Transcript of Trump's Pick Just Fell Apart

20:38 15 min read 0 views Published about 6 hours ago

Copy link
Episode summary

This episode covers a Senate confirmation hearing for Trump's nominee for Navy Secretary, Hung Cao, where several Democratic senators pressed him on the Iran war. Clips feature questions about the USS Abraham Lincoln's conditions and reported suicide attempts, the costs of the naval blockade and damage to a Bahrain base, Strait of Hormuz escorts and insurance rates, and aircraft carrier launch systems.

Host Ben Meiselas presents the exchanges and the senators' criticisms, while Cao's responses are heard as his own answers. Listeners hear how the questioning unfolded and where his answers drew objections from the senators.

In this episode Ben Meiselas, Hung Cao

This transcript of the Senate hearing on Hung Cao's Navy nomination was made with HappyScribe technology, the same technology behind Google Meet AI notes.

Ben Meiselas00:00:00

Donald Trump's pick to be the next U.S. Navy Secretary was just grilled under cross-examination during his Senate confirmation hearing. The acting Secretary of Navy, Hung Kao, who's now trying to be the Secretary of Navy, had a full-fledged meltdown during his Senate confirmation hearing moments ago. Let me show you what went down. First, I'll show you Democratic Senator Duckworth cross-examining acting Secretary of Navy Hung Kao during his confirmation hearing. Let's play this clip.

Tammy Duckworth00:00:30

Let me tell you something: I am a war fighter. I spent 2 decades—over 2 decades—as a war fighter. I am married to a man who spent 3 decades as a war fighter. I am the daughter of a gentleman who served during 2 wars. My daughter is named for Great Aunt Pearl, who was an Army nurse who kept a pistol in her bra even as she served, and even as she treated German POWs on multiple crossings across the Atlantic while being hunted down by German submarines.

So let me tell you something: this is about you becoming Navy Secretary, and are you going to stand up for the men and women in uniform? And the question is not about whether or not we're going to let the Iranians control the Strait of Hormuz. They didn't control the Strait of Hormuz before this ill-thought-out war. Now we've given them veto power over the Strait of Hormuz that they did not have before Trump, the five-time draft-dodging coward who decided to launch this war. So let's be clear: as someone who did lead troops, unlike our Secretary of Defense, who, by the way, managed to make it to the rank of Major without a ranger tab, jump wings, or an air assault badge, or a company command, the most unqualified Secretary of Defense in this nation's history, as someone who had more experience than that Secretary of Defense, did you or did you not stand up to this Secretary and say, "Mr.

Secretary, I do not think that moving forward is going to be in the best interest of the readiness of our nation's Navy"? Did you stand up to him and tell him that it was time to bring our troops home?

Hung Cao00:02:10

Senator, I want to thank you and your family for your service, and also your personal sacrifice as well. Again, I was born in war just like you were.

Tammy Duckworth00:02:20

Answer my question: did you stand up to the Secretary of Defense? Did you tell him and urge him and tell him that moving forward and not ending this war was not in the best interest of the United States of America?

Hung Cao00:02:31

Senator, my job is to organize, train, and equip the United States Navy. And when we had to bring the Abraham Lincoln home, I worked with the Secretary of War, including the Indopecom and the Central Command Commander, in order to get the George Washington into the.

Tammy Duckworth00:02:45

Did you push Secretary Hegseth to end this war? Did you tell him? Did you tell him that?

Hung Cao00:02:51

Senator, it's not within my— it's not within my purview to do that.

Tammy Duckworth00:02:54

It is within your purview to tell him and to urge him. Did you do that?

Hung Cao00:02:59

But, Senator, I mean, the Iranians have been killing us for 47 years. Senator, I mean, I— again, I.

Tammy Duckworth00:03:06

There is a way to conduct a war. And let me tell you something: this is a failure of leadership by President Trump and the unqualified yes-men he's installed, and it sounds like you want to be one of those. It's a failure of military strategy, it is a failure of military planning, and it's a failure of diplomacy. They started a war they didn't know how to end. They've not come to the American people and given us a plan on how they're going to win this war. Come to us and tell us: how are we going to win this war? And you are the person that's supposed to stand up and give your best advice to the Secretary of Defense.

Ben Meiselas00:03:38

Next, I will share with you Democratic Senator Gillibrand from New York's cross-examination of Hung Kao. Let's play this clip.

Kirsten Gillibrand00:03:46

Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth claimed reports of poor conditions and morale on board the USS Lincoln were, quote, "completely misrepresented."

Hung Cao00:03:56

I believe it did, Senator.

Kirsten Gillibrand00:03:57

Thank you. In August, as the USS Abraham Lincoln was nearing 9 months of uninterrupted time at sea, military families raised urgent alarms about ration supplies, sanitation failures, and severe mental health strain. Did you issue a public statement calling news reports "dishonest" and accusing the press of, quote, "trying to paint our warriors as victims"?

Hung Cao00:04:22

I did, Senator. And I spoke to our sailors on board, and they felt the same way.

Kirsten Gillibrand00:04:28

Well, I disagree with your assessment. Five weeks later, in response to my oversight letter, you yourself confirmed in writing that 8 sailors in the Lincoln strike group attempted suicide during that deployment, including one sailor who tried to go overboard in March. And you acknowledged piping failures, desalination outages, and rationed hygiene supplies. Looking back at those 8 suicide attempts and the documented conditions on board, were the President and Secretary Hegseth wrong to dismiss those concerns?

Hung Cao00:05:04

Well, Senator, again, these are 8 mitigations we're able to mitigate.

Kirsten Gillibrand00:05:07

Please don't call "attempted suicide mitigations." That is such an insult. It's an insult to these men and women who are devoting their lives to the armed services. When you say it's mitigation, you're compartmentalizing something that is clearly a mental health failure. The fact that a service member, a sailor, went overboard is beyond a mitigation. It is an attempted suicide that, but for the grace of God, was unsuccessful.

Hung Cao00:05:35

Senator, that sailor was not trying to kill himself. And he admitted that. He admitted that to the commanding officer.

Kirsten Gillibrand00:05:41

What was he trying to do? Swim to Guam?

Ben Meiselas00:05:43

Then you had Senator Slotkin of Michigan cross-examining Hung Kao. Hung Kao was trying to ask like— he was trying to act like the tankers couldn't get out of the Strait of Hormuz or the Bab el-Mandeb Strait before the catastrophic war, and then he tried to basically filibuster his answer and say, "Well, the insurance is just so high now." Yeah, because we launched a catastrophic war and every tanker needs a U.S. naval escort. And even in the past 24 hours, Iran struck 7 tankers in the Strait of Hormuz, regardless of the naval escort.

Play this clip.

Hung Cao00:06:17

Protected 3,700 merchant ships. We've been able to get 1.8 billion dollars.

Kirsten Gillibrand00:06:21

I don't— I do not quibble with how much the Navy is doing. But a year ago today, did a ship, a commercial vessel carrying petroleum products, need a military escort through either the Bab el-Mandeb or the Strait of Hormuz? In all honesty.

Hung Cao00:06:40

Well, Senator, that's why their insurance rates is $54,000 just for one transit.

Kirsten Gillibrand00:06:44

We can.

Hung Cao00:06:45

But it's so— it's so dangerous over there, Senator. That's exactly why.

Kirsten Gillibrand00:06:48

A year ago today, were the insurance rates— you're dodging the question. A year ago today, a commercial ship flagged for any nation could successfully transit the Bab el-Mandeb and the Strait of Hormuz without a naval escort.

Hung Cao00:07:04

Not always. Again, Senator, that insurance rate was a year ago $54,000. Today is $64 million just to get across the.

Kirsten Gillibrand00:07:10

I believe it because we launched a war, okay? We launched a war, and we cannot have the same— we do not have the same freedom of navigation that we had a year ago. And it's not a— you don't have to be a defense professional to understand that. The price tag of those insurance rates going through the roof, the price tag of fuel— I mean, the cost of this war, by any estimate, is over $260 billion. The average American has paid $2,000 because of the price of gas and additional delivery fees because of that.

So just, again, in an objective way of where are we on this war? And I'm someone who served in Iraq. The Iranians absolutely killed friends of mine. I understand, I think in detail, what bad actors they are. But that's different than deciding to launch a war that you can't get out of and that you had no strategic plan for.

Ben Meiselas00:08:07

More cross-examination here from Senator Duckworth. Powerful cross-examination. Let's play it.

Tammy Duckworth00:08:13

You're supposed to stand up to the Secretary of Defense, and you have done everything that you can to not answer this question. I mean, when you heard of rotten food, broken plumbing, unsafe water access for sailors on the USS Lincoln, did you tell the Secretary of Defense that this is not acceptable and that you cannot sustain that?

Hung Cao00:08:36

Senator, I went out to the ships to talk to the sailors personally. Again, we're talking about a very small.

Tammy Duckworth00:08:42

Did you talk to the Secretary of Defense and tell him that it is uns— this war is unsustainable for the Navy?

Hung Cao00:08:48

Senator, the Secretary of War knows my stance on our readiness and the strain it takes on our sailors. And again, I'm just.

Tammy Duckworth00:08:55

Okay, I cannot vote for you because you're going to be another yes-man. I yield back.

Ben Meiselas00:09:01

Then we heard from Senator Warren. Watch her cross-examination right here.

Tammy Duckworth00:09:05

Acting Secretary Kao, what is the daily cost of the U.S. naval blockade on Iranian ports?

Hung Cao00:09:13

Senator, I do not know the daily cost, ma'am.

Tammy Duckworth00:09:17

You don't have any idea? You've been running this thing since April, and you don't have any idea what that costs?

Hung Cao00:09:22

Well, Senator, I know the rough cost, how much it's costing us so far. But again, the cost of losing the Strait of Hormuz.

Tammy Duckworth00:09:28

I'm not asking you that. I just want to have the dollars here. Independent estimates are about $32.5 million a day. Does that sound about right to you?

Hung Cao00:09:39

Senator, let me do some quick Asian math in my head, but yes, it's about $30 billion so far.

Tammy Duckworth00:09:46

Okay, so you confirm that number. And that means the American taxpayers are spending about $1 billion a month just on this blockade. Let's do another. Iranian strikes have also caused extensive damage to U.S. bases and facilities in the region, including the U.S. naval base in Bahrain. It's home to U.S. Naval Forces Central Command and the U.S. Fifth Fleet and is a critical strategic hub for the U.S. military. You yourself said that Iran, quote, "blew the hell out of that base."

But the Navy has yet to tell Congress or the American people how much that damage costs. So, Acting Secretary Kao, when Iran hit our naval base in Bahrain, how much did that cost?

Hung Cao00:10:33

Well, Senator, we have not been able to do a full assessment yet because it's still a non-permitted naval.

Tammy Duckworth00:10:36

Okay, not a full assessment. What's your estimate?

Hung Cao00:10:39

Senator, it's— again, we're still making all the assessments because it's a non-permissive area for us to go into.

Tammy Duckworth00:10:46

So no number until I pull a number from somebody else? In June, the Wall Street Journal estimated that the damage to the U.S. naval base in Bahrain has cost the United States at least $400 million. That's a lot of money. It's not included in the Pentagon's estimates for the cost of this war. Does that number sound about right to you?

Hung Cao00:11:05

Senator, I'll find out.

Tammy Duckworth00:11:07

You've been running this for more than half a year, and you don't even know if this is in the right area?

Hung Cao00:11:14

Well, Senator, I can't— again, we have to assess the damage, and we still have to go in there. There's still— there's still much.

Tammy Duckworth00:11:21

You're just now thinking of assessing the damage in November?

Hung Cao00:11:24

Senator, look.

Tammy Duckworth00:11:24

So, look, Trump's war is costing taxpayers billions. It is harming our readiness, all while driving up prices here at home. So it's no surprise that the Trump administration doesn't want to reveal the total cost of this war. The Pentagon has admitted that it's at least $47 billion already, $47 billion and counting, all while Republicans have slashed health care for millions of Americans. This is outrageous. We should not spend another cent on this war, and instead we should be spending this money at home to lower costs.

Advertisement00:12:01
Ben Meiselas00:13:25

Then we heard from another veteran over here, Senator Kelly from the great state of Arizona. Here's what he had to say during his cross-examination of Hung Kao. And Hung Kao referred to the multiple suicide attempts, at least 8 suicide attempts aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln, as "suicide mitigations" is what they were referring to. They weren't attempts. They were mitigations. Here, play this clip.

Hung Cao00:13:50

As the mental health specialist as well. So that's why you say 8 suicide attempts. I see as 8 suicide mitigations that were able to keep these young men and women.

Mark Kelly00:13:58

Okay, well, it's actually both. There were 8 individuals that tried to take their own lives, and it was mitigated. I'll give you that.

Hung Cao00:14:06

Yes, Senator.

Mark Kelly00:14:07

But we shouldn't have conditions where sailors are wanting to end their lives because of the deteriorating conditions aboard the ship. Hey, these.

Ben Meiselas00:14:16

More cross-examination over here by Senator Kelly. Let's play this clip.

Hung Cao00:14:21

Senator, they are adequate. It might not be all the.

Mark Kelly00:14:24

How often does one of those ships get to zero? You say there's a week. Does it ever get down to zero?

Hung Cao00:14:30

It has never gone to zero, Senator.

Mark Kelly00:14:31

Not once.

Hung Cao00:14:32

No, Senator. It has never.

Mark Kelly00:14:33

So are you saying then that these reports of somebody losing 45 pounds are not true?

Hung Cao00:14:39

Well, Senator, it's just not what they want. It's like my kids opening up the refrigerator door and saying, "There's nothing to eat in here."

Mark Kelly00:14:44

No, I don't think that's.

Hung Cao00:14:45

Oh my gosh.

Mark Kelly00:14:46

Senator, it's. Mr. Secretary, I don't— somebody doesn't— somebody doesn't lose 45 pounds just because they don't like the options. I don't think that's a fair assessment. Have you.

Ben Meiselas00:14:57

Then you had Acting Navy Secretary Hung Kao again try to say "mitigations, mitigations." Here, play this clip.

Hung Cao00:15:05

So I care greatly for our sailors. They know.

Mark Kelly00:15:08

But your solution seems to be to continue just asking these sailors and their families for more without giving them or us the truth about what the nature and length of their deployment is going to be.

Hung Cao00:15:26

Well, Senator, I can't— I don't know. I don't control the deployment lengths. But I did answer those inquiries right away, especially with the mental health issues. You see as 8 suicide attempts, I see as 8 suicides mitigations because of the chaplains we have on board, the deployment resiliency counselors, as well as mental health specialists. Normally, most carrier strike groups, when they deploy, have about one or two suicides. This is well before Epic Fury, before all this stuff. It's just, unfortunately, this is the fight we're dealing with right now.

We had zero actual suicides on board the Abraham Lincoln. I equate that to the— again, the chaplains, the mental health providers, as well as the deployment resiliency.

Mark Kelly00:16:09

But.

Ben Meiselas00:16:09

Even Republican Senator Mike Rounds was getting deeply frustrated.

Speaker 700:16:13

Are you aware that on multiple occasions, where there have been classified discussions, our Democratic colleagues weren't invited? And when you don't invite our Democratic colleagues to join in on these high-end, specific, top-secret, and above threats, that means that it limits us to basically using Republican votes only to pick up on a reconciliation.

And if that doesn't work, a supplemental would require a 60 vote, which requires bipartisan support. Pretty tough to ask all of my colleagues to support that if they're not even invited in to hear the information in the first place. Now, we've talked about this in the past. I don't recall that you were necessarily in those meetings or not. But I want a commitment from you, and we'll ask it from others, that we move this back to a bipartisan basis when it comes to sharing critical information in the defense of this country.

And that requires a cooperative effort on your part in the future. Are you committed to that, sir?

Hung Cao00:17:24

Senator, if confirmed, I will— I commit to being open and honest with the entire Senate and the Congress also. I mean, this is a bipartisan issue. National Defense is not a partisan issue. This is a bipartisan issue. And so I give you my commitment that I will work with both sides. Just I have bringing Codelz on board, Abraham Lincoln, and Ford, I'm open and honest, and I pledge that I will be— that I'll work with both sides.

Speaker 700:17:53

Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Speaker 800:17:55

Thank you, Senator Rounds.

Ben Meiselas00:17:56

Finally, you had Democratic Senator Tim Kaine. Watch his cross-examination.

Speaker 700:18:01

On August 13th, the President released a memorandum that included language directing the Secretary of Defense and Secretary of the Navy to provide a plan for replacing the current electromagnetic launch system for aircraft carriers with steam and hydraulic systems. I recently visited the Ford, and I went on the flight deck, and I talked to the sailors on that flight deck, many of whom had worked on carriers that both had steam and hydraulic launch systems and the EMAL system. And they were very complimentary of the EMAL system, very complimentary of it.

Should the U.S. return to steam systems to launch aircraft off aircraft carriers?

Hung Cao00:18:40

Senator, the whole question is, how can I get— I can maintain 11 carriers. At this point, because of the delays with EMALs and the electromagnetic elevators, it's delaying our carriers by seven years. We're going to have five years. We're going to be down to nine carriers. I'm trying to accelerate that.

Speaker 700:18:57

And does that— and does that mean that you're considering return to steam launches?

Hung Cao00:19:02

Senator, because just the electromagnetic elevators alone, I don't know if you know, they require certain spacing. And so you weld— what they do is they weld the elevator in place, measure it, and then you weld.

Speaker 700:19:12

Yeah, I'm not asking about the elevator. I'm not asking about the elevators. I'm asking about the launches. Based, again, on what the folks on the flight deck told me, the EMAL system works very, very well. And to retrofit existing carriers or change the design, you talked about in an earlier instance, changing designs causes problems. And to go back to an old way of doing it is going to have an increased cost with diminished capacity. And so just because the President directed it, I do hope you'll consider the experience of those who've been operating these launches on the Ford in deciding before you decide to go down a path that will be more expensive and also less capable.

With that, I yield back, Mr. Chair.

Speaker 800:19:56

Secretary Kao, returning to steam is a nonstarter, and everybody needs to understand that.

Ben Meiselas00:20:07

There you had it, everybody. Let me know what you think. Hit subscribe. Let's get to 7 million subscribers. Go to store.meidastouch.com also for the latest MeidasTouch merch.

Speaker 900:20:18

One book, a whole lot of WTF. My brothers and I wrote WTF America about how we got into this mess, the millions of you who refuse to back down, and how we get out. Scan the QR code, click the link in the description, or find it anywhere books are sold, and order today.

Episode description

MeidasTouch host Ben Meiselas reports on Trump’s Navy secretary pick Hung Cao falling apart at his confirmation hearing under brutal questioning from Senators Tammy Duckworth, Kirsten Gillibrand, Elizabeth Warren, Mark Kelly, and others over the Trump administration’s catastrophic war.

Wild Alaskan: Get seafood you can trust. Go to https://wildalaskan.com/meidas for $35 off your first box of premium, wild-caught seafood.Order the new book from MeidasTouch, WTF America?!: The Way Out of This Hell and Back to Democracy, today: https://bit.ly/wtfamericayoutubeVisit https://meidasplus.com for more!

Remember to subscribe to ALL the MeidasTouch Network Podcasts: https://meidasnews.com/podcastSupport the MeidasTouch Network: https://patreon.com/meidastouchAdd the MeidasTouch Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-meidastouch-podcast/id1510240831Buy

MeidasTouch Merch: https://store.meidastouch.comFollow MeidasTouch on Twitter: https://twitter.com/meidastouchFollowMeidasTouch on Facebook: https://facebook.com/meidastouchFollow

MeidasTouch on Instagram: https://instagram.com/meidastouchFollow

MeidasTouch on TikTok: https://tiktok.com/@meidastouch
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices