Transcript of Trump Blames Biden as Aviation Crisis Grounds America (ft. Maggie Haberman)

01:05:42 43 min read 0 views Published about 12 hours ago

Copy link
Episode summary

Maggie Haberman joins Jessica Tarlov to unpack the fallout from a nationwide air traffic control outage that grounded thousands of flights, and the administration's response, which blamed the Biden administration and a copper-to-fiber upgrade. The conversation then turns to turmoil in Trump's administration after the midterm losses, including the departure of chief of staff Susie Wiles and the rise of Stephen Miller, and to the Nvidia scandal involving Jensen Huang and questions about chip export controls ahead of Trump's China trip.

They also discuss Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, his feud with Scott Bessent, and the challenge from Senator Chris Van Hollen to Chuck Schumer's Democratic leadership. Listeners get reporting context and the guest's views on what these shifts may mean.

In this episode Jessica Tarlov, Maggie Haberman

This Raging Moderates episode on Maggie Haberman's analysis of Trump's aviation crisis was made with the technology HappyScribe built to transcribe video to text.

Advertisement00:00:01
Jessica Tarlov00:02:03

Welcome to Raging Moderates. I'm Jessica Tarlov, and Scott would fully endorse me saying that I have a huge upgrade today because Maggie Haberman, the best-selling most author at The New York Times with Jonathan Swann of Regime Chains, is joining me today on a very newsy day, which you have been all over. How was your weekend?

Maggie Haberman00:02:26

It was good. Thank you for having me. And yes, we cannot lose my other news half, Jonathan Swann, without him. None of this magic happens. I didn't have a weekend, much of a weekend. It was a little busy. Yeah, I spent a lot of time working on stories about Nvidia and about President Trump and about the fallout from the Times's reporting about the intelligence gathering on a woman who Jensen Huang has now admitted he was having an affair with, who the U.S.

intelligence community believes was passing information to Beijing. And we're seeing where it goes now. And now there's a big effort to try to get Jensen Huang reinstated after he resigned. And I think you're going to see that become the big issue this week. And it's possible.

Jessica Tarlov00:03:20

That seems crazy. Okay, I was going to go FAA first, but let's go Nvidia. No, no, no. This is good. Let's do Nvidia first, and then we'll get to what it was like being grounded in Denver with all of the normie Democrats.

Maggie Haberman00:03:34

I was thinking about you, actually, when I was looking at the coverage, and I was like, oh, that was what your weekend was. Yes, okay.

Jessica Tarlov00:03:41

Yeah, it was super nice.

Maggie Haberman00:03:43

Why don't we just stay there? Let's stay with FAA. We're here. Let's talk about the FAA. Yeah, it's like my nightmare is actually a ground stop, to be clear, as a boomer who covered 9/11. And the idea that the entire system went down and the best we were hearing was the Transportation Secretary and the Homeland Security Secretary telling reporters that it was Congress's fault and getting annoyed at the questions they were getting asked.

That was new. It was interesting.

Jessica Tarlov00:04:15

It was a vibe. And it wasn't just Congress, it was the old Congress. Like Joe Biden, the most powerful man in the world, who's still destroying the country, even though he is sitting at home in Delaware doing remote interviews about his book. But just for background, for those of you joining us on Substack and YouTube, in case you didn't know what happened.

Maggie Haberman00:04:38

And whoever you are who don't know that there was a ground stop there.

Jessica Tarlov00:04:40

I'm so jealous of you that you don't know this. Thousands of flights were canceled and grounded nationwide, including my own in Denver. More than a million passengers were disrupted. The shutdown exposed just how urgently the country needs to modernize its decades-old air traffic control system. Officials say the outage was triggered by a routine upgrade from copper wire to fiber optic cables at a radio facility in El Dorado, Arkansas. A router overwhelmed the system. Is it router or rooter?

Maggie Haberman00:05:10

Router, I think.

Jessica Tarlov00:05:11

Router. Overwhelmed the system. Well, it does. And we're live. A router causing widespread communications failures. A similar issue at a radar facility in Amarillo, Texas, forced officials to issue a rare nationwide ground stop, the longest in 25 years. But as the crisis unfolded, Trump was largely silent. And I've read that he was actually with John Voight talking about the tax credit, the Hollywood tax credit bill that he's working on. While Sean Duffy and Homeland Security Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen faced reporters, the administration blamed Biden and demanded billions more in funding.

Trump finally weighed in Sunday and this morning, blaming the previous administration and calling for a massive investment in modernization. Let's watch a clip.

Speaker 600:05:54

Mr. President, what do you say to critics who say you were too focused on DC construction projects while our airline systems were crumbling, given the fact that Republicans had been in control?

Speaker 700:06:03

Well, if you take a look at the White House, it's flawless. If you listen to me, I know you don't see dirt, but if you take a look at the White House, you never notice broken windows, obviously, from where you come. I don't know. But we had 18 broken windows. So the White House is in beautiful shape. Take a look at the helipad. I hope you like it because it's gotten revealed. Listen to me. Why would you say I spend time? I spend very little time in the White House. I live here, and I see that this stone look, see this stone? 50 cameras on it.

This stone was badly broken. I have a responsibility.

Speaker 600:06:38

You said you'd given more money.

Speaker 700:06:39

Oh, you're so pathetic. We have old equipment, broken equipment. We've been telling that to Congress, and Congress upshore will move. Very old equipment, some of it 55 years. And I hate to blame any, but the Biden administration hooked up a lot of copper into glass. And copper, if you know anything about electrical engineering, you cannot hook up copper into glass. So a lot of money was wasted.

Jessica Tarlov00:07:07

Okay, I'm not surprised. I'm glad that we got a tour of all the upgrades of the White House while this is going on. What do you make of his response? And are you buying the cable explanation for this? There were definitely like tinfoil hat people out because we had the massive Outlook shutdown the day before, and then this happens. You're kind of like, it feels like something bigger could be going on here.

Maggie Haberman00:07:35

I mean, look, in our reporting, there was an initial reaction in the government was an assumption that there was an attack, that there was a cyber attack, and that there was a reason for that, because there have been cyber attacks and because this administration has been targeted by Iran, by China, et cetera, et cetera. I say this as President Trump goes off to China, but we'll get to that later. Look, I don't want to be a tinfoil hat person.

I know what they're saying. But if one copper wire upgrade, whatever this is that L3 Harris, the contractor, was working on, can shut down the whole system, that is scary. And I think L3 Harris is the company that's also now doing the investigation into what went wrong, which is also, I think, a little unusual. So we'll see. But there was a moment where the president said, you know, I don't take any responsibility for this, which that does seem clear.

Look, upgrading the system is a multi-administration issue. That's true. But that also includes the old Trump administration. And Trump is the president. He had control, the Republicans had control of Congress and the Senate for the first two years of this administration. And the president's legislative priorities, such as they were, were not funding the upgrade to the FAA. And when he was getting involved in airport-related matters, it was about having his name put on Dulles Airport and a remake of Dulles Airport, but modernizing it.

It wasn't about the FAA system. So yeah, I mean, I think you're going to hear from a lot of members of Congress who are going to say, including some Republicans, I suspect, who will say, you know, we just sent DHS a ton of money. You're asking for more money to fund a war that you never sought approval for in the first place. It's hard to say that this is everybody else's fault. And it wasn't just that the president was largely silent on Friday. He was speaking on Truth Social, his social media application, but he was talking about that tax credit.

We only found out, I think, today through John Lemire at The Atlantic that actually John Voight was in the Oval Office. And the president has a habit of bringing him along in interesting moments. So yeah, for those of us who are not great flyers, it was not reassuring, but I don't think it was reassuring for anybody.

Jessica Tarlov00:10:07

No, and the scenes from the airports across the country of people sleeping there, the stories, especially of people concerned about their elderly family members who are not in the best position to navigate a crisis like this. And I was sitting there in an auditorium, actually listening to Pete Buttigieg, talking to the last Transportation Secretary, who was viciously maligned by Republicans as being unqualified for this job, as Sean Duffy, not wearing the suit that he said that everyone should be in when you go to the airport, was lecturing us about the partisanship of this.

And your point is very well taken that, of course, this is a multi-administration effort to get to the right place, but the numbers are moving so quickly. At first, they were saying it's $30 billion. Now he's asking for $50 billion. And it does feel like, with at least some Republicans, that their frustration bubble is over at this point. They are just kind of sick of this and no one wanting to take responsibility. And there was a scene, I'm not sure if you watched the entire presser with Mark Wayne Mullen and Sean Duffy, but where Secretary Duffy looks visibly annoyed at Mark Wayne Mullen for essentially telling the truth to the American people about what happened there.

And that freaks me out as someone who is implicitly skeptical of what these guys are saying to our faces. And this links directly to what we're going to talk about with China and Nvidia and Secretary Lutnick, that it's like, if you can't even control your face from being aggravated by the guy who is at least trying to do part of his job and telling people what's going on as they're stranded all over the country, some abroad, trying to get home, and you've gotten the money that you asked for previously, and you're giving us no answer, just sass, that it leaves us in a really bad spot.

Maggie Haberman00:12:11

It was a very, very strange press briefing, to your point. I'm not entirely sure what Duffy was making those faces about. I don't know. In terms of my colleagues heard that there were frustrations at DOT about what Mullen was saying, but it's not clear if it was actually because Mullen was telling the truth or because Mullen got it wrong. Who knows? I don't know. But regardless, yes, there was visible discomfort as this was going on. And they clearly weren't entirely on the same page, but where they were on the same page was praising President Trump, which they did repeatedly.

They kept talking about how he's a builder, which is neither here nor there. I don't think that he does broadband or does copper cable for FAA networks. And separately, Sean Duffy in particular was really aggressive with reporters, like asking, who are you with? It was very much the President Trump trick of trying to throw the question and put the reporter off guard as if there was some impropriety in asking for answers about what happened.

And if you don't have answers, then what are we doing here? I mean, then you should say, we're still working on this and we don't want to mislead people. We don't want people to be afraid. But there was none of that. And Mullen at a gaggle with reporters, a small group right in front of the West Wing entrance before this briefing a few hours earlier, invoked the specter of 9/11, which a bunch of folks in the administration were kind of freaked out about because they had no idea what this meant. And then when a reporter was asking something about artificial intelligence, he stopped and said, we call it SI around here.

And so it's just these briefings tend to be very focused for the audience of one, which is President Trump. And the audience in this case is 300-plus million Americans who fly, not all of them, obviously, but it's a significant number, and who have been hearing about dressing better from Sean Duffy and how they should tolerate what is an increasingly unpleasant experience traveling, just for a lot of people, both in terms of airport lines, but also in terms of the experience on planes.

There have been a lot more situations with unruly passengers and all kinds of instances that maybe there were more of these once upon a time, and we just didn't know it because everybody didn't have an iPhone, but we hear about them all the time now. And I don't think actually this was quite so common. So you put all of this together, and it is understandable that the public is afraid, and that's just not what the tenor of this was at all. It was like indignance that they were being asked to talk about this. And that is a theme, Jessica, of this administration constantly. And this is something actually that Jonathan and I get at in regime change.

It's just there's this line in broadcast news. I don't know if you're a broadcast news fan, but it's like one of my all-time favorite journalism movies. And there's a bit where the William Hurt anchor character is making everyone watch a segment that he's doing. And during the segment, he has the camera turned to him. One of the cameras is on him and shows him crying during the segment. And it was very unusual and unorthodox. And the Albert Brooks character, when it's over, says, yes, let's never forget we're the real story, not them.

And that is sort of the theme here constantly of like, how dare you question us? How dare you ask us? This is making us uncomfortable. I mean, this is A, these are not compulsory jobs. If you don't want to be doing this, you could do something else. But also, the public elected you to help them, not the other way around.

Jessica Tarlov00:15:49

Yes. Broadcast news fan and fan of people going to public service who want to alleviate anxiety, not ramp up your anxiety and make you feel insane for being concerned about these things. And I'm curious, before we go to the Nvidia story, though it thematically links to this, has nothing changed about how they view their job based on the midterm results? Because you say, oh, it's just an audience of one, which has been the MO through the first Trump administration and the first two years of this.

But is there no sense amongst these characters that business as usual is not going to work? No, it's the same.

Maggie Haberman00:16:35

No, I mean, no, that may evolve. We'll see what it looks like when there is a new Congress in place and when Democrats don't need that many Republican votes to pass along a veto-proof bill, which I think you will see potentially on certain, especially populist items, things that relate to affordability, things that relate to housing, for instance. I would be shocked if anything changes on Obamacare subsidies, but we'll see, because that's just been a debacle for the Republicans in terms of constantly saying that they're going to undo Obamacare.

And then actually, it's a pretty popular program, but now it is going to the rates are going to go up for a significant number of people because the subsidies are expiring to states. There's been nothing. I mean, you don't name Stephen Miller as your chief of staff because you're trying to send a signal that you understand that the country actually views a lot of what you're doing as unpopular, or at least as harmful to them, or not what they voted for.

And the thing, Jessica, that Jonathan and I talk about a lot is the president's administration has managed to do something to offend or anger almost every element of this coalition that he stitched together for 2024. And it was a slightly different coalition than 2016, not dramatically different, but slightly. Non-college white voters, black voters who switched from Democrats, Latino voters who voted for the president in large numbers, the podcast bros, the maha moms.

I mean, I can go on and on and on here. And they all feel like they were, according to just polling and everything we've all read and heard from voters, they feel hoodwinked in various ways. And I'm not saying that they should. In many cases, it was clear what Trump was going to do, but certainly not in all of them. I don't think any of them thought that he was going to start a new war in Iran, no matter how hawkish he is on Iran compared to everywhere else.

But he leaped in with both feet and not a clear plan. And as we've seen, he said it was going—we're now, what is it, six months longer than the initial timeframe, he said. So for all of those reasons, they're in a difficult spot. And what Stephen Miller's pitch has been to other members of the administration and to the president is it's time to get back to policies that are popular with the MAGA base and with the president's base. And that's fine, except that's not typically what happens as a response to a midterm wipeout, which is what this was.

I mean, it was a generational wipeout. It was Watergate level during a lame duck presidential term. And so the president's base is a fraction of the country. It's not some broad segment of the electorate. Stephen Miller has told people he recognizes that the war is a political calamity and they have to figure out some end game here. But I don't know what the end game is because Iran gets a vote.

And whether they get a vote just against the U.S. or regionally in terms of chaos, I think the U.S. will see an answer. So that is a very long way of saying that really no one here is saying, you know what, this is time for us to shift course. And Trump, you know this as well as I do, he has one move, which is more Trump or more MAGA. And his whole team really bought into that and swallowed that worldview whole.

And now you're seeing it.

Jessica Tarlov00:20:31

Do you think that that was the principal contrast with Susie Wiles versus a Stephen Miller? It does seem—and there's a lot of reporting around it—that the amount of money that Susie Wiles' daughter was making off of passing trading influence, essentially, what Hunter Biden was accused of doing was a factor in President Trump parting ways with Susie Wiles. But do you think this back to basics part of it was really the deciding factor for him in switching gears?

Because my impression of her—and I don't know her and I know that she very deftly only shows up in stories when she wants to, like sits down with Vanity Fair for that big piece, but then is behind the scenes for most of it—that she's not a hardliner in the same way as Stephen Miller. She comes to this as a more normie Republican who understood America First and the MAGA movement, but certainly didn't grow up in that kind of ideology.

Maggie Haberman00:21:37

Yeah, I think—I mean, that I think is true. I think there's a—let me just start at the beginning of what you said. So in terms of why she left, there were a lot of reasons. The main ones—well, the main one is everybody has an hourglass timer with Trump on their own timeframe of how long they're going to last. The egg timer turns and the sand starts falling. It is literally true for everyone. And then they can end up coming back in some fashion. Corey Lewandowski would be one.

Tom Barrack was one. I mean, I can go down the list. Tom Barrack, now the ambassador to Turkey. Susie Wiles was with Trump at his lowest point in 2021. He was with her at her lowest point when Ron DeSantis, after she had helped manage the late stages of his gubernatorial campaign, they had a huge falling out. And it was over money-related issues. And he made all kinds of accusations. She and her allies said this was absolutely not true.

Trump stuck with her. So there was a lot of value in that for Trump. But A, a couple of things. A White House is different than a campaign. It's just a singularly different management challenge. There was a very small group around her and around the president who were involved in the decision-makings. They were all very focused on leaks. And sometimes that was to the exclusion of expertise. It's not like expertise is valued in this administration highly—long-term expertise.

I think she tried to, just from our reporting, she tried to balance between not managing him, which he hates, in air quotes, but making changes on the margins when she could. I think that she and Scott Bessent tried to steer him away in particular from certain decisions that would have been problematic for him, whether it was on tariff policy. Obviously, Liberation Day was a fiasco, but I'm talking about after that. Not firing Jerome Powell, which would have been another court-related test.

Not continuing to double down on Lisa Cook, at least until this year. But the reality is that Trump just wants to do what he wants to do. And so anybody who is going to kind of put some lines on that is going to have a problem. And Stephen Miller spent four years during the interregnum finding lawyers to staff this administration with. He actually understands the levers of federal governing very well or governance and how it works. Stephen Miller is not a lawyer, but he spent a lot of time finding lawyers who weren't the squishes of in his terms of the first term.

They were going to get the president to a yes. They were not going to stop the president and say, this is illegal. This is something we can't do. The answer was going to be, there is a way in the law. And you have actually seen that a lot with the DOJ. You didn't need Stephen Miller there for that. But I think that you were going to see an acceleration of that. When Susie Wiles got sick, she's been fighting cancer since February. She has said publicly she's cancer-free. But I don't know anything more about her condition. A couple of people have said to us privately that you can trace the beginning of sort of chaos becoming more visible.

It doesn't mean it wasn't there, but more visible and reverting to the Trump meme around her diagnosis. She wasn't physically as present. She tried working through it. People knew that she wasn't there. And Trump does not like weakness. And he started—not illness, excuse me. He sees it as weakness. And so he started picking on her. But there was also clearly a lot of people who were serving multiple roles. There were people who were working as special government employees and working with lobbying firms.

There were people who were associated with her, like James Blair and Chris Lacevita, who took this trip to Srpska three weeks before the midterm for not even a ton of money. Her daughter was just—it's like the worst of both worlds. And I understand that there are folks.

Jessica Tarlov00:25:54

And we're used to these insane sums.

Maggie Haberman00:25:56

Correct.

Jessica Tarlov00:25:56

When these stories get reported where it's like they went to lunch and got $50 million. And you're like, you went all the way?

Maggie Haberman00:26:03

You went to Srpska and you got, I think it was like $500,000 to $700,000, something like that. And there was some piece of this where her daughter, who was working for a lobbying firm, showed up in this. And yeah, that was inevitably going to be problematic for her. What everyone will say in response and has when we've talked about this on television or whatever is, well, but Trump is making so much money. And no question. I mean, the Trump self-dealing and the family's self-dealing and the Witkoff family's self-dealing and the Lutnick family increasing their money and the overlap between Commerce and Trump's son—sorry, Lutnick's son's—a Cantor Fitzgerald is significant.

We've written about it. But Trump tends to view that as differently. So this was always going to end poorly this way. But it is true that Susie Wiles was not—she's a transactional political figure in a way that Stephen Miller just is not.

Advertisement00:27:07
Jessica Tarlov00:29:17

Trump is heading off to China. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick is expected to join the president in Beijing, but there are questions about his influence over the negotiations and potential conflicts of interest. Your reporting found that Lutnick has pushed to ease restrictions on advanced NVIDIA chips going to the Southeast Asian data centers, which serve the Chinese tech companies. That's notable because Cantor Fitzgerald, the firm he ran for decades, which his sons run now, has financial ties to some of these companies, including one building a massive data center in Malaysia.

Meanwhile, the administration is moving to close a loophole allowing Chinese companies to access advanced NVIDIA chips through overseas data centers, potentially complicating NVIDIA's business in Southeast Asia. And this comes amid the sudden downfall of NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang, a close Trump ally. The Commerce Department says Lutnick has complied with his ethics agreements and there's no evidence his former firm's dealings influenced his decisions. We have heard that before. I thought it was interesting this morning that Trump was pretty defensive of Jensen Huang, saying it's not even clear that she was a spy at all.

Talking about Alice Wong, who works at Megaspeed, saying that it certainly isn't a bad idea, this idea that Silicon Valley CEOs and powerful folks are hankering for him to be able to come back and take his job again. This is Jensen Huang. And that Trump has invested in NVIDIA. You were talking about him growing his personal wealth. It grew more than 62 million before the scandal broke out. All right, over to you.

What is happening here?

Maggie Haberman00:31:00

There's a lot.

Jessica Tarlov00:31:01

Yeah.

Maggie Haberman00:31:01

A couple of things. Let me again start at the beginning. So a team of us at the Times have been working on this for some time. The first story began with some of my colleagues last year about Jensen Huang being seen with this woman who was an executive at Megaspeed. I think that company now says she's not there anymore. This company suddenly had $2 billion. It was a very tiny regional player to buy NVIDIA products. So right away, that has raised some flags for people who study the industry.

At the time, there was immense pushback that there was anything unusual about the relationship. More recently, a team of us have reported that the U.S. intelligence community had electronic surveillance on her and that they had determined that she was acting as a Chinese intelligence asset, that she was passing information to Beijing. And that this has been a topic of some concern, such concern that Marco Rubio memorialized it in a roughly two-page memo that focused on Jensen Huang's relationship with Alice Wong.

It did not say romantically, but it did make clear if you looked between the lines.

Jessica Tarlov00:32:23

It was close.

Maggie Haberman00:32:24

It was close, personal, and also on her relationship with Chinese intelligence services. And that memo was dated March 30th. And the president was briefed on this at least twice. I believe it was more than that. It was roughly a year ago that he was first briefed in our reporting. And Jensen Huang was left off of Trump's trip to China from the invite list of text leaders to go meet them there in May. When with very little notice, the president invited Jensen Huang to come get aboard Air Force One during a refueling stop on that trip.

And when Marco Rubio, who was on the plane, found out that this was happening in our reporting, he went and briefed President Trump and reminded him. Again, briefed to make it sound like this was new information. He was reiterating what they knew and underscoring it. And the president was undeterred as he had been every single time that this had come up. And there could be a bunch of reasons why. One is that, A, we know the president doesn't put much stock in what the intelligence community says if it contradicts something that he has an interest in.

We know that AI is crucial to his hopes for keeping the U.S. economy frothing and the CapEx that has been going into the U.S. and data centers and so forth has been significant. And NVIDIA has a massive market share on that massive of chips and of the advanced chips. And so consequently, instead of building up other companies, the president basically just seized on this relationship with NVIDIA in particular and Jensen Huang.

And so we reported on this on October 28th. And since then, a lot more has emerged. And we've reported the various things that I just said. And Jensen Huang admitted to this relationship with this woman about a week and a half ago. And then my colleagues a few days later reported that he had also been having an affair with a subordinate, a direct report. That appeared to be the real problem for his company and their board. That's a different corporate culture issue. But Jensen Huang.

Jessica Tarlov00:34:37

It's like both should be pretty bad for corporate culture.

Maggie Haberman00:34:40

Just reporting. You decide. Yes, exactly.

Jessica Tarlov00:34:42

Yeah. You report. I decide.

Maggie Haberman00:34:44

I don't know. You decide. You decide. Yes. I think they would too at this point.

Jessica Tarlov00:34:48

Yeah.

Maggie Haberman00:34:48

But Jensen Huang is the company. I mean, for lack of a better way of putting it, it's wild because this is a multi-billion dollar wildly successful company. And yet, in terms of the management, it's like a mom-and-pop shop. I mean, it is him, it's his wife, it's his daughter, and a very small group of board members. It's the general counsel. And so we will learn more about that in the coming days. It is a hard leap to see that he gets reinstated just because of the things that I just said. Really, more about what happens at NVIDIA as opposed to the rest of it.

And President Trump is saying, well, it hasn't been determined that she was—he seems to be seizing on the word spy. Jessica, there is no credible pushback on our reporting that she was gathering information for Beijing and serving as a Chinese intelligence asset. There just isn't. And so we'll see how various members of the administration address it. But what you've also seen is this fight over export controls, which was the other piece. And the bigger piece here is the smuggling question.

What you were just describing about the rule about cloud compute, where there can be remote access inside China from companies that are based in Southeast Asia using these chips. That has been a loophole for some time. And there has been a big fight within the administration. When I say big fight, it was like Howard Lutnick and then almost everybody else on how to handle this. Over putting in these tighter restrictions, what Lutnick would say is that he's worried about a trade war with China.

And that may be it. But the problem is that when you also have these personal interests, no matter if you've divested, if your sons are at this company and there's some intersection, people are going to wonder about motives. It's what happened with Susie Wiles. It's happening here. So Besant was incredibly critical publicly of Lutnick and strikingly so and said that he had been pushing for these export controls for months. They weren't happening. You'd have to talk to Commerce. President Trump seemed to side with Lutnick more than Besant this morning on his way to China.

That could change by the time they land. Who knows? But they and Marco Rubio and the president are all on this plane. So there we are.

Jessica Tarlov00:37:09

And you must be sad that you're sitting here with me.

Maggie Haberman00:37:11

I mean, I'm thrilled to be sitting here with you. But this would be a really good trip to be the pooler on. I'm not going to lie.

Jessica Tarlov00:37:19

Yeah. It seems like an excellent place to be hanging out by the restroom, just like, what is happening over there? Can we talk a little bit more about the Lutnick-Besant war, which is not new? And I thought this started, at least this round of it started on Friday on CNBC, where Besant really went for him on with Joe Kernan and the kind of background here.

And then the question, how does Trump decide who goes and who doesn't? Because I know that it's not as simple as the women go and the men get to stay. But in general, the women go and the men get to stay. Thinking about Kristi Noem, there was good reason. I mean, frankly, she should have been gone for that video in CCOT wearing the tight white T-shirt. But I get it after what happened in Minneapolis. And then they found the self-dealing, the no-bid contracts and got Senator Kennedy to kind of hang her out to dry in that hearing.

So her and Cory Lundowski, Pam Bondi with the Epstein files, which you detail amazingly with Jonathan in Regime Change of how important the Epstein files and the botched rollout of all of that was to the way that President Trump felt about her and what was portended for the midterms, which we saw come to fruition. But Susie Wiles gone. And you have these men who are seemingly incompetent in some pretty important ways.

And we just went through and there will be another impeachment vote with Hegseth once Democrats have control in Congress. You have Howard Lutnick, who's been in the hot seat about Epstein, about stuff like this, where there's definitely self-dealing going on vis-à-vis his kids. So how does he pick who gets to stay and who goes?

Maggie Haberman00:39:17

I mean, it's a good question. I think it's both notable, as you say, that these are all women who left and the men are still there. But as you also said, I don't think that's the driving reason. In the case of Katie Zachariah, the press secretary for five days, I mean, yeah.

Jessica Tarlov00:39:42

That could have been a dude.

Maggie Haberman00:39:43

Correct. Caroline Leavitt left on her own. That was her choice. And so that's another piece of it. If you have an administration that is primarily men, there will be more men left over. And so that's where we are number one. But number two, it's very, very situational. So I'll give you a for instance on Lutnick. Now, this is a real test of right now how long Lutnick is going to be able to survive. And Lutnick has been in trouble before with the president.

And then I'll get to him and Besant, particularly when the president was reading about Lutnick's sons building these businesses, the data center investments and work that overlap with the administration's policy. So we have a scene in the book where the president says in front of Lutnick and many people, and he said this, would say this over and over again, the only reason that I put up with Howard's bullshit is that he gave me $25 million. Am I allowed to curse on this? I am, right? I remember.

Jessica Tarlov00:40:44

We encourage it.

Maggie Haberman00:40:44

I just couldn't remember. But yes, then I remembered Scott and you and yeah, okay. Sorry. I just need to be I'm being polite, respectful of the house rules.

Jessica Tarlov00:40:51

Be you. I love it.

Maggie Haberman00:40:52

Yes. Okay. The only reason that I put up with Howard's bullshit is because he gave me $25 million. By gave me $25 million, he means that Lutnick wrote a $25 million personal check to Trump's pending presidential library slash hotel in Miami. And Lutnick did that at a moment when he was in trouble with Trump. And so Lutnick has specific means by which to elongate his tenure. If this situation with export control policy ends, we are just at the beginning of whatever happens with Jensen Huang and NVIDIA, that's one piece.

There are going to be investigations. There is already DOJ has this issue that was brought to them from Commerce about Megaspeed, which was Alice Huang's company, and whether it was evading export controls and whether it was the bigger issue remains here, potential chip smuggling. So we don't know where that leads. But if any of this, if any of Lutnick's pushback on what everybody else in the administration for the most part wanted in terms of tighter restrictions on sales to the region, to Southeast Asia, if any of that gets to the president, if any of it is Lutnick saying, I was just doing what the president told me to do.

If there was any sort of more conscious conversation, then I think the president might be less willing to hang on to his Commerce secretary. So we'll see. So that's one. In terms of Hegseth, Trump likes Hegseth. He likes the high-tee ethos and the push-ups and the this and central casting. He knows that Hegseth was a supporter, at least the last eight years. He certainly was not in 2016. But there's an issue of who they could get confirmed, right?

So that plays into the calculation. I think that if the trade-off on getting a defense spending bill through in this Congress, which is pretty vital, right? I mean, they have a real problem. DOW has no or DOD, whatever name we're using right now, has no money, like really is underfunded. The only well-funded agency in the federal government is DHS. So if the trade becomes, I mean, the president whipped votes against the impeachment. But if the trade is, we will be willing to cut Hegseth loose in exchange for funding, I think that's a trade you'd likely see the White House be willing to make, although Stephen Miller is much more aligned with Pete Hegseth than Susie Wiles was.

So there's that. And then on the others, I mean, the president has cut JD Vance off at the knees. He did that last week. You're obviously not going to fire your vice president, but you certainly can temporarily ice him from looking like he can make much traction for a 2028 presidential run, which I think has become much more complicated for Vance anyway, given the outcome of the midterms. Who else am I missing? Who am I forgetting in this sweep?

Jessica Tarlov00:44:03

Oh, the Besant-Lutnick.

Maggie Haberman00:44:05

Oh, yes. Sorry. That was the other question. So Lutnick ran the transition, the 2024 to 2025 transition. Lutnick very much wanted to be the Treasury Secretary. He was openly lobbying for it. He was sort of the Dick Cheney of the transition process. I'm going to name myself after an exhaustive search. Besant had been campaigning for that job in a potential Trump administration for two years and had been very smart in terms of the alliances that he had made. He had MAGA allies.

He hired people who he thought understood the movement. He hired people who were close with Steve Bannon. And Lutnick was very heavy-handed with a lot of people who did not recall him being around that much in Trump's indirect period or in term one. And so there was a lot of bad blood between Besant and Lutnick that dated back to that fight over the jobs. Lutnick settled for Commerce Secretary.

They have continued to be crosswise ever since, with the rare exception of being on the same page to walk Trump off of Liberation Day tariffs, which was on April 9th as the global bond market was about to melt down and essentially the universe would implode financially. But they have never gotten along. They have never liked each other. They have continued to be very, very opposed on policy. But now that the president is leaning toward Lutnick's more, oh, Jensen just wants to sell chips, view of the world.

I mean, so the Commerce Department put out this new export control restriction today, Monday. And I haven't had a chance to read the whole thing. It's quite long. But it literally says, I think, like the Commerce Department opposes this going into practice, into place. Well, Commerce has to enforce this. So I don't quite know what this ends up looking like. It makes very clear the Treasury and National Security Council were involved in this as well. I've never seen a line like that before.

So Besant is very much out on a limb right now publicly. And if Trump is coming back away from the idea of being behind Besant and what he was saying and instead is going to be more sympathetic to Lutnick's view of this issue, I don't know what that means. But it's going to make for an interesting China trip.

Jessica Tarlov00:46:36

Definitely. Just on that, the new guidance, the regulation, it has three new aspects of the rules to counter Chinese smuggling of AI chips, which is the supposition that that's what was going on, the Jensen Huang to Alice Huang pipeline, restrict Chinese companies from renting access to these AI chips. I did not know that renting was a thing that was happening so commonly and block Chinese chip designers from making AI chips at TSMC. So those are kind of like the three overheads.

I know on the Democratic side, Senator Cortez Masto is kind of like leading this. I'll be curious to see what pushback Lutnick can convince Trump that there should be. What's been sticking out to me, and I do want to, I realize I've spent so long on this, and I want to talk about the Democrats a little bit with you, but that everybody continually keeps, at least in that orbit, in the Trump orbit, save for Besant, is like talking about this as if it's a problem with a guy going outside of his marriage.

And I feel like that's so much of President Trump's framework as someone who has gone outside of all of his marriages and Stormy Daniels and what's the big deal in all of this? But this is a national security story. This is not a sex story at all.

Maggie Haberman00:48:00

Correct.

Jessica Tarlov00:48:01

Well, I mean, it's an element of it.

Maggie Haberman00:48:02

Well, it is. But yes, that's not to your point. That's actually not the key piece here.

Jessica Tarlov00:48:08

And they won't address it like that. And that's really frustrating as a concerned citizen that they keep saying, like, who cares where you stick it, essentially? And it's like, well, if it's a Chinese spy, but even if she's getting an under-the-table deal to circumvent our rules, that is a big deal. And it has huge implications for the AI race that everyone is seemingly so concerned with making sure that we stay ahead of China.

Maggie Haberman00:48:36

Well, what you just said, the contradiction there is part of what is frustrating to people inside the administration who are worried on this front and are worried about this as a national security issue. You are right that it's not just the president. I mean, Jensen Huang initially was trying to frame this as this is a personal issue. And I've failed my family. And there obviously is a personal aspect here. But yeah, that is not the story. The story is this much bigger, or it is a piece of the story, but there is a much bigger issue here, which is the question of possible chip smuggling.

And that has huge implications. And it's much easier to talk about this as if it is sort of a personal problem because it's less complicated. It doesn't surprise me that Jensen Huang's allies are doing that. They have a huge stake in NVIDIA staying afloat. And I understand that. But President Trump is discounting the national security issue here on multiple fronts, right?

I mean, if he's continuing to try to downplay anything connected to Alice Huang other than the relationship piece and also is undercut. I mean, he said, Marco never talked to me about this. That's just based on our reporting, patently not true. And so I'll be curious to see how Rubio addresses that, if he does at all. But I'm sure he won't say something publicly. But it puts everybody there in a pretty uncomfortable position because they are it can't be that everybody who raises an objection to anything in the administration is acting as a deep state asset, as they would say.

I mean, it's not that everybody's trying to undercut the president. These are his own picks for the cabinet. These are people who he wanted in place. And this is when you get a government that's really so fundamentally built on loyalty, which was the whole crux here, it's hard to then make the argument credibly in public that you're somehow being sold a bill of goods by people who are trying to undermine you. That's just it's really hard to see that that's what Scott Besant is doing or Marco Rubio is doing or on and on and on.

Now, people might have disagreements about how to handle export control policies. That's different. But there's also a there is a legal component there. If you are in violation of export control laws, that is illegal. And so what this ends up meaning going forward, we'll see. It's not like this is a DOJ that has been exactly independent of this White House. So Todd Blanch's comment the other day that he was asked about Alice Huang and in what capacity was she being assessed.

And he said, well, I haven't said that. And we haven't said what she is or isn't, which was sort of curiously taken by some in the media as some him saying no one has determined. He was just deflecting on the question. This is not what DOJ is doing. This is an IC question. But his job and his agency's job is to be investigating possible smuggling. And I don't know where that goes.

Advertisement00:52:02
Jessica Tarlov00:54:01

Democrats. As I mentioned, I was in Denver at Moderate Fest or whatever. It was like a mini DNC. And there were it was a range. And there were progressives there that were speaking like Ro Khanna and Chris Van Hallen, who had announced that he was running to challenge Chuck Schumer for leadership on the Senate side. He gave a speech. I was interviewing Hakeem Jeffries. And I had little we had some protesters, three waves of interactions.

Yeah, a crazy experience. I've never had that. And watching him deal with it, I think it's much more common for him, obviously. I have a lot of feelings about that, but that's for a separate episode. I'm curious as to what you think of Van Hallen's challenge and if it goes anywhere. I mean, so far, based on the numbers, it doesn't look like he'll be able to pull this off. And I thought it was interesting that he was more muted in terms of the policies that he thought could get passed in interviews over the weekend because you would expect after you launch a leadership challenge that you go to the walls, right?

You're like, we'll have Medicare for all in 10 minutes. And we'll abolish ICE and all the wish list, right? There'll be a Green New Deal. And it was a bit of a pretty conventional, dare I say, moderate response to questions about what he thought was really possible. So how do you see the leadership battle on the Democrat side?

Maggie Haberman00:55:39

So if you would ask me this question whatever day it was, like a week ago, maybe five, six days ago, people close to Schumer and around Schumer thought that he was in real trouble in terms of the leadership vote.

Jessica Tarlov00:55:54

Even after the midterm win.

Maggie Haberman00:55:56

Yes, because the so there had been a wide expectation that Schumer again, I'm saying expectation. I'm not saying this was a plan, but there was an expectation that he was less likely than not to seek another term in 2028. I just caveat on to age myself here. I was at the New York Hilton on 6th Avenue at Al D'Amato's loss party in '98 when Schumer won the first time.

And I think Al D'Amato got stuck in an elevator on his way down to the party. It was a grim night. But so that speaks to how I'm 53. That speaks to how long Schumer has been there. And so there is this question of the gerontocracy in the Senate generally, but also in leadership. And so the Democrats have a better night, vastly better night than even the biggest optimists anticipated. I was actually saying only Jonathan Martin was the only person who I heard call this correctly in public.

And yeah, I mean, he said 55 that morning. He was right. It may end up as 56, likely will. So that makes it harder for Schumer to go. And it makes it harder to make an argument against him. But there was still a feeling that there needed to be a change. And then it turns out that there is a, A, I think that there was too much of a gap in terms of an actual challenge being void. It gave Schumer time to regroup and time to get people on board. And it was clear within two days from the people I was talking to that actually he was in a stronger than not position.

So what I attribute it to is that Schumer is very good at this particular ask. He is good at recruitment. He's not perfect at recruitment. He obviously made some bets that were not good. But and the successes were certainly not all his doing. I mean, there was just a national climate and a mood. But he is good at dealing with these inside dynamics of inside the Senate Democrats. And I think that there is so much newness right now that there was a decision made, among other things, to for people who are undecided, stick with what you know, especially because Hakeem Jeffries is going to be a new speaker because he will never have been in leadership that way, and Schumer has, than to not.

And so I think Van Hallen is trying not to do damage.

Jessica Tarlov00:58:24

Well, it also seems like Van Hallen is now off the idea of running for president.

Maggie Haberman00:58:28

I think there's no question about that.

Jessica Tarlov00:58:30

Yeah.

Maggie Haberman00:58:30

Well, I mean, I shouldn't say there's no question, but certainly that's how it looks. Yes, I think that's right.

Jessica Tarlov00:58:34

Yeah, which I think is interesting. I mean, the stage is going to be so crowded. But Van Hallen had been racking up a lot of progressive bona fides, especially encapsulated in his trip to see what was going on with Kilmer Abrego Garcia and the fake story about the margaritas, but that he went and checked on his constituent who was being illegally held in a foreign prison. So that surprised me that this was the door that he wanted to go through because on the progressive side for president, save for AOC, if she decides to do this, though, to my mind, it feels like she might be inching more towards the Senate seat.

Like if Schumer retires and then maybe I love Pat Ryan, maybe it's an AOC Pat Ryan or something, maybe Richie Torres, I don't know, for the Senate seat. But that Van Hallen would have pretty good bona fides to go in that lane and also has institutional experience, which a lot of people don't remember that he.

Maggie Haberman00:59:34

That's true.

Jessica Tarlov00:59:35

Was part of the machine working with Pelosi, et cetera, back on the House side.

Maggie Haberman00:59:41

Yeah, I mean, I think that I think a couple of things. I think, yes, I mean, I agree with you that I think that he would have a case to make. I think that there is concern, and you have certainly seen this in a lot of AOC's recalibrations on just her language on certain fronts. Yes, obviously, there is a there was a progressive push and lift in this set of wins, but it wasn't progressive social policy that did it.

It was populism. It's economic populism. And so it is true that Van Hallen has certain cred on specific issues. And I agree with you about how front and center he was on Abrego Garcia, but that was also now a year and a half ago. I don't think that that would be an especially current discussion in a year and a half. And I also don't I don't know. I mean, it's interesting watching the governor-elect in Texas, who's a Democrat, saying that she agrees with the president that there needs to be tighter border security.

It's not a surprise. If you talk to anybody in Texas, that you know that this was what they were going to say. She just doesn't believe that there should be mass deportation sweeps and putting people in camps with bad conditions. But I think that we don't quite know yet where many Democrats are on the question of immigration. And I think that all of these things are going to be tied together. So whatever it may have looked like for Van Hallen months ago, I don't think that the results of this midterms suggest that yes, ostensibly, in the way that the media looks at things, would have some lane.

But I think that if Democrats don't get some policy wins on things that matter to voters underway, as opposed to simply doing oversight all the time. And to be clear, there's real reasons to be doing oversight. I mean, there are challenges that there's so much there that it's going to be very hard to narrow it. I think that both parties have made the mistake over the last 18 years of thinking that and this isn't just a Van Hallen issue. This is just broadly. It doesn't relate just to the Van Hallen question, but both parties have made the mistake of thinking that when there's a flip, that it means that the voters fell in love with their party.

And it was kind of encapsulated in that JD Vance long thing on social media about how voters didn't like the Iran war and it's all the Iran war's fault, which part of it was, but not all of it. And he said he was talking to some smart data guy and pollster and that their voters did come out. They just voted for Democrats. Well, they weren't your voters. That's the point. So these are coalitions. They're not promises of the future. And these are voters who are very, very frustrated that things have not been done to make their lives better.

And so if you're Van Hallen and you're a senator now, I don't know that you want to risk everything on something that I'm not sure his party totally understands. But again, I think I could say that for everybody, including AOC, which is why a lot of people in New York, where I am, anticipate she's likelier to run for the Senate. But who knows?

Jessica Tarlov01:03:04

Who knows? But it was definitely a big theme of the What's Next Summit that all of these new stars came out and said, these are the ways that we can work with President Trump to get things done. Notably, James Tallarico, if he wants a bunch of busts like LBJ, because it's a big deal that he now has LBJ's seat, all the interviews with Scott Caloum, the senator-elect from Mississippi, who did everything from working Trump lines at rallies.

And Abdul Al-Sayed, even the biggest bravado of the bunch with the Trump card for Trump care, right? We'll do Medicare for all. You want to make it gold? You want your name on it? Let's get it done. So we'll see where Trump falls on that and what Stephen Miller will allow. I have taken so much of your time, Maggie Haberman.

Maggie Haberman01:03:54

No, no, no. Thank you.

Jessica Tarlov01:03:55

Thank you so much. We're all a lot smarter for this. And we'll be looking out for the reporting. Hopefully, we'll get something off the airplane from whoever's pooling.

Maggie Haberman01:04:06

I'm keeping my fingers crossed. And then from others, thank you for having me, Jessica. I always love coming on with you.

Advertisement01:04:30
Episode description

Jessica Tarlov is joined by New York Times reporter Maggie Haberman to break down the growing turmoil inside Trump’s administration, the fight over Democratic leadership, and why Trump may be losing support from the podcast crowd that helped elect him.

After thousands of flights were canceled and grounded nationwide and more than a million passengers were disrupted, the shutdown exposed just how urgently the country needs to modernize its decades-old air traffic control system.

But as the crisis unfolded, Trump was largely silent. While Sean Duffy and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin faced reporters, the administration blamed Biden and demanded billions more in funding. Is Trump focused more on his legacy than the current state of affairs?

After a colossal midterms defeat, Trump is shaking up his cabinet. The president fired his chief of staff, Susie Wiles, earlier this month, replacing her with immigration hardliner Stephen Miller. Are more shakeups on the horizon? 

With Trump’s upcoming trip to China, there are some new questions about who will be in the president’s inner circle. How will the drama at Nvidia impact the meeting between Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin? 

There may be a serious challenge brewing to Chuck Schumer’s leadership: Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen. Is Van Hollen a credible alternative to Schumer for Democrats?

For ad-free episodes, exclusive livestreams, and to connect with Scott, Jessica, and the Raging Moderates community, join us at ProfG+ on Substack: https://ragingmoderates.profgmedia.com/

Get The Monday Rage newsletter: https://profgmedia.com/s/monday-rage/

Follow Raging Moderates on IG, Tiktok, and Facebook:

https://www.instagram.com/ragingmoderatespod/

https://www.tiktok.com/@ragingmoderates

https://www.facebook.com/ragingmoderates

Follow Jessica Tarlov on Instagram, Substack, and Bluesky:

https://instagram.com/jessicatarlov

https://substack.com/@jessietarlov

https://bsky.app/profile/jessicatarlov.bsky.social

Follow Scott on Instagram, Substack, and Bluesky:

https://instagram.com/profgalloway

https://substack.com/@profgalloway

https://bsky.app/profile/profgalloway.com

Subscribe to our YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/@RagingModerates
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices