Transcript of The Man Who Calls BS On AI: AI Is The World’s Greatest SCAM, And They All Know It! | Ed Zitron

02:27:18 55 min read 1 views Published 3 months ago

Copy link
Episode summary

Tech critic Ed Zitron argues that generative AI is overhyped and financially unsustainable, and that the industry misleads the public about its revenues, costs and capabilities. In a conversation with host Steven Bartlett, he covers how OpenAI and Anthropic depend on money from large tech firms, how token-based pricing and subsidised subscriptions hide the true cost of AI, and how data centre spending compares with past bubbles such as the dot-com era.

They also debate whether AI hallucinations, job losses and rapid improvement are real trends or marketing claims. Listeners will hear both the critic's case and the host's counterarguments, and get a framework for judging AI company promises.

In this episode Steven Bartlett, Ed Zitron

This transcript of “The Man Who Calls BS On AI: AI Is The World’s Greatest SCAM, And They All Know It! | Ed Zitron” from The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett was made with HappyScribe’s speech-to-text technology. Related: transcribe Teams meetings.

Ed Zitron00:00:00

I think generative AI is at its heart. Con. And seeing these ultra-rich, ultra-powerful people, life feels like a turns my stomach. The word "con" is a strong word. Well, what do you call something where, from the very beginning, they've sold it in the terms of magic? But it's just a half-arsery machine. They are misleading the entire world.

Steven Bartlett00:00:18

You are the first person that I've spoken to that has that opinion.

Ed Zitron00:00:20

Well, the fact that this is happening is insane, and the fact it's not a scandal is insane. And I've been in the tech industry for 16 years now, and I love technology, and I'm enthusiastic about it. But I don't like being misled. And this is the largest non-consensual push of technology in history.

Steven Bartlett00:00:36

So we're going to play a game, Ed. I have the things that you consider to be myths about the AI industry.

Ed Zitron00:00:42

Let's play it. The AI industry is creating enormous economic growth. No, it's not. All of these companies run at a horrifying loss. OpenAI lost $20.9 billion last year. None of these people could just say, "Yeah, we're on the path to making this profitable." Because they can't.

Steven Bartlett00:00:55

Next one.

Ed Zitron00:00:56

AI will replace all human jobs. That just isn't happening. There's no economic data to support it. Next, the United States needs to spend trillions to beat China in the AI race. What's the race to do? For us to constantly piss our pants worrying about China? But people keep saying, "What if these moguls fall into the wrong hands?" They're already in the wrong hands. Mark Zuckerberg, Sam Altman, Dario Amodei.

Steven Bartlett00:01:16

Mark Zuckerberg says, "We'll continue to invest aggressively in infrastructure to meet the demand."

Ed Zitron00:01:20

God met is a monstrosity. Makes me think of Shrek with Lord Farquaad. Some of you may die, but that's a risk I'm willing to accept. If only these people gave a fuck about poverty or actual problems in the world versus "Are we buying enough GPUs?"

Steven Bartlett00:01:33

If this continues, what does the future look like?

Ed Zitron00:01:37

Fuck.

Advertisement00:01:41
Steven Bartlett00:02:16

Ed Zitron, there are a number of things that you believe that a lot of other people don't believe.

Ed Zitron00:02:22

Right.

Steven Bartlett00:02:22

You have, I think, a couple of controversial opinions, and opinions that are in contrast to the other guests that I've sat here with. What exactly are those opinions, Ed?

Ed Zitron00:02:33

I think generative AI is at its heart con. I don't think it is sold as honest software. I think that they overstate both what it can do, what it will do, and the underlying financials to the point that they are misleading the entire world. And they're actively exploiting the weaknesses in journalism, in our economies, and indeed within the responsible parties with sell-side analysts, governments, and all over the shop.

Steven Bartlett00:02:57

The word "con" is a strong word.

Ed Zitron00:02:59

Yeah, I mean, what do you call something where, from the very beginning, they've sold it in the terms of magic as this thing that will replace all jobs, that will cure cancers, all of these things? And when you look at it, it's boring cloud software that's extremely expensive and unprofitable and also unreliable at its core.

Steven Bartlett00:03:17

People will be asking, "Where are you drawing from in terms of your references, your personal experiences? Where were you educated, what you study, what you write about?" What do you do, Ed?

Ed Zitron00:03:24

So that's the funny thing is people say, "He's not got a finance experience. He's not got a tech." I've been in the tech industry for 15, 16 years now. NPR, but still had practical experience. And I love technology, and I'm enthusiastic about it. And this thing just comes along that everyone is telling me is the best thing since sliced bread. It can't even do the basics. It can't even do search well. Whenever you ask an AI person, "Well, what's your setup?" they describe this pee-wees playhouse thing of like, "Well, you've got to harness here, and you've got to use the right prompt." Well, you don't want to use that prompt. You want to use this prompt here with this model, but don't use this model for the beginning.

But at the end, you're going to want to use this model. And this is meant to be artificial intelligence. It's meant to be smart. It's meant to be autonomous. It's meant to be something that you set and forget.

Steven Bartlett00:04:06

We have the sort of six leading AI companies on the table here: Anthropic, Amazon, Nvidia, Microsoft, OpenAI, Google. You're saying that their fundamental business model is a con.

Ed Zitron00:04:17

Well, their revenues are not really coming from AI. Up until fairly recently, none of their revenues were coming from AI, like dribbles of it. Right now, 70% of all AI revenues across those three companies are from OpenAI and Anthropic to unprofitable, unsustainable companies that literally cannot afford to exist without these very same companies giving them money. Amazon sent $50 billion to OpenAI this year. They sent $5 billion to Anthropic. Google sent $10 billion to Anthropic. And in the next three and a half years, OpenAI and Anthropic, based on actual sell-side analysts' evaluations, their estimates that inform whether a stock is going to go up or down after earnings, they're expecting $400 or more billion of revenue.

30 or something percent of cloud growth just from these two unprofitable companies that will need to be given the money from somewhere. And on top of that, these companies have such low respect for the average investor, for the analysts, for everyone, really, that they don't even disclose their AI revenues. The few times they deign us worthy, they use something called a run rate, an annualized run rate, which means, well, nothing. They never define it. It can mean month times 12. It can mean month times 13. It can mean last four weeks times 13. It's different every time, and they never define it.

And then they sometimes just don't mention it. So you've got this big thing that is meant to be the biggest, most influential change to software ever. And whenever you ask them about it, when you say, "What? How much are you making from this?" they go, "Oh, I couldn't possibly say. I'm too shy." These are public companies, or at least the ones that aren't Anthropic and OpenAI. When they have good news, they'll tell you. And when they don't tell you something, well, that actually speaks volumes.

Steven Bartlett00:05:55

Have you used these tools?

Ed Zitron00:05:57

Yes.

Steven Bartlett00:05:57

The AI tools: Gemini, Anthropic, ChatGPT, etc. And you found no value in them.

Ed Zitron00:06:02

There's some value, but it's not... They have spent over a trillion dollars in capex.

Steven Bartlett00:06:07

What does capex mean for you?

Ed Zitron00:06:08

Capital expenditures. So when you are a business and you have operating expenses, like electricity, for example, those come right off immediately. Capital expenditures are long-term investments that are theoretically one-off, so a data center, or indeed the GPUs you put inside an AI data center.

Steven Bartlett00:06:23

Okay, so you've got a data center, and then you have these GPUs, which are like computer chips.

Ed Zitron00:06:28

So AI GPUs are much bigger, much more power-intensive. They take a bunch of high-bandwidth memory. And because of how many of them you need, you need thousands of them, tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands in some case, you need a bunch of power. So an example: OpenAI and Oracle are building a data center in Texas, in Abilene, Texas, 1.2 gigawatts, called Stargate Abilene. Within that, with each one of the eight buildings, there'll be 50,000 Nvidia GB200 GPUs. So the city of Bristol takes about 780, 800 megawatts of power a year, right?

Well, Stargate Abilene is condensing more power than that, 1.2 gigawatts, into a space around 1,172 times smaller. The city of Bristol is about 1.2 billion square feet. Stargate Abilene is about 998,000. So you're condensing all of this power, all of this money, all of this labor into this one spot. And all of these data centers cost billions of dollars. All of these companies, other than Microsoft, are now to take out debt. And the thing is, they've spent over a trillion dollars so far, and they want to spend another trillion dollars next year.

And for what? To make tens of billions of dollars, most of which comes from two unprofitable companies, Anthropic and OpenAI.

Steven Bartlett00:07:42

One of the rebuttals to that would be that the adoption, the customer adoption of people using OpenAI and Anthropic has been absolutely insane. These are the fastest-growing products in all of history, especially as it relates to sort of technology. If we just focus in on technology, they are, you know, hundreds and hundreds of millions of people, billions of people are using these tools every single day for things that they have subjectively decided are problems they need solving. So, you know, money is a lagging indicator of value. So one would argue that they're just investing ahead of the monetization options.

Ed Zitron00:08:16

The first, let's start with this adoption. Is it honest adoption when you are forced to use generative AI when you load Google? When you load Google Docs, Gemini screams in your ear. When you load Word, Copilot's bugging you. When you use Amazon, whatever ruthless AI is, once it has opinions on what socks you're buying. This is the largest non-consensual push of technology in history. ChatGPT, for example. Every single media outlet has been screaming about this for three years. They've been saying this will take your job.

You must use this. If you don't use this, you're going to be falling behind. So people are using it because they've been told to use it constantly, and they're using it like search predominantly. And that's partly because Google fell behind search, and also because it's better at ingesting queries sometimes. Sometimes, if you use a generative search, it's like a trawling vessel. It's not very good at specifics. But if you're like, "Does this thing exist? Has this person ever said anything like this?" it'll still probably get it wrong, but it'll scour the ocean for you. Nevertheless, that's not worth a trillion dollars. None of it is. The amount of money being sunk into this is just incomparable to anything.

Railways, it blows everything out of the water because there is no post-Bubble story even for this. AI GPUs are not useful for other things either. It's a directionless egregore of capitalism, this headless beast that lumbers around, desperate to seek out growth everywhere, in the hopes that if it harasses people and scares people and demonizes labor enough, people will be forced to use it.

Steven Bartlett00:09:50

The reason I pause is because I just, I think about my own company. Obviously, everybody thinks about their own personal situation. So you have people listening now that don't use any AI tools. Then you have people that are using it for everything, from coding, new software tools to everything they write to, you know, images, whatever. And when you look at the stats around enterprise adoption, it says 88% of organizations regularly use AI at least once for one particular business function. And I'd say in our company, 95% of people use one of these AI tools like Anthropic or ChatGPT or Gemini every day.

Ed Zitron00:10:23

Right.

Steven Bartlett00:10:23

And that exists on some kind of spectrum of like the super users that are using it probably, you know, every hour of every day for almost everything to, you know, someone maybe hiring the executive team that's using it less because their job doesn't require of it as much.

Ed Zitron00:10:37

Right.

Steven Bartlett00:10:38

And when you look out into the world, you know, at how the world is changing from a content perspective, if we're looking at generative AI, it is obvious that these tools are being widely adopted. Part of the symptom is the AI slop you see all over the internet.

Ed Zitron00:10:52

Right.

Steven Bartlett00:10:53

So I don't know, this idea that it's not being used, I struggle with.

Ed Zitron00:10:59

It's being used. Here's the thing with the slop. Before we had AI slop, we had SEO slop because Google incentivized doing the lowest common denominator that would rank well in search. There's a whole story about how they pulled back spam guards thanks to Prabhakar Raghavan, which we can get into, where they made the internet worse by allowing worse content to rank higher. It's why we had, when you used to Google, our best washing machine. There's 11 different horrible blogs that read like somebody got a concussion. They are built to rank rather than be read by humans or built to be made good.

So AI helps weaponize that at scale. Yeah, you can make a bunch of generic slop. We've had slop for years. We've just found a slop machine. But then also there's the problem of cost. So when you use AI services, you burn tokens, and it's per million tokens.

Steven Bartlett00:11:47

What's a token?

Ed Zitron00:11:48

So it's around three-quarters of a word. So it's characters.

Steven Bartlett00:11:52

So the AI companies have a currency in which they charge you, like a taxi in New York has a meter.

Ed Zitron00:11:57

Yeah.

Steven Bartlett00:11:57

And they call it tokens.

Ed Zitron00:11:59

Yeah.

Steven Bartlett00:12:00

And every word, let's just say for ease, it's a word. You're paying per word.

Ed Zitron00:12:04

About a word, yeah. And it's per million tokens. So you'll be charged per million input tokens, the stuff you feed into it, like a document or a code base. And the output tokens are both the stuff it spits out at the end, but also when it thinks. So, okay, you've asked me to give you the best restaurants in this area of New York. I should find the best restaurants in New York. All of that's output tokens as well. However, when you're paying for a monthly service, you don't see any of that. Put all that crap to the side. They just have rate limits. You can use them a certain amount, and then when you run out, but they kind of obfuscate what that was.

Now, someone recently found, semi-analysis actually found this, a big analyst group, they found that on a $200 a month ChatGPT subscription, you can burn $14,000 worth of tokens. And on Anthropic, you can burn $8,000 for 200 bucks. That is how most, and even on the 20 buck a month service, you can burn $400. Now, most people don't realize that. Most people have no idea what AI costs. Most people just think, "Oh, it's 20 bucks a month." No, all of these companies run at a horrifying loss.

OpenAI lost $20.9 billion last year because people can burn as many tokens as they want. And when they tried to move everybody on the enterprise side, so companies bigger than 150, onto actually paying the cost of AI in around March of 2026, to quote Sam Altman, they said, "People have a big problem with it. I think it's a huge issue," which is not really what the air apparent of Tech's history is meant to be saying. But the point is, enterprises immediately started freaking out. Uber burned through their entire annual token budget in three months.

So suddenly, after everyone's saying AI is the most productive thing ever, it's amazing, it's changing everything. The moment people actually had to pay for it, they go, "Oof, I don't know, actually. Maybe it's, it's obviously we all love it. It's all great, right? But it's costing too much. We now need to reduce the cost because people are just dumping stuff into it, being like, 'What do I do here?' and getting whatever the median is out because that's what these things do. They provide the median answer.

Steven Bartlett00:14:06

So essentially, someone like me who's a power user of these tools, I could be costing Anthropic or OpenAI $1,000, but they're only charging me $100, let's say. So they are having to subsidize $900 of my usage because of the electricity costs and the costs at their data centers. And so your assertion here is that that is unsustainable.

Ed Zitron00:14:27

Yes. And just to be clear, they're probably not one for $1, it might be 30 for... We don't know. I think it's unprofitable. These companies don't disclose them. Even in their audited financials, they play funny games with how they categorize things. But nevertheless, yes. And on top of that, the way that you stand up inference, which is the thing that creates the output within these data centers, you're not just saying, "Okay, turn the inference machine on, let's go." You are standing up the GPUs necessary to take in the demand. And if you buy too much, you've wasted the money.

You have to pay for the hourly GPU use regardless. If you buy too few, your customers can't use it. They get pissed off at you. They cancel. They go with someone else. But nevertheless, yeah, they would get demand selling $20 or $40 for a dollar. And that's what these services do. And really, the simplest way to explain it is they were actually profitable if they were actually just, they believed that these services were worthwhile and that they were worthy of the cost, they'd charge it. Regular people wouldn't be able to get a monthly subscription. They'd just be paying what it's worth. Unless, of course, there was an economic problem.

And it's very simple. You pay when you use an LLM, regardless of whether you get what you want. When these things hallucinate, say you're doing something, you're coding something, and they go through a code base and they fuck up a bunch of stuff and they break a bunch of stuff, you're paying for that. You're paying for it, whether it works or not, unless, of course, you're using one of these subscriptions.

Steven Bartlett00:15:48

I think the really interesting point is, are they spending ahead of the value showing up, which is, I imagine, what they would argue, or are they spending all of this money and subsidizing all of their users in a way that's unsustainable and that will never be justified? Like, does it, you know, because you think back through the history of technology, you often get people losing money to grab market share.

Ed Zitron00:16:14

Right.

Steven Bartlett00:16:15

And they're also focusing on bringing the costs down and making it more profitable for them as well, but they can't afford to underinvest.

Ed Zitron00:16:24

If they were bringing the cost down, they would have brought the cost down, which they have not. It seems to be getting more expensive. In fact, everyone inference providers don't seem to be profitable. Even the companies renting out GPUs don't seem to be profitable. I imagine that it wasn't like they started out and they were like, "Shit, this is unprofitable." At the beginning, we know it, screw it. We'll keep doing it anyway. We'll screw it. I don't think it's some big conspiracy. They probably thought at some point, "Yeah, this will go profitable. The chips will catch up. Customers will pay for the overwhelming value." Because you don't know in 2023 where it's going to be in 2026.

You assume it's going to go up. That's the nature of venture capital. They should have stopped in like 2024 when OpenAI lost over $5 billion. They should have been like, "Yep, this is not going to work." But they kept going because it helped number go up so much. It helped stock values pump. It helped everyone pump. It helped Nvidia pump, Microsoft, everyone. And not from the revenues. Because here's the funny thing about Google, Microsoft, and Amazon. People for years have been saying their AI bets have paid off. Wow, their AI bets have paid off. As these companies refuse to say how much they're making from AI.

But because their existing businesses continued to grow and did so, by the way, through price increases, changes to how Google and Meta did advertising, Amazon bumped up prices and changed how they did. Actually, Amazon started a remarkable ad business during this whole time as well, and the selling through Amazon platform. Anyway, nothing to do with AI, but because number go up, because revenue go up, everyone went, "It's AI." Because these companies wouldn't spend a trillion dollars for no reason, right? Except in fiscal year 2026, which just ended for Microsoft.

Annoying, I know. They made total, according to Bloomberg, about $34.33 billion. $24.1 billion of that was from OpenAI. So that leaves them with about $10 billion in a year when they spent $115 billion on capital expenditures and then tend to spend $175 billion next year. The math does not make sense. I imagine their plan was, "Okay, this is just going to get exponentially more valuable, and at some point, the costs will be outpaced by the return." Problem is that large language models need a bunch of money to train them.

They need constant data flows to it. They need customized data. It's just this big expensive monster. And when you try and talk to people about it, and you try and say, "Hey, look, this is really bad. Nvidia has sold," it was $215.9 billion in the last fiscal year worth of GPUs mostly. And you try and go, "Yeah, that's to support like $22 billion of revenue total in the entire world outside of these two companies that literally require money being fed into them, sometimes by Nvidia to keep alive."

When you tell people that, they go, "Well, companies just lose money, right?" Companies, because we have this, quote Ed Ellison from Profit G Markets, we have this cult-like worship of the wealthy, where we think that someone wouldn't spend all this money for no reason, right? Because reconciling with that, with this idea that the ultra-wealthy, the ultra-powerful didn't get there through big brains, they didn't get there through anything other than luck and opportunism and getting an MBA perhaps of the right people, that they just got there because they're regular people and they just happened to be in the right place at the right time.

Reconciling with that and realizing that the world is not controlled by people like a meritocracy is kind of grim. So it's easy to be like, "No, they're not making a mistake. I must be missing something." And that's what they want.

Steven Bartlett00:19:48

So, you know, I think back through the history of technological breakthroughs, and I think about, I mean, you can look at different industries. And one of my favorite books on this subject is The Innovator's Dilemma.

Ed Zitron00:19:57

I'll read it.

Steven Bartlett00:19:57

And one of the things it talks about is how the innovation that ends up taking out or transforming an industry often starts worse, doesn't make economic sense, none of your customers are asking for it. And this is typically why we end up ignoring it. So like, you've got horse and carriages in the 1800s, amazing form of transport according to the 1800s, you know, people of the 1800s. And then you have this thing called cars come along. Now, the problem with cars is they broke down all the time. It's kind of like AI hallucinates now. They were more expensive and the economics of it didn't make sense.

You might as well walk than buy a car. There was a law at the time that meant you had to walk in front of it with a red flag and wave, and someone had to employ someone to walk in front of it waving a red flag. Obviously, it's worse. It's like a worse solution. However, these things that are disruptive innovations, they have a higher ceiling of growth. And so they eventually overtake the horse. And when I think about that analogy in the context of all of this, I go, "Okay, it's imperfect at the moment. The economic models aren't perfectly ironed out. They're still figuring out how to make it cheaper, the infrastructure, et cetera."

But if you think about the rate of improvement versus other, you know, let's say coding, how much can I train a human coder to improve and to increase their output versus an AI agent? One would go, if you just imagine any rate of improvement in these AI tools, at some point, if you just imagine a 5% rate of improvement per month, at some point, it's, you know, and then you imagine a 5% reduction in cost, which is what we did with the internet, what we did with cars.

Ed Zitron00:21:28

Yeah, but that's.

Steven Bartlett00:21:28

Moore's law.

Ed Zitron00:21:29

Moore's law is a theory, and Moore's law is not with GPUs. So let me actually explain something.

Steven Bartlett00:21:34

Nvidia.

Ed Zitron00:21:35

Nvidia invented, I think it was in the 2000s, they put out something called CUDA, which is the underlying software library and the way to run software on GPUs. Took them a solid decade or more to make it something where they could do data analytics, one of the early things, mapper and such. And then when AI came along, they'd had lots of experience with it. But nevertheless, this company has got more money, more attention, more geniuses behind them, more people focused on making their things more efficient than anyone could ever ask for.

Steven Bartlett00:22:04

And Nvidia, for anyone that doesn't know, makes the chips.

Ed Zitron00:22:07

So, and that CUDA thing I mentioned, they were the ones with CUDA, and CUDA allowed generative AI to grow.

Steven Bartlett00:22:12

Okay, so they're chips.

Ed Zitron00:22:14

Chips, yes.

Steven Bartlett00:22:14

And chips are needed. Those are the things that go into the data centers.

Ed Zitron00:22:17

And their specific chips are the ones where you can run AI software on it. So the training runs and also the inference. Now, here's the thing, the car example. Back then, you didn't have pretty much every mathematician and scientist going into the car industry. You didn't have the combined world's governments never shutting up about this. And by the way, giving them credit early, since 2023, they've been saying this is inevitable. Even in what you said, 5% improvement, I don't even know how you'd measure that because a junior software engineer can still experience things and learn things from context, from how people deal with problems.

And the way that people deal with problems is not as simple as looking at the code or reading some emails. It's context cues from speaking to a person. It's being in different environments. And there are uses for LLMs in coding. I don't dispute that. But even saying 5%, what does that mean? Is it better at Rust? Is it better at C++?

Steven Bartlett00:23:10

I'd say productivity. So just like, yeah, shipped. If we did it in the context of coding, it would be like shipped code.

Ed Zitron00:23:16

That's the thing. That would be like, "He's the best writer in the world because his newsletter's really long." That's an insane way of valuing it. With coding, it would be, I mean, it's even difficult to evaluate because it's, "Is the software out there better?" is actually a great way of evaluating it. And I would say, uniformly not. I would say the standard of software across Google, Microsoft, Amazon, Meta, especially, God, Meta's a monstrosity, is worse. GitHub, someone posted on Twitter earlier today, "We should get a notification when GitHub is up rather than when it's down because that would be more reliable."

Microsoft is one of the largest companies in the world, and they can barely wipe their own ass when it comes to GitHub. The quality of software is going down. Weirdly enough, as more people use LLMs and more businesses demand, and I really do mean demand, that people use these services.

Steven Bartlett00:24:03

So on this point of, if we go back to this horse and carriage and car analogy, say that we're at whatever point today, if you imagine any rate of improvement in the technology, which we have seen since ChatGPT came out.

Ed Zitron00:24:14

Sure.

Steven Bartlett00:24:14

I remember when ChatGPT came out and I was in Asia, and I was there showing it to my fiancée. I was like, "Look, it can do this." And it was hallucinating once in a while and getting things wrong. I actually don't have that experience anymore. I have moments where I believe its reasoning is weak, but I don't have outright hallucinations anymore.

Ed Zitron00:24:31

See, I disagree.

Steven Bartlett00:24:34

Give me an example of what you define as a hallucination.

Ed Zitron00:24:36

Okay, great one. So I have a Bloomberg terminal.

Steven Bartlett00:24:38

Yeah.

Ed Zitron00:24:38

The very useful thing they have on there is Ask B. So when you do a Bloomberg inquiry to like look up what we think Nvidia's revenue is going to be next quarter, it runs something called BQL, which is its own programming language. Now, instead of having to learn that, you can just type into Ask B and it will generate it and run it for you. And so you get it pulled up and you know where the data is coming from. Deals with hallucinations real well. The other day I was like, "You know what? Get a little spicy. I'm going to look up the growth rate of stocks of Microsoft, Google, Meta, and Amazon over the course of five years," I think it was.

Steven Bartlett00:25:09

Yeah.

Ed Zitron00:25:10

And I was about to, I was copy-pasted it over to something, looked at it in Excel, and I was about to, it was right in the newsletter. I went, "Microsoft stocks never been $575 a stock." You know what? When it's a cute little thing like, "Oh, it's a stock price and I kind of caught it, it was no harm, no foul," that's fine. But when you're talking about, I don't know, like a transcribing tool for a doctor or a financial model that a hedge fund is dependent on, at that point, it becomes a little more dangerous. And the thing is, a hallucination with a software package, for example, refactoring a code base, and it leaves a door open security-wise, or it just breaks something.

And you, I don't know, maybe you've been vibe coding for six months, you haven't really been coding with your own hands for a while, maybe you've forgotten a few things. You had this slot to look for and you go, "Fucking hell, why am I doing it?" And so the problems become multiplicative. And I don't really know how you train them out of that, and they've certainly not succeeded. So on one hand, they have got better, but one of the main ways they evaluate them getting better are benchmarks that are adjusted specifically for large language models, because you can't just have them do tasks.

They've got better at that. They found some tasks they can have them do on. But even them like Meta, METR, they have this thing where it's like, "Check out this chart. Look how much better it's getting at running tasks. Wow, it can go for an hour." And then you look, it's like, "Yeah," and successfully completing them 50% of the time.

Steven Bartlett00:26:34

They have a hallucination leaderboard, and it really focuses on basic tasks. And it shows that the four-year trend according to historical data from the Vectaria Hallucination Leaderboard shows that hallucination rates on simple summarization tasks have plummeted from around 21%, 21.8% four years ago, down to 0.7% roughly on today's top frontier models like Gemini and ChatGPT. Again, the point of nuance here is that these are on simple tasks, which is kind of what I've experienced. I've experienced that on day-to-day things that hallucinates less.

Again, rate of improvement thinking. So if I just imagine the trajectory to continue, there is going to become a time where hallucinations become rarer than they are today, increasingly. And also what I would say is when I think about other technologies, there's two more points. Other technologies at their inception, when they first came to the world, like the internet, also had technical difficulties. I remember growing up with dial-up modems, and I couldn't go on the phone at the same time as going on the internet. I'd have to stop RuneScape upstairs to go on the phone. And you thought, "This is crap. This is crap.

Technology's crap."

Ed Zitron00:27:37

I don't know, mate. I loved it.

Steven Bartlett00:27:39

Yeah, I know. It felt like magic. And then in hindsight, you go, "Wow, I now have Starlink and 5G internet from my phone. It's unbelievable." You couldn't leave the house with internet before. And that's what I mean by the rate of improvement thinking. I'd say the last point is we often compare AI to perfection.

Ed Zitron00:27:57

Right.

Steven Bartlett00:27:58

Whereas that's not actually the alternative. In the working world, like if I wanted to do, let's say, a simple writing task, I should compare AI to my alternative way of doing that simple writing task, which is both measured in my time, right, and my ability to hallucinate as a person who doesn't know everything, or if I'm hiring someone, an intern, who might also be prone to hallucination or have gaps in their knowledge. So it's not actually like we're comparing, we should compare AI to perfection. It's AI to the other alternatives.

And if someone hallucinates 0.7% of the time, but knows way more and is faster, maybe on a net basis, that's a good trade. Maybe I should use AI.

Ed Zitron00:28:38

So let's start with an example, someone I love dearly, Matt Hughes, my editor.

Steven Bartlett00:28:43

Yeah.

Ed Zitron00:28:43

He lives out of Liverpool, wonderful guy. I don't pay Matt Hughes because he knows everything. I pay him because he has incredible context and a ton of knowledge, and he's willing to expand it and work with me and moral support. And he's a great editor, but he's also someone who gets into the guts of it and has the experiences of it. He's a decorated tech journalist, and on top of that, a wonderful loving being with empathy and joy in his heart for the stuff he loves and absolute fucking venom for the people he hates. I can't get that from a large language model, but on top of that, I push back on just the assumption there.

When you say knows everything, what good is something that knows everything when it sometimes doesn't know anything? When it sometimes, and the thing is, are you really paying an intern for something basic? Are you really going to them and saying, "Yeah, can you look up what the date is?" No, you're doing that on Google. Whatever the task is, you are trying to also train an intern. The point of an intern is to train them and turn them in, take them out of Pinocchio status. But it's also an intern learns. An intern gets context. An intern learns your habits.

Steven Bartlett00:29:46

And AI gets context and learns.

Ed Zitron00:29:47

No, it doesn't.

Steven Bartlett00:29:48

AI doesn't learn.

Ed Zitron00:29:49

I mean, it doesn't. The way it learns is you create a giant Claude.md file that it sometimes doesn't read, sometimes does read. You create a harness. It's like it's Peewee's breakfast machine from Peewee's playhouse. You have to do all these controversies to mitigate the hallucinations. And even then at the end, how much effort have you put in?

Steven Bartlett00:30:08

But so, okay, this is an extreme simplified example. If I went on my Claude now and said, "What's my dog's name?" It would know my dog's name.

Ed Zitron00:30:15

Jesus Christ. This company raised $95 billion this year.

Steven Bartlett00:30:18

No, but you know what I'm saying? I'm using an extreme simplified example to show that it can remember things from the past. Obviously, it knows much more complex things as well, but I just use that as an example. So we accept the fact that it does have memory of the past.

Ed Zitron00:30:30

It has files it can access that have stuff on it, but that's not the same as memory. And it's also just, okay, so it remembers your dog's name. It might remember your habits. It might be able to read things you've said before. Does it know your moods? Does it know what's going on in the world around it? Does it have good days and bad days? Is it there for you? Because it's just a fucking text machine. And the thing is, the intern example, an intern is something that can grow. It's something that you invest in. That's not something you do through feeding files and text to it. The way that we store memories ourselves, the way in which we accrue experiences, is a milestone of emotion and feelings and facts.

Steven Bartlett00:31:10

Completely different. So I think there's two things here. There's the process in which something happens, and then there's the output. So the process, you were describing the process of how a human does memory.

Ed Zitron00:31:20

Right.

Steven Bartlett00:31:20

The way that an AI does memory is different, but the thing that people care about is their value in the output. I.e., you know, if I dump all of my files into Claude, I don't really care how it processes it. As long as when I ask it, "What's my revenue?" it has the number. And one could say the same thing about training someone. You could say, you teach them, you put lots of effort into them, you give them lots of context, you educate them and give them experiences, and then you might come and say to them, "By the way, what's my revenue?" Now, the processes are entirely different, but the outcome is what I care about.

Do they know the revenue number when I ask them? And so I think that's the part that we sometimes get lost in. We get, you know, because I've heard this debate about like, can AI be creative?

Ed Zitron00:31:59

Right.

Steven Bartlett00:31:59

I think like the way to answer that question is like, it's about the output. When I ask it to do a creative thing, does it give me the answer? Not, is the process the same as a human process? Because actually, who cares what the... People care about, they pay for the outcome, the product.

Ed Zitron00:32:14

I actually disagree about the process because Matt Hughes, for example.

Steven Bartlett00:32:19

Your editor.

Ed Zitron00:32:20

Yeah.

Steven Bartlett00:32:20

Yeah.

Ed Zitron00:32:20

Watching him go down a rabbit hole and being there with him, and actually vice versa, him doing the same thing. We wrote these, well, I mean, we were working on the research. I ended up sitting there for like the day-long session of writing 11,000 words, and he had given me a bunch of notes. It was actually just, even describing that process, I feel so happy because it was like us being like, "I can't believe how fuck these guys, Jesus Christ, they can't." Like just like the misanthropy of just the horrible, cynical people of asset managers like Blackstone, just learning about them and being like, "It can't be this," and having a back and forth with him.

That is fundamentally different because we were both learning together, and the learning process was as much about creating the output as the output itself. When you learn something, you're not creating the average, which really is what these things do, of the documents it could find. You're not getting particularly novel outputs. If I needed a generic slop output, sure, but I've used some of the higher-end LLM harness machines that the hedge funds use, and they all give the same shite. It's all the same generic reports, the same, "Oh, we noticed this analysis," things that you can find on any kind of AI slop out there.

Steven Bartlett00:33:28

What you described to me there, what I heard anyway, is there's two points of value you're getting from your time with that. I mean, there's many more, but you said you're learning, and then you're getting this book edited.

Ed Zitron00:33:38

Blog.

Steven Bartlett00:33:38

Blog. You're getting a blog edited, which is the output, and you're getting learning, and you're also really getting connection and all these other things.

Ed Zitron00:33:44

Yeah, exactly.

Steven Bartlett00:33:45

But when I come to, when people sort of think about the value of AI, of course they could use it to learn, but in the example I gave of like, "Repeat my revenue number back to me," or, "Do this number," I just care about the output. I could use it to learn. I could say it's far with me.

Ed Zitron00:33:56

What if the revenue number was wrong once? You should have defined deterministic ways of knowing those numbers. You should not rely on them. Even with the terminal running BQL, which I trust, I will double, triple check everything just to be sure. Partly because also the process of learning for me, I don't want just a report I go like that. I want something that I fully understand and also understand the context around it. I don't think that LLMs do that, and I just don't see them getting better in a way that does that because it's just not what they do.

And also there's the other problem of the more detailed the report, the more likely there are things to be wrong with it. If you are with Matt Hughes, for example, I can trust he's got it right. I can trust he understood, and I can trust that I can have a back and forth with him that will inform me if I've missed something. I can read the stuff that he's read and actually trust him because there's a big trust part as well.

Steven Bartlett00:34:50

What is the basis of your trust in Matt? Could it be his historical performance?

Ed Zitron00:34:56

I mean, yes.

Steven Bartlett00:34:57

Okay.

Ed Zitron00:34:57

And also the fact we've learned half of this stuff together.

Steven Bartlett00:35:00

But tenure doesn't necessarily, there's probably people you know for 15 years who you also don't trust.

Ed Zitron00:35:05

Yes.

Steven Bartlett00:35:05

So I think I was trying to figure out like, what is the thing that's causing humans to trust another thing? And I guess it would be continual delivery of a commitment made of sorts. And so with Claude, for example, on simple tasks, as we've seen from this hallucination leaderboard, it continually delivers for people. And that's why we've seen the fastest.

Ed Zitron00:35:24

I mean, is that what that board says?

Steven Bartlett00:35:25

Well, it's saying like, is it getting it wrong? Is it hallucinating?

Ed Zitron00:35:28

On simple tasks.

Steven Bartlett00:35:29

Simple tasks.

Ed Zitron00:35:30

How are those defined?

Steven Bartlett00:35:31

I don't know.

Ed Zitron00:35:31

That's the thing though, because this is actually a very illustrative thing of the AI industry. They are the whataboutist masters. They have like, "Well, look, we've got this benchmark that says we're good at this. And look, the number's higher. What's the number mean?" What does that mean? And I'm not using this as a critique against you. It's when you can't give a direct answer, you give a side answer. When you as the LLM industry want to prove your worth, you can't just be like, "Just use the product." When the first iPhone came out, of course, Penn State at the time, "Oh, I felt like the apes at the beginning of 2001."

I was like, "Fucking official voicemail." It was immediate. And I showed it to tech friends. I showed it to the most normal people in the world. And everyone was like, "Holy shit, this is," they were on Razors, they were on Nokia 3210s. It was obvious the value. Amazon Web Services, same deal.

Steven Bartlett00:36:19

It wasn't obvious though.

Ed Zitron00:36:20

Yes, it was. I mean, I bought it.

Steven Bartlett00:36:22

To you, it was.

Ed Zitron00:36:23

It was. And I also showed it to a bunch of people because I'm aware that I have bias when I just love gadgets.

Steven Bartlett00:36:28

But I remember the famous Steve Ballmer, who was the CEO of Microsoft, interview where he was told about the iPhone, and he bursts out laughing.

Speaker 300:36:40

$500 fully subsidized with a plan. I said, "That is the most expensive phone in the world, and it doesn't appeal to business customers because it doesn't have a keyboard, which makes it not a very good email machine." You can get a Motorola Q Phone now for $99. It's a very capable machine. It'll do music, it'll do internet, it'll do email, it'll do instant messaging. So I kind of look at that and I say, "Well, I like our strategy. I like it a lot."

Steven Bartlett00:37:10

He burst out laughing, mocking you.

Ed Zitron00:37:11

Yeah.

Steven Bartlett00:37:11

Because it was so disruptive. It was way more expensive, and it was way different. No keyboard.

Ed Zitron00:37:17

Well, phones used to be insanely expensive, and the carriers would cover them, but you had to sign a long contract. You were still spending 500 bucks. But the thing I'm getting at is you didn't have to explain to someone what perhaps you'd have to get past the cost part, but you could just be like, "Look how good this is." And then once the app was the iPhone 3G with the App Store, people were like, "Oh shit, this could actually change things." Mobile web, even though it was a monstrosity, it was so bad at first. Even then, you could get your emails and you could just look at them. Point is, Blackberries are also expensive and were still actually kind of cool, but the way they worked was not like consumer software.

They didn't have the classic GUI. iPhones felt like that. It felt like a cell phone designed even like a computer. It was obvious. It was obvious in the beginning. Everyone, I was dating a girl in the center of Pennsylvania at the time, and everyone I showed it to was like, "Wow, this is incredible." That to me is the obvious thing. With AI to this day, when you're like, "Okay, why is it so amazing?" People still differ. People are still like, "Yeah, you can't run a business fully with it without this weird system of pulleys and levers and such."

Steven Bartlett00:38:17

But how come then when you look at the stats around ChatGPT's growth, 100 million active users in just the first 60 days after launching? For comparison, TikTok took nine months, Instagram took 2.5 years, and the internet itself, the World Wide Web, took roughly seven years to reach that scale. Over 60% of the US adults are integrated into AI tools in their daily and regular routines within three years of the launch, reaching 40% of the population. And that same milestone took the internet five years and personal computers nearly 12.

Ed Zitron00:38:48

Okay.

Steven Bartlett00:38:48

So like this is the, I think this is the part that's giving me dissonance is like when I showed my fiance ChatGPT, okay, it didn't really work. But as a sole entrepreneur who English isn't her first language, who has to write lots of text, lots of copy and generate lots of images, and was paying a graphic designer to help her make certain images that she, you know, couldn't make herself because she doesn't have the skills, she would describe it as being transformative for her business. What I'm hearing from you is that it's not transformative and there's no value in it for people.

But if she was sat here now, she could get transformative.

Ed Zitron00:39:22

Would she pay the per million token rate? Would she pay the actual rate? Because that's the thing. If this was sold at its honest cost, I would actually, and people were reacting like that and they were paying $2, $3, $4 every time they did something and they were genuinely happy, that might be an argument.

Steven Bartlett00:39:36

What would be the honest cost if they weren't subsidizing?

Ed Zitron00:39:38

The actual per million token cost, the actual API cost, they should charge.

Steven Bartlett00:39:42

Do you know how much that is relative to what they charge?

Ed Zitron00:39:45

It depends on the model. But there's actually kind of a point I want to make about the thing you said with the internet earlier. So when I first got on the internet, a 33.4 kilobit second modem, even back then I was like, "Fuck, if this was faster." And that was like immediate, just like, "If this was faster," because it was slow, you go and like happy puppy or something, download, take all bloody day waiting for shareware to download. Immediately you're like, "If I could do this faster, it would be better." And even back then I'm like, "Man, you could probably do video camera stuff with this." Stuff that eventually happened.

And actually there's this guy called Jim Cavello from Goldman Sachs in a report he did in 2024 that was Gen AI, too much spend for not enough return. Paraphrasing there. And he made the point that in the run-up to the iPhone, there was thousands of presentations that when GSM radios get smaller, when Bluetooth radios get smaller, when Wi-Fi radios get smaller, it is inevitable that we will get something like this. And then he said that there is no such path for AI. There was no roadmap to AI becoming this thing that they promised. And I must be clear, if these companies had gone out there and they're like, "Yeah, this is interesting cloud software, it's generative, it's really expensive.

We're not sure if we can fully, not trust it, not in the all one scared way." I mean, just like, "We're not sure that this is going to be a disruptive, world-changing thing. It has potential, but we're going to go slow. It's really expensive. This is an R&D effort. We're not going to expose consumers to it and actually beat like, call them like, I don't know, language models and no generative AI stuff, just being, not even calling it because it isn't AI. It's not autonomous. It's not smart. I actually might respect it, but this is not, they've gone out there since 2023 and said, it was 2022, "This is the best thing since sliced bread.

This is changing everything. This is going to do all your work. This is going to take your job. You're going to talk to Bing and it's going to tell you to leave your wife." All of these crazy things. And what's funny is when the writer, Kevin Root, I think it was, he was speaking to Kevin Scott, the CTO of Microsoft about it. And Kevin Scott goes, "You know, I'm just glad we're having this conversation." Instead of being like, "Settle down, Beavis. It's a website. The website told you something. It's just LLMs." They talked it up. And that's because everyone is talking about what they wish this was rather than talking about what it can actually do.

This makes it scary to people, deliberately so. It makes it environmentally destructive. Look at the gas turbines poisoning black neighborhoods. I think it's in Louisiana. It's one of Musk's data centers. Look at the incredible energy draws. It is raising power bills. And also, it is creating inflation across all consumer electronics because of the massive RAM demand.

Steven Bartlett00:42:15

You know what's interesting? I almost feel like so much of what you're saying is true. And also, it can be true that this technology is going to profoundly change the world. And I think like, you know, I think back to the early days of the internet is maybe the closest analogy we have of, you know, in the dot-com bubble. You know, you wrote this great essay.

Ed Zitron00:42:36

Oh, yes, yes.

Steven Bartlett00:42:37

Which I found really funny, especially the name. The rot economy. And you talked about the rot com bubble.

Ed Zitron00:42:44

Yes.

Steven Bartlett00:42:44

Talking about how AI is of less value than people think. And in the sort of dot-com bubble, what you saw is huge hype, people overselling the capabilities of their websites and what they were building. But in the wake of the dot-com bubble, yes, 90% of stuff went to zero, but you had generational companies born that changed the world.

Ed Zitron00:43:07

Right.

Steven Bartlett00:43:07

And so I do, I kind of, and that's what bubbles do, right? Huge hype, overinvestment, investors get crazy delusional, they think everything's going to change. At the same time, you do have skeptics in these moments. The dot-com bubble had, I mean, the internet itself had the biggest skeptics. In 1998, Nobel Prize-winning economist Paul Krugman said, "By 2005 or so, it will become clear that the internet's impact on the economy has been no greater than the fax machine." In 1995, astrophysicist Clifford Stuart, famously, I wrote about this in my book, wrote famously in Newsweek, "Do our computer pundits lack all common sense?

The truth is no online database will replace your daily newspaper. No CD-ROM can take the place of a competent teacher. Commerce and businesses will shift from offices and malls to networks and modems." Baloney. So how come my local mall does a roaring business and the cyber mall gets zero business? And then I'll give you one more from Krugman, who was the award-winning economist. He said, "The growth of the internet will slow drastically. As it becomes apparent, most people have nothing to say to each other."

Ed Zitron00:44:15

That may actually be the worst one of those predictions. Like hang around any bar in Middle America. Honestly, the best conversation.

Steven Bartlett00:44:24

But it's just all the same thing.

Ed Zitron00:44:25

I actually, so Clifford Stuart actually, his piece was interesting because there were some boner points in it, but he made points about how like an overwhelming amount of bad information out there is bad for society. He's completely right, saying how online education would not be a great replacement for regular education. I think we've seen that. But there is an economic difference that's vastly. It's just completely different. So dot-com bubble is actually two bubbles. There was the website bubble, which was just trash on trash on trash. It was just like, I think what was it? Excite at home bought an eager eating card company for like a billion dollars.

It was insane crap happening. That was so small. The big thing that people are thinking about is the dark fiber.

Steven Bartlett00:45:04

Dark fiber.

Ed Zitron00:45:05

Dark fiber was all of the wires that put in the ground thinking, "We're going to have all this demand for internet." And it turned out that demand for internet, I think the analyst estimate was it was doubling every 90 days when it was doing that every 6 to 12 months, maybe longer. And just thus, there was a massive overbuild of fiber optic cable and indeed the transmission stations and such to simplifying to bring that to people's houses. And there was the assumption that, well, that would all get lit up and people would want it immediately. Didn't really happen. Now, the post-dot-com bubble thing people say is, "Well, but after that, there was demand from the internet."

That's the thing though. That's very different to demand for generative AI. Right now, the demand we have for generative AI is predominantly subsidized. Just let's start there.

Steven Bartlett00:45:50

Yeah.

Ed Zitron00:45:50

Predominantly subsidized and most people experience it and yet are not paying the real cost.

Steven Bartlett00:45:54

I agree.

Ed Zitron00:45:55

On top of that, we already have all of the possible marketing in the world. We have the largest, most disingenuous marketing campaign in the history of man pushing this up the hill. We have the apex predator of cloud software, Microsoft. They can only get single-digit billions from selling AI software. And Christ almighty, outside of OpenAI and Anthropic, we barely get $22 billion. And the thing is, $22 billion is a large amount to you and me. It's not a large amount of money when you spent a trillion plus dollars when you have Anthropic and OpenAI with $1.1 trillion worth of cloud commitments.

And on top of that, how does this turn into a post-dot-com bubble thing? A data center built today is going to be as expensive to run in 2050 as it is today. Unless there's some breakthrough in electricity. But again, that's not happening with AI. AI is not doing that. Unless there's some breakthrough in GPU technology. But we already have Broadcom, Nvidia etched. We have every major chip company, ARM, trying to do something about this. And no one seems to magically be able to make this profitable or indeed even less costly.

Even Nvidia with Vera Rubin, their more expensive new GPU system, even though they're like, "Yeah, 10X more efficient. It's more dollars per megawatt." They're all coy about it. They don't just say, "Yeah, we worked with OpenAI and Anthropic and we found it reduced their cost by 50%." Easiest thing in the world if it was true. And that's because it's not happening. And this isn't a case where.

Steven Bartlett00:47:22

So you're saying there's not going to be the demand for, let's say, you know, there's different types of AI, generative AI.

Ed Zitron00:47:29

Yeah, and actually that's a good point to make. The reason they use the term artificial intelligence is so everyone would lump everything into it. They would lump protein folding, nothing to do with LLMs, robotics, not LLMs, autonomous weapons, even horrible as they are, not LLMs, because you couldn't trust them. But they've mushed everything into AI so that when you say, "Well, AI can't," they'll go, "Um, um, sir, you forgot to give us homework." And also, AI, it's working on curing cancer when it's just like, "No, that's not LLMs. Stop giving them credit."

Steven Bartlett00:47:58

The similarity though is they all need GPUs or these AIs.

Ed Zitron00:48:01

And that's the funny thing. All those data centers that we're building, all of them are for just generative AI. They're not for all of the other stuff. They're not for the cool shit. AI has been around for a long time. Google, a lot of the good stuff that comes out of Google from the search side is AI, but pre-generative.

Steven Bartlett00:48:19

How would you run the type of AI that sits in a robot, let's say one of the Optimus robots, if you didn't have a GPU?

Ed Zitron00:48:27

So Matic, Matic has this cleaning robot, for example. That thing has not got a little GPU in it. What it has, and may indeed have used some GPUs, but nowhere near as many as they need for generative AI to run the data, feed training data into it so it's able to clean a house. But when the little buggers going around cleaning the floor, turdsley are called, if it goes around mopping the floor, it's not like burning money the whole time. But when it comes to these massive amounts of data centers, Sightline Climate said in February, there's 190 gigawatts of data centers under in planning, don't know about under construction.

That works out for about 12 million megawatts, like 1.6 trillion to 3 trillion dollars a year in annual demand you'd need for that. We don't even have $130 billion worth of annual demand. And people say, "Well, it will grow." How? When most of the demand is coming from Amazon feeding money to OpenAI and Anthropic, Microsoft feeding money to OpenAI and Anthropic, Google feeding money to OpenAI and Anthropic. Well, Google hasn't fed it to OpenAI yet, but they're a pretty big customer, billions of dollars. The con side is that we are building these effigies to capitalism, these giant GPU data centers, and people are being told, "Well, it's for AI."

You know, the thing that's done all this other stuff that's unrelated, or the worst thing I've seen, it's like, "Oh, you don't like, you like online banking, well, you do like data centers." There's a big difference between a data center for regular non-GPU compute for standing up a server, a content delivery system like Akamai or something that brings the website to you, or how Meta runs Facebook. That is not the same. It takes way less power, mostly CPU-driven, compared to these giant GPU data centers that offer one thing, one thing only.

Steven Bartlett00:50:03

But I was doing the research and looking at some of these notes here. It does say that for tougher types of AI systems designed to solve concrete physics, biology, and spatial problems, they require some of the most intense data center infrastructure on the planet.

Ed Zitron00:50:16

Yeah.

Steven Bartlett00:50:17

AI systems like DeepMind's AlphaFold, the protein folding company, used for genomic sequencing and climate forecasting, et cetera, run on high-performance computing clusters. These require immense precision and continuous heavy compute in data centers.

Ed Zitron00:50:30

Yeah.

Steven Bartlett00:50:31

Training the brains for self-driving cars requires billions of miles of simulated physics environments. The AI isn't generating text. It's learning to navigate 3D spaces and gravity and relies on data centers.

Ed Zitron00:50:44

Right. And the thing is, those data centers, they might have GPUs in them. We had GPUs used for this HPC, the high-performance computing, before generative AI. And yeah, that's how AI has been trained before. That's how Tesla did. I believe they've had their own data centers when it comes to training the autopilot system for better or for worse. That's how we've done it before. Again, that is not why we're building these data centers. These data centers are being built to sell to AI, generative AI companies, to either train systems or run inference.

These things are being built in this brainless way where it's just, well, actually, maybe this is a good way of illustrating the con. Because everyone saw Google, Microsoft, Amazon, and Meta give Nvidia over, call it $800 something billion. Because everyone saw that, they went, well, they wouldn't do that for no reason. They went, we've got to build more of these things. There must be all this demand. Even though the demand, 70% or more of all that demand comes from these two companies who are funded by these three companies.

And that's the funny thing. The reason that they don't want to break out their AI revenues is because it would become alarmingly obvious that this was the case. It turns out that the only real big customers, because it's not like they're building a few data centers, they're building trillion plus revenue potential they believe they'll get. Speculative, it's entirely speculative. They're building it because they saw the biggest companies in the world buy a bunch of GPUs and they said, "I want in on that." They must have diverse customers, right? They wouldn't just have two unprofitable fail sons that they're propping up with.

Christ, they've raised $217 billion just in 2026.

Steven Bartlett00:52:26

So we know that some of the biggest companies in the world are using AI, generative AI, to write a lot of their code. That is a great productivity gain for those companies, right?

Ed Zitron00:52:36

I mean, have you used Google or Facebook or Instagram or GitHub recently? Because they are catastrophically worse. Amazon Web Services went down multiple times because of their AI coding tool.

Steven Bartlett00:52:48

How is Google worse?

Ed Zitron00:52:49

Well, I'll tell the story of a real asshole, Goggle Prabhakar Raghavan. Previously, one of the heads of ads at Google, in 2019, Google called something called a code yellow, which is when they said, "We've got a problem." And it was material weakness in query numbers, which means the amount of times that people were searching on Google Search. A guy called Ben Gomes, internal at Google, then the head of Google Search, says, "Wait a minute, to increase this number of using Google more, we're going to have to, I mean, what you're suggesting would mean we give worse answers, because if someone got the answer quickly, that would reduce the amount of queries, right?"

And people at Google, Shashi Thakur was another engineer, was saying, "Yeah, can we please tell Sundar this? Because this doesn't seem good. We can't just increase the amount of queries. That would just mean that people would have to search more, which would make the product worse."

Steven Bartlett00:53:36

But it would make them more money, you say?

Ed Zitron00:53:38

Yes.

Steven Bartlett00:53:38

Because more queries means.

Ed Zitron00:53:39

And it would produce you'd show them more ads. So if you were spending more time on Google, because Google's work.

Steven Bartlett00:53:42

But is this linked to AI doing code?

Ed Zitron00:53:44

I'll get there. So this is, the problem is, is that this guy called Prabhakar Raghavan, who's the head of ads at the time, was pushing, pushing and saying, "No, we need to make more queries happen. Got to make it happen." Nick Fox, who was there as well, I believe he's actually taken over Google Search, said, "Got to make them go up. This is our new reality." Sometime in early 2020, Prabhakar Raghavan takes over Google Search. From then, and this is what I believe, can't prove it, if you go and look around the various SEO sites, such as Journal and the various forums, Google stripped back a lot of the suppression of spammy sites so that people would be on Google more.

And then over the course of time, Google wanted to create more queries and Google Search became much worse. It's why people always do like plus Reddit or from Reddit or what have you. It's because the actual underlying search results of Google had got worse. And then generative AI came along. And Prabhakar, wouldn't you know, it gets put to run part of Gemini. And Google also was having trouble getting people back on Google. And what did they think they'd do? Well, shit, everyone's talking about this AI thing. We'll just put it right at the top so people have to stay at Google. And actually, they'll use it more because instead of searching websites and doing that annoying thing where they click away from Google, they'll just only use Google.

Instead of generating answers, by which I mean giving you search results you click through, now Google is the answer. Is it right? God knows. It might tell you to eat rocks, might eat poisonous mushrooms. Maybe it'll give you a little few links you could click through. But the ideal situation was that AI was the ultimate form of Google's evil, which was.

Steven Bartlett00:55:15

But I'm saying here, I'm saying here, but that's not the fact that coders could code on Google that's made Google worse. That's human decisions have made it worse.

Ed Zitron00:55:22

Yes. And then there's the instability of Google's platform, which is actually, I should have probably led with that, a problem across the whole tech industry.

Steven Bartlett00:55:29

Okay, so you're saying that you're saying Google is going down more.

Ed Zitron00:55:32

Yes, Google is less stable. Google Docs is a bug fest right now and has been for a while. Google Sheets, same deal. And the thing is, you're right, I'm being a little unfair. This is everyone. It's the same with Microsoft. It's the same with Amazon. It's the same across the.

Steven Bartlett00:55:45

How do we quantify that outside of anecdotes? Like, is there a way to.

Ed Zitron00:55:49

You're right. I mean, GitHub downtime is the best example. Amazon Web Services went down, I think, two or three times this year because of AI tools. And honestly, you're right, it's kind of hard to quantify outside of anecdotes. But I challenge anyone listening to this, go and use a website these days and tell me how well it works. Tell me how buggy it is. Tell me how many problems, even with my iPhone, the supposed best UX in town. Even the iPhone is a flipping mess these days.

Steven Bartlett00:56:15

Okay, so the research says, the short answer is yes. Tech downtime and software outages have demonstrably increased over the last few years, and industry data points directly to the explosion of AI-assisted coding as a primary culprit. The problem is hitting the tech industry from two entirely different directions. The code itself is getting buggier, and the sheer volume of AI activity is literally crashing the underlying infrastructure. Interesting.

Ed Zitron00:56:41

Yeah, that's because GitHub, people are just writing a bunch of code, pushing it, and thus there's just more code on there.

Steven Bartlett00:56:48

That's interesting.

Ed Zitron00:56:49

Yeah, it's a real mess as well because open source has had this problem as well. Because it's well-meaning people. They're like, "Oh, I learned a bit of code with an LLM. I'm going to go out and do some stuff. I'm going to make this project better." And these people barely understand what they're shipping. Or maybe they understand a bit of code and they say, "Oh, Dunning-Kruger, this motherfucker. I'm going to, I'm just like, I can understand some of this." And now the code's all written and it just push it right now. So GitHub is flooded with AI code.

Steven Bartlett00:57:13

This sounds like it's making humans complacent.

Ed Zitron00:57:16

It is.

Steven Bartlett00:57:17

Because we're going, okay, look, I let it write the code for the last 100 lines, and it was broadly right. So the next 100 lines, I won't check them as much.

Ed Zitron00:57:25

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Steven Bartlett00:57:26

And that's human nature, is to get sort of, to take shortcuts, to spend less energy on an activity if you can.

Ed Zitron00:57:33

Right, but the AI's still making the mistake and we're still making all the promises of the AI. That's the thing. This thing is meant to be this autonomous, perfect. You say it can't be perfect. I don't know. Based on what Sam Altman has been saying for the last few years, Glammy Sammy's been promising the world, saying this will replace software engineers. Dario Amodei, Wario himself has been saying, "Oh yeah, 50% of white-collar labor is going to go away in the next few years." These people are promising the world. Again, if they were saying it would be smaller and they were like, "Yeah, it does have issues and we must be," none of this, "Oh, what if it wakes up and it's super powerful?"

Just like, "Yeah, it's probabilistic. It's going to make mistakes. And if you don't know what you're doing, you don't really know what you're looking at, you're going to miss those mistakes and it's going to get multiplicatively worse as you go when you don't know what you're doing." So yeah, human nature is part of it, but so is the marketing, so are the promises.

Steven Bartlett00:58:27

One of the smartest things a business can do is build like a bigger company without actually hiring like one. But the problem we all face is that most companies don't have every skill in-house. So when I look at the businesses seeing real success today, the consistent pattern with all of them is how quickly they move. They bring in specialists with skills in emerging areas to keep themselves ahead. Even in our company, we spent the last year pulling in talent across areas like AI-native strategy, no-code builds, and product workflows. And we find this talent through our longtime partner, Fiverr Pro.

Advertisement00:58:59
Episode description

Tech critic Ed Zitron exposes the AI bubble, why OpenAI and Anthropic are burning billions, the fake AI boom, and why the crash could wipe out the ENTIRE economy!

Ed Zitron is a British AI critic and one of the most cited voices warning that the AI industry is one giant bubble. He hosts the 'Better Offline' podcast, reaching over a million monthly downloads, and writes the newsletter 'Where's Your Ed At'. He is the founder and CEO of the PR firm EZPR, and is currently writing his upcoming book, 'Why Everything Stopped Working'. 

He explains: 
■ Why he believes generative AI is a “con” 
■ The real reason OpenAI and Anthropic can't turn a profit 
■ Why data centers could leave a $500 billion debt bomb 
■ Why superintelligence is a myth sold by tech billionaires 
■ Why AI won't take your job, no matter what CEOs promise

Chapters

00:00:00 Intro
00:02:15 AI Is A Con
00:05:55 How Much Power Data Centres Really Need
00:07:42 Is Widespread AI Adoption Manipulation Or Do People Actually Like Using It?
00:11:40 The Actual Cost Of AI And How Tokens Actually Work
00:15:49 Is The Spending Of AI Companies Justifiable?
00:19:47 Will The Rate Of Improvement Of AI Go Up, Like Previous Innovations?
00:24:03 How Bad Are AI Mistakes?
00:26:34 Comparing Human Error To AI Hallucinations
00:31:11 If The Output Is The Same, Does It Matter If Humans Or AI Created It?
00:33:58 Can We Trust AI Like We Trust Humans?
00:38:17 Would People Use AI If They Paid The Honest Cost?
00:42:15 How Does The AI Bubble Compare To The Dot-Com Bubble?
00:47:22 Does AI Demand Match The Cost And Risk Of Data Centres?
00:52:26 Is AI Making Websites Like Google Worse?
00:58:26 Ads
01:00:30 Is AI Job Disruption A Lie?
01:10:02 Could Your Narrative Be Helping AI Companies?
01:14:02 How Dangerous Is AI Cyberhacking
01:17:10 Is The AI Industry Creating Economic Growth?
01:18:53 How Would The US Beat China In The AI Race?
01:19:33 Is Robotics A Threat To Jobs?
01:23:03 What Do You Think About Agentic AI?
01:24:43 Is The Adoption Of AI The Same As The Rise Of The Internet?
01:27:46 The Overhype Of AI
01:30:03 What Do You Use Generative AI For?
01:33:21 Has AI Gotten More Intelligent?
01:34:09 Will AI Start To Do More Jobs As It Gets More Capable?
01:36:07 What Does The Future Look Like As AI Grows?
01:38:08 You Don't Think People's Workflows Have Been Transformed By AI?
01:40:21 Will All AI Be Powered By Data Centres?
01:43:20 Ads
01:44:34 Is Overspending On AI Due To Demand Or Something Else?
01:54:44 Tech CEOs Rebuttal
01:56:54 What Would It Take For You To Change Your Mind About AI?
02:00:12 Are AI Systems Already Blackmailing?
02:07:51 Are We In An AI Bubble And What Happens When It Pops?
02:12:48 The Tech Depression Is Coming
02:18:30 What Should The Public Do?
02:21:07 Why Do You Have A Bone To Pick With AI CEOs?
02:24:29 What Should We Be Doing To Improve Our Relationships And Social Connection?

Follow Ed Zitron:
Linktree: https://link.thediaryofaceo.com/C6fKrVK
Better Offline: https://link.thediaryofaceo.com/A9awRDM 
X: https://link.thediaryofaceo.com/GTr0z7R 
Where's Your Ed At Newsletter: https://link.thediaryofaceo.com/CZ3JLap 
You can get $10 off your first year of Where's Your Ed At Premium, here: https://link.thediaryofaceo.com/91LBdmi  

The Diary Of A CEO:
◼ Join DOAC circle here - https://doaccircle.com/
◼ Buy The Diary Of A CEO book here - https://link.thediaryofaceo.com/BWjLTZK
◼ Shop The Diary Of A CEO collection: https://thediary.com/collections/shop
◼ Get email updates - https://link.thediaryofaceo.com/5IB1H6E
◼ Follow Steven - https://link.thediaryofaceo.com/AGU9QP4

Sponsors:
Fiverr - https://fiverr.com/diary and get 10% off your first order when you use code DIARY
Saily - Download from the app store and use code DOAC at checkout for 15% off. For more details: https://saily.com/doac ⛵