Transcript of AEE 2723: Puzzling Prepositions Part 1: On or With?

15:52 14 min read 0 views Published about 3 hours ago

Copy link
Episode summary

In this episode of All Ears English, hosts Lindsay McMahon and Aubrey Carter explore the prepositions 'on' and 'with' as they describe things a person carries, such as keys, ID, money or a pen. Prompted by a listener question about whether Americans say 'on me' or 'with me', they explain that 'on you' usually means something is physically in a pocket or purse within reach, while 'with you' can mean available nearby, such as in the car.

The conversation also covers the more formal 'on your person' used in news reports and safety instructions, and includes a role play showing how these phrases sound in everyday situations. Listeners will learn how to choose between the two prepositions and why the difference matters.

In this episode Aubrey Carter, Lindsay McMahon

This All Ears English episode on on versus with was made with the professional transcription technology behind HappyScribe.

Speaker 100:00:00

This is an All Ears English podcast, episode 2723: Puzzling Prepositions, Part 1, "On or With." Welcome to the All Ears English podcast, downloaded more than 200 million times. Are you feeling stuck with your English? We'll show you how to become fearless and fluent by focusing on connection, not perfection, with your American hosts, Aubrey Carter, the IELTS quiz, and Lindsay McMahon, the English adventurer, coming to you from Arizona and Colorado, USA.

Advertisement00:00:40
Speaker 200:01:00

Do prepositions confuse you? Today we tackle the prepositions "on" and "with" to ask someone if they have something in their possession. Listen in today to this Part 1 of a 3-part series.

Advertisement00:01:19
Speaker 200:02:10

Hello, Aubrey. How's it going today?

Speaker 100:02:13

I'm great, how are you?

Speaker 200:02:14

Good, glad to be on the mic here on All Ears English. I do have a question for you. Are you ready?

Speaker 100:02:19

Yeah, let's do it.

Speaker 200:02:20

So if you needed to ask someone if they have their ID, let's say, for example, you're out at a bar or something, would you say, "Do you have your ID with you?" Or would you say, "Do you have your ID on you?"

Speaker 100:02:33

Ooh, good question. It would sort of depend on what I mean, right? If I'm asking if they have it in their pocket or in their purse, like with them right now, I'd probably say, "On you." Do you have your ID on you? But if I mean, "Did you bring it tonight?" Like it could be in the car, then I'd say, "Do you have it with you?"

Speaker 200:02:51

Right, right. So a little bit of nuance there. And I know that "on you" can feel a little bit more informal. So we're going to go into this topic today, and this is based on a question from Mateo. So Aubrey, do you want to read the question?

Speaker 100:03:04

Yes. Mateo said, "Hello, Aubrey and Lindsay. How's it going? I've just heard the FOMO YOLO episode. So fun. That was a great episode."

Speaker 200:03:12

Yeah, that was fun.

Speaker 100:03:14

Scroll back if you missed it, or maybe search FOMO on our blog to find that, or in the app. And then Mateo said, "I have a question. Would you say, 'I don't have my keys on me or with me?' I'm pretty confused about it because AI told me that Americans only say 'with me' and in the UK they say 'on'. But the problem is, I do hear Americans say both. Thank you so much. I just love the show for real. Have a good one, Mateo."

Speaker 200:03:38

I do too.

Speaker 100:03:38

Mateo just sent in a few other questions. Shout out to Mateo, a longtime super listener. What a great question.

Speaker 200:03:44

Yes. Guys, if you have a good question, we want to hear from you. Send your question into support@all-earsenglish.com. And I love that he said, "I just love the show for real."

Speaker 100:03:54

Such a great turn of phrase. So fun.

Speaker 200:03:57

It really is. So I mean, the answer is yes, we use both, right?

Speaker 100:04:01

Exactly. When we're talking about something we could have in our pocket or in a purse, like keys, ID, money, et cetera, we will say both, but there is a slight difference in the meaning if we use one or the other of these prepositions.

Speaker 200:04:14

Yeah. And Aubrey, we do get a lot of questions about prepositions. So what are we doing this month or this next couple of weeks?

Speaker 100:04:21

Yes, we're doing a series. This is a series.

Speaker 200:04:23

On prepositions. And Part 2 will actually be on the Business English podcast. So be sure that you're following All Ears English and also our Business English podcast to get this entire series.

Speaker 100:04:33

Awesome. Love it. Guys, yes, make sure you're following both shows. If you're not sure if you're following, go ahead and open the search bar. Search for Business English, hit that follow button, come back here to All Ears English, hit follow. Go to the top, wherever it is on your podcast. We all have different apps that we use to listen to the show. Make sure you are following or subscribed on YouTube. So Aubrey, let's break it down here very clearly. So "on" as a preposition really means physically with you, right?

Speaker 200:05:02

Exactly. Yeah. And it's interesting because it doesn't mean "on top of," like "on a surface." Like you often think this preposition would mean. When we say something is on us, we often mean it's in our pocket, it's in our purse, it's right with us. So for example, "I don't have my phone on me" means it's not in my pocket, it's not immediately in my reach.

Speaker 100:05:21

Yeah. Or for example, "I'll pay for Mark. He doesn't have any money on him." Okay?

Speaker 200:05:26

Yeah. Interesting. Or, "Let me grab my wallet. I don't have it on me." Meaning it's not in my pocket, it's not in my purse, I don't have it right with me right now.

Speaker 100:05:34

Yeah. And again, like you said, Aubrey, we're not saying it's like not on your shoulder or something.

Speaker 200:05:39

Right. It's not on my head.

Speaker 100:05:40

On your head. No. It's on your person in a sense, right? And that's what we're going to get into in a second. But we also have the phrase, "Do you have a pen on you?" Right? "Do you have a pen on you?" Very casual way of asking, "Can I borrow a pen?"

Speaker 200:05:54

Yeah. That's how we'll often say it, right? If we are at a doctor's office and we're asking to borrow a pen, we might say that. Or a friend, right? If we're just out and about, we need to write something down. "Do you have a pen on you?" Means, "Do you have a pen?" Like in your purse, do you have one?

Speaker 100:06:08

And I think just to get super nuanced, just because I know that our listeners love this at the B2, C1 level, if I went to a doctor's office, I feel like I'd be more likely to step up to the desk. Let's say I'm in the reception. I might say, "Do you have a pen?" Or, "Do you happen to have a pen?"

Speaker 200:06:22

That's a good point.

Speaker 100:06:23

Just because that person's not moving anywhere, right? That person's situated at a desk. But I agree, Aubrey, if a friend, you and a friend are out in the city walking around, then I would tend to say, "Do you have a pen on you?"

Speaker 200:06:35

Exactly, right? I sort of corrected myself halfway. I'm like, "At an office? No, actually, it's if I'm out and about with a friend and I need a pen." Then I'd be like, "Do you got a pen on you?" Right?

Speaker 100:06:44

Yes. That's such a nuance there. But these are little things that we can pick up and feel much more comfortable with English.

Speaker 200:06:50

Exactly. So interesting. And you mentioned this phrase, "on your person," meaning carried with you or physically on you. Really, when we say, "Do you have it on you?" It's this for sure, a shortened version of this for something to be on your person. And this is what we'll hear often in a news report. For example, it might say, "The police found a knife on his person." It's this polished, professional, up-leveled way of saying it was on him.

Speaker 100:07:16

Right. Or, "Please be advised, you should always have some form of identification on your person." So again, this is more like we said, institutional, formal. Aubrey, would you ever say, "Do you have a pen on your person?"

Speaker 200:07:27

Never.

Speaker 100:07:28

No. You're going to read this in some kind of instructions or see it on like a safety card, hear it in a news report, something like that. It might be on like the write-up of a police incident. But you would never say to someone, "Do you have your phone on your person? Do you have your keys on your person?" No. It's very formal sounding.

Speaker 200:07:46

Yeah, for sure. Okay. So then "with." How's it different?

Speaker 100:07:49

Yeah. So this is slightly different. Often, a lot of these things we said, it's very interchangeable. You could say "with" for any of these because you're just asking if they have it. But when you say "with," it means sort of available to you while you are somewhere. So the emphasis isn't necessarily on its physical location or that it's actually in your purse or in your pocket right now. It's more like, "Could you access it right now?"

Speaker 200:08:11

Right. So for example, "I have some gum with me. I think it's in the car." Yeah.

Speaker 100:08:16

Yeah. And you wouldn't say, "I have some gum on me. It's in the car." No, because then it's in the car. It's not on me.

Speaker 200:08:21

Yeah. If it's on you, it's got to be in your pocket or somewhere. "I have my purse with me, but Maggie's holding it and I'm not sure where she went."

Speaker 100:08:30

Right. So it's interesting how we'll say this. It's like, "I don't actually have my purse with me. If Maggie hasn't, she's gone, but I know she's here somewhere," right? "I still can access it. I'm out, I'm away. She's in the restaurant somewhere, maybe on the sidewalk." So I'd still say, "Yes, I do have my purse with me. Let me go grab my wallet."

Speaker 200:08:46

Exactly. And then asking the question, "Do you have an umbrella with you?" Right?

Speaker 100:08:51

Do you?

Speaker 200:08:52

Aubrey, everyone has a different theory about umbrellas. Well, this was more so when I lived in a place where it rained all the time, right? New York, for example, Boston. It doesn't really rain where we live. I don't think it does. Where I live, it doesn't rain much. Does it rain in Arizona?

Speaker 100:09:06

Almost never, right? We have a monsoon season in the fall, but it rains so rarely that when we need an umbrella, we're like digging for it. Like, "Where is this umbrella?"

Speaker 200:09:15

But I feel like on the East Coast, maybe you experience this. Umbrellas were kind of like a take it or leave it sort of thing. Like you might take your umbrella, you might leave it, and then you might pick up in certain situations, in certain places. Do you remember how we'd always see skeletons of umbrellas like on the sidewalk? One has like flipped inside out and broken and someone just ditches it on the sidewalk or next to a trash can.

Speaker 100:09:36

Totally. They're so, you know, the easy come, easy go kind of thing. When it comes to umbrellas, it's sort of interesting. So anything else we need to know before we take a quick break, Aubrey?

Speaker 200:09:46

Yeah. This is the main, sort of the pro tip here is unless you have it, like you said, Lindsay, in your pocket, in your purse, then you wouldn't say you have something on you. If you could access it, but it's in the car or something, then you could say it's with you. So that's the main differentiation. We only say something's on us if we could like grab it right now with our hand.

Speaker 100:10:06

Right. Love it.

Advertisement00:10:10
Speaker 100:11:02

Okay, Aubrey, let's go into a role play. So here you are picking up me and I'm your friend here. Okay?

Speaker 200:11:07

Yes. All right. So I was driving and I've come to your house to pick you up. I'll start us out.

Speaker 100:11:12

All right.

Speaker 200:11:12

Are you ready to leave?

Speaker 100:11:14

Almost. Do you have your ID with you?

Speaker 200:11:16

Yes, it's in my wallet.

Speaker 100:11:18

Okay, great. I've heard this place cards everyone.

Speaker 200:11:21

Ooh, I'll wager 10 bucks. They don't card me.

Speaker 100:11:24

You're on.

Speaker 200:11:26

By the way, do you have any cash?

Speaker 100:11:28

I could grab some. Why?

Speaker 200:11:30

I only have my credit card on me and I think this place only takes cash. Mind covering me and I'll Venmo you?

Speaker 100:11:35

No problem. Very typical conversation here, Aubrey.

Speaker 200:11:39

Absolutely. Especially for me because I am one to forget my purse, forget an umbrella, forget my wallet. I'm like, "You got me? I'll Venmo you."

Speaker 100:11:47

Yeah. We did this. My partner and I drove down to New Jersey from Boston a few years ago, and my partner did not have an ID at all. Like no ID. We realized it once we got there to New Jersey. This is like a 300-mile car drive. No ID.

Speaker 200:12:03

Oh boy.

Speaker 100:12:04

And more and more, like maybe you'll be okay, right? We're at a certain age where sometimes we won't get carded because my card is my face. See the wrinkles? I'm not going to get carded, but you never know.

Speaker 200:12:15

You should have your ID with you because I have that an ID. Yeah, for sure. It's kind of scary.

Speaker 100:12:20

You have to do all the driving.

Speaker 200:12:22

Yeah. And so now I'm always like, before we leave the house, do we have IDs? Do we have credit cards, right? Do we have the key things that would stop this trip?

Speaker 100:12:29

Exactly. Yes. You have to check. So this is interesting. We'll go through this here. I first asked if you're ready to leave, and then you said, "Do you have your ID with you?" So this is interesting because I drove here, I've come to the door to pick you up, my purse, my wallet, everything might be in my car. So you wouldn't say, "Do you have your ID on you?" Because you're not asking. You don't care if I have it in my pocket. You just want to know if I brought it with me. So what you'd say is, "Do you have your ID with you?" Or, "Did you bring your ID?"

Speaker 200:12:55

Good. Yes, exactly. With you, not on you, right?

Speaker 100:12:58

And you could say that, but then I might say, "No, but it's in the car." And then there's going to be more questions. You'd have to be like, "Okay, but is it in your car?" So you wouldn't say on you because you don't want to be that specific. You just want to know if I have it in general.

Speaker 200:13:11

Exactly. Exactly. And then you said, "By the way, do you have any cash?" And we didn't say, "Do you have any cash on you?" Why, Aubrey?

Speaker 100:13:19

So because what I am asking you, I'm letting you know that I didn't think to bring cash. So what I mean is, "Do you have any cash here at your house that you could go grab?" Like maybe you have it on you, but I'm asking, "Do you have cash while we're here at your house before we leave?" If we get to the restaurant and now you're not home, then I might say, "Do you have any cash on you?" Because I'm asking, "Do you have it on your person?"

Speaker 200:13:40

Right. And I say, "I could grab some. Why?" And you say.

Speaker 100:13:44

I said, "I only have my credit card on me, and I think the place only takes cash." And I could say with me here if I mean, you know, it's in my purse, it's in the car, but this works too, right? I've got my wallet in my pocket, or maybe I've got my credit card tucked into my phone. So I say, "I only have my credit card on me."

Speaker 200:14:01

Yes. Love it. So good. Guys, great question from our listener. And another episode to check out is 2722. We wager. You'll love this episode. That was a good one,

Speaker 100:14:11

Aubrey.

Speaker 200:14:11

I don't know if you guys caught that I said, "I'll wager." I do this with friends sometimes if they're like, "Be sure to bring your ID." And I'm like, "I bet they won't ID me." Or maybe I'd say this playfully, "I'll wager they don't ID me." And we have this sort of competition. If ever someone doesn't get or if someone does get ID'd at our age, then they're like the winner. It's like, "Ooh, I look so young. I got ID'd."

Speaker 100:14:32

You win. I know at some point it flipped over into, "I don't want to be ID'd too. I do want to be ID'd."

Speaker 200:14:37

Now you do want to be ID'd, right? You have bragging rights.

Speaker 100:14:39

I'm not sure when that happened.

Speaker 200:14:40

If you get carded.

Speaker 100:14:42

For sure. Any final takeaway for today, Aubrey, for our listeners?

Speaker 200:14:45

Yeah. This is so great. It really isn't that big of a deal if you say on or with, but this is one of the things that pushes you up to C1 because natives notice. Native English speakers notice if you are saying on when you mean with, right? This little or there could be a little bit of a confusion if you say on, they're like, "No," but then later you find out it's in the car. So you do want to say actually what you mean.

Speaker 100:15:08

Yes, exactly. All right. Really good episode today. And guys, hit the follow button so you don't miss this series, right?

Speaker 200:15:15

Yes. Awesome. Hit follow on both Business English and here on All Ears English for the entire series.

Speaker 100:15:21

All right. See you soon. Bye.

Speaker 200:15:22

Bye.

Advertisement00:15:27
Episode description

Want to know your English level? Take our free English-level quiz here to find out what your current English level is. 

Do you love All Ears English?  Try our other podcasts here:

Business English Podcast: Improve your Business English with 3 episodes per week, featuring Lindsay, Michelle, and Aubrey

IELTS Energy Podcast: Learn IELTS from a former Examiner and achieve your Band 7 or higher, featuring Lindsay McMahon and Aubrey Carter with Jessica Beck in previous episodes

Visit our website here or https://lnk.to/website-sn

If you love this podcast, hit the follow button now so that you don't miss five fresh and fun episodes every single week. 

Don’t forget to leave us a review wherever you listen to the show.

Send your English question or episode topic idea to support@allearsenglish.com

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices