Megyn Kelly speaks with comedian Samantha Pressdee, a friend of Russell Brand, who disputes claims that his behavior was an open secret and argues his case was shaped by a campaign against him. The episode also covers Charlie Kirk's earlier interview with Brand, media coverage of an Ole Miss incident, and allegations about Alina Habba's $50 million deal.
Kelly also reports on Thomas Markle Sr.'s return to jail after he allegedly cut off his ankle monitor. Finally, Heather Mac Donald of the Manhattan Institute argues that classical music's leadership prioritizes diversity over artistic excellence, citing the Boston Symphony's firing of conductor Andres Nelsons.
In this episode Megyn Kelly, Heather Mac Donald, Samantha Pressdee
This episode's transcript was made with the technology behind HappyScribe's subtitle generator, covering Russell Brand's case, Alina Habba and the Boston Symphony.
Ads in this audio differ from the text. Tap the sentence you're hearing to follow along.
Synced: the text now follows the audio.
Welcome to "The Megyn Kelly Show," live on SiriusXM Channel 111 every weekday at noon east. Hey everyone, I'm Megan Kelly. Welcome to "The Megyn Kelly Show." We have multiple stories with major updates today, including Thomas Markle Sr. allegedly trying to cut off his ankle monitor. This is unbelievable. He's only got the one leg. It's somehow he managed to get down and cut off the ankle monitor after he was given the enormous gift of being released pending trial.
He was charged with the possession of child sexual abuse material, as you know, and somehow misunderstood what an enormous gift that was and abused it. And now he's back in custody and will not be released again, I think it's fair to say. Unbelievable. But we begin today with an update in the Russell Brand case. As we reported Monday, a judge sentenced the British comedian to 10 and a half years in prison, with a minimum of seven years behind bars after a London jury convicted him of one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault.
Brand is currently incarcerated in a reportedly decrepit facility where inmates are kept, in quote, "unsafe, overcrowded, unsanitary, and squalid conditions," according to a watchdog report. The Daily Mail also reporting police say several more women have come forward with information about more accusations of rape and related charges, potentially against Brand. This is all pointing in a very dark direction.
And where were these people when they did the Channel 4 documentary, in air quotes? Where were they when the police were putting together the criminal charge? Now that he's been convicted, these women are coming out of the woodwork to say, "Me too. Please." All right. Just like they will not be satisfied until this guy is behind bars for the rest of his life. And the narrative now in the media, it's amazing how they're just piling on. I mean, every publication is, "Rapist Russell Brand, rapist Russell Brand."
I realize there's been a verdict, but please do a little research on the alleged rape before you run with this. These people know. They know how thin this is. There's a hatred for Russell, and you can see it behind the glee with which they're calling him a rapist. It's a joke. The rape charge was a joke. These people obviously know nothing about complainant five. Well, we wanted to speak with someone who actually knows Russell and who could shed some light on whether these claims are believable at all.
This alleged open secret, now that they're all saying, "Oh, it was an open secret, Russell was a rapist." Really? Where were you all? Why weren't you all jumping up and down, setting yourselves on fire to say, "Oh my God, don't be alone with that guy. He's a known rapist." Is that true? Or is this just his political haters trying to pile on as they enjoy his downfall? Samantha Presti is a British stand-up comedian who has known Russell Brand for over a decade.
Samantha, welcome to the show. Great to have you.
Hello, Megan. Thank you so much for having me.
Of course. So tell us how you know Russell. How did you and he get to know each other?
We met in a bar in 2006. His writing partner, Matt Morgan, was DJing at the bar, and Russell made an appearance. There weren't many people at the bar. There were about 50. They were all following him around like he was the Pied Piper, and I was just being cool. And then he came up to me and said, "Are you coming with me?" And I'm like, "Where?" And he's like, "To my home." And I was like, "No." And he's like, "Come on. It'll be an adventure." So I went to his home. We had a little bit of a romantic tumble.
I think the most important part of my story is that I said no to him at the most frustrating possible moment, the last possible moment I could say no. I said no, and he was a perfect gentleman about it. And to this day, I still care about him dearly. I've been around him a lot. Reconnected with him maybe around 2013 when he started getting political. We were both on the activist scene, and I was around him sometimes on a weekly basis. And all the comedy industry knew I was a comedian.
All the comedy industry knew that I was connected to him, and not one single person ever warned me to be careful around Russell Brand. So I don't buy the open secret. I would have been warned. It's a false narrative.
Why are they all coming out now claiming, "We knew. Everyone knew"?
I think journalists planted the narrative because the first I heard of it was from the comedian Alfie Brown. He said it on stage in 2023. And this guy, Alfie Brown, around 2016, had ridden with me in my campaign van that Russell's team had decorated. It got the truth on the side. It got Russell's website on it. Hop on the brand wagon. So he knew that I was connected to Russell, and he didn't say anything around 2016 when he knew that I was around Russell.
Everyone knew. I was talking about him on stage. I had publicity pictures that indicated a connection. I think there was a mention in my press release because we were working on a campaign together, which was a long political campaign called Sweetsway Resist. So he said nothing to me back then. His cousin also went to Russell's home around that time for romance, and he never even warned his cousin. So this is a lie that there was an open secret.
Maybe people knew that he was promiscuous, but he told people that himself. Nobody needed warning about that. We all knew that he was that kind of guy. And that kind of behavior in the UK is very normal and socially acceptable, even to this day.
I know you've said you think what's underway here is a feminist hit job against Russell. Why do you think that?
Because it's the same narrative, the believable women narrative. It's the same narrative as trans women are women. And any comedian, me being one of them, that's spoken against that narrative in recent years has been canceled. It happened to Graham Linehan. He's a BAFTA winner. He's the writer of Father Ted. He's a BAFTA-winning comedian, and he got canceled.
Came on this show.
Sorry?
Yeah, we had Graham.
Yeah, yeah.
After he got canceled and all the police were waiting for him when he was flying across the ocean.
He was arrested at the airport.
They treated him like he was a gang rapist.
Yeah. It's the same movement because the human right is to be innocent until proven guilty. That has not happened here. Russell has not had a fair trial. Instead of being thought of as innocent until proven guilty, no guilt has really been proven. Questionable women, anonymous women, have just been believed.
The ridiculous rush to just universally call Russell Brand a rapist now on the word of complainant five. Of all the accusers, complainant five, which is to me a joke and suggests no one has bothered to actually look into the claims or just no one cares. They had it against Russell to begin with, and they're just enjoying his downfall, which to me smacks of politics, given that the UK is very left and very woke and Russell isn't.
What do you make of it?
I think it is that. And I also think that with his defense, anyone in the comedy industry that may have had information that could have come to his defense, they would have been immediately ruined. There's a musician that's just spoken out about it, Ian McNabb from Icicle Works. He spoke saying that he thought it was a stitch up. He's been immediately canceled. All his tour has been canceled. So there's also this underlying cancel culture, which has basically led the campaign against Russell Brand, and it's undermined the justice system.
Yes, that right. That Ian, that comedian Ian, he said basically he just had like a social media post suggesting he didn't believe these claims against him. And now so his whole tour has been canceled because he's thrown his support behind Russell. That's it. So you're not allowed. You're not allowed to disbelieve the jury's conclusion. Suddenly now you must go along with whatever the jury says. If the jury had said not guilty, I guess everyone would have been required to go along with that.
And by this same logic, any woman out there posting, "I believed the women, and I think Russell did do it," I guess those female comedians who posted that would have had their lives canceled too.
It's only if you're on this, if you're challenging the narratives that you get canceled. It's the comedy industry has been completely captured for years by this leftist fake feminist ideology. I was about to quit in 2023. I wrote an article slamming the industry, saying that it was pushing an ideology that was curtailing freedom of expression and undermining women's sex-based rights against the transgender narrative.
And my show was canceled, and I got terrible. It blew up on Twitter. Apparently, people were telling me I was getting death threats. So it just basically proved my point. What happened after the article was published and then I got canceled? It proved my point that you can't tell the truth. The comedian is supposed to be the one that can tell the truth. But we've now kind of metaphorically killed the court jester in the UK, and we're living in tyranny.
We're not really a democratic country if we don't have free speech. So this is against the values that not just the UK, but the whole West has been built on.
And this was Graham Linehan's sin too, that he spoke out on the transgender ideology, and that's why he got canceled and arrested and on and on. It went like the harassment of him. His whole career had to go away because he would not accept that a man can become a woman. This comedian you mentioned, Ian McNab, this is what he posted.
He's a musician. He's a musician.
A musician. Sorry, musician. He posted, "Russell Brand is being stitched up for his outspoken views. He got close to the target, and he has a big audience. I know people who were in his orbit, and girls were throwing themselves at him every night. If that happened to me, I know what I'd do. Your pay is your money. Your takes your chance. If you want to hang out with the artist, don't cry when you're in the picture. All the chicks who turn up at these situations know exactly what's going on. The ones who decided they were done badly to 10 years after the event are the worst."
He speaks for many people who are too cowardly to say that. And then he posted the following after being canceled, his concerts. "It's with a heavy heart and deep sadness and regret I make this post. I've been canceled, and therefore all of my shows for the foreseeable future have also. This is as a result of a post I made regarding the plight of British comedian and entertainer Russell Brand." He says, "I don't support the actions of the man. Both you and I know he behaved wrongly in many situations, but I feel the story goes deeper.
In no way did I mean to cause offense. I've committed no crime." But then continues to say, "When he turned on the Epstein class, his fate was sealed. I fail to understand how many who have committed worse offenses continue to roam free without consequence." And he's exactly right. The double standard on rape claims in the UK is as plain as the nose on your face. There are how many of these Muslim immigrants who were never even charged with the rapes of young white girls because of skin color?
That's been documented.
Yeah. And people that were speaking out against that, they were being labeled racists, which is wrong. Again, it's almost like another manifestation of cancel culture to label someone as a racist or a rape apologist or a trans exclusionary radical feminist. It's crazy. It's insane.
Yes. And the woke mob will not be satisfied until Russell is in jail for the rest of his life. What do you make of these reports that now all these other women are coming forward calling the police, trying to add on to the charges that he may face in a potential second trial?
They could be gold diggers. I think that if a woman has believed that someone's hurt them, they should go straight to the police. That's the correct thing to do. You may stop that person from then hurting other women. Just that person being arrested might stop them hurting other women, even if it doesn't go to a trial. But at this point, after a documentary and the police coming out of the court and appealing for more people to come forward, I think opportunists are likely to jump on this bandwagon.
The notion that complainant five had her life ruined by Russell, her victim testimonial, which was read by the prosecutor, spoke to how she now no longer trusts her judgment. And we're supposed to attribute all of this to her alleged anal rape by Russell Brand. I know you've been paying attention to the case. Your thoughts on complainant five of all the women, now her allegations being used to label him universally as this terrorizing rapist?
She couldn't trust her judgment the day that she met him when she went into his dressing room and licked his back door. Who in their right mind would do that? So it's clear that this is probably most likely a woman that's got severe mental health issues. The judge said as much, but I don't think they came after her. I think she already had them. She was cheating on her boyfriend. She would have been upset about that. She may wanted to place the guilt on someone else. There was talk of her being in active addiction.
The way that she behaved, not even I used to hang out with all the groupies in the noughties. I don't even know any groupie that would behave like that to immediately go and do a thing like that. Like, no. It's insane that this woman who has cheated on her boyfriend, done a really gross sex act within minutes of meeting her hero. She was an obsessed fan. She probably had some parasocial relationship with him and was disappointed when he discarded her.
She couldn't have been in her right mind. Anyone in their right mind knew that if you were going to go into Russell's dressing room, you were going to be well, she knew that. She did that. She went to his house. She knew what was going to happen. But they should also know that he's going to quickly move on to the next woman. And I think that's probably what upset her, that she cheated on her boyfriend. Maybe she had this fantasy that Russell would be her new boyfriend. She'd be on the red carpet with him, and then he just discarded her after the events.
Exactly. That this person had consented to oral sex with him, to vaginal sex with him, to she performed anal sex on him within seconds of meeting him, and yet we're supposed to believe that him doing it to her was a bridge too far. That she said no to. Russell's testimony was that she did consent. She asked him to, quote, "be gentle." And he denied the claims that he treated her badly after the fact, saying, "Clean up the mess you've made," that he actually sat there and watched TV with her. Her testimony was they ended.
She had said no, and he scolded her. And she was effectively shamed and bitter about it as she had been cheating on her boyfriend and had agreed to everything but, she claims, the back door. The jury apparently bought it. But now there is a question about how this whole thing got started because there is this activist journalist, Roz Irwin, who was behind the whole thing. This is the person who basically put together the collection of women who came forward and participated in that so-called documentary, which kicked things off, which we've been discussing with our audience.
The notion of having actresses play the alleged victims in a so-called documentary is farcical. They are professional actresses who will portray the part of a victim, obviously potentially much better than an actual faker might who is telling lies about the perpetrator. I mean, this is just the whole thing is dishonest on its face. They play the scary music under the women's testimonial. And now you have this woman who was with Russell.
Her name is Georgina Bali. I know you know about her. She's now criticizing Russell, but she gave an interview in October of 2023 suggesting she too was contacted by so-called journalists, not necessarily from this so-called Dispatches documentary, but she the journalists out there trying to get dirt on Russell had been calling her too. And this is what she said on the podcast Anything Goes back then.
So I've been receiving calls from Channel 4 since 2020 about this, and they've wanted me to contribute to it. And I just said, well, I don't really have anything to say other than everything was consensual because that's the truth. And I had a few of these randoms sending me messages on social media and stuff. And so it's been sort of in my hemisphere for a long time. But I just.
They offered you money?
Yeah. Yeah, yeah.
How much?
Oh, I can't remember. But like it was they wanted me to basically anybody who's spoken to me from the mainstream media is trying to get me to bend to their narrative, and I simply will not do it because it's not the truth.
So they tried to get you to bend the Dispatch documentary?
No. So not people from Dispatch, but there were a few people that were saying like, you know, how did you feel used or anything like that? And really, I was using him just as much as he was using me.
Somebody's going, look, there's 10 grand. Say this about Russell. 100% of the time you're going to take the money.
Well, at then, when I was younger, absolutely. That's what I did.
So these journalists, so-called journalists, real journalists don't offer money for stories, have been sniffing around Russell's ex-girlfriends for quite some time now, Samantha.
Yeah. Yeah. I believe that they've also planted the narrative in the comedy industry because I'd never heard it before 2023, right before the documentary was going to come out. So maybe some comedians really believe that there was an open secret. They may have heard a rumor that had been planted by a journalist. But if there really was, it would have been around in 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, all these years that I was around Russell when he was an activist and I was working with him.
And they knew that.
And you is it true you offered to give character evidence on Russell's behalf, but the defense did not follow up with you?
I did. I sent an email to his lawyers before Christmas. I told him about something that I thought was contempt of court, the other comedian pushing the false narrative on stage when the attorney general had warned about contempt of court and reporting was restricted. So I wrote about that. I also wrote about that to the police. And I said, look, I can be a character witness if you need me. I knew that he would have difficulty getting anyone for his defense because of the cancel culture that we have. And people have mortgages and kids to feed. I'm already canceled.
I've got nothing to lose. So yeah, I didn't hear back. I did follow up. Still didn't hear back. Not sure what happened there. I just assumed maybe he's already got a strong defense. I wish I'd tried harder now.
Well, I mean, it was their obligation to follow up with you. You did more than most people would do, which is volunteer to come forward and help a man who's become a pariah. You know, Samantha, all I can think of as I cover this case is my friend Charlie Kirk, who did interview Russell. And as with virtually everything, Charlie saw the story correctly from the beginning and had the following exchange with Russell, some of which we pulled. Watch this.
The entire government is going after Russell. I hope you guys know that. You're under attack from the UK government on, I think, completely fake stuff. And you better believe the enemy's not happy that now you're proclaiming Jesus in front of millions of people. And we as believers believe Satan is real. Satan is active. Satan attacks. Satan targets. Satan is literally in Hebrew, Satan means the prosecutor, the deceiver. So all of what you are going through in the United Kingdom is a satanic attack to try to say, oh, Russell, remember that thing that happened 10 years ago? Try to have you feel guilty and ashamed.
Remember, Satan throughout the scriptures would constantly always whisper, whether it be in the Garden or elsewhere, about, oh, you need to be held back by what you once did. But Christ sets you free.
Wow.
It's chilling to watch. Charlie would be dead within weeks of that conversation, but he saw exactly what was happening to Russell. And he understands there are demons out there. And the entire UK wants us to believe that Russell is one of them, as opposed to Russell was a big star with a lot of groupies who threw themselves at him. He did not have to perform non-consensual sex acts on women. He had hundreds, if not thousands, of options for consensual sex, but found God, reformed himself, changed his political outlook, found someone he truly loved, had three children with her.
They are completely resistant to that narrative because the new version of Russell is what they find truly deplorable, Samantha. The old version of Russell, they completely supported, allowed, promoted. It was the new version that they objected to.
Yeah. And he was a sick man back then. He was an addict. And they used him. The media used him. They enabled him in his promiscuity. And now that he's cleaned up his life and his conversion is genuine. I've been to countless very small work-in-progress shows, Q&As that he did. And he would often recite the St. Francis prayer before he was officially a Christian. So I know that his walk with Christ is 100% genuine.
I've given him books about Christianity. He was very grateful to receive them. But they're trying to make out that he's made it all up to try and avoid getting caught for the alleged things that he did. I mean, he was promiscuous, but I don't believe that he was a criminal.
It's very chilling. I just feel like I don't understand how a close relative to the United States, somebody as close as the UK, you know a country as close in so many ways and from which we hail originally, could be this far gone when it comes to due process and a man's rights. The media, even though they weren't allowed to report on the case with analysis while it was ongoing, boy, as soon as it was unleashed, there's I mean, literally every single person over there, other than Dan Wootton, I think, in the media, is going with this.
He has almost no defenders. It's very unfair.
Yeah. And like I say, if he did have defenders, they would be canceled. That's what it's like here now. People are getting arrested, ordinary people, for social media posts. We have hate crime laws. We basically have a blasphemy law coming through so that you can't criticize Islam. Just Islam, not Christianity, only Islam. So it's really weird. It's really creepy. It is sinister. It is demonic. Yeah. It's hard to stay hopeful, but I'm just doing my bit.
I'm telling the truth about Russell, what I know of him. And I do feel that I know his heart. I think he's a good man. Like everyone, he's made his mistakes. But he's been in repentance from his former lifestyle for over a decade.
And it was a lifestyle that all these same media critics had no problem with while it was ongoing and he was still pledged to the left. It was only when he changed his politics, got outspoken on things like COVID lockdowns and vaccines, big government overreach, that they started to turn on him and got very, very interested in paying women for stories. It's deeply concerning. Listen, thank you. Thank you for speaking out. You've been very fearless over there. I hope you're enjoying your cancellation.
I mean, many have found liberty in it. I'm one of them.
Yes. That's true. It's very liberating. You can just speak your mind and they can't get you twice. So I'll continue to tell the truth.
God bless you. Thanks for coming on.
Thank you.
Wow. And the reports of that prison are very dark that Russell's in, which we told you about at the beginning. It's said to be a 360 prisoner no, sorry. Over the past year, there were 360 prisoner-on-prisoner assaults. Reportedly, drugs and other banned items are regularly ferried in via drone or thrown over the walls. There are some sort of record number of staff absences because the staff reportedly doesn't want to be there.
And they can mean that inmates can be locked in their cells for up to 22 hours a day. Alex Wood, 44, a Londoner who served a sentence in Wadsworth for fraud from 2015 to 2017, described the prison as a horrible and dangerous place, saying, quote, "I don't think the staff feel safe there either." This is quoting here from The New York Times. Just today, it broke that there is a prisoner inside the prison who somehow is posting to his social media.
I don't totally understand how he's managing this. He's gotten in trouble for doing it before. But he's a rapper named Turgut Agara, 35, known as Mover, who posted a veiled threat to Russell on Snapchat using his rap name. And it reads, "Russell Brand, you naughty boy, will be seeing you son." I don't know if he meant soon.
But that's disturbing. His words were pasted over a blurry photo that appears to have been taken through a window frame of his jail cell on an illicit phone. He was jailed for life with a minimum of 30 years after knifing a Lithuanian builder to death in front of the man's father outside of a school in 2014. So this is what Russell's dealing with now because of this woman and the alleged anal rape. It's just for 10 years.
This is just it's incredible. You know, I was just talking to a friend the other day who was asking me how I'm doing. How am I? I'm like, what do you mean on the Russell Brand stuff? Like, oh, you know, there's been you know people are really outraged with your coverage. I'm like, they are? You know, I don't even look at this crap anymore. Like, that's so insane. I mean, has anybody been paying attention? Like, I'm fine with people who want to believe this story. OK, that's fine. I would submit anybody who actually listened to the testimonial or read the testimonial accounts of complainant five would see it as I do.
But people don't. And there are other people who believe all women. They're still there and who think Russell's a dirt bag because he admits he was a dirt bag for most of his adult life. And I get all that. I don't defend Russell's conduct as that of a gentleman at all. And as you guys know, when this story first broke, the story about him being with a 16-year-old when he was 31 was genuinely horrifying to me. And I didn't want to talk to Russell. I didn't understand conservatives defending Russell.
And then I learned more about his story, about what he had done from that point to this one. And eventually, I did have him on the show and heard him out and saw him very differently. Not everybody is capable of reevaluating an earlier opinion or has any desire to. And look, there are a lot of people who genuinely believe he's a cad and potentially a criminal and have come to that in good faith. And I don't that's fine. Everyone's entitled to their opinion on this, including me. It's crazy to think like, I don't care.
Whatever. It's like the latest controversy. But if you followed this case, as I know all of you have with me, you know exactly why I have serious doubts about this verdict. And I think it is disgustingly unjust that he's been found guilty of these absurd allegations. And it's going to prison for nearly 10 years for them. The sentence is 10 and a half. He'll serve seven. His 10-year-old will be going off to college when he's done. He's going to miss the whole thing.
His 3-year-old, he'll miss all of the single digits. That child will be 10, his little boy. And a little boy needs his dad when Russell gets out. It's just this is very severe. I'm very worried that he might not make it. I don't know Russell well enough to say if he has the strength to handle these prison conditions where he's being held in solitary for his own protection. And while this isn't the prison that he's going to serve the entire term in, the UK jails are apparently known for their squalid conditions.
And I do wonder, will he make it? Can he do seven years? Is he going to be held in solitary for his own protection for seven years? Because we told you the other day, they're treating him, the other prisoners, like he's a child molester. They were chanting this word nonce, which apparently means child molester, when he arrived. And that's not the case. Russell was not convicted of any or even accused in this case of molesting anyone other than mature adult women.
And I just don't what kind of a normal human being can go seven years in solitary and be fine, you know which he tried to say to his wife when they sentenced him on Monday. It'll be OK. It'll be OK. I don't know how, but it will be OK. When he sat here and I played you that sort of funny clip between us where I said, "Russell, I'm worried you're going to go to jail." And he said, "I don't want to." It was kind of funny. And it still makes me laugh. He was able to be funny even in thinking of that.
But I actually saw the longer clip. Somebody else posted it online. And I was watching it. And I was like, oh, wow. I forgot that's where it went. And what I said to him was, maybe it's part of your journey. Maybe if you do get sentenced to prison, maybe this is part of your redemption arc. You know, maybe God intends this for you as well because there's someone in prison who needs your help or there's someone you need to save with your own life experience and conveying it or you need to go through this and emerge out the other side with some level of wisdom that could be used by others or by you to save others.
I don't know. We as mere mortals can never know. But I have to believe it's part of his redemption arc or God wouldn't have allowed it.
Now, I mean, there is a real question about why this story would be making national news. Why does the media think this is so important that they need to bring this to you on ABC nightly news and then again on their morning program? One does wonder. They are so desperate for stories of white-on-black racism that they're going to feature it all over ABC news when they think they found one alleged instance of it.
They're so excited. I mean, the number of crimes committed by black defendants on white victims, where in particular white women, but also white men and white boys are being murdered by black defendants is deeply disturbing. The numbers are they will rattle you to the bone. And most of us, out of like a sense of decorum and politeness, don't go there.
We're not looking to ratchet up a sense of racial grievance or target any particular group by reporting its crime stats on a day-to-day basis. But the mainstream media doesn't feel that way when they find what they think might be a white racist. They don't give a shit about the whites being murdered by blacks, just to be clear. They don't. What they care about is black victims of white racism, especially if the white perpetrator happens to be an attractive young woman.
Then it may lead World News Tonight. It may lead Good Morning America. They found a live one. Or did they? It's just it's genuinely upsetting because we do have stories of kids being killed, kids being killed, white kids, by black defendants. And they don't feel the need to go all in on those stories at all. But they do like this one a lot. Happened to the University of Mississippi, University of Mississippi, where they're currently investigating a video that shows three white women.
Only the first two you're going to see on this video are at issue. The third to travel along in the video is not accused of doing anything racist, as far as we know. Three white women outside a black student's apartment. And just as I read this from the ABC write-up, of course, because they changed the style guide the AP did back in 2020, and now all the media goes along with it, black is capitalized. White is not capitalized, but black is capitalized. You have to I don't do it. I'm not fucking capitalizing black or brown or anything.
Like, it's a color. Stop. And by the way, if you say something like black culture, they'll accuse you of being a racist. Well, what which is it? Is it like a special group that gets a capital letter? Because I just see them as my fellow Americans. I don't see them as particularly more dangerous, less dangerous, dumber, smarter, more prone to receive racism or to give it than anybody else. It's just this is weird woke language manipulation that requires the capital.
OK. A video showing three white women outside a black student's apartment Friday evening this just happened with two of them allegedly making racist noises and gestures captured on Ring camera footage. Quote, "The incident is being actively investigated by the appropriate university offices," says the vice chancellor of the university. "Our staff have reached out to the students directly impacted to offer support, listen to their concerns, and connect them with available resources. We'll continue to support them as we work through this process."
The two women in the video, which was posted to TikTok, are seen briefly stepping toward the door camera, beating their chests while grunting and cooing like monkeys. Reading here from ABC. The third woman glanced toward the camera, but she did not appear to make any gestures or monkey noises. The school said in its statement that it was investigating the incident. Here is the video, which has now been viewed over 12 million times. Watch.
Wait, is it not serious?
OK. That's it. That's all we have from the alleged incident. The school confirmed that the students sorry, that the women in the video are students at Ole Miss. It did not respond to ABC News' question about whether disciplinary action was taken, citing the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, meaning they have privacy rights there. But one of the students and one of the students' mothers so like, a student and one of their moms appeared on GMA and sorry, CBS and spoke to this, actually provided more detail about the alleged incident.
Let's watch part of that.
Who was first to discover this video on the Ring camera?
Me.
And what did you do?
We actually went outside and tried to, like, approach them and, like, have them get them to, like, explain why they did that. One girl was apologizing. She was like, "I'm sorry. We've did that to, like, four doors. And mind you, we didn't see anyone else's door. It was just ours that was targeted." And she was like, "We didn't mean any harm."
OK. So that was the girls who lived in the apartment and their moms. And you could hear them say that they there tried to approach the students who made the noises. And they went on. Let's play the next one.
They say the first person seen in the November 6 video, Elena Kunez, apologized. But the second person, who they say lives in their complex, doubled down off camera.
She continued to make the gestures after the girl was apologizing. It was like a slap in the face.
Yeah. And what did you guys say back when she continued? Because now I would imagine it's really hard for you to keep your cool.
Yeah. I had said that I don't think they should go around. Even if they did go to other people's doors and do that, I don't think they should do that because it's very disrespectful.
Do you forgive her?
I feel like no matter, like, who we are or if she knew our race or not, but the gestures and the noises, I feel like it still was very disrespectful. I just have mixed feelings about it.
I appreciate the apology, but I feel like it still doesn't change what happened on that Friday because it's still hurtful and it's still devastating that someone would come to our camera and do that.
OK. So the girls and their moms speaking out saying that they had a confrontation with these girls after the alleged doorbell incident or door camera, whatever, and that the second girl shown in the video made the gestures again. Let's watch the videotape one more time.
Wait, is it not serious?
OK. So they're claiming that the second girl doubled down and did it again, which is relevant because I believe it's the first girl who is denying that she knew that these were black girls in this apartment. She says to the women, she's issued a statement. Her name is Elena Kunez. She's a freshman, 18. She writes, and this is the first woman you see in the videotape making the sounds and beating her chest. Quote, "To the women I offended and to the Ole Miss community, I sincerely apologize.
Before the incident on November 6, I never met the women involved and was unaware of their race. However, I recognize my actions were insensitive, inappropriate, and deeply harmful. I would have never intentionally made those noises or gestures toward a person of color. I have apologized to the women, and I pray they will forgive me. I can never truly understand the pain I've caused them, and it was never my intention. These girls deserve to feel seen and understood, and what I did is not a reflection of who I am trying to become.
Over the past several days, my family and I have received death threats and harassment. I'm grateful for the authorities working to ensure our safety. As I intend to cooperate fully with the university's investigation, I ask for privacy for my family. I understand the seriousness of this situation and remain committed to taking responsibility and learning from this embarrassing ordeal." The student, that first girl, has also withdrawn from the university, according to a source. So she's out. But again, the suggestion is that one apologized.
One of these girls apologized. I don't know which one. That's what the girls who live in the apartment said. One was apologizing. And they say, yeah, they say it was her, the first girl. They said the first person seen in the video apologized, but the second person who lives in their complex doubled down off camera. Just want to be sure because they're using different names here. The statement is from Elena Kunez, who's a freshman, who says, "I had no idea that they were black women who lived in there."
CBS is reporting that the first person seen in the video is Elena Kunez, who apologized. So it could be that the second girl forgive me, I just don't know was the girl who issued the statement and has withdrawn from the university. Look, here's the bottom line, as far as I see it. I do find it a stretch to believe these girls were randomly making monkey noises and gestures outside of any old apartment door.
That seems like a stretch. I mean, why? I need more if you want me to believe that. Like, what made you do monkey noises? And if the one girl actually lived in this apartment complex, I also find it a stretch to believe she had no idea that there were black girls living downstairs. I mean, I don't know how big it is. That's also a fact that we need to find out. But if it's relatively small and, you know, they're freshmen, so it's still relatively early in the year, I think you'd know. But we need to know more.
If it is true that the one girl continued, who doubled down after the black girls came out of the apartment to say, "What are you doing?" and she then made those noises or gestures, that's ballgame. There's no question that's racist. And we have a racist incident on our hand, and it's unambiguous. So we need to know. But I do think the bottom line about this story, to me, is why is it getting so much attention?
The media is delighted with this story. They can't give us enough of it. And yet, as I pointed out, we just had an incident just recently. Do we have it here of a young white boy being murdered by a group of black assailants. His name was Austin Payne. And it got no attention whatsoever. Todd Starrans, my old colleague from Fox News, was posting this.
It happened on Halloween. Austin Payne called his mother on Halloween night. He was only 15 years old to tell her that he'd been shot. By the next morning, he was found dead inside an abandoned apartment in Georgia. He's white. His assailants were black, four of them. Now all four have been charged with murder. Albany, Georgia police announced the arrest three days after Payne's body was found on Cameo Lane in Albany. The charges are against Jens Quincy Donaldson, 15; Omari Marion, 15; Adairus Wallace, 16; and Deltra Vianne Parker, 22.
Witnesses told officers that armed individuals allegedly approached a group walking with Austin Payne, ordered them to hand over their belongings, and fired shots the night of October 31, according to an initial incident report. Didn't hear about that one, did you? You have no idea who Austin Payne is, do you? Do you know it's spelled P-A-Y-N-E? Do you know what he looks like? Looks actually very sweet. Do you have any idea what the story is around these defendants?
No. No one does. Because the media won't tell you about stories like that. Now, you tell me which one is more offensive. The murder of a 15-year-old on Halloween by a gang of others or two girls behaving completely inappropriately, if this is actually the motivation, to black girls whose feelings would obviously be deeply hurt and they would be rattled by it, but they were alive? I mean, just in the relative scale of sins, which, if you were a news organization, would be a bigger story.
And let me tell you why there's no big story on the four black kids killing the white kid. Because the media understands, unfortunately, given the crime statistics, that that is a dog-bites-man story. And they know, whether they'll admit it or not, that the actual racism, if that's what this is again, we need some more facts just to make sure is more of a man-bites-dog story. It's very hard to find. You've got to really look for it.
And when you find it, it's like the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow if you're ABC or CBS. They're thrilled. It confirms the narrative they've been spinning all along. Aha, latent racists everywhere in America. And we are 3-2-1 from them trying to get to these girls' social media posts and look for anything that bears a MAGA hat or suggests conservatism is in their family, right? We've all been through the drill. We know exactly how this goes.
So I object. I object to the whole thing. I object to the fact that I know these girls' names, that I didn't know the name Austin Payne or the names of any of the white kids who were killed by black gangs or others day to day in this country. You know, I mean, Matt Walsh is pointing out Carmelo Anthony. He writes, "Stabbed a white kid to death and was still able to stay in school and graduate with no issues while his family raised half a million dollars and bought a new house."
Two clarifications on our last report. It was Elena Kunez, who was the first person in the video, who both apologized and is seen first. It is the second person, whose name we do not know, who has not issued a public apology, as far as we know, who is accused of doubling down when the girls came out of the apartment. So just to be clear on that. And it is also Elena Kunez, whose family is now being harassed.
She's 18 years old, and she apparently has a granddad in Wisconsin-based Kunez Auto Group. It's on the border of Wisconsin and Illinois. And her father was the former COO before he left the company back in February. But her grandfather owns this car dealership. And CBS 58 in Milwaukee issued the following report. We've got part of it about that.
Watch this.
A southeastern Wisconsin woman caught on camera making monkey gestures and noises into a black woman's doorbell camera no longer goes to the University of Mississippi.
Yeah, she was one of three women in the video and has connections to a well-known local car dealership. Jenna Wells live in our newsroom with the new information tonight.
That's right. Jessa, Ben, Natalie, a source close to the family confirms Elena Kunez has withdrawn from the University of Mississippi due to safety and harassment concerns. A representative for Kunez tells us Elena is the granddaughter of Greg Kunez, the owner of Kunez Auto Group.
What does the grandpa have to do with this? Honestly. And now they're digging deep into his car dealership and reporting that there was an incident back in January 2025 when an Oak Creek woman said a racial slur was written on an oil change sticker placed on her vehicle following a service appointment. The Kunez Auto Group fired the employee when that happened and then issued a statement after CBS 58 did this report on granddad's car dealership in the wake of his granddaughter and the old miss controversy, saying the individual in the video has no employment, ownership, or professional affiliation with Kunez Auto Group.
We do not comment on private citizens unaffiliated with the company. So this is just ridiculous. OK, so there was an alleged racial incident there in January 2025. And so this is offered up, of course, so you can say the grandfather is a racist and that is why his granddaughter is a racist, none of which we actually know. We have no idea what actually happened with this alleged incident on the receipt. And we have zero idea whether this girl, Kunez, Elena Kunez, actually did know that there was a black person living inside that apartment.
We don't know. What we do know is that as soon as she saw black women emerge from the apartment to say, "What the hell?" she apologized. And she has maintained from the beginning she actually didn't know that there were black women inside of there. It is the second girl who is alleged to have doubled down. I don't know what the truth is. But dragging grandpa into the story seems like a below-the-belt hit, even for our disgusting media. Leave grandpa alone. If you've got evidence that grandpa himself, as opposed to some employee he fired, has done something racist, then we can talk about grandpa.
But you don't have it. So in the news biz, we would move right past that. Do we know whether the parents of the kids who killed Austin Payne are racists? Do we know whether the grandparents of the kids who killed Austin Payne have ever uttered a racial slur or had an employee who did something racist? Do we? Should we start taking these deep dives into black-on-white violence about the entire family, how they live, what comments they've made, whether they have any racism in their hearts?
OK. OK. I don't think you're going to like the way that's going to land. Not sure the woke brigade of 2020, which appears to be back, is going to like the way that goes. Instead, they would call all of us who did that a bunch of raging racists just for reporting on actual black-on-white crime that's truly violent and devastating and robs somebody not of their dignity, but of their life. So it's just so galling.
So now, I mean, again, what is with, like, the platforming? Again, all the national news networks are doing it. CBS gets not only the girls who live in the apartment, but their moms have to participate, too. Their moms are on camera. I mean, these girls are 18 years old, but their moms have to be there. I will say their moms were reasonable. One of the women's mothers said the following in SOT 6.
As a human being, I hate to hear that because, you know, the church is not a future. But I feel like everybody needs to be accountable.
What's your message to people as they listen to your story, your perspective of what happened?
I want people to be mindful of their actions. So I also want people who would potentially experience the same situations to speak out and don't let things be swept under the rug because this is a reality for us. And I feel like voices need to be heard.
So you heard the mom there reacting to news that the girl had withdrawn from the university, saying she hated to hear that, which is nice. But saying accountability is important, yes, OK. But that's not where the media is going to go with this. I mean, they won't stop until these girls' lives are absolutely ruined. I mean, truly absolutely ruined. And the Carmelo Anthony example is a good one. That case got so turned around by his very weird, dishonest band of supporters down there who turned the fact that this black kid had killed a white kid into a racist criminal prosecution because he was black.
They acted like he was the one who died. So, like, we are used to the media manipulating these situations. And it's going to be really hard now because, you know, there's alternative media now who are going to point out the inconvenient facts, like the disparity in attention on World News Tonight, GMA, and CBS to these other crimes. I'm actually thrilled that you're so interested in the racial component of crimes. OK? I look forward to your consistency on that front.
Let's keep going. There's news on Alina Haba. I mean, look, this woman defended Trump in Tish James' civil case against him where she tried to bankrupt him for allegedly making false or fraudulent statements to banks about the size of his New York apartment so he could get certain loans at a more favorable rate. I mean, the sophisticated investors and so on, all of them said, "We're not mad. The Trump Organization was always good to deal with.
Like, we have no beef here." But Tish James was like, "Well, somehow the consumers of New York were hurt by this transaction." How? She was never really able to prove it. Alina Haba tried that case for Trump. She was not impressive. I said this during the trial. I said I was not impressed with Alina Haba. I never have been. To me, I'm just going to be honest, she's seemed like a grifter from day one. I've seen her at a couple of events. I'm just, look, spend my impression. She glommed on to Trump and tried to make herself a star.
And she lost to that case, which was then reversed on appeal by an appellate lawyer. So she decided to glom on to Trump and try to make herself into something. And she is accused by Trump of doing something despicable, which is cozying up to some Venezuelan billionaire and effectively selling a pardon, bribing, taking a bribe for a pardon.
That's something she denies. She absolutely denies. But you tell me how a not impressive lawyer that nobody's ever heard of other than this particular lane where it was a loss winds up getting hired as general counsel for a company recently started by a Venezuelan billionaire accused of a crime, convicted of a crime. It was a felony, which he got knocked down to a misdemeanor, but was reportedly very upset about having any crime on his record whatsoever.
And suddenly his daughter formed this company and hired who, Alina Haba, as her general counsel. Why? Some Venezuelan billionaire needs a New York lawyer as her general counsel for her Venezuelan adventure? I've got questions. And not only that, struck a deal reportedly to pay Alina Haba $10 million a year as general counsel of that company.
I mean, that is such an outrageous sum. Let me tell you who gets $10 million a year as a lawyer. It would be the biggest rainmakers at the biggest firms in the country, the people who land the RJ Reynolds accounts, which fund an entire firm for years on end, could potentially get up around that number. But $10 million a year is astronomical for a lawyer practicing law, including as general counsel. Generally, you need to be COO, CFO, CEO, CTO to try to break in numbers like that at the most successful companies in America.
So a lot of people had eyebrows raised when this news broke. And while it was $10 million a year reportedly over four years, that would have been 40, but they said the deal she signed was worth 50, $50 million. And, oh, shocked, the guy got his pardon within weeks. He was pardoned. Alina Haba claims she had nothing to do with the pardon. OK, we'll see when she gets dragged before Congress and others do as well. But this happened. Trump found out about it and was very angry because it was pretty clear, as it is to all of us, what she had done.
And he said they should fire her and she should make a donation because now we find out she got a, I think it was an $8 million signing bonus and $6 million already paid. It was basically the equivalent of $14 million that had already been paid out. And he said she should be fired from this post. And also, she should make a donation of this potentially ill-gotten gain to the Trump Library or some other charity. I don't think she's done the latter. So she's $14 million richer, but she just got fired.
The company did fire her, suggesting that she had not lived up to her end of the deal. She hadn't fulfilled her legal obligations to the company, something she is denying. And she's reportedly now threatening to sue. So that'll be fun to watch. It's called Concord Partners. And in a letter dated November 4, they fired her, citing a failure to perform duties, according to a person close to the family and documents obtained by The New York Times.
The person said her priorities appeared to shift away from Concord after she started dating Turhan Mildan, a 25-year-old Turkish investor earlier this year. So she's 40-something and he's 25 and he's reportedly a billionaire. This is a separate story. But he's a Turkish billionaire who said he was 29, but in fact is 25. And they spent $10 million on their wedding.
So, look, my opinion is this woman cashed in. She's a grifter. She obviously saw her association with Trump as a piggy bank, parlayed it into, in my opinion, marrying some Turkish billionaire who is, what, 15 years younger than she is, and then wasn't satisfied with his billions and her $10 million wedding, but decided to enter into this very sketchy deal with a Venezuelan billionaire.
That's how it looks to me. And on top of that, she's accusing Rick Grenell of grifting off of the Trump administration, where her Turkish billionaire husband came forward in some explosive Oval Office meeting, reportedly, and told Trump he had cut Rick Grenell some sort of a check and said $6 million of it was going to be designated for the Kennedy Center. And then she claimed Rick Grenell never made that donation to the Kennedy Center, something he has denied vehemently and is accusing her of being a liar.
I have no idea what actually happened there, but I would submit she doesn't have a very good track record of honesty and upstanding behavior, in my opinion. So we'll see what happens. But I do believe, as she really wants us to call her Mrs. Meldan now, Mrs. Meldan, that's the last name of the Turkish billionaire, I think she's in some trouble. And she will be one of the first people to get subpoenaed by the new Democrat Congress. And as the kids say, I'm here for it. Not all of the investigations they're going to be pursuing will be political witch hunts.
That's a good one. Let's find out what exactly happened there. Let's find out what exactly Kimberly Guilfoyle did with the billionaires flying her to Paris on their jets and putting her up at George the Sank and all that. I mean, yeah, we should know. All of that is worthy of investigation. What was Kristi Noem and Corey Lewandowski doing? What were they doing at DHS? I don't trust that pair as far as I can throw them, especially him. And there have been a lot of allegations swirling around them. We'll see.
I think all of those are fair game. Grift within the Trump family and around it are fair game. They work for us. So we'll see, Alina, what exactly went on. Speaking of Trump, we've been talking this week about the president's comments on 60 Minutes, that he thought he could strike a deal with the Democrats on immigration for the landscapers and the hotel workers who are here illegally but haven't committed a second crime after the first one of coming in the country unlawfully.
He said it explicitly. He's looking to strike a deal. You could strike a deal on them. Yes, he said. Then backlash from the base. Then Trump tried to clarify it at a presser saying, no amnesty, no amnesty, but then said, but there may be a deal for some set of illegals who are here. OK, well, that is amnesty. So then Mark Wayne Mullen, who, as you know, is our DHS secretary, went on with Laura Ingraham, and she's great on this issue and always has been.
And she pressed him on whether we're getting amnesty in some way, shape, or form. Here's that in SOT 8.
Can you promise our viewers and the 77 million people who voted for President Trump that there is no change in his immigration policy?
Zero change. The president made that very clear. We're still going after the worst of the worst. And amnesty will never be on the table.
But why does he float DACA, Mr. Secretary?
So DACA.
Why is that the message for you guys of this election?
I mean, DACA applies to children that were brought in this country of no fault of their own. They were, yes, but they were brought here of no fault of their own. And some of them may not even speak English or never even lived in their country. I think there's a part that we could look to say, listen, you're not going to become citizens because you wasn't born here. But is there a path for you to be legal? It's a very far-fetched because the president tried to do this in 2016 and the Democrats weren't interested in doing it. But before we even consider doing any of that, we're going to make sure that, one, our base is with us on it.
They're not with you.
And if they're not.
They're not with you. I'm just saying this.
And I'm going to tell you, the president will not sign anything that isn't in the right movement for this country and the Republican Party.
OK, this is not an impressive figure. And he basically gave up the farm. Like, they just keep saying no amnesty, but maybe for this group. That's amnesty. That's amnesty. And by the way, the president wasn't even discussing children when he was on 60 Minutes. He was discussing landscapers and hotel maids who have been here for a long time, not children brought here by their parents illegally. The president was explicit about that. So I don't know what they're getting ready to do, but I think all of us who don't want amnesty because it leads to more illegal immigration have more than fair reason to be concerned here.
That interview did not help at all. OK, finally, Thomas Markle Sr. He got arrested by the FBI, as we told you, a few days ago. They searched his LA storage facility, and they say they found additional child sexual abuse material there, including pictures of Thomas Markle with young girls, like in compromising positions, like underage, prepubescent girls, which is the definition of pedophile, prepubescent children, an attraction to them.
And amazingly, even though he was brought up on charges here, one charge, there'll be more, but one charge of child sexual abuse material and having it, they released him. They released him on his own recognizance, but with an ankle monitor. And he reportedly chopped it off. Like, it's unbelievable. And yet it's totally believable. Here's what Bill Esceli, who's the U.S. attorney for this district out in California, posted. Four days ago, a federal judge allowed Mr.
Markle to remain out of custody pending trial. He was ordered to wear a location monitoring device. He allegedly cut the bracelet off at 1:45 a.m. last night. Release conditions are court orders, not suggestions. We are asking the court to revoke his release and detain him pending trial. And we will continue to prosecute this case to the fullest extent of the law. That request was granted by the judge a short time later, Judge Lindsay Griffin. Griffin said Markle had tampered with his ankle monitor and said he needed to be rearrested because his living arrangements had become untenable.
He's now jailed without bond. He was also, interestingly, rejected from his senior living facility. A spokesperson for the U.S. Marshals Service, the branch of federal law enforcement responsible for monitoring his whereabouts via his GPS ankle monitor, said it was working to establish exactly what had happened. The spokesperson said that he had been rejected from his senior living facility when he was bailed. And he was released to the custody of his other daughter, Samantha. On Saturday, The Daily Mail saw Mark Phillips, the partner of Samantha Markle, arriving to pick up Markle Sr.'s items from the home.
Phillips emerged moments later with several bags full of clothes, crutches, and a stroller. When The Daily Mail asked him exactly where Markle was, he snarled, that's the reporting, quote, you will never find him. OK, well, we did find him because he took off his monitor and now he's back in jail. Phillips, 68, then visited another care home in the Lakeland area and walked inside to collect a brochure before returning to the trailer he shares with Samantha, who is wheelchair-bound. The couple had attached a rope across the entrance and erected a no-trespassing sign.
At Markle's court hearing on Friday, the judge also ordered him to undergo a mental competency exam at his first court hearing, which is scheduled for November 20. By the way, I have something to tell you about Thomas Markle Jr. Deb, can you re-forward that to me so I have it in front of me? But before I get to that, for what it's worth, Representative Paulina Luna, Anna Paulina Luna, who is in Florida, and that is the state where Markle was living, he was in Florida. The cache of child sexual abuse material was in Los Angeles, where Markle spent his career and was living prior to moving to Mexico, then the Philippines, then a stint in Philadelphia, reportedly, then down to Florida.
Now he's in jail, we believe, in California. But in any event, she's from Florida, where he has been for some time. And she posted the following. Thomas Markle was found with photos of himself posing with a naked underage girl and an undressed child. He's a sicko. The guy was mentally fit enough to keep naked photos of children. He was mentally fit enough to hide the photos, mentally fit enough to travel outside the country to do it. He was mentally fit enough to exploit a child. Florida classifies sexual battery on a child under 12 by a person 18 or older as a capital felony under the following statute.
It is punishable by death or life imprisonment without parole. They should be seeking the death penalty. I am calling for Thomas Markle to receive the death penalty. And there she goes again, talking about how he was found. She said, I'm calling for him to receive the death penalty. Agent seized items from his LA storage units, including film negatives showing him ID'd by a longtime witness with a nude prepubescent girl, one involving apparent genital contact, plus other images of him with children in various stages of undress.
He's a sick human. I did not know that. That's the first I'd heard of that genital contact shown in the photos between Markle and a prepubescent girl, which is obviously deeply concerning. He is 82 years old. One final note. We reported to you a week or so ago that Philippine authorities were now expanding their investigation into Markle Sr. to include a look at Markle Jr., the one who raised the red flag about the cache of child sexual abuse material he says he found in Markle's home in the Philippines.
That came directly from a Philippine authority. We read you the name. We read you the statement. Well, they are now apologizing to Thomas Markle Jr. via the UK Sun reporting here after wrongly naming him a person of interest in their probe into Thomas Markle. Filipino police have cleared Thomas Markle Jr., 60, of any wrongdoing in the ongoing child sexual abuse investigation against his father. He was said to be a person of interest in a bizarre statement by Interior Minister Juanito Victor Remula last week.
The outspoken politician writes the UK Sun reported that witnesses claimed they saw underage girls entering Markle Jr.'s property and ring lights through the windows. But police in Cordova, Philippines, where Markle Jr. lives, have interviewed his fiance, Rose Ann Gabuia, and his wider circle, who have resolved the matter. On Friday, senior officials at the Philippines National Police apologized to Markle Jr. for their mix-up over the phone and confirmed the outlandish claims came from a nosy neighbor.
A source close to the case said, quote, the matter has been cleared up. Officers were very apologetic. Rose told cops her younger siblings, aged 11, 14, 16, and 17, are regular visitors to her and Markle Jr. at the property, as well as a young 3-year-old niece. Rose also told officers she often uses a ring light inside the house to film her own social media content and handed them at least 10 videos of her siblings dancing at the house. Good grief. What a mess. The Filipino authorities, this is why it's good that the FBI is handling the charges and taking the lead in the case against Thomas Sr.
I don't think we want this in the hands of the Philippines. I have no faith in them. I said it the other day, and this is just further evidence that there's no reason to have faith in them. So Thomas Markle Jr., not accused of any wrongdoing with respect to children, that's cleared up. OK, we're going to take a break, and then we're going to come back with the one and only Heather MacDonald. Heather, she's brilliant, and you should read her on anything and everything. But Heather, among her many other gifts, keeps a close eye on the art world, in particular the music world, of which she's a massive fan, classical symphonies and classical music.
Well, I read a new piece in City Journal, which you guys should all be reading, headlined, "Classical Music's Misguided Quest for Relevance." And it was written by Heather MacDonald, which anything she writes, I will read, and I will learn, and I'll be a better person for it. It examines the firing of Boston Symphony, sorry, Boston Symphony Orchestra conductor Andres Nelson's, just five months after he pushed to restore, quote, "artistic excellence" to the orchestra's strategic plan.
He wanted artistic excellence, you see, and that was the problem. Now, was Andres a bad conductor? Did he get up there and mislead the orchestra into playing badly and in a way that horrified the fans? Not at all. Here's a little sample of Andres conducting Tchaikovsky's Symphony No. 5 in October of 2025. Sot 40.
Absolutely beautiful. But the problem, you see, as Heather's documented in prior pieces with a lot of these orchestras, is a lot of the people you were seeing in that orchestra have committed the sin of being white, which is bad in the world of classical music. And a lot of the people sitting in the audience have been white, which is also very, very bad. And most unforgivable of all, they are playing music written by the worst thing you can be, which is a white man.
And Andres apparently had no problem with that. So, of course, he had to go. Heather documents all of this as only she can in great detail, and she's going to walk us through it. Heather, so great to have you back. Thank you for writing this piece and for shining a light on the arts, because as they erode and are decimated from within, we're really losing something special. So tell us about Andres and how this whole thing got kicked off.
Well, Meghan, you're absolutely right. We are losing our civilization. We are losing the highest aspirations and expression of humanity by a leadership class that is betraying every single day its primary duty, which is to curate this civilization, pass it on, teach the young why they should be down on their knees in gratitude before the geniuses that gave us both science, rationality, and beauty.
And this leadership class, as we saw in the Boston Symphony Orchestra's CEO and board of trustees, whether it's them or people that are overseeing medical schools, would rather get approval from their peers for fighting phantom at this point injustice than fulfill their paramount duty, which is to keep civilization going. Andres Nelson's, the conductor of the Boston Symphony Orchestra, was hired in 2014 by the BSO.
He is universally respected. He's got a joint appointment with a world-leading orchestra in Leipzig that loves him so much, they've hired him through 2036. And the BSO itself, before it got what is the very platonic form of the modern arts administrator Chad Smith in mid-2024, the BSO itself had given Andres Nelson's an automatically renewing contract, saying that his artistic leadership was peerless.
There was nothing to complain about. But the BSO changed leadership hands and got this guy who is indistinguishable from somebody you'd hear at the Harvard DEI office or the Cornell anti-female victimization office talking about, we need to foreground lost voices, silenced and marginalized voices, and we have to allow the audience to see themselves in classical music, which is a complete misreading of what artistic experience should be about.
It is not about narcissism. You should not tell audiences that they go to hear the Bach, St. Matthew Passion, or a Beethoven late piano sonata, works of terrifying sublimity because they want to see themselves reflected. They should be hearing music to lose themselves in the composer's soul. But we live in a world of narcissism. It's all about whether it's the leadership class feeling proud of itself for fighting injustice or teaching audiences to not be interested in real difference, which is the difference of the past.
You want to experience real difference? Listen to the French Baroque. Like, that is a different sensibility that is not ours, but we can learn from it. This leadership class has no interest in actual difference, but only wants to be identical to everybody else. So the BSO went through a two-year strategic planning process that is the height of corporate vapidity. It's all about priorities and planning.
And as Chad Smith, we need to do the work of diversity. He uses every cliché in the book. And in the process of that, they largely cut out Andres Nelson's. But in the process, as you said, Meghan, he wanted to restore a key phrase that had been deleted from the strategic plan, which was to make artistic excellence at the core of what the BSO does. He graciously asked that this phrase be restored.
And that was like the final straw. He had to go because that's too much of a diversion from the diversity imperative.
And Andres had played the game somewhat, other than this request that they focus on artistic excellence. He had done a bunch of diversity-type offerings in the selections made and the themes of some of the performances, none of which was enough because he landed on saying, OK, and I'm not rejecting any of that, but I do think the main focus of the orchestra should be artistic excellence. And that is what did him in.
This is also a power struggle. Well, what you have, you've got several things happening in the orchestral world that is no different than universities. It's no different than medical schools, which is the growth of the bureaucracy. 30, 40 years ago, the Boston Symphony Orchestra, like most orchestras, had about 100 musicians and six administrators. That was enough to keep this enterprise at the absolute top of the game. The BSO has been regarded for a century as one of America's great orchestras and still largely is.
We'll see what happens after Nelson's leaves. Currently, the ratio of administrators to musicians is about one to one. There's about 100 administrators now to 100 musicians. And that, of course, is vastly expensive. Feeding and keeping occupied, all of these human resources consultants and whatnot cost a fortune, which results in ticket prices going up. You know, if you want a diverse audience, how about you lower your ticket prices?
How about even making it free to schoolchildren? And so this has been going on, and they need something to do. And so they get involved in programming decisions and decide that music is not enough, that we need to wrap music around ideas. And these are, of course, transgressive ideas a lot of the time. Tanglewood, which is the summer home of the Boston Symphony Orchestra up in Litchfield, Massachusetts, it's, again, been a pilgrimage for music devotees and novices to classical music for decades.
One of the.
That's where I graduated from law school. We had our ceremony there.
Oh, you luck. Well, it's a gorgeous spot and a gorgeous place to hear music. I actually heard Tchaikovsky's Fourth Symphony there, which has one of the most erotic middle movements in classical music. Tchaikovsky was an absolute master at using the winds. And as you heard in that excerpt from the Fifth Symphony, his melodies are very sinuous. And the Fourth Symphony, I remember sitting out in the lawn outside the Tanglewood shed. It was hot and humid.
And I had a crush on the guy that I was with. And here comes this second movement with this melody being passed from a clarinet to an oboe to a flute. And it was absolutely devastating in its seductiveness. So it's a great place to hear music and feel its power. Anyway, so but what did they do this summer at Tanglewood? One of their concluding humanities programs was all about mass incarceration and systemic racism.
They brought in Brian Stevenson, who's absolutely beloved on the academic circuit as a commencement speaker or as a we'll bring him in to tutor a class on systemic racism, the criminal justice system. What does this have to do with classical music? Not clear. Except, actually, it has everything to do with classical music. Let me amend that today, Meghan, because classical music is seen simply as a jumping-off point to get to what really matters, which is fighting racism.
So this was, in one sense, a battle of who gets to decide what an orchestra is about. The conductor, somebody like Nelson's, who says, besides wanting the restoration of the phrase "artistic excellence," he also said, I want this strategic plan to say that cultivating the core repertoire, not diversity picks, and the sound of the orchestra, which is how it communicates, is our core mission versus the management and this absolutely nauseating narcissist CEO, Chad Smith, who want music simply to serve a political agenda.
And then the conductor kind of has to go along and put up with it.
This is reminding me, I'm sure you and I have discussed this story, but a friend of mine has a sister who is teaching at Yale. No, so not at Yale, at Smith. At Smith. And she was visiting from Yale at Smith. And she had reported back to this family member, who I know, that she got some sort of a protest as soon as she got there. She was an English literature professor. And he said, let me guess, because there were too many white men on the syllabus.
And she said, no, that there were any white men was the problem, that there was even a single, which Smith did not want. The students at Smith did not want to see one single white man and his work listed on a syllabus for English lit at Smith. And the same thing is happening in the music world when it comes to, I mean, some of our most beautiful offerings with these symphonies, they don't want to hear music authored by people like Tchaikovsky.
It's offensive to them. You've documented on this show before how they, back after the 2020 George Floyd Appaloosa nonsense, were trying to get rid of blind auditions, which is how they generally select their orchestras, because they thought they were discriminatory. How can they be discriminatory on the basis of race if no one knows what the race of the auditioner is? But they thought they didn't have enough people of color in. And now, of course, it's morphed over into what is the music saying? Does it talk about mass incarceration or doesn't it?
It's all narcissism. It's narcissism on the part of students. And I will be generous for a very fleeting moment and then take it all back. One could argue that, well, we can't really blame the students. It's for the adults to take them out of their adolescent self-involvement and solipsism. And if they feel like they're entitled to go on a rampage, a French Revolution guillotining of the greats before them, it's because the adults have allowed them to give in to their innate ignorance, no-nothing qualities, and desire to have the world revolve around them.
But the adults are just as narcissistic because they're seeking the approval of the students. There's a codependent relationship between ignorant adolescents and now preteens and the adults who were supposed to be the authorities in the room. We give them this power in universities because they used to be scholars. They used to have spent decades of their lives trying to understand the mysteries of the past, trying to understand the greatest of all human dramas, which is the evolution of style.
You know, it is an amazing thing to trace the evolution of, say, a romance, a medieval romantic epic through into the 19th-century realistic novel. How did that happen? It's absolutely compelling knowledge to understand how human beings have changed in their relationship in the world. That's what they should be studying. And instead, they're regurgitating the same just shallow academic rhetoric from one environment to another, whether it's music, whether it's literature, whether it's philosophy, or whether it's medicine, to be perfectly honest, because we see the same betrayal.
I've heard this from a lot of my doctors who complain about this. It's a faux sophistication. It's faux. It's like what they think they need to say in order to sound like they're well-educated from these universities. But on the subject of the BSO, you write in your piece that they had been doing the dance. Andres had been doing the dance to the extent he had to. In March of 2003, the orchestra offered a three-week festival called Voices of Loss, Reckoning, and Hope. It explored critical themes of discrimination, gender disparities, and identity in historical and contemporary works.
It included Anthony Davis's 2007 You Have the Right to Remain Silent, a clarinet concerto based on a police traffic stop that Davis had experienced in the late 1970s. The program notes written by composer George E. Lewis observed that Blacks in the US and Europe learned to accept the near certainty of being accosted by public authority in one form or another. The spurious motivation for many of these encounters is impossible to deny, despite the strenuous efforts made in some circles to do so and so on.
So he goes along with all of this, but then wants pure excellence to be the standard. And he winds up getting fired. And here is the president and CEO of the Boston Symphony Orchestra, Chad Smith, talking about the future of the group on a radio show in June 2026. It's Hot 41.
We landed at a place where we felt that the organization, that the orchestra must serve Boston, must serve our communities more expansively and inclusively, that we were seeing significant declines across a number of areas at the BSO. And the only way for us to move forward was to think differently about what it is that we put on our stages, whose voices get to be heard, whose stories get to be told, how do we do that in a way which continues to center and anchor the great canon of classical music?
But the decision came down to a need for alignment.
Oh, alignment and inclusivity.
Oh, it just you can tell the voice is just so oleaginous. And frankly, the guy is lying through his teeth because audience membership, you know, buying tickets increased under Nelson's. This was never about finances. They were very clear. It wasn't about the finances. The BSO is rich. It is loaded with its endowment. And it was never about artistic excellence. There was, you know, there was never a hint in the voluminous email correspondence between Nelson's, his agents, and various members of the massive management class at BSO that he was anything other than a great leader.
It never came up. So it's all about.
In fact, there were protests when he left, Heather.
Oh, huge. The orchestra members are furious. It is unprecedented, unprecedented to have a conductor who is beloved of his orchestra, against whom there are no charges of misconduct, of sexual improprieties, to be fired. It hasn't happened. And so the orchestra, they hadn't been consulted on this, and they started a protest of wearing red flowers in their lapels in honor of the Latvian flag, which was Nelson's home country.
And this continued into Tanglewood this year. And the musicians would hand these boutonnières out. And management finally said, this is getting like a public relations. It's too much of a disaster. And it cracked down and said, you may not distribute anything on the site of Tanglewood. And so the local businesses who have their windows are plastered with signs in support of Nelson's, they started handing out the red flowers. So yes, this produced a revolt.
The orchestra members have been telling members of other orchestras for years that the BSO had been forced under Smith to hire not the best soloists, not the best conductors, as guest conductors in the service of diversity. But that Chad Smith quote, you got the absolute heart of that NPR interview, was an absolute gem of academic fatuousness because, again, music is not about you.
It's about the conductor. Try listening to a Mozart piano concerto, maybe number 25, number 17. You lose yourself in Mozart. It's not about trying to hear your own little pathetic self. And this idea of who's we need to think about, as you said, whose voices get to be heard, whose stories get to be told. We are hearing the voices of Brahms and Chopin.
You don't go to a classical concert to hear your own voice. And here's what else you don't go to, Meghan, to hear more about George Floyd or any other current martyr to phantom racism. There are many, many opportunities. There is no shortage of opportunities to hear oppression stories in our culture. It's basically four years of academic indoctrination in that if you're going to college. What there is a shortage of, given the long-term tragic recession of classical music from popular consciousness, is an opportunity to experience an art form that tragically has become alien.
It is a complex musical language. The symphonic score is much more complicated than anything in pop music today. And it takes getting used to. Your ear has to be acclimated to it. There are people that have the wonderful experience of hearing a symphony orchestra for the first time. And it's magic. And I actually do think, how can you have that sound, that volume go through your sternum and not be shaken up and think, whoa, you know, what is going on here?
But if it's difficult, try it again. But that's what there's a shortage of, not of the, again, the voices being heard and stories getting to be told. The stories are the movement of the composer's soul. That's what you should be there to hear, not your own ridiculous, limited autobiography.
Heather Mac Donald says it like only she can. God bless you for writing this piece. Thank you for calling our attention to it. Much love to be continued. And we will be back with all of you tomorrow with Sean and Sohrab. We'll see you then. Thanks for listening to the Meghan Kelly Show. No BS, no agenda, and no fear.
Megyn Kelly is joined by comedian Samantha Pressdee to discuss her longtime friendship with Russell Brand, the false campaign against him, how the idea that Brand being a criminal was an "open secret" is a lie, the truth about how the campaign against Russell Brand started, how he changed his politics and fought the system and then the system came after him, Charlie Kirk's comments about Brand the month before he died, and more. Then Megyn dives into the corporate media focusing on the "monkey" Ole Miss female students incident, how the media is blowing up the story to try to push a racism narrative, what we know about what actually happened and what we still don't, the new details we're learning about the Alina Habba $50 million grift, the sketchy details of her marriage to a young billionaire, how she could be heading to a Congressional hearing very soon, Meghan Markle’s father Thomas Markle cutting off his ankle monitor, how he was sent back to jail without bond, a congresswoman floating the idea of the death penalty over his crimes, and more. Then Heather Mac Donald, fellow at the Manhattan Institute, joins to discuss the narcissism of the leadership class in the arts, an orchestra firing a conductor for pushing “artistic excellence” over diversity, the push by some to stop playing music from white men, and more.
Pressdee- https://x.com/SammiePressdee
Mac Donald- https://x.com/hmdatmi
Tax Relief Advocates: End your tax nightmare today by visiting us online at https://TRA.com or call 800-575-6845
Glacier Security App: Privacy isn't paranoia. It's protection. Get 20% off your first 3 months at https://theglacierapp.com/megyn and use code MEGYN at checkout.
Ethos: Protect your family’s future with fast, online life insurance from Ethos—get a free quote in minutes at https://Ethos.com/MK
Herald Group: Learn more at https://GuardYourCard.com
Byrna: Go to https://Byrna.com or your local Sportsman's Warehouse today.
Follow The Megyn Kelly Show on all social platforms:
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/MegynKelly
Twitter: http://Twitter.com/MegynKellyShow
Instagram: http://Instagram.com/MegynKellyShow
Facebook: http://Facebook.com/MegynKellyShow
Find out more information at:
https://www.devilmaycaremedia.com/megynkellyshow
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.