Max Rushden, Barry Glendenning, Jonathan Liew and Lars Sivertsen review a busy Champions League week and the wider Premier League picture. They discuss Liverpool's costly defensive errors in Fenerbahçe's 3-2 win, Manchester City's rotated side in Leipzig, Arsenal's uneasy 2-1 win at Slavia Prague, and Real Madrid's late comebacks.
The panel also covers Como's nine-goal rout of Lens, Viking's first Champions League win, and whether several Premier League managers could be sacked during the international break. Listeners also hear debate about how media coverage treats young footballers.
In this episode Max Rushden, Barry Glendenning, Jonathan Liew, Lars Sivertsen
This Football Weekly episode's transcript, covering Liverpool's Istanbul defeat and Arsenal's Prague win, was made with HappyScribe technology, the same technology behind its AI meeting assistant.
Ads in this audio differ from the text. Tap the sentence you're hearing to follow along.
Synced: the text now follows the audio.
This is The Guardian.
Hello and welcome to The Guardian Football Weekly. Defeat for Liverpool in Turkey, Dirk Coutts, Fenerbahçe winning by the odd goal in 5—all five of a thoroughly enjoyable low quality. Meanwhile, Man City are pushed in Leipzig. The game began with a wonderful own goal and ended with a beautiful sweeping move finished off by Erling Haaland, who always scores in this fixture. Arsenal win 2-1 in Prague, they looked a bit tired, but Victor Gyokeres set up one and scored a lovely goal too. Perhaps he's not just a lumbering oaf in, certainly, it's only Slavia Prague. Caveat: elsewhere, a Real Madrid against a Real Madrid this competition, just finding a way. A 3-2 win in Athens courtesy of a beautiful Valverde injury time strike, a glorious Bellingham back heel in there too.
There's Como scoring 9 (NINE), and a win for Viking. I hope there's a Norwegian on the panel for that one. Scott Parker's first game in charge of West Ham seems to have come from three downs to get a point at Cardiff, and there's a Premier League preview: as many as five managers just a game away from the sack ahead of the international break. All that plus your questions, and that's today's Guardian Football Weekly. On the panel today, Barry Glenn Denning, hello.
Hi Max.
Welcome, Jonny Lou.
Hi Max.
And good morning, Lars Iversen.
Good morning, Max.
Let's begin with Fenerbahçe 3, Liverpool 2. Really enjoyable game this, Jonny, I thought. 30 shots on goal, incredibly open, and I thought five goals of such incredible low quality. Like, it looked like sort of League Two, it was like a League Two highlights reel when you watched it. I've seen, I've played in games where all the goals kind of bobbled in or were deflected in, and I thought, this is what we need more of in the Champions League.
Yeah, two deflections looks, looks, looks just very ugly. Obviously the technical quality in between was fine, obviously. It's a great stadium, great atmosphere, very high-quality individuals on the pitch. But yes, I mean, the story I guess is Liverpool's defending, the individual errors, the kind of the sloppiness. That final goal where the ball just disappears into the air, and I think, I think Gnoni is under it, and Jacquet, and maybe McAllister.
McAllister's there, yeah, sure.
Who is it, who is it who gets up and scores the winner?
Maricki.
Maricki, yes. And you see the three of them looking at them afterwards going, "Whoa, you're allowed to jump. You're allowed to jump for these." None of the three of them had managed to get off the ground to make a challenge. It's just such an elementary goal to concede. And then, you know, the 2-all goal, which so many things have to go wrong in a row, you know, right up to Gakpo sort of misjudging his header and Archie Brown getting it at the back post. So yeah, I mean, for Liverpool it was one of those games that they weren't quite in control of it, but they had it.
They just needed to see it out. And it's becoming increasingly worrying that they aren't really able to see out these games. And as a result, they're not getting what they deserve out of games because they just have a five or ten-minute spell where things just sort of disintegrate into jelly. And I think that's a real problem for Areola to solve. I think the Arsenal game has taken a little bit of confidence out of them. They're playing some decent stuff, but it's just very clear that when they get into these sticky situations, they're looking around thinking, "Who's going to drag us out of this?"
And I don't see a huge amount of belief from them.
Yeah, actually after the game, Areola sort of said on those goals, "Cheap goals, messy goals. We knew set pieces were one of the strengths of Fenerbahçe. We've been dealing with them well, both this season and today. It's been something we've been working on since pre-season, but it cost us today. The last goal was maybe because they are strong and tall." I really loved that as an excuse. But the other two we have to control better. And I think he also said that it was so loud that maybe Gakpo and Alisson couldn't hear each other for that miscommunication. But Barry, it does look, it looks kind of weak.
Well, it was weak because that winner, Jonathan, spoke about the guy who scored it, Maricki, he didn't jump either.
Which held everyone down.
Four players under this ball that seemed to hang in the air for minutes. Nobody jumped. Alisson stayed rooted to his line. He could have come for it, and then none of the four players waiting for the header would have had anything to worry about. It was another ropey performance from Alisson, actually, after his boo-boo at the weekend. I think he was culpable for the second one as well. He could have come out for that. He's not having a particularly good season by his own high standards.
And Liverpool, the 2005 final against AC Milan, aside, their record in Turkey is really poor. They've only won one in nine away games in the Champions League there. And I was pretty impressed with Fenerbahçe here. I mean, I know their goals were fairly skanky, but, and heavily reliant on Liverpool defensive errors, but they, I thought they did really well here.
Would you agree with that, Lars?
Yeah, and I don't want to pick on Jeremy Jacquet because he started the season really well for Liverpool. I think he's been a very positive story for them. I think he's going to grow into being a very, very good center half indeed. But he's still young, right? He's still inexperienced. And it's just this sort of, it's such a strong image is almost a kind of cliché, and it's something you'd write if you were writing football fiction. Like you're going away to a team in Istanbul at the Sucre Sarı Kokluf, which is this sort of chocolate box, tight stadium, super, super loud, and you're having to play not against these flashy, glamorous Premier League players, but you're coming up against a 32-year-old striker who's six foot four from Kosovo, who spent half a lifetime sort of grafting away at various European leagues, but did score 23 goals for Mallorca last season.
So he's this kind of strong, wily experienced customer. And it's like, it's a different, it's part, I think it's part of growing up as a defender at this level to like, you're going to face those guys as well. And it's different to what you experience. And he just needs to be a little stronger in that situation. I was just wondering, like, you're right, McAllister was there, but I also think if you're McAllister and you're looking up at Maricki, you're just thinking, "Someone else is going to have to deal with this." Like, it doesn't really matter who jumps up high.
So I lower the rate.
I'm not getting there. You've got to bring in the Ents for this one.
There was this moment Bars, I think it was a 0-0, wasn't it? Green was running through and Simakas just sort of pushes him over. And you are like our sort of shove correspondent. And this must be, I mean, this is, of all the shoves, I can't understand how that isn't given.
No, me neither. It should definitely have been a penalty for Fenerbahçe and possibly a red card because he made no attempt to play the ball. So yeah, I don't understand why it wasn't given.
I don't either.
And in this game, Fenerbahçe, the score, the three goals came from set pieces. They should have had that penalty. And they absolutely smashed one off the crossbar as well. They could conceivably have won by more.
Positive to Liverpool, Jonny. I guess Nioni, big moment for him, you know, the second youngest Champions League scorer for Liverpool, behind Trent Alexander-Arnold. The youngest player to score his first Liverpool goal in the European Cup, surpassing David Odgaard's feat at PSV Eindhoven in December 2008. Just to mention David Odgaard.
That's a name I haven't heard in a while.
Quite a fun word to say. But it's interesting, Areola clearly rates him. I don't know if you've seen enough of him. I certainly haven't to make a judgment on what kind of midfielder he is and, you know, how high the ceiling is for him.
Yeah, I mean, I thought he had a really good game. A very, very controlled, you know, very composed on the ball. And, you know, he's a sort of player who I think the main worry about him at this point is, you know, how is he going to deal with really physical midfields? How is he going to deal with chaos? And I thought he acquitted himself really well. I mean, I think that goal was obviously going to give him a lot of confidence. I mean, in terms of other positives, I think Izak looked pretty good.
The midfield is still a real worry. And I think if you, I mean, if you look at that last five, ten minutes, and I was watching Wirtz, and he was running away from the ball a lot. And I just think of the times that Liverpool have found themselves in that situation. And, you know, Salah's going to get you out of it. You know, everyone's looking at Mo Salah, he's going to get you out of it. Or they're looking at Mané. He's going to bail us out of this. And I think I saw Liverpool looking around this team, going, "Who's going to actually get us out of this?"
Schob is like, "Is going to bury a free kick?" But, and Wirtz isn't that sort of player. He was doing a lot of little clever runs and making space. And, you know, I think we've had this debate to death about whether a £130 million player needs to be kind of more haptically involved. But I think it's a real fundamental issue that there are just going to be games where you can't tactic your way through it, where you need someone just to grab it.
And I don't think Liverpool have that player at the moment.
All right, let's go to the Leipzig-Man City game. City rotated a lot. I mean, it was a really great second half this, Lars, after a joyous own goal in the first half.
Yeah, and that was a meaningless one. I mean, you often think like these sort of crosses that gets bundled in, it was like, "Oh, it's unfortunate, you know, the defender had to do something." In this case, I'm not really sure he did have to do anything. It's like you watch it going, "What? There was no need for that." That was unfortunate. I think it's an endearing thing about the City team, if we can ever use that word about that club right now, is that they are now, I've said it a million times, but it keeps being true, they are no longer able to control games in the way they were.
And it's one of the things that made them so unstoppable. They can't do it anymore. What they can do is create chances against just about anyone, but they will give you a sniff, as they say. And RB Leipzig, you know, were dangerous. For me as a Norwegian, great to see Antonio Nusa really having like a breakthrough moment. He's such a talented guy. And he's been around for a while now. If you're like a European football sicko, you know all about Antonio Nusa. He's had full seasons behind him in Belgium with Club Brugge.
But there's always been this sense that for someone who's as talented as he is, he doesn't, his actual impact in games is not as big as it could be. Genuinely two-footed, you know, his big idol when he was young was Neymar. And I think you can see that in the way he moves, the way he treats the ball. And noticing the thing about his goals, or the goal he scores in this one, it's a very confidently taken strike with his left. But if you remember in the summer, he scored a brilliant goal for Norway versus Ivory Coast. And that was curling it in the top corner with his right. Like he is a proper sort of, yeah, you can use both his legs.
And it's often frustrating to see that he's not, his end product isn't as big as it can be, but now he's got four goals and six assists in eight games in the Bundesliga. Like he's having that kind of moment where he's actually putting it together. And I think that puts him in a very, very high bracket in the hierarchy of, you know, young stars in Europe. So I love seeing that.
Just on the own goal, I think Bill Leslie was doing the international comms, and he gave a very understated, "Well, that was not supposed to happen like that," which I really enjoyed as a line. Now look, Jonny, that's a great change.
I think what happened there, he was a little unfortunate in that he went to flick the ball away towards the touchline or out for a corner with his right foot, but it hit his standing leg and just went in. So it was somewhat unlucky, I would say.
Yeah, that's very generous of you. Donner Bomhanov.
I'm a generous man.
No, I know that. But Jonny, Donner Bomhanov had another weird night. I mean, there was one stunning save, I think it was from Baumgartner. And, you know, the weird goal he conceded at his near post. Just, and I'm worried I've created this idea that he isn't any good anymore. And so I want to kind of prove it every time I watch him. But he is an odd goalkeeper.
That Baumgartner save was, I think it was literally like a couple of minutes before the error. And at first viewing, it doesn't look so bad. You know, sometimes you just get a freaky shot that sneaks in. But when you actually, when you look at the replay, you realize that he's actually, he's a good six yards out of his goal. He's come a long way. And actually offered Baku a quite sizable target there, which is, you know, you could say that's poor anticipation or, you know, equally you could say that it's a keeper who has maybe come into a team where I think the onus is on him to be a lot more proactive and a lot more coming forward than he has been in his career so far.
And he's still, I think, trying to work out exactly, how to judge him exactly how proactive he wants to be as a keeper. So I wouldn't call it a decline as such. You know, I think he's still, you know, he's still, what, is this in his 20s? But, so I, you know, I think he's a class keeper. He's still working out his role in this team. And I think he's still working out his identity in this City team. And occasionally it just manifests in some quite weird looking errors. There was a goal against Liverpool, right?
There was the one where he basically sort of cleared it into his own net. Do you remember that last season? And I think it's just, his brain gets slightly scrambled and that's what happens when you're playing a slightly different game to what you're used to.
Yeah, he's 27. He did have a couple of other wrecks yesterday that he got away with. It was when it was still 0-0. Antonio Nusa had a long-range effort, which he almost flapped into his own goal. And you could see his heart was in his boots, but it went over the bar rather than under it. And then towards the end, there was a round free kick from out wide. And he misjudged the flight of that, but it dropped onto the crossbar. So it could have been a catastrophic night for him, but he kind of got away with it.
And obviously, yeah, there was that brilliant save from Baumgartner.
He's 27 until, of course, he's 28. Lars, look, the last two goals from City were great. The Fernandes bullet header enjoyed that. And then the move for the Haaland goal is super.
Yeah, and it's Erling doing, Erling Haaland doing what he's really good at, which is attacking those sort of spaces. And I think, again, he has had periods at City where he's frustrated about the number of times that ball arrives. Because they do like a more patient build-up sometimes. But I think Elliot Anderson deserves obviously his flowers for just a brilliant assist there. And I thought he was very good. He's been a very good signing. I will count myself among the people who were a little skeptical about whether he could make the jump up from the way, not necessarily ability-wise.
He's a great player, but it's a really big, Jonathan Lou very astutely mentioned the different styles for the goalkeeper. It's also a hugely different style being a midfielder for Man City, for being it for a counterattacking Nottingham Forest team. Your job description is incredibly different. And I wasn't convinced that was going to work, but you see him, he's really comfortable on the ball. And in this case, made it like this driving run forwards and put the ball in. It was really, really good.
Arsenal are 2-1 at Slavia Prague, their third away game in seven days. It sort of showed Bars. They look pretty leggy in this. And, you know, had Slavia Prague scored a bit earlier, it could have been a different outcome.
Yeah, it wasn't a particularly good performance from Arsenal, especially in the second half. They took their foot off the gas at 2-0 up. Mikel Arteta was not happy after the game. You could see he was fuming with cheapness, with which Arsenal gave the ball away with the chances they gave away. And Slavia Prague did have chances to score before they did. I thought they should have had a penalty for a Merino Barge at a corner.
Gabriel had a head a couple off the line. Ray had to make a save. Kubiak had a header from distance that hit the post and Ray had to scramble to keep it from crossing the line. So Slavia Prague did have the chances to equalize earlier and they didn't quite take them. Then they scored, yeah, Novak header when Raya had wandered off his line a bit into no man's land. But it's, you know, it's one of those games.
You go away to Slavia Prague, you come home with the three points. Apparently, it was a year to the day since Arsenal last played Slavia Prague. And if you win these games, it doesn't really matter about performance, I think. Yeah, but Arteta was not happy afterwards.
No, he said that we're extremely far from our standards in everything that we have to do, in every basic, in every concept, and in everything that we discussed to avoid the game that we played in the second half. That is a huge learning, he said. The Merino one was, I think Novak headed it and Merino headed him instead of the ball. And it's kind of the head isn't, you can't foul someone with a head unless, of course, you do a head-butting action where there's no ball anywhere near you and then you can. But like he really nuttered him, but it wasn't a penalty. The positive, I guess, Lars is, you know, Jochourez setting one up, scoring one, you know, being good.
I thought the Jochourez goal was very good and I thought it was interesting because he did the exact thing that I think he gets criticized for not being able to do, which is the strike on him is that he's just a little clumsy. His technique is not always quite on point and in the Premier League it means he often doesn't quite get the space he needs to get a shot off because he gets closed down too quickly. But here you can see his touch is perfect and he, again, without having too much space to work with, gets a really, really good finish off. Kind of clutching at straws here really because in the name of Scandinavian solidarity, I would quite like him to succeed, but maybe that is a sign that he is improving.
I also just thought a lot, I didn't watch the full 90. I kind of wish I watched the 90 minutes of this game. Because one of the things Arteta said after the game that he had warned the team at halftime that Slavia Prague, they don't quit, you know, they're going to keep working. But he also said they are going to become even more chaotic. And I'm not sure what that means. I should probably go back and watch the second half. What does it mean for a team to become more chaotic? How does that manifest itself? But I also think Arsenal do, out of all the teams who you'd think of as Champions League contenders to win it, I do think Arsenal are the one who have that steeliness in them that when the game completely gets away from them, as this clearly did, they conceded 11 shots from inside the box in the second half.
That shouldn't happen. But when that happens, they have this defensive organization to them that they can ride that out. Now, you should not have to ride out a game against Slavia Prague maybe, but they can do it in a way that I don't think any of the other top teams in Europe actually can. And I think it's one of the reasons they're so successful.
Unless you're incredibly time-rich, Lars, I'd say you don't have to go back and watch the second half of Slavia Prague, Arsenal. You know, and you know, for all the dogginess of Slavia Prague, they have set the record in the competition for the longest time without a victory, 22 matches in the competition stretching back.
23 matches.
Is it 23?
23.
Thank you so much for the update.
So I'm thinking maybe becoming more and more chaotic in games might not be a good thing.
Probably not.
Like maybe it's not what you want.
They won their first game in 2007 and that's been it for them. Any thoughts on Arsenal, Jonny?
Just, I thought they looked weirdly arrogant in the second half. That you could see Arteta, I mean, Arteta, I think he said this after the Brighton game, he said this after the Leeds game as well, where they were a little bit underpowered. That the intensity of Arsenal is their superpower. They don't have, you know, they don't have like a Yamal or a Haaland. They don't have a, you know, a generational talent. They don't have 14 Champions Leagues behind them. They don't have a state backing them. Their one superpower is that kind of like really intense energy to them, the obsession, the relentlessness to just keep making the right decision again and again and again.
And Arteta knows this. You know, Arteta knows that this team, take the intensity away from this team and that they could honestly be anyone. And I think he sees, he will have seen that, okay, they won at Anfield, huge kind of emotional high, then comes Slavia Prague and Hull and the international break. And he can see the little lull coming almost before it happens. And I think that's what we saw in the second half. I think it was a little glimpse of just how important that energy and relentlessness and intensity is to them.
All right, that'll do for part one. Part two, we'll begin with Real Madrid's victory at AEK Athens. Welcome to part two of the Guardian Football Weekly. I mentioned it in the intro, Bars, but you get the sense that Real Madrid are being quite Real Madrid in this Champions League, finding a way.
Certainly are, aren't they?
José Mourinho, you can just see, you know, can we handle José winning this whole competition? Like they've got the players to do it. You know, how they pulled this one out, I don't know.
I don't mind José doing well as long as he's not doing well in an environment where I have to watch all his interviews and pay attention to his press conferences and see his team play week in, week out. So if he wants to go and win the Champions League with Real Madrid, that's fine with me. I have no problem with that. But we saw they came back from the dead to beat Roma last game week.
And this week they went behind twice and emerged 3-2 winners with a wonderful Fede Valverde strike in added time. So that is a very Real Madrid way of going about things. There was five goals in this game. I thought four of them were top drawer. Jude Bellingham was probably the pick of them, but Valverde was excellent as well. The one that the AEK Athens left back scored where he made this absolutely long-busting run from inside his own half, played probably the longest 1-2 between passes in the history of football and fired home.
Just a brilliant goal for him. Pilios is his name. Yeah, and probably the most boring goal was just Kylian Mbappe tapping home a squared ball from Denzel Dumfries. But yeah, some brilliant goals in this game. Real Madrid doing Real Madrid things. And will they be good enough to win the competition? Maybe. Who knows?
Yeah, Pilios has only scored three goals for AEK Athens. And two of them have been against Real Madrid and Man City in the last few weeks. The power that Bellingham gets, like the timing, Jonny, of that backheel. It's like a sort of half volley. It's so beautiful.
It's just such. It's pure talent, isn't it? If you pulled that, if one of us pulled that off, we would be talking about it 10 years later.
I mean, I've talked about far worse goals 10 years later. And Barry's talked about a head we didn't even score for 25 years.
If I had scored that goal on the five-a-side pitch, I think I would be well within my rights to never play football again. You'd just sort of, you know, you'd just sashay out of there. And no celebration. Like he just, he doesn't celebrate it, which I love that. It was very, very modest, very understated, very Yeoman, very 1950s. Like you just, you know, a little handshake with your inside half, Chubby Taylor, or whatever his name would be. And, you know, back across the center circle. And I think, you know, just to follow on from the Madrid discussion, I think when you have players of that caliber, you're never quite out of it, are you?
Like they were pretty ropey for an hour. And suddenly, you know, you get players like Bellingham and Mbappe and Diamande who can just pull something out of the bag. That's why they're always going to be a threat.
I didn't see all this game because I was watching the Galatasaray-Liverpool one. But I believe that was Bellingham's second backheel goal of the game. But the first one was ruled out for offside and was apparently even better. So I haven't seen it, but I've heard about it. And last night, that was his 60th Champions League appearance. So he's the youngest player to reach that. His 60th milestone, I suppose it is. It's not 50, it's not 100, but it's a number within a zero at the end of it.
He's the youngest player to reach that milestone at the age of 23. So maybe he should retire after scoring that goal. And I mean, that goal, the cross was like a bullet.
Yeah, yeah. He surpasses David and Gogh with that record, of course. And if you remember, I've probably told this story before, and you know, and it's proof, Jonny. If you remember Gianfranco Zola's volley for Chelsea against Norwich through the legs, if you remember that one, I did that, Carl Schulten away. And honestly, like the look of absolute shock on everyone. Like I didn't Bellingham. I didn't celebrate. Like, you know, I didn't celebrate because no one, including me, could believe it. But it definitely happened.
A cross from Rob Elliott into the top corner. And I probably should have stopped playing.
No, I think if you...
Could get another column out of it next year. Yes, Jonny?
If you score a goal that is demonstrably too good for your talent, I think there is a certain embarrassment that follows it. You can't really say, unless you're a twats. Like, unless you're a twats, you can't really say, oh yeah, well, that is entirely indicative of my ability on a football pitch. I think you do have to be slightly bashful about it.
You're right. Although it's highly possible that I didn't celebrate because it was too good for me. But I'm also a twats. I mean, both things are possible. What do you make of Real Madrid's? Lars, I mean, we haven't really talked a lot about that Valverde strike, which is absolutely perfect.
No, I was going to be that person and say, okay, clearly, I mean, technically, yes, the Bellingham goal is the greater achievement possibly. Just find the Valverde shot so incredibly satisfying to watch. I don't know, there's something about the angle and the trajectory of the ball. It just feels pleasant. It triggers positive chemicals in my brain to watch that goal. Real Madrid are motoring. That's seven straight wins for them now. And I have a theory. My brain kind of pricked up a little bit as well when you said, ah, Real Madrid or Real Madriding.
But the interesting thing about that is all those sort of bizarro late wins that we remember that they've had in the Champions League and their ability to pull it out of the bag. Almost all of them were with a completely different group. Like that was the Toni Kroos, Luka Modrić, Sergio Ramos was still around probably, like all these dudes. And very, very few of these people are still in the building. This is a completely new group. This is a younger group. This is the group of Bellingham and Mbappe and Valverde and the guys. And I've been quite critical of them last couple of years because I think they've behaved like crybabies on occasion. And I think that's one of the reasons they haven't had those successes because you have to take responsibility for your own successes and failures.
The reason I'm saying all this is now, I think it's really significant that they had this comeback against Roma where they were terrible for a long part of the game, but they came back. This comeback, yes, is just against AEK, a Greek team. But I think it matters a lot that they also go to the new camp knowing that they have to win to keep the league title, the league race alive, and they managed to do it. Because I think you're trying to build a new group at Real Madrid who are unbelievably talented, but don't have that mentality yet. They haven't built that. They haven't experienced those highs.
They haven't broken through those barriers. And I think every time a team actually is under the caution that way and have to go deep and have to find something and you actually manage to do it, I think that's worth an extra half point because it teaches the players that this is possible. And the next time they're in that situation, they are so much more likely to do it. Anyone who listens to this podcast will know that I wang on about stats a lot, but I'm also slightly obsessed with like the sports psychology of the thing. I think it's so important. And I think the second a group has experienced overcoming these difficult situations, it becomes so much easier to do it again.
So I think this little period that Real Madrid have had now is quite significant in terms of them trying to build another team that can really do things.
Well, I'm going to Jamie Jackson reporting on JJ Gabriel saying that Real Madrid are close to an agreement with him and they can sign him via a FIFA loophole that allows clubs in the EU to secure young players on professional contracts if they have an EU passport. Gabriel walked out on, Gabriel, sorry, walked out on United in September, is believed to be training in Spain. Has anybody, there's been so much written about this footballer who I've never seen play and I just, there's almost been so much content I haven't really followed it that much. I don't know if anyone else has or has any sort of strong views on all parts of this story, I guess, because, you know, it's young players and tapping up or not tapping up or freedom of movement or what a parent should do for a player and all those kind of things are sort of quite interesting.
Yeah, Lars?
I have a strong view, which is I think it's extremely problematic that there's been this kind of global media attention on someone who is essentially a child, legally speaking at least, who has played no senior appearances anywhere. Yet you have the sort of sports media industry that we're all part of in some way or another churning out content, looking for clicks and stuff about his future and what he wants to do and what he doesn't want to do. I think it's extremely unhealthy and I think the best thing we can do is not talk about it at all.
No further questions.
I totally agree.
Yeah. Okay, that's fair.
I mean, I hold his team responsible for that as well. I mean, he's not, like JJ Gabriel isn't planting his own stories in the Daily Telegraph. So there was clearly an industry at work behind him.
Fair. Well, let's talk about Lens One, Como Nine. Ed saying a 4-1 defeat at Como looking a pretty decent result now. Carrick in. The biggest margin of victory in Champions League history. Nine is a lot of goals, isn't it? They were one they're up after half an hour and then the goals didn't stop. As far as I could tell, Nico Paz scored one and set up about 25 more. The greatest part of this barrier is that the best goal of the night was scored by Lens. That was my takeaway from this.
That was my note. Ruben Aguileras' sweet volley into the far corner from an outswinging corner to make it 7-1. And then the way he sort of rallied the troops with a lasso motion. Come on, guys. We can do this.
7-1 is a dangerous lead. Next goal's crucial, lads.
But yeah, it was the best goal of the night. So there's that for Lens. They were appalling and Como were just rampant. Looking at mine, yeah, just I made a note of the nine goals or the 10 goals and Nico Paz's name seems to feature quite sleeping off the page at me from a number of areas. De Vica scored a hat trick. I think a couple of Italian lads scored for Como. I think some of the criticism Ces Fàbregas has been getting according to James Horncastle, Italian expert, is that he doesn't give enough Italians opportunities.
So there's a couple of them on the score sheet yesterday. But they and I suppose Viking are the stories of this Champions League mega group stage so far. And who knows how deep they could go in the competition. I mean, they're not going to have opposition as obliging as Manchester United and Lens every week, but you can only beat what's in front of you or you can only hammer what's in front of you.
No, you're right. The guy's got a hat trick. De Vica's no relation of Steve Vickers, by the way. Jonny, I guess Como went out of the stage of you wouldn't want to play them, you know, like as the tournament progresses.
No, I think so many teams you see them come into the Champions League for the first time and they just look discomforted. Whatever they did the previous season, there is something about the step up in level that seems to disorient them a little bit. You saw it with Leverkusen actually the year after they won the Bundesliga. Como have just absolutely taken to this stage. A really high level of technical ability. They compete physically as well. They're not scared to just get in a cross and look for the big man as well.
They play with tempo and rhythm and obviously a huge amount of confidence. You know, the interesting thing about Nico Paz, who obviously, you know, came from Real Madrid and Madrid have a buyback, an 80 million euro buyback clause that expires next summer. So basically until next summer, you know, Madrid could take one of Europe's best young players for a pretty decent fee. And it's an interesting one because, you know, I think a lot of Madrid fans would love to see Nico Paz at Madrid, but also, you know, where do you fit him in?
If you think about the players they've got in those positions, you know, Arda Güler obviously is the obvious player, you know, who would be playing in that sort of right-sided role. So it's an interesting one. You know, how would, you know, if you're Madrid, how do you find a room for Nico Paz, but also how do you not, how do you not, you know, want to take a chance on a talent like this? So yeah, Como, I think they're going to win to this Sunday, which is basically the one team. I think they've been to Napoli and they've been to Juventus and beaten them and it enters basically the one team they haven't really beaten.
So that's the next big test for them.
I saw footage on social media of the Como players. They just arrived at the stadium and were going out to, you know, inspect the pitch or wander around and have a look around. And they were all wearing what looked like impossibly expensive overcoats, suits, and very expensive looking loafers with no socks. So they're a very dapper team as well as a very free-scoring one.
And people say they don't play in the Italian way. Come on. They're bringing the culture. My question is, does this result mean that United have actually beaten Lens 5-0?
Well, of course. Yeah, that is effectively. That's how football works, of course. Yeah. Maybe we should have some Football Weekly loafers as merch. I believe that the shop is not well stocked after Producer Joel's terrible half-and-half scarf idea. Viking 4, Saber 1, or Viking, apologies, Lars. I suspect they went into this game as favorites, right? But what's the feeling around Viking?
It's great. It's a win in the Champions League. This is a team that I think it was 2018 was in the second tier in the Norwegian football and they've won a game in the Champions League. They've won a game in the Champions League in which, if I'm right, they've started six players from the local area and four more came on off the bench. So you've got 10 players from the local area playing in a win in the Champions League. And this is not a huge place like the Stavanger region is, I'd say, about 300,000, 350,000 people. And I think that's incredible. I think that's absolutely unbelievable. And even if it's just Sabah from Azerbaijan, it's an incredible moment.
And I think it's one of those things that, again, it's why this tournament and its current format matters. Like I know there are people on the top of the football hierarchy who think you'll make more money if you just have the same big teams playing each other over and over again. But I think the whole point of this tournament is you don't have that. You have these stories. And this is a club that was completely down and out again less than 10 years ago. Got relegated, who were on the brink of just going under financially. They were completely gone. Their average attendance was half of what it is now.
And they completely reset. And what they did was not find a rich backer or anything. They reset by reconnecting with their local community. They say we have to be a club for the people of this region. And it's not just a lip service thing. They're genuinely open with their fans. They try to prioritize local players when they can. When they won the Norwegian title last year for the first time since 1991, I believe, 1992, '91, what they did was they sent the trophy on like a tour of the region. Like every day the trophy would be off to a kindergarten or a hospital ward or some kind of industry so people could, everyone could post.
We've all been in situations as journalists where we get to see the Premier League trophy or the Champions League. They sent it everywhere. And because Stavanger is the oil industry hub of Norway, they sent it out on an oil rig and lowered the trophy to the bottom of the ocean to just kind of the trophy went on tour. Because they don't just, it isn't just marketing speak that this is a club of the local people. They live that ethos. And that is kind of the power behind everything they do. So seeing them win in the Champions League with a ton of local players, seeing their homegrown center half score a goal and center blade by doing the worm, which is then replicated in the CBS studio by Micah Richards.
Like you might think that show is a bit cringe occasionally, but for a club like Viking where they come from to be seen in that way on a global stage is incredible. And it really matters. It's the whole point of this tournament in my opinion. So good day all around.
And also hilarious fourth goal. About sort of four ricochets where it squirmed in. It looked like that when it's next goal wins after two hours at fireside where nobody can move type goal. Elsewhere, Club Brugge won 2-1 at PSV, Dortmund beat Real Betis 2-1, Porto beat Napoli 4-1. My only note is, oh, that's where Jan Bednarek is. Porto's, sorry to steal what I presume I know you also had, Barry.
No, I didn't.
The opening goal for Porto. But unless anyone has any fascinating things to say about any of those three games, I will move to the next bit of this podcast.
We're just looking at the top eight of the group, about halfway through the group stage. I suppose Como are the only real surprise inclusion in there, presumably at the expense of Bayern Munich. You've got four English teams, Arsenal, Villa City, Liverpool, PSG, Real Madrid, Barcelona, and yeah, Como are the only kind of outlier in the top eight.
Does that say something about the format? I don't.
I don't know either. I guess Napoli sort of not qualifying might be the biggest side in that bottom section at this stage, but you know, four games to go. We will see what happens. That'll do for part two, part three. We'll talk about West Ham's comeback yesterday and do a Premier League preview. Welcome to part three of the Guardian Football Weekly. As we mentioned yesterday, FSA award nominations are open. And if you haven't voted yet and you heard yesterday's pod, shame on you, but also please vote for us.
We're up for podcast of the year. The Guardian is up for men's football media of the year. Lucy Ward for Pundit. The Guardian women's football weekly for women's football media. Susie Rack for writer. Seb Hutchinson and Robin Cowan for commentator. So there is a website. If you go to thefsa.org.uk, you will find out how to get there. So vote and create many accounts and vote many times. Scott Parker was confirmed as West Ham manager yesterday. He was in the dugout for the Cardiff game. At halftime, they were 3-0 down and they drew 3-3.
I don't know if anyone has caught the highlights of this game. Speak now or I can talk you through it. But Jared Bowen was brilliant in this one. Basically set up all three goals. Almost a sort of Harry Kane style for two of them, sort of dropping back into midfield and playing beautiful balls over the top. So that was quite a morale-boosting point for Scott Parker. Big win for Wrexham over Middlesbrough. Big win for Phil Parkinson in particular.
That seemed like a real shock, Wrexham beating Burrows after all the flowers we hurled Burrows' way last when we did our last EFL podcast. We should probably give a tip of the hat, by the way, to Jack Moylin, who scored a hat trick for Cardiff against West Ham. I saw one of his sensational goals.
Oh, yeah. It was a brilliant goal. And also a mention of Sean Neave, 19-year-old, who's on loan from Newcastle at Wolves, came off the bench to score both and he sort of headed one. He was almost in the goal when he scored the winner in the 89th minute, but ended up in the goal as well. It was brilliant. I think the most interesting thing about the Premier League weekend is these five managers who might not be there after it. You know, you've got Carrick, Glasner, LeBris, Saj, and Gijslaer-Baz. How many do you reckon will still be there in two weeks' time?
I had made a note of this before you said it and I checked to see what's the biggest number of Premier League managers ever to be sacked in a day and it's two and I think that's happened three times.
Right.
And right, if you look at the game, so Matthias Gijslaer, Newcastle away at Fulham, I'd give Fulham every chance of winning that match. Oliver Glasner, Forest, home at City against City, they'll probably lose. Regis LeBris, Sunderland home against Chelsea, I'd say Chelsea will probably win that. Pierre Sarge, Palace at home against Liverpool, fancy Liverpool there. And Michael Carrick, Man United home against Villa.
You know, one half of good Champions League football against Roma aside, you would definitely fancy Villa to win that. So there is, it's not beyond the realms of possibility that we could lose five with an international break beginning on Monday. There's every chance you could have five managers getting the bullet in the space of a couple of days.
I've written a piece about this. I mean, the most excited person is presumably Sean Dyche's agent, who is just sitting there going, "Another million? Oh, I'll go there. Another million? Maybe manage more than one club, I imagine." Yeah, what do you reckon, Johnny?
Well, I think some of them are closer to the edge than others, aren't they? I mean, like Sarge does seem a little bit out of his depth. Palace. LeBris, I think it would be harsh on, I think it would be really harsh on LeBris, especially given what he's done over the last couple of seasons. I think he still has a bit of credit in the bank. I wouldn't actually rule out them getting results against Chelsea, sort of depending on what happens. We're sort of recording this before the Europa League games.
Carrick has probably bought himself, he's probably bought himself the international break with that comeback against, yeah, the time to sack him was probably two weeks ago. And it's very clear that they are sort of, they're maneuvering, they're thinking about the next move. But I think there was something about that comeback that just, I don't know. It bought him a week. It bought him a couple of weeks. Gijslaer is an interesting one. There was a big, there was a story by Craig Hope in the mail last night about how the Newcastle players are finding it quite baffled, are finding Gijslaer's tactics really baffling.
Things like, you know, they're not quite sure what he wants from them. And they're sort of baffled by, you know, insisting on playing a number 10 when they don't seem to have a natural number 10. And I think all of this stems from Gijslaer's comments after the Everton game on Monday night where he said, "Well, you know, I didn't ask them to be playing long balls. They weren't doing what I told them to do." And that does seem to have disintegrated quite quickly, really, because there are a lot of senior players in that dressing room. And Eddie Howard was such a respected figure that for all the talent that has left that club, there are still senior players who I think have a pretty strong idea of how they think this Newcastle team should play.
And Gijslaer hasn't really earned that trust yet. So even though it felt like one of those appointments that, you know, okay, they're going to give him a while, he's a promising coach, and they're going to let him rebuild. It's actually a relationship that looks like it's kind of going to ground quite quickly.
I suppose, Lars, the international break is a sensible time to sack managers, but it does seem sort of, you know, just because you get there when most of your players aren't there, so you get a chance to just, you know, like sort your office out before everyone comes in. I mean, that aside, it just does seem slightly strange that it's, I mean, maybe they'll all keep their jobs, who knows? But it happens very regularly, doesn't it? I don't know if it just seems so obvious as a time to just sort of have a little place card in the season to go, "Well, now's a good time."
Yeah, because you don't have a game in like two and a half days, which you usually do, right? It's pretty non-stop now. And just, I think, I mean, this is unludicrous, but I actually think the admin and the turnaround of just getting people out of the office, getting a new person into the office, having team meetings so that the players have at least seen the new guy before the first game. Like that stuff is actually not easy to do when you have midweek games all the time and you have to travel and you have recovery sessions. I think there's a very logical reason for that. Out of all of these, Glasner's the one that fascinates me because it is the XG thing of like their XG difference is still the fourth best in the league.
It's like ludicrous that they're in the situation they are. And this is such an interesting point where my two sort of enthusiasms for stats and psychology kind of crash because the statistical argument is if your XG numbers are that good, just keep doing what you're doing and you'll be fine. But here's the thing, it's really hard to keep doing what you're doing when you're not winning games. It sucks when losing football games sucks. The media will be after you. Like players will get annoyed. They'll lose confidence in themselves. They'll lose confidence in each other. They'll lose confidence in what the manager's telling them.
And it could be based on the post-game interview at the weekend. Maybe Glasner is losing confidence in some of the things he's doing. It's really hard to tell a group actually what you're doing is fine when you keep losing games. So this is where the psychology side of that comes in. And I'm really fascinated to see how that situation plays out because I would look at the numbers and say, "This is fine. Keep doing what you're doing, Oliver." But of course, you also look at the table and say, "Ooh, this is actually not fine."
One imagines, and I could be doing a bit of service, but I suspect Marinakos isn't going, "Well, our XG is fine and we played really well against Palace and lost 3-1, so that's okay."
Stay the course. Well, they're probably not bringing Daishin is all I'm saying because that was not ideal when that happened.
You're probably right because see, Glasner's just popping back to Palace, couldn't you go? Well, why not?
That was a mistake by everyone involved. Let's just go back to.
Exactly. I know where the toilets are. Let me in. In the game's featuring managers that we, yeah, in the game's featuring managers who we presume will still be there after the international break. You've got Leeds, Spurs. Leeds were that a win in five? Spurs won their last three. Means nothing. Brighton, Brentford. Brentford haven't won away all season. Arsenal play whole. Everton conferences on Friday night and Ipswich, Bournemouth. Anything jump out? Yeah, we've got quite a Spurs-y panel here. Lars and Johnny, how are you feeling about the Tottenham renaissance, Johnny?
The bandwagon, the Juggernauts, the Dreadnought, getting like firing missiles off its hindquarters. I don't know. I sort of lost my train of thought there. It's incredible. Just, you know, what a few goals will do for the confidence of a team. From maybe like three or four weeks ago, you just didn't know where the next goal was going to come from. And, you know, even the Coventry game where I think all three goals came from outside the area.
And, you know, it just felt a little bit chanty, but sometimes you need those goals to go in just to remind everyone what it feels like, you know, to hear a ball hit a net and hear the sound after it. You know, humans are very simple and Pavlovian like that. And so it is with Spurs. I didn't realize that Leeds had kind of stuttered to that extent, actually. So, you know, maybe it's a good time to play them.
Yeah, probably isn't. But there we go. Any other games, Baz, that catch your eye? You can say no.
Brighton-Brentford's an interesting one. Obviously, there's a lot of animosity between the owners of the respective clubs. Matthew Benham and Tony Bloom used to be partners, business partners, and then fell out. They're well-run clubs. We were obliged to say it. Yeah, that one's interesting. Everton-Coventry. Everton are a weird team insofar as they're doing pretty well, but quite a few of their fans seem, it's like when David Moyes was at West Ham and even though he was doing well.
Tough catch a break, this poor guy.
Yeah, honest to God. He won the trophy, but a lot of West Ham's fans didn't like the pragmatism of his football. And the same seems to be the case at Everton. But he's doing really well this season and he's one of the few dinosaur managers that's still working, if you know what I mean. I don't mean that as an insult to him. So, and Coventry, they're doing all right.
Yeah, I think they're good.
So, yeah, that is, I'm interested in the Leeds-Tottenham one as well because Tottenham will get bullied in this game. You know, however well they play, Leeds are a big physical side of bullies. And we'll let's see how lads at Tottenham deal with that as part of their renaissance.
Sure. Part of the Juggernaut, which suddenly one slight push and it all falls to pieces like a clown car. Yes, Lars.
United-Aston Villa for me.
Of course.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Aston Villa, who are a massive club, we should say, just be very clear, huge club. They've had this suggestion of there being interest in Unai Emery's services from Man United. It seems that instead Unai Emery is going to sign a contract extension. That seems to be the latest news. And good on Unai Emery for using this sort of, he's had a good start to the, well, he's managed to figure this team out.
Jamie Carragher get a cut? Is that what happens?
And, well, they had a disastrous start to the season, but he has shown that actually he's able to knit this group of guys together into another team that looks like it's going to be able to do well. And then United's interest come down. Instead of going to United, he's maybe get himself a little pay rise out of that situation. I think that's well played, Unai, if that's how that's gone down. And I think interestingly, it's the football gods, you know, they know what they're doing. Sometimes they throw up these things. When there's been so much talk about this, then Aston Villa, massive club, go away to Manchester United and have a chance for Unai to kind of show them what they're not getting, possibly.
Yeah, I think it is the game of the weekend, isn't it? Also, first round properly, the FA Cup ties to look out for Oxford City taking on Leicester City. Burton play Rushton at Diamonds, who reached this round for the first time in their history. The first ever shoot I did for the Soccer Ham Glory Years was a day's filming with Anne Diamond so that we could go, "How did Rushton at Diamonds do last week?" And we go, "Oh, they got whipped." And then it would cut to Anne Diamond whipping me or something like that. It's been an up and down week for Rushton at Diamond. Cut to me and Anne Diamond bouncing up and down on a trampoline.
It was a surreal day.
It was a different time, Matt.
It was a difference. Of course it was. You know, I did have a shirt off, but I was wearing, I was clad from the waist down while being whipped by Anne Diamond. Anyway, Wimborne Town take on Crawley. Stafford Rangers home to Grimsby. Craig Wanderers, who've played seven games already to get here, take on Stockport County. And then might you use go to Bristol Rovers.
They're not Irish. I'm Craig Wanderers Irish.
That's Bray one. That's Bray.
It's the wrong Wanderers.
One of my neighbours yesterday asked me, an elderly woman asked me, "What do you know about Bravey's?" She said, "What do you know about Craig Wanderers for Stockport?" Because she knows I'm a football journalist. I said, "What?" And she, I made the same mistake Johnny just did. I thought she said Bray Wanderers. And I said, "Why would Bray Wanderers be playing Stockport County?" So then she clarified for me, and it turns out someone she used to work with is being interviewed on, I think, I was going to say Football Focus, but it isn't Football Focus, is it?
But he's being interviewed by the BBC because he reports on Craig Wanderers. Got it. I love the idea that, you know, you're just the football savant of Brixton. Elderly women thrown from knockers on the door all the way down the pyramid to say, "Talk to me about Stockport County," and you're like, "I don't even know where Sergio Ramos is. Don't ask me about Craig Wanderers being Stockport County, for goodness' sake." Anyway.
I'll tell you, Craig Wanderers, they're in the Eastmin League and Stockport County are second in League One. So it would be quite the upset if Craig Wanderers beat them.
Well, we're all Craig Wanderers now. Good luck to them. Good luck to everyone else. Thank you, everybody. That'll do for today. Cheers, Baz.
Thank you.
Thank you, Johnny.
Yeah, thank you.
Thanks, Lars.
Thank you, Max.
Football Weekly is produced by Matt Bentley-Varney and Ty Papoula. The executive producer is Joel Grove. And we'll be back on Monday.
This is The Guardian.
Max Rushden is joined by Barry Glendenning, Lars Sivertsen and Jonathan Liew as Liverpool lose for the first time in the Champions League this season and Manchester City and Arsenal escape with narrow wins. Help support our independent journalism at theguardian.com/footballweeklypod. Watch us on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@FootballWeeklyPodcast