Transcript of Russell Brand's Lengthy Sentence, Trump's Shock Immigration Deal Comments, and Disgusting Charlie Kirk Attacks, with Emily Jashinsky, Dave Aronberg, and Viva Frei | Ep. 1437

02:24:28 118 min read 103 views Published 7 days ago

Copy link
Episode summary

Megyn Kelly and guests Dave Aronberg and Viva Frei discuss the more than 10-year prison sentence handed to Russell Brand, the judge's remarks, and the claim that the case was a show trial. Aronberg, a former prosecutor, argues the jury acquitted him on several counts and the sentence fell within guidelines, while Frei contends the UK justice system is broken.

The second half features Emily Jashinsky on a reported immigration deal Trump floated, Republican midterm losses, Cali Means' claims about MAHA and lobbying money, and Jennifer Welch's comments about Charlie Kirk.

In this episode Megyn Kelly, Dave Aronberg, Emily Jashinsky, Viva Frei

This Megyn Kelly Show episode on Russell Brand's sentencing and Cali Means' MAHA claims was made with the technology behind HappyScribe's Google Meet note taker.

Megyn Kelly00:00:00

Welcome to "The Megyn Kelly Show," live on SiriusXM Channel 111 every weekday at noon east. Hey everyone, I'm Megyn Kelly. Welcome to "The Megyn Kelly Show." Happy Monday, lots of news. Let's do this. Including President Trump giving his assessment of the Republicans' midterm wipeout on "60 Minutes" last night, and this morning once again claiming it was a mess with election. Okay. Can you— can we not— can we— can we just be, like, really honest about what actually— what— this is so fucking pointless.

Like, we're going to do that again? We don't trust the vote? We do. We do. No matter what you— you know, as a— to steal a phrase? "Too big to rig"? That's what just happened to your party. Uh, first, though, we start with breaking news from across the pond, where a judge just sentenced Russell Brand to 10 and a half years in prison. Good Lord. 10 and a half years in prison. He grabbed a boob, he kissed a lady, he, uh, sniffed a lady, and he had backdoor sex with a woman who licked his back door before she was even introduced to him.

He is going to prison for 10 and a half years for that. This is insane. This is a country that let— let how many— how many of these immigrants who would come into their country rape young white girls with impunity for years? They did nothing for the vast majority of those child rapists. And now Russell Brand, for grabbing boobs, kissing, sniffing, and having that kind of sex with a woman who consented to vaginal sex with him seconds beforehand, and also had clearly been joking with him and talking with him about having anal sex, and had given him the equivalent, on their first meeting, for that he's going to jail for 10 years.

This is an outrage. This is an obvious double standard. And if you needed any further proof that this is a political witch hunt against Russell Brand, that judge just gave it to us. Good gracious. Here's how the judge opened the proceedings.

Emily Jashinsky00:02:30

Twenty years ago, Russell Brand, you were becoming famous. You were clever and, in many people's eyes, funny and charismatic. You had also become a sexual predator. Your status protected you until 2023, when journalists collected and published the allegations that were broadcast as a Channel 4 documentary and in articles in The Times newspapers. Those public declarations that you were a sex offender empowered a number of women to come forward and tell their stories of your activities many years before.

Megyn Kelly00:03:13

Okay. So it wasn't just the judge. It was even the defense lawyers that were using language that presumed Russell— Russell's guilt, which, at this stage of the proceedings, is appropriate since he's been found guilty. Just so you know, that's why you'll hear the judge and the defense lawyer talk about Russell as though he's done all the things that he was found guilty of. Um, but this judge made no doubt— I mean, throughout the entire proceedings— whose side he was on. He absolutely had a finger on the scale. He clearly didn't like Russell.

And neither does the press. Because if you were to read the articles about Russell's case, his verdict, and his sentencing over the past three days, it is clear that they are treating him like he is one of the most prolific sexual predators ever to roam the earth. Here's the moment Russell learned his fate.

Emily Jashinsky00:04:05

I pass a sentence of imprisonment for 9 months for count 3, 18 months for count 5, reduced from 2 years to allow for totality, and 8 months for count 7. Those sentences are all concurrent to one another to further allow for totality, but consecutive to the sentence for rape. The sentence I pass on count 6, rape, is 9 years imprisonment.

So the total sentence is 1 of 10 years, 6 months. The few days you have already served will count. You will serve two-thirds of that sentence, then be released on license, and will be liable to be recalled into custody if you breach its terms. On your release, you will also be indefinitely subject to the notification requirements under the Sexual Offences Act, 2003.

Megyn Kelly00:05:04

As you heard there, Brand was sentenced to 9 years— 9— for allegedly raping the woman identified in court as complainant 5. She's the one who allegedly performed oral sex on Russell Brand's anus shortly after meeting him. No, she didn't— she didn't meet him. They walked her into the dressing room. She dropped down on her knees and shoved her tongue inside his rear end. This is our 9-year-in-prison Russell Brand victim. This is ridiculous. She later admits she consented to vaginal sex with him before she says Brand anally raped her.

This is the one who, when the press first contacted her about her exchange with Russell, said, "You know, I was just a stupid young person. I was just as responsible as he was." Okay. Great. She did not show up to read her victim impact statement, possibly because she knew we would all be rolling our eyes on this made-up claim. A prosecutor read it. She said she was so emotionally damaged by that incident that she had to leave her job and return to live with her parents for an unspecified period of time.

From her statement, quote, "It's something I carry with me every day, and it often feels never-ending." I don't believe you. Just before handing down his sentence, the judge commented on the bravery of the women who came forward against Brand.

Emily Jashinsky00:06:28

Finally, before passing sentence, I pause to pay tribute to the determination and bravery of all the women whose evidence I have been recounting. I do not increase your punishment because of it, but all those women had to face being confronted and being told they'd lied or twisted the truth and/or they'd agreed to your sexual demands. That was all done because of you, on your instructions.

I also commend the Metropolitan Police for their hard work in gathering evidence and taking great care of all the women who testified.

Megyn Kelly00:07:11

According to "The Daily Mail," Russell's wife, Laura, fell forward and cried as the judge handed down the sentence. Again, this could have been as low as around 4. Uh, we expected between 5 and 10. And he's given him 10. He's basically given him the maximum within the guidelines, though he's allowing it to run concurrently as opposed to consecutively. So he got that one bone thrown to him. "The Mail" also reported that Russell's father, Ron Brand, looked shaken upon hearing this insane sentence.

Take a look at these reporters. I mean, not for nothing, but while we're on it, I was just last week saying that the sentence of Elizabeth Holmes should be commuted at this point. It's ridiculous. She's in jail for longer than Russell's going to jail for. Like, all these relative sentences are insane. She got an 11-year sentence. He got 10 for rape, alleged rape, and three sexual assaults. She got 11 for defrauding some of the most sophisticated investors in America, like Rupert Murdoch. Like, whatever. Trump should commute the sentence of Elizabeth Holmes.

And this sentence is an outrage when you've got all these migrants running around the UK having faced zero justice for raping young girls. It was— there was a racial thing. It's been well-documented. They were Muslims, they were immigrants, they were brown-skinned, they were raping young white girls, and the authorities didn't want to prosecute them because of political correctness, wokeness, racial sensitivities— choose your— your brand— that you want for what they did.

But it was absolutely disgusting. And now they've suddenly found a conscience when they found their first white conservative man. Now it's time. Now we're going to crack down. Okay. Great. Great. We really appreciate that. Great. Just in time, uh, to save these adult women who consented to every sex act under the sun with Russell, except possibly, maybe not that one, according to this jury, which nobody believes. I mean, please. She was so horrified about the thought of backdoor action she did it to him within the first 10 seconds of meeting him.

Stop it. This is absurd. Speaking of Russell's father, this is— look, watch this. Okay? This is him, outside of the courtroom, being confronted by these rabid reporters.

Speaker 300:09:36

That's very unfair.

Speaker 400:09:37

Is this the type of man that you raised? Leave the man alone.

Speaker 300:09:40

No, stay on there. Don't— don't answer the questions.

Speaker 400:09:43

Do you have a message to the victims?

Speaker 300:09:45

Admitting what? What Russell?

Speaker 400:09:47

Not Russell. His victims.

Speaker 300:09:48

The girls you mean who chased him and harassed him?

Speaker 400:09:50

He was convicted by a jury of victims.

Speaker 300:09:53

I don't care. I don't care. It's a system.

Speaker 400:09:56

We don't believe the justice system.

Speaker 300:09:57

I don't believe it on the basis of what I've just watched. No. No. See, we've got social media. It's easy to find the right jury. Go on Facebook and see what sort of things they say.

Speaker 400:10:07

You're saying the jury was corrupted?

Speaker 300:10:08

Well, I'm saying it's possible. Are you saying it's not possible?

Speaker 400:10:12

I believe in the justice system. Doesn't— isn't that what we're supposed to believe in?

Speaker 300:10:15

Are you saying you couldn't go on social media and look at what people are saying and find people who are attacking Russell Brand? Are you saying that? Or do you understand you could?

Speaker 500:10:23

Ron, Ron. Do you think your son will be able to cope in prison?

Speaker 300:10:26

Yeah. He's strong. He's strong.

Megyn Kelly00:10:30

This is incredible. I mean, look at the dad actually saying something quite reasonable, right? Saying— look, are you saying the jury was corrupted as if no jury ever has been? Are you saying it's not possible? I believe in the justice system. You do? In the UK? Why? I wouldn't. You shouldn't. There's a lot of evidence of a two-tiered system in which the white guys— never mind if you're a conservative— have one standard of justice, and the brown-skinned men who are from other countries entirely get a totally different system of justice.

Advertisement00:11:06
Viva Frei00:12:22

I said one thing: that innocent or guilty, this was a show trial set up for a conviction. I can appreciate there's people out there who think that Russell Brand is a known, uh, beyond-womanizer sexual predator. Fine. This was set up for a conviction regardless. When you're dealing with charges or accusations that are 15 years old, at the most recent, 20-some-odd years old for some of them, this is not a system where you can actually successfully maintain your innocence when silence is deemed to be, uh, you know, something to be used against you, and you're simply incapable of proving innocence after that period of time.

You listen to what that judge said, and if you changed the language to North Korean, it would be no different than the judge thanking the state for the, you know, good prosecution of Otto Warmbier and congratulating them on a job well done. That is not a judge who's administering justice. That is a judge who is thanking his co-conspirators for setting up and allowing this manufactured conviction of Russell Brand so they can set an example to everyone else out there. We will tolerate your debauchery because, at the very least, it was debauchery until you become politically inconvenient.

Then we will prosecute you, and we will have a show trial, and we will sentence you just like they did to Otto Warmbier in North Korea.

Megyn Kelly00:13:33

Yeah. That's how it feels to me. Dave used to prosecute cases like this for a living, so what's your take?

Dave Aronberg00:13:39

Well, I— I wouldn't call it a show trial. I'm just going to be back with you, Megan and, uh, and Viva. Um, you know.

Megyn Kelly00:13:44

Good to see you.

Dave Aronberg00:13:45

The jury acquitted him on almost half of the counts. So if the court had orchestrated some show trial designed to ruin him, the jury would have found him guilty across the board. The judge did not sentence him consecutively. He did it concurrently. And it wasn't just a he-said-she-said. Yes, these are old allegations. But when it comes to the evidence, they did have text messages and other evidence. So this wasn't he-said-she-said. So I'm not willing to go as far.

Megyn Kelly00:14:12

Can I just say something to you about that? Because there's— there's a story going around on the internet that complainant 5, the alleged anal rape gal, had a text message of Russell saying that he was sorry. It's not true. She testified that she received such a text message. None was ever introduced in a trial. And that was the critical text message. There's misinformation about this. So there is reason to question this woman's account, given what I just told you she said to the press about how, you know, "I was young and stupid. I don't even know why they're coming to me about my story." Um, and yet there is a common belief that they sort of had Russell dead to rights in some text message there.

Dave Aronberg00:14:48

Well, you know, when it comes to the main account, you're right that there was consensual encounters, and she willingly had sex with him before. She agreed to have vaginal sex with him that night. That's all part of the record. But the findings were that Brand removed the condom and forced a different act, and then kept going after. She told him twice to stop. And so whatever they did the first time they met, a jury can conclude, and the judge can conclude, that it was not reasonable for him to keep going after she told him repeatedly to stop.

Megyn Kelly00:15:21

10 years in prison, Dave. 10 years on something she didn't come forward over for 22 years. This is crazy. I mean, come on. Let me— let me just tell you something, Dave. Look at this. Uh, I had the team pull a couple of examples. David Lyons in the UK, 44 years old. What did he do? He pleaded guilty to the manslaughter of his autistic neighbor, Philip Quinn, who was 54 years old.

He launched a violent sustained assault on him, kicking and stamping his autistic neighbor with learning difficulties to death. He got less than Russell got today. This guy got 9 years and 6 months in prison. Maybe it was a long time ago before they actually decided to get tough on crime. No, it was April of 2026. That's just one. Here's another guy, Harper Dennis, 19, convicted of manslaughter. He killed a man by fatally stabbing him five times in the chest over a money dispute. He will be— he was sentenced to prison for less than Russell Brand.

He— he got 10 years, which all in is 6 months or more, less than Russell Brand. Murderers, Dave.

Dave Aronberg00:16:34

Yeah. Yeah. No, I— I get it. I get your— your outrage on that. I just— I just want to clarify, though. When it comes to rape, the statutory maximum here is actually life. Category 1 ranges up to 15 years.

Megyn Kelly00:16:46

True.

Dave Aronberg00:16:46

Right? And the prosecution asked for Category 1. Um, the judge gave 9 years. So it's not as much as he could have given. So I'm not willing to say that this was a show trial or this was the system against him. I mean, he— he had the trial. He had a— he had the best lawyers in the entire country. He had a jury that found— acquitted him on about half. And then he had a judge who decided to cut him a break and not run the sentences consecutively. So it could have been a lot worse.

Viva Frei00:17:16

Yeah. I— I don't think that's the indication that it wasn't a show trial. I think the indications that it was a show trial is that these women come out with accusations after the Channel 4 documentary, damn near two decades later. It is, unfortunately— I appreciate there's some corroborating evidence, like, okay, her friends were compla— said that she was complaining about soreness. So it is, unfortunately, he-said-she-said, and you're dealing with a woman now. I don't know if you have the clip where the judge basically admitted that the woman has a history of mental illness and a history of drug addiction, which is related to other.

Megyn Kelly00:17:48

We do. Hold on. Let— let's— let me play it, and then you— you take it. Watch.

Speaker 800:17:51

In her victim impact statement, she wrote of struggling to eat and sleep, of taking two to three months off from work, and of abandoning the career she had embarked upon. Although the rape was 17 years ago, she still finds it affects her ability to form new friendships and to know when she can trust people. From her evidence at trial, I also know she developed an alcohol problem partly as a result of your attack on her. I will not detail the victim's lengthy mental health and addiction problems here, as they might have a tendency to identify her, but the harm was significant and long-lasting.

It could be seen as severe, though she told the police with an openness that characterized her evidence that there had been other issues in her life that contributed to those later difficulties.

Viva Frei00:18:48

Now, just to.

Megyn Kelly00:18:49

Go ahead, Viva.

Viva Frei00:18:50

Make it clear. This is not a question of victim blaming and saying, "Oh, she's a drug addict, and she got what she deserved" at all. No. This is a question of you're dealing with someone with a drug addiction, mental illness, a long history of it related to other things other than the alleged, now I guess, adjudicated rape. And it is a hearsay— a he-said-she-said where, you know, a woman who was engaging in a number of, you know, types of sexual activity, then saying, "I— I didn't consent to that." Dave, and for everyone, there's a difference between used and raped. And there's zero question that Russell Brand used a lot of women.

And the moral of the story is, when you use more women than you can remember, chances are one of them's going to come back and remember something that might not be accurate or might be their accurate memory of what happened. You use enough women, something's going to come back to haunt you. That being said, whether or not she felt used, it's a difference between being used that he— she might have been raped, and 15 years later, you'll forgive the world for saying, "I don't know who is right and who is wrong." But if you wait that long.

Megyn Kelly00:19:46

I don't— I— I don't accept that word, though, even that he used them. They used him. Yeah. I'm going to— I'm going to take a risk and say, on behalf of every female audience member listening to this right now, not a one has stuck her tongue in a man's anus within 10 seconds of meeting him. F that term used. This woman was begging, begging to be used by Russell Brand. She was obsessed with him. You teach people how to treat you. It's not that she invited rape by that behavior, but she clearly was telegraphing to Russell Brand that she was fine with backdoor action.

And he testified that they actually did explicitly discuss it before they did it, and she consented. And what she said to him was, "Be gentle." Obviously, the jury rejected that. But I'm just saying, that was— it was a he-said-she-said on that particular sex act. It was admitted what she did to him within moments of meeting him. And here's another thing that I— that I was just, um, saying. Her— she— her friend testified— testified that she suggested to this complainant that she should speak to this— this journalist, Roz Irwin, who's behind this entire case.

And the alleged victim, complainant 5, replied to her in a message, "I'm not sure my story has much in it. I was an idiot, young and stupid, probably as much to blame." Nine years for this woman's newfound testimonial come to after she saw the so-called documentary. It's just— and here's the other thing, Dave. She's up there giving the witness, uh, impact statement— not she personally, but it was read for her— um, saying, "As a result of all this, I doubt my ability to make good decisions."

Yeah. You should. You should. Because you're the one who chose to go backstage with him and engage in a threesome within seconds. "I no longer trust my instinct the way I did." You shouldn't. It steered you entirely the wrong way. And then you willingly had vaginal sex with a man you knew nothing about. You didn't know his character. You didn't have any reason whatsoever to believe that he cared about you or would treat you well at all. Like, this is obviously a woman who said yes, yes, yes, yes to everything.

And I think it's zero problem to believe she said yes to this as well, who then felt gross, and she didn't feel like he treated her very well when it was over. I'm shocked. Shocked.

Dave Aronberg00:22:05

Well, Megan, I don't think it's fair to say that she was silent for 15 to 20 years and then all of a sudden suddenly disclosed this to a jury or to prosecutors. The prosecutors called multiple independent witnesses, friends, uh, housemates, uh, colleagues who took the stand to confirm that she— and not just she, but others, the women who are the victims here— told them about the assaults at the time that they occurred in the 2000s. So it's not more than just delayed reporting.

Megyn Kelly00:22:33

Here's— here's the evidence on that. You're— I'm not disputing that she said something to friends. Not rape. But here's what she said. The summer after the alleged incident, she allegedly told a friend, um, that she had asked Russell to stop multiple times, but he didn't. She said that woman 5 told her, complainant 5, she felt humiliated and violated, that Russell scolded her for making a mess of the bed. That's not illegal. That's— I mean, if— if it's true she said stop and he didn't, that would be illegal. But that business about she felt humiliated, that he wanted her to clean up the bed, to me, that's actually probably— that maybe that— that did happen, and she felt angry, and it could be the basis of this entire claim.

A colleague said in the days after the alleged incident, a woman 5 came to her office looking ill and ashen. Quote, "I asked her if she consented. She said, 'No, I did not consent to that.' I said, 'You have to tell the police.' She said, 'No, they won't believe me.'" And then there was another friend who said she was distraught when she came home. She was in physical pain. Um, she— the— the friend said she told woman 5 she was told that they had consensual sex. Um, and then Russell said he wanted anal sex.

Woman 5 said no. They started to have consensual vaginal sex, and then he turned her over and he raped her anally. That was the friend's word. So this woman was telling the story about having gone through the back door, but she was not saying rape until she saw that documentary many years later.

Dave Aronberg00:23:58

Well, you know, he had six different women who testified about separate events across multiple years. They didn't know each other when the offenses took place, but they had these sworn accounts that independently described virtually identical behavior. And that's where it really was very powerful, I think, for the jury, the under the laws of evidence, you know, when you have multiple unrelated people who come together and say pretty much the same thing without colluding with each other, sort of destroys a defense theory of coincidence or misunderstanding. And that's— that's problematic. As far as.

Megyn Kelly00:24:27

I mean, why was that allowed, Dave? We just had the Harvey Weinstein reversed in New York City, New York State, because of this very kind of testimony that was introduced against him with our court of— our— our appellate court, which is no left-leaning court, saying, "This has got to be thrown out. This was unfair to him."

Dave Aronberg00:24:42

Yeah. I think it was close in the appellate court. It wasn't like 4 to 3, but yes. Every state— and I can speak to United States law, not necessarily UK law as an expert, but just about every state has what we call in Florida Williams rule evidence, which is if you can show a pattern, if you can show an MO, then you can bring in these prior bad acts. Not to show propensity evidence, but to show that this is his fingerprint, this is what he does in all these cases, and you can bring it up. But the prosecution in the Harvey Weinstein case went too far, and it— it went into propensity evidence.

Like, "He's a bad guy. He must have done it here. Convict him." And the appellate court, in a narrow vote, decided to throw it out.

Viva Frei00:25:20

Well, I mean, in this particular case, Russell wrote the book. He basically documented his own— I will call it exploitation, but there is, you know, legal consensual exploitation, which results from bad judgment and groupies wanting to give a BJ to a celebrity, which can leave people feeling so used and so exploited that they, 10 years later, say, "Oh, you know what? It really wasn't that consensual." Much like, uh, the Cornell University girl two years later saying, "You know what? It wasn't that consensual. It was degrading. It was demeaning. I am living with the consequences of this now.

And so I'm going to—" you know, it's not very hard to reframe something as not consensual when it was so damn exploitive in the first place. When it comes to this, Russell Brand sort of explained his own MO. And I— I said they were going to do it, and they ended up reading passages from his own book to him on the stand. He made it easy for that type of evidence, and he made it easy for a— a, you know, a non-sympathetic jury to say, "This man is such a— a sexually exploitive pig that I'm going to give the, you know, the doubt to the victims or the alleged victims and not believe him that it was all consensual."

He was so high on drugs and so high on his own fame that he didn't even realize that it wasn't consensual. So he made it easy. And if you live a life of sin like that, you know.

Megyn Kelly00:26:29

He was— he was clean and sober by 2009 when, uh, the alleged rape happened. Um, but I— exploitation is not unlawful, you know? And honestly, like, to— to paint him as exploiting complainant 5, the alleged rape victim here, is ridiculous, given the way she behaved toward him within seconds of meeting him. She clearly wanted it. Then after that interlude in the dressing room where her friend fellated him as she took care of the backside, then he called her and said, "Hey, let's get together again." And she knew. She knew she was going over to his house for sex.

She was cheating on her boyfriend. She wanted sex with Russell Brand. And we're supposed to believe he said they talked about doing it this way, whatever. We've been over that. But I'm just saying, I don't see this as exploitation at all. Exploitation is like when there's a clear power imbalance. Just because he's famous and she's not doesn't mean there's a power imbalance. It means one person's famous and one person is not. Power imbalance speaks to a lawyer and a client, a psychiatrist and a patient, um, a teacher and a student, a boss and an employee.

That's— those are positions of fiduciary where you actually have an obligation as one party not to exploit the other. Star and starfucker? No. It doesn't exist. This is ridiculous. This woman 3 who said he kissed me at the bar without my consent, and then he dragged me into a bathroom stall and forced me to orally fellate him, the jury said no to point 2. We don't believe you. They rejected her rape allegation on that. But they said yes to he forcefully kissed you at the bar.

This woman, I— like, it's unbelievable what she told the court today. She— she takes— she actually insisted that she be there personally to read her own victim impact statement. So she wanted her moment on the stand. She was initially, she said, in shock and turmoil after the attack. Now, let's keep in mind, this victim impact statement should be to what happened when he kissed her at the bar and allegedly grabbed her boobs. That's what's at issue. That's what Russell's being sentenced for, not for an alleged oral rape.

So she wants the jury to know she was in shock and turmoil. She says she, quote, "literally lost any love for myself for a long time, thinking I was damaged goods." She felt, quote, "physically sick seeing him in the press. I didn't have any respect for myself. This really affected how I viewed myself. I got into situations with toxic men as I didn't have any self-worth. Um, seeing the front pages of the newspaper talking about what happened to me caused me to have the only panic attack I've ever had in my life.

It was a truly terrifying experience." This is ridiculous. I'm sorry, madam. You're a complainant in a criminal trial where a man could be going to jail for life. You're going to have to take the stand. And yeah, that may be an issue of panic, but it's allowed to be listed as one of her, like, damages here. Uh, even more terrifying was seeing my character being torn apart on social media by people believing all of us women were making it up. This is ridiculous. Her name has been kept anonymized. She will have that anonymity for life. This is all going into the mix of why Russell got 10-plus years, Dave.

That's ridiculous.

Dave Aronberg00:29:44

I hear you, Megan. Uh, when a victim is speaking afterwards on the penalty and then conflates the count that was acquitted with the count that was convicted, but you're allowed to elocute. You're allowed to— you're allowed to say what happened and in her mind, even if the count was not believed by the jury. And then it's up to the judge to make that determination, to say, "Okay, we're only sentencing him on the kiss, not the rape, because that was acquitted."

And I think the judge did that. The judge focused on those counts where he was acquitted and gave sentences that were within the sentencing guidelines in the UK. It just wasn't on the top of his head. It just wasn't because he hated Russell Brand. If he did really hate him, he could have given him the maximum and then made it consecutive, which he didn't.

Megyn Kelly00:30:34

He got nine months. Nine months for the grabbing of the breasts by that complainant who's, like, playing it up. And he got 18 months in jail, Viva, for complainant number 4. Here is the BBC describing her testimony about what he did that he just got a year and a half in prison for in SOT 212.

Speaker 800:30:58

They were inside a small room and came out into a smaller holding section when, quote, "he just leapt on me." They described how Russell Brand lunged forwards and began to kiss them. They said, quote, "it was a flash of lightning." They said he wasn't alone. There was a woman with long dark hair with him and three other men. When they were asked to describe the kiss, they said it was frenzied, it was hard, it was very, very hard. I would say it was sloppy and it was wet. He was kissing all down my neck and his hands were all over me. He touched my bum, my breasts, my waist. He was pushing his body against me and I was up against the wall.

Again, they clarified it was rough and then said, quote, "it was violent." At one point, they said they managed to put their hand up between them and Russell Brand and push him off and tell him to fuck off, at which point he lunged backwards and in a laughing way went ha ha and looked at the other people who were around. Complainant number 4 told the jury that not one of the other people, the women or the three men that they said were there, stepped in or said anything during the time they alleged they were assaulted by Russell Brand.

Megyn Kelly00:31:54

Right. So the question was raised, how traumatic could this have been if all these people were like, "It's a nothing burger"? Then she testified via paper statement that was read by the prosecutor, "This has had a lasting impact on my life." Um, a lasting impact. The incident impacted my work when dealing with stories of sexual violence. It affected my relationships with some of my male colleagues. Um, she was advised to seek therapy for serious anxiety and on and on.

I— he— he grabbed her at a bar and started kissing her violently, whatever that means, and allegedly feeling her. And for— he's going to jail for 18 months for that, Viva. That— I mean, I'm sorry, but these are just so out of whack.

Viva Frei00:32:40

And just to highlight again, she said no, even by her own testimony. He backs off and stops and laughs it off and stops. The issue is this: it happened so long ago, a proper defense is virtually impossible. And I— and I'm not sitting on offense here. I'm just saying, guilty or innocent, this was set up for a conviction. You cannot isolate this trial and this conviction from the broader UK system. I don't like comparing it to the Muslim Pakistani men rape gangs, because that sort of equates Russell Brand's behavior to that. I sort of more equate it to what just happened to Tommy Robinson.

You— you somehow can't find justice for actual criminals in the UK. And they literally lock up, say, white Christian men who are protecting their nation or conservative for years. Remember what happened to Tommy Robinson? Contempt of court, tried, convicted, and sentenced to 13 months in jail within five hours of the alleged violation. The system is broken. And whether or not it results in people who might otherwise have been found guilty, you know, questioning their guilt when they get found guilty, the system is broken. It— it is a third world country that is more commensurate with the legal system in North Korea than that of the United States.

Megyn Kelly00:33:44

Yes.

Viva Frei00:33:44

And so the issue is we don't know and we'll never know if he was innocent or guilty. That's what happens when you wait too bloody long to avail yourself of your rights if you were a victim. We know the lifestyle that he lived. We know what he's admitted to publicly. And we know what these women have admitted to publicly. But the system is fundamentally broken in that hellhole of a country. And everyone who's there should notice this, leave if they can, and sure as hell not go back for trial if they can avoid it, because it won't be a fair trial.

Megyn Kelly00:34:08

Here's— here's the other one, Dave. This is complainant 6 who worked with him and, um, was allegedly asked by somebody to give Russell's shoulders a massage, which she says she did. Listen to her testimony. I just want you to know, for this that you're about to hear, Russell Brand was sentenced to eight months in prison. Listen. This is the BBC describing it.

Speaker 800:34:32

And then she was told at one point by his production staff that he wouldn't continue unless she gave him a massage. They said that complainant number 6 thought this was a joke and said, "No." Um, but then she realized that they were being serious. And then she was concerned that if she didn't do everything in her power to get this project over the line, she would end up in trouble. She says the prosecution told the jury that Russell Brand then re-enters the room, drops to his knees in front of complainant number 6, and buries his face in her groin. They said that complainant number 6 could feel his breath on her genitals. And he was saying, "Come on, do it," as in, "Give him the massage."

And they said that complainant number 6 ultimately got her fingers and prodded them into his upper shoulders and made a remark like, "Oh, you're so bony," which made the other men in the room laugh. They told the jury that Russell Brand did not like this and then began to make disparaging remarks like, "You have a deep voice. Do you have a dick or a fanny?" They went on to tell the court that complainant number 6 reported this to her line manager, that it went up the chain, but that ultimately it wasn't taken seriously enough.

Megyn Kelly00:35:30

Eight months in prison for that, Dave? Eight months in prison? If they had ever tried to bring a case just based on that incident alone or based on the alleged violent kissing at the bar alone, there is no way these kinds of sentences would have been handed down.

Dave Aronberg00:35:45

Yeah. I— I think that is probably your strongest point here. I think that for a massage that was, you know, unappreciated or unwanted, eight months does not seem proportionate. Um, but apparently the eight months did not add any time to Brand's sentence because the judge ran that concurrently. So I would just say that that I— I would agree that that's a lot for that charge. But because the judge ran the sentences concurrently, it's not going to add a day to his prison time.

Megyn Kelly00:36:20

I get your point. I see your point. Because he got nine years for the alleged rape. He got eight months for the sniffing. He got 18 months for the kissing and grabbing her bum and her breasts at the bar. And he got nine months for the kissing at the bar before he brought that woman into the bathroom where they did not find he raped her. But here's the story. Let me— let me just give you this. I read you some of the statements, some of the sentences they've given to murderers, murderers in the UK, less than what Russell got. Let's just look at some of the rape sentences that have come down.

Um, here's one. 2025. Uh, men who abused a vulnerable teenage girl, uh, including Ibrar Hussein. Hussein was jailed for six and a half years for not one, but two counts of rape. He gave the girl heroin, a teenager heroin, and raped her twice. This guy got less of a sentence than Russell did for this alleged rape of a teenage girl.

Six and a half years he got. This is insane. One other, Darius Andrew Leonas, 46, deemed a dangerous man who raped a woman in a late-night stranger danger attack near a gas station. He, um, came up next to her. He sat next on a wall. Then he dragged her in a nearby bushes. She begged him not to rape her. He placed his hands on her mouth and neck to stop her from screaming, leaving her in fear for her life. She tried to reason with him.

He continued the attack. She only managed to get away after he had raped her. That guy got seven years. Seven. And Russell gets nine and a half. So I don't give any credit or points to the judge at all for saying, "Oh, the 18 months and the nine months and the eight months are going to run concurrently with the nine and a half," which is— which was a bullshit sentence to start with, Dave.

Dave Aronberg00:38:23

Well, I'm not as familiar with these other cases, but I would hope that sexual assault rape would be treated seriously by the system and people wouldn't get a slap on the wrist. You know, as a former prosecutor.

Megyn Kelly00:38:35

If Dave Aronberg were in charge, that would be happening in all cases. This I know. But that's what's so outrageous about this. In the UK, it's made international headlines that they're not doing it that way. Go— go ahead. Sorry to interrupt.

Dave Aronberg00:38:46

Well, also, I— I agree with Viva. That was upset. It was a Tommy Robinson case. The way that was handled, that was totally a miscue, where they treated the victim as the perpetrator and the perpetrator as the victim. And it was done based on whatever their training was, which has to be dramatically revamped because they were too quick to listen to a guy because he was, I guess, wearing a turban to claim that he was the victim when it was the opposite. But when it comes to this case, I did have a lot of evidence, and the jury reviewed all the facts.

And, you know, the jury system may be imperfect, but it's the system that we have and the UK has. And they're the ones who are there every day reviewing the evidence and decided that he was guilty on some counts, not guilty on others. And then the judge gave a sentence that was commensurate with the sentencing guidelines and made it concurrent.

Viva Frei00:39:36

I— I want to just want to add.

Megyn Kelly00:39:37

What do you make of it, Viva?

Viva Frei00:39:38

Well, you know, the idea that, well, at least it's concurrent, so no biggie. It's another feather in the cap of everybody who wants to say he's been convicted of three or four charges now. Look at all the— and nobody's going to distinguish between the bogus weak convictions and the— and the big one. And, you know, to go back to what Dave said earlier, and Dave, this is not to pounce on you at all, you know, there were a lot of witnesses, and the judge— the jury found him not guilty on three of the six charges or half of them. That's what the purpose of a Gish gallop is in an argument. You throw so much against the wall and you just hope that one or two things stick.

You know, finding these victims, and I'll put them, you know, victims now, coming out years later with from ranging from innocuous nothingness to serious if true, and you get the serious if true. The question is, had you had one trial on that main charge of anal rape alone, would there have been a conviction in the absence of five others, two of which get dismissed or not found guilty, tainting your perspective of the big one? And it's the tactic, and it succeeded because, you know, you throw enough out there, you make them look bad enough with lesser transgressions of sexual deviancy, you're more prone to come to a finding of guilt on the big one, which is all that they ever wanted in the first place.

But the bottom line, it was just the passage of time is the injustice here. And unfortunately, after a certain period of time, I appreciate there's no statute of limitations, another reason to avoid the system, they exploited all of that to come down hard on a political rival in the UK.

Dave Aronberg00:41:04

But that's why there's no statute of limitations. It's because these are very underreported crimes. And you had someone who did speak to several people at the time it occurred and then, yes, waited to speak to the authorities until about 2023. But delayed reporting is normal in cases like this.

Megyn Kelly00:41:18

It's unfair to the man. It's— but it's so unfair to the man. I understand it's normal, but as a woman, you understand sitting around doing nothing for two decades may undermine your ability to bring a claim later in time, either civil or potentially, in this country anyway, criminal. Because we have due process, because we have fairness both to the accuser and to the accused. And it just— it's— it's impossible here. And then you have the press, which is responsible for this whole thing. They're responsible for this entire thing, that documentary with actors, Dave, actors playing the parts of the alleged women, which is just so inappropriate, right?

Like, who— there's no chance to assess the credibility of the actual accusers who got this whole thing rolling in this so-called documentary. You have a professional actress saying the lines. Of course she's going to be better at it than the actual victim who may or may not be telling the truth. And right— right up to the moment that we watched as Russell's father was leaving the courtroom, Ron, is this the kind of man you raised? What the F? What kind of a question is that from someone who is supposed to be an objective journalist?

Dave Aronberg00:42:27

Well, that's the press, and that's another conversation for another day. But when it came to that one journalist, it wasn't the journalist that was the first one to talk about it. The reason why the journalist got the information was because Russell Brand had— excuse me, the victim had spoken to enough people that one of her friends went to the journalist and said, "Hey, here's this story. Here's what happened." And that's what led the one journalist to write about it. And that's what put everything in motion.

Megyn Kelly00:42:55

But Dave, I get it. But they talked— many people talked about how Russell's behavior was, quote, "an open secret." An open secret. And he's got defenders right now who are disputing that. But the complainant's side was saying that it was an open secret what he was doing to women in Hollywood. And so it's like, okay, if it was an open secret, why wasn't the press interested in him? I'll put it to you, Viva, back when— before he was a conservative, back before he was basically the UK's Joe Rogan. There was absolutely no sniffing around whatsoever, nor any in-depth documentary with actresses playing his alleged victims.

No, that all happened after his politics changed.

Viva Frei00:43:30

Well, there's zero question about that. But I also do wonder about, you know, when people say it was an open secret, much with Harvey Weinstein, what people understood as the open secret is that women would exchange sex for stardom and that that's part of the deal with the devil that a lot of people make in Hollywood. And that people said it was an open secret, not that necessarily Harvey Weinstein was a serial rapist hiding in alleyways, but that he was a serial exploiter who would exploit women who would exchange sexual favors for stardom in Hollywood. I— it was a Constantine Kissin from Trigonometry.

It's not— it's like, we all knew it was an open secret with Russell Brand, and we warned women accordingly. The question is, what was the open secret? That he was a sexual deviant, a sexual pervert, a hyper— hypersexually aggressive in— within the bounds of the law. He wrote a book about it. Of course, that's— if the secret that everyone knew about was that he was a serial rapist of the criminal order and they all covered it up, I mean, that's one hell of an admission that they were basically tolerating criminal behavior. Or reality, they were tolerating what they knew as degeneracy because they weren't ready to use it against him at that time.

As immoral and debaucherous and degenerate as it was, it wasn't crossing the threshold to illegal. And ten years later, it's a whole hell of a lot easier to apply today's morals and standards to behavior from 20 years ago, which everyone knew about back then and knew wasn't illegal back then. That's why nobody reported it. To apply today's standards and sensitivities to that in order to facilitate a conviction 20 years later. I mean, that's my view. I— Brand led a sinful life that facilitated this type of conviction, right or wrong as it is. But the bottom line is the mere.

Megyn Kelly00:45:04

Yes, he behaved recklessly. There's no question. There's no question. And as a man, you got to be damn careful about that because it's women who come back and alleged rape. It's never the men. Um, he's going to jail for ten years. He is going to have to serve— well, he's going to have to serve two-thirds of that. So it's basically going to be.

Viva Frei00:45:24

Seven years.

Megyn Kelly00:45:25

Seven years. He's— he's going to have to go to jail and actually serve the next seven years. He's 51 years old. He has three kids, ten, eight, and three. His little boy will be ten the next time they get to spend time outside of a prison together. And they may not be done. The prosecutors, I told the audience on Friday, are talking about possibly charging him with two additional counts. Um, they really don't want this guy to see the light of day again. Uh, the reports out of the UK press on his first weekend in jail because he was not allowed to be released on his own recognizance pending sentencing were very, very dark.

He's at some prison called Wandsworth, um, though he may not be staying there. They write that as a sex offender, he's kept apart from the other convicts. He's assessed by officers. Prison bosses have carried out a cell-sharing risk assessment on him. They've opted to house him on his own amid safety fears. They've blocked him from mixing with the others to keep him safe. Uh, a source told the UK Sun that his first day in jail was a real shock to his system. In a wake-up call, he looked shaken. He was quiet. A horrible, noisy, and dirty jail like Wandsworth is a world away from his glamorous Hollywood lifestyle.

Uh, he would be expected to serve two-thirds of his sentence, correct? And then he has to register as a sex offender. There was chanting inside the jail by the other inmates. There is a brand new nonce on the wing. A brand new nonce. Brand, you see word, you ain't so effing Larry now. There's a lot in there that I didn't understand. Nonce, I guess, is a word in the UK for a child molester. Larry means behaving in an unpleasantly loud, overly confident, or slightly aggressive way.

Right now, the Daily Mail says it's only been verbal abuse because they are keeping him away from the other inmates. Uh, the quote in here by one was, "They've got to get their amusement somewhere." So they've made Brand the object with hundreds of prisoners shouting the chant. Brand only leaves his cell to collect his food at mealtimes before returning. He is going around like a shadow. When he came into court today, um, they— the court called the clerk at 11:01 a.m., calling him in.

Eight minutes later, he came in with two guards. He answered to his name. He noticed his wife, Laura, sitting behind the dock where he sits and mouths, "Are you okay?" She nodded. He says, "It'll be okay. I don't know how, but it will." To his wife, as he takes a long look at his family and associates sitting behind him in the public gallery, his wife says, "I love you." Laura Brand said, "Oh, God," as her husband walked into the dock and then said, "I love you," to him after he turned around to face her.

This is just so dark. It's just so dark. And he is being treated truly like he is the worst of the worst, like a truly dangerous serial rapist, Ted Bundy type. If you read the press about him, it's almost universal. And very few of these people have any idea, uh, about what was actually testified to at this trial in terms of the facts on Russell's side, the things that were not in dispute even, like I testified to about what this woman did when she met Russell.

Uh, it's just— it's deeply unsettling, I have to say. And I can't— I keep thinking of this one exchange Russell and I had when he came here. It's kind of funny. I mean, to me, I laughed, but it's not as funny now. I don't know. Here it is. It's quick. Sat 233. I'm worried about your criminal trial. I don't think that you're going to get a fair shake in Great Britain.

Viva Frei00:49:02

Oh, no.

Megyn Kelly00:49:03

They love to put people in jail.

Viva Frei00:49:04

Oh, no. I don't want to go to jail. It's my strong preference to not go to jail.

Megyn Kelly00:49:11

Back then, it still seemed, you know, not like a joke, but like something we could laugh about, like it might not happen. And now he's faced with a very stark reality. So you tell me, Dave, is there any chance of getting out before the two-thirds? Is there any chance, given what's happening to him in prison, that they will do something on a humanitarian basis for Russell?

Dave Aronberg00:49:30

Generally, what they do is they put them in supervised, like custody. It's called the SHU in the United States, the Special Housing Unit. We see this with the Tate brothers, who then complain that they're in isolation, but you're in a special area so that the others don't come after you. It's interesting. I saw a bunch of social media posts talking about that quote you mentioned, using the word nonce, and they would, like, put dashes like this was the most horrible word. I didn't know what they meant. I was like, "What? I don't know what that word is."

Megyn Kelly00:49:58

Same.

Dave Aronberg00:49:58

Yeah. I've heard the word Larry.

Megyn Kelly00:50:00

Me neither.

Dave Aronberg00:50:00

But, you know, this does— it is interesting because this has become— everything is politicized, but this has become so politicized. You know, Harvey Weinstein was a big supporter of liberals and Democrats. And then when he went down for his crimes, you heard— you didn't hear much about it from conservatives. And now you hear this when it comes to Russell Brand. So it shouldn't be political. It should be everyone, you know, should appreciate our civil rights and civil liberties. It reminds me of the old joke that a conservative is a liberal who's been mugged. But I would counter that a liberal is a conservative who's been arrested.

Viva Frei00:50:35

Make it understood.

Megyn Kelly00:50:37

Go ahead, quickly, Viva.

Viva Frei00:50:38

They've stuck Tommy Robinson in a predominantly Muslim prison because they wanted him to get killed. They want Russell Brand to either kill himself or get killed. And that's what they're setting it up for. And I think it's patently obvious. This is what they do to political dissidents.

Advertisement00:50:50
Megyn Kelly00:52:23

She is the host of Afterparty on the MK Media Podcast Network. You can go and subscribe at afterpartyemily.com. She also hosts our wrap-up show on SiriusXM Channel 111 right after we air live there from 12 to 2. She's two to three. Emily, great to see you. Welcome back. So unbelievably, he sits down with Ross DuThote. No one knows how to pronounce Ross's last name, but it's pretty close to that. And, um, like, the whole thing to me seemed like an exercise in President Trump trying to be likable.

He was, you know, this wasn't the combative President Trump. This was the, like, gee, I'm super likable. Let me remind you of why so many of you used to like me and I'll charm— I will charm you. And in that context, he gave away the farm an amnesty. Like, I— my jaw dropped when I saw this. Like, if you wanted— like, if you were sitting around the White House, like, what could we do? We're very angry at the Republican base for not voting for us. They— they— they feel betrayed on Epstein.

They feel betrayed on the Iran war. They feel betrayed on all the corruption that we've been guilty of when we haven't been thinking about their problems. What could be a way to drive around— drive out the last few standing? What— how could we get rid of the last fans we have within the Republican base? Try this answer. Sat one.

Speaker 800:53:50

So you think your deportation policy went too far.

Megyn Kelly00:53:53

I think it was too far.

Speaker 800:53:53

It was too tough.

Viva Frei00:53:54

I think it might be too tough, yeah.

Speaker 800:53:55

What would happen? What does the deal look like with the Democrats?

Viva Frei00:53:58

Ultimately, that hurt me. Well, the deal would be we would work something out. And I think it's something— I think that's something that's actually doable.

Speaker 800:54:05

Doable to create some kind of— some kind of legal status for the landscapers and the—

Viva Frei00:54:09

Yeah. When you go into a hotel and you have a woman that's worked there as a— you know, as a maid, as a cleaner, as a this, as a that, as a waitress, a lot of good things, great jobs, and all of a sudden they're being taken out of the country, it's tough. It's a tough thing. But there is a group of people that I would say on the sort of pretty far right that would like everybody taken out.

Speaker 800:54:32

Do some of them—

Viva Frei00:54:33

And there's a group of people.

Speaker 800:54:34

Do any of those people work in your administration? Are they in the building with us right now?

Viva Frei00:54:38

Yeah. No, no. Well, there are a lot of those people. Then there's also people that are more modified on that. In other words, get the killers out. Get all the rough ones out. Get the drug dealers out. But let the people that are here and in some cases here for 10 and 15 years work a deal for them.

Megyn Kelly00:54:56

Okay. Now there's no question what he was talking about. The deal would be we'd work something out. Legal status, yes. We'll work out a deal. There's just no question what he was saying. I mean, the question was explicit. Do you mean the landscaper will get legal status? Yeah. Yes. That's what he said. Then you had this Rapid Response 47 X account, which we believe is affiliated with his campaign, not the official White House, immediately puts out in response to an X post by the Blaze that read, "Trump says he may work on an amnesty deal with Democrats."

They put out wrong. The word amnesty was never even said in this entire exchange. Right. But that's exactly what working out a deal to allow legal status to illegals is. And everyone knows that. Even a six-year-old can understand that. So the campaign, understanding the political jeopardy he just created for the last few Republicans standing, tried to lie about what the president said. But we have eyes and ears.

And he said it over and over and over. And just in case you thought the deal was, we'll work out a deal that they'll all leave and then we'll make it easier for new ones to come, et cetera, which isn't what happened at all. But there's no wiggle room. Ross specifically said, "Do you mean legal status for the landscaper that Trump raised? Someone who's been here illegal?" And he said, "Yeah." So what do you make of that?

Emily Jashinsky00:56:28

Well, legal status for that landscaper would also then involve, in all likelihood, people who have committed other crimes after, you know, crossing the border illegally. It's very hard to be an immigrant in the United States and not to be fudging the system in one way or another, whether it's with Social Security.

Megyn Kelly00:56:44

Saskia Laund Omar.

Emily Jashinsky00:56:45

Yeah. Yeah, right. But I mean, it is genuinely really common, whether it's with work fraud, those types of things, fraudulent documents. It is really genuinely hard to do that. So you end up creating a giant carrot program for people who have— for people who have been here. They get amnesty. They get forgiveness for other things that they may have done. And that incentivizes other people to just try to get into the country. That's one of the major problems with these types of deals that have attempted to have been struck. James Linkford not long ago, Mitch McConnell worked with congressional Democrats on the Senate side to get a bill like that passed.

And it was atrocious. I mean, I remember reading through it several years back. This was right before Biden's reelection that became a Kamala Harris election. And it was a disaster of a bill. That is the last deal that Republicans and Democrats were able to work through. And it was a total carrot. It ended up being something that would just attract more and more people. Yes, it's important that he's closed the border. But on top of that, you can't have policies that once people are in the United States because they've claimed asylum or other things, they then end up staying. Like, that's a huge, huge problem. So I'm not entirely surprised that he's floating this because one of the frustrations that immigration hawks have had with this administration is that they're actually not going after employers.

And what Trump just recited to Ross was a lot of the sort of frustrations that employers have had with hawkish immigration policy, right? That you have this person that's worked for them as a landscaper at a hotel. And Trump went into detail because you know he's been hearing from those people who have farm.

Megyn Kelly00:58:12

And he is one of those people.

Emily Jashinsky00:58:13

Exactly. Exactly. And that's exactly why hawks have said you could have avoided what looked like a lot of cruelty in Minneapolis and other places. You could have avoided all of those optics by starting to crack down on employers first.

Megyn Kelly00:58:27

Do e-verify. Just do e-verify. You don't have to run around hunting down Hispanics in the streets. He's right that I'm sure that did hurt him with a certain subset of the population. There's certainly independents, maybe not as many hardline Republicans. But just do e-verify. Then they can't work. It makes it impossible for them to collect a paycheck in the United States and they self-deport. That's the most humane way of doing this.

Emily Jashinsky00:58:52

Right. And that, again, people have been saying that forever. I mean, there are ways to crack down on banking that immigration hawks are frustrated with this administration for not going far enough on. E-verify is a huge one. And it just hasn't happened yet. And so that's where Ron DeSantis last week comes out on Election Day swinging against Kristi Noem and says, you know, what everybody kind of knew, but was just kind of not talked about enough openly on the right, which is that this was a circus. It was a show to get headlines that endeared her to Donald Trump. And yes, obviously, he switched leadership at DHS and they have been hitting record numbers of deportations month after month.

But we had a record level, a historic surge. That's according to The New York Times' David Leonhardt. He had at a low estimate about 8 million people came into the United States. Non-citizens came into the United States in about a three-year period. It is a bigger surge than the peak of Ellis Island. And so even record number of deportations are not going to reverse that. So it's a— if you're Donald Trump and you want to deal with this intractable, difficult situation, you can do the hard thing that's going to get you in trouble with a lot of donors, a lot of people you know, and it is going to be on a different side of an issue that you've been on for than you've been on for a long time.

Or you can do the easy thing and try to cut a deal with Democrats like he did back in, I think it was 2018 or '19 with Nancy Pelosi. They were sitting down and talking about DACA at that point in time. So I'm not surprised. Now that Stephen Miller is White House Chief of Staff, I think that interview with Ross was taped before Stephen Miller was named White House Chief of Staff. I might be surprised if something gets past Stephen. He'll be kind of the goalie on this. But I don't know. I mean, Trump would do it.

Megyn Kelly01:00:25

I mean, but the truth is, while the Chief of Staff is considered the president's alter ego and somebody who sets agenda in the White House, not with this president. This president sets his own agenda. There is— Stephen Miller is a hardliner on immigration. But if the president himself is saying, "I want to cut a deal," Stephen Miller's going to have to cut a deal. He's not actually the president. So, I mean, while I would normally feel heartened by the appointment of Stephen Miller, who I actually am a fan of, I don't, because I just heard the president himself say over and over again, "The deal would be we'd work something out."

Legal status? Yeah. And once again, talked about a deal on 60 Minutes. This is not a throwaway on a tarmac. This is a sit-down interview with 60 Minutes, which he knows is going to make news. Deeply disturbed. This is not going to help. They've tried it. Reagan gave 3 million illegals amnesty. And what happened? We got a whole lot more. It is an incentive to additional illegals. And President Trump is not going to be president forever. He's going to leave. The next president could be a Democrat who is almost certain to loosen the border restrictions that Trump put in place at the border.

And if we also have an incentive on amnesty that the Republican president just worked out, God only knows what we're going to be asking for. When Mitt Romney lost the election in 2012, I was at Fox News when the Republicans convinced themselves it was their rhetoric around immigration. And I was there when Roger Ailes told the staff, "We're going to have to loosen up. The Republicans have cut a deal on immigration. We're going to have to change our rhetoric." And go back and look at the Sean Hannity clips from 2012 after the Romney loss. It was like the invasion of the body snatchers.

He started going from, like, hardline immigration talk to being like, "Maybe we need a deal. You know, maybe we just have to be humane about finding a solution for those who are here." And Marco Rubio was the person who, like, penned the whole proposal, which circled the drain as they watched how Republican voters reacted to that, including Hispanic voters who didn't want that at all. And by the time we got to '015, '15 and a half, and '16, who was the dominant Republican talking about immigration in a winning way?

Donald Trump, whose whole platform was, "No amnesty. No cracking. Only cracking down, build the wall," which to this day remains his greatest approval line. So, like, this is insane that even he now is falling back into these old traps, being like browbeaten by the left into thinking his problem with Hispanics was the immigration crackdown as opposed to the economy. But he is not— he is not wrestling with anything having to do with what he did to drive this vote.

In fact, he's honest about the fact that people didn't like the war, but he's still convinced it was the fact that he wasn't on the ballot. Here's his analysis of the midterm losses, Sat two.

Viva Frei01:03:21

Well, number one, I was not on the ballot, but I campaigned hard for some people. And I think if I was on the ballot, it would have been a much different situation because you saw the level of popularity and love. There was love. We had massive rallies. You had to transfer those voters, however, to candidates that they didn't like. But there's something beyond that. They didn't like the war. They didn't like the fact that gasoline went up because I had it down at a low. And there's a great dislike, incredibly, for Israel.

Speaker 801:03:54

Let's go through those then one by one. Start with the candidates, right? You said it was tough to transfer your own appeal to candidates. But in a lot of cases, you picked the candidates. You endorsed Ken Paxton in Texas. He had a tough time. You endorsed Darlene Graham in South Carolina.

Viva Frei01:04:10

Clinton would have lost also. Darlene, I did that in honor of a man named Lindsey, who was a friend of mine. And she fought hard.

Megyn Kelly01:04:20

So we're going with candidate quality. And he will— he'll say the thing about the Iran war. They were against the Iran war. But then he'll say, "But it was worth it. It was worth it. It was the greatest decision ever. You know, we had to do it." I stopped them from having a nuke, which may be a reference to June of 2025, but absolutely is a fake reference to what happened in March of 2026. But there's not real reflection here, Emily, other than to say it was a candidate quality issue that cost the Republicans. We don't even— how many seats is it in the House?

Like 40-plus seats and maybe seven to nine seats in the U.S. Senate.

Emily Jashinsky01:04:57

I mean, yeah, like I have— I posted on X like the day before that I predicted the conversation was going to be about candidate quality because it was so obvious that that was going to be a cope for trying to get away from the overall environment. And it's not entirely untrue that Darlene Graham was a bad candidate, but a bad candidate that was foisted on the public by Donald Trump. She won her primary by like four points. It was very much a Trump bump over Ralph Norman. So no question that he had a hand in picking some of those people. He's probably right that Corbyn would have lost too. But anyway, all that is to say, I'm glad.

Megyn Kelly01:05:27

But by the way, just to hold that thought, because another thing on that is like, "Oh, but I did it for my friend Lindsey Graham." What? Why are we doing favors? Like, Lindsey Graham is dead. He doesn't have to live the consequences of these decisions. You and I do. Our children do. Just the absurdity of that. And that was an adequate explanation for who would serve out the remaining four months on Lindsey Graham's term, but not who should actually run for the six-year term. And he is the reason that Darlene was chosen. And here you have him dismissing it as like, "I did it for my friend Lindsey, who's dead and buried."

Emily Jashinsky01:05:56

Yeah. And also, I think it's pretty clear that wasn't a favor in the end to Lindsey Graham because the Lindsey Graham legacy is now tarnished by the fact that Darlene Graham lost in— lost the state of South Carolina to Annie Andrews, who was like resistance posting her way through the pandemic. If people haven't seen the videos that she posted around the pandemic period, they have to go look them up online because it's incredible.

Megyn Kelly01:06:18

And also, forgive me, just one of the— it's up to now an 80-seat majority in the House, not 40. 40 is what the Dems beat the Republicans by in Trump's first term and the first midterm where they retook the House. It's up to 80. And he wants us to believe it was a candidate quality issue, Emily, because he wasn't on the ballot. These are lies. This is spin. It does absolutely no one any good to not be totally, brutally honest about why the Republican Party was eviscerated a week ago.

Emily Jashinsky01:06:52

This is what's actually been driving me crazy over the course of the last week. It is that people are welcome to disagree with me on tariffs. They're welcome to disagree with me on the war. They're welcome to disagree with anybody. They're welcome to believe the war was a good idea and that tariffs were a bad idea. That is, I think, a perfectly fine conservative position. I completely disagree with both of those positions, but they are welcome to have those positions. I would never deny that tariffs were a serious problem in the election. They clearly were campaigned against in Kansas and Iowa and Texas. They were a factor.

Megyn Kelly01:07:19

Same.

Emily Jashinsky01:07:20

Of course they were. Of course they were. But what you see on the charts of gas prices and diesel prices is a complete surge right after February 28th that continues until Election Day. The Tax Foundation estimated this year that tariffs were going to cost the average American family about $820. It was about $1,000 the year before, obviously there were court decisions that intervened in the years since. But on top of that, Mark Zandi of Moody's Analytics said that the Iran war had already cost the average American family $2,000. And that is directly showing in his approval rating, which you can see David Shore, the polling analyst, said it's a structural shift in public opinion in Donald Trump when the Iran war happens.

And you can see it in all the charts. They've been putting people who are anti-tariff and pro-war have been putting this chart that's going everywhere that shows Trump's approval rating going down starting at Liberation Day. That's what they say the chart shows. No, it shows Trump's approval rating going down on these charts that they are posting when he gets inaugurated. That is the point at which his approval rating starts dropping. So what happened after Liberation Day was continuing a trend that preexisted Liberation Day. The Iran war continues it, but prices were high right now.

Megyn Kelly01:08:28

And it went up when J.D. Vance signed the memorandum of understanding. Trump's approval went up when that happened and then fell again once the war resumed.

Emily Jashinsky01:08:37

Yes. And that is a very difficult point for people who say it was the MoU that cost the— I mean, I don't— I can't understand how people are saying this stuff aloud and taking themselves seriously.

Megyn Kelly01:08:47

It's lies.

Emily Jashinsky01:08:48

There are mountains of evidence to the contrary.

Megyn Kelly01:08:49

There are lies.

Emily Jashinsky01:08:50

Yeah.

Megyn Kelly01:08:50

I don't even know if they are taking themselves seriously. They have an agenda. You know what I mean? It's so very obvious they have an agenda. They don't want you to say, "Oh, you're Israel first." Well, you are. You are. You don't have to be Jewish. A lot of these Christian conservatives, evangelical types who are very, very pro-Israel, who like the main thing is that we protect Israel. No. The main thing is that we protect the United States of America and American voters and workers. Mark Tieszen is out there trying to suggest that President Trump was not saying that the Iran war had anything to do with the election.

Like, again, he did. And even Don Jr. was like, "Play the whole soundbite, Mark. What are you saying?" Like, the whole soundbite of Trump has him saying, "Yes, the Iran war was in fact to blame." But the president goes on to say, "But I would do it again." You know what I mean? Because the president is never going to say, "I did the wrong thing." That's not really the way Trump operates. And now you've got Mark Levin out there. Okay, so you would think that Mark Levin, who is one of the chief— one of the chief cheerleaders for the war and one of the main reasons why President Trump was goated into doing it and continuing it.

So did he have a come-to-Jesus moment? Well, I guess maybe that's not the right phrase. Did he have a let's get honest moment where he was ready to reflect on what he did? No. Listen to this, Sat five. This is Sunday night, last night.

Dave Aronberg01:10:17

The only way we can defeat the Marxist-Islamist threat, and it is a grave threat, the threat to our country is if we are united, clearheaded, mission-oriented, and mission-focused, and become the Tea Party type activists of the recent past. And today that means a few major immediate objectives, starting with the war with Iran. First, defeat the Iranian regime.

No more back and forth. End it. Destroy it. Arm the Iranian people, the Reagan doctrine, ensure that this genocidal, seven-century terrorist regime can never have a nuclear weapon because if it survives, it will. That means it must no longer exist, whether the isolationists, Democrats, or those who cheer for our enemies, like it or not. This is the only way to end it.

Megyn Kelly01:11:18

He'll never listen. The neocons will never stop pressing for more war, annihilation of the entire regime. Okay, he already got his bomb on the Ayatollah and the top emissaries. But you want to talk about eliminating the entire regime? That's all of the Revolutionary Guard. That's hundreds of people. That would require boots on the ground. He wants a full-scale ground war in Iran right now. That's what he wants. And he's still very close to President Trump.

Emily Jashinsky01:11:47

I just want them to be honest about that. I mean, seriously, like, please be honest. Either say he's extremely brave because he made a— Trump is extremely brave because he made a politically unpopular decision that might have cost him the midterms, or just say, honestly, this is a decision that has cost us the midterms. But they want to have it both ways, right? They want to say Trump was courageous. He did something despite public opinion going against him, despite the risks to his own legacy and career in the short term because he's a long-term thinker. On the other hand, they want to say, "Oh, no, no, no.

It was all the tariffs." Like, I just want you to be honest that there were massive political consequences to this. And I don't know if you saw, Megan, over the weekend, viral clips of John Kennedy on Theo Von going around. That was from July. And Marco Rubio said the same thing that John Kennedy said in that clip, which was the claim intelligence showed that Iran was building its ballistic missile capacity up so much so that they would be past a point of immunity when we wanted to strike and take out further nuclear enrichment and all weapons and those sorts of things. Marco Rubio said that within two days of Trump going into Iran.

And then, yeah, John Kennedy repeated it on one of the most popular podcasts in the country. And people were, you know, re-upping these clips over the weekend and saying, "It was just the messaging. It was just the messaging." Well, that is bullshit because both of those messages reverberated around the country over and over again when they were made. Again, Theo's podcast is one of the most popular in the country. Marco said that and it was viral immediately. The problem for them is nobody buys it. Nobody buys it after Iraq and Afghanistan. Nobody is buying this intelligence anymore.

Megyn Kelly01:13:19

And also because Tulsi Gabbard, who was the DNI at the time, was simultaneously saying, "We assess that they are not close to getting a nuclear weapon and this is not a concern at all." And President Trump himself in June of 2025 told us all, "We've annihilated their nuclear capacity. Annihilated it." So where exactly were they getting the ability to build a nuke from? Because what you put on the tip of that missile is a nuclear weapon. The missile is the delivery system. The actual bomb is the nuke. And President Trump told us they decimated their ability.

We in June of 2025. So which is it? Because we had a DNI saying there was no threat. We had President Trump saying there was no threat. We had the Mark Levins of the world saying there was one. And they and Bibi Netanyahu were in President Trump's ear and managed to get him to do it, suggesting this could be another Venezuela, which everyone knows now it wasn't. It was far from that. This guy will not stop. And listen to him now. Listen. More lies here in Sat six.

Dave Aronberg01:14:20

As for this war, it's not really a war. Are we storming the beaches? Are we parachuting the 82nd Airborne into Iran? Are there ground troops? Are there tanks? Are there constant and ongoing military actions? Are there massive amounting casualties like past wars? This is a military operation. And yet listen to the naysayers. What would they have said during World War II? What would they have said during World War I?

Megyn Kelly01:14:50

Oh my God.

Dave Aronberg01:14:51

What would they have said during the Civil War when Lincoln was under pressure to make peace with the South of the Confederacy? What would they have said? These people don't represent America. They want you to believe that we lost the election because we decided to stop Iran from getting a nuclear weapon and from killing Americans.

Megyn Kelly01:15:13

Oh my Lord. No one believes you.

Dave Aronberg01:15:15

That's not why we lost the election. If this military operation had any role in it whatsoever, it's because it's not completed.

Megyn Kelly01:15:24

Oh my God. Still with the lies. So first of all, are there any ground troops? You have to have ground troops in order for it to be a real war. Why are there no ground troops? Because we all objected because so much of President Trump's base revolted when he launched this war without our approval, without the majority approval in the United States, never mind the U.S. Congress, that it would be a lot more kinetic than it already has been if it weren't for the strong stamp of disapproval and the pushback the president got from members of his own party when he did this. Okay.

But second of all, that doesn't mean it's not a war. The Secretary of War, Pete Hegseth, and President Trump himself, the Commander in Chief, have called it a war numerous times. And then the nerve to suggest that, you know, these same people would have objected to World War II and the Civil War. Talk about apples to oranges. We had decimated the nuclear program and Iran was a problem in the Middle East, but didn't have the capability of hurting the United States. If they had the capability of hurting the United States, they would have unleashed it after we attacked them and killed 170 girls in their girl school.

By the way, Mark Levin, does that count as war? Is that—do we count that? 170 dead girls in Iran by our Pentagon's decision for which we still have not apologized or even taken responsibility, which is un-American. Anyway, and he's still peddling the same bullshit that it wasn't this conflict that drove any votes in the midterm elections at all.

Emily Jashinsky01:16:48

Yeah. And by the way, 21 dead Americans. Like, it's so offensive. I don't know. I was listening to that. I was like, this is like deeply offensive to the sacrifice that has already happened for the stagnancy in the Strait of Hormuz that we've seen over many, many months now that is being brought at enormous cost to the U.S. military. And so it's inconsistent. His argument doesn't make sense. And just like some basic honesty. I mean, to have that tape, I know you played it last week with Ben Shapiro and Mark Levin, like in September, saying they believed the Iran war wouldn't be an issue in the election.

And then to look at the election results and have zero, zero humility about their political prognostication, that's not just a competence issue. I mean, it should be a massive competence issue. It's the type of thing that Fox News should actually make you address and apologize for if you're Mark Levin. I haven't seen that he did that. Maybe he did. But any news network, I think if you have something that is that flagrantly embarrassing within a couple of months of happening, I honestly think they should make him address it or apologize for it on air, explain why he got it so wrong.

Megyn Kelly01:17:48

Yeah. Oh, they won't. They won't because he speaks for them.

Emily Jashinsky01:17:50

It's a credibility problem, clearly, but it's also a character problem. I mean, how do you say something like that in front of millions of people watching you? I don't know if this audience has a million. It's probably around a million. But how do you say something like that?

Megyn Kelly01:18:02

If that.

Emily Jashinsky01:18:02

Right. How do you say something like that?

Megyn Kelly01:18:03

No. And also say it like, what's with the like reading, reading? He's got like a script, a paper script on his desk. He's looking down.

Emily Jashinsky01:18:12

Like a book report.

Megyn Kelly01:18:13

Manage the teleprompter. But it's like, this is all you talk about. Why can't you look into camera and say what's on your mind? Why do you have to have your little pre-printed script that you've got to read off of your desk to make your points, which you want us to believe are heartfelt? And you clearly spend day and night thinking about them. I don't—I actually genuinely don't understand that. He also says the Iran war is not why we lost the election. That's not what President Trump is saying. President Trump is defending J.D.

Vance's commentary saying we lost because of the war. Here he is in Sat four.

Speaker 801:18:50

Has J.D. Vance's comments about Iran questioning some of those decisions, has that impacted your relationship at all?

Speaker 901:18:56

No, not at all. But a lot of people didn't like his comments, but not me. He was right, other than one thing. He should have made one other statement, one statement that I think is very important. If you had it to do again, would you do it again? The answer is yes. I can tell you, if I had it to do again, this historically, for history, will go down as one of the best things we ever did. Because if they ever had a nuclear weapon, they would blow up the world. You know why? Because they're crazy.

Megyn Kelly01:19:25

So that's Trump doing what you were asking these other Republican pro-war pundits to do, which is be honest. 74% said it was the critical or a major factor in their vote, the war. But he's saying it was worth it. To me, it was worth it. Okay, that's at least somewhat honest. We can actually work with that. But you can't deny reality like Shapiro and Levin and Teason are doing, which is to deny that the Iran war itself, the decision to do it, and then what was done there actually did drive vote.

74% of the electorate voted on it. It's like you can't work with these people because to deny that makes you a dishonest hack.

Emily Jashinsky01:20:07

Just look at gas prices. Look at gas prices alone and look at diesel prices. Diesel prices control so much inflation throughout the economy. All you have to do is look at the before and after and see how high both of those prices went after the Iran war. And that's it. In a nutshell, that is your answer. And the reason, again, that I think so many of these people are absolutely unwilling to be honest in a way that Trump at least is coming out and say it. I mean, you see how Trump frames it as part of his legacy, that he's brave, that he did this because it had to be done and other people didn't. Like, that's one much more honest way to do it.

But the reason I think a lot of other people don't is because they see this ultimately as being about the battle for the soul of the Republican Party. And they see it as about being about J.D. Vance because they believe that he's the threat to taking the Republican Party in a more populist direction and a direction that is, yes, a little bit more protectionist and a little bit less interventionist. And that, to them, is what this is really all about at the end of the day, which is why they're not making the honest moral argument, even if you and I disagree with it. That's why they're making the political argument. That is why they're absolutely wedded to the idea that what they describe as Vanceism, and sometimes they won't even come out and say that they're really talking about J.D., but a lot of times they do, is politically toxic.

That's what they want to say. Mike Pence came out and said that voters rejected economic populism. That is insane. James Talarico was running on economic populism. So many of these candidates, Richard Ojeda in North Carolina, was running on economic populism. I mean, so many of the high-profile Abdullah Al-Sayyed, money in your pocket, money out of politics, Medicare for All.

Megyn Kelly01:21:37

Gina Hiena-Hosa down in Texas.

Emily Jashinsky01:21:39

That's just economic populism across the board. And Republicans' number one issue, according to a Wesleyan study on ads towards the end of the election, was taxes. So they were running on tax cuts. So that is why they're obsessed with this political reading of the shellacking as something that is about actually the toxic political implications of populism. It's all about trying to control the future of the GOP.

Megyn Kelly01:22:02

Mark Teason is out there saying, if you have something that you want to say, you know, about the Iran war and so on, you know, stop blaming the pundits around President Trump. Have the nerve to say it was Trump's decision and it's on him. I don't know who he's talking to. Certainly not this show, because it is Trump's decision and it is on him. And most of us who have been complaining about this, from Tucker to yours truly to many in the right wing sort of pod sphere, have had absolutely no qualms whatsoever about blaming the Commander in Chief, Donald Trump. It's 100% his fault.

But the analysis for any smart person doesn't stop there. You have to figure out who convinced him, who told him this would be a good idea. I don't know what world Teason operates in, but in my world, which is the real one, there are advisors around a Commander in Chief who tell him, this is a good idea, this is the plan, this is how you'll execute. And those people include you, Mark, my old friend from Fox News, include you, Mark Levin, who now denies he ever advised President Trump, even though he knows full well President Trump, first of all, is addicted to that stupid dishonest show.

Second of all, is tweeting about it all the time, demanding everybody watch it or you're not MAGA. Third of all, was in Mark Levin's noogie elbow with basically the hands, the knuckles rubbing against his head by Mark Levin, who tried to dominate him and has succeeded in doing so. And General Jack Keen and of course chief among them, Bibi Netanyahu, all of which you weren't allowed to say or you were considered an anti-Semite. But as far as I know, Mark Teason is a Christian conservative. I think General Jack Keen is too. It's not about Jewish.

It has nothing to do with Jewishness whatsoever. That's something Netanyahu and Israel's defenders use to try to shut you up. Same way as if you criticize Sharia law, they try to throw Islamophobia at you. Well, that didn't shut me up either. So everyone can fuck off. We're only dropping truth bombs on this show. That's the way it's going to be.

Emily Jashinsky01:24:00

I mean, one of the reasons I especially blame President Trump is the reporting from inside of the White House at that time, John Swan and Maggie Haberman. John Swan is an excellent Trump reporter. And they reported that everyone was lukewarm except for like one person in the president's inner circle was lukewarm at best. And many, including Marco Rubio, including Marco Rubio, lukewarm at best about this decision, if not totally opposed to it and casting doubt on the intelligence he was given by Netanyahu at the time. Trump's own inner circle was not counseling him to do this with maybe one or two exceptions.

And so yes, there had to have been a very convincing message coming from others. And it would be we would be remiss not to note that Ron DeSantis, who again came out on Election Day before he even knew that Florida was going to be so close and the rest of the country was going to be a bloodbath for Republicans, he came out and said it was the war. Ron DeSantis is very close to Israel. He is very close to Netanyahu. He is very hawkish. He has been very hawkish throughout his entire career. And even he.

Megyn Kelly01:25:01

I don't trust him at all.

Emily Jashinsky01:25:02

But even he is willing to say he thinks that.

Megyn Kelly01:25:05

No, I know he's willing to say it. But I have to say it's a bit much to watch DeSantis try to position himself as like the godfather of Republicanism. And he's going to come out. He's going to judge everybody. He's going to tell us what's real. He's even got a thoughts on how the media ought to cover it. Like the, you know what, take a seat. Okay. You won Florida. Good for you. You were a disaster in the GOP primary. A disaster. I was there. You didn't get any votes. No one was into you. You weren't even a strong second. You're not a strong retail politician. Okay. So like, I think he should tread a little lightly because he's got criticism for every single Republican and every Republican media.

He wants to be the new boss of the media. It's a no, sir. Learn how to work the media and perform in front of a camera. And then maybe we'll start listening to you, but we don't answer to you. And honestly, this like whole business of like, oh, you know, this about the he's going to be honest about the Iran war. Thank you. But you're as close to Bibi Netanyahu as any GOP politician in the country. So where's your disavowal until I hear something that's a lot stronger on how the country needs to put our own interests ahead of Israel's? And you're not going to be beholden to Bibi's wishes. I don't really want to hear from him.

I don't want to hear from any politician who's up the ass of a foreign leader.

Emily Jashinsky01:26:16

At the very least, Ron DeSantis should. Well, I mean, at the very least, it's a smarter argument than what we're hearing from Mark Teason and Mark Levin. I'll put it that way. Like if you're trying to persuade people.

Megyn Kelly01:26:27

Yes, I agree.

Emily Jashinsky01:26:28

That at the very least he's doing so. That's what also kind of drives me insane about this is that they're counterproductive to their own cause and they're too smug and insulated to realize that they are hurting their own cause over and over again. Every single strategy they attack or they come to is like counterproductive repeatedly. One of the things I was thinking about as you were just talking is that, Megan, you were like fairly supportive of Midnight Hammer as were most conservatives. They were mostly supportive of Midnight Hammer. And then everybody's patience was tested. Like people went out on a limb and said, yeah, we think this was the brave thing to do.

We think this was the right thing to do. And we're not, you know, there was no question of people's loyalties to the president or people's like nobody was doing nobody was playing this game. And then suddenly people say that's a little bit too far for me. And everything explodes after Iraq, Afghanistan, like it is just it constantly making people distrust the side that is pushing war more and more. They couldn't be doing themselves more of a disadvantage with the strategy.

Megyn Kelly01:27:28

Yes, yes. And then you have this from President Trump today. Does anybody really believe that this election in air quotes was honest? Well, he's using actual quotes. How could the polls be so wrong? Some early voting dumps were so large that it was impossible to win no matter how many people went to vote. It's all about the machines, which are far more important than the voter. President DJT. So once again, trying to suggest that there's something wrong with the election. How could the polls be so wrong?

You are misled, sir. You are fed little gold nuggets by a bunch of sycophants who work for you like Natalie Parp, not to tell you the truth, but to make you feel good as you put your head against the pillow at night. That's your fault. That's your fault for having people around you like Susie Wiles, reportedly, who wouldn't tell you the truth because they were too afraid of you, because they were too worried about their own backsides getting fired. They were too mad about you getting angry. That's why you were fed those little bullshit sweet nothings whispered into your ear day after day.

Though Jonathan Swan and Maggie Haberman are reporting that he was told at least the week before the vote what the polls were showing and he refused to believe it. He's the power of positive thinking guy. He refused to believe that it's real. And so now we've got to go back down this ridiculous lane of the election was dishonest. Just stop. Stop. We're not doing that. Nobody believes that shit. No one. The pet food industry will not tell you that the real story is in the ingredient panel, not the front of the bag.

Advertisement01:29:04
Megyn Kelly01:30:14

He's appealing to what's left of like his core core supporters who are under his spell. And that number is shrinking exponentially by the second. But he's still thinking, you know, if he could just, you know, reach into that pocket and like throw them a couple of nuggets, he can make the reindeer fly again, Emily. And it's not going to happen.

Emily Jashinsky01:30:38

Yeah, I mean, it might work with a small fraction of the Republican Party, maybe something like 20% that trust Trump over literally everybody else. But one of the reasons the polls were wrong is that they were overweighting for rural Republican leaning voters that they had often had a hard time connecting with in the Trump era. And I think one of the big reasons that those polls were off is that those were exactly the voters that they were waiting overly on the Republican side. Those were exactly the voters that flipped or stayed home. And so the polling actually missed that some of Trump's, I mean, what we're seeing in Patrick Ruffini, right of Center pollster, put together a great report showing shifts.

And if you look at the MAGA coalition, rural voters shifted double digit to Dems. Men shifted, independents shifted like 13 points, like core components, non-college, yep, core components of the Trump coalition. And so that's actually one of the best explanations for why the polling is wrong is that the people that were being weighted heavier because they weren't, they felt in places like Maine, pollsters felt they couldn't get in contact with. So like that's why Susan Collins polling was wildly off in 2020. This is what pollsters came at the time to recognize is they were not getting in touch with enough of those specifically rural Republican leaning voters in the Trump era.

And that's the best explanation for it is actually a lot of people who may have voted Republican in the past 10 years, they might not have voted Republican before Trump, by the way, which is an important part of this. They actually turned out for Democrats this time. And that's why some of the charts that are going around, the polls that are going around that look weird to people, they're actually explicable by the kind of Obama-Trump crossover voters going against Trump this time.

Megyn Kelly01:32:11

Yeah, they left you. The polls, they weren't wrong. They were wrong, if anything, against the Democrats. They undercounted the support for the Democrat candidates because it was your core voters leaving you. Like, listen, your only obligation now is to listen to them and help them instead of living in denialism about where the polls were wrong and it wasn't an honest election.

Good luck. Good luck, Republican Party. If I were a Republican on Capitol Hill, I would say the classic, it's over for Donald Trump. We have to forge on without him. That's it. We've got to forge on without him. All I can think of is when I moved to Chicago as a young lawyer, I was about to start my legal career and we traveled cross country, my mom, my stepfather Peter, and my boyfriend and I. And it was a crazy drive. It took, you know, 18 hours. We were from upstate New York to Chicago.

We tried to do it in one fell swoop. It was like some of us were in the cab, four of us were in the cab, then two of us would sleep in the back. It was like I had a, I had one sofa, a love seat, a couple of crates and a bed, but U-Haul had run out of the small little units. So we had this huge like 18-wheeler situation. Anyway, by the time we got to Chicago, our nerves were shot. We were stressed out. We were tired. And we got to try to, to the apartment building to try to like back this enormous truck in. And my stepfather Peter had had it.

He was like beyond. And my then boyfriend Jason comes in. My mom and I are in the elevator holding all these things. And Jason says, his last name is Kerwin. He goes, Kerwin's no good to us anymore. We're going to have to forge on without him. Like, let's go. We're going to have to abandon my stuff. And I'm sorry. That has to be the motivation for this next scene by Republicans in Congress when it comes to Donald Trump. This shit about stolen elections is not going to help anybody. And the same for this shit about amnesty.

I mean, like, let's kill off the very last of our supporters with nonsense like this. My friends, forge on without him.

Emily Jashinsky01:34:26

Well, I was going to say, imagine the incentives for a senator in a place like Kansas or Texas that just flipped really blue. The incentives for a Republican senator in those states are no longer to follow in lockstep with Donald Trump, even a Republican senator. That has all changed. South Carolina, when you see mandates, maybe you're up in two years. Look at Ron Johnson in Wisconsin. He's up in two years. The political incentive to walk in lockstep with Donald Trump.

Megyn Kelly01:34:50

And he's criticizing.

Emily Jashinsky01:34:51

Yes. Yep. Exactly. And so the political incentive not to upset the hardcore Trump base now that it's diminished a bit, but especially now that Trump's power appears to be diminished, the political incentive for those senators to go along with every single thing Trump says is gone. And that's going to be an interesting thing when votes, potential impeachment votes come up, when investigations come up in the next couple of months or the next six months over some things corruption wise that are actually very serious. Those senators, if you are now a senator from Texas and your coworker is James Talarico or South Carolina, Tim Scott, and your coworker is Annie Andrews, you have a different set of political incentives now because voters in your state just turned out lopsided for Democrats by double digits in some cases.

Megyn Kelly01:35:31

Yep. Ron Johnson was out there last week calling out the corruption in the administration, in this Trump administration. Ron Johnson, Republican of Wisconsin. And he's been very active in the MAHA world. The big news over the past three days was Cali Means, friend of this program, spent on many times, went on tour with us calling out the corruption in the administration, naming names in particular, Susie Wiles as the main reason he says MAHA has died.

MAHA can't get through. She, he says, is why glyphosate, this ridiculous fertilizer that's poisoning all of America, made by Bayer, was the subject of an executive order giving Bayer immunity from lawsuits and is, you know, just as robust and ubiquitous as ever under the new MAHA administration, the special pass for glyphosate, for Pepsi, for sugar, for ultra-processed foods. He's putting it squarely at the doorstep of Susie Wiles, who's now the departed chief of staff.

She's pushing back and so is her top dog, who's also left the administration. That's just one of the many things in the news today. We're going to pick it up. I'm going to take a break. Emily and I are going to keep going. The Russell Brand news set us back a bit on hard news coming out of Washington. We've got that. And we've got the vile, vile Jennifer Welch, the disgusting angry lady hosting the Far Left podcast, who's getting her own just desserts now after having found it hilarious that Charlie Kirk, leader of a national movement, father of two toddlers and husband, was assassinated with a bullet to the neck that we all watched.

Advertisement01:37:15
Megyn Kelly01:38:51

Like, this was the brains behind the whole thing. He is like weirdly brilliant. Like he's one of those geniuses who, like, you kind of just got to sit back and watch his mind work. And he says he can't do it. He says it can't be done because the admin is not committed to getting it done. They are committed to lining the pockets of the big industries who are behind ultra-processed foods, big sugar, et cetera. Here's a bit of what he told Joe Rogan last week on Friday, Saturday 11th.

Speaker 301:39:27

The system of DC does not want any change to happen. And the fact that we had a voter coalition and could use that and say this coalition, you, other people are going to be pissed off if we don't get things done. We were able to get things done. But the simple reality in why I left is that there is a very concentrated group of people in the Trump administration that are antagonistic to what people voted for and are frankly, I think it's very clear, doing things for other reasons, particularly in many cases to enrich their families.

Susie said to me many times, we need money for the midterms, Cali. We need money for the midterms. So when you convince yourself that money is the most important thing for the midterms and for the future political dynamics, and this was the narrative in the Trump administration by Susie from almost the beginning, then you can justify almost anything. And what Tony Fabbrizo did with this polling is said, oh, people don't really care about the food issues. People don't really care about the pesticide issues. People don't really care about the taking on farm or whatever. So that's the big shell game, I think, that happened is everything in the political strategy was based on getting enough money for the midterms, not actually doing the things that would then energize voters enough.

Megyn Kelly01:40:41

Yeah. So well said. This is so sad to me. I do think it's the death of MAHA. And I just don't even know how they'd even begin to tackle it without him there behind RFKJ. We'll pick it up there and go back to the hideous Jennifer Welch in one minute. Don't go away.

Advertisement01:40:58
Megyn Kelly01:41:33

Back with me now, Emily Jashinsky. She's host of Afterparty. You can find it every Monday and Wednesday on YouTube and all podcast platforms carry it as well. So Emily, what do you make of Cali Means leaving? Oh, so sad. And sounding the alarm that for all intents and purposes, MAHA is dead.

Emily Jashinsky01:41:51

Yeah, I mean, MAHA is such an important part of the Trump coalition, and there are so many people inside of the Trump administration that do really, really care about MAHA. They have been totally converted to MAHA diehards that I have to believe there will still be some inside agitation for MAHA goals within the administration. On the other hand, I checked in with some sources myself just to get a picture of what Cali was saying, of whether what Cali was saying was accurate. And yeah, it appears, at least from my sourcing, that it's a relatively accurate picture of what was happening inside.

I think Donald Trump appointing Susie Wiles, who's a very, very successful lobbyist, to the White House chief of staff position, that goes back to Donald Trump. I mean, it doesn't, you can blame Susie Wiles, but at the end of the day, you also have to blame Donald Trump. You have to delegate when you're president of the United States all kinds of tasks, information flow, those sorts of things to a chief of staff. And to put somebody who's a very powerful lobbyist in that position is obviously going to have consequences when you're in Washington, you're on a drain the swamp platform.

I don't think we can understate how important that was to Trump's success in 2016, also in 2024. But just since he came down the came down the escalator, drain the swamp was so hugely intertwined with his brand. It was such an important part of his brand. And if you look at the lobbying registration disclosures for Ballard, which is where Susie Wiles used to work, they have exploded since Trump came into office because all of these massive corporations, including Bayer, which obviously merged with Monsanto as MAHA people who've been following this closely know, they got exactly what they wanted.

They lobbied. They got what their clients paid for out of Ballard. Ballard did the job. It was paid millions of dollars to do, which was to successfully get the administration to be more friendly to Bayer. They got that, as Cali talked about with Joe Rogan, a big carve-out on a national security basis for freaking glyphosate. Like, it's completely insane. But they paid millions of dollars and they got it. And on the lobbying disclosure, Brian, I went and looked at it after Cali posted it. I verified it. Brian Ballard is listed on the lobbying disclosure, and they say they were lobbying people in the administration. So yes, that's how Washington works. But Trump was supposed to be the person whose administration resisted the way Washington worked.

And it's just such a good example of how MAGA was really captured by K Street and the swamp here in DC.

Megyn Kelly01:44:08

By bullshit. That's I'm mad at myself because I did buy the MAHA promises and they were bullshit. They were fucking bullshit. Like Marty McCarry did a good job at the FDA to the extent he could. You know, he got some food dye out of certain products and that was a plus. And I think Bobby Kennedy's rearrangement of like the food pyramid and his pushback on some of the vaccine mandates and so on have been a good thing. But they haven't accomplished what they set out to accomplish at all.

Like the fact that they provided this blanket protection for glyphosate was such a thumb in the eye to every MAHA activist who backed them. And Means is calling it out. Like he's saying Susie Wiles and this Ballard are way too comfortable and that Susie Wiles has a daughter who was effectively a grifter too. And here's him explaining some of that in SOP 13.

Speaker 301:45:10

Susie's daughter became a lobbyist. And I don't know if you have the graph, Continental Strategies, but this is really interesting. Susie's daughter went to a lobbying firm and it was an open discussion in the White House. If a company hired Susie's daughter, then that was getting a high priority. And there's this chart that shows Continental Strategies, the group Susie's daughter worked for, had almost zero in revenue before the Trump administration shot up to 30-ish million dollars a year in revenue.

So if you're a special interest and you want to get something done, the secret's out. You pay Susie's daughter. And it was openly discussed that when they had a client. So this is what happened to Continental once Susie's daughter worked there. And then Susie worked at a firm called Ballard Partners. Ballard Partners has become the highest revenue generating lobbying firm in history. If you hire Ballard, you get a meeting with Susie and you can get things done.

Megyn Kelly01:46:18

It's so gross. It's just really disgusting. He's now trading barbs with Susie's top guy named James Blair. And James Blair is saying that Cali's lying. He's saying he tried to speak to Cali like privately and that he's not returning or answering his calls. He's saying, he says, quote, "Cali, your poor me act is tiring and embarrassing for a grown man who launched a smear campaign.

I've been countering your factual inaccuracy all day. You thought I was going to lay down and take it. I do this for a living. I've been called worse things by better people than you, and I haven't even gotten started." Means meantime, Cali writes, "In light of suggestions that Susie Wiles and James Blair may pursue legal action over my Joe Rogan interview, I am publicly requesting that she, Ballard Partners, Continental Strategy, and other relevant parties immediately preserve all potentially relevant records and communications, including comms between Susie Ballard and their representatives about lobbying access, meeting policy decisions, and corporate clients.

All communications involving Bayer, Monsanto, Ballard Partners, and White House officials concerning glyphosate, et cetera, sugar industry political contributions, Tony Fabbrizio, the Pollster, food industry representatives, White House officials concerning MAHA initiatives." It's on, Emily. This like to quote few good men, you fucked with the wrong Marine here because he's not going to go quietly. There's zero chance of that.

Emily Jashinsky01:47:47

And definitely not. And there's clearly a market for it. I mean, he goes straight to Joe Rogan. I'm sure this episode is going to blow up. It's been absolutely everywhere. People are fascinated by how the sausage is made here in Washington and furious about it. And they should be. You could go to one of my favorite newsletters, actually. It's called Politico Influence. It's every weekday. And they had a one, this was like last January. I just pulled up the headline. It was Trump 2.0 unleashes a gusher on K Street. And they break down the Ballard numbers. They break down the other lobbying firms with people who have been either in the Trump administration or very close to the Trump administration.

Like you actually don't need to follow the tit for tat personnel disagreements between Cali, James Blair, and Susie Wiles. You can literally just look at the lobbying disclosures. These corporations are not funneling millions of dollars to lobbying firms for nothing. And in this case, Politico reported that Susie Wiles did meet with Bayer. So all of the receipts are there. I mean, you just have to put one plus one together and say it equals two. Like you can, people can follow this stuff. People are smart. And this is exactly how Washington, DC works, arguably on another level. I mean, other places, it's happened with MAHA, it's happened with crypto, it's happened with betting markets, it's happened with all kinds of different industries.

Certainly in the Pentagon side, this has continued to happen under Trump. It's in a way been almost more transparently corrupt because Trump sort of says he's a deal maker and put like Jared Kushner getting $2 billion from the Saudis into Affinity Partners and then going back into the White House and negotiating our Middle East deals. Like he's not trying to hide that he got all the money from the Saudis. So some of it you see happening out in the open. But with the MAHA stuff, I think it's going to be so profoundly disappointing to people the more and more they see what was happening behind the scenes because it is really gross.

And those corporations are not going to go quietly into the good night. They are going to put up a fight with every bone that they have in their body, with every million of dollars that they can spend on the lobbyists. And those lobbyists get paid to do really, I think, awful work.

Megyn Kelly01:49:39

Marty McCarry reportedly left FDA because they were pressuring him to approve or to fast track fruit-flavored vapes, which honestly is a huge issue for moms across America, never mind MAHA moms, because they're very appealing to kids and it gets them hooked on something that's very bad for them. And he did not want to fast track them. He did not want to put any stamp of approval on them. He did not think that they were good for children or teenagers or should have any sort of FDA blessing or assistance whatsoever to the point where he quit rather than do it.

And this is one of the things that Cali is talking about, these flavored vapes and how much pressure there was within the administration to fast track them and to approve of them. He actually talked about the sugar industry and talked about how Trump's chief pollster, this guy Tony Fabbrizio, takes tons of money from Pepsi. And Cali knows about Pepsi because he used to work at Pepsi. In fact, before I play you what he said about Pepsi, let me play you what he said to me on the tour. He was one of our tour guests last fall.

And back then he had a much rosier picture that he was presenting about MAHA and the admin. And we talked about Pepsi among other things. And here's what he said back then, SOT 10.

Speaker 401:51:00

And they came into the White House and they said, "This is hurting jobs to take food stamp funding away from soda." They said, "We need, because we're building new factories, we need to keep ultra-processed food in school lunches because the Trump administration is taking a sledgehammer to school lunch, to crappy food in school lunches and getting fresh food in schools." They said that it is completely inappropriate that the FDA is finally studying the chemicals in our food. We have 10,000 more chemicals in our food today than Europe.

And the FDA actually has a goal with the NIH to study them. And they said that's going to hurt our business. And the administration said, "No, thanks. You can get out of this office." And that has never happened before. And I'll just say that the reason I'm fired up is because this is what is happening on every single front. This administration is taking on big, messy conversations on every single level. They are putting warriors in there to go up against entrenched interests.

Megyn Kelly01:52:00

Okay, so they're much more hopeful, optimistic, specifically speaking to the soda industry, trying to keep that kind of product in kids' lunches. Listen to him on Joe Rogan. We're going to do two sound bites back to back. Let's play 16 and then 15.

Speaker 301:52:18

Tony Fabbrizio is one of the most powerful people in the country. He's Trump's chief pollster, very good friends with Susie. He is on the outside the whole time. And every single policy issue goes through him because he tells the team whether it's politically appropriate to do or not based on his polling. He takes money from Pepsi. He takes money from pharmaceutical companies. He takes money from almost every single industry we're fighting against right now to this day. So he's taking money at the same time. I don't even know if President Trump fully knows that. But as we were fighting things like school lunch reform and getting an ultra-processed food definition, 90% of the country wants this.

We're going to define ultra-processed food. 70% of a child's diet is ultra-processed food. We need to define it. We need to figure out what to do there. It's a widely popular promise from the administration. He is getting paid by Pepsi and giving political analysis that the juice isn't worth the squeeze on doing policies like that. As simple as school lunch reform. As you might know, the FDA, up until we just closed it, did not know what's in our food. Doesn't know. It's been a full self-policing from the food industry where they are able to self-certify both in the ingredients and importantly the amount of the ingredient having an impact or not.

So you have all these things marketed to kids with high sugar. They're actually legally responsible for having studies showing how the amount of sugar that they're recommending for daily use for kids actually doesn't harm kids. I would imagine they don't have that. They're legally required to have that. This would open up a door to start that conversation, getting the truth out. Nothing regulatory. We did a 60 minutes. We got full White House approval. We went through the interagency process. And we were going to do a big initiative on basic food safety, asking whether the amount of sugar in a children's diet was appropriate.

And that's where Susie told me, "We can't do that. I need the sugar industry money."

Megyn Kelly01:54:05

So depressing. I believe every word. I believe Cali. I think he's a straight shooter. That's why I say it's dead. MAHA's dead. They're in exactly the same boat every other administration has been in. The money from big pharma or big ag or big sugar is more important to them than the voters. They're more interested in saving their own electoral hides because the corporations have all the dough than they are in actually changing things for the better in the country.

That's what Cali's trying to say. Like if you could actually make headway on some of these initiatives, the voters would show up for you. They would show up. You could unite them, but you refuse. You keep selling out for the quick buck, thinking if you get another 100 million in your war chest, you can put together another whole host of ads that are really going to take down Tallafrico. And that's just, that's not what happened. The voters had their say this time saying, "Fuck off.

We see how grifty you are." Corruption was rated higher than any other issue. More people said that that was their top, like their critical or most important issue than any other issue. I think it even beat cost of living or at least tied. It was 90%. So it didn't work. And yet they're not going to learn. They're not going to say, "Oh, okay, now we will reject the money from Pepsi." No, they're not, especially with Cali gone.

Emily Jashinsky01:55:38

Yeah. And big sugar has been a problem for Republicans. Or actually, it's been kind of a sugar daddy for Republicans for years and years. The Fondue brothers. It definitely influences our policy towards Cuba. Tim Carney, Peter Schweitzer have done good reporting on this stuff from the right for very many years. But I think what happened with MAHA is that we have this like whiplash. I love that you played those clips back to back because it just took me back into that moment early in the administration, especially after Donald Trump won in November of 2024 through January 2025. And I think about that picture of Trump getting inaugurated with all of these CEOs behind him, mostly tech CEOs, but you have Bezos, you have all these guys, Elon, they're all behind him.

And I think the message then from Donald Trump was, "I have conquered these oligarchs." The question for me was always, was it like that or was it the other way around that they were conquering him? And I feel like more and more we're getting the answer that he was the one that was conquered. And part of the problem is that, listen, one of the reasons I have a hard time voting anymore, I'm not telling people not to vote, but one of the reasons I have a hard time voting is that I've been here long enough and I just don't know that anybody, and I sound as jaded as Cali does there, but I don't know that anybody can resist the structural incentive system here in Washington, DC.

So what you need is somebody who runs on a platform like Drain the Swamp and makes it their mission to structurally reform the way that the administrative state works, the way that money and politics works. But that feels almost impossible.

Megyn Kelly01:57:03

So I have to say, like I'm not blowing smoke on Tucker, but I do think the Tucker, Joe Kent, Thomas Massie, MTG thing that's happening would resist it. I do. Maybe I'm being naive, but I do think there's a collection of people that are so angry about the Iran war and the corruption and this bullshit that if they could somehow rise to power with donations from individuals, five and $10 donations, that kind of thing, and possibly have independent wealth, they could do it.

I just don't think that group, Thomas Massie's proven he can't be bought and paid for. You know, I just, Joe Kent, no way. His wife was killed in one of these foreign wars. Like he is not going to bend the knee to the military industrial complex. And he quit after Trump launched that war. Tucker, he's independent, wealthy, and he could do it. Like I just think there is a group that's bubbling up right now that is, to quote the movie, mad as hell, and they're not going to take it anymore. And I've been told by every pundit who's come on here that I need to write them off, that they can't do it. And I've told all of them, I just, I wouldn't be so sure.

Just think the mood of the electorate is much more with those guys than it is with any of the traditional parties.

Emily Jashinsky01:58:12

Oh, it totally is. I mean, Gallup's polling has found a record number of people identify as independent in this country. It's like 45% of the country identifies as independent according to Gallup's polling, which they've done over many, many years. And so I wonder actually, like the whiplash between 2024 and 2026, I wonder also if we look back at 2028 on 2026, where you have Democrats riding this wave and feeling like they've now initiated a vibe shift and saying like making jokes about woke being back and all that sort of thing. If we look back in 2028 or 2030 and Democrats are once again feeling like they got left out in the vibe shift because people right now are totally open to new discussions and ideas and the old gatekeepers, their power is like totally waning.

People can circumvent them with information like Cali on Joe Rogan. I mean, yes, he went on, I think he also went on CBS and made this message, but it doesn't come across like it does in a free-flowing two-hour conversation with Joe Rogan, which was, I think, a very, very powerful glimpse inside Washington.

Megyn Kelly01:59:09

The only solution is to limit government, not to change government. Changing the party from one to the next is not going to do much. It's going to accomplish very little. The only real solution is to limit the power these fuckers have over us so that they're not in a position to exploit it to the extent both of them have. That's truly our only option at this point and to hope that private industry can come up with innovative solutions that we can get behind. You know, like we can find answers from geniuses who are in the private sector whose incentives are known, declared, and trackable.

You know, as opposed to what we're seeing in government because we've been betrayed by both parties. They both grift. They're all interested in lining their own pockets as opposed to in helping actual suffering Americans. The presidency has gotten way too big. The executive branch is way too big. It's bloated and it's disgusting like Shrek the Ogre. That's what the executive branch looks like right now. It is always meant to be small and humble and limited. Congress, they've been so feckless that all the bums got thrown out.

And we'll see. The new bums are likely to be just like the old bums, just with a different grift. Sorry to be so blackpilled, but that's really the truth. So the answer is to try to take as much out of their hands as humanly possible. Pray for gridlock. I'm in favor of that. And to shrink the executive, to elect somebody who promises to shrink the executive and its branches and to be a humble governor of the people. Okay, I want to keep going because I almost never talk about this woman because she's so disgusting and hateful.

But like Emily, I've got to say, you know, you and I do this all the time. And there are a lot of hateful characters on the left in particular when it comes to things we care about. And I cannot think of one, not a single one, not this Jennifer Welsh, not one whose death I would celebrate. But truly, I cannot. I don't really have that in me. I have it in me to celebrate the death of like a hardened criminal who's murdering or attempting to harm my children. You know, like that, I could.

But like just a pundit who has different political views from my own, even ones I find, quote, hateful or, you know, really objectionable. I just, I am never incapable of seeing their humanity. I don't, I genuinely don't understand what's happening on the left with this assassination culture thing and this dehumanizing people on the right whose views they disagree with. You know, all their bullshit about feeling dehumanized by a remark about Santa being white, which actually was said to me.

Emily Jashinsky02:01:54

A classic.

Megyn Kelly02:01:56

Right? Like that's such utter bullshit. And this stuff is actually dehumanizing what they're doing. You know, celebrating the murder of right-wing pundits. Like it's very, very dark. And I wish I had some great insight on it, but I don't. I know it's absolutely despicable. And that's what this woman's been since she really emerged on the national scene. So her name is Jennifer Welsh. We usually just call her the angry podcast lady, but that is her name. She's got a sidekick named Angie Sullivan who's just as gross.

And they made this so-called joke about Charlie Kirk on their podcast on November 5th.

Emily Jashinsky02:02:37

Dad Morrow says, "We're digging up Charlie Kirk and doing it again." I'm zooming in for Fox. No comment. No comment. No comment on that.

Megyn Kelly02:03:05

Other than he was shot by somebody that was super MAGA family.

Emily Jashinsky02:03:08

He was shot by a MAGA person.

Megyn Kelly02:03:09

Right. So do that with what you will.

Emily Jashinsky02:03:13

White person, white MAGA family.

Megyn Kelly02:03:17

So they're disgusting pigs. They're like pig whores just trying to laugh it up to get clicks with their audience. And I have absolutely no use for either one of those total fucking twits. But now they're getting, they're just desserts because advertisers are starting to leave them in droves. I mean, like scores of advertisers. And the reason the advertisers are leaving is because this wasn't a one-off. It wasn't one thoughtless moment.

I mean, it wasn't even just one moment. They laughed for how many seconds there? They were hysterical. They could barely get themselves back under control. They genuinely thought it was hilarious to laugh about the assassination of a young man who's the father of two young babies. It's because this is their brand. This is their bread and butter. This is a day ending in Y for these two. On the very same show, this is what that Jennifer Welsh said, SOT 28.

Emily Jashinsky02:04:17

I have so much more hate to give towards him. I've barely even tapped into it. I would say out of my potential of hating him 100%, I'm only 10 to 15% there. I still have 85 more percent to realize in these next two terms. You have seen nothing yet. If you think our measly 10 to 15% of hate for this guy is, you've never seen anything like it, sit down and get your fucking popcorn, fat ass, because we are just getting started.

I can't even begin to tell Sean Hannity how much untapped hatred I have for Donald Trump and the MAGA movement at large. I feel like, I feel invigorated. I feel like, my God, I can go, I'm going to go, here's 5% more hate here. Here's three more percent there. I will hate this motherfucker forever and ever and ever and everybody that voted for him. I want you to have healthcare. I want you to have all that stuff. But if you voted for Trump, I fucking hate, hate.

I hate you.

Megyn Kelly02:05:25

And this is why we call her the angry podcast lady. Trump derangement syndrome, really, it corrodes you from the inside. It's very, very poisonous. It's really, really disgusting. It eats away your insides, your internal organs. It starts with your heart, moves on quickly to your brain, and then you can see, obviously, it eats part of your face and makes your outside match your inside. And the next thing you know, you're saying shit like that, like openly about your fellow Americans. Then came the backlash because Turning Point started to tweet a lot about what she had said.

And so did many of us. And then they started to lose advertisers, one after the other, after the other, after the other. And now they've lost 25 advertisers who want nothing to do with this disgusting toxic brand. And here was her follow-up statement after she tried to issue a paper statement, quote, apologizing. It was a lie. It wasn't a real apology. It was, she didn't mean to make light of gun violence.

She didn't mean to make light of gun violence. Nothing about Charlie's humanity, nothing about how genuinely rattling and disturbing that was to most sane Americans, never mind the right wing who loved Charlie, but just absolutely no thought for people's humanity and what this is actually doing, not to mention Erica Kirk and his children. And then she must have heard from her little hateful minions who watched that show and decided to come out like, oh, I'm a badass now. Everyone can fuck right off.

And this was the follow-up message we got in SOT 29.

Speaker 302:07:13

All right. There's a huge online cancellation campaign from all the titty babies over at Turning Point. Andrew, we're never, ever going to sit down and listen to you. When we apologized for laughing at a joke on our podcast, that wasn't for you. That was for us because somebody I love very much died from gun violence two years ago. And I just didn't feel good about that. I don't expect you to understand this because at Turning Point, y'all laugh at violence all the time.

But for you to think that apology was for you just exemplifies how out of whack you are with where the American people are right now. Let's grow this thing and show Turning Point how irrelevant they are.

Megyn Kelly02:07:59

Okay. So I don't think that her podcast is going away. I think she'll plug it in and get subscriptions. And what I am concerned about is that there is an audience for this, that this is scratching the itch of some number. I don't know. They're never ranked anywhere. I have to be honest. I watch the podcast ranks. You're never up there, sweetheart, and you never will be with this brand. But some collection of leftists is getting off to this.

And that I do find deeply disturbing him.

Emily Jashinsky02:08:31

Yeah, she gets a lot of big interviews and has really fashioned herself as more than a podcaster, but also an activist and agitator for the party to go in a much more progressive direction, which, I mean, it's all, it's odd. A lot of it is her anti-Israel sentiment that she tries to channel into these interviews with major politicians. But she's not just a comedian, right? Like she's not Chapo Trap House. She's somebody who's trying to actually be an activist within the Democratic Party and a serious political commentator that gets really big interviews. So I think there's a significant difference.

If you're part in the political ecosystem, the ecosystem of the discourse is a comedian, that's one thing. If you're part in the ecosystem of the discourse is to be a like serious podcast commentator slash activist trying to nudge actively the politics of the Democratic Party in an ideological, particular ideological direction. If you're part of that movement and you are seen as a significant part of that movement by the politicians who sit down with you, then yeah, you're going to have to, you're going to have to reap the consequences of this type of thing. And I just like, I don't like the idea of pressuring companies to make speech-related decisions.

I just don't like it. I've seen it too many times. I understand why that's happening in this case, particularly. It's not because somebody said that, you know, a biological woman is not a man. This is over a joke about a political assassination from somebody who wants to see herself as sort of like the tip of the spear for the Democratic Party going in a further left direction. And it's just so sad. I mean, even her bringing it, saying it's not for you, Andrew, it's for us. It's about me. It's because I, like, it is all just profoundly sad. She has built her personality around anti-Trump politics, around anti-conservative politics, going back to their days at Bravo.

Their entire shtick was being anti-conservative Christian, anti-Evangelical Christian. They have built their entire lives around that brand. And it has to be, it has to be so painful and exhausting and sad. And I feel like you can see that. They would never admit to it publicly, but you can just see it. It's sad. It's sad. They need something more fulfilling and positive to center their lives around than this because going off about how bitterly you hate your fellow countrymen, how bitterly you hate people who are also just trying to do the right thing, but disagree with you, like to have that much hate in your heart, man, that's just a terrible way to go about life.

That sucks. I'm going to pray for her tonight because that's awful.

Megyn Kelly02:10:49

Yeah, I'm same, honestly, because that level of commentary, I feel about that level of commentary, those words, those sentiments, that messaging, the way I felt during COVID when we would walk around the streets of New York and occasionally you would see a pile of human excrement on the sidewalk. Just look away. Like get away and look away and try not to think too much about it because it's just obviously something happened there that is the dregs of society and a sign of like serious societal decay. And like she's obviously not a complete idiot.

You know, like she's got some thoughtful things to say, I imagine. I don't know. Just the way she articulates her thoughts suggests to me she's not a complete moron and could potentially be actually using those powers for good, but has just gone to the most abjectly hateful place one can go. I actually do feel sorry for her and for the weird little sidekick.

Emily Jashinsky02:11:46

That's what I call the resistance diamond and silk. That's what they're really doing.

Megyn Kelly02:11:50

Yes, I see it too. Yes, exactly. The Temu, like the cheap one-off version of the real deals. Sadly, it's not limited to the no-name podcasters who literally nobody's ever heard of. Dave Chappelle was out there this weekend in an absolutely disgusting display, and he's far more powerful than these two losers. Also celebrating the murder of Charlie Kirk.

He was at Madison Square Garden on Friday, and here's what he said, SOT 23.

Speaker 402:12:27

I feel fucked up saying this. It's scary being a public speaker. And I mean, look, ever since that guy Charlie Kirk got murdered, and I shouldn't say this publicly, but I feel better. I know I shouldn't say that, but it's just a feeling. I didn't ask you to do this.

I'll just be driving around like, why am I in such a good mood? I'm sure Charlie Kirk is looking up at us right now, laughing so hard he can't breathe.

Megyn Kelly02:13:14

So just in case you didn't think he meant it or it was out of context, there he is following up saying Charlie's looking up at us, laughing, meaning he's in hell. So it was clearly a joke about Charlie. He meant it. And he's openly saying, I mean, the irony that he began with, it's scary to be a public speaker. His fright came from he was about to say something controversial. Charlie was a public speaker and got his fucking neck blown out. So Dave Chappelle should take a moment to sit back and think about what fear actually looks like because it's people on our side of the aisle who now genuinely have to worry about that shit.

Not you, Dave Chappelle. You were wanded like you were going into a presidential event before you went into Madison Square Garden to see him. Guess what? I'm sorry to break it to you, but it's our people who are being gunned down, who are literally being shot at political events, including pundits, not just presidents, not just their supporters, but random pundits out there speaking and having respectful debate with people across the aisle from them like Charlie. So you can fuck yourself, Dave Chappelle. Go fuck yourself.

I'm so disgusted with him. What a pig. He's a pig. I dare him to come on this show and say it. Come on. Let's go. Say it to somebody like me. You can call me a racist. You can say whatever you want to say. Come on my show and have the balls to say it to somebody who will fight back and who will tell you what it felt like to love the man who had his head blown off. You fucking asshole. It's unbelievable. His supporters first tried to come out and say it was taken out of context. It wasn't taken out of context.

When you hear the so-called context, Emily, it makes it worse. He went on and on, talked about what a great mood he's been in every time he thinks about Charlie getting his head blown off. What an asshole. I'm sorry to just resort to ad hominem swear words, but I just don't, what else conveys the level of anger that that makes you feel? I don't feel sorry for Dave Chappelle. I actually feel just nothing but anger. He's had nothing but gifts from this amazing country.

The people there, you could hear even they were groaning. There were a couple of laughs, but there was a lot of groaning going on. And the woman filming was like, come on, that's not nice. And he doesn't care. Like he thinks he's banking on being applauded for that level of hate and yes, dehumanization. And he knows full well Charlie's got two babies at home wondering where their father is. There's something wrong with Dave Chappelle and these others who are continuously celebrating the political assassination of a fellow American.

Emily Jashinsky02:16:00

Well, right now, polling shows it definitely is, there's definitely more inclination to say or to agree with political violence being justified, to justify political violence, especially on the young left. And so that is a real thing that people can go look up. There's research that shows that is most prevalent in that cohort. You know, with Dave Chappelle, if I'm not mistaken, he actually was attacked on stage when he was in this phase of his career where he was pushing back on the left and Charlie defended him. If I'm remembering this correctly, Charlie defended him over there.

Megyn Kelly02:16:30

Yes, that happened.

Emily Jashinsky02:16:30

Which is the correct position. Like nobody, I don't think it would be right to, you know, call up Netflix or Madison Square Garden and say, stop hosting Dave Chappelle. I guess I'm curious to hear the set. I've been a fan of Dave Chappelle.

Megyn Kelly02:16:43

That's where he was attacked.

Emily Jashinsky02:16:44

Yeah. And so it's like, I mean, for me, it's kind of a character question. Like what point is he trying to make with this joke? Is he making a joke that he actually feels relieved at somebody's political assassination, that it actually led off some type of pressure relief inside of him? Because that's mystifying. I mean, that's actually definitely hard to understand. And I think it does speak to also how the myth of Charlie Kirk that was really attempted to be set by the left after his assassination has taken hold in so many people's minds that he was something that he actually wasn't at the end of his life, that he was a person, that he was a caricature, that when he was assassinated, the man was taking questions from people who disagreed with him.

He said, send your best libs to the front of the line. And he was making a concerted effort to engage in dialogue and discourse with people. And he was actually defending people like Chappelle. So I mean, just to me, that's another part about this that's sad is the legacy of Charlie is in and of itself, you know, part of our microculture that if you're in one silo, you're totally resistant to some of the truth and the reality about what he was doing when he was killed. I mean, actually, even in the Angry Podcast Lady clip you played, they're still saying that it was a MAGA person who did this.

They're still implying that there was potentially some MAGA motive because the story is just, it's been completely, the narrative has been set for so many people on the left in a way that's just out of touch with reality.

Megyn Kelly02:18:11

I do wonder if Dave Chappelle is going to fall subject to the same stadium cancellations that Ed Sheeran had to face when Matt Gilmore opened for Ed Sheeran and made some comments about what's happening in Gaza. He got cracked down on by Robert Kraft at Gillette Stadium. You're not allowed to say that. He needs to be banned, whatever. The blowback wound its way onto Ed Sheeran, who was really just trying to stay out of it, but was, you know, had hired Matt Gilmore as an opener.

Is this okay? You allowed to say this? I just, like, I wonder, does the next stadium in Ohio just allow more of this? Do we just, it's fine. We're just going to platform this and we're going to allow, because conservatives do go to see Dave Chappelle. Like I'm sure there were a lot of people there who were not expecting anything like this level of discourse. And he just behaves with impunity. Why? Because he's a black man in America? Well, fuck off. Because you should be held to the same standards of decency as everybody else.

You're disgusting. You're pathetic. And that is actual dehumanization to have so little care for the grieving relatives, for the grieving millions, for the grieving millions. Charlie led a movement. Charlie was important to a lot of us. And honestly, to celebrate his murder, it's just in a league of its own in terms of depravity. It really is. Because of course, what you celebrate, you know, what you permit, you promote. That's what you're doing. You are promoting additional political assassinations and effectively taking the blood on your hands of what this murderer unleashed.

And then to the nerve of starting it with, it's scary being a public speaker. Oh, what a risk you're taking, Dave Chappelle. What a risk in saying something controversial as opposed to somebody like Charlie who actually went out there trying to advance dialogue with the other side and gave his life for it. Like the fucking nerve, the irony, like the cluelessness alert for somebody. Maybe he's not as smart as I previously suspected.

Emily Jashinsky02:20:18

Well, I think he might genuinely be reflecting a sentiment like we were talking about earlier that is real. And one of the reasons that, well, we know it's real. We've seen other people, you know, show us clearly that it's real. And I think that's one of the reasons I don't like the idea of stadium boycotts. Like I don't want to give Robert Kraft more power over our Overton window of political discourse than average people. And that to me is what's like most, I don't know, sad or interesting about all of this is just that we have millions of people who are our fellow countrymen to persuade that dehumanizing your political enemies and justifying political violence.

Like I go back to that clip of Hassan Piker after, as the, actually as he learned that Charlie Kirk had been assassinated and he is shock jawed, he's pale in the face, slack jawed and pale in the face and saying, yo, this is not good. This is not going to be good for us. And I think obviously he's moved on from that moment, but that moment is just really important to hold onto because when it happens, it's not funny. When it happened, nobody was laughing except for some true sickos like teachers and nurses who were laughing within like the first 24, 48 hours.

But like there are millions of people around the country who now do have this justification in their hearts for political violence. And that's setting the stage for something that we need to deal with because if we do not deal with it, it is going to bubble up to the surface and we will find ourselves in a very, like actually violent situation here in the United States on a daily rolling basis. And God forbid it gets to that point, but we clearly have a lot of work to do at pulling some of our fellow countrymen back from the brink.

Megyn Kelly02:21:52

I think about what we saw at like Jimmy Carter's funeral, you know, where like Obama and W were joking around with each other. And it's like those moments where you see presidents from either side come together and like yuck it up and glad hand, notwithstanding political differences, are so good for the country. They really are. They may infuriate the most diehard partisans, but what they show you, and especially that's one of the reasons why the peaceful transition of power is so important and why it was disgusting that Trump didn't let it happen in 2020.

But in any event, that's really important because what it shows the populace is we all fight very hard for the politics that we believe in and the policies we believe in. We fight very, very hard. And politics is a rough and tumble sport. But at the end of the day, we come together, we're fellow Americans, and we understand that a lot of that stuff is part of a game when it comes from the politicians, when it comes to ads and slogans and things like talla friko. It's part of a game.

It's not a pretty game. It's not a nice game, but it's part of a game. And while the policy battles are heartfelt, like you mean them, you know, like take the life issue, like there's a genuine disagreement between the two parties on that one. It doesn't make you hate your fellow American that they disagree with you on it. Like we're still Americans first. That's the way it's been for the majority of my lifetime. And these people, these cretins are letting that slip away. They're taking it too far.

It's not just like the demonization of their adversaries. It's the genuine hope that they'll be murdered in the most disgusting, violent, upsetting fashion possible. And that is something new. That is something evil. And you're right. The bottom line is we should pray for them. So I, okay, I will, I will pray for Dave Chappelle too. You should pray for him because if he comes on this show, it's not going to go well for him.

Emily Jashinsky02:23:52

I'd love to see it. I would love to see that.

Megyn Kelly02:23:55

Oh, he's not man enough to do it. Are you kidding? He would claim, oh, it's whatever's beneath me. I'm not going to go on this whatever, you know, terrible person from Fox News's show. That's not why. He doesn't have the balls. He is too afraid. He will never say yes. Too bad too, because that would be must-see TV. Emily, great to see you, my friend.

Emily Jashinsky02:24:14

Thanks, Megan.

Megyn Kelly02:24:15

All right. We are back tomorrow. We'll see you then. Thanks for listening to the Megyn Kelly Show. No BS, no agenda, and no fear.

Episode description

Megyn Kelly is joined by Dave Aronberg, co-host of "The MK True Crime Show," and Viva Frei, Rumble creator and former litigator, to discuss the breaking news of Russell Brand being given a massive prison sentence of more than 10 years, the judge explaining his decision, the fairness of the prison sentence, the argument that the system was rigged against Russell Brand, the comparison between Russell Brand's sentencing and other criminals in the UK, and more. Then Emily Jashinsky, host of "After Party," joins to discuss a potential immigration deal with the Democrats that sounds like amnesty, the truth about his immigration policy vs. the enforcement of those policies, how the GOP isn’t learning from their 2026 mistakes so far, how neocons aren’t giving up on the Iran war, the focus on "candidate quality" as the new cope, Calley Means going on Joe Rogan and getting honest about what really happened to MAHA, the depressing connections he was exposing between Big Pharma lobbyists and the Trump administration, the leftist podcaster Jennifer Welch making a disgusting comment about Charlie Kirk, how her show is starting to lose advertisers after these comments, and more.

 

 

Subscribe to The MK True Crime Show:
Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/mk-true-crime/id1829831499
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/4o80I2RSC2NvY51TIaKkJW

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@MKTrueCrime?sub_confirmation=1

 

Aronberg- https://substack.com/@davearonberg

Frei- https://rumble.com/user/vivafrei

 

Subscribe to Emily's "After Party":
Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/after-party-with-emily-jashinsky/id1821493726
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/0szVa30NjGYsyIzzBoBCtJ
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@AfterPartyEmily?sub_confirmation=1
 

 

Birch Gold: Text MK to 989898 for a free info kit and to claim eligibility for your free silver on a qualifying purchase through November 11th

Byrna: Go to https://Byrna.com or your local Sportsman's Warehouse today.

Sundays for Dogs: Upgrade your dog’s food without the hassle—try Sundays for Dogs and get 30% off your first order at https://sundaysfordogs.com/MEGYN or use code MEGYN at checkout.

Tax Relief Advocates: End your tax nightmare today by visiting us online at https://TRA.com or call 800-575-6845

 

 

Follow The Megyn Kelly Show on all social platforms:

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/MegynKelly

Twitter: http://Twitter.com/MegynKellyShow

Instagram: http://Instagram.com/MegynKellyShow

Facebook: http://Facebook.com/MegynKellyShow

Find out more information at:
https://www.devilmaycaremedia.com/megynkellyshow

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.