This episode covers air traffic controllers' public criticism of the FAA, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin after a nationwide ground stop. The host reports that controllers, speaking to reporter Anna Ghiratelli, reject the official explanation that new equipment overwhelmed older systems and raise the possibility of a hack.
It also covers FAA administrator Brian Bedford's productivity push, a delayed 2.8% raise, controller burnout, and a contractor dispute. Listeners hear the controllers' concerns and competing accounts of what caused the shutdown.
In this episode Ben Meiselas
This episode's transcript on controllers' criticism of an FAA ground stop was made with the tool HappyScribe built to transcribe audio to text.
Ads in this audio differ from the text. Tap the sentence you're hearing to follow along.
Synced: the text now follows the audio.
FAA Air Traffic Controllers are speaking out against the Trump regime, they're speaking out against the FAA administrator Brian Bedford, they're speaking out against Sean Duffy, the Transportation Secretary, they're speaking out against Homeland Security Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen. And these FAA Air Traffic Controllers are not ruling out that what really took place is a cyber attack or a hack on their systems.
They're saying that they were not buying what Mark Wayne Mullen, or what Sean Duffy were selling. These air traffic controllers have also called out Brian Bedford, the FAA administrator. Just to give you a little background about who Bedford is: he previously served as the President and Chief Executive Officer of Republic Airways, like a former CEO, Trump oligarch guy who was put into this position, who just completely disrespects the air traffic controllers.
And they've spoken out against this guy before. I'll talk more about that in a moment, but here's what Bedford brags about. In his 26 years at the helm of Republic Airways, the airline grew from $85 million in revenues and 36 turboprop aircraft to more than $3 billion in revenues and an operating fleet of more than 250 jets, while maintaining a perfect passenger safety record. It's like a typical guy that Trump would put in that position. But after Duffy and after Mullen gave that disastrous press conference last night, Anna Ghiratelli, she reported the following.
Now, she's been on the beat for a very long time of the maltreatment, mistreatment of air traffic controllers. I got to give her credit. Follow her on X or whatever social media platform you're on that she's on if you want to focus on this beat, because she does a really good job, at least at this beat. So she said last night, "I've spoken with 60 air traffic controllers about what Sean Duffy and what Homeland Security Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen said at the White House today.
None of them, zero air traffic controllers, are buying what Duffy said, because they said these types of switches that the FAA is doing, they don't happen during the day. They don't happen during busy times like a Friday afternoon. They're doing these midweek, middle of the night when there is no air traffic going on." The controllers were saying, "We don't buy that this is actually what's happening." The reason that Sean Duffy is saying that this happened—now, the reason Sean Duffy said this happened is also very humiliating and embarrassing, though, for the Trump regime.
I mean, his story is that, well, if you listen to what Mark Wayne Mullen said, Duffy was trying to kind of hide it. Duffy said it was a data overload based on an outdated system and was trying to blame it on Biden. But the outdated system, or the older system, worked. You know, it had redundancies built into it. But what Mark Wayne Mullen, Department of Homeland Security Secretary, said is, "When we were doing the patches for the new digital system, it basically broke the old system. The new system and the old system didn't work.
So the new system basically inundated the older system with data and it broke it," basically is what Mark Wayne Mullen said. But what the air traffic controllers are saying is they believe something else was going on. Could it have been a hack? Could it have been a cyber attack? Could it have been rogue AI? The F—I mean, I think it's important that we listen to what the FAA air traffic controllers are telling Anna Ghiratelli, because they know better than me or Anna or you. This is what they do.
And I want to talk about these air traffic controllers in a moment too. I know a lot of them watch this show and we're thinking about you tonight as well. Ghiratelli explains that when she interviewed the FAA administrator Brian Bedford in August, he spoke about the big rollout that they were doing, that he was bragging about the $12 billion they got from the big, beautiful bill to overhaul the air traffic control system in 10,000 ways. And over 400 air traffic controllers privately reached out to Anna, the reporter, after the interview with Brian Bedford because they were so upset with his focus on infrastructure and not on the controllers themselves.
They're saying they've been left behind, that suicides among controllers are eight times the national average now. Nothing's being done for them. Duffy now wants $50 billion more for infrastructure, when Brian Bedford, the FAA administrator, said back in August he got the $12 billion, he was bragging about it, and the FAA air traffic controllers were pissed that they weren't being prioritized and that all this money was going to the systems.
So the money was dedicated to the systems. Also, in the Biden administration, Biden had allocated like $25 billion for modernization of air traffic control systems in the infrastructure bill. Ghiratelli also explained how she interviewed the head of the FAA back in August. More on this. She said hundreds of air traffic controllers contacted her. They were outraged that the FAA wouldn't pay them their 2.8% raise. All the air traffic controllers wanted and still want is a 2.8% raise, and Brian Bedford, the administrator, was not giving them that raise.
Although Congress approved and funded the compensation package in April, Bedford, the FAA administrator, says it was on hold until the agency could, quote, "unlock more productivity from its workers by having them work five hours at the controls each shift instead of the current four." He cited how controllers worked five hours 15 years ago. She said that she found an FAA chart that showed that the average time on position now, and then it showed controllers did not work five hours on position back then.
Again, it goes back to why was the raise really held up. In other words, Congress allocated funds for the very important job of the air traffic controllers. But the guy who was the administrator, who comes from the kind of Trump oligarch corporate world, would not give the air traffic controllers the raises that they deserve. These people work 16-hour days. They work six days a week, 16, 17-hour days.
Their shifts are crazy, and they're not getting a raise at all. Anna Ghiratelli also says three days ago the FAA administrator Bedford was supposed to testify before Congress. This past week, before this all happened, Bedford was supposed to testify before Congress, where lawmakers would have likely berated him and grilled him for not paying air traffic controllers their raises, among other issues. Brian Bedford has been silent on social media all day yesterday.
Didn't post a thing with all of this going on. He didn't even post to thank the controllers who kept everyone safe during this unprecedented ground stop. Think about that. She also says that she's hearing the same things from inside the FAA on L3 Harris, and they won't rule out cyber attacks, which makes more of a concern that the system is back up and running. Because can this happen again? Can this happen again? From a prior article that she wrote, quote, "We work hard every day and take a tremendous amount of pride in what we do," one air traffic controller wrote in a text message to Anna.
"Most of us are veterans. We have been completely demoralized for the past five years while trying to manage the busiest airspace in the world, with more airplanes than any other time in aviation. Suicide among air traffic controllers is eight times the national average. Let that sink in." She then goes on to say, "Air traffic controllers told me they believe Brian Bedford is approaching agency management entirely backward, treating a federal safety agency like a corporate balance sheet by trying to squeeze out every ounce of productivity from controllers.
Critics say he's running the FAA like a capitalist businessman, prioritizing cost-effectiveness as he did at his former company, Regional Republic Airways, while treating public safety as a secondary concern." One controller from the New York Center who retired in August said he chose to leave after more than two decades due to the deteriorating culture. "With the administration that's in now, the morale in that building is at an all-time low," he said, speaking on a condition of anonymity. The retired controller stated that management at this facility focused heavily on keeping controllers on shift longer, a movie says "actively endangers the public."
I want to remind you, during the press conference that took place yesterday with Duffy and Mark Wayne Mullen, you can see Secretary Duffy, Transportation Secretary Duffy. He's from the Real World Road Rule Challenge. That's how he got on Donald Trump's radar. He was on Real World and MTV. You can see his reaction as Mullen says that it was the new technology that overwhelmed the system and that that screwed up the system, and that's what caused the ground stop. Here, play this clip.
How about cybersecurity? Once again, we're still looking at it. We're not ruling out anything. What it appears to be right now is, as Secretary Duffy and FAA was going in and putting patches into the system, they were putting new equipment and new technology. And that new equipment, new technology, just wasn't—it was overwhelming the older system, which is why Secretary Duffy made it very clear, "The patchwork doesn't work. We need one complete system.
We need someone to come in and."
Oh, you can see how—just zoom in on this one. I want to show you from this angle how pissed Duffy was when Mark Wayne Mullen just said the reason for the ground stop, the nationwide ground stop where thousands of planes didn't take off and were canceled, was because of the new technology overwhelming the old technology. Play this clip.
Secretary Duffy and FAA was going in and putting patches into the system. They were putting new equipment and new technology. And that new equipment, new technology, just wasn't—it was overwhelming the older system.
Now, Pete Buttigieg was speaking at an event yesterday while all of this took place, and he was at the What's Next conference in Denver after the big Democratic victory in the midterms. And here was Pete Buttigieg addressing what took place with this FAA ground stop when he found out. Let's play it.
I'll begin with a public service announcement. I will be available in the hotel bar following the concert for anybody who needs to rebook their flights or get a refund per your rights.
Now, as Adam Parkemenko says, "If you're looking for the truth, here it is." Pete Buttigieg explains what his team did when the system went down and gives credit to the career staff doing the work today. Worth hearing in his own words. And notice that Pete Buttigieg, the former Transportation Secretary, talks directly about the air traffic controllers and the hard work that they do. Notice during the press conference of Duffy and Mark Wayne Mullen, they don't mention that once. Listen to what Buttigieg has to say.
Play this clip.
Hi, buddy.
Hi.
Pete, do you want to just kick us off?
Yeah, sure. First of all, obviously, like everyone else, very concerned about what's going on in the national airspace. Don't claim to have any inside knowledge. I'm approaching this as a member of the traveling public who has a flight tomorrow, but I know that lots of people's flights have been disrupted. I also know the kinds of people who work at the FAA and the Department of Transportation day in, day out. I imagine this is a very stressful day for them, but also they're very dedicated public servants. And obviously, I am hoping that they'll be able to get this resolved quickly.
Yeah, with that, happy to take any questions.
Do you want guidance for the American public?
Well, one thing I would say is passengers have rights. And so I should check the department's website and make sure you're familiar with the rights that even in a non-controllable event that you have as a passenger and try to get taken care of by the airlines.
You were Transportation Secretary. I mean, can you help us understand how much actually needs to go wrong for there to be ground stop for this magazine?
Well, what I'd say is that the system has many redundancies in it. So that normally, if there's one point of failure, something else can catch it. Even when we had what was the most extreme disruption that we experienced when I was Secretary, which was the what was called the NOTAM system going out, which triggered an outage that lasted about an hour to an hour and a half, there were actually four different systems. And when one of them went out, another one could be brought online to cover that. So it is not clear to me why that redundancy did not prevent an outage of this magnitude.
In terms of scope and duration, this is the biggest nationwide ground stop since 9/11. But again, we don't know much. I certainly don't want to speculate.
Why do you make criticism of the Trump administration if the Biden administration didn't do enough to upgrade the system?
Look, we did a lot to upgrade the system. When we had an outage, I didn't stand there complaining about the Trump administration. We got to work. And I am certain that that's what the career officials and the career day-to-day employees at FAA and USDOT are doing. This should not be about politics. What I will say, of course, is that there needs to be answers and there needs to be transparency about what happened. I imagine there will be a lot of interest on Capitol Hill. Obviously, there's a lot of interest in the public. And again, as a member of the flying public, as well as somebody who cares a lot about what goes on in the national airspace, I will have a lot of interest in getting answers too.
How difficult is it? How confident are you about this administration, the FAA? Can you look at this back up?
Sorry, one more time. It's a little harder.
How confident are you that this administration, the DOT, FAA will get this outage back up and running or restored in due time?
All I can say is that whatever differences I might have with this administration, I am very much rooting for them to get this resolved as quickly as possible.
Now it's a good time to re-up this article as well. "Trump's FAA picked an unlikely contractor to lead its air traffic overhaul. The agency is having second thoughts." This is from a while ago, this article. "One person knowledgeable about the situation said that the Virginia-based company Peraton was not meeting the moment. The FAA officials are raising concerns about the performance of a contractor overseeing the Trump administration's overhaul of the nation's air traffic control system.
Unhappiness that could result in scaling back the company's role." Three people familiar told Politico, "The friction comes just eight months after Peraton, a Herndon, Virginia-based contractor with little prior experience working with the FAA, won a $1.5 billion contract to oversee the work, which was spurred in part by the deadly January 2025 mid-air crash over Washington. The company's role is to lead coordination of the modernization effort."
The three people, including two industry officials and a person familiar with the project, were granted anonymity to discuss Peraton's relationship with the FAA. Two of those people said they had heard directly from FAA officials about the agency's frustration with Peraton, including the prospects of curtailing the contractor's role. One official described instances in which they said the contractor failed to manage other contractors at a worksite and let schedules slip on a project in Alaska.
"The issue is threefold. The big issues are threefold," said a person familiar with the discussions, adding that Peraton has basically not done any work since they got in. The person said the agency was partially at fault too, saying the agency has stonewalled Peraton's efforts to work seamlessly with the FAA counterparts. I also want to just share this with you. Anna Ghiratelli said, "Now would be a great time to subscribe to my page. It's just a way for those who enjoy my work to say thank you for going above and beyond covering the FAA and air traffic control.
And right now, that was important to my reporting. So I want to give credit where credit is due, as I always would to reporters who put in the work. She's certainly someone who puts in the work. Hit subscribe. Let's get to 7 million subscribers. Thanks for watching. Appreciate y'all.
MeidasTouch host Ben Meiselas reports on hundreds of air traffic controllers speaking out against Donald Trump, the FAA administrator, and the administration’s mistreatment of controllers. Meiselas highlights their concerns about the nationwide ground stop, why they’re challenging Sean Duffy and Markwayne Mullin’s account of what happened, and their warnings about the administration’s handling of the FAA.
Order the new book from MeidasTouch, WTF America?!: The Way Out of This Hell and Back to Democracy, today: https://bit.ly/wtfamericayoutube
Visit https://meidasplus.com for more!
Remember to subscribe to ALL the MeidasTouch Network Podcasts:
https://meidasnews.com/podcast
MeidasTouch relies on SnapStream to record, watch, monitor, and clip the news. Get a FREE TRIAL of SnapStream by clicking here: https://go.snapstream.com/affiliate/meidastouch/meidasnews?utm_campaign=4490308-affiliate2025&utm_content=customerpartner
Support the MeidasTouch Network: https://patreon.com/meidastouch
Add the MeidasTouch Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-meidastouch-podcast/id1510240831
Buy MeidasTouch Merch: https://store.meidastouch.com
Follow MeidasTouch on Twitter: https://twitter.com/meidastouch
Follow MeidasTouch on Facebook: https://facebook.com/meidastouch
Follow MeidasTouch on Instagram: https://instagram.com/meidastouch
Follow MeidasTouch on TikTok: https://tiktok.com/@meidastouch"
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices