Transcript of Trump Admits Mass Deportations and Building the Wall Was All a Total Scam. Tucker Responds.

01:09:18 51 min read 56 views Published 5 days ago

Copy link
Episode summary

This episode of The Tucker Carlson Podcast argues that Ronald Reagan's 1986 amnesty law helped drive later immigration, population growth and demographic change in the United States. Tucker Carlson looks back at Reagan's record and the amnesty speech, then links the law to language diversity in public services, wage pressure on lower-income workers and the labor needs of agriculture.

He also examines Donald Trump's recent comments on deportation and amnesty after the midterm elections, and claims that business lobbyists and neocons push for more immigration. Listeners will hear the host's arguments presented as his own views, alongside the clips and statistics he cites.

In this episode Tucker Carlson

This Tucker Carlson episode on Reagan's 1986 amnesty and immigration was made with the same technology behind HappyScribe's meeting transcription.

Tucker Carlson00:00:00

It's hard to remember now, but people mocked Ronald Reagan and, in fact, expressed what seemed like genuine alarm about Ronald Reagan based on his age when he was president. Ronald Reagan was the oldest man at the time to serve as president of the United States. He was 77 when he left office. Of course, he died of Alzheimer's. But even while he was president, people accused him of having Alzheimer's. He was seen as very, very, very old. Well, 40 years ago this week, Ronald Reagan was in his second term, two years into it.

It was right after the midterm elections. Of course, that year, 1986, in which Republicans did very badly, Ronald Reagan was 75 years old at the time. And this is not widely remembered, but it was that year, 40 years ago this week, that Ronald Reagan signed an amnesty bill, probably the first in American history, that gave amnesty legal status to people who had been breaking the law and basically wiped away their crimes, sort of as if by magic, a stroke of a pen, and put them on what we now refer to as a path to citizenship.

It legalized them. About 3 million people, people who were living here legally, and thanks to Ronald Reagan signing this, they were on their way to becoming citizens. And people don't remember it in part because history records Ronald Reagan as a terrifyingly right-wing president. And by the second year of his second term, he'd been hearing that, well, for six years. Ronald Reagan is a racist because you may not remember this. He began his national presidential campaign in 1980 near a town called Philadelphia, Mississippi, where three civil rights workers famously had been murdered during the civil rights movement in the 1960s.

It wasn't actually in Philadelphia, not to relitigate all this 46 years later, but it was very meaningful at the time. Ronald Reagan began his first term as president with every headline in the country calling him a racist, and they kept it up, well, almost the entire time he was president. So six years in, Ronald Reagan had been called a racist, a fascist, a Nazi every single day for six years. And he was probably a little tired of it, in part because whatever Ronald Reagan was, he was not actually very right-wing, at least on the social issues.

It was Ronald Reagan who signed the second legalized abortion law in the United States. A few months after Colorado signed its law legalizing abortion in 1967, Ronald Reagan legalized abortion in the state of California. He is not remembered for that. In fact, AI probably won't even tell you that, but it's a fact. Ronald Reagan was an abortion pioneer, legalizing abortion in the country's biggest state. Ronald Reagan was also married to a liberal woman and had a liberal daughter and was, as just noted, demonstrably liberal on the social issues.

You wouldn't have known that unless you paid close attention because, again, he was constantly being attacked as a Nazi and too old. And so it's possible that six years into his term as president, he just kind of gave up and signed the biggest amnesty bill in American history. Ronald Reagan is really kind of the father of radical demographic change in this country. In any case, we thought it'd be interesting to look back 40 years to the week at Ronald Reagan signing amnesty for 3 million illegal aliens.

Here he is.

Speaker 200:03:17

This bill, the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 that I'll sign in a few minutes, is the most comprehensive reform of our immigration laws since 1952. It's the product of one of the longest and most difficult legislative undertakings in the last three Congresses. Further, it's an excellent example of a truly successful bipartisan effort. The administration and the allies of immigration reform on both sides of the Capitol and both sides of the aisle worked together to accomplish these critically important reforms to control illegal immigration.

Distance has not discouraged illegal immigration to the United States from all around the globe. The problem of illegal immigration should not therefore be seen as a problem between the United States and its neighbors. Our objective is only to establish a reasonable, fair, orderly, and secure system of immigration into this country and not to discriminate in any way against particular nations or people. Future generations of Americans will be thankful for our efforts to humanely regain control of our borders and thereby preserve the value of one of the most sacred possessions of our people, American citizenship.

Tucker Carlson00:04:31

Well, the first thing you notice, he doesn't seem that old, really, certainly by modern standards. Again, he was 75 when he gave that speech. Some say he had Alzheimer's as he gave it. And yet he was still younger than at least 10 current sitting or in some cases slumping members of the United States Senate who are much older than Ronald Reagan was. And of course, our current president is 85 years older than Ronald Reagan was. In any case, if you listen to what he just said, he said, this is actually this bill to provide amnesty to people breaking federal law is actually an effort to stop illegal immigration.

He said that multiple times. Future generations will thank us for securing our borders and preserving the value of American citizenship. So the reason to play something like that, the reason to watch that, apart from its inherent historical interest, is to measure the promises of the time against the reality of the present. And there is a big divide between the two. Of course, 40 years later, citizenship is barely recognized as a concept by states and municipalities across the country and perhaps coming soon by the federal government.

People who are not citizens, who are foreign-born and foreign nationals, people who are citizens of other countries but here illegally, get to vote in elections across the country. Not in federal elections, but in state and local elections. Did the amnesty law of 1986 reduce illegal immigration? Well, let's see. At the time there, and of course, no one ever knows exactly how many illegal aliens are in the country at any one time because they don't register. And for some reason, in a nation that has really led the world in counting things and creating metrics in measuring everything that is based on the scientific method of measuring things, we can't seem to measure within like 10 million the number of illegal aliens in the country.

Sort of weird. Flock cameras aren't helping at all. But in any case, it was about 3, 3.2 million illegal aliens in the country estimated when Ronald Reagan signed that law. He gave amnesty to basically all of them. Today, 40 years later, we have, well, let's see. So the liberal pro-immigration groups claim there are maybe 15 million illegal aliens in the country. The Trump administration says at various times there are 25 million. They do run the governments. They might have some sense. Other times they say there are 50 million people here illegally.

Greg Bovino, who was the commander in charge of the border patrol, whose job it was to keep track of these things, just said recently there are 100 million illegal aliens in this country. So whatever it is, whether it's anywhere between 15, the low estimate, 100, the high estimate, there are a lot more illegal aliens in this country than there were in 1986 when Ronald Reagan signed the law designed to secure our border and end illegal immigration. And this has been much written about subsequently in those 40 years. But that law giving amnesty to people who were under the shadow of the law before it was signed, in other words, they were breaking the law and they knew it and so did everybody else, making them legal did not end illegal immigration.

It inspired massive waves of it and then the perhaps inevitable demographic change that followed. So when Reagan signed that in 1986, the United States had a population of about 240 million people. Today, again, we can only guess because the one thing we're not good at counting is who lives here, but it looks like the United States has a population of about 350 million people. So that's a huge increase in people, more than 100 million people in 40 years in a finite amount of space and certainly a finite amount of infrastructure.

So by legalizing 3 million, you got tens of millions more. And if you think about it, considering the state of the American birth rate, which the higher you hike immigration, the lower the birth rate goes, and it's very low at this point, below replacement, it seems very obvious that the majority of people included in that increase of 110 million, the majority of them are foreign-born. And that means that the country has turned over completely. And the bottom line numbers tell you that.

So when Reagan signed that, the United States was about, I don't know, 80% white, 81, I think, and it's now about half. The state of California then, as now, our biggest state where Reagan was from, he was the governor, of course, famously of California, the state of California was about 70% white when he signed that. And now it's in the range of about 30%. So that's a big change, whether you welcome it or not. But there are all kinds of other changes which may or may not be connected to that observation that are not welcomed by anybody.

California had relatively little poverty in 1986. Now it's got an above-average amount of poverty. And if you drive through certain parts of it, it's all on display because there are hundreds of thousands of people living on the street. Not all of that is a result of immigration, but you can't say that stuffing the state with people from foreign countries has made it a better state because that's just not true. That combined with probably other phenomena have made it a much poorer and more dysfunctional state. When Reagan signed that, it was only 1986, not that long ago, the majority of public school students in the state of California, like the majority of the population, were white.

Now it's about 20%. Now, part of the reason for that is the absolute decline in white people in California and in America, by far the fastest shrinking group in the country, by far. But also it's a measure of the failure of California schools. So California had above-average, in some cases, top-performing schools nationwide around the time Ronald Reagan signed that bill. And now California has some of the worst schools in the country. And the test scores, though they can't quite be compared to each other because this test has been completely changed in an effort to hide the declining educational attainment of students, you can still play with the numbers a little bit and find out that the bottom line truth is fewer California students can read or do basic math than could 40 years ago.

A lot fewer and far fewer go to school. The absentee rate in California schools is almost 20%. It's like a fifth of the class just doesn't show up. So the state, in a lot of ways, certainly at the public end, services for the public, the things that everybody gets, roads, education, power, if you're not rich, the things that you rely on, in every category, the state has become, well, a lot more like the countries from which its population came. No one wants to hear that. But is there another explanation?

Advertisement00:11:11
Tucker Carlson00:12:19

So if you think about it for a second, while all kinds of great things have happened since 1986, would you go back to a country before Ronald Reagan signed that amnesty bill? You'd have to say you would because on a baseline measurement, it was a richer, more stable, and certainly more unified country. And that leads to the part that like no one ever says out loud, but maybe the most important part. And it's not how crowded are your hospitals. Answer way too crowded to use in a lot of cases. No. The question is what unites all 350 million Americans living within the borders of this country.

And the answer is increasingly hard to find. Now, for most countries, the first answer, of course, is language. We all speak the same language. And language because it shapes the way people think and process information and imagine things and dream. Language is the main driver of culture and of the stories that over time form a history. So if you don't have a language unifying the country, well, the country in the end probably falls apart or lives in a state of soft civil war like, I don't know, Belgium or Canada.

There are tons of examples. It can't live in harmony, a country that doesn't have a common language. And it doesn't. Civil wars start over language all the time, and they always have. So leaving aside the race question and even the income question, any economic question, at a core level, how does your nation hang together depends probably more than anything else on what language people speak. And unfortunately, the Reagan amnesty of 1986 has been followed by an explosion of languages.

And not just languages that people use at home, which seems legitimate, but languages that people use in public and that the government at the state level and at the federal level uses to communicate with them. So for example, in the city of Los Angeles, election materials, and we actually have the list because it was hard to believe this was real, are now provided in 23 different languages. Here are the languages that the county of Los Angeles, the biggest county in the state of California, uses to disseminate election materials.

Armenian, Bengali, Burmese, Chinese, Cambodian, Khmer, Farsi, Filipino, Gujarati, Hindi, Indonesian, Japanese, Korean, Mongolian, Russian, Spanish, Thai, Vietnamese, etc. So the question becomes, why would you educate people and give them voting instructions in a language that is not the majority language in the country? In other words, you're asking people to run a government that operates in a different language from the one they speak.

How can they weigh in in a meaningful way? How are they part of the system if they don't speak the language? And no one has bothered to answer that question because it's almost never asked. In fact, the last time anyone in the Senate asked him that question, he was immediately denounced by Chuck Schumer, the then-Senate Majority Leader, as a racist, despite the fact that language and race are completely different things. But in any case, the explosion of immigration into this country has been overwhelming in absolute terms. Very few countries in history have had a turnover demographically as quick as the one we've lived through for 40 years.

But it has also been accompanied by a total unwillingness to think through basic questions like, how do we not have a civil war? And in fact, if you think about it, if you take three steps back, the people pushing it, well, it's hard to know motive, seem to be motivated by a desire to break the country into smaller pieces, really to atomize it, to make sure that there is no common anything, no language, no culture, no religion, no race, just a bunch of individuals living in apartments on public assistance, taking orders.

I mean, not to be conspiracy-minded about it, but at every single turn, there has been an explicit effort to make certain that people aren't united in any common thing, that there's no working majority of anything. It almost seems like a divide and conquer strategy. Just saying, it is recognizable in that way. But in any case, it has happened. And then the final and most obvious effect that we used to talk about, but really do now, the mass migration into the United States that followed Ronald Reagan's 1986 Amnesty Act.

Certainly, his liberal wife and daughter were congratulating him after. And of course, he didn't live to see the consequences, as elderly leaders never do. But one of the consequences could have been foreseen, and that was the total collapse in wages for people at the bottom end of the labor market. And the reason that previous generations would have understood this is because immigration was always, always understood to be a response to labor needs. And the core tension was between employers who wanted more workers so they would have to pay less because supply and demand never changes.

If you've got more of something, its value falls. That's why grains of sand are cheap. If you have more workers, you don't have to pay them as much. But in a tight labor market with fewer workers, you have to pay them more. And what employer wants to pay more? So it was pressure from employers in 1986 and in 1965 and at the turn of the last century. At any point in American history in the 1840s where you've seen big waves of migration come to the US, it was always employers who pushed for it because they wanted lower wages.

This is not a mystery. And it's the main reason the immigration restriction of 1924, the act that kind of ended migration into the United States, well, for 40 years, was pushed by the labor unions, not because they were racist, didn't want any more people from Eastern or Central Europe. In fact, they were run in large part by people from Eastern and Central Europe. No, it had nothing to do with race. It had to do with economics. If you have more of something, it's worth less. And that includes labor. So what has been the effect of this mass migration into the United States, migration so mass, so vast, kind of resembles an invasion.

That's just true based on the numbers. What's been the effect on labor markets? Well, you may already know the answer, which is for high school educated men, they have been stagnant. For white American-born men of all kinds, they have been stagnant. White American-born women have done pretty well. White American-born men have not. And among black men American-born, not immigrants from Africa, but people who are born here, usually descendants of slaves, their wages have gone down over 40 years.

And that shouldn't surprise anybody. So that bill, which Reagan told us would end illegal immigration, actually sparked a lot more of it. 30X illegal immigration blew the population to 110 million more people at least in 40 years without building a, say, new interstate highway system or a brand new power grid. Basically the same infrastructure for 120 million new people.

And it completely shafted the group that we now refer to as Trump voters. And so if you think about it, maybe for like 10 seconds, it's not that surprising that the people who voted for Trump in 2016 and 2020 and 2024 did because they were overwhelmingly in the group whose wages had remained stagnant for 40 years thanks to immigration. Therefore, you should not be shocked when they vote for a guy who says he's going to shut it down because immigration, whatever else it is, a source of great new restaurants, and who even knew there was such a thing as Indonesian food?

How exciting. But for most people, it means you're making the same money you made 40 years ago or less with much less respect. So there's kind of no upside. In fact, there is no upside for you unless you love Indonesian food.

Advertisement00:20:18
Tucker Carlson00:21:31

So it's not a surprise why the Trump message, which and its core message was always against more immigration into the United States, always. So given that, what we saw on 60 Minutes on Sunday was a little bit surprising. Or was it? Well, we'll let you decide whether you're shocked by this or not. But here is President Donald Trump days after losing in the biggest landslide, probably in our lifetimes, in the midterm elections when the Republican Party was repudiated up and down, lost the House and the Senate by huge margins, lost seats in states that no one ever imagined were at play.

Kansas, Mississippi, Alabama, total blowout. And the question was like, how is Trump going to respond to this? Will he be defiant? Well, here was his actual response.

Speaker 300:22:25

For getting people out, I get very high marks for getting the bad ones out, but I get hurt because we also took people that had good jobs that created one violation or breaking of the law. That was that they came into the country illegally. Now, there is a large part of the country that think that they should be put out, and there's a large part of the country that think that they should be allowed to stay. If they're good people working in a landscaping company or working in a hotel or doing something, right?

And in some cases, paying taxes. And there's a large group of people think that they should be allowed to stay. So.

Speaker 200:23:04

So you think your deportation policy went too far. It was too tough.

Speaker 300:23:08

I think it might be too tough, yeah. And a lot of people would say that it's great, but a lot of people think it's too tough.

Speaker 200:23:15

What does the deal look like?

Speaker 300:23:17

I think ultimately that hurt me. I think it, well, the deal would be we would work something out. And I think it's something, I think that's something that's actually doable.

Speaker 200:23:26

But you think the Democratic Party right now has people in it who would be interested in this kind of deal?

Speaker 300:23:33

I think so, yeah. People have already called me.

Speaker 400:23:36

Yeah, people have already called me about doing the deal, about doing the one thing, well, after starting regime change wars in the Middle East that I said I would never do, which is give amnesty to a number I've described as tens of millions of people here illegally, but we've already been talking about it. Trump says, so what is this exactly? Well, those who know Trump know exactly what it is. And this is not a reflection of his deep desire to change the demographic mix of America. Probably not. He is after all a racist, remember?

No. What it likely is, is Trump's deepest desire, which is to be liked by other people. And so stung by a nationwide rejection in the midterm elections, Trump casts about for someone who might like him and finds the Democratic Party and decides, maybe we can make a deal. Maybe if I do the one thing that you want me to do, which is offer amnesty to tens of millions of people and thereby ensure that you will run this country forever, because they're all going to vote for Democrats, of course.

That's how California, by the way, went from a state that elected Ronald Reagan and Pete Wilson and George Duke Magian, a state in which Bill Clinton lost in 1992 to the most reliable Democratic state out of 50. And it's because of immigration, because there are different people there. It was 70% white, now 30%. Like it's kind of that simple. And the Democrats know that because they're, unlike the Republicans, not stupid and they lie to themselves a little bit less. Any case, Trump looks around and he says, who could possibly like me? Well, my own party's mad at me because I betrayed them and everything.

And so he just moves instinctively, as a cold animal does to the fire, toward the warmth of acceptance. And he wound up endorsing the one thing he said he would never do. So if you're shocked by this, if you're shocked by this betrayal, you probably haven't been paying close attention because actually, at almost every single point for the past six years that he has held power, Donald Trump, when under pressure, has moved in exactly this direction.

You smack him hard enough and all of a sudden he starts offering his enemies the one thing that they want that will certainly destroy him. It's a tick of his personality, but those who've watched him are very familiar with it. Charlie Kirk saw this coming. And he saw this coming at exactly the moment that Trump, in the first two years of his second term, was under the most pressure. And that was during the period when he had unleashed what we now know as the prelude to the regime change war, but it was the war to eliminate Iran's nuclear program.

And as that whole debate was going on, Charlie Kirk, in this clip, saw what was going on beneath the surface. Watch this.

Speaker 200:26:18

Literally the day before President Donald Trump was signing the big beautiful bill, I got a couple phone calls from people that you would call members of the ruling class. A lot of money and a lot of connections. They said, Charlie, isn't this amazing? We passed the big beautiful bill. I said, oh, yes, sir. And they said, now we need mass amnesty. What? I said, we haven't even signed the bill yet. They said, yeah, you know, these deportations, we're going to lose the midterms because of the deportations.

The people on the right, they'll understand. And we need to come to the middle and we need to legalize the 25 million people here in this country. I was speechless. So we don't know any details, but it looks as if President Trump might be in preliminary discussions. And I could tell you that there are many different discussions that I've had with people and they are pushing it hard to create some kind of amnesty proposal aimed specifically at farm laborers in the United States. But it's more than that. It could be hotels, it could be leisure properties. If you want to break our coalition, go and push amnesty.

That right there would be a complete collapse of everything that we have worked for. Everything.

Tucker Carlson00:27:31

Farm labor. It always starts with farm labor. We need the farmer. Who's going to pick the crops? There are still crops that are picked by hand. Not that many. No grain is picked by hand, of course. But increasingly, the world is mechanized. I mean, it's true when you go to a convenience store and you check yourself out. And it's true if you're harvesting sugarcane. For example, 1986 when Reagan signed his bill, and of course it was heavily geared toward the ag sector, which we need. It's a national security question. No American's going to pick a crop, obviously, because they're lazy.

When that bill was signed, about two-thirds of all sugarcane cut in this country was cut by hand, by sugarcane workers. You remember that? Appalling conditions. Living near Lake Okeechobee. Now, how much sugarcane is cut by hand? Ooh, about zero. In the United States, about zero. Even in Brazil, another huge sugar producer. Basically zero. It's all mechanized. And that's true for a bunch of different segments of the agricultural sector. So actually, the labor needs have reduced across the board, not just in ag, but across the country.

We need less labor. But the press for amnesty and for more immigration remains undiminished. Kind of amazing. And we'll get into why that is. What could possibly motivate that? It doesn't make any sense. But before we do, just a reminder that no one is for this. Now, there are some who are ideologically possessed on the subject and they think that any immigration restriction is racist and white supremacist and et cetera, et cetera.

If you're against immigration, you're a racist. That's a pretty small group, actually, with no working majority of anything. It's now a multi-racial country, for better or for worse. That's not changing. Most people, including the majority of Hispanic men who voted for Donald Trump, are not against immigration because of the race of the people. They're against it because it undercuts their wages. It puts strain on their services. It makes their cities less manageable, less orderly.

It makes the country poor. There's no economic justification, of course, for mass migration in 2026. Zero. It's not good for them. It's not good for anybody. And almost everybody is against it. Even the people who claim they're not against it and who parade around telling you, you know, they're getting their housekeeper a green card and they're good people and they're not racist. Well, they're all now living in Jackson Hole, Wyoming. Well, why? Because there's no diversity there. That's why. So on some level, everyone agrees with this.

This has not been good. It hasn't helped anybody. Even recent immigrants are against it. Even the majority of Hispanic men are against it. And again, it was on the basis of this pledge, I'm going to end this, that Trump got elected just two years ago. So in case you've forgotten what he said about his plans on immigration, here's a quick selection from, well, weeks before he won that election. Watch.

Speaker 500:30:37

Immediately upon taking the oath of office, I will launch the largest deportation program in American history. We'll get him out. And I will rescue every town across America that's been invaded and conquered. These towns have been conquered. When I return to the White House, we will stop the plunder, rape, slaughter, and destruction of our American suburbs and cities and towns.

We will begin the largest domestic deportation operation in the history of our country. We have no choice. The United States is now an occupied country, but it will soon be an occupied country no longer. November 5th, 2024 will be Liberation Day in America. And on day one, I will launch the largest deportation program in American history. We're going to get these criminals out.

To keep our families safe, the Republican platform promises to launch the largest deportation operation in the history of our country. I will rescue every city and town that has been invaded and conquered. And we will put these vicious and bloodthirsty criminals in jail. I'm going to kick them the hell out of our country as fast as possible.

Tucker Carlson00:32:07

We're going to deport everybody. And it was on that pledge. Everyone here illegally, not just people who criticize the Israeli government who have legitimate green cards, but people who are here illegally are going to be deported. Did he mean it? Well, let's just check the numbers. As of right now, as of tonight, which is on or about November 11th, 2026, Donald Trump has deported fewer people than Barack Obama did in his second term. Well, you say that's unfair.

That's killing Obama's entire second term versus just the first half of Trump's second term. Fair. But the pace is lower. Which is to say, if Trump deports as many people in the next two years as he has in the first two years, if he doesn't, as he just promised in the 60 minutes, if you just slow it way down, but if he keeps it up at the same racist breakneck pace, he will at the end of this term have deported fewer people than Barack Obama did in his second term.

And that's Barack Obama, who was ideologically committed to the project of changing the demographics of the United States to ensure the continued dominance of his party, the Democratic Party. He's deported fewer people than Barack Obama. That's just a fact. And by the way, if you really believed that opening up the borders during the Biden administration and letting 50 million people into the country illegally, or whatever the number was, tens of millions of people, then of course you would at least have hearings into the people who did it.

And that would be Alejandro Mayorkas of the Department of Homeland Security. And that would be Merrick Garland, the former attorney general. Where are they? Not before Congress answering questions on how they did that. Not one person that we're aware of from the previous administration has ever even been forced to answer the question under oath. Why did you do that? And how was it done? How did all these people get from South America across the Darien Gap in Panama to Mexico and then into San Diego County? Like who abetted that? Who paid for that? Who paid for all the flights into the United States?

We still don't know. And you would think that the people who run our vast law enforcement agencies and our intel agencies, for that matter, people in the West Wing, would get to the bottom of that question. Who paid for all this? Somebody did. But they haven't. And so that should have been a sign. Just like failure to release the Epstein files should have been a sign. They're not actually going to drain the swamp or return the country to what it was, which is a country in which people are subject to the law, regardless of their race, regardless of where they're from.

Everybody has to obey the law. And there's a penalty for ignoring the law. You don't get a pass just because you're from another country. How does that work exactly? But they were never serious about it. And the fruit now is completely obvious.

Advertisement00:35:01
Tucker Carlson00:37:34

So it seems clear, no matter what they're telling you, and of course they're walking back Trump's remarks on 60 minutes, well, he didn't really mean it. And Trump is telling people around him, well, if there's a bill in the Senate, we're going to insert poison pills into it. The Democrats can't possibly vote for it. But the fact is, the most famous immigration restrictionist in American history, the person who gave speeches like the ones whose snippets we just showed you, the guy who made the case against changing the country completely, who made the case against illegal immigration, the rapist and not sending their best, that guy?

That guy has just said out loud that he was too mean. This is the fruit of lower testosterone levels in old age. You start listening to the liberal chicks in your orbit, trying to please them instead of doing the right thing. Oh, my liberal daughter. One area in which Reagan and Trump have a lot in common, both loved by neocons as well. But in any case, that guy has just seeded the game. He's just admitted that he's wrong. He's just moved the marker.

Whatever the opposite of expanding the Overton window is. It's now the Overton porthole. He's basically said, anybody who wants to enforce federal law is a baddie. He's mean. Really? Does that apply to us, the rest of us? Do we not have to follow federal law now? Because if you think about it, not only is granting amnesty to millions and millions and millions, and by the way, what is the number? Trump didn't suggest it, but by his own estimate, that could be 50 million people getting amnesty.

But whatever the number is, some huge population is being told in public, no, you don't have to follow federal law. It doesn't apply to you. You get a pass. Like, that's forgotten. Never mind now. And that, of course, is discouraging to the rest of us who felt that we had some obligation, legal if no other, to follow federal law. Like, got to follow federal law. It's the law. Kind of Anglo understanding of nations. It's the law. I'll follow the law. I believe in the law. But at a certain point, it doesn't just discourage people and make them cynical.

It provokes real questions. Like, why am I doing this? Why am I paying my taxes? Like, why should I do that? They don't have to. Why can't I vape on airplanes? Seriously. Why do I have to have a driver's license for that matter? Because millions of people who are using fake social security cards and birth certificates and passports and driver's licenses are all being told they don't, it doesn't matter. No one's being penalized for it. In fact, they're being rewarded for it. Everyone else around the world who wants to come here has to stand in line in some embassy and get treated like garbage by a disinterested State Department employee.

But these people just show up here, take federal benefits, and they're rewarded for it. It's like, what am I doing? There are states, Illinois, for example, where you could be fined thousands of dollars for speeding. That was just a revenue-raising technique. Same as cigarette taxes. They don't actually care about your safety. They wouldn't be giving you the mRNA shot if they did. No, it's about raising money. Well, scolding you. And you can sort of see what's going on. But then the question is like, well, why am I participating in this? So I get pulled over for speeding in the state of Illinois.

And the corpulent governor thinks he can stick me, try to keep the state solvent on the backs of people who are dumb enough to pay their speeding tickets. But why should I be one of them, actually? If 50 million people are just told they don't have to obey the law, why do I? You can see why things fall apart really quickly. Because the system fundamentally is voluntary. There will never be enough law enforcement or flock cameras to force everybody to follow every law. People follow the law because they believe in the project. Things fall apart if you don't follow the law in other sort of Anglo folktales that are no longer operative, I guess.

But if you tell tens of millions of people that they don't have to follow federal law, you should not be surprised when tens of millions of people who are born here decide they don't have to either. And then you have to deal with the consequences of that. And good luck. So this sets a precedent, not just to the rest of the world that sees clearly coming to the U.S. has no penalty and you get free healthcare at the emergency room and free schools. But it sets a precedent for American citizens who feel like I'd be an idiot to play along.

And you see this already. Mass welfare fraud by immigrants, which is mass, I mean, it's real, documented, has changed the attitudes of a lot of Americans. Forty years ago, most Americans, self-respecting Americans, birthright Americans, or whatever they're calling them, now people born here, not could take welfare unless they really have to because it's shameful. But you look around and there's a fake Somali daycare center in Lewiston down the road. The guy's making $30 million and driving some expensive car, defrauding Medicare or the state.

And you're like, well, I don't know. Why don't I apply for veterans' benefits? Why wouldn't I? And so you can sort of see it's a race to the very bottom. And pretty soon everybody is in it for himself and no one is in it for the country. And then you really are at that point done. And the sad thing is none of this was necessary. It's not actually that hard to get control of an illegal immigration immigrant population in the United States.

You don't have to go shoot white girls, which is what the Trump administration did. Shoot some protester. She cut me off in traffic, a shooter. Behavior like that is basically designed to get you the 60 Minutes interview you just saw on Sunday, where the president sees videotape of some heavyset white girl getting shot to death at an immigration protest. And he's like, this is too mean. You don't need to do that. In fact, you probably would only do that if you wanted to turn people against deportation.

The first thing you would obviously do is ban remittances. There's no reason that people working here illegally should be allowed to take U.S. dollars and send them outside the country. And yeah, a lot of them are good people, by the way. This is sincere. I mean, they're working hard and sending money to their families back in country X. And that's great. But why is it great for us? Of course, it's not great for us. It's not good for us at all. Why is it? These are people who clearly aren't vested in our system who are just using it. And by the way, if they were working in their own countries, ask anyone from one of those countries from which there's been massive immigration.

Has immigration from your country to the U.S. been good for you? Is it good when all the energetic people leave and all the doctors leave? No, it's not good at all. So it hasn't been good for the rest of the world either, despite the screeching from the race mongers, all of whom are like white and went to Oberlin. But in real life, it's not good. So you just shut down their remittances. That would do a lot. You could also enforce the existing laws against carrying forged federal documents. What would happen if you showed up at the airport with a fake passport or a fake driver's license?

Don't try it. You go right to jail for that. But every person living here illegally and working here illegally is using fake documents. There's been no effort to crack down on them. Why is that? Well, because no one wants them deported. That's why. It's obvious. And maybe the most basic thing you could do is if you're here illegally, if you're not allowed to be here, you're violating our law in this country, you can't use any of our resources. You can't send your kids to the school. Nothing against your kids.

I'm sure they're great. It's not their fault that they're here. But there are also American kids who would like to use that school and they're paying for it. And their ancestors built it. And if you flood a school with people who can't speak English, the school collapses. It's not a better school. It's a much worse school. And anyone who says otherwise doesn't have kids. That's true. And the same is true for hospitals. Across the country, hospitals closing. Rural hospitals especially. And that's a direct result of immigration. Immigrants get sick like everyone else. And they don't have insurance. And they show up in the emergency room.

And you feel sorry for them. Of course, it's nothing against them. They're taking advantage of a system that has been provided to them in an effort to destroy the country. And it's working, of course. But if you wanted to fix it, you would say, no, of course you can't use a hospital at public expense if you're not even here legally. Why would we do that? But there's been no effort to do that whatsoever. Because again, they don't want to change it. And by the way, you might debank some of these people too.

Tucker Carlson00:46:11

Keep in mind that over the past 10 years, a lot of people who've complained about immigration into the United States have been debanked. They've been told by their bank, Bank of America, JP Morgan Chase, we're not going to allow you to bank with us anymore. These are American citizens. How many American banks have debanked an illegal alien? Probably none. And there's certainly been no encouragement from the Trump administration to do that. So the whole thing is not real. They never planned to do what they promised you they were going to do. They didn't build the wall.

They had opportunities to do that. They spent the entire first term whining about how they couldn't do it. But they didn't really try. And that's the truth. And a lot of Trump supporters, me included, kind of ignored that and imagined that Trump had the best intentions. But did he? Well, he didn't try. So we're going to get amnesty because the Republicans want it and the Democrats want it.

But what will it do to the country? And this is the thing to think about. Mass migration always has profound effects. Sometimes you can make a case for economic growth on the basis of it. Sometimes you can't. Always changes the culture. Always makes the country less stable. It always makes it less unified. Always and everywhere. But you can, as noted, sometimes justify it on the basis of labor shortages. Like we don't have enough people. Like we're building all these new factories. Who's going to run them? We need people from country X.

Can you make that case now? You make the opposite case now. And in fact, the people who are charting our future are thinking not about how to fill factories, but how to pay for the upkeep of an unemployed population. They're thinking about UBI. They're thinking about a nationwide welfare program because there won't be enough work thanks to AI and robotics. So whether or not you consider that like, great, the promise of an endless vacation, everyone's on welfare, awesome, let's go to the beach, or you consider that dystopian, no matter what side of that you're on, you can't look at the picture that's been painted so clearly for us of employment going forward, like starting now and going into the foreseeable future.

You can't look at that picture and say, you know what, we just need a lot more people in this country. Particularly people with no skills who can't speak English. You didn't graduate from high school. You need a lot more of those. And in case you don't know what we're talking about, here's the founder of Anthropic, the AI company Anthropic, saying on television what his technology is going to do to employment in the United States. You've said AI could wipe out half of all entry-level white-collar jobs and spike unemployment to 10 to 20% in the next one to five years.

Speaker 200:49:00

Yes. That's shocking. That is the future we could see if we don't become aware of this problem now.

Tucker Carlson00:49:07

Half of all entry-level white-collar jobs.

Speaker 200:49:09

Well, if we look at entry-level consultants, lawyers, financial professionals, you know many of kind of the white-collar service industries, a lot of what they do, you know AI models are already quite good at and without intervention. It's hard to imagine that there won't be some significant job impact there. And my worry is that it'll be broad and it'll be faster than what we've seen with previous technology.

Tucker Carlson00:49:38

So we're going to have mass unemployment at or above the scale of the Great Depression, which unleashed revolutionary movements within our borders, by the way. Roosevelt, using a bunch of pretty clever strategies, kept it under control in the country together, whatever you think of Roosevelt. Basically put millions of young men to work at $5 a week with the CCC, the Civilian Conservation Corps. But whatever, that was one of the most profoundly disruptive things ever to happen to the United States, the stock market crash of October of 1929.

People still talk about it a hundred years later. And we're going to have unemployment that is greater than that, where it's not just farm workers out of business, it's half of all entry-level white-collar jobs. So that's like the entire graduating class of half of American universities will not have jobs. So it's into that recipe for revolution, chaos, collapse that you're going to bring tens of millions of low-skilled foreign workers.

Because why? This isn't just a bad time to increase the population and to let in people with no skills from poor countries. It is the worst possible time. What will they do? No one knows, but they're pushing forward anyway. So that raises the question of why. Who is behind this and what are their motives? Well, as far as we can tell, there are two groups pushing for this. The first are lobbyists and the second are neocons.

So to the first, lobbyists are people who represent business interests in Washington. And as we've learned the hard way over the past 50 years, but in exquisite detail in the last week, they're the only people our elected officials listen to. People who pay them either in campaign contributions, in future jobs, jobs for their friends and family, maybe even in bribes. Can't discount that possibility. And so lobbyists from interests that employ people are putting enormous pressure on this administration to increase immigration into the country.

We don't have enough workers. We don't have enough workers. Now, in some cases, they don't have enough workers. That is true. It is a tight labor market at the lower end, believe it or not. But one of the reasons is that mass immigration has removed any incentive from the ruling class of the country and the government that it administers. Any sense of responsibility for the next generation of Americans, which is to say our schools collapse and nobody cares because you just import better educated people from Bangalore and you don't have to educate them.

It's kind of an arbitrage on the education system of other countries. That's exactly what's happened. Like why should you care about our people when you can just import new people? So immigration always causes the withering of the native-born population. Like as you import more impressive people, your population becomes less impressive. That is just a fact everywhere. You see it in the UK, you see it here, you see it all through Europe, Australia, New Zealand, and Canada.

I mean, the state-sponsored suicide program in Canada, the MAID program, medical assistance in dying, which has killed over a hundred thousand people. It's Canada's answer to rising healthcare costs. We'll just kill you. No, you can't get a new knee, but we do have a suicide shot for you. The numbers came out last year on who exactly is getting that. And it's a hundred percent white native-born Canadians. They're the ones killing themselves. No immigrants in Canada are killing themselves. Why would they? They see boundless opportunity. So but that is the nature of mass immigration. Not of all immigration, but when you turn over the population really quickly, the existing population is literally replaced and surrenders and dies.

It's always true. Every single time. And that's exactly what's happening here. So business interests, which have sort of sat by and watched this happen and who are short-term thinkers at their best, are pushing for more immigration in exactly the moment when looking out three or four years, you don't want more immigration. And among the people they are using to do this is the Secretary of Homeland Security, Mark Wayne Mullen, the former Senator from Oklahoma. Now, who is Mark Wayne Mullen? Mark Wayne Mullen is already himself kind of a lobbyist.

Mark Wayne Mullen, to name one example, and I should just say parenthetically, but emphatically, one of the most corrupt politicians we have. Mark Wayne Mullen is an investor in a Kratom company. Kratom, in case you're not aware of it, is often called gas station heroin. And it's an addictive drug that kills people that has still not been banned for some reason by the FDA. And lo and behold, we learn in the New York Times that Mark Wayne Mullen is pressuring the FDA not to criticize or ban Kratom because he is an investor in a Kratom company.

So I guess the reason it's worth bringing that up is anyone who would lobby the government while working for the government as a cabinet secretary to keep Kratom, of all things, legal, will probably lobby for anything. So who knows who got Mark Wayne Mullen, one of the most corrupt people in the United States Senate and now in the Trump administration, to say the following. But here he is on Fox News the other day, right after the loss, saying, actually, I think we need some amnesty. Watch.

Speaker 300:55:07

It seems like every time Republicans feel like they're running into a rough spot, they rush to some type of immigration deal with a party that you yourself have said has no interest in lowering immigration, legal immigration, or enforcing the laws as they exist. So why would any idea be floated to work with the Democrats on an issue that is their holy grail as well?

Speaker 200:55:30

Well, I think it depends on what you're talking about. If they want to talk about making people that enter this country here illegally legal, that's a non-starter. If they want to talk about how to reform amnesty and how the port of entries work, if they want to talk about.

Speaker 300:55:44

But why does it float DACA, Mr. Secretary?

Speaker 200:55:46

So DACA.

Speaker 300:55:47

Why do you float? Why is that the message for you guys of this election?

Speaker 200:55:50

I mean, DACA applies to children that were brought in this country of no fault of their own. They were, yes, but they were brought here of no fault of their own. And some of them may not even speak English or never even lived in their country. I think there's a part that we could look to say, listen, you're not going to become citizens because you wasn't born here. But is there a path for you to be legal? It's a very far-fetched because the president tried to do this in 2016 and the Democrats weren't interested in doing it. But before we would even consider doing any of that, we're going to make sure that, one, our base is with us on it.

Speaker 300:56:25

They're not with you.

Speaker 200:56:26

And so if they're not.

Speaker 300:56:27

They're not with you. I'm just saying this.

Speaker 200:56:28

And I'm going to tell you.

Tucker Carlson00:56:30

It's for the children. It's for the children. You can't have anonymity on the internet because we're going to help the children. We're going to save the children. You can't have firearm. You know, because of the children, we got to put Russell Brand in prison because of the children. Say the governments that, you know, are hiding the Epstein files. It's for the children. You have to have amnesty because of the children. Of course, says Mark Wayne Mullen. Of course. So clearly the calculation is here. This is of short-term benefit to certain industries.

They're lobbying the administration. You have to think, including Mark Wayne Mullen, the gas station heroin guy. And so they're making their case on Fox News, but it's for the children. So don't worry about it at all. We're just here for the children. We really, really care. Not about American children, by the way, as they die in huge numbers of drug ODs, as they use Kratom, Mark Wayne Mullen's Kratom, but foreign-born children, because we care, because we're compassionate people from Oklahoma. So there's that. There is the conventional business lobby pushing for increased immigration to expand the labor pool and lower the price of labor, as they have been doing really since the country was founded.

We shouldn't be surprised there, even though two years out, we'll have too much labor. But by that point, the costs of all those unemployed people will be transferred to the taxpayer. So it's not like Mark Wayne Mullen and his Kratom company are going to be paying anyone's unemployment, obviously. They'll be supplying more Kratom to unemployed people so they'll forget that they're unemployed. Okay. But there is another lobby pushing for mass migration and demographic change and has been pushing for it for, I don't know, at least 60 years.

It's a little less obvious why. It's not exactly clear why the neocons, people who put the interests of a foreign nation above the interests of the United States, why would they be so anxious to change the population of the U.S.? Why would they be such stalwart defenders of amnesty? If you, I don't know, got elected to the United States Senate to serve the interests of Israel, why does that mean necessarily that you're for mass migration in the United States? We don't know. And it's not a standard that's universally applicable.

I mean, none of the people you're about to see are calling for amnesty for the Palestinians, giving them a pathway to citizenship, despite the fact they've been there since the beginning of history. It's actually their land. They didn't arrive as immigrants. They were already there when immigrants came in and took their country away. But no one's talking about giving them amnesty. That's not on the table. It only applies to people from poor countries who come to the United States. What is that? So here's tape, recent tape of two of the most fervent neocons in the United States House of Representatives.

That would be Don Bacon of Nebraska. And that would be a guy called Mike Lawler, who, thank God, just lost from New York. But watch as they argue, not as they normally do, for the United States to go send more of its young men to die in the Middle East, but to open its borders even more than it already has. Here they are, Lawler and Bacon.

Speaker 200:59:39

Most Americans agree with that. Where I think most Americans also agree is that if you have been in this country five, ten, fifteen, twenty years, you've been working, you've not committed crimes, you have children or grandchildren that are American citizens, we want a legal path forward. Not citizenship, not amnesty, but a legal process forward that those people can come out of the shadows and go through.

Speaker 401:00:10

Without immigration, we have a 1.7 birth rate. That means we have a declining workforce. We have an aging workforce, less people working to pay for people on Social Security, Medicare. You can't grow your companies.

Tucker Carlson01:00:24

I mean, you shouldn't be surprised if you're willing to send other people's children to go die for Israel and Syria or Iraq or Iran, some other faraway place that has no direct connection to life here in the United States. If you're willing to literally sacrifice the children of your own nation for your donors, then of course you don't care about why Americans are having fewer kids. And of course, Americans are having fewer kids because they're discouraged about what the future looks like because of the terrible leadership in this country.

People who've sort of run a proud and rich nation into the ground. And they look at this, they're like, I don't want to have kids. And by the way, a lot of them feel they can't afford to have kids. So if you're really concerned about declining birth rates in the United States, you would, I don't know, try to make housing more affordable or do something about the tens of millions of working-age men in this country who aren't working and whose lives are not captured by the unemployment data because they're not even trying to get a job. What about them? But no one's trying to do that.

No one's trying to make college worth the cost. No one is trying to lower the price of single-family housing. No, not multi-family. You're living in some tenement that politicians can control, but like a normal house. No one's doing that. No one cares. And so after creating the conditions where Americans can't reproduce, they have the balls to lecture you about, oh, you need more people from some foreign country because there aren't enough of us. But what about us? That's never a consideration. It's the glee with which they demand that we further change this country that makes you wonder, like, what is this?

And there are really no two people who embody this worldview, exactly, is it? Maybe not a worldview. It's more like latent hostility suddenly becoming obvious. What you're watching is not people who are indifferent, actually. You're watching people who are hostile to the United States, who don't like the country as it was, don't like the people who live here, don't like the customs of the country, don't like America.

And you're watching those same people lecture you about how you don't like America if you're not willing to make it totally unrecognizable from the country you grew up in. So we just checked because we thought it'd be interesting. So Sunday night, Trump does this interview with Roth Dauthi on CBS, 60 Minutes. Pretty interesting interview, actually. And in it, he just blithely announces, yeah, I'm for amnesty. After spending his entire political career, 10 years arguing against amnesty, now he's for it, days after his party loses.

Kind of a big story. And so we checked the two most patriotic, pro-America people we can think of on the internet, people who are constantly accusing other people of being insufficiently patriotic or controlled by a foreign adversary, taking talking points from Putin or the Ayatollahs, people who are very quick to call you inadequate as an American, people who are conservative, who are on Fox News, who are representing the bedrock values of this nation.

And people like that, you would expect, would be a little bit surprised, if not horrified, to see the president of the United States whip around after 10 years of making one case and make the opposite case, in fact, the core liberal case. And we're speaking, of course, of super patriots, Mark Levin and Ben Shapiro. And so we're just sort of interested, like, what have they said on Twitter, which is their metier, where they express their deep thoughts, both lawyers, handy with the word. And so we expected long essays about, with respect, Mr.

President, you ran against this. Most people don't want this. There's no economic justification for it. And in fact, you could really wreck the country even more than your predecessors, like Ronald Reagan already have, so maybe no. And just say it in a nice way, lay it out. How would you possibly give amnesty to millions of people on the verge of the AI and robotics revolution? Tell us. But that's not what we found. What we found in both cases was post after post after post about Israel and Likud and Iran and what's happening at the other end of the earth, which is, by the way, itself an argument against mass migration.

Because when you let in the rest of the world into your country, by definition, you import not just the people, but ancient feuds. Those come too. And maybe that's why the, I don't know, pick a race, Michigan Senate race last week was dominated not by questions of what we're going to do for the people of Michigan, but by the oldest blood feud of all. Muslim versus Jew in the Middle East. What side are you on? How about neither one? Like, who cares, actually? Maybe we talk about Michigan for a second? No.

Where are you in Hamas and Islamic Jihad? Bibi. Arab-Israeli. How did that conflict come here? Mass migration. So that's kind of what you wind up with. And Mark Levin and Shapiro are perfect examples of this. As the president of the United States, who they claim they are very close to, key advisors to, announces that he's going to sell out his country even more profoundly than he did when he attacked Iran, they say absolutely nothing. Well, not nothing, actually.

Shapiro said nothing. But Mark Levin was on a roll. And you may have seen this. Last night, he dropped the news because he's not simply a Fox News host and an eminent radio show host and obviously a man of the law, a constitutional scholar, a best-selling author. You know, he's also a man of technology. He's kind of an older man, but he's got an eye toward the future. He knows where this is going. And so he released a quite lengthy tweet aimed not at the American people or even the government of Iran or even his friend Benjamin Netanyahu, but at the, presumably, there's still people who work there, the management of America Online, which is an internet company based in Northern Virginia that at one point people used for email.

And I guess Mark Levin couldn't get into his AOL. Pushing 70 and he just could not get into his AOL account. And because he couldn't, he couldn't write yet another tweet calling some American an Islamist and glazing Benjamin Netanyahu. So he was outraged by that. Last night, he signed off by saying, I can't get into my AOL account and I'm notifying the appropriate authorities. Well, this morning, around 11:30, the mystery was solved. I'm going to read this to you because this is an actual tweet.

Now, keep in mind, this is Mark Levin's almost the totality of his non-Israel-related output in the last week. And you'll notice amnesty not mentioned. And we're quoting. We all know the Iranian regime is a great fan of Tucker Carlson's America Hating videos, which air from time to time on their government-run propaganda platforms. In my case, the Iranian regime has a much different approach. My wife and I were warned yesterday by the appropriate federal agency that we might be targeted by the Iranian regime, specifically by a possible cyber attack.

Well, that appears to have occurred. That said, my brilliant staff is working around it. And this boomer will not be intimidated or silenced to the great chagrin of the woke-rike neofascists. So it turns out that when a nearly 70-year-old man who hasn't left his rec room, probably since the second Reagan term, since amnesty was signed, can't get into his AOL account, what you're looking at, ladies and gentlemen, is not ineptitude or creeping senility. No.

It's an Islamist cyber attack launched by the Islamic Republic of Iran against America's greatest patriot, Mark Levin, who somehow never mentioned the fact that his president is about to usher in amnesty. So why do we tell you this? Because when you don't acknowledge something like what Trump said on Sunday, you're doing it for a reason. And that's because you endorse it. And make no mistake at all, the people who would like to change the population of Gaza would very much like to change the population of the United States.

And they are. Thanks for joining us. We appreciate it. We'll see you next Wednesday at 6 o'clock Eastern.

Episode description

Now we’re getting amnesty? Why are neocons always pushing for radical demographic change?

Paid partnerships with:

Baerskin: Buy any 2 BaerSkin hoodies & get the rain jacket thrown in for free! Text TUCKER to 36912 and Baerskin will send you a link directly.

@MenGoToMars For a limited time, our listeners get 50% off FOR LIFE, free shipping, AND 3 free gifts at Mars Men at MenGoToMars.com/TuckerAmerican Financing: NMLS 182334, nmlsconsumeraccess.org. Average savings based on borrowers who save over $199.99. Call 800-685-5696 or visit http://www.AmericanFinancing.net/Tucker.

Last Country Supply: Put your fears at ease. Stock up on survival essentials at https://lastcountrysupply.com/tucker
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices