? Like, you show up to this town. What is the name of the town?

Payne Lindsey00:16:21

Osilla.

Shawn Ryan00:16:22

Osilla, Georgia, 3,000 people. Everybody knows everybody.

Payne Lindsey00:16:26

Yep.

Shawn Ryan00:16:27

Word travels fast. I mean, where do you even, where do you start with that information?

Payne Lindsey00:16:32

Well, I went to the safest place possible. I called my grandma. And just so happens that she lives about 20 minutes down the street. And one of her best friends named Melba actually saw Tara the night that she went missing. And I didn't even know that this was so close to her like that. And so I called her out of the blue one day and asked her about this. And she tells me this information. Then next thing you know, I'm talking to Melba, who's now introducing me to this person.

And I'm sitting there thinking, I think my grandma just opened the door to this case for me. And so, yeah, I mean, all credit to grandma, to be honest. That's where I started. And it actually spawned a chain of new interviews. And I pursued that. And I started talking to people who were close to Tara through that.

Advertisement00:17:36
Payne Lindsey00:21:20

I mean.

Shawn Ryan00:21:20

Were they happy? Somebody took interest in it?

Payne Lindsey00:21:23

They were. People were, at first at least, the people I talked to were excited that anyone still gave a shit, that anyone was looking into this. They'd seen the news coverage over the years. They had seen other TV specials. And a decade had gone by and they still had no clue what happened to her. And so a new fresh look, even if it was from some city slicker podcast guy, they were cool with that.

And they had no clue what happened. I would get, you know, mixed reviews on that. I think there was a lot of suspicion.

Shawn Ryan00:22:03

What did they think happened?

Payne Lindsey00:22:05

There was a lot of suspicion about her. Her ex-boyfriend came up a lot. There was another police officer from a nearby town who left his business card in her door and had a relationship with her. And he was married. He was on the radar. There was also a former student of hers that was arrested for essentially harassing her at her doorstep like six months earlier. So there's these three male figures in her life that some of their stories had holes in it.

Some of the behavior was weird and couldn't be explained. You could maybe try to find a motive if you searched hard. But again, the deeper you dove into these people, it never really turned into anything. And I think that's what law enforcement kept running into was that, okay, it's got to be one of these guys, right?

Shawn Ryan00:23:00

Did you talk to them personally?

Payne Lindsey00:23:01

I did. So actually, I got a hold of the former student on Facebook. And I called him randomly one day. And he had never spoken to media before about this at all. And I just asked him point blank, what was your relationship like with Tara? Was it sexual? And he said, yes, which to me seemed like something that you wouldn't make up. It's not a good look necessarily to make that up.

I could tell he was being honest. And I think for a lot of people, it sort of cleared that up a bit, like the mystery around that. And in some ways, we were able to kind of check him off the list a little bit. Like just based on his whereabouts, his alibi, and his admission to, yeah, we did have a consensual relationship for a couple of months. I want to know what happened to her too. Okay. That's.

Shawn Ryan00:24:06

How did you approach, like was that your first?

Payne Lindsey00:24:08

Yeah, I was like, I'm Payne Lindsey. I'm doing a podcast. Yeah.

Shawn Ryan00:24:13

Were you sexually involved with Tara?

Payne Lindsey00:24:15

Yeah, I think I said, I said, so were you in a relationship with Tara? And he's like, yeah. And I go, was it sexual? And he just goes, yes. I'm like, okay. I had to ask the question. I think, yeah, that was the first time I really had to put like my big boy pants on and ask uncomfortable questions that someone may not know are coming their direction. And yeah, I mean, obviously, I was like pretty uncomfortable talking about this stuff and putting someone else even in an uncomfortable position.

But I think I realized even just after that one phone call where I learned that information from him that he was way, way more uncomfortable than I was, right? And so, I mean, if I'm uncomfortable, that's fine. But almost nine times out of ten, the other person across the room or on the other line is probably ten times more uncomfortable. I should remember that and lean into this sort of creating of an atmosphere that things are okay.

Let's just talk about this in a chill, relatable way. You're not under, this is not interrogation. I'm not a cop, bro, right? I should lean into this because that's one of the few things I have that's making me stand out in this world of investigative reporting or true crime podcasting or whatever the hell it was that I was doing, which I was still trying to figure out what that even was. But I learned that people were kind of drawn to the familiarity of just what seemed like a more normal individual that didn't have an agenda and sort of being surprised that, wait, it's just this guy?

And I was like, okay, I should use that to my advantage, you know, regardless of who they are that I'm talking to, if I can.

Shawn Ryan00:26:25

Wow. And so would you, I mean, how quick would you, how do I ask? How much research and investigating and interviewing would you do before it would turn into one episode?

Payne Lindsey00:26:41

I'm not going to lie. I mean, I spent probably six months researching, doing interviews. And eventually, I just said to myself, I got to put this out or I'm just never going to put it out.

Shawn Ryan00:26:54

Shit. So you spent six months before the first one?

Payne Lindsey00:26:57

But then I put out episode one and I told people that episode two was coming out next Monday and I had nothing planned for it. And I used, I already used all my interviews too. And I was like, okay, that was a bold move, bold choice. But that began a series of me sort of chasing my tail, but in the strangest way, opened up this extremely raw, real-time sort of communication line with this community.

Shawn Ryan00:27:31

Damn, that's crazy.

Payne Lindsey00:27:32

People would tell me something and then the same day sometimes it would be in the podcast. And it would come out in this sort of cinematic storytelling form. It wasn't just like a raw phone call. It was presented with a cliffhanger at the end each time. It was kind of this very surreal beast that I was, you know, making. And it allowed me to maneuver in ways that were super quick.

I didn't have to like go shoot for six, eight months and then, you know, whatever happened back then is what this is going to be. It's like, no, we can change this today, tonight, or just keep rebuilding the timeline. And so eventually things started just getting pushed back.

Shawn Ryan00:28:23

And so in the first one, you said it got like 5,000 views in seven days.

Payne Lindsey00:28:28

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan00:28:28

So by the time episode two, did you stick to the timeline in a week?

Payne Lindsey00:28:32

I did. I stuck to my word.

Shawn Ryan00:28:34

So who were those 5,000 people? Do you have any idea? Was it people in that town?

Payne Lindsey00:28:38

I think that there were probably mostly people in the town. I mean, that would basically be the whole town and probably.

Shawn Ryan00:28:45

2,000 more.

Payne Lindsey00:28:46

Yeah. My Twitter followers at the time. I mean, it's probably the math. I think most of the town probably heard it and saw it. And there was a bunch of, I mean, several local news outlets that kind of picked it up early on. And yeah, they wanted to do a story on it. I was like, okay, this is cool. I mean, this is, people were interested in, I guess, this podcaster guy taking on a cold case.

That was sort of a novel idea at that point. It's a trope now. I mean, I kind of helped make a trope, which is kind of, it's kind of funny. When people ask me, you know, do you have any advice for me on how to be a true crime podcaster? I usually say, just don't do it. Not to say that I'm for some reason better at it. That's not what I mean. I mean, literally, it's just, it's hard.

Shawn Ryan00:29:49

Why do you tell them? Because it's hard? You tell them?

Payne Lindsey00:29:52

Yeah, because it's, because if you're a listener of, let's say, Up and Vanished, right? I don't think that the work that I'm really doing, what it really is behind the scenes is what you get to see or hear. And I think it would be misleading to think that it is maybe as simple as it is or I don't know, as stress-free or maybe just organized.

It's very, you have to make a lot of decisions that there's no one there to help you make. And they're not always clean right or wrong answers. It's, you know, I'm having to use my own sort of moral compass. And that, that, you know, that pulls at you a lot. You have to really think about how this is going to be portrayed. You promised this person this. You cannot burn them. That would be messed up. You need to put this tape out.

Should you call him again and try to convince him to give you permission? It's legal to record this and this guy might be a person of interest. Do I just drop this anyway? Am I going to get sued? Do I put this call out with law enforcement? Are they going to come after me? Do I show my hands yet? Do I, what do I show to see if they react? So then I'll figure out what to do with this thing. A lot of stuff like that that, you know, there is no playbook for.

And I don't know if I did it the right way or the wrong way or the best way. I just did it the only way I knew. I knew I tried my best to make sure that it was as fail-proof as possible. But it was on the fly and there was no one saying, this is how you should do this. I had to make those decisions myself. And that taught me a lot about the responsibility that comes with telling a true crime story.

You know, watching them on TV or listening to the podcast at the gym is one thing. And that's awesome, you know? But making them comes with a lot of decision-making and the responsibility that I decided was for me, if I'm not willing to go to whatever length necessary to actually try and find out for real what happened to this person, I shouldn't be doing this.

Shawn Ryan00:32:33

So when you, so you release episode one, then you're right back in it in the same town. How, I mean, when did you start hearing, hey, I listened to your podcast or you know what I mean? Like you got this wrong or I got some stuff for it. Do people start like seeking you out at this point? They're like, I want to, you know, contribute to this.

Payne Lindsey00:32:57

Yeah. I mean, it was pretty quickly. It was within the first couple of days, there were locals contacting me. I had even reached out to the GBI and I heard from one of the original investigators who originally agreed to talk to me. And then when he found out that I was interviewing this other private investigator that the family hired at some point after they couldn't find any answers, I think he was offended by that or something. And I mean, he told me in an email point blank that he wasn't going to talk to me anymore because I was affiliated with this other individual.

I was like, that's kind of petty and immature as a professional.

Shawn Ryan00:33:41

Okay.

Payne Lindsey00:33:42

But yeah, people were responding immediately. And I realized that, okay, I need to turn my bullshit detector on full blast here because people are saying some crazy shit. And I know that most of the stuff can't be true. But somewhere in here, I think there is a kernel of truth sometimes. I can tell, I can see the patterns or I can tell that this person doesn't have any sort of motivation to make something up like this.

It's the ones that are too eager that you're really kind of keeping an eye on. The people who really have genuine information usually aren't super willing to divulge it like that.

Shawn Ryan00:34:24

What were some major turning points for you in the middle of this?

Payne Lindsey00:34:27

I mean, I think once I started talking to people like her neighbor and people who were in the town, in the neighborhood around where she disappeared that night and got their perspectives and their timelines. I think when I talked to, so she went missing in October 2025, or sorry, October 2005.

She was last seen at this barbecue party at her superintendent's house, not too far down the street from where she lived. She was there. She was seen by people. And then she drove and left. And this individual I met and spoke to for three or four hours. I secretly recorded that conversation and I chose to beg for forgiveness instead of permission there.

And I asked him later about using it and he said it was fine. But I got a much clearer picture about the moment she was last seen and that he was convinced that she went this way down the street, right? And that's the last known sighting. It's whatever happened after that is the mystery. And so I was able to clear up that, okay, she didn't die at this party. There's nothing suspicious about this over here. It's something between 11 p.m.

Saturday night when she leaves the barbecue and the following afternoon when this local cop from another town that she was, that was having an affair with her comes and puts his business card in the door. Something happened to her. Those are some hard, you know, parameters here. And so it's kind of started shaping up. And I started just putting everyone under scrutiny that needed the scrutiny to eliminate them or just to move on.

I mean, there was plenty of rumors about people like her ex-boyfriend who just coincidentally was, he was on tour in the military, but he was back in town during this couple of weeks that she went missing. And some people found that to be kind of odd or coincidental, right? And that night, his alibi was that he was on a ride-along with one of his cop buddies in town.

And that also seemed weird to some people. But I was able to get the phone logs and the records for that night and actually see where they were on that ride-along. And it cleared a lot of things up. I mean, it opened up some new questions, but it actually put to bed any sort of crazy rumor that he was over here, he was over there. Now we have the records. And so that was like the first time anything like that was coming out. And I think people in the beginning felt like there was genuine progress being made in clearing some of these stories up and just fine-tuning everyone's perspective on what may have really happened to her.

And that sort of set the stage for everything that happened next.

Shawn Ryan00:37:59

Wow. What did happen next? What, I mean, what point, what were you digging for under a crawl space?

Payne Lindsey00:38:11

I was digging for a body.

Shawn Ryan00:38:13

I mean, yeah, but.

Payne Lindsey00:38:16

Right. I mean, the tip that I received was that the current homeowner, and I never said this back when the podcast came out, but I can say it now, but like at the time I didn't say it. The house that I was actually searching underneath was the house where the barbecue happened, which was where she was last seen. There was a new owner of that house now. And he said that he was in the crawl space recently and he, there was a weird mound of dirt.

And he reached out to me with this information. And he's like, could be nothing, but could be something. I was like, screw it. Let's go down here. And next thing you know, I'm with my younger brother and this homeowner and we got headlamps on and I foolishly wore sandals for whatever reason. And I'm digging around and I'm like, am I about to find human remains down here? That's like, what am I doing? This is insane. And turns out that the area that we were digging in, we didn't find any bones, but in a different spot that the GBI ended up searching just a few hours later because we just searched there, they did find bones.

It was later determined to be animal bones, but I again found that so odd. And it really felt like they were reacting to the actions that I was taking in this podcast. And it just seemed that black and white simple to me. What are the odds that you got this tip from anywhere else other than learning about it today from me?

Shawn Ryan00:40:02

Damn, man.

Payne Lindsey00:40:03

And does that signal that you don't have shit on this case? Maybe. It definitely feels like it because I was questioning myself underneath that crawl space.

Shawn Ryan00:40:15

Did you have any other interactions with the TBI? I mean.

Payne Lindsey00:40:18

Oh, yeah.

Shawn Ryan00:40:19

Were they contacting you?

Payne Lindsey00:40:21

Yeah. There were several. Yeah. Throughout the next year, I had several interactions with the GBI. That would be a continued ongoing bizarre relationship I had. Yeah. I mean, there's one time I was down there at a gas station and I was at the ATM and I felt somebody, like I felt somebody really close behind me. And I'm at the ATM where I'm punching in like my PIN code. And I just was like, someone behind, I look behind and there's a GBI agent there.

I'm like, oh, hey, what's up? What's you doing? And he's just, oh, just saw your car parked outside, just saying hey. I was like, okay. You trying to get my PIN number or something? No. All right. Well, see you later. I'm like, was that like a posturing sort of veiled threat?

Shawn Ryan00:41:23

Passive aggressive.

Payne Lindsey00:41:24

Yeah. I'm like, yeah. Like we're not friends, man. Not to say that we couldn't be cool, but I don't think you'd be that cool with me walking up on you like that. Don't act like that wasn't weird just then. And that unnerved me a little bit because I didn't trust them. And it felt like it was turning into more of a damage control situation for them than it was finding the truth.

And then keeping finding the truth for me up here became a heavier burden, it felt like.

Shawn Ryan00:42:08

When did it start to turn?

Payne Lindsey00:42:11

It turned in an instant one day in February 2017. I got a phone call. It's actually the first time, ironically, that I was ever ahead in the podcast. I got one full episode complete days before it came out. I finally had figured out a method. But then it's around 6:30 in the morning, I get a phone call from a buddy of mine who works in the local news and she's saying that there is a press conference being held in Osilla at the courthouse today at noon.

And it's about Tara Grinsett's case. And they've never held a press conference about this case in 10 years. And I'm like, well, what's it about? We have no idea. So I packed my stuff right then. I left from my office. I was wearing this dumb looking Hawaiian shirt. Ended up being what I wore on Good Morning America the next morning because I didn't realize I was going to be spending the night there and this would turn into something that would change this case forever.

But when I get there at noon, within minutes, the GBI comes out and they say that they have made an arrest in the Tara Grinsett case and that they have arrested a man who has never appeared on their radar before. And he was a former student and his name is Ryan Duke. And everyone's like, who the hell is Ryan Duke? And that started a whole new chapter for me.

The podcast in that moment became about something else entirely. It became about, did they get the right guy or do they have the roles mixed up here? Because this other guy over here looks a lot worse and it's not getting any better. What do I do about that?

Shawn Ryan00:44:25

Wow. Why did they arrest Ryan Duke?

Payne Lindsey00:44:28

Because he confessed, which I mean, anyone who confesses to something is like, well, it's a pretty big deal. But I would say confession might be a little bit too nice. I would say he had an incoherent, rambling, drug-infused recollection of hitting Tara once in the head and her dying. That was the story.

And it was later discovered that he was on morphine at the time, Vicodin, a bunch of painkillers, and.

Shawn Ryan00:45:09

Not right.

Payne Lindsey00:45:11

Yeah, he was not right. I mean, you can tell. There's a video of it. He doesn't sound right. And it's like, I mean, John Benet Ramsay case or something, right? There've been people who've come forward and confessed. The cops didn't just go, okay, cool, you're under arrest. They go, let's make sure that checks out first, right? And then every time they did that with at least her case, they could prove that they weren't in the same state at that time or something that didn't add up. You can't just confess to a crime and that's it.

It has to be proven that you did that. And so I think that's where they rushed to judgment. I think that there was, we're all people, we're humans. I think that in 10 years, you finally have some guy confessing to this murder and you can go tell the family, we got him. I think that there was some excitement around that.

And I think some people in law enforcement moved too quickly and didn't assess the situation the way they should have in hindsight. And it came back to bite them. And I think once they doubled down on, no, we think it's this guy, well, then you just dug yourself a little bit deeper into that hole.

And then that's the whole pride thing comes into play.

Shawn Ryan00:46:51

And who were you looking at?

Payne Lindsey00:46:53

There was another guy and I learned about this guy that day. I mean, as soon as I heard Ryan Duke's name, at least a dozen or more people, which was insane, that that many people were reaching out to me, were saying, dude, this couldn't be Ryan. This guy Bo Duke's, he's a problem. You should look over there. And I'm like, okay, why is everyone pointing me over here? And I interviewed somebody that night, like two in the morning at the Osilla Star newspaper warehouse.

And he's telling me that he knew Ryan and Bo. And he was telling me this Bo guy, he's crazy. He's not somebody who you should trust. He's dangerous. Ryan isn't the kind of guy who would do something like this.

Shawn Ryan00:47:51

These guys brothers?

Payne Lindsey00:47:52

No, just a weird South Georgia Duke and Duke's. Couldn't make this up. But I censored Bo's name the first time I put it out. And then a few weeks later, the cops arrest him.

Shawn Ryan00:48:07

No way.

Payne Lindsey00:48:08

And then I play that clip again and I rewind it and I uncensor that name. And from that point forward, it was me versus Ryan Duke and Bo Duke's.

Advertisement00:48:21
Payne Lindsey00:50:20

I've actually never, I've never spoken directly to Ryan or Bo. I have, I mean, I've been close, about as close as you can get, several of Bo's army buddies at the time were talking to him extensively about these crimes, about the details of them burning Tara Grinsett's body and getting rid of evidence, really graphic stuff.

And little did Bo know, his buddy was giving me all that information, all the recordings, all the screenshots. And eventually I just dumped it all out there. And what it did was it painted the picture of a really dark, twisted person who had a fascination with, like a sexual fascination with doing stuff with women in this orchard where he admittedly burned Tara's body for days.

And he had no problem talking about the most graphic details of that as if it was a movie he saw the other day. And that shit, to me, was just pure evil. And I think everyone who saw these messages, these conversations, this person essentially relishing in the fact that this popular true crime podcast is talking about this thing that he knows more about.

Shawn Ryan00:52:20

So it stroked his ego.

Payne Lindsey00:52:21

Absolutely. He couldn't keep his mouth shut.

Shawn Ryan00:52:24

Holy shit.

Payne Lindsey00:52:26

Next thing you know, he's talking to all the female listeners on the discussion board who are obviously giving me all this information. And it just painted this pattern of somebody who had no remorse was relishing in this sort of moment and just some real genuine narcissistic behavior that proved that he was a liar and also strangely obsessed with this crime in a way that he has acted out on other women and almost in a way that seemed like he was reliving a crime.

Shawn Ryan00:53:13

What kind of stuff was he saying?

Payne Lindsey00:53:16

I have spoken to a woman who met with him one time out there in the Pecan Orchard where they burned Tara's body. And it started off as a goth.

Shawn Ryan00:53:32

Essential thing.

Payne Lindsey00:53:33

Yeah. Bo and Ryan burned her body together, admittingly. But years later, this girl tells me that she meets Bo out there on an app or something. And it started off consensual. And then next thing you know, he's tying her to this tree and hog tying her. And she got really scared. And he says, you know, you could scream as loud as you want and no one out here will ever hear you.

And that spooked the shit out of me and obviously her. And so when she was telling me this, she was relaying it to me like now in hindsight, now that she's learned about the crimes that he was involved in, she's like, she's thinking that he did it and that's what he was talking about. It was scary to her then. But with the bigger picture, it was, we're dealing with a real monster.

And yeah, he is a monster. And it was the first monster I ever really encountered this close up who knew about me and I knew about him. And I mean, he would piss me off. I was, yeah, I had become so immersed in this and really was in over my head.

And I wanted to figure out what happened to Tara and nothing was going to stop me anymore. And so I was really like pissed at this guy. Like the fact that he was saying the things he was saying, being so nonchalant about it. I mean.

Shawn Ryan00:55:39

Wow.

Payne Lindsey00:55:40

I was enraged and trying to stay objective. And part of me was like, fuck that. And I did my best. But it was a real test. But yeah, I still feel that way when I think about that guy.

Shawn Ryan00:56:03

So how long he starts posting on your message boards and you're getting this information, you're putting it out. I mean, how long was it before and you found out about this guy the day they arrested the other Duke?

Payne Lindsey00:56:18

Yep.

Shawn Ryan00:56:21

How long did it take for him to arrest? Was it Bo?

Payne Lindsey00:56:25

Within a couple weeks, they arrested Bo. And I think at first the state thought they had their star witness with Bo. They thought that this guy was going to be the main person to testify against Ryan. We got this sort of confession, if you want to call it that, and we're just going to just like that. But let's not forget that Bo is a real life narcissist who that was why they even found Ryan in the first place.

He was drunk with his girlfriend one night and he was texting his buddies about the podcast up and vanished. It's on his mind. And then he drunkenly tells his girlfriend that he knows what happened to her because he burned her body with Ryan Duke out here at his uncle's orchard. So she goes and tells the cops this. But he was listening to Up and Vanished. And it's harder to keep a secret when everyone's talking about it, especially if you're a guy like that who just can't help himself.

And so within a couple weeks, they kind of were like, okay, we're arresting you because you lied about some stuff. So they only arrested him for the crimes that he admitted to, which was getting rid of her body with Ryan. But then the narrative shifted in the community and every listener across the country was like, look at these two people. This guy did it, not this guy. And that's just what it looks like. And I didn't have to go find evidence to support that.

It just kept supplying itself. And I was nervous about it because I didn't know if the GBI had something that I didn't, right? A part of me was thinking, like giving them the benefit of the doubt, really. Surely they have some big thing that I'm missing.

Shawn Ryan00:58:34

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey00:58:35

Or else this is too flimsy.

Shawn Ryan00:58:37

They've got to be good at their job, right?

Payne Lindsey00:58:39

Right. There's some smoking gun that I don't know. But that never materialized.

Shawn Ryan00:58:45

Holy shit. So what was it like when they started, was it the GBI that was contacting you for the IP addresses and all that kind of stuff?

Payne Lindsey00:58:53

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan00:58:54

How did that go?

Payne Lindsey00:58:55

That was probably the least fun part of the podcast making process, I would say. I didn't like having to deal with them. I recorded every call, but I never put them out. And recently, actually, I was going back through and listening to some 10-year-old phone calls. And wow, has it aged poorly for some of them, just what they were asking. I mean, one of the first calls I have is one of the lead investigators calling me and he's asking about a specific username on the Up and Vanished discussion board on my website.

And I asked him more details about it to see how much he would tell me about it. And he gives me the username and I asked him, well, what was the statement that they made about? And he said that the person claimed that Bo recruited his mom to fabricate this alibi for him for that night. And so for a moment in 2017, after they had arrested Bo, they were seriously looking into in their investigation based on my phone calls with them, whether or not Bo was telling the truth about his involvement in her murder.

And then fast forward years later, Ryan Duke gets acquitted because the state presented the same flimsy story they did in 2017. And the jury is like, I don't buy that. Doesn't make sense. Well, yeah, it didn't then, it doesn't now, which is a shame for Tara's family because 20 plus years now, and I'm talking about it, and I started this case 10 years ago, and we're still talking about who may have killed her and what actually happened to her.

That's insane to me. And I haven't stopped investigating this.

Shawn Ryan01:01:11

So this guy gets arrested, he's admitting to burning her body for days and he's out?

Payne Lindsey01:01:19

Yes.

Shawn Ryan01:01:19

Yeah, so he gets out.

Payne Lindsey01:01:22

He got a little slap on the wrist. I mean, he got out on bail.

Shawn Ryan01:01:26

How did he get out? How did they botch that?

Payne Lindsey01:01:28

I mean, I don't know. Maybe it was just a good attorney. I don't know. But yeah, Ryan was stuck in there because he was on murder charges. But Bo Dukes was able to get out within 24, 48 hours. And he was back on the discussion board.

Shawn Ryan01:01:46

What's he saying?

Payne Lindsey01:01:47

He's saying any and everything about the graphic details of destroying Tara's remains. I mean, talking at length for hours about stuff I don't even want to utter out loud, stuff that is really repulsive and just saying it in a nonchalant way like it's no big deal. And he was really fascinated and into what seemed like almost all the female listeners of my show, at least the ones that were talking on the discussion board.

Shawn Ryan01:02:31

Can you say some of the stuff he was saying?

Payne Lindsey01:02:33

Yeah. I mean, he was basically, he was flirting with these girls.

Shawn Ryan01:02:39

And with the remains.

Payne Lindsey01:02:40

Oh, I mean, on more than one occasion, he described like the way her chest looked and her face and stuff when he lit the flames. And that he stood there and watched for like 12 hours.

And it's like, what the fuck?

Shawn Ryan01:03:18

Whoa.

Payne Lindsey01:03:20

And yeah, that's some evil shit. And just not a kernel of remorse in there. If anything, he felt like he was cool because he had this insider knowledge to other listeners of this popular true crime podcast that's out right now. But.

Shawn Ryan01:03:47

I don't understand how he got off.

Payne Lindsey01:03:50

Well, he was never charged with the murder. That's why. The police stuck with their original story that this other guy did it. And we can't really explain all the details of it. You know, we can't explain how Ryan got to her house because he doesn't have a car.

Shawn Ryan01:04:08

So maybe it's the GBI. They're too proud to admit they fucked up.

Payne Lindsey01:04:11

That's my take. I mean, I can't prove that, but what does it look like? I was in the courtroom on verdict day. I mean.

Shawn Ryan01:04:21

Dude, there's a lot of this shit that happens in Georgia. I have a buddy, Don Bradley, this happened to. He got shot in the head in a road rage incident.

Payne Lindsey01:04:29

Shot in the head?

Shawn Ryan01:04:30

Shot in the head by a target.

Payne Lindsey01:04:31

He survived it?

Shawn Ryan01:04:32

He survived it.

Payne Lindsey01:04:33

Oh my God.

Shawn Ryan01:04:34

His name was Don Bradley and they ran his name. And I guess there's another Don Bradley down there.

Payne Lindsey01:04:41

Probably.

Shawn Ryan01:04:42

With a long rap sheet. This guy was a retired green beret, worked with him at CIA for years.

Payne Lindsey01:04:49

Okay.

Shawn Ryan01:04:50

And then he was driving, I can't remember if it was to or from work one day and it was a road rage incident. He got out.

Payne Lindsey01:05:01

That's insane.

Shawn Ryan01:05:02

Shot in the forehead.

Payne Lindsey01:05:03

But survives this.

Shawn Ryan01:05:04

Survives it. And they were too proud to admit that. So, you know, I mean, I could see it. You know what I mean? Like you get a Don Bradley, you run it, this long rap sheet.

Payne Lindsey01:05:15

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan01:05:15

But this other guy who was like an ice cream delivery man or something also had a rap sheet.

Payne Lindsey01:05:23

Right.

Shawn Ryan01:05:23

Like domestic abuse, shit like that. And then allegedly domestic abuse, shit like that. And I'm not, this was years ago, so I'm not totally smut up on it anymore. But then they find out, oh shit, we had this other, you know, we ran the wrong name and doubled down on it.

Payne Lindsey01:05:49

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan01:05:49

Wound up getting the case dismissed. I don't know what's happening now. I think he's suing them. This was back in like 2018, 2019.

Payne Lindsey01:05:58

I mean, it's a human thing. I mean, a lot of us are a victim of it at times. I don't think anyone would say that they like being wrong. I don't like being wrong.

Shawn Ryan01:06:09

Yeah, well, I mean, yeah, but no, I wouldn't like.

Payne Lindsey01:06:14

You're right.

Shawn Ryan01:06:15

I've admitted I'm wrong several times to millions and millions of people.

Payne Lindsey01:06:18

It's capable of doing that. Yeah.

Shawn Ryan01:06:20

But I'm not going to let a sick murderer who's burning remains after God knows what happened to her out free because I'm too proud to admit I made a mistake. Holy shit. So what does the public say about that? What is the podcast listenership? What do they have to say about the GBI just like turning a blind eye to this shit?

Payne Lindsey01:06:44

I mean, there was immediately contention between the podcast, myself, and law enforcement and the suspects. And the listeners were kind of in the mix of this thing unfolding in real time. And the judge in the county issued a sweeping gag order that was historically ridiculous. That was clearly in an attempt to silence the podcast.

Shawn Ryan01:07:13

A sweeping gag order?

Payne Lindsey01:07:15

Yes. No one can talk.

Shawn Ryan01:07:16

Oh my gosh.

Payne Lindsey01:07:18

We got them to talk anyway. It didn't stop us.

Shawn Ryan01:07:22

Like the whole community.

Payne Lindsey01:07:23

Yeah. They wanted this thing.

Shawn Ryan01:07:25

How do they do that?

Payne Lindsey01:07:27

I mean.

Shawn Ryan01:07:28

You're not allowed to talk about this to an entire town?

Payne Lindsey01:07:33

Yeah. Right. When there's this huge, they wanted it to go away. And it didn't work. And other attorneys actually in the state of Georgia, just who were objective, were like, this is bullshit. And they fought to just for their own to get it removed. And eventually they did because it was ruled to be like unfair. But it was, I mean, I don't think it was for anything else.

I don't know what else they were trying to muzzle. The podcast was coming out every week and their case was getting a little messier because of it. Because every week we would learn something new about Bo.

Shawn Ryan01:08:17

Makes him look really bad, man. Wow.

Payne Lindsey01:08:21

Yep. Yep.

Shawn Ryan01:08:24

So what's your take now? What are you looking in? What are you still looking into?

Payne Lindsey01:08:27

With this case?

Shawn Ryan01:08:28

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey01:08:30

So I mean, Ryan was acquitted. He was found not guilty. So he can never be charged again with Tara's murder. Bo, however, technically could still be tried and found guilty for her murder. Now, there would have to be a different story that the state presents, but maybe it's one that actually makes sense and fits the evidence. I think now that 20 years have passed and Ryan is getting out early next year, I think all of the players in this awful story who previously had reasons not to talk now have no reason not to talk.

And I think they're going to talk to me. And my hope would be to try to write an ending as in tell us what happened to Tara. Can somebody actually be made responsible for her murder? How is that still not happened? And if all these years later, the evidence is still mounting towards this other guy, who by the way, is in prison for much longer than Ryan because back in 2019, he went on this spree of raping and assaulting women with a shotgun that he shoved in their mouths.

And there was a statewide manhunt for him for five days. This guy, who was eventually apprehended, he's serving more time for that than he is the Tara Grinstead cover-up. But that's the kind of guy we're talking about here.

Shawn Ryan01:10:28

Wait, what?

Payne Lindsey01:10:29

Yes. This happened after the podcast. This is the man who is the other suspect. And this is what he's provably capable of doing. So yeah, I'd like to talk to both of them. And I have interviews that I have not ever put out that would make a whole hell of a lot more sense now. And there's dozens of them.

Shawn Ryan01:10:59

Are you going to put them out?

Payne Lindsey01:11:00

Oh yeah, absolutely. Yeah. I only didn't put them out back then because I was weary about the nature of how this was developing. And I didn't want to do anything that I would regret or would put me in hot water. But now it's like, no, in hindsight, my instincts were correct. I always thought that this guy had more to do with it and the Ryan narrative was bullshit, so did the jury.

And you know, even Bo now in prison is messaging women pictures of his dick. I got those too. I don't like looking at those, but this is what this guy's doing. And he's leading these conversations with these women with, I'm part of this crime that you may have heard of before. It's like, okay, bro.

Shawn Ryan01:12:08

Shit. Have you talked to Tara's family?

Payne Lindsey01:12:11

Talked to some of them. Yeah. This has kind of been a, I mean, obviously, for anyone who knew Tara, was close to Tara, roller coaster of 20 years, right? And sometimes I've learned this that from my perspective, when something awful happens, like your loved one goes missing under mysterious circumstances or your loved one is murdered, right?

And it's unsolved. You need someone or something to be mad at, right? And it's usually the bad guy, the person who did it, which we sometimes don't know who that is, the police for not doing their job or not catching that guy in time or being transparent or three, the journalist covering it in the middle of it.

And I think that it's kind of subconscious, but it's, I've just realized that because I'm talking about real stuff, real sensitive things, that this is like someone's worst day of their life, their worst everything, a nightmare, right? It's probably not amazing to hear that. You know what I mean? And I'm conscious of that as a, I wouldn't want a true crime podcast about me if I went missing necessarily.

But again, I just go back to where my actual heart is at in all this. If I, again, if I didn't really make finding the truth the number one thing and make sure that I'm not afraid to even put myself in danger to find that answer, then I should not be doing this shit. And so in every instance that I've made a podcast about an unsolved disappearance, I have played that role where there has been a major gap in law enforcement's ability to close this case.

And I'm coming in trying to generate something new, knowing that it's going to get messy, you know?

Shawn Ryan01:14:52

Sheesh. Let's take a quick break.

Payne Lindsey01:14:56

Sure. Yeah.

Advertisement01:15:00
Shawn Ryan01:16:59

All right, Paint, here we go. We're going to go into Colorado 2018, Crystal Reisinger?

Payne Lindsey01:17:09

Reisinger.

Shawn Ryan01:17:10

Reisinger. Who is she? How did she pop on your radar?

Payne Lindsey01:17:18

Actually, I never told anyone this, at least when the podcast came out, but it was over Christmas break and my uncle, he lives out there in this tiny little town. I'll spare his name for now.

Shawn Ryan01:17:32

Your uncle lives in this town?

Payne Lindsey01:17:33

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan01:17:33

So it goes from your grandma to your uncle.

Payne Lindsey01:17:37

Yes. I'm like, at this point, what is happening? But he's telling, you know, me and my family over Christmas break that there's this really bizarre disappearance of this woman named Crystal in this tiny town of Crestone, Colorado. And I'd been there before, I mean, years ago. I'd seen how remote this area is. It's a quirky little town where a bunch of different religious groups are there.

Pretty granola, mostly harmless stuff. But there is a little bit of an underbelly seedy part to it. And she was affiliated with some people that were doing some bad stuff. And one night she just goes missing. And she had a daughter. She'd never leave her daughter. The person's house that she was last seen at, his name was John.

His nickname was Catfish John. And he was a character to say the least, but he was somebody who admittedly told police that Crystal was at his house the night she went missing and then retracted that and was either so fried from acid or meth or the combo of both or all the above that he'd almost start speaking to me in riddles like he was the damn Joker.

And I'm not kidding. It was this brain rotting gibberish where he would almost play this sort of cat and mouse thing with me and drop little hints and say this.

Shawn Ryan01:19:24

Are you serious?

Payne Lindsey01:19:24

Yes.

Shawn Ryan01:19:25

Can you give me an example?

Payne Lindsey01:19:26

I mean, oh my God. It's like, I can't really. It's just word vomit. Like he's speaking, you've seen somebody on the side of the street in a major city doing this before where they're talking to themselves or something and it's a mixture of drugs and mental health and something else, but he's very aware and he's calculated.

And I thought this guy was just a total joke. I mean, he's like a complete loser. And he was there from daddy's money and there's a bunch of poor people who live around there. And so a lot of the younger hippie kind of kids didn't have any money. So they'd always kind of hang out at Catfish's house.

Shawn Ryan01:20:24

Why'd they call him Catfish John?

Payne Lindsey01:20:26

Because there was a Grateful Dead song called Catfish John. And for whatever reason, John convinced himself that it was probably about him or something. I don't know.

Shawn Ryan01:20:38

Got it.

Payne Lindsey01:20:40

Nothing remarkable, but I know it comes from that. But he's this trust fund baby who has fried his brain with drugs and this woman goes missing, last seen at his house, and all the stories around town are about him and his buddies killing her and getting rid of her body. And he's someone I spent hours talking to on the phone.

And just like in Tara's case, the second he heard me talking about him, he picked up his phone and finally opened the Facebook messages and video FaceTime me on Facebook. And I'm like, oh shit, holy shit, this is him right. Roll on this, roll, roll. And I'm talking and I wasn't expecting it. I was in the moment.

And instead of putting that out immediately, I wanted to see how he would respond if I kept talking to him. And I just never mentioned to anyone that I was talking to him and didn't put out any of the stuff he wanted me to say or, you know, or wanted to hear himself say. And it turned out he didn't like that very much.

Shawn Ryan01:22:05

How long did it take for him to reach out to you after you started talking about him?

Payne Lindsey01:22:09

I would say probably episode five.

Shawn Ryan01:22:12

What's the time spent?

Payne Lindsey01:22:13

I was five weeks, six weeks.

Shawn Ryan01:22:15

You started talking to him on an episode five?

Payne Lindsey01:22:17

I had done a whole bunch of investigating and I had a whole kind of series arc built, but a lot of it was left for what I was going to find once I turned this thing on. And everyone knows up in Vanish is about this case. And now the locals are listening and they're calling me and I'm generating new information that I didn't have before, all from the podcast itself. And so he was one of them. He's someone I tried to talk to before, but it wasn't until he heard other people talking about him that he felt compelled to actually pick up the phone.

And that would become a pattern. And I spent too many nights, regrettably, talking to this person. And eventually, I did agree to meet with him in person. And I knew that he was a loose cannon.

Shawn Ryan01:23:11

Did you think he had done it?

Payne Lindsey01:23:13

I think that whether he was the actual trigger puller or not, I think that he either at least saw it happen or it happened in his house and he absolutely orchestrated getting rid of her body. So whether it was an accident, whether it was an accident or a drug overdose or something gone wrong, whatever you want to call it, he was there and he's hiding that. And so I don't know those final moments, but yeah, he's lying about what happened to her and he knows and he helped get rid of her body.

That's what I believe.

Shawn Ryan01:23:53

Before you met him, you believe that?

Payne Lindsey01:23:55

Before I met him, I believe that. After I definitely, that just solidified it, to be honest. But yeah, meeting him, I mean.

Shawn Ryan01:24:03

How did you meet him?

Payne Lindsey01:24:05

I popped, I sent him a Facebook message and I told him I was going to be in Raleigh, North Carolina, which is where he was actually staying. After the podcast came out, he, after the podcast came out, he fled Crestone, Colorado, completely up and left. Odd timing for sure. And so he went back to where his dad is from and where he grew up in North Carolina. So I determined that that's where he was.

And I messaged him and I said, "Hey, I want to meet in person. Let's just bury the hatchet. Let's just have a conversation about this man to man. And you can say your piece and I can ask you questions and you don't dodge them this time." And so he agreed to that. I knew that it was likely he was going to change his mind at some point or get high and say, "No, I didn't." But the day comes and I FaceTime him and I'm down the street from this bar that we agreed to meet at.

Turns out he's actually already there. And so I said, "Hey, I'm five minutes away. I'll be there in five minutes." So I met on the outside patio and we're filming it and we're also, I'm also wearing like a lavalier mic under my shirt. And this man looks at me in the face and he grabs a sugar packet and he tears it open and he pours it in his mouth and then coughs and just, I'm like, "What, what, not who am I dealing with?

What am I dealing with here? Like what is this guy?" I mean, it sounds kind of funny because it was, it was ridiculous. I was like, "What are you, what is happening? What the hell is this person?" It didn't take long for me to ask a few normal questions about, "Hey, you told the police that Crystal was at your house this day." And he gets defensive and he starts mouthing off and he looks at me and he goes, "You know, I could reach across the table and just strangle you right now."

And normally that would scare the shit out of me, but after his sugar packet incident and just how frail and not that I'm a big guy, but I was like, "This guy wouldn't even see the punch coming if it went to that, I don't think." But I didn't like it. I didn't like going from what I felt like was an attempt for me to create a professional environment for him to actually talk.

And I went through a lot of hoops to get there and flew out there to meet him that within five minutes, he's threatening to kill me essentially from across the table at this restaurant we're at. And so I realized right then, I'm like, "Yeah, I'm not going to get anything out of this guy." And frankly, I'm pretty pissed off now. So I just said, "Hey, don't ever say that to me again. Like don't ever threaten my life." And he gets up mumbling, walks away and he left his glasses on the table, his sunglasses.

And I just, I use it as an opportunity to keep engaging with him. I was like, "Hey, you left your glasses." So I'm following him down the patio and turns out his dad is sitting right there across the way. So daddy was there, you know, making sure everything was okay. And I recognized him from the pictures. I was like, "Oh, hey, you're his dad." I was like, "I didn't know it was a family affair here." And we were chatting and he takes his motorcycle helmet and he goes to swing at me, airballs it.

Shawn Ryan01:28:12

His dad?

Payne Lindsey01:28:12

No, Catfish does. The suspect, the absolute Joker. He takes his motorcycle helmet and attempts to swing it at me. I mean, if he hit me, it would have definitely hurt or damaged my head, but he missed. And at that point, I was like, "Screw this. I'm out of here, man." And I walked to the car, but I'm still, I mean, I think it's probably adrenaline going at that point, to be honest.

I was kind of just, "Well, while I'm here, I'm going to keep just barking at this guy because who knows what he might say next, right?" He's heated too, obviously. And if this was any other setting, I would not have tolerated it as much as I did in that moment. I think the restraint was kind of killing me too. But I just started talking shit to him from the driver's seat.

I probably said something like, you know, "If you threaten my life again, you know, your ass is going to jail," something like that. I don't know. I'm just saying stuff and he marches on over to the car and he tries to punch me again from outside. And I'm like, "Okay, this is just turning into a reality show. This is ridiculous. I'm dealing with an unwell person who is playing with me and thinks this is funny.

I didn't find it funny. I released all that stuff. And I think if you were a listener of that season where you followed Crystal's case, you got to see, "Okay, this is who this guy really is. And he's another monster, really. And who would act like this?" No one's pointed the finger at him. I didn't accuse him of anything. I'm asking him about statements he made to police.

I mean, it's, "You said it." And so I kept everything pretty, you know, like by the book. I wasn't trying to insinuate anything, but he just didn't like the fact that people were talking about him, but also relish in it too, just like the other guys I'd encountered. And so that case was the first time I actually developed a good relationship with law enforcement.

Shawn Ryan01:30:59

Well, that's good. How did that develop?

Payne Lindsey01:31:03

I got a phone call one day, about a year after the podcast was released, from a Colorado area code. And it was an agent from the CBI, the Colorado Bureau of Investigation. And he asked me to call him. And so what I didn't tell everybody during the release of that season when it was coming out is that about halfway through, I did develop a relationship with one of the CBI officers, one of the investigators.

And we had a just very by the book, "I won't snitch on you, you don't snitch on me." I wouldn't call it like sharing information. So we didn't want to blur the lines between journalist and investigator so things could still be used in court. But when there were serious things happening that I felt maybe actually evidentiary, I would float that over there. And he'd sometimes, you know, nod to look that way.

And so there was a very kind of, we had a mutual respect and a common goal to figure out what happened to Crystal. And he unfortunately got injured in the line of duty and he no longer was on the force. And so there was a new cold case unit that was established. And he was telling the head guy of the cold case unit now that, "Hey, I talked to that guy Payne for a couple of years and I know he was recording me, but he never put it out.

And so he's good for it." And that's literally verbatim what he said. He said, "I'm only talking to a true crime podcaster right now, not because I want to, but because this guy's, you know, put his word on it." And I was like, "Okay, respect." And I developed that relationship with this person. And he said, "Look, I know that you have, I listened to the whole podcast. I know that you have hours of tape with these people.

And I think we both know who we're looking at here. How would you feel about, you know, giving us your audio?" And I said, "Yeah, no problem. One condition." He's like, "What?" I was like, "You let me record everything." And if he said no, I probably still would have done it. But he said, "Sure, no problem." And I still haven't put most of that out, but it was also kind of a reassurance thing for me too.

But then in our first meeting in Denver, about halfway through, I'm like, "I kind of like this guy. He's kind of funny. He's kind of like me. He's cool. Like we're speaking the same language about this thing right now." And he mentioned something about recording and I was like, "Well, yeah, I mean, we're recording right now." And he goes, "Well, obviously we are too." And I was like, "Okay, I like this guy." But yeah, since then, there's been several canine searches and another suspect identified that I had communications with too.

And this person is actually currently on the run. He was last seen in Texas. I have an idea about where he is. I think one day I may plan to pop up on this guy, but he's also somebody who is definitely dangerous.

Shawn Ryan01:34:50

Why do you say that?

Payne Lindsey01:34:52

I mean, because law enforcement has told me that he's killed people.

Shawn Ryan01:34:58

Oh, really? There's multiple?

Payne Lindsey01:34:59

Yes. And I'd heard of this person and I've talked to ex-girlfriends of this individual and stuff like that. But he's the guy who, you know, sometimes, most of the time, you're going to be fine. Like if you're just a journalist asking questions and you're not doing anything to really invite danger to yourself. But there are people who have nothing to lose. And those are the ones that you really got to look out for because they might do something that they regret for the rest of their life.

But I could be dead. And this is a guy who I think wouldn't hesitate to try to off somebody who pissed him off who was asking about an unsolved murder he's likely involved in.

Advertisement01:35:51
Payne Lindsey01:37:18

So I think it happened at Catfish's house. And I think.

Shawn Ryan01:37:22

Do these guys know each other?

Payne Lindsey01:37:23

They do. And so I think that in the process of covering this up, it had to have required multiple individuals to get rid of her body. And this would be the guy who would do it, who would organize all that, who Catfish would bring into the picture. And Catfish is now dead overdose. So we won't hear from him ever again. But what he left us with is pretty much paints who he is.

But there is an individual who is wanted right now for other crimes on the run.

Shawn Ryan01:38:03

How long has he been on the run?

Payne Lindsey01:38:05

Probably a year or more.

Shawn Ryan01:38:07

Was it, did he go on the run because of this?

Payne Lindsey01:38:09

No.

Shawn Ryan01:38:09

Because of your podcast?

Payne Lindsey01:38:10

Other crimes. Yeah.

Shawn Ryan01:38:12

Geez.

Payne Lindsey01:38:13

South Texas or Midwest Texas. I know about where he is. But yeah, again, it's one of those things where, what am I going to get though? If I go knock on this guy's door, one, it's definitely dangerous. I might get a cool sound bite for a cliffhanger of a new Up and Vanished episode, but that might be it. And at what cost? And is that really what I want?

Not really. I kind of want someone to tell me something for real. I don't want someone to say, "Get the fuck off my property." Just for the quick little hard cut.

Shawn Ryan01:38:57

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey01:38:58

That's not interesting to me. And so I'm just kind of watching from afar. So yeah, I mean, I know about where he is and I think one day I will talk to him, but maybe it'll be behind bars, actually. That's what I'd hope.

Shawn Ryan01:39:19

Damn. And you're still in contact with the CBI about this?

Payne Lindsey01:39:24

Yeah. Yep. Because he found one of his buddies in Texas and they're looking for him on other crimes. And so we kind of triangulated it, but there was a lot of people I was talking to back then that were associated with this drug scene and, you know, offing people down there and making people disappear. People other than Crystal as well. And he was one of the main names and he had originally messaged me from prison.

There's an app that you could use that you can message prisoners on and you have to buy like the minutes and the texts and stuff. And he reached out to me through a friend. I bought him enough minutes to communicate with me and he said that he knew what happened to her because he was there. I mean, it's his own admission.

Shawn Ryan01:40:21

Holy shit.

Payne Lindsey01:40:22

And he started trying to retract that and then he goes ghost. He gets out of prison. He commits more crimes and now he's on the run. But the CBI, when I met with him the second time, they mentioned his name. And it'd been so long, so many years, so many cases that I was like, "Why does this sound familiar?" And so I have the worst ADHD in the world and I have so many screenshots on my phone. And nine times out of ten, I never go look at that again.

But on the new iOS, you can actually search your pictures and it pulls up like words or like even a screenshot, like the name of somebody. And then I just did that there in front of him. I was like, "Oh shit, you mean this guy?" And it was our prison communications. And it was one of those aha moments where, "Okay, this was a name we never put out. This is exactly who we were looking for. And this guy's currently on the run. Okay, we have a real lead here."

And so we know who it is. And I still keep up with the CBI and I talked to them last month. And I think this case will eventually be solved. This guy needs to be arrested first. I can't arrest anybody.

Shawn Ryan01:41:48

Yeah. I mean, man, it's got to feel pretty crazy to, I mean, first one year in contact with the GBI, second one year in contact with the CBI. You've humiliated the Georgia Bureau of Investigation. You're teaming up with the Colorado Bureau of Investigation in two, like right off the bat.

Payne Lindsey01:42:17

I mean, I was really, I was very disheartened in Tara Grinsett's case about the way the GBI went about their relationship with me. I didn't want anything special, but they were clearly taking the information that I was reporting seriously, but playing both sides. And I mean, they're calling me asking for usernames and IP addresses. So they clearly wanted to know what I knew if they could.

But at the same time, they're kind of playing this sort of good old boy role, like, "Yeah, true crime podcaster. We got the real story figured out." Well, not to a jury you didn't. And I was pleasantly surprised to meet other state officials who, I mean, understandably were hesitant about getting involved with a true crime podcaster. I wouldn't want to.

I would be like, "Absolutely not." Right? Like, give me a good reason. So I'm not offended by it by any means, obviously. But just that, "Hey, this has been cold long enough here. It's time to try something different." And maybe that doesn't mean talking to me could be something else, but that's one of the options. Yeah, shake it up. The method that you've been running with isn't working.

So that's just an objective observation.

Shawn Ryan01:44:01

Let's go to Montana.

Payne Lindsey01:44:03

Okay.

Shawn Ryan01:44:04

Ashley Loring Heavy Runner. Now, there was a fact about natives.

Payne Lindsey01:44:17

Yeah. I mean, this disappearance took place on a reservation in Montana, the Blackfeet Reservation.

Shawn Ryan01:44:25

A lot of weird laws about all this.

Payne Lindsey01:44:27

Yeah. It's a clusterfuck, man. I mean, I watched a few episodes of Yellowstone before, right? They kind of go into that a little bit, but it's way worse than you even think it would be. It's just so disconnected. And there's FBI involved. There's local tribal police. There's a lack of resources altogether. I don't know if you've been to Montana before, but there's a lot of space out there, right?

It's a lot of empty open land. And so everything's far as hell away from itself. And it's super easy for like an obviously suspicious disappearance of a native woman in, let's say, the Blackfeet community in Montana to get swept under the rug or caught in this bureaucratical system that's broken where the FBI is there supposedly to be able to help provide resources when there is a crime like this.

But the biggest problem with a missing person's case is that there isn't a body. And if you get a couple lazy or incompetent people in wherever they are, it's all it takes to keep the case cold for decades. And that happens a lot, sadly, with the MMIW community, which was why I wanted to make a season about a native person who went missing, because there's a lot about that I personally didn't know either.

Like, what are the laws here? Why is it so complicated? And I mean, it goes back, obviously, we stole their land and it's been this sort of like generational thing that's turned into a modern-day issue with communication and solving a crime and how agencies work with each other or not at all. And so it's like playing telephone and it's always, it's going this way, that way. It's just a mess.

Shawn Ryan01:46:45

And I have heard native women are murdered at 10 times the national rate. 95% of cases get no national coverage. In a 1978 Supreme Court ruling, bars tribes from prosecuting non-natives. And about half of identified perpetrators are non-native. Excuse me. Jurisdiction is a three-way handoff where everyone assumes someone else has it.

Payne Lindsey01:47:13

Yeah. Oh, it's their responsibility. And he talked to them. They're like, "Oh, no, it's their responsibility." Okay. So no one's responsible and everyone's just passing the buck to someone else.

Shawn Ryan01:47:25

Why do native women are murdered at 10 times the national rate?

Payne Lindsey01:47:31

That is a scary, that's a scary astounding number. Why do I think?

Shawn Ryan01:47:36

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey01:47:37

I think that they're potentially in more vulnerable environments. I think that for a lot of people, I mean, the natives that I have met and the places and the communities I've been invited into and got to know some people, there's a lot of hardship in these places and there's not a lot of money and there's generational trauma.

And I think bad people prey on vulnerable people a lot. And I think that oftentimes an indigenous woman may be in super vulnerable positions. And I mean, what was the stat about them being non-natives who were committing the crimes?

Shawn Ryan01:48:41

Yeah, I don't think we had that. It said, oh, about half of identified perpetrators are non-native.

Payne Lindsey01:48:49

Right. So that means a lot of these crimes are not from people within their community. And so if you are, if you're someone committing crimes like that, it's clearly easier to get away with it. There's oftentimes like a casino or a resort in some of these places. So it brings in outsiders or people crossing state lines. And so someone can commit a crime sometimes and hit the highway and never be seen again because there's not really anything preventing that from happening.

And so the level of danger is there. I think it's just extraordinarily more of a vulnerable environment and bad people prey on vulnerable people.

Shawn Ryan01:49:36

So how does Ashley pop on your radar? She's part of the Blackfeet Nation, disappeared after a party in June 2017. Her sister led the searches, friends, not police, and they found a red-stained or they found red-stained boots and a torn sweater.

Payne Lindsey01:49:56

Yep. I got an email from one of her friends and she was a listener of Up and Vanish. She listened to season one on Tara, season two on Crystal. And she said, "Will you please do a third season about my friend Ashley?" And I emailed her back and then she put me in contact with her sister, Kimberly, and I flew out to Oregon to meet her. And then we just started talking. And at this point, it'd been several years since I started making True Crime Podcasts.

I've done a few other shows too. And I realized that Up and Vanish specifically has been sort of used as a tool too. Like it's an investigative tool. It's not just a show. It's a living, breathing thing. And so there's value to that, to be able to put the spotlight on a case that may otherwise go unnoticed or get no media attention, right?

And so if I can utilize this tool to shine a big bright spotlight on a case that isn't getting the right attention, one, it's the morally correct way to do this, in my opinion. And I also felt like it might actually generate the most information because these cases are rarely covered.

And so what would happen if we come here and we say, "Turn on all the lights, shake the trees," we might find something. And we found a whole bunch of shit. And.

Shawn Ryan01:51:50

What kind of stuff did you find?

Payne Lindsey01:51:52

I mean, we quickly got down to the persons of interest. And there are several of them. I've talked to all of them. This is the first time I actually had a gun pulled on me in Montana. This guy named Sam, who was one of the last people to see her alive. He's got a really kind of unfortunately unbelievable story. He says that Ashley was with him for several days. She's about half his age. They were doing drugs together.

And then he drives her to meet this person who he only knew by a nickname. And he passes out in his car and he wakes up and she's gone. I'm like, "Really? If that's really what happened, that's unfortunate because or it's just a really bad story or a really bad lie." But I challenged him on this. I showed up unannounced to his house and I forgot for a second it was Montana, I guess.

But he kind of pops up from around this sort of broken down car. We're way up on this mountaintop. There's no neighbors around. You can't hear. There's no city nearby. And I see this thing coming from his waistband. It's like an old big-ass revolver. And I'm like, "Oh my goodness." And I go, "Sam, Sam." And I could tell he's like, "Okay, wait. This person knows my name." And I'm not reacting to the fear that I'm feeling that this guy might shoot me.

And my first instinct was to throw a little confusion out there in the sense of maybe you know this person and I'm unfazed by this potential threat. I'm like, "Oh, Sam, it's Pain." He's like, "Who?" And I'm still approaching instead of reacting or running away. And I just fight or flight. That's what I chose to do. And I just walked all the way up to him and then he put it down.

He goes, "I'm sorry." He goes, "Do we know each other?" I was like, "Well, we haven't met like in person, but I just started talking to him." And then next thing you know, I was there for three hours and he told me nearly everything. And I almost just dipped out in an instant because, I mean, the fight or flight kicked in and I was really more concerned about de-escalating this moment right now fast.

And you're not going to shoot someone who is your buddy. You're going to be like, "Okay, you're grudging me down if I'm just being like, 'Hey, Sam, I already know your name.'" Okay, so this guy doesn't look like a cop or like a, but he's not a mailman either. You know, so he's definitely curious, but using that enough to get closer and then kind of show that I'm here, I'm here to find out more information about someone that I believe you care about too, right?

I mean, you did, right? And so that's usually my way in. I would find it odd if they didn't want to talk unless they had something to hide. Even if we didn't put it on record, don't you care about what happened to them? You know?

Shawn Ryan01:55:29

What did you learn from him?

Payne Lindsey01:55:32

I learned that he retold the story about her being with him for days and dropping her off and falling asleep in the car and waking up and her not being there.

Shawn Ryan01:55:47

Anything else?

Payne Lindsey01:55:47

I mean, a part of me believed, like believed him at first. I think it was just the way that he was seemingly being open about it all, but I kept circling back to it just months later and years later even. It didn't feel right. And I haven't talked to him since then, but a part of me wonders if that entire story is fabricated, obviously.

And if it is, that means he's guilty of something. It's that simple. Or he really did fall asleep. He's telling the truth. And the individual she gets in the car with is who is responsible for her disappearance. And I know who that person is too. And I met with that guy. I mean, it was a knock-knock, just a drop-in. That was a scarier interaction for sure.

I mean, I knew he was dangerous. I also had seen videos from prior arrests and he was screaming and yelling and he just office rocker. And so I'd drive out to this person of interest's house, way up on the top of a hill again, of course, knock on the door. This younger kid answers. I'm like, "Hey, I'm here to see Paul." He's like, "Okay, what is he here for?" And I said, "I'm here about the podcast."

I kind of kept it vague, but I did say that. And he's like, "Okay, come on in." And I'm sitting in the kitchen and I'm talking to this guy. And I'm slowly realizing that I'm pretty sure this guy thinks I'm somebody else. I think he thinks I'm some other person that they were expecting today for whatever reason. That is absolutely not me. And I'm like, but at this point, I'm like three rooms in. I'm in the kitchen. And I'm like looking around, I'm like, "Where was that, you know, that exit again?"

And just sort of like, "Okay." And he comes up the stairs. He goes, "Hey, are you John or some random name?" I was like, "No, I'm Pain." He goes, "Who?" He's like, "You're here with the, some with the bank?" I'm like, "Oh shit. He really thinks I'm someone else, but they've now accidentally let me inside their home. And I'm here. And I'm wired up. I'm recording. My friend is in the car with headphones on, listening, ready to hit the gas pedal and get the hell out of there if needed."

And he goes, "What are you here for?" I said, "Oh, well, Ashley Laurie Heavy Runner. Get the fuck out of my house." "Oh, okay. All right. Well, I was just talking to the family. Get the fuck out of my house." "Okay, well, I don't have that much time between here and the door, but in this space, I'm going to try to take my time and backpedal. I'm leaving your property just like you asked me to. And this is the last 30 seconds I have to get anything if I could at all."

And I'm backing up and he's just mouthing off. He's really pissed. I think he was even more pissed that his cousin let me in the house. And he's got this podcast guy who he knew who I was at that point, was now in his house, likely recording him. And I'm at the door and I'm like, "I'm just trying to keep him there as long as I can." And I just started asking. I'm like, "Well, why don't you want to talk? I don't understand.

No one's pointing fingers at you. I'm not pointing fingers at you at all. The family wants to know what happened." And he goes, "Fuck the family." I was like, "Well, I'm pretty sure Kimberly's not going to like to hear you said that." And then I was like, "Okay, this guy, I think it's time to go." I think his last line to me was, "Get the fuck off my property before I send the dogs on you." And that was my cue.

And I hopped in that SUV and we barreled out of there. That was terrifying. I think that I knew going up to that guy's house beforehand that this was probably one of the more dangerous surprise interactions I'd done. Six months later, he's arrested by the FBI for nearly beating a man to death with a baseball bat.

Shawn Ryan02:00:44

Shit.

Payne Lindsey02:00:45

So he was that dangerous. You know what I mean? And thankfully, I wasn't in that sort of heated exchange with him, but this is someone who is capable of doing that. And those are the ones that spook me. They should spook anyone. You know, because people, even a smart bad guy, will do something that they regret. Killing me, it's like, you're probably not going to get away with it.

You know, we got it on recording. You know, my business partner will probably make a really cool true crime documentary about it. But I'm dead now, right? That's not worth it. And so people who are loose cannons, though, they're not thinking about the weight of their actions in that moment. They do stuff like that. You're not getting away with this. It doesn't matter. They're not thinking like that. And so that spooks me sometimes. And so all I can do is try to recon as much as possible there a little bit.

Shawn Ryan02:01:52

Have you had other interactions like that?

Payne Lindsey02:01:54

Yeah, several.

Shawn Ryan02:01:55

Really?

Payne Lindsey02:01:57

Yeah. I mean, I'd say I probably had seven or eight really kind of sketchy interactions with murder suspects that were surprise visits.

Advertisement02:02:13
Payne Lindsey02:03:34

That's an easy one to answer. I know it. There's one specifically. It happened most recently, actually, in the fourth season of Up and Vanished. It took place in Nome, Alaska, tiny town, Arctic Circle. It is out there. I mean, look at it on a map. I mean, it's closer to Russia than it is another city in Alaska. It's out there. And this native woman, she disappeared.

And she was last seen with a man with the nickname Oregon John, which I feels like at this point, I'm like, why are these, there's so many Johns, catfish John, Oregon John with these monikers. And this guy had the same long bad rap sheet. I mean, I pulled his files. Animal cruelty, rape, assault. Firstly, how is someone committing these many crimes and just walking around?

That is yet to be explained to me. But I knew that this was the last person to see Florence Ocpiluk alive. And he admitted to her sister that she was in his tent. He also had her cell phone and her clothes. So she was in his tent and then she just vanishes off this beach. No. This guy was the last person to see her alive and knows what happened to her.

And I'm convinced of it. And I know that all roads lead to John here and I'm going to have to find him. And then when and if I do find him, what am I going to do? Right? I've already done this a couple times now. I've done this for, you know, almost a decade at this point. And a lot of times when I even find the bad guy, I end up with a 30-second recorded exchange where they're just getting pissed off and they try to fight me.

I'm over that. What's the goal here, right? What is the goal? The goal is to get as much information as possible. My goal is for them to talk to me. So I located this man. He was in Ketchikan, Alaska. And I learned that he was working on these cargo ships. And I also knew that those schedules are really weird. You're two weeks on, two weeks off. And we could go, you know, spend days and thousands of dollars and time trying to pop up on him and not even be there.

And even if he was there, he might just say, "Fuck off." And I'm like, that wasn't worth it. That was poor planning on our part. Thankfully, I did something that was not part of the plan, but I ended up using. Nine months before that, I have a fake Facebook account. And I've used it for years. And so it looks legit. I won't say the name of the person, but I've just used it to communicate with people. Little burner account. And I had messaged him from this account.

I said, "Hey, John, how's Alaska?" Just throwing a little something out there. Maybe he'll think that I'm somebody he met at a bar one time or something. And he responded kind of normally, like right away, and said something along the lines of, "It's been good, you know, over here in this part of the state now." And I didn't say anything back, but I was like, "Okay, he like engaged with this person." And so now I'm trying to find out where he is.

I'm trying to find him and I'm trying to talk to him. And so I get back on this fake Facebook account and I start messaging him. And I start making up this sort of fake story about myself, how I'm from Kodiak, Alaska. And, you know, my uncle got a lot of money, but he's kicking me out of the place I'm staying at. And me and my friend, we both are really interested in becoming a certified seaman like you are and work on these ships. I saw that you just posted that you got your certificate.

You know, what's that like? And, you know, I think he immediately was like, "Oh, someone cares about what I'm doing, right? It's a pretty normal thing." And he starts engaging and happily showing me the ropes. And so I start asking about, you know, his schedule and what the work life is like on the ship. And I said, "You know, it'd be awesome to grab a beer sometime and talk about it in person.

You know, I'm not that far. Like, what's your schedule like?" Okay, hopefully he's going to tell me when he's going to be here. Oh, well, he's actually, he's off all week this week. Okay, well, me too. And I said, "Well, it'd be awesome if, you know, me and my friend can meet you. How's Wednesday look?" Cool, let's meet at this bar. Okay, I'm like, "Shit, well, we got to get to Alaska in 48 hours." And now I'm like, "Well, what have I done?

Am I going to pop up and say, 'Actually, I'm not this fake imposter. I'm Payne Lindsay, the podcast guy.' How's that going to roll over? Is that going to even be safe? Am I going to get anything out of him at that point? I don't think so." But he's like taking the bait so much on this catfish that I created, this imposter, that I'm like, "What if I tried to continue being this person?"

Now it'll be, it's a huge risk either way here. I could meet him as this fake guy and him immediately say, "I just looked you up on Google and you're Payne Lindsay. You're Wikipedia, bro. I see it." That was a very likely possibility. And so I knew that. But I also knew that it was equally, if not more likely, that if I admitted to tricking him or this other guy doesn't show up and now it's me, he's going to, he's not going to respond well to that and I'm not going to get any more information.

And I already have something building here. And so I decided to bite the bullet and I did something journalistically that I've never done before, which I was kind of at odds about, to be honest. I didn't know how I felt about it in terms of tricking this person, right? But I did. I pretended to be somebody else and we fly to Ketchikan, Alaska. And I wanted a two-v-one scenario here, mostly because I didn't want him to be looking at me the whole time.

Like, I wanted him to have someone else to kind of ping-pong back and forth from. And my friend happens to be from Alaska, small town. So he could talk about that kind of stuff, right? And so we had this whole backstory. Like, we had to have this bulletproof.

Shawn Ryan02:11:11

Came up with a cover story.

Payne Lindsey02:11:13

Cover story.

Shawn Ryan02:11:13

Nice.

Payne Lindsey02:11:15

And it was, it involved Nome, Alaska at a certain point, because that was going to be our end to hopefully prompt him to say, "Well, you know, I lived in Nome, Alaska for a while." "Oh, really? When did you leave? Why did you leave?" Right? And so the day of, he offers to pick me up from the ferry. And I had told him that I was arriving at different times than I really was. I told him later times than they actually were, but it was still the same day.

So I was already there at this Airbnb and I already found another bar that I was going to divert us to, so we could stake it out first. And I opted out of him picking me up. No, we're not doing all that. There's a different bar I found and we've been there for like a couple hours now. We've set up. There's four of us. Two of them are just playing pool in the back. They have headphones on, but you can't really tell. They're listening to everything. And then it's me and my buddy Cooper, who's playing along this charade with me.

And then we just sat there and we waited. And sure enough, this guy, Oregon John, walks in the bar. And I decided that to try to eliminate suspicion as much as possible, I'm just going to be almost like overly annoying or something. Like, kind of like, like, what's up, John? Like, I don't know, just like this sort of like, I don't know, like louder and different and like kind of this, the podcast guy wouldn't act like this, right?

And it almost made me seem like I was dumber than I am or something or more gullible or something. And it also kind of just gave room for me to ask stupid questions or get really curious about this missing person's case that he's involved in. And sure enough, 20 minutes in, we talk about Nome, Alaska, and he's telling me that, "Yeah, people think I murdered this girl." And okay, we're there now. And he's talking about it. And then he says that they basically, you know, were blaming him and he left town because he couldn't be there anymore.

And then he goes and talks about something else. "Oh yeah, the thing I was there for. Shit." Right? And I'm like, "Okay, well, how do I get back to that again?" And each time I do, it gets a little bit weirder each time. Back to that Nome, Alaska missing woman, right? Like, how many times can I say that before he's like, "Why are you so curious about that?" So over the course of three hours, no, I mean, I just know that that's coming, right? So over the course of three hours, I circle back to it like every 25 minutes or so.

And eventually he tells me things that are obviously total bullshit. And he makes up lies about how this other person did it and her body's under this house and just saying things that are crazy and preposterous just to get me to shut up and look the other way. And at this point, it seems like he trusts me. He's no longer suspicious of me. And he goes, "You know what, man? I'm not going to lie. When I saw your Facebook at first, it looked a little sketchy to me."

And then he starts looking at my friend. He goes, "Have you seen his Facebook? He has no profile pictures. You know, he said he was from Georgia and this thing." He's like, "Who is this guy?" And I'm like, "Hey man, I never use Facebook. You know, I'm not even into that kind of technology really." And he goes, "You know what? To be honest, at first I thought you might be this podcast guy." Holy shit. And when I say I was legitimately a deer in headlights, I was.

Because in that moment, man, I wasn't expecting it, but I thought.

Shawn Ryan02:15:11

You're like, "Shit, I'm going to look it up."

Payne Lindsey02:15:13

Yeah, I'm caught. But I instantly, instead of conceding, I was like, "No, no, no." I was like, "But I had to be quick." I go, "Podcast guy. What do you mean podcast guy?" And he starts describing this podcast guy to me, which was me. And I realized that he had just really learned about me the day before. And this other woman who I had talked to had told him about me. He just hadn't Googled me yet.

And I could tell that, because some people were like, you know, in comments and stuff were like, "He knew that it was you." No, he did not. Trust me, I thought the same thing at first. But I sat there for 30 more minutes and he didn't. He genuinely thought, he was just telling this person that he thought, I mean, it's a mindfuck. But then fast forward four months later, I'm trying to get a hold of him again and I'm like, "I need to call him as me.

I need more information." And so I knew that he was doing DoorDash around there. And so I kept ordering McDonald's until I got a man named John. And I just hoped that it would be him because his phone wasn't working anymore. And then he gets to the lobby of the hotel. He's like, "Hey, John, there's actually no Uber order. You can keep the McDonald's. This is Payne Lindsay, by the way."

And he's like, "What?" It's Payne, the podcast guy. He goes, "Oh, shit. What's up, man?" I was like, "Hey, sorry about how we met, you know?" He's like, "It's okay." I'm like, "But I would like to start over with you if we could, you know?"

Shawn Ryan02:17:14

And this is on the phone?

Payne Lindsey02:17:15

It's on the phone as he's dropping off the McDonald's to a place that I'm not at. And I eventually, after talking to him, we kind of buried the hatchet about my catfishing of him. And I was being completely sincere. I was like, "No more bullshit. I'd like to give you the platform to clear your name if that's something that you can do or want to do, but not answering some of the things, not answering to some of the things that you said in our last communication, it's going to leave a big question mark for everyone.

And I can't change that. Only you can change that. And I have no tactic here." And he proposed himself to take a polygraph test. I was like, "Okay, I mean, that's pretty ballsy. I mean, whatever you say about polygraph tests, you know, whatever, science is whack or whatever. I mean, police still use them as a tool to either intimidate or someone out or whatever. It's not admissible.

But hey, I mean, if this guy passed with flying colors, it would definitely help him, you know? And so we arranged this to happen and he failed it twice. And I don't make the rules. He could have passed it, failed it. I had no part in that. And it doesn't mean he did it, but he could have passed it and it would be a different narrative if that were the case. And so I don't like put all my eggs in that basket, but he did fail it twice.

And then on one of the questions, the woman asked him, the polygrapher asked him, "Have you been completely truthful to law enforcement about your involvement in Florence's disappearance?" And he said no. And that was a truth. So he admitted, ironically, that he did know more than he had told police. And that was a truth.

And if anything, that's what I feel like we gathered of the most value.

Shawn Ryan02:19:44

What was the, I mean, what was the scariest part for you?

Payne Lindsey02:19:47

The scariest part was me making sure that this wasn't a trick of his to just kill me or something.

Shawn Ryan02:19:58

So you were just the only person at the time?

Payne Lindsey02:19:59

Yeah. Like, how are we going to like, also, I didn't want to put this polygraph lady in danger. I didn't want to put my own team in danger or myself. Where do we do this? Where do we, I need to buy him a flight. Where do we put him up at? Where does he think we're at? And where do we really stay at that is not that place? And so we needed like three places. It was a logistical kind of nightmare. So I decided to do our meeting at this hotel in Portland, Oregon. We flew him in from Ketchikan.

We were coming in from Atlanta at the time. And we had another Airbnb that was unbeknownst to him. For all he knew, we were staying at this hotel. We just had one room rented. And I was kind of afraid to leave him in this room alone with her. And so just because I don't know this person, but she's a professional and she has interviewed, you know, convicted murderers throughout her career.

So it was, it's not like she, it was her first rodeo or something, but I was thinking about this, right? So I just told her, I was like, "Hey, have your laptop up. I'm on text." And like, "We'll be right outside. And just, even just hit a space bar if you need us to come in here or whatever." But I wanted to not be just staring at him while he's doing this. But come to find out, once he takes the test, I also told her, "Do not tell him the results, because they know it immediately."

But like, good or bad, I don't want you to ruin this guy's day and say, "Hey, you failed twice, buddy." Right? That's kind of triggering. So she's like, "No, I have to go back and review the results." So he, I come back in there and he wants to take it one more time.

Shawn Ryan02:22:00

One more time?

Payne Lindsey02:22:00

And he wants to take it one more time because he wants me to see him take it. And so I very uncomfortably sit there like this with my phone and just film him for like 15 minutes, just us three sitting there. And I put it on Instagram, but you can see, and that's when he answered that question very strangely, where he basically admitted to not telling the whole truth to law enforcement. But yeah, that's kind of where our investigation hit a stall because we landed on this person.

We've talked to them multiple times. They've said more than enough suspicious statements that are contradictory that warrant at least a real investigator from an agency paying a visit. But it's in the state of Alaska. That's hard to come by, it seems. And that's, you know, that's been true for a lot of cases up there. But thankfully, recently, the FBI has taken both of these cases pretty seriously because I personally believe that there probably is some real corruption.

I'm like the most anti-conspiracy guy, believe it or not. I'm not like a government conspiracy kind of guy. And so I really put that through like a stress test. I'm like, "Okay, surely it's something else and it just looks like this." It's almost definitive in my brain that there are powers and positions that have made people look the other way and pushed this aside because there are not good answers or reasons or excuses for either the level of incompetence or stupidity by law enforcement on a local and state level.

And I spent over a year or so collecting signed affidavits from family members of one particular family that's in question who have snitched on, they believe that their dad or their brother or whatever it is, is hiding something. And the FBI took it pretty damn seriously. And so I'm still in communication with them about this.

And I told the listeners that, "Hey, I'm going to give it a shot with them." And I told the FBI, "This is not a media inquiry. This is, I have some information that I think warrants an investigation into law enforcement. I know it takes a compelling amount of information to look into your buddies, but here it is." And so I didn't also just give it to them all at once because that would be stupid. I gave them enough to tell them what it is that I have without the details to force a meeting in person.

Truly, just in hopes of some momentum. I really believe that, you know, not everyone in the state of Alaska, law enforcement is corrupt here. There's a couple of young guns in there for sure who are like, "Hell yeah, this could be my promotion." For sure, yes. Not everyone's, you know, complicit. And so there's some good people still in there. I know it. I've talked to some of them. So I think in one weekend interviewing everyone, they could gather enough information to probably talk to a prosecutor about some stuff.

Shawn Ryan02:26:04

Shish.

Payne Lindsey02:26:05

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan02:26:09

Man, you're uncovering some good stuff, man. Holy shit. Speaking of conspiracies, let's talk about, I mean, you've looked into monsters, lab leaks, UFOs.

Payne Lindsey02:26:24

Yeah. UFOs.

Shawn Ryan02:26:26

Where do you want to go? Let's go to UFOs. We're talking about Gnome Alaska. Gnome Alaska has.

Payne Lindsey02:26:33

There's that movie, right? Fourth Kind? You ever see that?

Shawn Ryan02:26:35

Oh, is that a gnome?

Payne Lindsey02:26:36

Yeah. I mean, it's based in like a, in Gnome.

Shawn Ryan02:26:39

My wife wants to go to Gnome. She says there's more, we looked it up before this, but she says, I think she's always said there's been more people that disappear per capita there than anybody, than anywhere else in the US.

Payne Lindsey02:26:51

There is a very strange, strangely high number of disappearances in Gnome Alaska.

Shawn Ryan02:26:57

I mean, how many people live there?

Payne Lindsey02:26:59

I mean, under a few thousand.

Shawn Ryan02:27:03

Holy shit.

Payne Lindsey02:27:04

And there's at least, I mean, I want to say 25 to 30 disappearances, I believe, within the last 40, 50 years, which is an insane number for a place that small and that remote. But yeah, who knows? I mean, there's, I do think there is some weird, some other weird shit out there in the universe. I mean, I grew up watching Unsolved Mysteries and every now and then they have a cool episode on a UFO sighting, right?

Or an alien. Always just kind of liked that, just from a sci-fi angle, just fun. But as I got older and in the last 10 years, I feel like the conversation got a little bit more legitimate, maybe. And there are real whistleblowers, decorated military, people who fly the most badass jets and planes and aero tech we have, saying that they've seen anomalous craft or objects or whatever in the sky.

I mean, that's the guy you believe. So why are there so many of those kind of people saying the same things? What's the motive? What are y'all getting out of this besides tanking your career? Right? The risk-reward there isn't worth it. What, a book deal? Maybe. Not even. So it's like, there's enough, there's enough cases and accounts from credible people that it's, in my opinion, it would be a bigger anomaly if they were all untrue.

That would be, to me, even crazier than something fantastical being true, that we've just convinced ourselves that there might be something. Even though it's possible and it's this massive, that we've convinced ourselves that it exists, but it doesn't, but it could. Like that's way, way stranger than something happening.

Shawn Ryan02:29:24

What have you looked into?

Payne Lindsey02:29:26

I mean, what started it for me was the New York Times article and the Politico article years ago where they kind of broke open that there was a hidden government program looking into UFOs. Okay.

Shawn Ryan02:29:46

Was this after the congressional hearing?

Payne Lindsey02:29:48

This is like 2017.

Shawn Ryan02:29:50

Oh, okay.

Payne Lindsey02:29:51

When they first kind of, to me, that's where it changed the tune of this publicly.

Shawn Ryan02:29:57

10 years ago.

Payne Lindsey02:29:58

Which is crazy to think about, yes. Almost nine years ago. Yeah. That, to me, was, you know, early '51, they got aliens, but now we actually have a government-funded program that was secret with millions of dollars that was actually looking into unidentified flying objects. Either that is the dumbest, like just sci-fi for fun thing ever, or why would the government actually take it seriously unless there was something to maybe take seriously?

It doesn't make any sense, right? And so that opened my eyes. And there's too many people that are credible that are on different sides of politics, different walks of life, different backgrounds, different educations, and they're all saying similar stories. And that is a pattern. And I think that even if it's just the 1% of all of those, some of that shit is for real.

Shawn Ryan02:31:07

What have you looked into personally?

Payne Lindsey02:31:10

I mean, I've talked to experiencers of some of the more infamous kind of abductions and sightings that have happened that have sort of painted this picture in American folklore a lot, really. And I mean, I'll give you like a quick example. Travis Walton, I want to say it was 1975 in Snowflake, Arizona, but this man was with five other people out there in Snowflake, Arizona, this logging crew.

They all claim that this craft comes and appears above their truck. Travis is amazed by it and also starts darting towards it. And they all get freaked out and drive off. They come back, he's gone. They go tell the police this and they're like, "Oh, okay. Sounds like you guys killed him." Right? And they're like, "Oh, a UFO took him." And so they were actually under suspicion of murder and they were polygraph tested and being held there.

He was missing for five days. So the police, like they don't know where he was. He wasn't at his house. I mean, what was happening? It's either the most elaborate prank that for, I don't know why or how they pull it off, which again, would be more amazing to me. I would think that it's more fascinating than something unexplained having happened. And so that stories like that where there's multiple witnesses, there is this underlying event that is really hard to rationally explain.

And when you talk to these people, you can tell when somebody has genuinely experienced something that they don't know how to quantify because it's frustrating to them. They're not jumping to aliens or ghosts or the boogeyman. They usually say, "I have no idea what that was," because it fits a no-basket for them. You know, you could say it's a this or a that, but I don't know. And you could tell it just is infuriating to them a lot of the times.

Going a lifetime, never being able to really understand what it was that you saw, knowing that it was probably advanced and something that's not of this world, whatever that means, and to never know what it really was and struggle to explain it to other people or get people to believe you.

Shawn Ryan02:33:51

Did you talk to those guys?

Payne Lindsey02:33:52

I have, yeah. Yep.

Shawn Ryan02:33:57

How did the guy show back up? He was gone for five days.

Payne Lindsey02:34:00

So yeah, five days go by. And so according to him, next thing you know, he wakes up on the side of the road. He's frail. He's lost like 15 pounds. He goes to a payphone and he calls his brother. And that's how they're alerted that he's alive. But they went out there with like Geiger counters and stuff like that. And there was something that happened there. There was, you know, like burn marks on the ground. There was radiation in like the trees and the ground.

You have five other people saying they also saw this metallic disc. And so even if it was some other natural event that they witnessed, we don't know what that is either. So that's what I kind of like to tell people. Even if they all had some hallucination that happened at the same time, we still can't explain that either. So does it really matter what it was? It's just, are they telling the truth or not? They believe this happened to them.

So what is real? What is reality? Then if they all believe it, then it happened. What's the difference between believing something happened or knowing it happened and it really happening or something? That's when you start staying up too late and getting on the Reddit boards and.

Shawn Ryan02:35:24

Have you looked into anything else?

Payne Lindsey02:35:28

I've always just been fascinated by the science part of it. Like I know nothing about like astrology or space like that, but I tend to believe that eventually science will explain everything to a degree. And I think that the paranormal, ghosts and stuff like that, aliens even, UFOs, there's some overlap there that science will eventually be able to explain.

I don't know if you've ever had like a ghost encounter or something. I've only had one or two instances and they weren't, I mean, super dramatic, but I know that it was, I know what I heard. I lived in a very old house in Marblehead, Massachusetts. The house was built in 1767.

Shawn Ryan02:36:21

Shish, what did you, what happened?

Payne Lindsey02:36:24

I was there. The first week I was in there, my girlfriend at the time was going on a run and I was upstairs sitting on the toilet, actually. The most vulnerable position you could ever be in, right? And I'm on the very top floor, it's broad daylight, and she had just left. So it would be surprising to hear her like coming back up the stairs. And I just heard all of a sudden like the three flights of stairs, just you know, just this kind of escalating. I was like, "Someone's coming up the stairs."

Like, "Oh, shit. Shit." And freaked me the hell out. And it stopped at the top of the stairs and I'm like, "Okay." And I get up, I check the security cameras. Well, there's nothing. No one came in. Were they already in here? Then I got a knife, just the first thing I see, and I walk around the house and I'm like, "This is crazy right now." And it only scared me because it was a real sound.

It wasn't like an imagining of, and it was like a seven-second, you know what it sounds like when someone's running up the stairs? I never heard a sound like that in that place. And it had plenty of other weird sounds that were consistent. It sounded like someone running up the stairs and there was no one there. And when I think about it later, I oftentimes wonder, I mean, it's a really old house, you know? And I never felt like any evil presence or anything, but I wonder, I'm like, "What if," like to get all heady about it, like talk about time, "What if there's once upon a time, there were a couple of kids who were running up the stairs, right?

Maybe it was 200 years ago. But what if like that was still happening? Like everything is always happening or something. It's almost like an imprint or I don't know the best way to describe it, but it's like, it's not like the ghost of grandpa. It's like a.

Shawn Ryan02:38:25

It's happening in present time in another dimension.

Payne Lindsey02:38:28

Yes. That would be the best way to use our words to describe it. Yes. Like it's, we're on top of each other. Sometimes it's like bumping, but it's always, there was always something running up those stairs. Just like I was always right here. Or I don't know. It's like, it's like, "What?"

Shawn Ryan02:38:44

Don't you think you would continuously hear stuff though?

Payne Lindsey02:38:47

I mean, I don't know. Not if you only got a glimpse of it. Not if it was just like.

Shawn Ryan02:38:53

Why do you think that there would be a tear in reality to where you could see or hear another dimension?

Payne Lindsey02:39:01

Nothing about that day or that moment was spectacular. I can tell you that.

Shawn Ryan02:39:06

I've had the same things happen.

Payne Lindsey02:39:08

So I couldn't pinpoint it to anything. Nothing seemed to have triggered it. And, you know, like there was, it was a super old house. So if you believe that houses can be haunted, this could be one of those houses. But I never felt any sort of evil presence or anything in that house. That was the only thing that really spooked me because it was just a genuine sound. It startled me. I didn't think ghost, I thought intruder, you know? And that's what made me go, "Oh my God, that was a real thing."

I didn't turn that into something later. I don't know what it was.

Advertisement02:39:47
Payne Lindsey02:41:17

Means it happened to you?

Shawn Ryan02:41:19

Oh, I've had a bunch of things happen like that.

Payne Lindsey02:41:21

Sounds or visual?

Shawn Ryan02:41:22

Sounds.

Payne Lindsey02:41:23

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan02:41:24

Sounds.

Payne Lindsey02:41:26

Like what?

Shawn Ryan02:41:27

Well, one time, I've told this a couple times on here, but one time we were doing, there's people in this building that were there for that. But we had one time where we were doing a survival series. Like it was before this podcast started and we were doing like this survival shit. And we used an old kind of Civil War timeframe cabin as the set. And me and my wife stayed there before as like just kind of a weekend getaway type place.

And we heard shit then.

Payne Lindsey02:42:06

Didn't it deter you from coming back?

Shawn Ryan02:42:07

No, because I didn't know, I didn't know if I was dreaming or my wife thought I was dreaming. I was like, "I don't dream." And, you know, and I was like, "Oh, man, whatever."

Payne Lindsey02:42:17

Maybe I did hear some shit.

Shawn Ryan02:42:21

But it was like loud bangs on the roof of this old cabin. And I was like, "Now, that wasn't a squirrel. It's two o'clock in the morning. Squirrels aren't running around anyways." But whatever. Maybe it was something in a tree kicked a limb down. I don't know. So I kind of chalked it up. And then anyways, we're doing this, we're doing this kind of end-of-the-world survival scenario series and we're doing a debrief in this thing and in this old cabin.

And it's on camera.

Payne Lindsey02:42:57

Oh, really?

Shawn Ryan02:42:57

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey02:42:58

Can you hear it?

Shawn Ryan02:42:59

You cannot hear it on the camera, but you can hear static. You can hear static when the footsteps come.

Payne Lindsey02:43:05

Maybe even weirder though.

Shawn Ryan02:43:06

Right? And so, but there was at least six of us in there. And all six of us, so you're in this cabin and then there's a loft up top with a spiral staircase. You know, it's not a room. You could look over the edge and there's only one way up and one way down. And we just hear these cowboy boots walking across the top of the cabin.

Payne Lindsey02:43:35

You hear the spurs clicking and like?

Shawn Ryan02:43:37

Not spurs clicking or anything like that. Just the, you know, just like.

Payne Lindsey02:43:40

A boot.

Shawn Ryan02:43:41

Yeah, a boot hitting the wood floor. And all like three of us are on camera. All three of us look up at the exact same time. And I look over at the kind of the crew. My wife was there. And they're all looking at me like, you know, and we go up there and nothing's there.

Payne Lindsey02:44:06

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan02:44:06

But we also had like, remember I had like this is months, maybe years before we did this. And, you know, I remembered I was like, "Oh shit, I heard stuff in here before." And that wasn't a bang on the roof. That was cowboy boots on a wood floor.

Payne Lindsey02:44:29

That was walking.

Shawn Ryan02:44:29

And when we went there too, there was a lot of shit going on with the electricity. And like we'd plug a lamp in this outlet and we'd plug it into the other one and it wouldn't plug in. Then we'd plug something else in. It would work. And I can't remember the exact scenario, but I remember thinking like, "This is like weird. Like how is this happening?"

Payne Lindsey02:44:51

Yeah, like this is not normal. I've seen a lot of places. This is not normal.

Shawn Ryan02:44:54

Yeah. Like I was like, I was just like the electric in here, like it's unexplainable right now, you know, because this works on this outlet, but not in the other, but.

Payne Lindsey02:45:03

It's not mathing.

Shawn Ryan02:45:04

It's not like you're plugging a bunch of shit into one outlet and it's not working. Some stuff works, some stuff doesn't, but everything works in one hour. Anyways, and yeah, that's happened. We've had all kinds of wazoo shit happen.

Payne Lindsey02:45:20

So what'd you make of that one? I mean, there's other people there.

Shawn Ryan02:45:23

Well, yeah. So I'm really dubbing this story now because I've told it so many times. But I was telling, so anyways, we pull the footage because all of us are like, "What the hell? We get the hell out of there." I'm like, "Let's just get out of here, dude." And we go back to my house and we pull the footage and everywhere there was a footstep, it was like, it's crazy.

Payne Lindsey02:45:48

I mean, like explain that even.

Shawn Ryan02:45:50

Right? And I mean, people, you know, probably think I'm full of shit because it was on camera. I guess we could have reenacted or acted.

Payne Lindsey02:45:59

But you were all there and you all experienced the same thing.

Shawn Ryan02:46:01

Every single one of us, man. We're all looking at each other like, "What was that?"

Payne Lindsey02:46:07

So what do you think that was though?

Shawn Ryan02:46:09

Oh, I think, I mean, I think it was a ghost or something. It couldn't have been anything else. So then I'm telling a friend about it that I grew up with and he goes, "You ought to like check out the reviews on Airbnb."

Payne Lindsey02:46:28

Oh, really?

Shawn Ryan02:46:28

And just see like if there's anything there. So I get on there and sure as shit, there's like a whole list of reviews on it.

Payne Lindsey02:46:37

Are they giving one stars or five stars with their ghost experience?

Shawn Ryan02:46:39

Yeah. It was like a lot. Don't bang on the walls, they'll bang back. Don't show up after dark. It changes. But which interesting too is it's not an original, it's an original cabin. But if I remember correctly, because we're actually, we know the family that owns the, it's a big farmer out here.

Payne Lindsey02:47:02

Okay.

Shawn Ryan02:47:06

And they had that cabin, like it's a real Civil War cabin, but it was deconstructed and relocated to put on their property.

Payne Lindsey02:47:15

Oh, interesting.

Shawn Ryan02:47:16

And then they put it as an Airbnb.

Payne Lindsey02:47:17

So they brought the bones of this thing and put it on the property.

Shawn Ryan02:47:20

Yeah. And then there's a, I mean, my house in Marble Hill was kind of like that too. It was kind of reconstructed and, but there was old wood.

Payne Lindsey02:47:27

From another location though. This isn't like a refurbished house.

Shawn Ryan02:47:30

Oh, they just, you can get online and find these Civil War cabins, you know, era Civil War campers that have all been reconstructed. And then you buy like, you basically buy like the logs. You know what I mean?

Payne Lindsey02:47:45

I did not know this.

Shawn Ryan02:47:46

Yeah. And you can reconstruct it. And I think like some of them might have like some of the original fireplaces that have been.

Payne Lindsey02:47:52

So there's pieces from.

Shawn Ryan02:47:53

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey02:47:54

Okay. Yeah.

Shawn Ryan02:47:54

But I mean, it's the whole, it would be like, it would be like ripping this house apart.

Payne Lindsey02:47:59

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan02:48:00

Or ripping this building apart down to the studs and then saving all the studs and labeling where they all go.

Payne Lindsey02:48:06

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan02:48:06

And then reconstructing it at another property.

Payne Lindsey02:48:11

Damn.

Shawn Ryan02:48:11

So that's what this, you know, which is kind of odd because you'd think it'd go with the land.

Payne Lindsey02:48:15

Right. But I mean, yeah.

Shawn Ryan02:48:17

You talk to a lot of priests and people too, and they say that like spirits or whatever you want to call it can travel with objects. You know, so, you know, I guess it's a possibility.

Payne Lindsey02:48:32

Did you feel like it was evil?

Shawn Ryan02:48:34

I didn't feel like it was friendly. I can tell you that.

Payne Lindsey02:48:36

Okay.

Shawn Ryan02:48:37

But I mean, I didn't have any other interactions with it. It was just sound, but it's, none of the interactions that I had, like it's like two o'clock in the morning or three or one or whatever time it was in the middle of the night waking up and it's like, you know, on the ceiling.

Payne Lindsey02:48:55

You'd be a dick either way.

Shawn Ryan02:48:56

Yeah. It's like, yeah.

Payne Lindsey02:48:59

That would be terrifying. If it was you doing that, I'd be like, "Oh my God."

Shawn Ryan02:49:03

Yeah. So I was like, but it was that loud, you know?

Payne Lindsey02:49:06

Okay. So it was like unmistakably disruptive.

Shawn Ryan02:49:10

Yeah. But I was like, "All right." You know, first I was like, "All right, maybe it was a dream." Because it's, you know, you don't hear it when you're full awake.

Payne Lindsey02:49:20

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan02:49:20

You're like, "Did I just hear like banging?"

Payne Lindsey02:49:22

Coming to, something woke you up.

Shawn Ryan02:49:24

You know? And so anyways, but yeah, we've had like, I went to, there's a lot of this shit in this area. I mean, this is frontline Civil Wars. We went to this.

Payne Lindsey02:49:35

Yeah, I mean, it's the Civil War stuff. It's probably a bunch of that over here too, right? I mean.

Shawn Ryan02:49:39

You could go to downtown over here and there's ghost tours all over the place.

Payne Lindsey02:49:42

Oh, really?

Shawn Ryan02:49:43

I mean, if you go to the courthouse.

Payne Lindsey02:49:45

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan02:49:45

I got a tour of the courthouse. Really good friends with the sheriff here and I got a tour of the courthouse by one of the deputies. And at the courthouse here, they used to hold court and there's a big balcony. Like if you go, if you have time, go check out the town square.

Payne Lindsey02:50:05

And just the.

Shawn Ryan02:50:06

Here.

Payne Lindsey02:50:06

Yeah, okay.

Shawn Ryan02:50:07

And there's the courthouse is there and there's a big balcony.

Payne Lindsey02:50:12

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan02:50:12

And they would hold court and if they were found guilty, it was the death sentence, they would just march them right out of court and hang them right off that balcony.

Payne Lindsey02:50:20

Just.

Shawn Ryan02:50:21

And then all the sheriffs, all the sheriff deputies and everybody.

Payne Lindsey02:50:25

Oh, that place has got all kind of bad shit.

Shawn Ryan02:50:27

Yeah, they're like, nobody wants to be here after dark. Like people hear shit.

Payne Lindsey02:50:31

After five.

Shawn Ryan02:50:31

All the time.

Payne Lindsey02:50:32

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan02:50:33

But there's, I mean, yeah, there's like all kinds of, I don't, I've never taken one.

Payne Lindsey02:50:40

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan02:50:40

But because I don't, I'm a kind of, if you can't kill it, don't fuck with it type person.

Payne Lindsey02:50:46

Totally.

Shawn Ryan02:50:46

And, but yeah, I've had a lot of stuff with electricity and like all kinds of crazy things. But yeah, yeah. Have you had anything else happen? Have you looked into ghosts?

Payne Lindsey02:51:05

Actually reminded me, I mean, the other ghost experience I had was also in the same house. This would happen all the time though. And again, it never scared me as in like an evil presence. At first it was like that spooky, but there was a mini bar area between the living room and the dining room. And there was a sink there. And I mean, once a week or so, it would just turn on.

Shawn Ryan02:51:34

Holy.

Payne Lindsey02:51:35

And we had plumbers come out and look at it. The previous owner talked about it. Everything is completely normal. It's like nice hardware and stuff. And I'm like, what is actually happening? It's like the electricity thing. It's like, what is.

Shawn Ryan02:51:51

Like would the thing be moved too?

Payne Lindsey02:51:53

It would be like just enough for it to have done it. But even if I were to do that, it wouldn't have, like water wouldn't come out. And it wasn't like something was like kicking water up. It would just all of a sudden be like, water's coming out and it would, or it would start dripping and then go.

Shawn Ryan02:52:11

Oh, jeez.

Payne Lindsey02:52:12

And nothing's like, there's no toilet being flushed. I mean, they stuck a camera down this thing. There is nothing abnormal about it. And it sometimes it would just be like, you know, I would just, I can inform my friends like, "Hey, sometimes this happens." We'd be talking and all of a sudden it's just, you hear like and it's like dripping. And I'm like, "Oh yeah, the sink's on it or whatever."

Shawn Ryan02:52:37

I always, you know, I believe a lot more in it now than I ever used to.

Payne Lindsey02:52:41

Really?

Shawn Ryan02:52:43

But yeah, you know, if it's, you know, if it's anything that could possibly be interference from a neighbor or a, you know, like TVs turning on and off, I'm like, "Dude, especially if we're at like a hotel or in town or an Airbnb, I'm like, that could be, the neighbor could have the same TV or have the remote on the same frequency or ceiling fan."

Payne Lindsey02:53:06

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan02:53:07

It could have been.

Payne Lindsey02:53:07

There's like rational Bluetooth.

Shawn Ryan02:53:08

Yeah. Like who knows? Like, you know what I mean? I always chop it. But there are some things that are just like, it couldn't be anything else. There's nothing popping in my head that anything else this could possibly be.

Payne Lindsey02:53:21

Yes. And that's what the previous owner had said to us and every plumber that came out there. So I never saw anything. One of my friends did say, like my girlfriend at the time, she was out of town, but my friend was staying, I think it was the first night he stayed at that house. And he was at the very top, which is where I heard the stair thing, you know, running up the stairs. And I think the cat crawled into bed with him that night.

And he said he woke up and the cat was just like sitting up on the bed and staring and looking up and down at something. And he was like, "I swear there was like a shadow figure thing there at the edge of the door." And then I heard like a, he said it really spooked him. Like, obviously that would be scary, but I never felt any sort of like bad entity, but he personally did not like that.

Shawn Ryan02:54:21

I don't think I would like that.

Payne Lindsey02:54:23

Yeah. So there were some times where I was in the house by myself and I'm like, "I'm not afraid of the dark," you know? Then I'm like, and I'm like, I think about that story he told me and I'm going up there and I'm like, "Oh my God, man. I really don't want to encounter anything right now. I really don't. I'm just trying to."

Shawn Ryan02:54:39

I don't know either.

Payne Lindsey02:54:40

I'm just trying to get my charger from upstairs, you know? Like, yeah, so I definitely don't.

Shawn Ryan02:54:44

Like singing real loud and like.

Payne Lindsey02:54:46

Yeah, you're trying to be all like, "Man, I don't give a shit about ghosts, man." You know what I'm saying? But you're like, inside you're like, "Yeah, what?" But yeah, it was a weird house. But the faucet thing, that was never really rationally explained to me.

Shawn Ryan02:55:04

Jeez. That is weird, man. Do you look into that stuff?

Payne Lindsey02:55:10

A little bit. I think I'm personally more fascinated by aliens.

Shawn Ryan02:55:15

Do you think there's a connection between the two?

Payne Lindsey02:55:17

I think so. I mean, I think a lot of times the way that people describe things, I mean, even with some of these just crafts that people are saying, like if you notice just like the common, one of the common threads in a UFO sighting is usually like paraphrasing here, someone says, "It was there and then it was just gone." It's rarely, then it just zoomed off really fast. You know what I mean? There are a lot of stories where it's there, then it's not there.

It's like, boop. Like either it took off really fast or it like went behind another layer of the universe or dimension or shield, whatever. And I feel like there is something scientific about that, whether it's like advanced craft or beings or something that we're seeing. And I think there's an overlap there with the paranormal stories a lot of the time.

I think that there has to be an intersect there, because if we're talking about realms or places or dimensions that we can't see, then we're, that something can kind of slip behind the veil from and show itself for a second and then go back. Well, both the UFO experiencers and ghost experiencers are saying the same things are happening. So if any other place or dimension exists, then it would make sense that there could be some intersect there.

Yeah, I think there's probably so much that we don't know that even explaining it, if we figured it out, would break our brains probably. It's like if we went back in time and gave a caveman an iPhone, right? I mean, he could definitely break that thing for sure. He could smash it on a rock and break it. He probably couldn't turn it on. And if he did get it turned on, it would eventually die and he would not be able to use it ever again.

Shawn Ryan02:57:32

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey02:57:32

And so I wonder like about our own technology, like if we have craft, I would lean more on the side of, we probably have shit from the '60s that we haven't been able to turn on since '62 or something. You know, they're like, "We know it's not ours, it's not Russia's, it's not China's, but we can't get this damn thing to start anyway."

Shawn Ryan02:57:52

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey02:57:53

I don't know.

Shawn Ryan02:57:54

Do you, yeah, I don't know. You know what I mean? We only have five senses. We can only hear certain things.

Payne Lindsey02:58:03

Well, what do you think? I mean.

Shawn Ryan02:58:04

What do I think?

Payne Lindsey02:58:05

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan02:58:07

I don't know. I used to be fascinated by this stuff. Now I'm not.

Payne Lindsey02:58:10

You burned out by it?

Shawn Ryan02:58:12

Yeah, a little bit. I mean, I brought on.

Payne Lindsey02:58:14

It's awesome.

Shawn Ryan02:58:14

I brought on so many, I brought on a lot of people to talk about this stuff. And I talk about this all the time, every time it gets brought up too. Every time, none of these people are working together.

Payne Lindsey02:58:28

I know, I know.

Shawn Ryan02:58:29

They all hate each other. They all talk shit about each other.

Payne Lindsey02:58:33

No, they're right.

Shawn Ryan02:58:34

Except, an exception to that, my friend Brandon Fugal. I think he's.

Payne Lindsey02:58:40

That's the guy who owns the.

Shawn Ryan02:58:42

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey02:58:43

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan02:58:44

I've been out there with him.

Payne Lindsey02:58:45

Have you?

Shawn Ryan02:58:46

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey02:58:46

Cool.

Shawn Ryan02:58:47

And he's a friend of mine.

Payne Lindsey02:58:49

Oh, very cool.

Shawn Ryan02:58:49

I think he follows me on Instagram. He's open-minded.

Payne Lindsey02:58:52

He hasn't opened my DM yet, but I was like, "Can I come see Skinwalker?" I was just, let's hang out. I'm not going to film it.

Shawn Ryan02:58:57

Dude, it's cool to see.

Payne Lindsey02:58:59

Have you like, was it, did you experience something or was it just, I mean, obviously it's cool.

Shawn Ryan02:59:03

I did not. I did not. There's one thing that happened.

Payne Lindsey02:59:06

Okay.

Shawn Ryan02:59:07

But it didn't happen. So, you know, like all these guys are getting kind of messed up there.

Payne Lindsey02:59:12

Yeah, like.

Shawn Ryan02:59:12

You know, like weird things will happen to them. So we went and I don't know what it was, because I went in every single house and we went and we saw all the like stuff that's painted on the rocks from back, you know, who knows when. And climbed around on them and like did the whole thing.

Payne Lindsey02:59:33

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan02:59:33

You know, with Brandon.

Payne Lindsey02:59:34

Cool.

Shawn Ryan02:59:36

And I came back, we were just on a vacation, me and my wife went on a vacation out in Utah. And he picked me up and we went out there and it was cool. And so we got back, we were staying in an Airbnb and we got back and I can't remember if it was that day or that night or whatever, but I remember like I had like a couple of, they were like burned blisters on my fingers.

Payne Lindsey03:00:05

Just.

Shawn Ryan03:00:05

But like really small ones, nothing. And I don't know where those came from. It's not like I, I didn't burn myself.

Payne Lindsey03:00:13

You didn't feel it.

Shawn Ryan03:00:14

I didn't get like, I didn't get my finger like caught in a door, you know what I mean? It wasn't a blood blister. So it was like a clear little bitty like blister that hurt. I was like, "What the hell is that?"

Payne Lindsey03:00:29

That is kind of weird. I'm not going to lie.

Shawn Ryan03:00:31

And so I was like, "Oh me, damn, maybe it is actually from the ranch."

Payne Lindsey03:00:35

Yeah?

Shawn Ryan03:00:35

I don't know. I've never, I don't think I've ever even told anybody that other than my wife, because I was like, "Nah, it's."

Payne Lindsey03:00:40

You're like, "Look what they did."

Shawn Ryan03:00:41

It's probably from something else.

Payne Lindsey03:00:43

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:00:43

And it was so insignificant, because it was like this big.

Payne Lindsey03:00:45

Yeah, but.

Shawn Ryan03:00:46

They talk about like the radiation spikes and shit out there. And they give you a radiation thing to like run around with.

Payne Lindsey03:00:52

Oh, really?

Shawn Ryan03:00:52

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:00:52

So you see it kind of.

Shawn Ryan03:00:53

But ours never went off. So I don't know. I don't know. Maybe it's from touching like one of those like big boulders that have the shit painted on it. Not shit, but whatever that is. You know, I told Brandon about that house that I was, that Airbnb.

Payne Lindsey03:01:07

What'd he say about that?

Shawn Ryan03:01:08

He was like, "Give me the address."

Payne Lindsey03:01:10

He's like, "Yo, I'm going to stay."

Shawn Ryan03:01:12

He's like, "The next time I'm there, I want to go check that place out."

Payne Lindsey03:01:15

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:01:15

And that's been years ago. I don't think he ever did it. But I don't know. I mean, what do you think happens?

Payne Lindsey03:01:21

I mean, you feel like he's more reliable, like or more neutral?

Shawn Ryan03:01:24

I think.

Payne Lindsey03:01:25

Is that part of the Twitter wars about.

Shawn Ryan03:01:27

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:01:28

The skeptics versus the.

Shawn Ryan03:01:29

When you talk to him, he's not like, if you bring anybody else up, he's like, "That guy's falling." You know?

Payne Lindsey03:01:34

I know.

Shawn Ryan03:01:35

You know?

Payne Lindsey03:01:36

It's.

Shawn Ryan03:01:36

I'm the only one that can possibly know this. You know what I mean? It's like, you just have to be the one to bring it out, dude.

Payne Lindsey03:01:42

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:01:43

But literally all of them do that shit, except Brandon. And.

Payne Lindsey03:01:48

Yeah, a lot of them do that. And that's been a very frustrating part of this. I try to stay completely out of it.

Shawn Ryan03:01:55

That's discrediting in itself.

Payne Lindsey03:01:57

It is. It's an image. It's petty. It's weird. It's.

Shawn Ryan03:01:59

I think the government shit is discrediting at this point.

Payne Lindsey03:02:03

Yeah. I mean, are you also just personally like exhausted? Like we don't care to just say it or not or.

Shawn Ryan03:02:10

I think it's now being, because I do, I don't know if I've seen a lot of shit in government at this point to know that it's just dirty.

Payne Lindsey03:02:23

Sure.

Shawn Ryan03:02:23

You know? And they will say things and they will make things trend on Twitter to get people to talk.

Payne Lindsey03:02:33

Oh, right.

Shawn Ryan03:02:34

You know, like.

Payne Lindsey03:02:34

Cyopkinas and stuff were just like.

Shawn Ryan03:02:36

And look over here.

Payne Lindsey03:02:36

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:02:37

They'll have a hundred thousand bot accounts to all repost something and type some shitty thing. And then the next thing you know, it's the number one trending thing on Twitter. Like I know that happens.

Payne Lindsey03:02:50

Yep.

Shawn Ryan03:02:51

And so, you know, I was at the first congressional hearing about, you know, it was when David Grush came out about, you know.

Payne Lindsey03:03:02

Oh, yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:03:03

Non-human biologics.

Payne Lindsey03:03:04

I was there too. Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:03:05

And I was like all excited, you know?

Payne Lindsey03:03:09

Right.

Shawn Ryan03:03:10

It felt like a.

Payne Lindsey03:03:11

It's the first one.

Shawn Ryan03:03:12

Legendary day, right? And now I'm like, "Okay, what is non-human biologics, dude? Is that like a deer carcass on the side of the road?"

Payne Lindsey03:03:21

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:03:22

Like that could be anything.

Payne Lindsey03:03:23

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:03:24

Could you be a little bit more, you know? I would love to talk to him. And I have talked to him.

Payne Lindsey03:03:29

Come on, Grush. Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:03:30

But I just, I don't, I just, I don't know, man. I just, people get famous off that shit.

Payne Lindsey03:03:38

I know. It's like.

Shawn Ryan03:03:39

It's a great way to like throw a shiny object out there that's like, "Look over here, everybody."

Payne Lindsey03:03:45

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:03:45

You know? And whether it was legitimate at the beginning, I don't think it's legitimate now. Now I think if they've seen what it does, they've seen what it does and how much attention that it moves. And so now it's a tool, you know? Maybe there's some legitimacy to it. Maybe there isn't.

Payne Lindsey03:04:06

How about the, I mean, not all of them, but the missing and murdered scientists thing that's related to UFOs?

Shawn Ryan03:04:14

Yeah, we started to get into the news for a little bit.

Payne Lindsey03:04:17

It's odd.

Shawn Ryan03:04:18

Some of them are, I mean, some of them are just objectively odd disappearances.

Payne Lindsey03:04:22

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:04:22

You know?

Payne Lindsey03:04:24

What do you, that's about the time also where I was like, "Dude, I'm done talking about shit."

Shawn Ryan03:04:31

You've burned out on this.

Payne Lindsey03:04:31

But what do you think happens when you die?

Shawn Ryan03:04:35

Oh, man.

Payne Lindsey03:04:39

I don't know if I have a definitive thought line on that. I don't know if I have something that I believe more than something else. I don't know. I think it's, a part of me feels like when you die, you're just starting over again or something.

Shawn Ryan03:05:10

Like reincarnation?

Payne Lindsey03:05:11

Maybe. And maybe it's like you never stop. It's always happening. And so maybe that's like a reincarnation thing.

Shawn Ryan03:05:19

Like the energy just gets recycled?

Payne Lindsey03:05:21

Yeah. Or I don't know. I mean, occasionally I'll see something on Reddit, even though I'm anti-conspiracy, where I'm like, "Well, if that was true, that would be crazy, right?" It was something about, you know, one of the big government secrets is that, you know, after you die, there's like an afterlife. And I'm like, that would be actually a very peculiar thing to have discovered if that were true.

It's like scientifically, because then I would imagine a lot of people might try to kill themselves or something. I mean, I don't know. Like if you, if there was another place guaranteed, and I'm not talking about heaven or hell right now. I'm talking about just like another, this is just like the temporary part or something. If there was like, "Oh yeah, it's way, way better over here." If that was a fact and we knew that, I could see how there would be reason to keep that.

You know what I mean? Like I always think about the UFO secrets and stuff like that. If I was the government who had all of the secret files and I knew everything in Area 51 or something, if it were to really disrupt everyone's belief systems or something and make, spook a lot of people, I could see why there would be no advantage to releasing that information.

Not saying that it's not morally correct. Yeah, obviously we should know the truth, but I could see the argument for someone to say there's nothing to gain by doing this. And that could be objectively true. Only bad things could potentially happen. Now I think the younger generation doesn't give a shit. They're like, "Yeah, aliens are real. We knew that." You know what I'm saying? I don't think anyone's going to be so shocked.

Shawn Ryan03:07:29

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:07:32

And maybe that's what it takes. Or maybe we've just convinced ourselves over like a hundred years that aliens have visited us and they haven't. But it's totally possible that they could, given the size of the universe and the probability of life on other planets. That it would be so much crazier to me that we've got to this level of intelligence where we've gaslit ourselves. That's, maybe we have. But it's even weirder that we could have done that, but it also be scientifically possible at the same time.

Like it's scientifically more likely that we are not alone in the universe. It's too vast. The likelihood of there being another Goldilocks situation, another planet that could sustain life is almost certain. It could be forever away. We may never see it in our lifetime, but it's too vast. And so with that possibility, is there another Earth-like place where they're banging their heads against the wall right now too?

You know what I'm saying? I'm saying like, do they exist or not? Just doing it in the same boat we are.

Shawn Ryan03:08:43

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:08:43

I mean, maybe. I always thought like, wouldn't it be funny if like Roswell with the crash in New Mexico, if it was just like a couple drunk teenagers or something? Like aliens though.

Shawn Ryan03:08:58

That wouldn't surprise me.

Payne Lindsey03:09:00

Right? And they're like, "You guys messed up big time here. Like you wrecked on Earth is the problem."

Shawn Ryan03:09:08

I don't know. I think it's, I mean, I do believe in heaven and hell. I'm a Christian, so.

Payne Lindsey03:09:15

Do you, do you, where does science cross that for you? Or is it outside of that entirely?

Shawn Ryan03:09:20

I don't.

Payne Lindsey03:09:21

It's not a challenging question. It's actually like.

Shawn Ryan03:09:23

Yeah. No, I don't.

Payne Lindsey03:09:24

I've talked about it and thought about it too.

Shawn Ryan03:09:25

I don't know. But I mean, if you think like, I don't, I just, I don't think there is any other creation other than here.

Payne Lindsey03:09:34

Other than Earth.

Shawn Ryan03:09:35

Other than Earth.

Payne Lindsey03:09:37

Why do you think that?

Shawn Ryan03:09:38

Because I just, I think we would know by now, maybe.

Payne Lindsey03:09:45

Why would we know though?

Shawn Ryan03:09:46

I don't, I don't know. I just, it's just a, it's just a gut feeling.

Payne Lindsey03:09:50

The Fermi paradox where it's like.

Shawn Ryan03:09:51

It's just a gut feeling.

Payne Lindsey03:09:52

Show yourselves, right? Like wouldn't we have seen it by now?

Shawn Ryan03:09:55

Maybe kind of, you know, but you know, and everybody that's, I don't know. I guess I'm just vomiting thoughts out right now, but you know, the universe is, you know, it's expanding. Everything's getting farther apart from each other. Galaxies are getting farther apart, you know? And I don't know. You think of consciousness, it never ends. Like your creativity will never end. There's always more, more, more, more to think about. And I think that that's the universe as well. I think the universe is infinite and never ends and it keeps expanding.

And I think that, you know, a lot of the, I think a lot of the things that we see are probably spiritual. And you know, if you look at, you know, a lot of people say, you know, they see these things go, you know, into the water.

Payne Lindsey03:10:47

Yep.

Shawn Ryan03:10:47

You know, and there's no, the same speed. You know what I mean? It's not like it slows down and comes out and like.

Payne Lindsey03:10:54

Yep.

Shawn Ryan03:10:55

And there's people are seeing things go through mountains and, or through hilltops, and it's transcending matter. You know? And so I think that, and if you look into like angels and demons and that kind of stuff, there's the seraphin. I think it's the seraphin angels. And they don't, you know, they don't look like, you know, an angel that you see on a Christmas ornament, you know?

Payne Lindsey03:11:23

Okay. Right. They're not the.

Shawn Ryan03:11:25

A seraphin, you know, supposedly is like a, it's a disc.

Payne Lindsey03:11:33

Okay.

Shawn Ryan03:11:33

You get your phone on you?

Payne Lindsey03:11:35

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:11:35

Look it up.

Payne Lindsey03:11:36

How do you spell that?

Shawn Ryan03:11:37

Oh, shit. I don't know.

Payne Lindsey03:11:39

Seraphin.

Shawn Ryan03:11:39

S-E-R.

Payne Lindsey03:11:41

Seraphin?

Shawn Ryan03:11:44

A.

Payne Lindsey03:11:44

Let's see.

Shawn Ryan03:11:45

P-H-I-N or something.

Payne Lindsey03:11:46

Seraphin?

Shawn Ryan03:11:47

Yeah, I believe so. But it's like this, it looks like a, it's in a disc and it's got like eyeballs all over it and lights and stuff.

Payne Lindsey03:11:55

Seraphin. Not Steven.

Shawn Ryan03:11:59

Seraphin. It just wants to say Steven. Okay. I'm going to say Seraphin UFO.

Payne Lindsey03:12:07

Seraphin angel.

Shawn Ryan03:12:09

Ah, here we go. Okay. I think, angel? Okay. I see angel. Is it like a craft?

Payne Lindsey03:12:18

Do you see a picture of it yet?

Shawn Ryan03:12:21

This thing?

Payne Lindsey03:12:23

You can type it in.

Shawn Ryan03:12:25

All right, mess it up.

Payne Lindsey03:12:28

Is this like the stuff that it's like in the hieroglyphics and stuff where it's, or in like biblical paintings where it's like a ball?

Shawn Ryan03:12:37

Yes.

Payne Lindsey03:12:37

And there's like little creatures in it or something? Or like a, I mean, they look like UFOs kind of a little bit in some of those pictures.

Shawn Ryan03:12:45

Oh, man. I can't find it.

Payne Lindsey03:12:48

So have you seen one of these things?

Shawn Ryan03:12:49

Yeah, here you go. This isn't exactly what I'm talking about, but they look pretty freaky, man. So.

Payne Lindsey03:13:03

And you can go back and scroll around. I'm not talking about like a body with wings on it, but you see what that is? Like, you know, everybody when they think of an angel, they think of a, you know, a masculine figure with, you know, ginormous bird wings coming out. Like, like St. Michael over there on the shelf, but a seraphin, you know? And it could not, it might not be a seraphin, but.

Shawn Ryan03:13:30

I talked to a pilot who said he saw something similar to this.

Payne Lindsey03:13:33

Right? See what I'm saying, dude?

Shawn Ryan03:13:34

Right? Was it Ryan Reeves said that?

Payne Lindsey03:13:37

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:13:37

He's like this sphere thing.

Payne Lindsey03:13:39

Yeah, the Tic Tac stuff.

Shawn Ryan03:13:42

Yeah. It feels like it's that kind of shape he was describing.

Payne Lindsey03:13:46

And so.

Shawn Ryan03:13:46

The spherical one within a sphere.

Payne Lindsey03:13:48

And so they also have ones that are, you know, and who knows, right? They also have ones that are in disc form, you know, like, like that has like a bunch of eyeballs on it. The eyeballs.

Shawn Ryan03:13:57

So what are these things?

Payne Lindsey03:13:58

They're angels, dude.

Shawn Ryan03:14:00

And what is an angel?

Payne Lindsey03:14:02

I mean, like, and I mean, I guess the same thing that the Bible says they are.

Shawn Ryan03:14:06

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:14:07

But that's just not the way that they painted them in kids' books.

Shawn Ryan03:14:12

It's interesting, right?

Payne Lindsey03:14:13

No, it is. And it's like, okay, are they, yeah. So you tend to believe that most of these sightings are more of like a spiritual nature and not from like, let's say, a being like us that's more advanced from some other faraway place or something. Like a traditional alien, you know, from Mars. It's more like a, but why so much space?

Shawn Ryan03:14:44

What do you mean?

Payne Lindsey03:14:45

Like, why is there so much space, empty space? Like planets that don't have any life on it.

Shawn Ryan03:14:50

I can't answer that. I don't know. You know what I mean?

Payne Lindsey03:14:52

You know what I mean? It's like, why not just make it smaller?

Shawn Ryan03:14:55

Because I don't know. I don't know.

Payne Lindsey03:14:59

Maybe that's a dumb question, but it does, it crosses my mind. It seems like so infinitely large that it almost feels like it needs a justification for that.

Shawn Ryan03:15:07

That's why it does. Maybe that's why maybe it never ends.

Payne Lindsey03:15:10

I don't think it does. I think.

Shawn Ryan03:15:11

It's like you will never find the end of it.

Payne Lindsey03:15:13

There is not like a Truman Show wall.

Shawn Ryan03:15:16

It's expanding. You know, and if there was, something would have to be on the other side and then that would maybe reveal there's a multiverse.

Payne Lindsey03:15:22

That's in the marble. Yeah. And then.

Shawn Ryan03:15:23

But, but I think, you know, like we're searching for all these answers and we're not finding anything. And it all kind of leads back to one book.

Payne Lindsey03:15:35

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:15:35

For me.

Payne Lindsey03:15:36

Yeah. I mean, I've definitely seen the, I mean, that's one of the things that even me and my own friends and producers are curious about is that sort of intersect with religion, Christianity especially, and UFO sightings. And it seems like there's so many like spiritual kind of moments that these people describe when they're either seeing something or feeling it. And I've talked to some of them where, I mean, they, I talked to this guy who worked in the Navy, Kevin Day, and I mean, he had like a profound moment in his life.

And like he categorizes it as this, this Tic Tac experience as a spiritual kind of experience. And I mean, he was in tears telling me this story. And I'm like, what could make somebody, what could move someone that much? And does God play a role in all this stuff? And what does that even mean?

Right? And like I've thought about these things. I thought there's been enough weird coincidence type things in my life. And coincidence is kind of a bad word. I want more like serendipitous or something where it felt like, like what are the odds? And this is like things were kind of working together and it feels just like, I don't know, like things are being connected. It feels in those moments that I've experienced that there is this potentially like higher power or being, or like we're, there's something bigger going on here.

Shawn Ryan03:17:29

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:17:29

You know what I'm saying? And like, and like I felt that genuinely and not in like a religious way. Like, you know, I mean, I'm actually confirmed Catholic. I mean, I grew up, but I, it was more like a, like a God-like thought. Like there is a God. Like that was, the thought was that simple. I don't even know, I can't even articulate exactly why, but even my friends have kind of agreed. Like, yeah, there's like, I don't know, there's something to that.

What is it? You know what I mean? I don't know.

Shawn Ryan03:18:04

I know. Yeah. I mean, I've been, I've been, I grew up Catholic too. And then had a, had a kind of a maybe a UFO type encounter.

Payne Lindsey03:18:16

Okay.

Shawn Ryan03:18:17

In Sedona, Arizona. I like totally lost faith. Totally left the church.

Payne Lindsey03:18:22

Oh, wow.

Shawn Ryan03:18:22

Joined the SEAL teams. Did a stint with the CIA as a contractor. And like the shit I saw during that time, I was like, no.

Payne Lindsey03:18:32

Yep.

Shawn Ryan03:18:32

And then, and then, and then like some profound stuff happened. This dude read my mind. Like read my mind.

Payne Lindsey03:18:41

Who?

Shawn Ryan03:18:42

A gate guard in Sedona. And I don't want to.

Payne Lindsey03:18:44

Gate guard?

Shawn Ryan03:18:45

Yeah. In Sedona. I was walking back through and I was having this internal battle in my head.

Payne Lindsey03:18:50

Oh.

Shawn Ryan03:18:50

And with my wife.

Payne Lindsey03:18:53

Okay.

Shawn Ryan03:18:53

And we were coming back from a hike and I walked through and this, it was, it was about like, it was about like trans stuff and kids.

Payne Lindsey03:19:02

Okay.

Shawn Ryan03:19:02

Like in my head. And surgeries and all that kind of stuff.

Payne Lindsey03:19:06

Yeah. You were thinking about this.

Shawn Ryan03:19:07

Yes. Not vocalizing it.

Payne Lindsey03:19:09

Yeah. You were just thinking about.

Shawn Ryan03:19:11

Thinking about what, how do I, what am I supposed to do with my podcast?

Payne Lindsey03:19:16

What do I say? Do I not?

Shawn Ryan03:19:17

Yeah, yeah. And there was a lot of like wazoo shit happening in the world. It was COVID time for him.

Payne Lindsey03:19:23

Yeah. Everyone's also lost their mind too. Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:19:24

And I walked through the gate and this guy like reads my mind. Like reads it, dude. Looks at me, tries to talk to me. I don't want to talk to him. He starts talking to my wife and I'm like, shit. And I turn around and he tells me like all this shit that's happening, all this stuff that's happening with kids and gender and duh, duh, duh, duh. He's like, that's not your battle, man. And then he starts, I was also like really concerned about China at the time and he goes into that.

Payne Lindsey03:19:57

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:19:58

And then I can't even remember the rest of the stuff that he said because I was so freaked out that he was inside of my head.

Payne Lindsey03:20:06

What, how did he, what do you make of that though? Was he a person?

Shawn Ryan03:20:11

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:20:12

How did he know that, you think?

Shawn Ryan03:20:14

I don't know.

Payne Lindsey03:20:14

Did he have some ability or was in that moment, was there some sort of like.

Shawn Ryan03:20:18

I think he was placed there at that particular moment in time to show me that there's something more to life.

Payne Lindsey03:20:24

Do you think he even recalls doing that?

Shawn Ryan03:20:27

I've never seen him again.

Payne Lindsey03:20:29

Right.

Shawn Ryan03:20:29

I was there for a week. I pretty, I paid really close attention to security.

Payne Lindsey03:20:35

That's what I was saying.

Shawn Ryan03:20:36

Just my background.

Payne Lindsey03:20:37

Again.

Shawn Ryan03:20:37

All the other people knew me.

Payne Lindsey03:20:39

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:20:39

They listened to my show because of a huge military presence.

Payne Lindsey03:20:43

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:20:44

You know, and then do selfies with them, say hi, talk to them. You know what I mean? And then this old dude.

Payne Lindsey03:20:49

Yeah. So you've clocked people that you.

Shawn Ryan03:20:50

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:20:51

Especially him, you'd know.

Shawn Ryan03:20:52

This is our last day. And then this old dude comes out who I've never seen before and reads my mind from front to back. In front of my wife, I look like a ghost.

Payne Lindsey03:21:02

And she didn't probably even know that you were thinking that moment.

Shawn Ryan03:21:04

She knew, yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:21:04

Or she did. Oh, no. She didn't know. Like in that moment, you're like, you felt seen.

Shawn Ryan03:21:08

I was seeing probably like, holy shit, this guy's.

Payne Lindsey03:21:10

I felt naked. Dude, you weren't feeling naked.

Shawn Ryan03:21:12

Yeah. Like what do you do with that?

Payne Lindsey03:21:13

That would freak me out.

Shawn Ryan03:21:14

You feel naked in front of that dude. Like you're like.

Payne Lindsey03:21:17

What did he look like?

Shawn Ryan03:21:18

He looked like a nice old dude.

Payne Lindsey03:21:20

White guy?

Shawn Ryan03:21:21

Yeah. Just a nice old man with gray hair.

Payne Lindsey03:21:24

Did he look like he belonged there?

Shawn Ryan03:21:27

He didn't look like he didn't belong there.

Payne Lindsey03:21:29

It was just like a benign.

Shawn Ryan03:21:30

I didn't, when I saw him, I didn't want to, you know, I wasn't like, that's weird. Why is this guy standing at the gate?

Payne Lindsey03:21:36

Okay.

Shawn Ryan03:21:36

You know what I mean?

Payne Lindsey03:21:37

He wasn't like.

Shawn Ryan03:21:37

There was no suspicion. There's no suspicions.

Payne Lindsey03:21:40

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:21:40

Until after he read my mind. And then.

Payne Lindsey03:21:42

I see. If anything, you were like at first, I don't even, I don't want to talk to this guy.

Shawn Ryan03:21:46

Yeah. I was just like looking at him over my shoulder like potty posturing. Like don't, I don't want to, I don't give a shit if you watch the show. I don't, I'm not in the mood.

Payne Lindsey03:21:54

I'm over it today. Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:21:55

And I, and right before I got there, I felt this battle for my soul. Like I was like, do I like, do I just like, you know, to me, I'm totally against that stuff.

Payne Lindsey03:22:04

So what happened after that? Did that change?

Shawn Ryan03:22:06

What happened after that?

Payne Lindsey03:22:07

The way you looked at him.

Shawn Ryan03:22:08

I went into my, we were staying in a, in a, like a bungalow that was kind of a duplex at this resort.

Payne Lindsey03:22:15

Okay.

Shawn Ryan03:22:15

And it was Enchantment. If you've ever been there. Enchantment in Sedona.

Payne Lindsey03:22:19

No, I haven't.

Shawn Ryan03:22:20

Was that resort. And right before that trip, I don't have a lot of friends here. And, and whatever, this is a big podcast. A lot of people, you know, claim to be your friend and then you get used. I'm sure you get it.

Payne Lindsey03:22:39

Yeah. It's like we're buddies, right? Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:22:40

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:22:41

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:22:41

And well, I met a guy that was a SEALs named Dan Cirillo. And he, he owned a really successful security company and like a couple of small hospitals.

Payne Lindsey03:22:56

Okay.

Shawn Ryan03:22:57

And me and him will get together. He doesn't need any, like genuinely doesn't need or want anything from me and I don't want or need anything from him.

Payne Lindsey03:23:04

It's the best. We're just like cool. We can just gloves off.

Shawn Ryan03:23:06

Yeah. And we can like talk business or whatever, you know? And we had the SEAL background in common. And so anyways, he died right before this trip.

Payne Lindsey03:23:17

Oh, wow.

Shawn Ryan03:23:18

And I'd never met his daughter. And I walked into my hotel or my bungalow with my wife and I'm like, holy shit, I think that was God talking to me. Like what is happening? And she's like, yeah, Sean, that is what's happening. And.

Payne Lindsey03:23:34

She was that confident right away with that.

Shawn Ryan03:23:36

And she said her first words were, Sean, God's always trying to talk to you. You just don't make room for him. You don't, you don't make enough room for him to listen.

Payne Lindsey03:23:45

Damn.

Shawn Ryan03:23:46

And, and we get in there and we're like having this chat and I'm in this super emotional state. And his daughter texts me who'd never, like I'd never met, never talked to her. Texts me. And so she must have got my number out of her dad's phone and says that she had walked in, trying not to get emotional here. She walked into her dad's gun room for the first time since he had died and said that he had talked to her and said that I had recently become his best friend and she wanted, he wanted her to reach out to me because I knew a side of him that nobody else knew.

Payne Lindsey03:24:36

Wow. I mean.

Shawn Ryan03:24:42

Pretty crazy.

Payne Lindsey03:24:43

Nothing's more real than that.

Shawn Ryan03:24:47

And then I went, and then the next morning I was like, what? Am I going to go on a hike and see the burning bush or like what is going on?

Payne Lindsey03:24:55

Am I like on like some odyssey adventure now? What is happening?

Shawn Ryan03:24:59

So yeah, so I went on this little hike and I wanted to, I just, I was like, I just, this is all of that, like we were flying out that morning. So I woke up.

Payne Lindsey03:25:06

I mean, it probably was like just, you're probably, you're probably still thinking about it, right?

Shawn Ryan03:25:10

No.

Payne Lindsey03:25:11

Or do you put it out?

Shawn Ryan03:25:12

I know what it is now. I've had so many.

Payne Lindsey03:25:13

Well, I mean like the next day, I mean.

Shawn Ryan03:25:15

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:25:15

You were like.

Shawn Ryan03:25:16

Dude, that's so profound.

Payne Lindsey03:25:18

Yeah. Like you're listening.

Shawn Ryan03:25:19

The timing of it, the timing of it was like.

Payne Lindsey03:25:22

How are you like, like how are you rationalizing this or like this, deciphering its meaning for you? Because that really is what it came down to.

Shawn Ryan03:25:30

I was at the time, what's also weird is I was like searching, I went to Sedona because I believed in like crystal energy and shit.

Payne Lindsey03:25:37

Okay. There's a lot of that out there. Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:25:39

You know, and so I went out there and they got these energy vortexes.

Payne Lindsey03:25:42

Right. Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:25:43

And so that's what I had hiked up to.

Payne Lindsey03:25:45

Oh.

Shawn Ryan03:25:45

Took my wife.

Payne Lindsey03:25:46

That's actually an interesting thing.

Shawn Ryan03:25:47

We had this crystal. I had bought us a fucking crystal. And I was like, dude, that's, I didn't know. You know what I mean? I'm like looking for answers. And I hike up to this energy vortex. I'm like, oh, maybe if we hike up this, let me smoke a joint.

Payne Lindsey03:26:03

Right.

Shawn Ryan03:26:04

Grab this crystal, hike up this energy vortex. Maybe I'll feel something.

Payne Lindsey03:26:09

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:26:10

You know? And on the way back down, that's when I felt that battle happening in my, you know what I mean? Where I'm like, do I like give in to this shit? Do I speak up about it? What am I supposed to do? Maybe I'm the messed up one that I should just give in and or like maybe I should accept it, you know? And then that's kind of the way I started leaning.

Payne Lindsey03:26:28

True inner turmoil.

Shawn Ryan03:26:29

Yeah. Yeah. And that's the way I started leaning. And it was, you know, this is all about kids. And then I walked through the gate. That dude reads my mind, walked to the bungalow. His daughter, Taylor, texts me. And then, and then there's a little bit more than happened, but we don't have to get into it all. Then the next morning I hike up to that thing and I think I, I now I don't know. Now I'm doubting it, but I hiked up. I just wanted to see the sunrise because so many things had happened. There was actually three things in succession that happened.

And the other one is just real quick.

Payne Lindsey03:27:05

Mm-hmm.

Shawn Ryan03:27:06

My best friend, Gabe McCarty, he died and he was always, he was a SEAL. He was a contract for the agency and then, and then kind of succumbed to an addiction later on in life. And but when he was well, he was always known as a protector. He was also a pro hockey player. It was an enforcer.

Payne Lindsey03:27:29

Protector. Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:27:31

Goes to the SEAL team. Everybody knows Gabe will handle shit. You know, if they need him to, goes to the agency. Same reputation. And I kept seeing this guy that looked exactly like Gabe all throughout the week.

Payne Lindsey03:27:44

Just like everywhere I would go.

Shawn Ryan03:27:45

Everywhere I would go or something.

Payne Lindsey03:27:46

Just like that.

Shawn Ryan03:27:47

Out in town, on a hike.

Payne Lindsey03:27:48

That's kind of weird too.

Shawn Ryan03:27:49

At the resort.

Payne Lindsey03:27:50

Like a doppelganger kind of thing.

Shawn Ryan03:27:51

All week.

Payne Lindsey03:27:52

That's weird.

Shawn Ryan03:27:53

I walked to my room and I realized this dude is staying on the other side of the duplex is me.

Payne Lindsey03:28:00

Like a, yeah, that's, that's the kind of stuff where I'm like, yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:28:05

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:28:06

Because you probably did a real double take there a couple times. We were like, wait.

Shawn Ryan03:28:09

My wife noticed. We saw him at the minute we checked in. I was like, holy shit, that guy looks like Gabe.

Payne Lindsey03:28:14

So what do you make of that?

Shawn Ryan03:28:16

I mean, these, I think it's all like, I think it is all an unveil into I think it is an undeniable experience catered to me to bring me back to Christ. That's what I think.

Payne Lindsey03:28:30

It sounded positive, right? It sounded like it was.

Shawn Ryan03:28:33

In a very, in a very, you know, emotional, vulnerable state. Like I broke down on the plane ride there, dude. I'm not a guy that breaks down. Like I don't feel much emotion other than anger. And it's just kind of the symptoms of.

Payne Lindsey03:28:54

No, I mean you.

Shawn Ryan03:28:55

My previous life.

Payne Lindsey03:28:56

You're, yes.

Shawn Ryan03:28:57

And so, and I'm there searching for answers like, oh, let's go. Maybe I'll feel something at this energy vortex. You know what I mean? Maybe that's what I'm, it's all about energy and all this worldly shit, feathers and whatever.

Payne Lindsey03:29:10

Interesting that you're looking over here.

Shawn Ryan03:29:12

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:29:12

Like you, you know.

Shawn Ryan03:29:13

And then it was like, it was like a, it was like, hey, send him the signals, you know? And it got my attention, dude. And then it drew me in like, like quick.

Payne Lindsey03:29:28

What do you think made you like able to receive that? Looking back on that, do you think it was just like a moment that was right for you? Like you said, like a curated experience where it delivered to you all the signs that you needed to know and feel and see? Or like for someone who hasn't ever experienced something like that, whatever it is, would you, I mean, besides asking for it literally, because you didn't in that moment.

Shawn Ryan03:29:54

No, I was not looking for that.

Payne Lindsey03:29:55

Right. Which that, that's interesting to me. It's like it came, I guess when you needed it or I guess you were still, you were open to it enough, I guess.

Shawn Ryan03:30:03

I wasn't really open to it.

Payne Lindsey03:30:04

But you still, you remained.

Shawn Ryan03:30:07

It's, what's interesting is I was searching for something.

Payne Lindsey03:30:10

Okay. Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:30:11

But that was not it.

Payne Lindsey03:30:12

Yes.

Shawn Ryan03:30:13

Like we went to Sedona because I wanted to go to those energy vortexes and see if I felt anything. And it wasn't that. We went to a bunch of them. I didn't feel shit, nothing. You know what I mean?

Payne Lindsey03:30:27

Crystals didn't work.

Shawn Ryan03:30:28

Yeah. We went to the crystal shop. We, I went and like did some psychedelic stuff. I like, dude, I was open, I went to a medium or not a medium, whatever, what do they call it? A psychic. Like I did all that shit on that trip.

Payne Lindsey03:30:44

And so all these things, they didn't.

Shawn Ryan03:30:46

Nothing.

Payne Lindsey03:30:46

Move the needle for you.

Shawn Ryan03:30:47

No. And then at the very last day, all that stuff happens.

Payne Lindsey03:30:52

So you were on this, the journey, you were searching for whatever it was.

Shawn Ryan03:30:57

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:30:57

I mean, it found you or you found it.

Shawn Ryan03:30:59

Searching in the wrong places.

Payne Lindsey03:31:01

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:31:01

It stumbled in. Like I don't think it was an accident. I think it was, it was, it was, it saved me, dude.

Payne Lindsey03:31:16

In what way? Do you feel like your, your purpose or your understanding of.

Shawn Ryan03:31:22

It brought me in. It's, it saved my soul, I think. It led me to like everything that's going on today in my life. And, and like it grabbed my attention and it put me on a, on a, on a new path because that, for me personally, you know what I mean? I don't give a shit what anybody else's opinions are, but for that to me, to happen to me, and that all happened within 15 minutes, you know?

And it was an undeniable experience that was obviously set up by a higher power for me to experience to save my soul.

Payne Lindsey03:32:04

Does it scare you thinking about your life before that? Or like when you were lost looking for something? Or.

Shawn Ryan03:32:12

It scares me for other people.

Payne Lindsey03:32:14

Okay.

Shawn Ryan03:32:14

That shut it out.

Payne Lindsey03:32:17

So how do you not shut it out then?

Shawn Ryan03:32:20

What do you mean shut what out?

Payne Lindsey03:32:21

I don't know. I mean like, how do I make sure I'm not too closed off to never see the signs of something? I mean, I'm being serious.

Shawn Ryan03:32:31

Yeah. I think you, I think you just got to be open to it, man.

Payne Lindsey03:32:36

Right.

Shawn Ryan03:32:37

Like one thing about me.

Payne Lindsey03:32:38

Even you weren't open to it. But you were searching, I guess. So.

Shawn Ryan03:32:42

I'm always looking to do good in the world.

Payne Lindsey03:32:45

Okay.

Shawn Ryan03:32:46

And so.

Payne Lindsey03:32:47

So that was always a constant anyway.

Shawn Ryan03:32:48

Yeah. And even though maybe I didn't believe in God and I definitely had no interest in Christ or the Bible or any of the teachings or anything.

Payne Lindsey03:32:59

Interesting.

Shawn Ryan03:32:59

You know, I was always like, I've always been passionate about standing up for the underdog.

Payne Lindsey03:33:06

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:33:06

You know, at that particular point in time and still today, a big passion of mine is kids that have been sexually abused or exploited.

Payne Lindsey03:33:17

Yep.

Shawn Ryan03:33:17

And, and that's just something that I like, that'll probably be a lifelong fight.

Payne Lindsey03:33:22

Did you ever work with Nick McAll?

Shawn Ryan03:33:24

No. Who's that?

Payne Lindsey03:33:25

The National, I'm going to mess it up. National Center, Nick, National Center for Missing and Exploited Children. John Walsh, like the.

Shawn Ryan03:33:38

Oh.

Payne Lindsey03:33:38

Mexicans Wanted, he started that. It's a legit, I mean, you should definitely know them. But like they, they like, they have a, actually a really cool facility in DC that has every single agency inside the building, like all of them. And a designated officer and they, they, you know, scrub the internet of like child porn and like, like just do a bunch of like digital stuff. And yeah, it's kind of incredible.

I had no clue this was as big as it was, but I got to tour it recently.

Shawn Ryan03:34:16

Oh, that's awesome.

Payne Lindsey03:34:17

It was really, I mean, impressive that this guy, I mean, John Walsh's son went missing and was ultimately murdered by these.

Shawn Ryan03:34:27

Yeah. Familiar.

Payne Lindsey03:34:28

Horrendous people. And this is what he turned all of that into, which was pretty, I mean, amazing.

Shawn Ryan03:34:36

Yeah. So that's a bit, so I've just always been, I just always want to do good. And, but my, my beliefs, you know, weren't in line. And so.

Payne Lindsey03:34:51

But you had that sort of, like you were, I don't know, I'm like, I'm thinking like a higher power and I'm like, you had everything else, but maybe the, the, the final direction or something like that. Like you already had built into you, like this guy is someone who already values doing good for people and has what it takes. It's tough enough to stand up to this kind of bad shit in the world or something, right?

Shawn Ryan03:35:26

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:35:27

Which I mean, I have no explanation.

Shawn Ryan03:35:30

Yeah. I.

Payne Lindsey03:35:31

I have no explanation.

Shawn Ryan03:35:32

I don't think that you need to.

Payne Lindsey03:35:33

Why it would have happened.

Shawn Ryan03:35:34

Even provide one. I think it's definitely special.

Payne Lindsey03:35:41

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:35:41

Like that's not, and the fact that it has impacted your life ever since then and wasn't just a weird series of events is to me like a, I mean, there's your proof.

Payne Lindsey03:36:00

That's all the proof I needed.

Shawn Ryan03:36:01

You know what I mean?

Payne Lindsey03:36:02

I got plenty more proof at this point.

Shawn Ryan03:36:03

Yeah, no, but I'm fascinated by it. I feel like I've, I've been close to stuff like that, but I've never had a profound experience like that. If I did, I would absolutely, it would definitely impact me probably.

Payne Lindsey03:36:16

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:36:17

In a profound way.

Payne Lindsey03:36:20

Well, I hope you do have one.

Shawn Ryan03:36:22

I do too now.

Payne Lindsey03:36:25

Wasn't it scary a little bit though?

Shawn Ryan03:36:27

Yeah, it scares the hell out of you.

Payne Lindsey03:36:29

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:36:29

But it also just makes you happy, man. Because you know, you know whatever, you know what it all is now. Even though you don't know much, you know where you're going and you know, like you just know what you, you know your beliefs are solid, you know? And there's a lot more to know and.

Payne Lindsey03:36:52

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:36:52

And like I don't, I don't think it ever ends, you know? But, but it's, it definitely brings a certain peace over you.

Payne Lindsey03:37:02

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:37:02

And, and I, I like I still continue to learn, like it's, you know, I just now, and then I got all, I got super deep into politics and all this other shit.

Payne Lindsey03:37:13

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:37:13

And now like I don't really care about any of that shit because I look at all these people who are looking for the next guy to fix shit.

Payne Lindsey03:37:28

Right.

Shawn Ryan03:37:29

Whether it's.

Payne Lindsey03:37:30

And we do that every four years.

Shawn Ryan03:37:31

Yeah. You know what I mean? But it's like after this last one, it's, you know, you know.

Payne Lindsey03:37:39

Felt duped?

Shawn Ryan03:37:40

Oh man.

Payne Lindsey03:37:41

We're not felt duped. We're duped.

Shawn Ryan03:37:43

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:37:44

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:37:45

And, and I think a lot of people before this one on the other side felt duped. Now I know I'm like, there are no sides. It doesn't matter who gets put in there.

Payne Lindsey03:37:54

Yeah. I always ask like people, I mean, I, I also stay out of politics, but I'm like, who's your favorite president? And like not a current one, like that changed your life. And some people might, may have some real stories.

Shawn Ryan03:38:07

Yeah, maybe.

Payne Lindsey03:38:08

It's true. But everyone I've asked doesn't.

Shawn Ryan03:38:11

I don't.

Payne Lindsey03:38:12

You know what I'm saying? Like what did they change about your life? And I'm, I'm, I'm asking it not as a rhetorical question. I'm hoping to eventually hear somebody say, well, this president changed my life in this way, but I never hear those stories.

Shawn Ryan03:38:29

Me neither.

Payne Lindsey03:38:30

You know what I mean?

Shawn Ryan03:38:32

It makes me, kind of makes me sad to see everybody get all wrapped up in it.

Payne Lindsey03:38:36

Right. Like it's almost like a false hope that we recycle every.

Shawn Ryan03:38:40

You're going to waste all this time and energy researching.

Payne Lindsey03:38:45

You've already done doing so much more. Like, I mean, in, in like the power of what you are able to do.

Shawn Ryan03:38:52

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:38:52

Just like by helping people, like you're saying, yourself.

Shawn Ryan03:38:57

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:38:57

You know what I mean? You don't need like someone's permission to do that or I don't know, like wait for someone to do it for you.

Shawn Ryan03:39:06

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:39:07

You know what I mean?

Shawn Ryan03:39:08

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:39:11

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:39:11

Funny ways, that's a good rabbit hole, huh?

Payne Lindsey03:39:13

That was deep. I don't know how we got there, started there.

Shawn Ryan03:39:16

UFOs.

Payne Lindsey03:39:17

It was, yeah. I mean, yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:39:20

The seraphin.

Payne Lindsey03:39:21

I don't know. That, that, that, your story is going to stick with me for a while. I'm, and I'm going to tell my friend Mike about it because we've, we've had conversations like about this, you know? And I don't know. I think it's, yeah, I mean, I'm not religious like that, but also I'm not like anti or like whatever.

Shawn Ryan03:39:46

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:39:46

But like when I hear a story like that, I feel like that's true.

Shawn Ryan03:39:56

Poke around a little bit.

Payne Lindsey03:39:58

You know what I mean?

Shawn Ryan03:39:58

If you're an investigator, poke around a little bit, see what happens.

Payne Lindsey03:40:01

Mm-hmm.

Shawn Ryan03:40:02

You know, I think you just got to be open to it.

Payne Lindsey03:40:04

Mm-hmm.

Shawn Ryan03:40:05

But, and there's all kinds of stuff, man. Like you're confirmed Catholic.

Payne Lindsey03:40:09

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:40:10

I'm sure Boston's got some beautiful cathedrals.

Payne Lindsey03:40:12

Oh, they have some beautiful, yeah, absolutely.

Shawn Ryan03:40:14

Go to a weekday mass. They're like.

Payne Lindsey03:40:15

Mm-hmm.

Shawn Ryan03:40:15

They're like 25 minutes and just whatever's on your mind.

Payne Lindsey03:40:20

Mm-hmm.

Shawn Ryan03:40:21

Like I've had times recently, I've had times, I went and did a psychedelic experience. I mean, I was using for therapy. I'll never use it again.

Payne Lindsey03:40:37

It's too duped.

Shawn Ryan03:40:38

After this last experience.

Payne Lindsey03:40:39

It's too duped?

Shawn Ryan03:40:40

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:40:40

I'm afraid to do it.

Shawn Ryan03:40:41

I had like a hell experience. And because once again, I was looking for answers.

Payne Lindsey03:40:46

Yep.

Shawn Ryan03:40:47

Like I had this, that, what I told you happened years ago and I started looking for answers again through other methods.

Payne Lindsey03:40:53

Mm-hmm.

Shawn Ryan03:40:54

And, and I was shown hell. And I thought that meant I was.

Payne Lindsey03:40:59

You were shown hell.

Shawn Ryan03:41:00

Yeah. I was, I thought that meant that I was going to hell.

Payne Lindsey03:41:03

Yeah, that's what I would think too.

Shawn Ryan03:41:05

And, and I was wondering why I was in hell. And I thought during the experience, and I thought I was like, am I, like I believe in forgiveness and confession and all that, you know, whether it's confessed to a priest or you.

Payne Lindsey03:41:24

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:41:24

Or whoever.

Payne Lindsey03:41:25

Yeah, yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:41:26

And or just out loud.

Payne Lindsey03:41:29

Yeah, just like the.

Shawn Ryan03:41:29

I've done a lot of bad shit.

Payne Lindsey03:41:30

Accountability, even just ownership of something. Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:41:32

Done a ton of bad shit and horrible shit in my life. And, but I didn't feel like it was any of that. And then I had this thought pop in my head, maybe I'm here because I, maybe I love my wife and kids more than I love Christ. Because that's not the, that's, it's supposed to be, you know, Christ.

Payne Lindsey03:41:54

That came to your head though.

Shawn Ryan03:41:55

Yeah. I was like, maybe that's why I'm here.

Payne Lindsey03:41:57

Right.

Shawn Ryan03:41:58

And this was debilitating. Like I went home.

Payne Lindsey03:42:01

You felt like a weight of something or like a.

Shawn Ryan03:42:03

Dude, it was the worst experience of my life.

Payne Lindsey03:42:04

Like a guilt or like a.

Shawn Ryan03:42:06

It was, I was just trying to figure out why I was.

Payne Lindsey03:42:09

Like what is, what is happening? Also, what does hell look like?

Shawn Ryan03:42:12

It looks like nothing.

Payne Lindsey03:42:15

Like a void?

Shawn Ryan03:42:17

Not fire. It's nothing. It's nothing.

Payne Lindsey03:42:21

A dark room?

Shawn Ryan03:42:21

It's no love. It's no, it's anxiety and fear and black.

Payne Lindsey03:42:27

But you just, but you knew it was hell when you were looking at it? That's scary.

Shawn Ryan03:42:33

But I couldn't, I couldn't like, it's the worst shit I've ever felt in my life.

Payne Lindsey03:42:40

Wow.

Shawn Ryan03:42:40

And it just felt like I was there for eternity. And so that popped up, that thought like flashed through my head like, am I here because I love my wife and kids more than Christ? Anyways, I'm really dubbing this one down. I'll send you some shit if you want to.

Payne Lindsey03:42:56

Send me some link, yes.

Shawn Ryan03:42:57

But, because I actually recorded that entire experience and never put it online.

Payne Lindsey03:43:01

You did? Oh wow.

Shawn Ryan03:43:02

Because I was, I just not ready to put it out yet. And so I come home and I'm, I just have like this overwhelming sensation like I just, I have to go to mass and get communion or something. Like I don't know what just happened.

Payne Lindsey03:43:22

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:43:24

So we go to the church and walk in and the homily, when the priest is talking and kind of explaining the scripture, it's about loving your wife and kids more than Christ.

Payne Lindsey03:43:41

This is after you fell?

Shawn Ryan03:43:43

This is after. This is the.

Payne Lindsey03:43:44

Okay. Yep. So yeah, that was a, beyond a bizarre coincidence, I'd say.

Shawn Ryan03:43:55

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:43:56

On the, on the nose.

Shawn Ryan03:43:59

This shit happens all the time, man.

Payne Lindsey03:44:01

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:44:01

And it's like there's always these little seeds where.

Payne Lindsey03:44:05

That's what I.

Shawn Ryan03:44:06

Yeah, you're like.

Payne Lindsey03:44:06

You did like.

Shawn Ryan03:44:07

Like what?

Payne Lindsey03:44:08

100%.

Shawn Ryan03:44:09

Seriously?

Payne Lindsey03:44:09

You're right.

Shawn Ryan03:44:10

Like how many scriptures are there?

Payne Lindsey03:44:11

They are listening to my phone.

Shawn Ryan03:44:13

Yeah. But I'm just like, wow.

Payne Lindsey03:44:20

No, that's incredible.

Shawn Ryan03:44:21

You know, I'm like, wow, dude. Like, so I go like every morning.

Payne Lindsey03:44:27

Wow.

Shawn Ryan03:44:27

Now it's, I don't even want to say the time or where or anything, but like.

Payne Lindsey03:44:31

Yeah, yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:44:32

I go every single morning and it's the first thing I do every day.

Payne Lindsey03:44:38

Wow.

Shawn Ryan03:44:38

Just, but, and sometimes, you know, sometimes, I'm not going to lie, sometimes I don't get anything out of it. Sometimes I'm not present, but more and more now it is these weird bizarre coincidences that's like, okay, that's what I needed to hear.

Payne Lindsey03:44:58

Got it.

Shawn Ryan03:44:58

You know, and, and I think, I just think that the more you're drawn in, the more, the closer you allow yourself to get to it.

Payne Lindsey03:45:06

Mm-hmm.

Shawn Ryan03:45:07

You know, and you're not like, you know, it sucks being a kid going to Catholic church. I get it.

Payne Lindsey03:45:12

Oh yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:45:12

Watching my kids. I'm like, yeah, yeah, whatever.

Payne Lindsey03:45:14

It was not always the most fun.

Shawn Ryan03:45:15

For sure. But if you're open to it and you can pay attention, you know what I mean?

Payne Lindsey03:45:20

Mm-hmm.

Shawn Ryan03:45:20

And, and like you're actually looking for guidance and not trying to solve every problem yourself.

Payne Lindsey03:45:26

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:45:27

You just kind of sit with it. Like generally in my limited experience, because I'm new at this, you know, it, it, the answers come.

Payne Lindsey03:45:39

Because you allowed yourself to listen?

Shawn Ryan03:45:41

Yeah. Because you can be still.

Payne Lindsey03:45:43

Instead of solving it all yourself or.

Shawn Ryan03:45:44

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:45:45

Overriding it with some reasoning.

Shawn Ryan03:45:46

Or thinking about work. You know what I mean? All the time.

Payne Lindsey03:45:48

Right. No, for real. Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:45:50

I can tell you love what you do.

Payne Lindsey03:45:51

The next thing you got to do after this and then whatever.

Shawn Ryan03:45:53

Like I can tell you love what you do and you're probably always thinking about that.

Payne Lindsey03:45:59

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:46:00

Because I am. You know what I mean?

Payne Lindsey03:46:01

Probably too much. Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:46:02

But it's, it's, and if you're not talking about it, like you want to be talking about it and you, it's just, it's just, that's what anybody that's the best at what they do, that's what they do.

Payne Lindsey03:46:14

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:46:14

And, but if you can like just carve it out a little bit, man, you know what I mean? And be, be a little bit more open, just a little bit, like.

Payne Lindsey03:46:25

Like with that intention of, I mean, yeah, listening, right? Or like pause, like is there like a, a pausing of, and like letting it, I don't know. It's like a stillness. I, I'm like getting away, you're describing it, where it's like, okay, like all this grind, but then it's like, hey, shh, like it sounds like these moments happened when you were, there were quiet moments that were loud inside or something.

Shawn Ryan03:46:57

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:46:58

And they were like more still.

Shawn Ryan03:47:01

Mm-hmm.

Payne Lindsey03:47:03

You were able to receive it and then it landed that way or something. And then it immediately applied to something in your life. And then instead of turning the other way, you, I don't know, leaned in maybe? I don't know.

Shawn Ryan03:47:17

Yeah, man. I mean, I'm, I'm pretty close now.

Payne Lindsey03:47:21

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:47:21

I mean, like I'm, I'm drawn in. I know, I know what this is all about.

Payne Lindsey03:47:26

That's cool to me because I, I don't, I mean, all the stories I usually hear, it's like the youth group camps I went to or something as a kid.

Shawn Ryan03:47:35

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:47:35

Where I'm like, this guy sucks.

Shawn Ryan03:47:37

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:47:38

You know what I'm saying?

Shawn Ryan03:47:39

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:47:39

Like he's probably like.

Shawn Ryan03:47:40

I can't relate to that.

Payne Lindsey03:47:40

Like you should probably check his record or something.

Shawn Ryan03:47:45

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:47:46

But no, like it's cool. Because I, I can, I can picture that. I can see that having a, like a similar impact on me and just like in a relatable kind of way. Like, yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:48:05

I think you have to find it yourself.

Payne Lindsey03:48:07

Absolutely.

Shawn Ryan03:48:08

I mean, I don't, I don't think you can go and like.

Payne Lindsey03:48:10

There's not a.

Shawn Ryan03:48:10

Start talking to people. Like I think it's good to start talking to people and it keeps you open, but like it, it's, I don't know, for somebody as hardheaded as I am, that's, that's just what it would have taken. You know what I mean?

Payne Lindsey03:48:23

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:48:23

You could talk to me about it.

Payne Lindsey03:48:24

The crystals were not going to cut it.

Shawn Ryan03:48:26

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:48:28

You had to take those back.

Shawn Ryan03:48:29

All, all that stuff, dude. You know what I mean? All that stuff. Like it just, and that's like, that's what drew me out of the alien shit. That's what drew me out of psychedelic stuff eventually.

Payne Lindsey03:48:41

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:48:41

That's what drew me out of energy vortexes and crystals and all the feathers and.

Payne Lindsey03:48:48

Does it all make sense to you now in like a, a different sort of coexistence or something? Like without having to like literally explain it.

Shawn Ryan03:48:59

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:48:59

It just all fit together or something for you?

Shawn Ryan03:49:03

I mean, it's still like, it's in my not, you know, it's just still growing.

Payne Lindsey03:49:07

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:49:07

But, you know, but now I just, I know what it is. I know there's no, I just, you know, answers just.

Payne Lindsey03:49:14

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:49:14

I know it's a waste of time to put your faith in a fucking guy that's going to fix everything for the country or the world.

Payne Lindsey03:49:20

Yeah, no, you're not wrong.

Shawn Ryan03:49:21

Or anything. You know what I mean?

Payne Lindsey03:49:22

I, I agree.

Shawn Ryan03:49:23

Like we are flawed. Human beings are flawed and they always will be and they always were.

Payne Lindsey03:49:28

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:49:28

And nobody's going to fix this shit. Like you are going to be the, you know, the piece that you create for yourself and the only way you're going to find that is through Christ.

Payne Lindsey03:49:40

Amazing.

Shawn Ryan03:49:41

Your own way, you know?

Payne Lindsey03:49:42

Yeah, right.

Shawn Ryan03:49:43

Not, not from what I'm telling you.

Payne Lindsey03:49:45

It might be, yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:49:47

Like you have to be hungry for the answers.

Payne Lindsey03:49:50

Yeah. You were searching. So that's, that's also a component. You weren't like being lazy or ignorant about some filling something or finding something.

Shawn Ryan03:50:04

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:50:04

You were like, if anything, trying too many things.

Shawn Ryan03:50:07

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:50:07

But hey, you, every one you tried, you're like, nope, nope, nope. And like that was probably the combination of like all this shit's stupid. And then that, I mean, I would imagine for me that hitting me in a time where, yeah, it would have landed like an answer.

Shawn Ryan03:50:31

Who knows where else I would have gone? There's all kinds of stuff I didn't, you know, do. I mean, but there's all kinds of, you know, other beliefs and occult stuff and, you know, who knows, man.

Payne Lindsey03:50:45

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:50:45

But it got me, got me when it needed me or when I, when I needed it, you know? And, and, yeah. Anyways.

Payne Lindsey03:50:56

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:50:56

Good stuff.

Payne Lindsey03:50:57

Good stuff, man. I did not see it going there. I really, I really didn't, but I'm not mad that it did though. It's, I mean, it's.

Shawn Ryan03:51:07

Well, I can tell you're thinking about it.

Payne Lindsey03:51:08

No, I know. I am. I'm going to, I'm just going to be a, yeah. Yeah. My mom's going to see this and like, see, I told you.

Shawn Ryan03:51:20

Yeah. Oh man, that's cool.

Payne Lindsey03:51:24

Yeah.

Shawn Ryan03:51:24

What do you got coming up?

Payne Lindsey03:51:26

Man, "Up and Vanished" is going to be a year-round show. And I mean, in the last 10 years, there are dozens of cases that I've been involved in and not all of them have ever even been shared with everybody. There's investigations I've been a part of, stuff I've recorded, other encounters with suspects and persons of interest.

And so in the same sort of investigative style that you may be used to getting, if you turn on any season of "Up and Vanished," I'm trying to give you a version of that all year round without, you know, dumbing it down. Actually, instead of doing a retelling of a horrible thing that happened one time, I'm opening the line of communication, sharing, you know, new information, exposing people and corruption and suspects, and also kind of just putting it out in the ether and creating an internet dialogue about it.

And also being able to turn "Up and Vanished" into a platform that can cover more cases that people send me.

Shawn Ryan03:52:56

Absolutely.

Payne Lindsey03:52:56

Because there's so many, there's thousands. And it feels like, it feels weird sometimes that there's so many emails that I can't even like respond to everybody appropriately. And I wish I had an amazing answer for everybody, but this at least kind of opens the door to expand my investigative reporting.

Shawn Ryan03:53:20

Yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:53:20

And also do more visual stuff. Because a lot of stuff we've filmed and, you know, go knock on some more doors and.

Shawn Ryan03:53:30

Any particular case that you're looking into that you're, that's coming out soon?

Payne Lindsey03:53:34

There's, I'm first going to take people through some disappearances that I, I covered a couple years ago that I never released a lot of the material on. One of them is a woman, she was actually, she was born on my birthday, or she disappeared on my birthday, like my actual birthday, November 21st, 1987. And she disappeared with her daughter and the husband is the number one suspect.

And it's, I mean, law enforcement just doesn't have the bodies, there is not a lot of physical evidence, but they've all signaled that they think this is the guy. His two estranged sons reached out to me a few years ago and we went and drove to his house in Florida unannounced. And the sons went, went to the door first and they literally just said, "Hey, Dad, we're your sons."

And he's like, "Holy shit. This is crazy." And they go inside, they're all mic'd up and I'm in the car listening and I'm texting them. And eventually they say, "Well, Dad, we want you to meet somebody." It was like a Chris Hansen style.

Shawn Ryan03:54:55

Holy shit.

Payne Lindsey03:54:55

Walk in, I had, and I walk in there and he, he talks to me for at least an hour and I'm, I'm filming it on my phone and he says some really, really strange things that only a guilty person would say, in my opinion. And there is a moment where, I mean, I was kind of posturing a little bit. I was just trying to like rattle the cage a touch. And I, I, I wanted to give him the impression for a second if he could pick up on it that the cops are outside right now.

Like not literally.

Shawn Ryan03:55:31

Yeah, yeah.

Payne Lindsey03:55:32

But I was like just saying stuff like, yeah, I mean, the police have done a couple pawn searches recently, which was true. And I don't know, it seems like they're, they're getting pretty close to something. I mean, they're, this seems like the closest they've ever been. And he, he gets up and he's nervous and he's like holding his coffee cup and he goes to reheat it. I'm like, which is good news, right? He's like, "Oh yeah, that's, that's great news."

And I'm like, he, like he thinks, I mean, in hindsight, I was watching, I was like, he totally thought that the cops were about to come in here. And I'm like, unfortunately, they weren't there and there was not any evidence to prosecute this guy yet. But I mean, his own sons are here saying, "We think you killed Mom." So, and our sister.

Shawn Ryan03:56:26

That is heavy.

Payne Lindsey03:56:27

Mm-hmm. So a lot of these feel like unfinished business to me. And they're brand new to someone who didn't even know about this at all. And I feel like some of the material I have, if I put it out, it can maybe spark some, some movement in some of these cases or some pressure or somebody saying the wrong thing and finally getting caught up in their lies. And that, that's the hope. And if not, it's going to be a spotlight for other unsolved cases and a way of expanding.

Shawn Ryan03:57:01

Man, you got a hell of a story, dude.

Payne Lindsey03:57:04

Thanks, man.

Shawn Ryan03:57:05

It's like.

Payne Lindsey03:57:05

Thanks, man. I did not see this, it going this way. I thought I was just going to make a podcast, you know? But, yeah, I didn't set out to investigate anything, to be honest.

Shawn Ryan03:57:16

It's pretty awesome. I'm proud to know you. I'm glad we met.

Payne Lindsey03:57:19

Thanks, man. Likewise. Cheers, dude.

Shawn Ryan03:57:20

All right, cheers.

Payne Lindsey03:57:21

I appreciate it.

Speaker 303:57:22

Thanks a lot.

Shawn Ryan03:57:34

No matter where you're watching the Sean Ryan Show from, if you get anything out of this at all, anything, please like, comment, and subscribe. And most importantly, share this everywhere you possibly can. And if you're feeling extra generous, head to Apple Podcasts and Spotify and leave us a review.

Episode description

Payne Lindsey is a filmmaker, podcast host, and co-founder of Tenderfoot TV, best known for co-creating and hosting the true-crime podcast Up and Vanished. His investigation into the disappearance of Georgia teacher Tara Grinstead brought renewed attention to the long-unsolved case and launched his career in investigative podcasting. He also hosts Atlanta Monster and Radio Rental, and his work has expanded into television through Oxygen’s Up and Vanished series.

Shawn Ryan Show Sponsors:

Privacy Isn't Paranoia. It's Protection. Download Glacier - https://theglacierapp.com

Try ZipRecruiter for FREE today at https://ziprecruiter.com/SRS to find the right people for your roles, seasonal or otherwise.

Become a Defender today and donate to partner with the Tim Tebow Foundation to help rescue children. https://timtebowfoundation.org

Protect your family with life insurance from Ethos. Get up to $3 million in coverage in as little as 10 minutes at https://ethos.com/SRS. Application times may vary. Rates may vary. Trustpilot rating as of 8/1/2026.

Take advantage of HexClad’s Best Sale of the Year and GET UP TO 52% Off by going to https://hexclad.com/SRS #hexcladpartner

Try Gusto today at https://gusto.com/SRS and get three months free when you run your first payroll.

Start your free trial at https://shopify.com/srs

Payne Lindsey Links:

Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/paynelindsey

X - https://x.com/paynelindsey

Tenderfoot TV - https://tenderfoot.tv

Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/tenderfoot.tv

Youtube - https://www.youtube.com/@tenderfoottv
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices