This episode of The Dan Le Batard Show mixes office gossip with sports debate. The hosts argue over who drank the last of Dan's oat milk in the kitchen, then debate whether black beans beat other beans.
Guest A.W. Hawkins shares NFL stories about punctuality, and the group discusses the Miami Dolphins' quarterback situation, Justin Herbert's reputation, and how well NFL teams evaluate talent.
They also cover the Miami Heat's strong start led by Giannis Antetokounmpo. Opinions are personal and often playful, so listeners hear several contested claims presented as debate rather than settled fact.
In this episode Dan Le Batard, Greg Cote, A.W. Hawkins
This Dan Le Batard Show episode about the Miami Dolphins' quarterback and the Miami Heat was made with HappyScribe technology built to convert audio files to text.
Ads in this audio differ from the text. Tap the sentence you're hearing to follow along.
Synced: the text now follows the audio.
Chris, do you know why your father's late again today?
Ugh, traffic. And he's going to blame traffic, but really, last week he came on a day where there was no traffic, so he just thinks, "Oh, last week there was no traffic because it was Veterans Day on Wednesday, so I can just leave late every day." He's annoying, Dan.
Uh, Hawk, how often during your playing career were you late to anything?
One time I got a flat tire on the way to a game. I was not late, but that was the closest I ever even came to being late.
What really happened?
I was like 15 minutes early.
What really happened, though?
Nothing, nothing.
Come on.
I mean, I would never be. In the NFL? I would rather get in a, like, literally force a car accident than to show up to an NFL training facility late.
So if you're running late to a practice, you just barrel into the car in front of you?
Literally, you hit a mailbox. So have you ever seen, like, players like, "Oh, he hit a mailbox," or there's like at least a 50% chance they were late and were like, "I need an excuse," because you can't just show up and be like, "I was late."
I'm late, I got a crash in my car!
Literally. You think it's so serious? If you show up even a minute before the meeting, people will look at you like, "Bro, what happened? You alright? Is everything okay?"
Trista, in your entire history in the media or consuming media, have you ever been watching a program of any sort and one of the hosts wanders onto the set late? In all of the entertainment you've consumed in your life?
I worked at Barstool Sports. That was, like, a part of the whole shtick. It was like, "Lean in. That's the Barstool difference. We're just not a real company. We don't do real things. We're slapdics."
I don't believe that that is their—
Is that the slogan?
—that is their slogan. But I'm talking about mainstream media, because Barstool is sort of sloppy by design.
I've never done mainstream media, and can you tell? Like, they don't want me around.
You've watched a lot of mainstream media. Have you ever been watching television and somebody comes in? Because what's also going to happen here, he's going to make a loud—there are going to be a lot of loud sounds with him setting up, like awkward sounds, opening of things, you know, computers and phones beeping. It's not just that he's going to walk in late. He's going to walk in late as a tornado of distractions.
There was that one time on First Take where Stephen A was late and they picked him up, like, walking the dock at the Seaport site, strolling in, like, not even a rush, just walking his way in. But he was late.
I mean, he was late once.
It happens around here.
Yeah, I was going to say, is this mainstream media, by the way? Because this is not—
It comes from mainstream media.
Also, Hawk, you walked in a minute before the show.
Did I?
Yes.
That studio.
Like, this studio?
Yes, just now.
Is that late?
Yeah.
Oh, wow. Okay, that's different. In the NFL, you show up at 6:00 a.m., the meeting starts at 9:00. As long as you're in the building, you're good.
Well, I'm not very good about setting firm boundaries. I'm actually going to save this for the main show because something happened yesterday that I just can't believe happened here, and I want to talk about it.
Greg Cody is late again. I'm sure he will come in very quietly and subtly and discreetly and not offer anything in the way of distraction whenever he does arrive. I do not have a firm set of rules and standards here, so I want to ask you, Hawk, how I should feel about something that happened yesterday here. I walk into our eating area, otherwise known as the kitchen, and—
A lot of people call it that, but go ahead.
—as I'm walking in there, I see that Rose is looking at me and she's got a totally horrified look on her face. And then I look around and the other people all around her also have a horrified look on their face, and I'm like, "What happened?" And she looks at me and she says, "I drank the last of your milk," because I was going over there to get coffee and now I couldn't have my coffee because it didn't have milk. And before I left for New York, like, that is one set of things, but before I left for New York, there were several bottles of my allergen-sort-of-free milk that were in the fridge that have my name on them.
Like, it just says Dan's Milk with a Post-it on it, which means that she drank the last of the milk, but only after everybody else was drinking the rest of the milk. So it's not just that she drank the last. Like, she got caught, but it couldn't have been just her unless she was just drinking it straight from the carton for the few days that I was gone. So both how am I supposed to feel about that and what am I supposed to do about that? Because I don't know how much clearer it can be made than a Post-it that clearly has, "Don't touch this milk.
It's Dan's milk because he's got certain allergies and he can't eat and drink normal things."
Are you asking, like, my actual advice, or are you asking how should you handle this from an NFL perspective?
Well, how are those two things different?
Well, you got to fight more people at work. In the NFL, that's just how it happens, man. You don't get respect, you take respect, okay? When things are mine, when that's my soap, you don't touch my soap. And if you touch my soap, we fight. And then the winner knows, "Okay, I won't have any more issues with the soap."
So your advice is for me to fight Rose?
I think you figure out who else drank your medicated milk. And I didn't know they made prescription milk.
It's not medicated milk.
What does that mean, medicated? You're picking it up from, like, CVS?
Yeah, I don't know. It's a special prescription milk, apparently. What is it for?
It's just oat milk because I can't have dairy. So it's not medicated milk.
Oh, okay. I thought it was, like, prescription, very specific milk that only you can—the only kind of milk you can drink.
Like milk of magnesia or something.
Something. You know what I mean? Like, oat milk is okay. I could see that being a little more communal than maybe anticipated.
Why did you choose oat milk?
Because I can't have almond milk or soy milk either.
So you literally can't have anything.
Can't have milk.
I mean, because oat is really, like, the worst of the alternative milks in terms of health.
But it's the only one I can have because I can't have any of the other milks, and that's why I just—I didn't want to get caught in these particular weeds, which is what—
They're important, though.
—well, it's why I said allergen-free milk, thinking I would get away with that, but then it became medicated milk and it became an assortment of other things, when it's just oat milk because I can't have any of the other milks.
Yeah. Well, I mean, the milk in question should not have been drinking. Drinking.
Drinking?
Drinking?
Drunk?
Drunk?
Drink?
Drunk?
Drunk?
Regardless, you got to put your foot down. You do have a problem with boundaries because if it says Dan's Milk and that doesn't do anything for anybody, then that's a you issue. That's not a team issue.
Really?
Yeah, absolutely.
So you believe—let me go through some of the coaches you had. Well, briefly at the end, briefly at the end, you were with the Patriots.
Yes.
Very briefly.
Very briefly, yeah.
So you're saying that if—
A literal cup of coffee with milk.
Okay, so a literal cup of—you didn't have a literal cup of coffee with the Patriots.
Yeah.
But if you had gone to the fridge and seen a fridge.
All right, I'm ready.
—an item, okay, we'll get to you in a second.
Good distraction.
But if you had seen, just to be clear on what you're saying, you go to the fridge and it says Bill Belichick's Milk.
Yes.
And you drink some of Bill Belichick's Milk, and then you explain to him afterward, that's a you problem. You have to set boundaries. That's not a me problem. That's a you problem, Bill. That's what you're arguing right now.
Yes, pretty much. Pretty much. And I mean, I wouldn't expect the person who had the milk to explain that to Bill, but when Bill asked one of his coaching buddies or his coordinator, he asked Brian Flores, like, "What's going on here?" Flores is going to be like, "This is a you problem, Bill. The fact that it said Bill Belichick's Milk and Andrew Hawkins walked over here from the Cleveland Browns and drank all of your prescription milk, that's a you problem."
Both times. Like, the fact that you have to use prescription milk is a you problem, and the fact that you can't stop him from drinking your milk is a you problem.
Only betas allow players to drink their milk. If you were a true alpha man.
Alpha? Wish someone was a true alpha man.
First of all, if you were—
Don't touch my milk.
An alpha man, you could drink real milk. You know what I mean?
Yeah, stop.
Even if you couldn't drink it. Alpha males have stomachs they can handle.
Well, like that whole milk.
Cow milk.
2%.
Only beta or theta men have to drink almond and, like, can't even have soy or almond. Hypothetically, if you could only drink oat milk, you are clearly not an alpha male. And then you let a—drink your milk, and you didn't do anything at all to set the line. They came in and they said, "He's not going to do shit."
Yeah.
I do have a food question, though, as a non-Latina that I've been thinking about for, like, months. Whenever I came in here last, I was thinking about it literally for weeks. Is there a difference between black beans? Like, is there?
What?
And any other black beans? Like, you said you only go to this one place for your black beans, and I was like, "How much better could they be?"
So black beans are better than all the other beans, and Cuban black beans are better than all the other ethnicities cook black beans. So that's what I would argue.
So why are black beans better?
It's just all of it with rice is richer, and I would say.
They dance better?
It's the most delicate of the beans. Unfortunately, I can't have those either.
Better athletes.
And the story that I have regarding that is my body is so sensitive.
Musically inclined.
To certain things that don't match with my body that I had something that had a single black bean. And remember when I claimed here on the show and a lot of people objected, I said, "I don't fart, really," because when my body.
I know, it feels so good.
When my body eats the wrong thing, it immediately knows when I have any of the wrong ingredients. And I had a single black bean, and my body told me because I could not stop farting.
One black bean?
Yes. Valerie makes fun of me still because it was a single.
I don't believe that.
Okay, you don't have to believe that.
I don't fart.
No, no.
Come on, no.
When I eat the correct ingredients, I don't fart. When I've had the wrong ingredients, what happens to me is my body immediately tells me by having either acid reflux, burpiness, or farting. That's what ends up happening. You guys don't have a preferred bean, and you guys don't believe that black beans are better than the other beans. You guys are willing to nominate another bean.
Yeah, pinto.
Put it on the poll.
Pinto beans.
Put it on the poll at Le Batard. Is the black bean the best of all the beans, yes or no?
They're bigger.
Are they?
They're blacker.
Black beans and pinto beans are like the same size.
Yeah, they are. That's a good contribution by you. I'm glad we waited for it. Why are you late today?
I'm the bean king. I love beans more than anybody. Otherwise, lima beans suck.
And you can't prove that.
What, that I like beans better than anybody?
Yeah.
Oh, you go in my cupboard, you see a million beans. Lentils?
It's a lie.
Lentil beans I love. Although there's controversy in the bean community about lentils. We don't want to let them in, some people. I wasn't late, actually. I was right on time.
How come there's a black man on your shirt?
Oh, boy. This is one of my heroes, Jimmy Cliff. He died last year, and I'm honoring him. Next question. Handled that with beautifully.
So he said he got here on time, even though he was clearly late. Let's show some video here.
He started early.
Of his son being furious with him as we had started without him, and he had not put his headset on, and he was having trouble communicating with his father. So he went to pantomime. He went to yelling at him, and his father strolls in when he wishes to. Speaking of my inability to set boundaries or generally my getting trampled by people, your father, who has me working for his Substack for free while we pay him around here and he doesn't write for us, I agreed to write for his Substack.
You guys saw all of the controversy around it. He requested an apology, etc., etc. He said he would leave me alone. He said I could have editorial independence. Today he wrote me with what he'd like me to write.
That's a great idea.
He wants me—it wasn't a suggestion, it was a challenge. It wasn't a request. It was not. He said he not only gave me an assignment, he gave me an assignment in which he said, "This is to challenge you." And I'm sure it was a selfless act just to make me better. I'm sure it had.
It was a challenge.
Yeah. I'm sure it has nothing to do with that it would serve him or what he would like me to write about. It's just that he'd like to challenge me to be better.
I'm there for you. I'm an idea man. I don't know if you know that or not. I'm the bean king.
That's what I thought. I thought you were the bean king. That's what I was just going to say.
I'm the bean king and the idea man.
I delegate to be the bean king.
How could you be the idea man and the bean king?
I'm the bean king.
You got to choose one of the.
I want others to do my great ideas for me.
The beans spark the ideas, Dan. It's not a crazy concept. You can be the bean king and the idea man.
The blood that pours from me has your Lucian. Now drink. It's you. The figure in my dreams. Drink.
Great Cody.
No. No, no, no, no, no. There is no leaving. You will not wriggle away.
Jonathan Sasslow.
Drink from me. And with this baptism of my blood in your mouth, throat, and veins, you shall be my servant.
This is the Dan Le Batard Show.
Put it on the poll. Can you be the bean king and the idea man?
I'm the bean king.
When did you stop being able to eat black beans? Because remember when you had your story where you brought in all pennies and quarters to the bean spot? That wasn't that long ago.
It was for my dad, though. I was buying them for my father.
It was just for you.
Yeah, yeah. I was buying them. It's actually my father's very difficult to buy for. This is his favorite place for black beans. And so whenever I want to do anything for my father, any kind of gift, I just bring him black beans from wherever it is that I am, and he can't get enough of them. So that is.
Just picture like, "Dad, the beans are in here." He's like, "Oh, okay."
I want to suggest something to you. Black beans are all alike.
That's what I'm saying. That's what I'm saying.
If you rinse black beans and eat just the bean, you can do a blind taste test and you won't know the difference. The difference is the sauce that the beans are in.
It's the preparation.
The cumin level makes a big difference. Do you have chopped scallions in them? What are you doing to your black beans? That's the key. That's why I'm the bean king.
That is not a joke.
I'm the bean king because I know it and you know it.
So yesterday on Football America, Nick Costos said to me, because he was making fun of the fact that I'm not interested in the dolphins this year, that I don't find them interesting and haven't found them interesting for many years. And as a football file, as a football nut, he's like, "How can you not be interested in how well they are drafting and how they're maneuvering to get into position? They're playing well. They clearly know what they're doing." And I'm like, "Well, I've been in an abusive relationship for 25 years that has a lot of betrayal."
And I thought Mike McDaniel knew what he was doing because it really seemed like it for a minute. For a minute there, it did seem. And I'm like, "They still don't have a quarterback." And so you can tell me they draft well if you think that's an actual science that people do better than others. I have my questions about that because I find that awfully unscientific. So maybe people in the league think the dolphins are doing it better and they're giving a lot of opportunities to young people and they seem to have hit on the first draft. But if you think that they have that ability to be better than others in selecting players, I don't believe that there are a lot of teams in the league that have a substantive advantage over the other team because they are a great deal better at evaluating talent.
Do you believe that that is a thing? Who are the best in the league at evaluating talent? And will you ever give me a bad team? Will you ever give me a losing team that's still good at evaluating talent and also losing?
Good at evaluating talent and also losing.
I'm saying that people say people are good at evaluating talent after they win, not before they win.
Ravens. Ravens currently stink. We know they're good at evaluating talent.
That's right. For 25 years, they've done it well, but they always win. And Ozzie Newsom started that and then they recreated it after that. And it's why Kyle Hamilton is saying now we're disgracing our place with the way that we're playing losing to the Chargers last night because we know we are good at this. The Ravens are obviously a good one, but when I ask you this as the football expert in our room, you believe that this is a science? You believe that there are several teams in the league that are a great deal better at drafting or evaluating talent?
That there's a big difference between the way that Andy Reid evaluates talent and the way that Jim Harbaugh evaluates talent?
I do believe that there are better talent evaluators than other organizations. And also, I think it's probably a lot more individual than we probably give it credit for, depending on who's running that department, who has the final say in things. And it's like good bosses hire good talent. Shitty bosses hire shitty people, and then they become shitty bosses because they're in it. That's just how it works. So what you'll see is it's like the Shanahan Tree thing. And I know it feels like a comic book-like thing, but Shanahan is really good at evaluating talent. He's also a really good coach.
And what happens is he's not trying to make other people good coaches or good talent evaluators. He has a system that he uses that he teaches his team. He has a way that he coaches that he teaches his team of coaches, and then they go off and do their version of it. And their ability to stay as close to that vine as possible with their own little positive mix determines how good they are or aren't. That's why all the fricking coaches that you are getting hired all come from that same system.
Philadelphia is said to have this as well, the ability to. And look, I'm being a bit hyperbolic. I know some people are good at it, but it's something that is inherently unscientific and you're playing odds. And as it relates to the specifics of why it is I'm not excited about the dolphins is I believe almost all of them are bad at quarterback.
All the dolphins?
No. Yes, that too, but all of the evaluators are bad at evaluating who's going to be a good quarterback. I believe that Kyle Shanahan can take Garoppolo and make him a good quarterback or take Brock Purdie and make him a good quarterback, but he could do it with a great many people. Brock Purdie's last in the draft. Everyone evaluated him as he doesn't have very much talent. The evaluation on Brock Purdie is he can't play in this league. The evaluation on Tom Brady is he's unlikely to play in this league.
He's a six-round pick. He's not likely to see the field. That's pretty ridiculous, I would say, in terms of how bad teams are at knowing who's going to be a good quarterback, and the dolphins still don't have one. So no matter how good they are at drafting, I can only get so excited about that.
Yeah. But they're going to have a top five draft next year where there's a lot of quality quarterbacks.
Is there?
That may or may not work out. That may or may not work out.
You can say that about any team picking anywhere.
But if you think Mestemaker or Mensah would make this team right here be winning a lot more, I don't, but okay, go on.
Well, the proof is in or there is no proof in drafting. There is no guarantee. But the indication of optimism with the dolphins is you look at who they drafted. They have a great rookie class. Caleb Douglas, Jacob Rodriguez, Chris Johnson, who had a 59-yard interception.
The white safety with three interceptions already.
That's right. They have a lot of they have a lot of talent.
Does he have a name?
Taffy?
Yep, begins with a T. I knew that.
Is it Taffy? I don't know how to pronounce it. It's like T-A-A-F-F-E.
White safety word.
It's like a weird name.
Shake that left, Taffy.
Like a lot of vowels in that name. It's weird. Anyway, the dolphins unequivocally have had a great draft class. Do they need a quarterback? Of course, because Malik Willis has been a huge disappointment. And the guy who just started, Kyle McCord, is another one of those six-round picks. He's not Purdie. He's not Brady because those are once-a-generation guys. 95% of six-round picks.
They were in the same generation.
No, Brady was a football generation earlier.
You know what? Malik Willis is a huge disappointment. I don't think it's a huge disappointment. To me, I don't think it's a huge disappointment because they're taking a chance. Like, "Hey, let's give it a look." And it's not a contract that is going to really hinder them from doing anything. I don't think it's a big disappointment.
Well, he's the only spending they did in the offseason. I thought what they got him for, relative to the position, was sort of a bargain. But he's disappointed. He takes so long to throw. I don't know whether it's a lack of decision-making or a lack of separation by his receivers, but he takes longer to throw the ball than anybody else. He hasn't been as mobile. He hasn't ran as much as I thought he would. I don't know. I've just been disappointed in him. Maybe you love Malik Willis. Go ahead.
I think every year you have to convince your fan base that you have a quarterback that can take you the distance. And I won't be disappointed in Malik Willis because I never thought he could take the dolphins the distance. I think to Zaz's point, it puts you in a situation where you still have the ability to be a top five draft pick. Worst case, if you win on this flyer, and the biggest thing is make it and make sense to the fans. You get this new coach. He's coming with some kind of an insight of a quarterback who's shown well in the little moments that he's had. It's pretty much the only quarterback that's available to you at that time.
When he doesn't live up to Dan Marino, I'm not disappointed in it. But I also think that evaluating quarterbacks is way harder for most people because I don't think they really take into account probably the intangibles from a personality standpoint. That Brock Purdie, that's why it's like an inexact science because you're like, "He's not Purdie." No, he's not Purdie because Purdie being drafted the last pick in the draft does matter for his psyche. It's like these canon moments that if he's a top 10 pick, I don't know if Purdie is who Purdie is.
I don't know if Tom Brady is Tom Brady if he gets drafted number five overall. Still talented, but you don't know what drives him. And it's like it changes their neural pathways to create this version of a quarterback who will more times than not rise to the occasion because it's not just about how tall you are, how much arm power you have, how fast and how quick you are. And there's plenty of examples of that in the NFL.
Well, I was going to ask you this. First and foremost, this dolphin skill positions, they just stink. Devon HN is injured, and you look at all the wide receivers, and all of them leave a lot to be desired. But Huck, Herbert is Herbert.
Cody, disagree with him. Disagree with her.
No, I don't want to interrupt her. I do disagree. I think Caleb Douglas is showing tremendous WR1 potential. I think Malik Washington is a decent number two. I think Ole Gordon has been a pleasant surprise at running back. And when they get HN healthy, I think they have position guys. But the big thing with the dolphins is who are they going to pick with their top five pick next year? And a lot of people think they should take the Ohio State wide receiver. I think they have to take a quarterback. They have to prioritize the most important position.
So that's the argument right now among dolphins. Some want the tanking for the number one pick. Some want to win as much as possible. Some want a quarterback like I do. Some think, "Nope, you got to go for the other positions of need, like wide receiver."
You need a quarterback. That's like what you absolutely need. And if you can find a franchise quarterback and actually evaluate who that's going to be over someone like Jeremiah Smith, you have to do that. But you talk about intangibles versus looking like you're built in a lab. Hawk and Justin Herbert, my Oregon Duck alum, he had all of the tools. He has all of the makings of being that guy, and yet he kind of stinks. And when we were in our pre-production meeting, I asked you, "Is he cooked?"
Yeah, that's a great question. Real quick, before we jump into that, how do dolphins fans feel about Justin Herbert now?
Well.
I know it was like, "Oh, we should have got him over to a " do you still feel that way? Is that still the sentiment amongst the fan base?
I still think Miami Dolphin fans feel like they erred onto a and would have been better off taking Justin Herbert even today. I mean, Justin Herbert, I think, is a quality quarterback, and I'm not surprised the Chargers didn't try to deal him at the deadline. But I want to ask you about something you said because it interested me.
Hold on. Not to cut you off, but let me make sure I get back to Tara. I think when you think.
Trista also.
Trista, my bad.
Okay, I'm sorry. No, you're not going to go off.
Who's this sidepiece that you have? You got to go.
You know what? He's got like.
Damn, that was my first dolphin.
Murdering the show with their bare hands in a dismemberment kit in cold blood.
In the local hour too.
Yeah, I had a good question for Hawk. I know I can't answer it.
Please show yourself out. Dan Le Batard.
I heard that as a woman faking pain. I didn't think that sounded real. I really didn't.
It was not fake. It was in no way fake.
You can spot a woman faking it?
Great Cody.
Yes, I can, Jess. I've been married 40 years.
This is the Dan Le Batard Show.
That was bad.
I mean, I don't have.
The Bean King never makes that kind of mistake.
I don't have a penalty that addresses specifically not knowing the name of your teammate, okay? But some of the lack of chemistry showed there just in general in not knowing each other. When we're asking each other questions and no one's answering it and then saying, "No, but I want to go back over here to this question," you guys can do that on your own shows. On ours, that's not what we're going to end up doing here. And so I can't have Andrew Hawkins right now sit out for long enough with everything that he just did. And I hope that he learns from his shame in the other room.
I doubt he will.
Yeah, they all learn from me.
I have not found him to be a quick learner. If he would learn from you, he would start being late. That's what he would learn from you.
I don't know what that is.
A couple of things that I wanted to address here. One, if we call it an inexact science, is it a science? Because this is what I'm saying about drafting players. I don't think it's a science. I really don't. I'm looking at it and I'm saying you may have some ability to improve the probabilities, but there are a million things that go into whether a guy, when he gets to your camp, has whatever it takes to survive a football locker room. And you can try to measure all of those things, and it's going to be really hard to measure all of those things.
And it's going to be hard to have a science be at all a science if it's inexact. So put that on the pole first at Le Batard Show. Is an inexact science still a science? Also put on the pole, is your quarterback's neuro or are your quarterback's neuro pathways altered by the experience at Le Batard Show? Because Hawkins was talking about neuro pathways. And also, when you mentioned Malik Willis and him being disappointing, is it disappointing or is it hugely disappointing?
It's disappointing.
Or is it as.
Disappointing.
As Aaron Glenn says, is it just merely disappointing?
It's disappointing.
Because.
It's disappointing.
I'm with.
It is disappointing.
It's disappointing.
Disappointing.
It's disappointing.
I'm with Zazlow on Malik Willis is absolutely not disappointing because or hugely disappointing because.
It's disappointing.
Because the contract and everything is structured in such a way that you can get a quarterback next year. And he can play quarterback for a little while until you play him the way that Fernando Mendoza would play for after. You have something that's built in to get you to the next couple of years.
Yeah, Greg, I know you mentioned that he's the only guy they spent money on. It's the most money they spent this offseason. So what? It hasn't prevented them from doing other things right now.
Well, okay. If you're speaking about the dolphins in the best-case scenario entering this season, the best-case scenario is that Malik Willis is kicking ass. He is taking full advantage of his first real opportunity to lead a team. He's doing great. They may still be one and eight or whatever, but he's doing great. People are talking about how good he is and how he finally is playing up to what people thought he might be. He isn't. So instead of Malik Willis being real good right now and having the luxury to think, "Let's spend that first-round draft pick on Jeremiah Smith," instead, they don't have that luxury because he hasn't proved to be good enough.
He's not the worst quarterback in the league, but he's in the bottom five if you look at any statistic you choose.
Hawkins, what were you saying before you were shamed? And you earned that shame, right? You wore it in the other room.
As a Walter veteran, I earned every piece of that shame. I'm not going to get over that for weeks.
How do I support your confidence here and build you back up so that you can feel better about yourself? When you laugh.
Steroids? I don't know.
He's going to support your confidence. He's a pro athlete.
Well, but he's hurting. He's hurting right now. Look, he's a professional. He's prepared.
Medicated milk? I don't know.
He's very good at his job.
Tara.
And you.
Tara.
I have an excuse, but I'm not even going to put it into the ether.
I need to know.
Tara. We'll talk offline. This is not now, Tara. Tara, I got to.
So you were saying, did you remember what you were saying?
Does it matter what I was saying at this point? Tara. Does it matter? Seriously.
So should I just move on? I should move on to other things? I'm happy to talk about the Miami Heat because.
No.
Oh, yeah. Now I can't also double whammy and not answer her question because then it's like, "Yeah." All right. So this is what my take on Justin Herbert, your Oregon Duck. I think Justin is one of those quarterbacks that should be great. He has all the makings. And how I would equate it to, "Sucks. This is such a damn good analogy that I had teed up, and that's why I got too excited." Tara. There are diamonds, right? And then there are cubic zirconias, okay? And the cubic zirconias, they get cloudy damn near immediately after a daily use.
It's very easy to spot a cubic zirconia, Malik Willis, in a certain situation. It's a very small sample size. But the diamonds, over time, they are built in a way where they're rock solid. And then there are lab diamonds that even the best gemologists, they're not able to decipher from the naked eye. It takes a much longer sample size to say, "Hey, you have all the makings of a diamond, but you're not that." And for Justin Herbert, he has all the makings.
And there's been moments, and there's been certain seasons, and there's been games where you're like, "Oh, I see it. I see the Joe Burrow in you." But over time, as they continue to age next to a diamond who is flawless, and when you put the right scale on it or whatever it is to measure diamonds, you can see, "Oh, okay, it's just not cut exactly the same as that." So there's always going to be something to be desired. And that's what I think of Justin Herbert. I think he has all the makings and should be that, but he just can't.
Tara.
So he's a lab diamond.
He's a lab diamond.
Okay. Better than zirconia, but not the real.
He's not a cubic zirconia, but he's.
Indecipherable from a diamond until you know they're actually a lab. I preferred your rice cake analogy.
Yeah. I've been dropping a lot of.
I mean, calling Justin Herbert a rice cake, processed, not cooked or raw.
That sounds a little more harsh, though. I think I was I think I backed back from that one. Because she asked him, "Was he cooked?" And I'm like, "I don't know. Is a processed food cooked?" Because it's very similar to a lab diamond. If it's made that way, it's kind of always it is what it is. That's what I think of Justin Herbert.
But we like Rice Krispies. So if you're a Rice Krispie of cereal, everyone loves you. You're not to a you're not Burrow, but you're an edible, credible, the incredible edible egg.
Okay. I'm not getting a lot of help in here today. It is what it is. It's not useful commentary.
It's great what it is to do with Rice Krispies.
It is what it is. It's great commentary.
It's not useful commentary.
Let's not get anybody fired today.
It is what it is is a good podcast. It is not good as commentary. You mentioned the cubic zirconia. I just have a Manny Ramirez story. Manny Ramirez had a giant diamond in his ear, and he was just always pointing to it and whispering, "$65, $65." Because he was like, "Nobody knows the difference. They all think it's a big diamond. They all think, but I only paid $65 for it." And some of what you're saying is not exactly true because when it comes to lab diamonds, diamond experts can very easily tell the difference between a.
Easily?
Diamond experts. I'm not a diamond expert. I'm not claiming to be.
There's very few diamond experts.
But the diamond experts who are measuring the value of diamonds can tell the difference between a lab-grown diamond and a real diamond.
But very few diamond experts, though.
Okay, but there are only a handful of teams making these decisions, and I'm saying none of them are diamond experts.
What about a blow diamond?
I'm telling you that none of the people in NFL front offices, except for maybe Kyle Shanahan are diamond experts.
I agree. That's what we're saying, the same thing, man.
The Miami Heat last night beat the Houston Rockets, and I want to talk about something here because Zaz is now convinced they're good, and it was 10 games ago that everybody thought that they were going to be terrible.
Not me.
Also, last year at about this time, we also thought the Miami Heat were going to be good for different reasons. They were playing a different style of basketball, and we were wrong about that. But the most encouraging thing, if you are not watching the Miami Heat games and all it is that you are doing is consuming the coverage of the Miami Heat team, which makes it fairly hysterical after four games. It will not be nearly as loud right now as it was through the first four games when so many people were yelling, "Giannis is hard to play with." It will not be nearly as loud now with twice the sample size larger than that of people saying, "Holy shit, Giannis is playing like Shaq."
Like, "Oh my God." Everything that's happening with Clay is, well, that's what it looks like when Clay is allowed to play with people who are Giannis.
We're at three minutes 12.
And he's not going to look quite as washed as he looked in Dallas all of a sudden because this looks like prime Clay when he's making all of the shots and he's got his legs under him. But I do think that it has been underreported. Just as it got loud after four games, wildly underreported how dominant Giannis is. We have had this exactly twice in the history of the Miami Heat. It's the first version of Shaq at the very beginning, and it's this. He gets the ball. It's a dunk.
That's what I'm saying. That's what I'm noticing these first few weeks. And really since the start of the season, because if you notice the way Giannis was playing those first few games, which was not the way to play with this team, he's getting the ball near half court. He's coming downhill. It's spin move and just try and bull people over at the basket. They're not doing that anymore. They're finding him near the hoop, and if he catches the orange underneath the basket, it's a dunk.
And it's like watching Shaq again. It's like watching a really athletic Shaq where he catches a ball near the basket. Guess what? It's going to be a dunk. And I feel like we're I don't know if taken for granted is the right way to put it, but it's seemingly every night we're getting 30 and 15 and a block or two. And do we understand those numbers aren't a really big deal?
It's never 12. He's always going to get his shots. He's always going to get his 15 shots and 20 shots, and he's always going to get his free throws, and he's always going to get a double-digit bat.
He's getting 10 free throws a game, and he's 10 to 15 from the floor every game. It's like having Shaq again.
Well, it shows you that Giannis has never respected any of the coaches that he's had because they've been baitus. They have allowed Giannis to do whatever he wanted to do, drink their oat milk and eat their black beans and run rough shot over them. Jason Kidd allowed Giannis to think he was a point guard, and then for every other coach that he ever played for, he's just dribble, dribble, dribble, tween, tween, tween trying to get downhill. And now he finally has an alpha, AKA Eric Spoelstra, where it's like, "No, dude, you're a five.
Just dunk the ball."
It feels a little bit like when LeBron first got here where, "No, no, no. The way you've been playing, I got a better way for you to play. You're going to have the ball around the basket." And I know you want to shoot these three-pointers, but how about you just dunk as much as possible?
The surprise to me isn't that the Heat are eight and two since starting 0-4. The surprise is the surprise when they were 0-4 and everyone was panicking. Giannis is a great player, arguably top five in the league. We didn't think that the best coach in the league is going to figure this out.
It was the loss to Charlotte. Also.
So what?
It was the loss to Charlotte. And Tara, I would say to you that Pablo Torre finds out, has done an episode about the myth of the alpha. The alpha is not actually a thing. It's all mythological. It's not factual. The idea of alpha is a contrivance.
That's what a beta would say. Shake that left, hey, toffee.
"You're the incredible, edible egg."
Greg Cote is not only the idea man, but he's also The Bean King™.
Today's cast: Dan, Greg, A.W. Hawkins, Roy, Chris, Tara, and Zaslow.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices