Noah Eagle, the play-by-play broadcaster, joins Dan Le Batard and Greg Cody to discuss calling a major NFL game on short notice, the disputed catch in the Miami and Notre Dame game, and how his father reacted. The conversation moves to a friendly rivalry with his father, rankings of memorable broadcast calls and catchphrases, and a segment where Eagle tries out Greg Cody's 'very good' line in a parrot voice.
The hosts also discuss Nathan Fielder's work and the Knicks benching Mikhail Bridges, debating whether a trade can still be worth it after a championship. Listeners will hear broadcasters' takes on sports rules, fandom and roster decisions.
In this episode Dan Le Batard, Greg Cody, Noah Eagle
This Dan Le Batard Show episode with Noah Eagle on his Thanksgiving Eve assignment was made with the technology behind HappyScribe's AI note taker.
Ads in this audio differ from the text. Tap the sentence you're hearing to follow along.
Synced: the text now follows the audio.
This guy again. Oh my god, his success is so annoying. So, he's an Emmy Award-winning broadcaster, he's the play-by-play voice for Big Ten Saturday Night on NBC Sports, he's the play-by-play voice for NBC Sports' NBA coverage, he's also the host and play-by-play announcer for the tennis channel, he's also the play-by-play announcer for Netflix's broadcast of the NFL's first-ever Thanksgiving Eve game. And so I tried the other day to just find a place: where can I get away from Noah Eagle? And I'm like, Sunday night football, surely I will not see him there.
And then I look up and Tariq goes, "Gone clearly," because Noah Eagle has poisoned something in his food or something, because he wants the job of everybody in the industry. Noah, welcome to the show. I'm just curious, you got a day of notice on that. Were you perfectly ready for that moment with utmost confidence, or were you terrified because you knew the size of the assignment?
It's a good question. Great to be with you guys, as always. Also, I apologize for whatever demolition is going on in the apartment above me. I don't want you thinking that I live in, like, a Joe Missoula type of practice scenario where there's war zone sounds going on. To answer the question, it was somewhere in between, probably. You know, I made the drive over. The best thing for me was the crew is awesome, and Rob Hyland, the producer, is on top of everything, and Drew Esikoff is a legend as the director. And Chris Collinsworth, we get in there and he's just like, "Here's what you're going to see tonight."
And it was good. I just listened to what he had to say and Melissa Stark, and I followed their lead. So it wasn't perfect, but I did feel like I reached a baseline level that I could go and call the game and it would be all good.
Did it feel a bit like a dream?
A little bit, yeah. I would say so. And it certainly helped that we got a great game and the Bears were a great story going in, and it all worked out.
What did the dream look like if that didn't look most like whatever the dream was supposed to look like?
Yeah, a little bit like that. I think the dream that I always had as a kid, it was the classic, you have a test that you never studied for. And so it was something like that where you had the test, you get there, and then you ace the test and everything works out. And I felt like maybe it wasn't an A-plus, but it was as close as I could have gotten on the notice that I got. And like I said, I worked around with a great crew and we got a great game. So in that sense, it definitely felt very similar.
Noah, what was it like telling your father?
He basically said, "Oh, bleep," and then said, "All right, well, do your first game, then do your second game." Because Miami-Notre Dame, as you guys know, was massive. And that was the game I prepared all week for. And so I wanted to make sure that that was still most important. He made sure that in my head, that was going to be the case. So one game at a time, kind of like how I handle food. I eat my main course, then my side. And that's how I let it rip.
Catch or not a catch?
So I've listened to what you guys have said. Again, from an emotional, and if you listen to how I called it in the moment, I said, "Catch." I said, "He caught it." And I think that it's really the nuance of the rule. If it was me, I'm saying he catches that. I think that's catch. He gets the two feet in. But based on the rule, I understand why they called it incomplete. Now, would I change the rule to make that a catch? Absolutely. That's just how I view it. But by lay of the law, that is not a catch in terms of rulebook.
So you change the rule, I think, before he drops the football, right? That's right when I change the rule, right before he drops the football.
Yes, that exact moment, yes. No, I would tell you that the way I view it is you have possession of the football, you have two feet down. It should be dead, right? It should be you're in the end zone. That's 100% the way I view it. Now, I understand the argument of, well, if he's in the middle of the field and this happens, then it's no longer a catch. I get all that. But I think that the rules are different or should be different for when you've crossed the plane, when you've crossed the goal line, when the ball automatically, if it's in your possession, crosses the goal line, it's a touchdown.
And so the way I saw it, at least live, was he's in the end zone, he crossed the goal line, he's got the ball in his hands, that's a touchdown. But again, the letter of the law says otherwise. And unfortunately for Miami's case, that was not a catch. The good thing for Miami, obviously, is they built up such credibility leading into that game. And I mean, we could get into a deep discussion about the playoff committee and how they're viewing teams that aren't in a specific conference and all things like that. But I think Miami has put themselves in position. Certainly, if Malachi Toney does come back and plays to the level that he's even 80% of what he is, I think he's the best receiver.
Malachi?
Yeah, Malachi, sure. I think he's the best receiver in the country, including Jeremiah Smith. I think that he's outstanding. And you put him back in there with what they've got around, and certainly Darien Mensah, now Barkade, it feels like, has real confidence after these last couple of weeks. I just think they're as dangerous as anyone.
Can you sort of examine with me the intergalactic stupidity of us covering this sport the way that we do and just examining every single thing that there is about this sport? So many people talking about it. And when it comes to a simple rule, you get the extremes of people arguing that was a catch, wasn't a catch. Give me another example anywhere throughout the history of time that that is also where you are sitting here and people can't agree on the rule.
Yeah. Maybe is a hot dog a sandwich? That feels probably the closest thing that I can think of quickly. But no, it is wild. And obviously, it's been something that we've been dealing with for years. But I'm also the type of person that thinks that Dez Brian caught it. So I clearly am pro-receiver in all of this.
He did.
I'm with you. He did. He caught it. I just feel like he has possession long enough. And to me, it should be very simple. When the ball is in the air, do you claim it as you come down to the ground? The whole process of completing all the way through. Again, I understand it and it's the rule, so we're going to follow the rule based on how it's written. But again, you look at Elijah Lofton, he goes up and makes the spectacular play of catching that football, which, by the way, was a ridiculous throw by Darien Mensah as well. And he comes down with two feet down. To me, if we're just playing in the backyard, that's a catch, right?
That's a catch. No any other extenuating circumstances that are going to separate from that fact. So yeah, it is hilarious to your point that something that unique and that detailed and that nuanced could impact so much of a sport that we are all so entrenched in.
Hawk, on our television show on Highly Questionable, I used to ask players all the time, "When did you stop playing against your son?" And all of them would say, "The first time he came close to beating me." We stopped playing anything. Do you believe that Noah Eagle's father is happy that Noah Eagle on Thanksgiving Eve is doing Packers Rams while he's doing college basketball, while his father is doing Duke and UConn and college basketball and his son is doing a giant NFL game?
I think he is ecstatic. I think most athletes are eagle maniacs when they give that.
And broadcasters aren't.
Broadcasters, they have a little eagle maniac to them. But I think it's really hard to have a son who is as successful as Noah and not have a father who has pushed at every moment for that to be the case. I tell my son, there's one man on planet Earth that wants you to do better than them, and you're looking at him. So everything I'm telling you is to set that up. And I think that's he's going to be not only happy about it, proud that he's doing college basketball.
Is that true, Noah?
No, I think it's absolutely false.
Yeah, I mean.
That sounded so good, though, didn't it? He's irate. He can't believe that I've got the potential of Miles Garrett on one side and Micah Parsons on the other side, and he's got Caden Boozer. You know, I don't think no. I mean, look, he's got the replay of one of his all-time break calls and one of his all-time break games with Duke and UConn from last year and the Mullen shot. So I think he'll be doing all right. He's got a great crew around him. And Stan Van Gunney will make sure that he keeps the seat warm right next to him.
So when you guys have, like, the makeup holiday that you guys get to have with one another, if you even have the chance to do them, do you guys workshop, like, best calls or lines to kind of go back and forth and battle with one another?
Yeah, that's our version of Festivus is there's no feats of strength. It's who can beat the call, beat that call. It's, "Oh, it's good." No, no, that sucks. You got to give me a bury's it. And I go, "Oh, I don't that's old news." I think maybe a sweet sassy molasses, like, go to the SNL and see if it works. Do it live. We just try all of it. Yeah, that honestly, we should incorporate that. I feel like we haven't done enough of that. We've gone more of the airing of grievances. So maybe we'll shift to something more positive this year.
Noah, do you have a call sometimes where after the game you think to yourself, "Oh, that was a good one. I nailed that"? Like, do you have a favorite recently?
You know, there was one last year that it was a game that I don't think a ton of people were watching because at the time it was New Mexico with the first year I had coached in his first game, Jason Ek at Michigan. This is just the one that pops into my head because pretty much every call, I would say 90-something percent of them, I don't plan ahead of time. I get lucky sometimes. And there are every now and then where you have something in your head ahead of time that you just nail in the moment that you had already kind of thought up. But this one, I completely just made up in the moment where New Mexico, they were near the goal line and they snapped the ball between the quarterback's legs to the running back, and he threw a jump pass into the end zone to trim the deficit, I think, to seven at the time towards the end of the first half.
And I said, "The lobos get loco at Michigan Stadium." And I loved it. For whatever reason, at that moment, that's what came into my head. And after the game, that was definitely one. I was like, "Did I say that? Oh, yeah, that was good."
Last week, I think you said PG-13 has turned rated R.
Oh, I love that one.
One to ten, what are you rating that one? One to ten, ten being the highest.
So the funny thing about that call is I did the Clipper games for four years. Paul George was on the Clippers all four years. I was using that call in 2019, but I was on radio. Nobody heard it. And so it was the first time I really had him at that level where it was a national audience. And last year, he was wearing number eight. So I couldn't really call him PG-13 if he's wearing number eight. So to answer the question for the nostalgia vibes, I give that an 8.7.
So over the weekend, I heard a San Francisco radio guy yell as Deebo Samuel is running down the sideline. Willpower, horsepower, Deebo does Dallas. What are your thoughts on that one to ten?
That's good. If that maybe was Guy Haberman, I would assume. I'm going to give that. And that's better than PG-13's rated R. I'm going to go 8.8, 8.9, somewhere in that range.
What are your tens, not necessarily for you, but all time, like where you just say to yourself, having heard someone say, "Oh, man, I wish I had that one"?
Yeah, there are a couple that stand out. I mean, there are the classics, right? Do you believe in miracles has to be a ten. I think we will see you tomorrow night from passed down generation to generation has to be a ten. I think Mike Breen delivering a hearty bang has to be a ten. I will say one that maybe doesn't get enough recognition, in my opinion, Dave Pasch, Big East Tournament, Kemba Walker, game winner. Kardiak, Kemba does it again. UConn wins at the buzzer. Was perfect because then you just lay out. At that point, his mom's going crazy in the stands. Jim Calhoun is literally double fist pumping up.
His dress shirt is getting untucked as he's doing it. I think the scenes of that are phenomenal. So yeah, I think anything that stands out is always good. Anything that you can recite then later is probably what I give a ten.
Dan Le Batard. Sixteen. Great Cody.
Take the rest of the day off.
This is the Dan Le Batard Show.
What about Carson Beck with his legs?
Oh, yes, yes. I would say if they win those games, certainly the national championship, because then you have Mendoza as well running the football. Yeah, yeah. Let's give it an eight. An even eight.
Roy, can you play, please, because I believe that Noah Eagle's facts are wrong. And I also believe that his judgment is wrong when he says, "Do you believe in miracles" is the best of all the calls. We have already replaced that officially around here with this.
Daniels.
Yeah.
He's not passing the ball.
Okay.
Yeah. They don't have a timeout. What are they doing?
Oh, man.
They got to get up and spike it. They're not going to be able to get this guy to do it.
They're not going to.
It's going to run out on them. The clock ran out as Daniels ran the ball. And Skatabu says, "I'll take the tie and get out of town."
Yeah. Did Skatabu truly get out of town? Do we know?
I don't know. I believe that's irrelevant here. I don't want to nitpick on the greatest call of all time. You wouldn't like it if you didn't know.
What about the Ryan Ruco one where he's like, "They don't use it. Why don't they use it?" To fire Chris DeMarco.
That is, yeah. I mean, that basically lost Chris DeMarco the job. I will say, I think my favorite Ryan Ruco is the incredulous Ryan Ruco. If you watch Nets games, that happens a lot because the Nets sometimes down the stretch do some puzzling things. And his reactions are tremendous. That is before a hearty why not or you bet or my favorite Ruco call is probably just the middle of the second quarter of Durant. Sure. I just trimmed it too much.
I want to play for you here as Greg Cody tries to get you to say one of his catchphrases on one of your broadcasts. I want to play for you a couple of people who have done that for us. Let's play Jason Benetti first, please.
Tigers offense has started to cook here in Tampa. They're going to leave going. What, we break a window on the way out of here?
Let's play Kevin Harlan here. I believe Kevin Harlan so far is the best of these.
Offensive line has kept Mahomes clean and quiet. He drives this offense and driver comfort is paramount.
The music helps so much. It's just crazy how much the music helps. Are you willing to take some suggestions to sprinkle somewhere into a broadcast because you're the world's most confident young broadcaster?
Yeah, this is a dangerous game considering people don't understand that this entire college football season, I have been sneaking in words and phrases that have been given to me from my crew. And some of them have been absurd anyway. So this is going to be an improvement. I look forward to it.
All right. So let's see, Greg, what would you like to hear? And which broadcast is it that you're not thinking of doing this on the first ever Thanksgiving Eve game on Netflix?
Oh, that would be great.
To quote Ryan Ruco, why not?
All right. So here we go. Let's see what it is that we've got here. Greg, what are you offering?
Okay, well, this is quick because it's a two-word exclamation. You know, somebody makes a great play and all you got to say is very good.
Like that?
It is high for me.
Yeah. Hold on, hold on. Are you asking me to do a Borat voice on Netflix?
Very good.
It's a parrot. He's sort of it's out of the sun.
A parrot? You want a full parrot?
Yeah.
Okay.
Give him some options. Give him some options here, Greg, because it's ridiculous for him to do that.
No, no, it isn't ridiculous.
Out of the side of his mouth like a parrot.
Very good.
You want him to go, very good?
Yeah, you got to be high pit.
All right.
How about this?
Give him some options.
Okay. You're going to go to Buffalo with Bernie probably?
Greg, give him something easier than that.
Okay, something easier. All right, hang on. Well, blanking it means doing it. You know, somebody makes a great catch.
Greg, give him something good. Give him an option he can actually use.
Who made it a salad?
Very good feels like the best of these, which is saying a lot.
Who made it the salad works.
Who made it a salad makes it much easier.
Yeah.
Who made it a no, who made it.
Who made it a salad?
Who made it a salad?
Okay, yeah.
Done?
Right?
Do what now?
I'll one-up you.
Done?
I'll one-up you.
Good.
I'll give you a very good Saturday at Notre Dame in a parrot voice, and I'll give you a who made it a salad on Netflix Thanksgiving Eve.
I don't believe you. You're going to get let me hear the very good now. Let me hear you do it out of the.
Let me practice.
Out of the side of your mouth.
Let me make sure. Yeah. CJ Carr rolls, throws. Oh, it's caught Micah Gilbert. Very good. Touchdown.
We'll work on it.
Yeah.
Was that good?
Think of yourself.
A little higher?
Think of yourself as on helium for just that phrase.
Greg, show him how to do it. Let's go back and forth. You and him go back and forth.
Okay, you ready?
Okay.
Very good.
Very good. Was that better?
That's better. One more time.
Very good.
Very good. Yeah, it's good. It might not be it might not be in my vocal range. That's the problem. Very good. I felt better about that one.
Okay.
Yeah.
All right. It needs a little work, if I'm being honest with you.
All right. You know what? I've got until Saturday to workshop it, make sure that it's right.
Yeah.
I will make sure by Saturday it's good. It's perfect.
And if not, you can just say if you want to go to Buffalo with Bernie Parmalee.
Yeah.
Yeah, yeah. I'll use my consolation.
Yeah, there you go. Thank you, though.
Do you want any more help from Greg Cody so that you can get it exactly right? You want to give him a couple of more, Greg? Because it's got to be out of the side of your mouth, correct?
Yeah. Think of a parrot, a talking parrot from a distance.
Very good.
From a distance.
Yeah.
I see.
Very good.
I see. Very good.
Yeah.
Yeah.
You got to look at the side of my mouth when you do it.
Very good.
You're giving me like a little yeah, you're going with like almost an Elvis mouth. Very good.
Very good.
Very good.
Okay. You know what? You're working on it.
All right, here it coming. I'm telling you.
Bring Dad into it. Bring Dad into the conversation. Maybe you'll give me a couple of steps.
He can do it himself. He doesn't need his dad.
Well, that's the thing. My dad did have a parrot growing up. That's info that people don't know. So I'll make sure he probably has a better sense of this.
Perfect.
Noah, when did your voice drop to this level of baritone?
Yeah.
Elizabeth Holmes.
I would love Nathan Fielder to do a documentary on me. That would be great. Let's start there. Second, I think that I vividly remember walking into school when I was in sixth grade and this dude saying, "Your voice dropped." And I was like, "No, it didn't." You know, it was one of those. I'm like, "Ah, I just have a cold." I'm like, "Yeah, I'm all good. I'm very good." That was how I felt.
Noah, good seeing you. Thank you. Appreciate the time and enjoy listening to you. Thanksgiving Eve on Netflix. You got a big one, and he is going to be doing the big ones for the rest of the time as his father gets insanely jealous. Thank you, sir.
Thanks, guys. Appreciate it.
As he mentions, Nathan Fielder, do any of you or have any of you actually seen Nathan for you? Is it something that you guys follow? Because the ambition of Nathan Fielder has been super interesting to watch his growth. I remember, I think I told you guys that I sort of read all of Dan Brown's novels like back to back, and I sort of saw how the evolution got to Da Vinci Code because you can see some of the mistakes he was making in previous incarnations of what it is that he was doing.
When you watch Nathan Fielder go to the rehearsal or even the curse or now the documentary that's so popular, you can see everything. You can see the growth of somebody that's just crazy. But Nathan, for you, as a concept, what he was doing, saying yes and to every absurdity, it's just brilliant. The degree of difficulty on what he does is crazy. But none of you guys, none of you guys are interested in Nathan Fielder's work? I got nobody here that's interested.
I watched the rehearsal. You know, I didn't see anything for you.
But the rehearsal is him just throwing even more money at the things that he was doing on Nathan for you when he created dumb Starbucks and did just a bunch of really clever things that no one else is doing or making. I wanted to transition into some basketball with you guys, though, here because the Knicks have essentially benched Mikhail Bridges. The Knicks are telling you that they want Shannon and McBride to get the minutes. And it's not just Bridges that's losing minutes. It's also Josh Hart, who is heart and soul guy.
And Mike Brown's telling you that my champion guys don't trust him the way that I did. My other guys have gotten better, and some of this revealed itself during the finals when he was getting stuff in shooting that he wanted from McBride and Shannon. What do you guys make of the fact that Mikhail Bridges, who the Knicks traded five first-round picks for, that basically he is somebody who isn't getting minutes anymore?
I think this is actually a good thing for them right now because normally for champion teams, the hardest part of repeating is the monotony. And this shakes things up a little bit when they couldn't really add a piece in the offseason. A lot of times champions want to add a new face. You know, it gives you a little bit of an energy, a little bit of a spark. And this changes things up a little bit in that locker room. I think this is a good thing for them right now. They've gotten off to a very mediocre start.
It feels like when Hawk called me Tara and had to go into another room, and then for the rest of the show, he's just been like struggling with confidence. I don't know how Mikhail Bridges, when you get benched for and you have to sit out the rest of the game against the Cavs for Landry Shamets, a guy who we're struggling whether he's Shamets or Shamets, and Deuce McBride. Who knows, right? Names are tough.
Yeah.
Like for a guy who was at the highest high to now be benched, I feel like the confidence is going to be tough to get back.
And it's tough because then you transition into basketball and they just stop throwing you the ball. It's like we're not even going to talk NFL football. So then the confidence goes down even lower because it's like we don't even feel it from you this game. We got to win somewhere else. I can identify with that.
Well, she's also trying to get you to identify with the idea of being somebody who was feeling pretty damn confident, champion-level confident, and they traded five first-round picks for somebody. So he was a final piece. And what's weird, I'm not going to say weird, but what has happened here in terms of construction is the Knicks traded for him because they needed to guard the Celtics' wing players. And so that trade was successful. They ended up being better than the Celtics, and they ended up winning a championship.
The totality, Trista, of that trade, your assessment is what? The Knicks traded for Mikhail Bridges, five first-round picks, successful trade or not?
I think it's the top five, one of the top five worst trades in modern memory.
How could you say that? They won. It worked.
But now James Dolan, and I actually think I side with James Dolan. Like I can't trust paying any of you guys. Like I can't trust that after I pay you, except for Jalen Brunson who continues to take pay cuts, that you're going to continue to perform at a level that is that caliber, especially in the age of this new CBA and the second apron. And I'm cheap. So why am I paying Carl Anthony Towns? I'm not. Why am I going to pay Josh Hart? I'm not. Like now they're already thinking about trading Mikhail Bridges.
Well, and that would open the door potentially for being able to re-sign Carl Anthony Towns if they were to trade him. By the way, Mikhail Bridges has that Iron Man streak. He's never missed a game in his career. Matter of fact, he's played 83 games in a season before. He's never missed a game. So I wonder if that streak winds up ending at some point here.
An anonymous scout says they should bench Mikhail for the rest of the year. And it's not even his offense, which has been horrendous. He had five straight games going under double digits.
He's been really bad.
But defensively, when Mike Brown is like, "Yo, we'd rather have Landry Shamet out there."
I'm surprised that you're saying that. You think it was that you're calling it one of the worst trades. Like I think he can go the rest of his career and be a total bum and it was still a great trade. It worked.
Because winning a championship means you never have to say you're sorry, even if it hampers you for the end of time.
No, because the price that's right. There's no bigger price. There's no steeper price to pay if you wind up winning the championship. Like you would take the championship now for it to hurt later on.
Yeah, I think you sign up for the championship. I get like on the back end it not feeling like, okay, if you just look at it in a vacuum that Mikhail Bridges isn't worth the compensation. I try to equate it to the Cleveland Browns. They do the Deshaun Watson thing, and it has not gone at all the way that they imagined.
If they win a Super Bowl this year, it was worth it.
If they win a Super Bowl in Cleveland, it will be the best trade that they've ever made in the history of the franchise.
Dan Le Batard.
Boy.
Who needs me? Greg Cody.
Who needs me?
This is the Dan Le Batard Show.
Let me see how I do this here because the last time I remember having a version of this conversation, it actually involved Ugith Urbina, the closer of the Marlins. I think they traded Adrian Gonzalez for Ugith Urbina. They won the championship. He was super shaky as a closer, but they won the championship. And so what is the tipping point on this if we're having the conversation of how good do I have to make the player for the people, the fan base to say, "You know what? I'm okay with the fact that we didn't win a championship.
I would have liked to have kept that player that we traded away." I don't know what the five first-round picks for Mikhail Bridges have actually become. I have not been tracking that. But I think most people would agree with the assessment that it can't be a top five worst trade of all time if you win the championship soon after making that trade and the player involved actually is contributing to that championship because Mikhail Bridges was important for them. He may not be now, but he was in the winning of the championship.
He's a great perimeter defender, and they need that.
What if this team not only can't contend, but can't compete for the next 5, 10, 15 years because of the draft compensation? They haven't even conveyed yet and the situation that we're in where it's now the high of the high and then a really bad vibe the next year when guys are already pissed off and then now it's just dead. You can't compete for the rest of time.
Well, entertain my hypothetical. Under what circumstances would what you traded hurt so much that you would say, "I would rather have that than the championship that New York won that is the first one in half a century?" It's the biggest and greatest story that New York sports has had in I don't know how long, maybe ever. What do I have to make the player or the damage for you to say, "Nope, not worth it." Obviously, in this case, she's already saying it's not worth it with just the value of the fifth-round picks.
For the rest of you, if you're disputing that, where do I have to put the value for a fan to be like, "Nope, that's too much of a player. I would have preferred the prime of Mike Trout or whatever. I would have preferred to have the player who never won a championship, but I got Shohei Otani, but I got to watch someone who I never thought I'd be able to watch wear my uniform, and I wouldn't have traded that person for a championship."
Luca?
I think it has to be more than a one-year fix, even if that one year is your first championship in 50 years. When that trade was made, everybody thought five first-round draft picks is too much to give.
But they won the championship.
They won the championship, but a few months later, he's a bust. He can't get in the starting line. He can't play. That's not worth five first-round draft picks.
But they won the championship. If I told them right now, "Hey, you can't have the championship, but you can have the first picks back," they'd say no. They would say, "No, I prefer the feeling from last year."
But that doesn't make it an ideal situation for the Knicks by any means.
Like do you think the Toronto Raptors, like was it a bad trade what they traded away for the one year of Kawhi? They won the championship. They've been shit since. It was a great trade. It was only one year.
Yeah, but it's different.
It was a great trade.
But he won the championship. Like that no one would dispute that there's any amount of trade that wouldn't be worth it for the guy being the guy who wins the championship. Mikhail Bridges was like the fifth most important player on that team, if that.
Yeah, that's a valid piece. But if the alternative is no championship, like what would it take? I'm just thinking as I grew up a Bangles fan, Browns fan, and knowing those fan bases will literally do anything to bring a Super Bowl home, five years of first-round pick. It could be 10 years of first-round pick. They could pick up I was even trying to think of them moving the team to Baltimore. They would feel better if they made a decision that ended up being the reason they moved the team to Baltimore if they still had a Super Bowl. They would still sign up for it.
Are you guys aware of how ridiculous it is? And I don't think Hawk is wrong when he says if Deshaun Watson wins the championship, a true absurdity because I don't think the Browns are any good. But if the Browns were to win the championship, do you realize that we will have gone in the Deshaun Watson story from it being the single worst contract in the history of the sport to Hawk's assessment being the single best trade in the history of that region in sports ever?
We did this here with Sergei Bobrovsky. It was a horrendous albatross of a contract. And now I'll tell you, it's the greatest freedom signing in Panthers history.
Thank you.
But the Mikhail Bridges analogy would be the Browns win the Super Bowl and Deshaun Watson is a big reason. And then next October, he flames out and he's never the same and they're still eating that contract into the next decade. So is that a good trade? I think it can be both. If you win the Super Bowl, you can argue the Deshaun Watson trade is good. But if he flames out next year, no, you can't, I don't think.
I think most people listening to this would just arrive at the assessment that any trade you make that wins you the championship is a good trade and worth it and it doesn't need any context after that of any kind.
Especially in Cleveland. Especially in Cleveland. We went 1 in 15 in 2016. We went 0 in 17 in 2017. Multiple years of as low as you possibly can without a championship. They would sign up for that. I'm telling you 10 times out of 10. In Miami, the Dolphins haven't won a Super Bowl since 1973. Let's say Tua had led the team to a Super Bowl win. And then the next season, he flames out. They don't even want him anymore. He can't get on the field.
That contract they gave him, they're still paying for right now and next year and the year after that. Is that a great trade? I mean.
If he wins you a Super Bowl? As the quarterback of the team?
No. No, no chance because.
It can be both.
You're prioritizing one year of elation and the feeling of.
One year of the greatest thing that could possibly happen.
Totally. At the top of the mountain in your life for that team, yes, and for the fans. But that memory dissipates, especially generations down the way. If you're a mediocre team then and you have no chance of competing for the next decade or two decades or hell, with the Knicks, could be 50 years.
So the Knicks fan gets to continue living exactly the way he's been living. But he had the one year. Like he had the year.
But once you get that taste, you get the needle in the vein. You want that feeling again. And now there's no chance.
I said before any of this happened this season that I would be more stunned and it's a little bit of hyperbole, but I would be more stunned if the Knicks won a second one than I was by them winning their first because I just don't see that team and didn't see that team last year being what it ended up being and they caught a bunch of breaks and they earned it with one of the great playoff runs of all time. But I don't think that New York Knicks fans would trade that for anything. I don't think they'd trade it. Like I don't know where I'd have to put these numbers for a fan base to say, "What would you rather have?"
In fact, put this on the poll. What would you rather have? The guarantee of one championship or the possibility of one for 10 years? What would you rather have, the guarantee of one or the possibility that you get 10 years? You may be competitive, but I'm not guaranteeing you anything. You're just going to compete for it. Maybe you win four. Maybe you don't win any. It's like buying insurance in blackjack. I think New York just ends up taking the one.
"Yeah. 'Malockey.' Sure."
Noah Eagle's ever-competitive father, Ian, definitely loves him. He also had a pet parrot when he was growing up.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices