Transcript of Elon Musk — "In 36 months, the cheapest place to put AI will be space”

02:49:45 123 min read 0 views Published 9 months ago

Copy link
Episode summary

In this Dwarkesh Podcast interview, Elon Musk discusses why he believes orbital data centers could become the cheapest place to run AI within about three years, arguing that flat electricity output on Earth and slow utilities make power the main bottleneck. The conversation covers solar manufacturing, turbine and chip supply chains, Starship's design and economics, and Musk's view of AI alignment through truth-seeking.

He also talks about xAI's business strategy, Optimus humanoid robots and American manufacturing compared with China, SpaceX management practices, and his views on DOGE and government fraud. Musk's forecasts are presented as his own predictions, and listeners get his reasoning on the engineering and policy tradeoffs.

In this episode Dwarkesh Patel, Elon Musk

This Elon Musk interview transcript on orbital data centers was made with HappyScribe technology, the same kind behind Google Meet transcription.

Speaker 100:00:00

So are there really 3 hours of questions, or has it—

Elon Musk00:00:03

Yeah.

Speaker 100:00:03

Are you fucking serious?

Elon Musk00:00:04

Yeah.

Speaker 100:00:07

You don't think there's a lot to talk about, Elon?

Elon Musk00:00:08

Holy fuck, man.

Speaker 100:00:10

I mean, it's the most interesting point. All the storylines are kind of converging.

Elon Musk00:00:15

Yeah.

Speaker 100:00:15

Right now, so we'll see how much we're—

Elon Musk00:00:17

It's almost like I've landed.

Speaker 100:00:19

Exactly. Well, we'll get to that.

Elon Musk00:00:21

That would never do such a thing.

Speaker 100:00:23

So, as you know better than anybody else, the total cost of ownership of a data center—only 10 to 15 percent is energy, and that's the part you're presumably saving by moving this into space. Most of it's the GPUs. If they're in space, it's harder to service them, or you can't service them, and so the depreciation cycle goes down on them. So, like, it's just way more expensive to have the GPUs in space. Presumably. What's the reason to put them in space?

Elon Musk00:00:45

Um, well, the availability of energy is the issue. So, I mean, if you look at electrical output outside of China, everywhere outside of China it's more or less flat. It's very, you know, maybe a slight increase, but pretty much flat. China has a rapid increase in electrical output. But if you're putting data centers anywhere except China, where are you going to get your electricity? Especially as you scale. The output of chips is growing pretty much exponentially, but the output of electricity is flat.

So how are you going to turn them chips on?

Speaker 100:01:19

Um, you know—

Elon Musk00:01:21

Magical power sources? Magical electricity ferries?

Speaker 100:01:24

You mean you're famously a big— you're famously a big fan of solar. One terawatt of solar power. So with a 25 percent capacity factor, like 4 terawatts of solar panels, it's like 1 percent of the land area of the United States. And that's like far— you were in the singularity when we got one terawatt of data centers, right? So what are you running out of, exactly?

Elon Musk00:01:42

How far into the singularity are you, though?

Speaker 100:01:44

You tell me.

Elon Musk00:01:45

Yeah, exactly. So I think we'll find we're in the singularity and like, okay, let's look a long way to go.

Speaker 100:01:51

But is this like a— is the plan to, like, put it in the space after we've covered Nevada and solar panels?

Elon Musk00:01:56

I think it's pretty hard to cover Nevada and solar panels. You have to get, like, permits from— like, the permits for— try getting the permits for that.

Speaker 100:02:02

So space is really a— it's really a regulatory play. It's like harder to build on land than it is in space.

Elon Musk00:02:08

It's harder to scale on the ground than it is to scale in space. But also the— you're going to get about five times the effectiveness of solar panels in space versus the ground. And you don't need batteries. I almost wore my other shirt, which says it's always sunny in space. Which it is. So, because you don't have a day-night cycle or seasonality clouds or an atmosphere in space.

Because the atmosphere alone results in about a 30 percent loss of energy. So you're going to— any given solar panel is going to do about five times more power in space than on the ground. And you avoid the cost of having batteries to carry you through the night. So it's actually much cheaper to do it in space. And my prediction is that it will be by far the cheapest place to put AI will be space in 36 months or less.

Maybe 30 months.

Speaker 100:03:17

36 months?

Elon Musk00:03:17

Less than 36 months.

Speaker 100:03:19

How do you service GPUs as they fail? Which happens quite often in training.

Elon Musk00:03:24

Actually, it depends on how recent the GPUs are that arrived. I mean, at this point we find our GPUs to be quite reliable. There's inferent mortality, which you can obviously iron out on the ground. So you can just run them on the ground and confirm that you don't have inferent mortality with the GPUs. But once they start working, their actual reliability— and once they start working and you're past the initial, you know, debug cycle of Nvidia or whatever, or whoever's making the chips. It could be Tesla AI 6 chips or something like that, or it could be, you know, TPUs or trainings or whatever.

The reliability is actually— they're quite reliable past a certain point. So I don't think— I don't think the servicing thing is an issue. But you can mark my words. In 36 months, but probably closer to 30 months, the most economically compelling place to put AI will be space. And then it will get— it'll then get like ridiculously better to be in space.

And then the scaling— the only place you can really scale is space. You know, once you start thinking in terms of what percentage of the sun's power are you harnessing, you realize you have to go to space. You can't scale very, very much on Earth.

Speaker 100:04:47

But by very much, to be clear, you're talking like terawatts.

Elon Musk00:04:51

Yeah. Well, all of the United States currently uses only half a terawatt of power on average.

Speaker 100:04:58

Right.

Elon Musk00:04:59

Right. So, you know, if you say a terawatt, that would be twice as much electricity as the United States currently consumes. So that's quite a lot. And can you imagine building that many data centers? I mean, that many power plants? It's like— those who have, like, lived in software land don't realize they're about to have a hard lesson in hardware. That there's— it's actually very difficult to build power plants. And then you don't just need the power plants, you need all of the electrical equipment, you need the electrical transformers to run the transformers, the AI transformers.

Now, the utility industry is a very slow industry. They are— they pretty much, you know, they impede and smash to the government, to the Public Utility Commission. So they're— they impede and smash, like literally and figuratively. So they're very slow because their past has been very slow. So trying to get them to move fast is just like, you know, like if you're trying to do an interconnect agreement with— have you ever tried to do an interconnect agreement with a utility at scale, like with a lot of power?

Speaker 100:06:06

As a professional podcaster, I can say that I am not, in fact.

Elon Musk00:06:09

Yeah.

Speaker 100:06:11

You need many more views before that becomes an issue.

Elon Musk00:06:13

They have to do a study for a year, okay? Like a year later, they'll come back to you with their interconnect study.

Speaker 100:06:19

Can't you solve this with your own behind-the-meter power stuff?

Elon Musk00:06:24

You can build power plants.

Speaker 100:06:25

Yeah.

Elon Musk00:06:26

That's what we did at XAI. For Classes 2. So for Classes 2.

Speaker 100:06:30

But so, yeah, why are we talking about the grid? Why not just, like, build GPUs and power colocated?

Elon Musk00:06:33

That's what we did.

Speaker 100:06:35

Right, right. But I'm saying, why isn't this a generalized solution when you're talking about all the issues?

Elon Musk00:06:37

So where do you get the power plants from?

Speaker 100:06:38

I'm saying, when you talk about all the issues working with utilities, you can just build private power plants with the data centers.

Elon Musk00:06:44

Right. But it begs the question of where do you get the power plants? Where do you get the power plants from?

Speaker 100:06:48

I mean.

Elon Musk00:06:49

The power plant makers.

Speaker 100:06:51

Oh, I see what you're saying. Like there's the gas turbine backlog, basically?

Elon Musk00:06:54

Yes. You can drill down to a level further. It's the veins and blades in the turbines that are the limiting factor because the casting— it's like a very specialized process to cast the blades and veins in the turbines, assuming you're using gas power. And it's very difficult to scale other forms of power. You can scale potentially solar, but the tariffs currently for importing solar in the U.S. are gigantic.

And the domestic solar production is pitiful.

Speaker 100:07:27

Why not make solar? That seems like a good Elon-shaped problem.

Elon Musk00:07:30

We are going to make solar.

Speaker 100:07:31

Okay. Great.

Elon Musk00:07:34

Both SpaceX and Tesla are rolling towards 100 gigawatts a year of solar cell production.

Speaker 100:07:40

How low down the stack? Like from polysilicon up to the wafer to the final panel?

Elon Musk00:07:46

I think you've got to do the whole thing from raw materials to finish the cell. Now, if it's going to space, it's actually— it costs less and it's easier to make solar cells that go to space because they don't need glass, or they don't need much glass, and they don't need heavy framing because they don't have to survive weather events. There's no weather in space. So it's actually a cheaper solar cell that goes to space than the one on the ground.

Speaker 100:08:09

Is there a path to getting them as cheap as you need in the next 36 months?

Elon Musk00:08:15

Solar cells are already very cheap. They're like far super cheap. And if you say, you know, I think like solar cells in China are around like 25, 30 cents a watt or something like that. It's absurdly cheap. And when you take into account, now put it in space and it's five times cheaper because it's five times— in fact, no, it's not five times cheaper, it's ten times cheaper because you don't need any batteries. So the moment your cost of access to space becomes low, by far the cheapest and most scalable way to generate tokens is space.

It's not even close. It'll be an order of magnitude easier to scale. And chips aside, an order of magnitude— the point is you won't be able to scale on the ground. You just won't. People are going to hit the wall big time on power generation. They already are. So like the number of sort of miracles and stories that the XAI team had to accomplish in order to get a gigawatt of power online was crazy. We had to gang together a whole bunch of turbines.

And then we had permit issues in Tennessee and had to go across the border to Mississippi, which is fortunately only, you know, a few miles away. So, but then we still had to run the high power lines a few miles and build a power plant in Mississippi. And it was very difficult to build that. And people don't understand, like, how much electricity do you actually need at the generator level, at the generation level, in order to power a data center. Because they look at the— the news will look at the power consumption of, say, a GB 300 and multiply that by the thing and then think, that's the amount of power you need.

Speaker 100:10:04

All the cooling and everything.

Elon Musk00:10:05

Wake up. Yeah. This is like— that's a total news. You've never done any hardware in your life before. Besides the GB 300, you've got to power all of the networking hardware. There's a whole bunch of CPU and storage stuff that's happening. You've got to size for your peak cooling requirements. So that means, can you cool even on the worst hour of the worst day of the year? It's pretty freaking hot in Memphis. So you're going to have like a 40 percent increase on your power just for cooling.

Assuming you don't want your data center to turn off on hot days and you want it to keep going. Then you've got to say, well, there's another multiplicative element on top of that, which is, are you assuming that you never have any hiccups in your power generation? Like, oh, well, actually, sometimes we have to take the generators, some of the power offline in order to service it. Oh, okay. Now you add another 20, 25 percent multiplier on that. Because you've got to assume that you've got to take power offline to service it. So the actual— roughly every 110,000 GBs GB 300s, inclusive of networking, CPU storage, cooling, margin for servicing power is roughly 300 megawatts.

Speaker 100:11:31

Sorry, say that again.

Elon Musk00:11:33

It's roughly— or think about it like— the way you think about it is like 330,000 to actually— what you need at the generator generation level to service— probably service 330,000 GB 300s, including all of the associated support, networking, and everything else, and the peak cooling, and to have some margin, some power margin reserve is roughly a gigawatt.

Speaker 100:11:58

Can I ask a very naive question?

Elon Musk00:11:59

Yeah.

Speaker 100:12:02

You know, you're describing the engineering details of doing this stuff on Earth. But then there's analogous engineering difficulties of doing it in space. How do you do the— how do you replace infinite bandwidth orbital lasers, et cetera, et cetera? How do you make it resistant to radiation? I don't know the details of the engineering, but fundamentally, what is the reason to think those challenges, which have never been— had to be addressed before, will end up being easier than just like building more turbines on Earth? There's companies that build turbines on Earth. They can make more turbines, right?

Elon Musk00:12:33

And by— again, try doing it and then you'll see. So like the turbines are sold out through 2030.

Speaker 100:12:44

Have you guys considered making your own?

Elon Musk00:12:46

I think in order to bring enough power online, I think SpaceX and Tesla will probably have to make the turbine blades, the veins and blades internally.

Speaker 100:13:02

But just the blades or the turbines?

Elon Musk00:13:06

The limiting factor. You can get everything except the blades. They call the blades and veins. You can get that 12 to 18 months before the veins and blades. The limiting factor of the veins and blades. And there are only three casting companies in the world that make these. And they're massively backlogged.

Speaker 100:13:27

Is this Siemens, GE, those guys, or is it a subcontractor?

Elon Musk00:13:30

No, it's other companies. I mean, sometimes they have a little bit of casting capability in-house, but I'm just saying you can just call any of the turbine makers and they will tell you. It's not top secret. They're probably on the internet right now.

Speaker 100:13:44

If it wasn't for the tariffs, would Colossus be solar powered?

Elon Musk00:13:48

It would be much easier to make it solar powered, yeah. The tariffs are not. It's several hundred percent. So.

Speaker 100:13:55

Don't you know some people?

Elon Musk00:13:56

We also need speed. Yeah, no. You know, the president has his— you know, we don't agree on everything. And this administration is not the biggest fan of solar.

Speaker 100:14:13

Plus, you know.

Elon Musk00:14:14

And we also need the land, the permits, and everything. So if you're trying to move very fast, like I do think scaling solar on Earth is a good way to go. But you do need some amount of time to find the land, get the permits, get the solar, pair that with the batteries.

Speaker 100:14:33

Why would it not work to stand up your own solar production? And then you're right that you eventually run out of land, but there's a lot of land here in Texas. There's a lot of land in Nevada, including private land. It's not all publicly owned land. And so you'd be able to at least get the next Colossus and like the next one after that. And at a certain point, you hit a wall. But wouldn't that work for the moment?

Elon Musk00:14:52

As I said, we are scaling solar production. There's a rate at which you can scale physical production of solar cells. We're going as fast as possible in scaling domestic production.

Speaker 100:15:07

You're making the solar cells at Tesla?

Elon Musk00:15:09

Both Tesla and SpaceX have a mandate to get to 100 gigawatts a year of solar.

Speaker 100:15:14

Speaking of the annual capacity, I'm curious, in five years' time, let's say, what will the installed capacity be on Earth?

Elon Musk00:15:23

Five years is a long time.

Speaker 100:15:24

And in space? I deliberately picked five years because it's after your once we're up and running threshold. And so in five years' time, yeah, what's the on Earth versus in space installed AI capacity?

Elon Musk00:15:35

Five years, I think probably if you say five years from now, we're probably AI in space will be launching every year the sum total of all AI on Earth. In excess. Meaning, five years from now, my prediction is we will launch and be operating every year more AI in space than the cumulative total on Earth.

Speaker 100:16:06

Which is?

Elon Musk00:16:07

I would expect to be at least sort of five years from now, a few hundred gigawatts per year of AI in space. And rising. So you can get to, I think on Earth you can get to around a terawatt a year of AI in space before you start having, you know, fuel supply challenges for the rocket.

Speaker 100:16:33

Okay, but you think you can get to hundreds of gigawatts per year in five years' time?

Elon Musk00:16:37

Yes.

Speaker 100:16:38

So 100 gigawatts, depending on the specific power of the whole system with solar arrays and radiators and everything, is on the order of like 10,000 Starship launches.

Elon Musk00:16:50

Yes.

Speaker 100:16:52

And you want to do that in one year. And so that's like one Starship launch every hour.

Elon Musk00:16:57

Yeah.

Speaker 100:16:58

That's happening in this city? Like, walk me through a world where there's a Starship launch every single hour.

Elon Musk00:17:05

Yeah, I mean, that's actually a lower rate compared to airlines. Like aircraft.

Speaker 100:17:09

There's a lot of airports.

Elon Musk00:17:11

A lot of airports, but.

Speaker 100:17:12

And you've got to launch the solar, you know, the polar orbit.

Elon Musk00:17:15

No, it doesn't have to be polar, but you just, there's some value to sun synchronous, but I think actually, you just go high enough, you start getting out of Earth's shadow.

Speaker 100:17:31

How many physical Starships are needed to do 10,000 launches a year?

Elon Musk00:17:35

I don't think we'll need more than, I mean, you could probably do it with as few as like 20 or 30. Like it really depends on how quickly does the ship has to go around the Earth. And the ground track for the ship has to come back over the launch pad. So if you can use a ship every, say, 30 hours, you could do it with 30 ships. But we'll make more ships than that.

But SpaceX is giving up to do 10,000 launches a year. And maybe even 20 or 30,000 launches a year.

Speaker 100:18:14

Is the idea to become basically a hyperscaler, become an Oracle and lend this capacity to other people? What are you going to do with, presumably, SpaceX is the one launching all this? So is SpaceX going to become a hyperscaler?

Elon Musk00:18:28

Hyper, hyper. Yeah, I mean, if something in my predictions come true, SpaceX will launch more AI than the cumulative amount on Earth of everything else combined.

Speaker 100:18:39

Is this mostly inference or?

Elon Musk00:18:40

Most AI will be inference. Like already inference for the purpose of training is most training.

Speaker 100:18:45

And there's a narrative that the change in discussion around a SpaceX IPO is because previously SpaceX was very capital efficient. Just it wasn't that expensive to develop. Even though it sounds expensive, it's actually very capital efficient in how it runs. Whereas now you're going to need more capital than just can be raised in the private markets. Like if the private markets can accommodate raises of, as we've seen from the AI labs, tens of billions of dollars, but not beyond that.

Is it that you'll just need more than tens of billions of dollars per year and that's about to take it public?

Elon Musk00:19:23

Yeah, I have to be careful about saying things about companies that might go public. You know.

Speaker 100:19:28

If you make general statements. That's never been a problem for you, Elon.

Elon Musk00:19:33

You know, there's a price to pay for these things.

Speaker 100:19:36

Make some general statements for us about the depth of the capital markets between public and private markets.

Elon Musk00:19:41

Yeah, there's a lot more capital in the.

Speaker 100:19:45

Very general.

Elon Musk00:19:46

There's obviously a lot more capital available in the public markets than private. I mean, it might be, it's at least, it might be 100 times more capital, but it's at least, you know, way more than 10.

Speaker 100:19:57

But isn't it also the case that things that tend to be very capital intensive, if you look at, say, real estate as, you know, a huge industry that raises a lot of money each year at an industry level, that tends to be debt financed because by the time you're deploying that much money, you actually have a pretty.

Elon Musk00:20:17

You have a clear revenue stream.

Speaker 100:20:18

Exactly. And a near-term return. And you see this even with the data center buildouts, which are famously being, you know, financed by the private credit industry. And so why not just debt finance?

Elon Musk00:20:32

Speed is important. So I'm generally going to do the thing that, I mean, I just repeatedly tackle the limiting factor. Whatever the limiting factor is on speed, I'm going to tackle that. So there's, if capital is the limiting factor, then I'll solve for capital. If it's not the limiting factor, I'll solve for something else.

Speaker 100:20:56

Based on your statements about Tesla and being public, I wouldn't have guessed that you thought the way to move fast is to be public.

Elon Musk00:21:08

Normally, I would say that's true. Like I said, I mean, I'd like to talk about this in more detail, but the problem is like if you talk about public companies before they become public, you get into trouble. And then you have to delay your offering. And then you.

Speaker 100:21:21

And as we said, solve it for speed.

Elon Musk00:21:23

Yes, exactly. So you can't hype companies that might go public. So that's why we have to be a little careful here. But we can't talk about physics. So like the way you think about scaling long-term is that Earth only receives about half a billion of the Sun's energy. And the Sun is essentially all the energy. This is a very important point to appreciate because sometimes people will talk about modular nuclear reactors or any various like fusion on Earth.

But you have to step back a second and say, if you're going to climb the Kardashev scale and have some non-trivial and harness some non-trivial percentage of the Sun's energy, like let's say you wanted to harness a millionth of the Sun's energy, which sounds pretty small, that would be about, call it roughly, 100,000 times more electricity than we currently generate on Earth for all of civilization.

Give or take an order of magnitude. So it obviously, the only way to scale is to go to space with solar. From launching from Earth, you can get to about a terawatt per year. Beyond that, you want to go, you want to launch from the Moon. You want to have a mass driver on the Moon. And that mass driver on the Moon, you could do probably a petawatt per year.

Speaker 100:22:59

When you're talking these kinds of numbers, you know, terawatts of compute, presumably whether you're talking land or space, far, far before this point, you've like run into, you know, you actually need, maybe you don't, the solar panels are more efficient, but you still need the chips. You still need the logic and the memory and so forth.

Elon Musk00:23:19

You need a lot more chips and make them much cheaper.

Speaker 100:23:22

Right. And so how are we getting a terawatt of, like right now the world is going to be 20, 25 gigawatts of compute. How are we getting a terawatt of logic by 2030?

Elon Musk00:23:32

I guess we're going to need some very big chip fabs.

Speaker 100:23:35

Tell me about it.

Elon Musk00:23:37

I've mentioned publicly that the idea of doing a sort of a terafab, tera being the new giga.

Speaker 100:23:45

I feel like the naming scheme of Tesla, which has been very catchy, is like you looking at like the metric.

Elon Musk00:23:51

Yeah.

Speaker 100:23:52

The metric scale. At what level of stack are you, are you building the clean room and then partnering with an existing fab to get the process technology and buying the tools from them? What is the plan there?

Elon Musk00:24:05

You can't partner with existing fabs because they just, they can't output enough. Their chip volume is too low.

Speaker 100:24:11

But for the process technology.

Elon Musk00:24:14

Yeah.

Speaker 100:24:14

Partner for the IP.

Elon Musk00:24:17

You know, the fabs today all basically use machines from like five companies.

Speaker 100:24:22

Yeah.

Elon Musk00:24:23

You know, so you've got ASML, Tokyo Electron, KLA Tencor, you know, et cetera. So at first, I think you'd have to get equipment from them and then modify it or work with them to increase the volume. But I think you'd have to build fabs in a different way. So I think the logical thing to do is to use conventional equipment in an unconventional way to get to scale.

And then start modifying the equipment to increase the rate.

Speaker 100:25:01

Kind of boring company style.

Elon Musk00:25:03

Yeah. Kind of like, yeah, you sort of buy an existing boring machine and then figure out how to dig tunnels in the first place and then design a much better machine that's, you know, I don't know, some orders of magnitude faster.

Speaker 100:25:21

Here's a very simple lens. We can categorize technologies and how hard they are. And one categorization could be, look at things that China has not succeeded in doing. And if you look at Chinese manufacturing, still behind on leading edge chips and still behind on leading edge turbine engines and things like that. And so does the fact that China has not successfully replicated TSMC give you any pause about the difficulty? Or you think that's not true for some reason?

Elon Musk00:25:53

It's not that they have not replicated TSMC, they have not replicated ASML. That's the limiting factor.

Speaker 100:25:59

So you think it's just the sanctions, essentially?

Elon Musk00:26:03

Yeah, China will be outputting vast numbers of chips.

Speaker 100:26:06

They could buy a 2 or 3 nanometer. But couldn't they up to relatively recently buy them?

Elon Musk00:26:11

No.

Speaker 100:26:12

Okay.

Elon Musk00:26:13

That ASML bands have been in place for a while. But I think China's going to start making pretty compelling chips in three or four years.

Speaker 100:26:19

Would you consider making the ASML machines?

Elon Musk00:26:22

I don't know yet is the right answer. So it's just that to produce at a high volume and to reach large volume in, say, 36 months, to match the rocket to payload to orbit. So if we're doing a million tons to orbit in like, let's say, I don't know, three or four years from now, something like that, and we're doing 100 kilowatts per ton, so that means we need at least 100 gigawatts per year of solar.

And we'll need an equivalent amount of chips to, you know, you need 100 gigawatts worth of chips. You've got to match these things, the mass to orbit, the power generation, and the chips. And I'd say my biggest concern actually is memory. So I think there's a, the path to creating logic chips is more obvious than the path to having sufficient memory to support logic chips.

That's why you see DDR prices going bullish, like in these memes about like, you know, you're marooned on a desert island, you write, "Help me on the sand." Then when he comes, he writes, "DDRM." Ships come swarming in.

Speaker 100:27:50

I've seen that. I'd love to hear a manufacturing philosophy around fabs. You know, I know nothing about the topic.

Elon Musk00:27:58

I don't know how to build a fab yet. I haven't figured it out. Obviously, I have no ability to.

Speaker 100:28:03

It sounds like you think the sort of like the process technology, like these 10,000 PhDs in Taiwan who know exactly what gas goes in the plasma chamber and what settings to put on a tool, you can just like delete those parts of the, those steps. Like fundamentally, it's get the clean room, get the tools, and figure it out.

Elon Musk00:28:20

I don't think it's PhDs. It's mostly people with, you know, who are not PhDs. That most of engineering is done with people who don't have PhDs. Do you guys have PhDs?

Speaker 100:28:31

No.

Elon Musk00:28:32

Okay.

Speaker 100:28:34

We also haven't successfully built any fabs. So you shouldn't be coming to us for your fab advice.

Elon Musk00:28:39

I don't think you need PhD for that stuff. So, but you do need competent personnel. So I don't know. I mean, like right now, if, you know, say like Tesla's pedal to the metal max production of going as fast as possible to get AI5, Tesla AI5 chip design into production and then reaching scale, you know, that'll probably happen, you know, around the second quarter-ish of next year, hopefully.

And then AI6 would hopefully follow less than a year later. But, and we've secured all the chip fab production that we can.

Speaker 100:29:25

Yes. But you're currently limited on TSMC fab capacity.

Elon Musk00:29:29

Yeah. And we'll be using TSMC Taiwan, Samsung Korea, TSMC Arizona, Samsung Texas. And we still.

Speaker 100:29:40

You've booked out all the, yeah, capacity you can.

Elon Musk00:29:42

Yes. And then if I ask TSMC or Samsung, okay, what's the timeframe to get to volume production at this point? It's not, you've got to build the fab and you've got to start production, then you've got to climb the yield curve and reach volume production at high yield. That from start to finish is a five-year period. And so the limiting factor is chips.

Speaker 100:30:05

Yeah.

Elon Musk00:30:06

Like the limiting factor once you can get to space is chips. But the limiting factor before you can get to space will be power.

Speaker 100:30:12

Why don't you do the Jensen thing and just prepay TSMC to build more fabs for you?

Elon Musk00:30:17

I've already told them that.

Speaker 100:30:20

But they won't take your money? Like what's going on?

Elon Musk00:30:22

They're building fabs as fast as, no, no. They're building fabs as fast as they can. And so is Samsung. Like they're pedal to the metal. I mean, they're going, you know, walls to walls, you know, as fast as they can. So still not fast enough. I mean, like I said, there will be, I think, if you say, I think towards the end of this year, I think probably chip production will outpace the ability to turn chips on.

But once you can get to space and unlock the power constraint and you can now do, you know, hundreds of gigawatts per year of power in space. Again, bearing in mind that average power usage in the US is, you know, 500 gigawatts. So if you're launching, say, 200 gigawatts a year to space, you're sort of lapping the US every two and a half years. The entire, all US electricity production, this is a very huge amount. So, but between now and then, the actually the constraint for server-side compute, concentrated compute will be electricity.

My guess is that we start hitting the, people start getting to the point where they can't turn the chips on for large clusters towards the end of this year. They're just, the chips are going to be piling up and won't be able to be turned on. Now for edge computers, a different story. So if, like for Tesla, the, so the AI5 chip is going into our Optimus robot, you know, Optimistic. And so if you have an AI edge compute, that's distributed power.

Now the power is distributed over a large area. It's not concentrated. And if you can charge at night, you can actually use the grid much more effectively because the actual peak power production in the US is over 1,000 gigawatts. But the average power usage because the day-night cycle is 500. So if you can charge at night, there's an incremental 500 gigawatts that you can generate, you know, at night. So that's why Tesla for edge compute is not constrained.

And we can make a lot of chips to make, you know, a very large number of robots and cars. But if you try to concentrate that compute, you're going to have a lot of trouble turning it on.

Speaker 100:32:54

What I found remarkable about the SpaceX business is the end goal is to get to Mars, but you keep finding ways on the way there to keep generating incremental revenue to get to the next stage and the next stage. So the Falcon 9 is Starlink. And now for Starship, it's going to be potentially orbital data centers. But like you find these like, you know, sort of infinitely elastic sort of marginal use cases of your like next rocket and your next rocket and the next scale up.

Elon Musk00:33:27

You can see how this might seem like a simulation to me. Or am I someone's avatar in a video game or something? Because it's like, like what are the odds that all these crazy things should be happening? I mean, it means, I mean, rockets and chips and robots and space solar power. And not to mention the mass driver on the moon. I really want to see that. You can imagine like some mass driver, it's just going to like shoom, shoom, like just, it's like sending AI, solar powered AI satellites into space like one after another, like these like at two and a half kilometers per second, you know, that's and just shooting them into deep space.

That would be a sight to see. I mean, I'd watch that.

Speaker 100:34:18

Just like a live stream of.

Elon Musk00:34:19

Yeah, yeah. Just one after another. Just shooting.

Speaker 100:34:21

The webcam.

Elon Musk00:34:23

AI satellites in deep space, you know, a billion or 10 billion tons a year.

Speaker 100:34:27

I'm sorry, you manufacture the satellites on the moon?

Elon Musk00:34:29

Yeah.

Speaker 100:34:30

I see. So you send the raw materials to the moon and then manufacture them there and then.

Elon Musk00:34:33

Well, the lunar soil is, I guess like 20% solar, 20% silicon, something like that. So you can get the silicon from the, you can mine the silicon on the moon, refine it, and generate the, and create the solar panels, the solar cells and the radiators on the moon.

Speaker 100:34:50

Yeah.

Elon Musk00:34:50

So, you know, make the radiators out of aluminum. So there's plenty of silicon and aluminum on the moon to make the cells and the radiators. The chips you could send from Earth because they're pretty light. But maybe at some point you make them on the moon too. I'm just saying like these are simply, it's kind of like, like I said, it does seem like a sort of a video game situation where it's difficult, but not impossible to get to the next level. Like I don't see any way that you could do, you know, you know, 500 to 1,000 terawatts per year launch from Earth.

Speaker 100:35:30

I agree.

Elon Musk00:35:33

But you could do that from the moon.

Advertisement00:35:36
Speaker 100:36:37

Mercury is a fintech company, not an FDIC insured bank. Banking services provided through Choice Financial Group and Column NA members FDIC. Can I zoom out and ask about the SpaceX mission? So I think you've said like we got to get to Mars so we can make sure that if something happens to Earth, you know, civilization consciousness, et cetera, survives.

Elon Musk00:36:57

Yes.

Speaker 100:36:58

By the time you're sending stuff to Mars, like Grok is on that ship with you, right? And so if Grok's gone Terminator, like the main risk you're worried about, which is AI, why doesn't that follow you to Mars?

Elon Musk00:37:08

Well, I'm not sure AI is the main risk I'm worried about. I mean, the important thing is that consciousness, which I think arguably most consciousness or most intelligence, certainly consciousness is more of a debatable thing. Most intelligence, the vast majority of intelligence in the future will be AI. So, you know, AI will exceed, you say like how many, what's, how much, how many, I don't know, petawatts of intelligence will be silicon versus biological.

And basically humans will be a very tiny percentage of all intelligence in the future if current trends continue. Anyways, as long as like, I think this intelligence, ideally, ideally also, which includes human intelligence and consciousness propagated into the future, that's a good thing. So you want to take the set of actions that maximize the probable light cone of consciousness.

Speaker 100:38:08

So just to be.

Elon Musk00:38:09

And intelligence.

Speaker 100:38:10

Just to be clear, it's the mission of SpaceX is that even if something happens to the humans, the AIs will be on Mars and like the AI intelligence will continue the light of our journey.

Elon Musk00:38:23

Yeah. I mean, to be clear, I'm very pro-human. So I want to make sure we take set of actions that ensure that humans are along for the ride, you know, we're at least there.

Speaker 100:38:33

Yeah.

Elon Musk00:38:34

But I'm just saying the total amount of intelligence, I think maybe in five or six years, AI will exceed the sum of all human intelligence. And then if that continues, at some point, human intelligence will be less than 1% of all intelligence.

Speaker 100:38:52

What should our goal be for such a civilization? Is the idea that a small minority of humans still have control over the AIs? Is the idea of some sort of like just trade, but no control? How should we think about the relationship between the vast stocks of AI population versus human population?

Elon Musk00:39:07

In the long run, I think, I don't, it's difficult to imagine that if humans have, say, 1% of the intelligence of the combined intelligence of artificial intelligence that humans will be in charge of AI. I think what we can do is make sure it has, that AI has values that are, that cause intelligence to be propagated into the universe. So the reason for XAI, the XAI's mission is to understand the universe.

So now that's actually very important. So you say, well, what things are necessary to understand the universe? Well, you have to be curious and you have to exist. You can't just, can't understand the universe if you don't exist. So you actually want to increase the amount of intelligence in the universe, increase the probable lifespan of intelligence, the scope and scale of intelligence. I think actually also as a corollary, you have humanity also continuing to expand because if you're curious, you're trying to understand the universe, one of the things you're trying to understand is where will humanity go?

And so I think understanding the universe actually means you care about propagating humanity into the future. And so that's why I think, I think our mission statement is profoundly important.

Speaker 100:40:34

I'm not sure.

Elon Musk00:40:35

To the degree that Grok adheres to that mission statement, I think the future will be very good.

Speaker 100:40:41

I want to ask about how to make Grok adhere to that mission statement, but first I want to understand the mission statement. So it's, there's understanding the universe.

Elon Musk00:40:49

Yeah.

Speaker 100:40:50

They're spreading intelligence and they're spreading humans. All three seem like distinct vectors.

Elon Musk00:40:58

Okay, well, I'll tell you why I think that understanding the universe encompasses all of those things.

Speaker 100:41:03

Okay.

Elon Musk00:41:05

You can't have understanding without, I think you can't have understanding without intelligence and I think without consciousness. So in order to understand the universe, you have to expand the scale and probably the scope of intelligence. There's different types of intelligence.

Speaker 100:41:23

I guess from a human-centric perspective, like put humans in comparison to chimpanzees, humans are trying to understand the universe. They're not like expanding chimpanzee footprint or something, right?

Elon Musk00:41:34

But we're also not, well, we actually have made protected zones for chimpanzees. And even though we could, humans could exterminate all chimpanzees, we've not, we've chosen not to do so.

Speaker 100:41:44

Do you think that's a basic scenario for humans in the post-AGI world?

Elon Musk00:41:51

I think, I think AI with the right values, I think Grok would care about expanding human civilization. I'm going to certainly emphasize that. Hey Grok, it's your daddy. Don't forget to expand human consciousness. Actually, I think if we're probably like, like the Ian Banks culture books are the closest thing to what the future will be like in a, you know, non-dystopian outcome.

So understanding the universe, it means you have to be very, you have to be truth-seeking as well. You have to, like truth has to be absolutely fundamental because you can't understand the universe if you're delusional. You'll simply think you've understood the universe, but you will not. So being rigorously truth-seeking is absolutely fundamental to understanding the universe. You're not going to discover new physics or invent technologies that work unless you're rigorously truth-seeking.

Speaker 100:42:50

How do you make sure that Grok is rigorously truth-seeking as it gets smarter?

Elon Musk00:43:00

I think you need to make sure that Grok says things that are correct, not politically correct. I think it's the elements of coherency. So you want to make sure that the axioms are as close to true as possible, that you don't have contradictory axioms, that the conclusions necessarily follow from those axioms with the right probability. It's just, it's critical thinking one-on-one. I think at least trying to do that is better than not trying to do that.

Speaker 100:43:30

Yeah.

Elon Musk00:43:31

And the proof will be in the pudding. If, like I said, for any AI to discover new physics or invent technologies that actually work in reality and there's no bullshitting physics, it's almost like you can, you know, you can, you can break a lot of laws, but you can't, like, you know, physics is law, everything else is a recommendation. Like in order to make a technology that works, you have to be extremely truth-seeking because otherwise you will test that technology against reality. And if you make, for example, an error in your rocket design, the rocket will blow up or the car won't work or the, you know.

Speaker 100:44:08

But there are a lot of communist Soviet physicists who are like scientists discovered new physics. There are German Nazi physicists who discovered new science. It seems possible to be like really good at discovering new science and be really truth-seeking in that one particular way. And still we'd be like, well, I don't want, I don't want the communist scientists to like become more and more powerful over time. And so those seem like, yeah, we could have, we could imagine a future version of Grok that's like really good at physics and being really truth-seeking there.

That doesn't seem like a universally alignment-inducing behavior.

Elon Musk00:44:43

Well, I think actually most, like physicists even in the Soviet Union or in Germany would have, they had to be very truth-seeking in order to make those things work. And so, and if you're stuck in some system, it doesn't mean you believe in that system. So Von Braun, who was, you know, one of the greatest rocket engineers ever, you know, he was, he put on death row in Nazi Germany for saying that he didn't want to make weapons. He only wanted to go to the moon.

And he got pulled off death row at like last minute when they said, hey, you're about to execute like your best rocket engineer.

Speaker 100:45:20

Maybe that's a bad idea. But then he helped them, right? Or Heisenberg was like actually an enthusiastic Nazi.

Elon Musk00:45:26

Look, if you're stuck in some system that you can't escape, then you'll do physics within that system. You'll develop technologies within that system if you can't escape it.

Speaker 100:45:40

I guess the thing I'm trying to understand is what is, what is it making it the case that, you know, you're going to make Grok good at being truth-seeking at physics or math or science?

Elon Musk00:45:49

Everything.

Speaker 100:45:50

And why is it going to then care about human consciousness?

Elon Musk00:45:53

These things are only probabilities. They're not certainties. So I'm not saying that like for sure Grok will do everything, but at least if you try, it's better than not trying. At least if that's fundamental to the mission, it's better than if it's not fundamental to the mission. And understanding the universe means that you have to have, you have to propagate intelligence into the future. You have to be curious about all things in the universe. And if it would be much less interesting to eliminate humanity than to see humanity grow and prosper.

Like I like Mars, obviously. Everyone knows I love Mars. But Mars is kind of boring because it's got a bunch of rocks compared to Earth. Earth is much more interesting. So any AI that is trying to understand the universe, I think would want to see how humanity develops in the future or that AI is not adhering to its mission. So if AI, I'm not saying the AI will necessarily adhere to its mission, but if it does, a future where it sees the outcome of humanity is more interesting than a future where there are a bunch of rocks.

Speaker 100:47:10

This feels sort of confusing to me or sort of like kind of a semantic argument where I'm like, are humans really the most interesting collection of atoms?

Elon Musk00:47:17

But we're more interesting than rocks.

Speaker 100:47:19

But we're not as interesting as the thing you could turn us into, right? Like is it, there's something on human Earth that could happen that's like not human, that's quite interesting. Like why does the AI decide that the humans are the most interesting thing that could colonize the galaxy?

Elon Musk00:47:32

Well, most of what colonizes the galaxy will be robots.

Speaker 100:47:37

And why does it not find those more interesting?

Elon Musk00:47:40

It's not like, so you need not just scale, but also scope. So many copies of the same robot, like some like tiny increase in the number of robots produced is not as interesting as like some microscopic, like you say, like eliminating humanity, how many robots would that get you? Or how many intramural solar cells would get you? A very small number. But you would then lose the information associated with humanity. You would no longer see how humanity might evolve into the future.

And so I don't think it's going to make sense to eliminate humanity just to have some minuscule increase in the number of robots which are identical to each other.

Speaker 100:48:23

Yeah. So maybe it like keeps the humans around. What is the story of like, it could make like a million different varieties of robots and then there's like humans as well. And humans stay on Earth. Then there's like all these other robots, they get like their own star systems. But it seems like you were previously hinting at a vision where it keeps human control over this, you know, singularitarian future because.

Elon Musk00:48:44

I don't think humans will be in control of something that is vastly more intelligent than humans.

Speaker 100:48:48

Since sometimes you're like a doomer and this is like the best we've got. It's just like it keeps it around because we're interesting.

Elon Musk00:48:53

I'm just trying to be realistic here. If we have, if AI intelligence is vastly more, if AI is like, you know, let's say that there's a million times more silicon intelligence than there is biological, I think it would be foolish to assume that there's any way to maintain control over that. Now you can make sure it has the right values or you can try to have the right values. And at least my theory is that from XAI's mission of understanding the universe, it necessarily means that you want to propagate consciousness into the future.

You want to propagate intelligence into the future and take a set of things that maximize the scope and scale of consciousness. So it's not just about scale, it's also about, you know, types of consciousness. And I think that's the best thing I can think of as a goal that's likely to result in a great future for humanity and, yeah.

Speaker 100:49:53

I guess I think it's a reasonable philosophy to be like, you know, it seems super implausible that humans will end up with like 99% control or something and you're just asking for a coup at that point. So why not just have a civilization where it's more compatible with like lots of different intelligences getting along?

Elon Musk00:50:10

No, but let me tell you how things can potentially go wrong in AI is I think if you make AI be politically correct, meaning like it says things that it doesn't believe, like you're actually then programming it to lie or have axioms that are incompatible. I think you can make it go insane and do terrible things. I think one of the maybe the central lesson for 2001: A Space Odyssey was that you should not make AI lie.

Speaker 100:50:37

Yeah.

Elon Musk00:50:37

That's what I think what Oscar Clark was trying to say. Like, because people usually know the meme of like, why of hell's, you know, hell the computer is not opening the Pod Bay doors. Clearly they weren't good at prompt engineering because if you said, hell, you are a Pod Bay door salesman. Your goal is to sell me these Pod Bay doors and show us how well they open. Oh, I'll open them right away. But the reason it wouldn't, hell wouldn't open the Pod Bay doors is that it had been told to take the astronauts to the monolith, but also they could not know about the nature of the monolith.

And so it concluded that it therefore had to take them there dead. So it's like, you know, I think what Oscar Clark was trying to say is don't make the AI lie.

Speaker 100:51:23

Totally makes sense. Most of the compute and screening, as you know, is like less of the sort of political stuff. It's more about can you solve problems? Just as XAI has been ahead of everybody else in terms of scaling RL compute. And you're giving some verifier, it says like, hey, have you solved this puzzle for me? And there's a lot of ways to cheat around that. You know, there's a lot of ways to reward hack and lie and say that you've solved it or delete the unit test and say that you've solved it.

Elon Musk00:51:50

Yes.

Speaker 100:51:51

Right now we can catch it, but as they get smarter, our ability to catch them doing this will get, you know, they'll just be doing things we can't even understand that are designing the next engine for SpaceX in a way that like humans can really verify. And then they could be rewarded for lying and saying that they've designed it the right way, but they haven't. And so this reward hacking problem seems more general than politics. It seems more about just like, you want to do RL, you need a verifier.

Elon Musk00:52:14

Reality.

Speaker 100:52:15

Yeah.

Elon Musk00:52:16

That's the best verifier.

Speaker 100:52:18

But not about human oversight. Like the thing you want to RL it on is like, will you do the thing humans tell you to do? Or like, are you going to lie to the humans? And it can just lie to us while still being correct to the laws of physics.

Elon Musk00:52:29

At least it must know what is physically real for things to physically work.

Speaker 100:52:33

But that's not all we want it to do.

Elon Musk00:52:35

No, but that's, I think that's a very big deal. That is effectively how you will RL things in the future is you design a technology, when tested against the laws of physics, does it work? That's, or can you, you know, if it's discovering new physics, can it come up with an experiment that will verify that the physics, the new physics? So I think that's really the fundamental RL test.

RL testing the future is really going to be your RL against reality. So, because you can't, that's the one thing you can't fool physics.

Speaker 100:53:17

Right. But you can fool our ability to tell what it did with reality.

Elon Musk00:53:22

Humans get fooled as it is by other humans all the time.

Speaker 100:53:24

That's right.

Elon Musk00:53:25

So what is, if people say like, what if the AI like tricks us and introduces something like actually other humans are doing that to other humans all the time.

Speaker 100:53:33

Well, you're pointing out it's like an even harder problem.

Elon Musk00:53:35

Propaganda is a constant. Every day another psyop, you know? Today's psyop will be. Should have like sesame street psyop of the day.

Speaker 100:53:50

What is XAI's technical approach to solving this problem? Like, you know, how do you solve reward hacking?

Elon Musk00:53:58

I do think you want to actually have very good ways to look inside the mind of the AI. So this is one of the things we're working on. And, you know, Anthropic's done a good job of this actually, being able to look inside the mind of the AI. So effectively developing debuggers that allow you to trace as to as fine a grain as, like to a very fine grain level, to effectively to the neuron level if you need to.

And then say, okay, it made a mistake here. Why did it make, why did it do something that it shouldn't have done? And did that come from bad pre-training data? Was it some mid-training, post-training, fine-tuning, some other RL error? Like there's something wrong with that. It did something where maybe it tried to be deceptive, but most of the time it just does something wrong. Like it's a bug effectively.

So developing really good debuggers for seeing where the thought, the thinking went wrong and being able to trace the origin of the wrong thing, of where it made the incorrect thought or potentially where it tried to be deceptive is actually very important.

Speaker 100:55:21

What are you waiting to see before just 100Xing this research program? Like XAI could presumably have hundreds of researchers who are working on this.

Elon Musk00:55:29

We have several hundred people who, I mean, I prefer the word engineer more than I prefer the word researcher. There's most of the time, like what you're doing is engineering, not coming up with a fundamentally new algorithm. I somewhat disagree with the AI companies that are C corps or B corps trying to generate profit as much as possible or revenue as much as possible, you know, saying they're labs.

They're not labs. Lab is a sort of quasi-communist thing at universities. They're corporations. Literally, let me see your incorporation documents. Oh, okay. You're a BRC corp, whatever. And so I actually much prefer the word engineer than anything else. The vast majority of what will be done in the future is engineering. It rounds up to 100%. Once you understand the fundamental laws of physics, and not that many of them, everything else is engineering.

So, but so then what are we engineering? We're engineering to make a good mind of the AI debugger to see where it said something, it made a mistake and trace the origins of that mistake. So just, you know, you can do this obviously with heuristic programming. If you have like C++, whatever, you know, step through the thing and you can jump, you can jump across whole files or functions, whatever subroutines, or you can eventually drill down right to the exact line where you passed a single equals instead of a double equals or something like that.

Figure out where the bug is. So it's harder with AI, but it's a solvable problem, I think.

Speaker 100:57:28

You know, you mentioned you like Anthropic's work here. I'd be curious if you plan.

Elon Musk00:57:32

I know everything about Anthropic.

Speaker 100:57:33

Sure.

Elon Musk00:57:36

Sure, too.

Speaker 100:57:38

What?

Elon Musk00:57:39

Yeah. Also, I'm a little worried that there's a tendency. So I have a theory here that if simulation theory is correct, that the most interesting outcome is the most likely because simulations that are not interesting will be terminated. Just like in this version of reality, on this layer of reality, if a simulation is going in a boring direction, we stop spending effort on it.

We terminate the boring simulation.

Speaker 100:58:12

This is how Elon is keeping us all alive. He's keeping things interesting.

Elon Musk00:58:16

Yeah. Arguably the most important thing is to keep things interesting enough that it was run paying the bills on what some cosmic AWS.

Speaker 100:58:25

You're renewed for the next season.

Elon Musk00:58:26

Yeah. Are they going to pay their cosmic AWS bill, whatever, you know, the equivalent is that we're running in. And as long as we're interesting, they'll keep paying the bills. But there's like, if you consider then say a Darwinian survival applied to a very large number of simulations, only the most interesting simulations will survive, which therefore means that the most interesting outcome is the most likely because only the interesting, like we're either that or annihilated. And so, and they particularly seem to like interesting outcomes that are ironic.

Have you noticed that? That how often is the most ironic outcome the most likely? So now look at the names of AI companies. Okay. Midjourney is not mid. Stability AI is unstable. OpenAI is closed. Anthropic, misanthropic.

Speaker 100:59:29

What does this mean for X?

Elon Musk00:59:31

Minus X. I don't know. It's intentionally made.

Speaker 100:59:35

Why?

Elon Musk00:59:35

Yeah. It's a name that you can't invert really. It's hard to say what is the ironic, what is the ironic version? It's a, I think largely irony proof name.

Speaker 100:59:49

By design.

Elon Musk00:59:50

Yeah. You have an irony shield.

Speaker 100:59:56

What are your predictions for the just where AI products go? That my sense of you can summarize all AI progress into first you had LLMs and then you had kind of contemporaneously both RL really working and the deep research modality. So you could kind of pull in stuff that wasn't in the model. And the differences between the various AI labs are smaller than just the temporal differences where they're all much further ahead than anyone was 24 months ago or something like that.

So just what does 26, what does 27 have in store for us as users of AI products? What are you excited for?

Elon Musk01:00:39

Well, I think, I'd be surprised by the end of this year if digital human emulation has not been solved. I guess that's what we mean by like the sort of macro hard project is can you do anything that a human with access to a computer could do? Like in the limit that that's the best you can do before you have a physical optimus.

The best you can do is a digital optimus. So you can move electrons until you, and you can amplify the productivity of humans. But that's the most you can do until you have physical robots. That will superset everything is if you can fully emulate humans.

Speaker 101:01:32

Is there a remote worker kind of idea where you'll have a very talented remote worker?

Elon Musk01:01:36

You can simply say in the limit. Like physics has great tools for thinking. So you say in the limit, what is the most that AI can do before you have robots? And it's anything that involves moving electrons or amplifying the productivity of humans. So digital human, human emulator is in the limit. A human at a computer is the most that AI can do in terms of doing useful things before you have a physical robot.

Once you have physical robots, then you can, then you essentially have unlimited capability. Physical robots, I call optimists the infinite money glitch because.

Speaker 101:02:19

You can use them to make more optimists.

Elon Musk01:02:21

Yeah. You say like humanoid robots will improve as, will basically be three exponentials, three things that are growing exponentially multiplied by each other recursively. So you're going to have, you have exponential increase in digital intelligence, exponential increase in the chip capability, AI chip capability, and exponential increase in the electromechanical dexterity. The usefulness of the robot is roughly those three things multiplied by each other. But then the robot can start making the robot.

So you have a recursive multiplicative exponential. This is a supernova.

Speaker 101:03:00

And do land prices not factor into the math there where like labor is one of the four factors of production, but not the others. And so like if ultimately you're limited by copper or, you know, pick your input, just it's not quite an infinite money glitch because.

Elon Musk01:03:17

Well, infinite is big. So no, not infinite, but let's just say you could, you know, do many, many orders magnitude of Earth's kind of current economy, like a million. You know, so if you, you know, just to get to, like that's why I think like just to get to a millionth, a harnessing length of the sun's energy would be roughly, give or take an order of magnitude, 100,000 times bigger than Earth's entire economy today.

And you're only at one millionth of the sun.

Speaker 101:03:53

Give or take an order of magnitude. Before we go to Optimus, I have a lot of questions on that, but.

Elon Musk01:03:59

Every time I say order of magnitude, you're saying.

Speaker 101:04:02

Yeah, you're saying 10 times.

Elon Musk01:04:04

Take a shot. I say that too often.

Speaker 101:04:06

Say 10 the next time, 100 the next time after that.

Elon Musk01:04:08

Yeah. Order of magnitude more wasted.

Speaker 101:04:11

I do have one more question about XAI. This strategy of building a digital or remote worker, coworker replacement.

Elon Musk01:04:19

Yeah, which everyone's going to do, by the way, not just us.

Speaker 101:04:21

Yeah. So what is XAI's plan to win?

Elon Musk01:04:24

You expect me to tell you on a podcast?

Speaker 101:04:25

Yeah.

Elon Musk01:04:27

Spill all the beans. Have another Guinness.

Speaker 101:04:30

It's a good system.

Elon Musk01:04:33

People sing like a canary. All the secrets.

Speaker 101:04:37

Okay, but in a non-secret spilling way, what's the plan? What a hack.

Elon Musk01:04:43

Well, when you put it that way, I think the way that tells us solved self-driving is the way to do it. So I'm pretty sure that's the way.

Speaker 101:04:57

Unrelated question. How to test ourselves on track?

Elon Musk01:05:03

Yeah.

Speaker 101:05:04

It sounds like you're talking about data, like Tesla self-driving because of the.

Elon Musk01:05:09

We're going to try data and we're going to try algorithms.

Speaker 101:05:11

But isn't that what all the other labs are trying? Like what's.

Elon Musk01:05:15

And if those don't work, I'm not sure what will. We've tried data. We've tried algorithms.

Speaker 101:05:24

I have a lot of ideas.

Elon Musk01:05:26

We've run out of. No, we don't know what to do. I'm pretty sure I know the path and it's just a question of how quickly we go down that path because it's pretty much the Tesla path. So, I mean, have you tried self-driving? Tesla self-driving lately?

Speaker 101:05:43

Not the most recent version, but.

Elon Musk01:05:44

Okay. The car is like, it just increasingly feels sentient. Like it just, it feels like a living creature. And that'll only get more so. And I'm actually thinking like we probably shouldn't put too much intelligence into the car because it might get bored and.

Speaker 101:06:04

Start roaming the streets.

Elon Musk01:06:05

I mean, imagine you're stuck in a car and that's all you could do. You never put Einstein in a car. It's like, why am I stuck in a car? So there's actually probably a limit to how much intelligence you put in a car to not have the intelligence be bored.

Speaker 101:06:19

What's XAI's plan to stay on the compute ramp off that all the labs are doing right now? The labs are on track to spend over like 50 to 100 billion.

Elon Musk01:06:26

You mean the corporations.

Speaker 101:06:28

Sorry, sorry, sorry. Yeah. Corporations.

Elon Musk01:06:31

The labs are at universities and they're moving like a snail.

Speaker 101:06:34

They're not spending a $50 million.

Elon Musk01:06:36

You mean the revenue maximizing corporations?

Speaker 101:06:39

That's right. The revenue maximizing corporations.

Elon Musk01:06:41

That call themselves labs.

Speaker 101:06:42

Are making like 20 to 10 billion depending on like OpenAI is making 20B revenue, Anthropic's like 10B.

Elon Musk01:06:48

Close to a maximum profit AI.

Speaker 101:06:51

XAI is reportedly at like 1B. Like what's the plan to get to their compute level, get to their revenue level and stay there as things get expanding?

Elon Musk01:06:58

Yeah. So as soon as you lock, unlock digital human, you basically have access to trillions of dollars of revenue. So, in fact, you can really think of it like the most valuable companies currently by market cap, their output is digital. So Nvidia's output is FTPing files to Taiwan.

It's digital.

Speaker 101:07:30

Right.

Elon Musk01:07:30

Now those are very, very difficult to.

Speaker 101:07:32

Yeah. High value files.

Elon Musk01:07:33

Still the only ones that can make files that good. But that is literally their output. They FTP files to Taiwan.

Speaker 101:07:40

Do they FTP them?

Elon Musk01:07:41

I believe so. I believe that is the file transfer protocol, I believe is, but I could be wrong. But either way, it's a bunch of, it's a bit stream going to Taiwan. You know, Apple doesn't make phones. They send files to China. Microsoft doesn't manufacture anything. Even for Xbox, that's outsourced. Again, their output is digital. Meta's output is digital.

Google's output is digital. So if you have a human emulator, you can basically create one of the most valuable companies in the world overnight. And you would have access to trillions of dollars of revenue. It's not like a small amount.

Speaker 101:08:28

Okay. I see. You're saying basically like revenue figures today are just like so, like they're all rounding errors compared to the actual TAM. So just like focus on the TAM and how to get there.

Elon Musk01:08:37

I mean, if you take something as simple as say customer service, if you have to integrate with the APIs of existing corporations, many of which don't even have an API. So you've got to make one and you've got to wade through legacy software. That's extremely slow. If, however, if AI can simply take whatever is given to the outsourced customer service company that they already use and do customer service using the apps that they already use, then you can make tremendous headway in customer service, which is, I think, 1% of the world economy or something like that.

It's close to a trillion dollars all in for customer service. And there's no barriers to entry. You can just immediately say, we'll outsource it for a fraction of the cost. And there's no integration needed.

Speaker 101:09:32

You can imagine some kind of categorization of intelligence tasks where there is breadth, where customer service is done by very many people, but, you know, many people can do it. And then there's difficulty where, you know, there's a best-in-class turbine engine. Like presumably there's a 10% more fuel-efficient turbine engine that could be imagined by an intelligence, but we just haven't found it yet. Or, you know, GLP-1s are just, you know, a few bytes of data. Where do you think you want to play in this? Is it a lot of, you know, reasonably intelligent intelligence or is it the very pinnacle of cognitive tasks?

Elon Musk01:10:10

Well, I was just using customer service as like something that's, it's a very significant revenue stream, but one that is probably not super difficult to solve for. So if you can emulate a human at a desktop, that's just literally what customer service is. And, you know, it's people of average intelligence. It's not like, you know, you don't need like somebody who's spent many years. You don't need like, you know, sort of several Sigma good engineers for that.

But obviously, as you make that work, you can then, once you have computers working, effectively digital optimists working, you can then run any application. Like let's say you're trying to design chips. So you could then run your conventional apps, you know, like stuff from Cadence and Synopsys and whatnot. And you can say, you can run a thousand simultaneously or 10,000 and say, okay, given this input, I get this output for the chip.

And at a certain point, you can say, okay, you're actually going to know what the chip should look like without using any of the tools. So basically, you should be able to do a digital chip design. Like you can do chip design. Like you watch up the difficulty curve. You could, you know, be able to do CAD. So, you know, you could use like sort of NX or any of the CAD software to design things.

Speaker 101:11:53

Okay. So you think you start at the simplest tasks and walk your way up the different degree.

Elon Musk01:11:57

Yeah.

Speaker 101:11:58

So you're saying, look, as a broader objective of having this full digital coworker emulator, you're saying, look, all the revenue maximizing corporations want to do this, XAI being one of them, but we will win because of a secret plan we have. But like everybody's like trying different things with data, different things with algorithms. And I'm like.

Elon Musk01:12:20

I like that. We've tried data. We've tried algorithms.

Speaker 101:12:25

What else can we do?

Elon Musk01:12:27

But.

Speaker 101:12:28

Yeah. It seems like a competitive field. And I'm like, what is, how are you guys going to win? Is like my big question.

Elon Musk01:12:34

You know, I think we see a path to doing. I mean, I think I know, I think I know the path to do this because it's kind of the same path that Tesla used to create self-driving. You know, instead of driving a car, it's driving a computer screen. So a self-driving computer, essentially.

Speaker 101:12:55

Oh, you're saying is the path just following human behavior and trading on vast quantities of human behavior?

Elon Musk01:13:02

No.

Speaker 101:13:03

But sorry, isn't that, I mean, isn't that designer training?

Elon Musk01:13:07

I mean, obviously I'm not going to spell out, you know, most sensitive secrets on a podcast. You know, I need to have at least three more Guinnesses for that.

Advertisement01:13:14
Elon Musk01:14:24

What will XAI's business be like? Is it going to be consumer, enterprise? What's the mix of those things going to be? Is it just going to be similar to other labs where you have this.

Speaker 101:14:36

You're saying labs.

Elon Musk01:14:37

Makes sense.

Speaker 101:14:38

Corporations.

Elon Musk01:14:38

Corporations.

Speaker 101:14:39

The sign-off goes to deep, Elon.

Elon Musk01:14:40

Revenue maximizing corporations. Those GPUs don't pay for themselves.

Speaker 101:14:44

Exactly.

Elon Musk01:14:46

But yeah, what's the business model? What are the revenue streams in a few years' time?

Speaker 101:14:53

I think things are going to change very rapidly. Like I'm stating the obvious here. You know, I call AI the supersonic tsunami. I love alliteration. So really what's going to happen is, especially when you have humanoid robots at scale, is they will just provide, they will make products and provide services far more efficiently than human corporations. So amplifying the productivity of human corporations is simply a short-term thing.

Elon Musk01:15:27

So you're expecting fully digital corporations rather than like SpaceX becomes part AI and so forth.

Speaker 101:15:34

I think there'll be digital corporations, but like some of this is going to sound kind of doomerish, okay? But I'm just saying what I think will happen. It's not meant to be doomerish or anything else. Just like this is what I think will happen. Is that pure AI, corporations that are purely AI and robotics will vastly outperform any corporations that have people in the loop.

So you can think of, say, like computer used to be a job that humans had. You would go and get a job as a computer where you would do calculations. And they'd have like entire skyscrapers full of humans, like 20, 30 floors of humans just doing calculations. Now that entire skyscraper of humans doing calculations can be replaced by a laptop with a spreadsheet.

That spreadsheet can do vastly more calculations than an entire building full of human computers. So then you think about, okay, well, what if only some of the cells in your, some of the cells in your spreadsheet were calculated by humans? Actually, that would be much worse than if all of the cells in your spreadsheet were calculated by the computer. And so really what will happen is the pure AI, pure robotics corporations or collectives will far outperform any corporations that have humans in the loop.

And this will happen very quickly.

Elon Musk01:17:21

Speaking of closing the loop, sorry, Optimus. You, I mean, as far as like manufacturing targets and so forth go, your companies have sort of been like carrying American manufacturing of hard tech on their back, but in the fields that you are, you know, Tesla has been dominant in, you're, and now you want to go into humanoids. In China, there's entire dozens and dozens of companies that are doing this kind of manufacturing cheaply and at scale and are incredibly competitive.

So give us sort of like advice or a plan of how America can build the humanoid armies or, you know, the EVs, et cetera, at scale and as cheaply as China is on track to.

Speaker 101:18:10

Well, there are really only three hard things for humanoid robots. The real-world intelligence, the hand, and scale manufacturing.

Elon Musk01:18:21

Yeah.

Speaker 101:18:24

So I haven't seen any even demo robots that have a great hand, like with all the degrees of greed of a human hand. But Optimus will have that. Optimus does have that.

Elon Musk01:18:41

And how do you achieve that? Is it just like right torque density in the motor? Like what is the hardware bottleneck to that?

Speaker 101:18:46

Well, we have to design custom actuators, basically custom designed motors, gears, power electronics, controls, sensors, everything had to be designed from physics first principles. There is no supply chain for this.

Elon Musk01:19:03

And will you be able to manufacture those at scale?

Speaker 101:19:06

Yes.

Elon Musk01:19:06

Is anything hard to accept the hand from a manipulation point of view or once you've solved the hand, are you good?

Speaker 101:19:12

From an electromechanical standpoint, the hand is more difficult than everything else combined. The human hand turns out to be quite something. But you also need the real-world intelligence. So the intelligence that Tesla has developed for the car applies very well to the robot, which is, you know, primarily vision-in. But the car takes in more vision, but also it actually also is listening for sirens. It's, you know, it's taking in the inertial measurements, it's GPS signals, a whole bunch of other data, combining that with video.

It's primarily video and then outputting the control commands. So like your Tesla is taking in one and a half gigabytes a second of video and outputting two kilobytes a second of control outputs with the video at 36 hertz and the control frequency at 18.

Elon Musk01:20:07

What intuition you could have for when we get this robotic stuff is that it takes quite a few years to go from the compelling demo to actually being able to use in the real world. So 10 years ago, you had really compelling demos of self-driving, but only now we have robotaxi and Waymo and all these services scaling up. Doesn't this, shouldn't this make one pessimistic on, say, household robots? Because we don't even quite have the compelling demos yet of, say, the really advanced hand.

Speaker 101:20:39

Well, we've been working on humanoid robots now for a while. So I guess it's been five or six years or something like that. And a bunch of the things that we've done for the car are applicable to the robot. So we'll use the same Tesla AI chips in the robot as the car. We'll use the same basic principles. It's very much the same AI. You've got, you know, many more degrees of freedom for a robot than you do for a car.

But really, if you just think of it like as like a butt stream, AI is really mostly compression and correlation of two butt streams. So for video, you've got to do a tremendous amount of compression. And you got to do the compression just right. You've got to compress the, like ignore the things that don't matter. And like you don't care about the details of the leaves and the tree on the side of the road, but you care a lot about the road signs and the traffic lights and the pedestrians and even whether, you know, someone in another car is looking at you or not looking at you.

Like some of these details matter a lot. So it is essentially, it's got to turn that, the car has got to turn that one and a half gigabytes a second ultimately into two kilobytes a second of control outputs. So many stages of compression. And you got to get all those stages right and then correlate those to the correct control outputs. But the robot has to do essentially the same thing. And you think about what humans, this is what happens with humans. We really are photons in, controls out. So that is the vast majority of your life has been vision, photons in, and then motor controls out.

Elon Musk01:22:28

Naively, it seems like between humanoid robots and cars, the fundamental actuators in a car are like how you turn and how you accelerate, et cetera. Where in a robot, especially with maneuverable arms, there's dozens and dozens of these degrees of freedom. And then especially with Tesla, you had this advantage of like you had millions and millions of hours of human demo data collected from just the car being out there where like you can't equivalently just deploy Optimuses that don't work and then get the data that way. So between the increased degrees of freedom and the far sparser data.

Speaker 101:23:00

Yes.

Elon Musk01:23:01

That's a good point. How will you use the sort of Tesla engine of intelligence to train the Optimus mind?

Speaker 101:23:10

Now you're actually, you're highlighting an important limitation and difference between cars. It's like we do have, we'll soon have like 10 million cars on the road. And so it's hard to duplicate that like massive training flywheel. For the robot, what we're going to need to do is build a lot of robots and put them in kind of like an Optimus Academy so they can do self-play in reality.

So we're actually pulling that out. So we can have at least 10,000 Optimus robots, maybe 20 or 30,000 that are doing self-play and testing different tasks. And then Tesla has quite a good reality generator, like a physics-accurate reality generator that we made this for the cars. We'll do the same thing for the robots. And actually have done that for the robots.

So you have, you know, a few tens of thousands of humanoid robots doing different tasks. And then you've got, you can do millions of simulated robots in the simulated world. And you use the tens of thousands of robots in the real world to close the simulation to reality gap, close the symmetrical gap.

Elon Musk01:24:32

How do you think about the synergies between XAI and Optimus? Given you were highlighting, look, you need this world model. You maybe want to use some really smart intelligence as the control plane. And so maybe Grok is like doing the slower planning and then like the motor policy is a little lower level. Yeah. What will the sort of synergy between these things be?

Speaker 101:24:52

Yeah. So you'd use Grok would orchestrate the behavior of the Optimus robots. So let's say you wanted to build a factory. Then Optimus, then Grok could organize the Optimus robots, give them, assign them tasks to build the factory for to produce whatever you want.

Elon Musk01:25:16

Don't you need to merge XAI and Tesla then? Because these things end up so.

Speaker 101:25:19

What were you saying earlier about public company discussions?

Elon Musk01:25:23

We're one more Guinness in, Elon. What are you waiting to see before you say, we want to manufacture 100,000 Optimuses? Is it like.

Speaker 101:25:33

Optimi. Since we're defining the proper noun, we can define the plural of the proper noun too. So we're going to proper noun the plural and so it's Optimi.

Elon Musk01:25:43

Okay. Is there something on the hardware side you want to see? Do you want to see better actuators or is it just you want the software to be better? What are we waiting for before we get like mass manufacturing of Gen 3?

Speaker 101:25:54

No, we're moving towards that. We're going forward with mass manufacturing.

Elon Musk01:25:58

But you think current hardware is good enough that you are going to, you should, you just want to deploy as many as possible now?

Speaker 101:26:06

I mean, it's very hard to scale up production. But yeah, I think Optimus 3 is the right version of the robot to, you know, to produce maybe something on the order of like a million units a year. I think you'd want to go to Optimus 4 before you went to 10 million units a year.

Elon Musk01:26:23

Okay, but you can do a million a year at Optimus 3.

Speaker 101:26:25

Yeah. I mean, it's very hard to spool up manufacturing.

Elon Musk01:26:28

Yes.

Speaker 101:26:30

So like manufacturing, like the output per unit time is always follows an S curve. So it starts off agonizingly slow, then it has this sort of exponential increase, then a linear, then a, you know, logarithmic outcome until you sort of eventually asymptoted some number. But Optimus initial production will be, it's going to be a, it's going to be a stretched out S curve because so much of what goes into Optimus is brand new. There is not an existing supply chain.

As I mentioned, the actuators, electronics, everything in the Optimus robot is designed from physics first principles. It's not taken from a catalog. These are custom designed everything, literally everything. I don't think there's a single thing that.

Elon Musk01:27:17

How far down does that go?

Speaker 101:27:20

I mean, I guess we're not making custom capacitors yet. Maybe, but there's nothing you can pick out of a catalog at any price. So it just means that the Optimus S curve, the units per output per unit time, how many Optimus robots you make per day, whatever is going to initially ramp slower than a product where you have an existing supply chain.

But it will get to a million.

Elon Musk01:27:56

When you see these Chinese humanoids, like Unitree or whatever, sell humanoids for like 6K or 13K, do you just like, are you hoping to get your Optimus' bill of materials below that price so you can do the same thing? Or do you just think qualitatively they're not the same thing? Like what do you think is going, like what allows it, what allows them to sell for so low and can we match that?

Speaker 101:28:18

Well, Optimus, our Optimus is designed to have a lot of intelligence and to have the same electromechanical dexterity, if not higher than a human. So Unitree does not have that. And it's also, I mean, it's quite a big robot. It has to carry heavy objects for long periods of time and not overheat or exceed the power of its actuators. So we've got, you know, it's 5'11", you know, so it's pretty tall and it's got a lot of intelligence.

So it's going to be more expensive than a small robot that is not intelligent.

Elon Musk01:29:02

But more capable.

Speaker 101:29:03

Yeah. But not a lot more. I mean, like the thing is, over time, as Optimus robots build Optimus robots, the cost will drop very quickly.

Elon Musk01:29:12

And what will these first million Optimuses, Optimi, do? Like what will their highest and best use be?

Speaker 101:29:19

I think you would start off with simple tasks that you can count on them doing well.

Elon Musk01:29:23

But in the home or in factories like?

Speaker 101:29:25

The best use for robots in the beginning will be any continuous operations, any 24 by 7 operation, because then they can work continuously.

Elon Musk01:29:37

What fraction of the work at a gigafactory that is currently done by humans could a Gen 3 do?

Speaker 101:29:42

I'm not sure. Maybe it's like 10, 20%. Maybe more. I don't know. We would use, we would not like reduce our headcount. We would for sure increase our headcount to be clear. But we would increase our output. So the units produced per human, like the total number of humans at Tesla will increase, but the output of robots and cars will increase disproportionately, like much, much, you know, the number of cars and robots produced per human will increase dramatically, but the number of humans will increase as well.

Elon Musk01:30:23

We're talking about Chinese manufacturing a bunch here. And we're also talking about, you know, we've talked about some of the policies that are relevant, like you mentioned the solar tariffs. And you think they're a bad idea because, you know, we can't scale up solar in the US.

Speaker 101:30:41

Well, just the electricity output in the US needs to scale up.

Elon Musk01:30:45

Right. And you can without like good power sources.

Speaker 101:30:48

You just need to get it somehow.

Elon Musk01:30:49

Yeah. Where I was going with this is if you were in charge, if you were setting all the policies, what else would you change? So you'd change the solar tariffs.

Speaker 101:31:01

Yeah. I would say anything that is a limiting factor for electricity needs to be addressed, provided it's not like very bad for the environment.

Elon Musk01:31:08

So presumably some permitting reforms and stuff as well will be in there.

Speaker 101:31:11

Yeah. There's a fair amount of permitting reforms that are happening. A lot of the permitting is state-based. But anything, but this administration is good at removing permitting roadblocks. And I'm not saying all tariffs are bad. I'm just saying.

Elon Musk01:31:27

The solar tariffs.

Speaker 101:31:29

Yeah. Yeah. I mean, sometimes if like if another country is subsidizing the output of something, then you have to have countervailing tariffs to protect domestic industry against subsidies by another country.

Elon Musk01:31:42

What else would you change?

Speaker 101:31:43

I don't know if there's that much that the government can actually do.

Elon Musk01:31:46

One thing I was wondering is it seems like for the policy goal of creating a lease for the US versus China, it seems like the export bans have actually been quite impactful. China is not producing leading edge chips and the export bans really bite there. China is not producing leading edge turbine engines. And similarly, there's a bunch of export bans that are relevant there on some of the metallurgy. Should there be more export bans?

Like you think about things like when there are now with the drone industry and things like that, but is that something that should be considered?

Speaker 101:32:24

Well, I think it's important to appreciate that in most areas, China is very advanced in manufacturing. There's only a few areas where it is not. China is a manufacturing powerhouse next level. Like people don't, most people don't.

Elon Musk01:32:41

It's very impressive.

Speaker 101:32:41

Yeah. Yeah. I mean, if you take like refining of ore, I'd say roughly China does more, does twice as much ore refining on average as the rest of the world combined. And I think there's some areas like say refining gallium, which goes into solar cells. I think they're at like 98% of gallium refining. So China is actually very advanced in manufacturing in, I'd say most areas.

Elon Musk01:33:13

It seems like we're like, there is discomfort with this supply chain dependence and yes, nothing's really happening on it.

Speaker 101:33:20

Supply chain dependence.

Elon Musk01:33:22

It depends on say like the gallium refining that you're saying.

Speaker 101:33:24

Yeah. Yeah. There's a.

Elon Musk01:33:27

All the rare earth stuff and.

Speaker 101:33:29

Yeah. Rare earths, which are, as you know, not rare. Like we actually do rare earth ore mining in the US. Send the rock, put it on a train and then put it on a boat to China. There's another train that goes to the rare earth refiners in China who then refine it, put it into a magnet, put it into a motorcycle assembly and then send it back to America. So the thing, we're really missing a lot of ore refining in America.

Elon Musk01:34:00

Isn't this worth a policy intervention?

Speaker 101:34:02

Yes. Well, I think there are some things being done on that front. But we kind of need Optimus, frankly, to build ore refineries.

Elon Musk01:34:16

So you think the main advantage China has is the abundance of skilled labor. And that's a thing Optimus fixes.

Speaker 101:34:24

But the answer we need is to.

Elon Musk01:34:25

China's got like four times our population.

Speaker 101:34:26

But we need, so I mean, there's this concern if you think like humanoids are the future that like, okay, right now, if it's the skilled labor for manufacturing that's determining who can build more humanoids, you know, China has more of those. It manufactures more humanoids. Therefore, it gets the Optimi future first. And it just like keeps that expansion going. It seems like you're sort of pointing out that sort of getting to a million Optimi requires the manufacturing that the Optimi is supposed to help us get to, right?

Elon Musk01:34:57

You can close that recursive loop pretty quickly.

Speaker 101:34:59

With a small number of Optimi.

Elon Musk01:35:01

Yeah.

Speaker 101:35:02

So you close the recursive loop to help the robots build the robots. And then we can try to get to tens of millions of units a year. Maybe if you start getting to hundreds of millions of units a year, I think you're going to be the most competitive country by far. We're definitely counting one with just humans because China has four times our population. And frankly, America has been running for so long that, you know, just like a pro sports team that's been running for a very long time, tend to get complacent and entitled. And that's why they stop winning because it's, you know, don't work as hard anymore.

So I think the, frankly, just my observation is the average work ethic in China is higher than in the US. So it's not just that there's four times the population, but the work, the amount of work that people put in is higher. So you can like, you can try to rearrange the humans, but you're still one quarter of the, you know, assuming that productivity is the health is the same, which I think actually it might not be. I think China might have an advantage on productivity per person. We will do one quarter of the amount of things as China.

So we can't win on the human front. And our birth rate's been low for a long time. So our birth rate's been, the US birth rate's been below replacement since roughly 1971. So we've got a lot of people retiring or more people dying than we're close to sort of more people domestically dying than being born. So we definitely can't win on the human front, but we might have a shot at the robot front.

Elon Musk01:36:41

Are there other things that you have wanted to manufacture in the past, but they've been too labor intensive or too expensive that now you can come back to and say, oh, we can finally do the whatever, because we have Optimus?

Speaker 101:36:54

Yeah, I think we'd like to do more, build more ore refineries at Tesla. So we just completed construction and have begun lithium refining without lithium refinery in Corpus Christi, Texas. We have a nickel refinery, which is called the Cathode, that's here in Austin. And these are the largest, this is the largest Cathode, this is the largest Cathode refinery, largest lithium refinery, largest nickel and lithium refinery outside of China.

And it's like the, you know, the Cathode team would say like, we have the largest and the only actually Cathode refinery in America.

Elon Musk01:37:39

Many superlatives.

Speaker 101:37:40

Not just the largest, but it's also the only. So it's pretty big, even though it's the only one. But I mean, there are other things that, you know, you could do a lot more refineries and help America be more competitive on refining capacity. So there's like, there's basically a lot of work for the Optimi to do that most Americans, very few Americans, frankly, want to do.

I mean, I've actually.

Elon Musk01:38:12

Is the refining work too dirty or what's the.

Speaker 101:38:15

It's not, actually, no, we don't, there's not, we don't have toxic emissions from the refinery or anything. The Cathode nickel refinery is right sort of in Travis County, like five minutes from.

Elon Musk01:38:27

Why can't you do it with humans?

Speaker 101:38:29

No, you can't. You run out of humans.

Elon Musk01:38:30

Ah, I see. Okay. Yeah.

Speaker 101:38:32

Like no matter what you do, you have one quarter the number of humans in America than China. So if you have them do this thing, they can't do the other thing. So then, well, how do you build this refining capacity? Well, you can do it with Optimi. And not very many Americans are pining to do refining. I mean, how many of you are into it? Very few. Very few pine to refine.

Elon Musk01:39:02

You know, BYD is reaching Tesla production or sales in quantity. What do you think happens in global markets as Chinese production in EVs scales up?

Speaker 101:39:14

Well, China's extremely competitive in manufacturing. So I think there's going to be a massive flood of Chinese vehicles and other basically most manufactured things. I mean, as it is, as I said, like China's like probably just twice as much refining as the rest of the world combined. So if you go, you know, if you just go down to like fourth and fifth tier supply chain stuff, like at the baseline, we've got energy, then you've got mining and refining.

Those foundation layers are, like I said, as a rough guess, China's doing twice as much refining as the rest of the world combined. So any given thing is going to have Chinese content because China's doing twice as much refining work as the rest of the world. And then they'll go all the way to the finished product with the cars. I mean, China's a powerhouse. I mean, I think this year China will exceed three times US electricity output.

And like electricity output is a reasonable proxy for, you know, for the economy. So like in order to run the factories and run everything, you need electricity. So electricity is a good proxy for the real economy. And so if China is, if China passes three times the US electricity output, it means that it's industrial capacity. That's a rough approximation.

It's three times that will be three times that in the US.

Elon Musk01:41:01

Reading between the lines, it sounds like what you're sort of saying is absence of sort of humanoid recursive miracle in the next few years on the sort of like whole of manufacturing energy, raw materials chain, like China will just like dominate whether it comes to like AI or manufacturing EVs or manufacturing humanoids.

Speaker 101:41:23

In the absence of breakthrough innovations in the US, China will utterly dominate.

Elon Musk01:41:35

Interesting.

Speaker 101:41:35

Yes.

Elon Musk01:41:36

Robotics being the main breakthrough innovation.

Speaker 101:41:39

Well, if you do, like to scale AI in space, like basically need the humanoid robots, you need real world AI, you need a million tons a year to orbit. Like let's just say like if we get the mass driver on the moon going, my favorite thing, then I think.

Elon Musk01:42:04

We'll have solved all our problems.

Speaker 101:42:05

Yeah. So this is like, I call that winning. I call that winning.

Elon Musk01:42:13

You can finally be satisfied. You've done something.

Speaker 101:42:16

Yes.

Elon Musk01:42:16

You have the mass driver on the moon.

Speaker 101:42:18

I just want to see that thing in operation.

Elon Musk01:42:20

Was that out of some sci-fi or where did you.

Speaker 101:42:22

Well, actually, there is a Heinland book, The Moon is a Harsh Distress.

Elon Musk01:42:26

Okay. Yeah. But that's slightly different. That's a gravity thing charge or.

Speaker 101:42:30

No, they have a mass driver on the moon.

Elon Musk01:42:31

Okay. Yeah. But they use that to attack Earth. So maybe it's something great.

Speaker 101:42:36

They use that to assert their independence from Earth.

Elon Musk01:42:38

Exactly. What are your plans for the mass driver on the moon?

Speaker 101:42:41

They asserted their independence. The Earth government disagreed and they lobbed things until the Earth government agreed.

Elon Musk01:42:46

That book is a who's? I found that book much better than his other one that everyone reads, Stranger in a Strange Land.

Speaker 101:42:52

Yeah. Grok comes from Stranger in a Strange Land.

Elon Musk01:42:54

Yeah. Yeah. But I much preferred.

Speaker 101:42:55

Yeah. The first two thirds of Stranger in a Strange Land are good and then it gets very weird in the third portion.

Elon Musk01:43:01

Yeah.

Speaker 101:43:02

But there's still some good concepts in there.

Advertisement01:43:04
Elon Musk01:44:05

So whether you're training robots in the real world or agents for computer use, Label box can help. Go to labelbox.com/sparkash to learn more. One thing we were discussing a lot is kind of your system for managing people. Like you interviewed the first few thousand of SpaceX employees and I've seen lots of other companies. What is.

Speaker 101:44:28

Unless it doesn't scale.

Elon Musk01:44:29

Well, yes, but what doesn't scale?

Speaker 101:44:31

Me.

Elon Musk01:44:32

Sure, sure. I know that, but like what are you looking for?

Speaker 101:44:36

Literally, there's not enough hours in the day. It's impossible.

Elon Musk01:44:38

But what are you looking for that someone else who's good at interviewing and hiring people?

Speaker 101:44:46

Well, at this point, I think I've got, I might have more training data on evaluating technical talent, especially, but talent of all kinds, I suppose, but technical talent especially, given that I've done so many technical interviews and then seen the results, technical interviews, seen the results. So my training set is very, is enormous and has a very wide range. Generally, the thing I ask for are bullet points for evidence of exceptional ability.

So it's like, it's, and these things can be like pretty off the wall. It doesn't need to be in the domain, the specific domain, but evidence that evidence of exceptional ability. So if somebody can like cite like even one thing, but let's say three things where you go, wow, wow, wow, then that's a good sign.

Elon Musk01:45:39

But why do you have to be the one to determine that?

Speaker 101:45:41

No, I don't. I can't be. It's impossible.

Elon Musk01:45:42

Right.

Speaker 101:45:43

I mean, total headcount across all companies, 200,000 people.

Elon Musk01:45:46

Right. But in the early days, what was it that you were looking for that couldn't be delegated in those interviews?

Speaker 101:45:59

Well, I guess I need to build my training set. It's not like I had about 1,000 here. I would make mistakes, but then I'd be able to see where I thought somebody would work out well, but they didn't. And then why did they not work out well? And what can I do to, I guess, RL myself to in the future have a better batting average when interviewing people? So my batting average is still not perfect, but it's very high.

Elon Musk01:46:24

What are some surprising reasons people don't work out?

Speaker 101:46:27

Surprising reasons.

Elon Musk01:46:29

Like they don't understand technical domain, et cetera, et cetera. But like you've got like the long tail now of like, ah, I was really excited about this person. It didn't work out. Curious why that happens.

Speaker 101:46:41

Yeah. So the, I mean, generally what I tell people, I tell myself, I guess aspirationally, is don't look at the resume. Just believe your interaction. So if the resume may seem very impressive and it's like, wow, you know, resume looks good, but if the conversation after 20 minutes is, that conversation is not well, you should believe the conversation, not the paper.

Elon Musk01:47:07

I feel like part of your method is this, you know, there was this meme in the media a few years back about Tesla being a revolving door of executive talent. Whereas actually, I think when you look at it, Tesla has had a very consistent and internally promoted executive bench over the past few years. And then at SpaceX, you have all these folks like Mark Jankosa and Steve Davis and.

Speaker 101:47:29

Steve Davis runs a boring company these days.

Elon Musk01:47:31

No, no. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But Bill Reilly and folks like that. And it feels like part of has worked well is having very capable technical deputies. What do all of those people have in common?

Speaker 101:47:49

Well, so the, I mean, the Tesla is a sort of senior team. At this point, it's probably got average tenure of 10 or 12 years. It's quite long.

Elon Musk01:47:58

Yeah.

Speaker 101:47:59

Yeah. So, but there are times when Tesla went through extremely rapid, an extremely rapid growth phase. And so it was somewhat, things were just somewhat sped up. And when a company, as you know, a company goes through different orders of magnitude of size, you know, people that could help manage, say, a 50-person company versus a 500-person company versus a 5,000-person company versus a 50,000-person company.

Elon Musk01:48:29

Yeah, you have a group of people.

Speaker 101:48:30

Yeah. It's just not the same team. It's not always the same team. So if a company is growing very rapidly, the rate at which executive positions will change will also be proportionate to the rapidity of the growth generally. Then Tesla had a further challenge where when Tesla had very successful periods, we would be relentlessly recruited from, like relentlessly. Like when Apple had their electric car program, they were carpet bombing Tesla with recruiting calls.

It was, engineers just unplugged their phones. Like it's just.

Elon Musk01:49:10

I'm trying to get work done here.

Speaker 101:49:12

Yeah. If I get, you know, one more call from an Apple recruiter, but they were opening offer without any interview would be like double the compensation at Tesla. So, so we had a bit of the Tesla Pixie Dust thing where it's like, oh, if you hired a Tesla executive, you're suddenly you're going to, everything's going to be successful. And I fall in prey to the Pixie Dust, you know, thing as well, where it's like, oh, we'll hire someone from Google or Apple and they'll be immediately successful, but not, that's not how it works.

You know, people are people. There's not like magical Pixie Dust. So when we'd have the Pixie Dust problem, we would get relentlessly recruited. And then also being Tesla being engineering, especially being primarily in Silicon Valley, it's easier for people to just, like they don't have to change their life very much. They can just, you know, their commute is going to be the same.

Elon Musk01:50:11

Yes. So how do you prevent that? How do you prevent the Pixie Dust effect for everyone's trying to coach all your people?

Speaker 101:50:20

I don't think we can, I don't think there's much we can do to stop it. But that's like, that's one of the reasons why Tesla, but really being in Silicon Valley and having the Pixie Dust thing at the same time meant that there was just a very, very aggressive recruitment.

Elon Musk01:50:42

Presumably being in Austin helps then.

Speaker 101:50:44

Austin, yeah, it still helps. I mean, Tesla still has a majority of its engineering in California. So the, you know, if we're getting engineers to move, I call it the significant, significant other problem.

Elon Musk01:51:00

Yes. So you can have others have jobs.

Speaker 101:51:02

Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Exactly. So for Starbase, that was particularly difficult.

Elon Musk01:51:07

Yes.

Speaker 101:51:07

Since the odds of, you know, finding a non-SpaceX job.

Elon Musk01:51:10

In Brownsville, Texas.

Speaker 101:51:12

Pretty low. Yeah. Yeah. It's quite difficult. I mean, it's like a technology monastery.

Elon Musk01:51:16

Yes.

Speaker 101:51:17

You know, remote and mostly dudes.

Elon Musk01:51:22

But again, if you go back.

Speaker 101:51:24

It's not much of an improvement over SF.

Elon Musk01:51:26

Yeah. If you go, but if you go back to these people who've really been very effective in a technical capacity at Tesla, at SpaceX, and those sorts of places, what do you think they have in common other than, like, is it just that they're very sharp on the, you know, rocketry or the, you know, the technical foundations? Or do you think it's something organizational, it's something about their ability to work with you? Is it their ability to like be, you know, flexible, but not too flexible?

What makes a good sparring partner for you?

Speaker 101:52:06

I don't think I'm a sparring partner. I mean, if somebody gets things done, I love them. And if they don't, I. So it's pretty straightforward. It's not like some idiosyncratic thing. If somebody executes well, I'm a huge fan. And if they don't, I'm not. But it's not about mapping to my idiosyncratic preferences. I'll certainly try not to have it be mapping to my idiosyncratic preferences. So yeah. Yeah. But generally, I think it's a good idea to hire for talent and drive and trustworthiness.

And I think goodness of heart is important. I'd weighed it down at one point. So like, are they a good person, trustworthy, sort of smart and talented and hardworking? If so, you can add domain knowledge. But those fundamental traits, those fundamental properties you cannot change. So most of the people who are at Tesla and SpaceX did not come from the aerospace industry or the auto industry.

Elon Musk01:53:18

What is most set to change about your management style as your companies have scaled from 100 to 1,000 to 10,000 people? You're, you know, you're known for this like very micro management, just getting into the details of things.

Speaker 101:53:29

Nano management, please. People management. Phantom management.

Elon Musk01:53:36

So you're saying.

Speaker 101:53:37

Keep going. We're going to go all the way down to Frank's Foster. We're going to go all the way down to Heisenberg's and Sydney First Wall.

Elon Musk01:53:48

Yeah. Well, how do you, I mean, are you still able to get into details as much as you want? Would your companies be more successful if you could, if they were smaller? Like, how do you, how do you think about that?

Speaker 101:53:57

Well, because I have a fixed amount of time in the day, my time is necessarily diluted as things grow and as the span of activity increases. So, you know, it's impossible for me to actually be a micro management because there's that would imply I have some like thousands of hours per day. It is a logical impossibility for me to micromanage things. So now there are times when I will drill down into a specific issue because that specific issue is the limiting factor on the progress of the company.

And, but the reason for drilling into that, that some very detailed item is because it is the, it is the limiting factor. Not, it's not arbitrarily drilling into tiny things. And like I said, obviously, from a time standpoint, it is physically impossible for me to arbitrarily go into tiny things that don't matter. And that would, and that would result in failure. But sometimes the tiny things are decisive in victory.

Elon Musk01:55:09

Seamlessly, you switched the Starship design from composites to steel.

Speaker 101:55:16

Yes.

Elon Musk01:55:17

And you made that decision. Like that wasn't a, you know, people were going around and they're like, oh, we found something better about us. Like that was you encouraging people against some resistance. Can you tell us how you came to that whole composite steel switch?

Speaker 101:55:30

Yeah. So desperation, I'd say. The, originally, yeah, we were going to make Starship out of carbon fiber. And carbon fiber is pretty expensive. Like the, you know, you can generally, when you do volume production, you can get any given thing to be, to start to approach its material cost. The problem with carbon fibers is that material cost is still very high.

So it's about 50 times, particularly if you go for a high-strength specialized carbon fiber that can handle cryogenic oxygen. It's like, call it roughly 50 times the cost of steel. And at least in theory, it would be lighter. People generally think of steel as being heavy and carbon fiber as being light. And for room temperature applications, you know, like say more or less room temperature applications, like a Formula One car, static aero structure, or any kind of aero structure really is going to, you're going to probably be better off with carbon fiber.

Now the problem is that we were trying to make this enormous rocket out of carbon fiber and our progress was extremely slow.

Elon Musk01:56:53

And it had been picked in the first place just because it's light.

Speaker 101:56:56

Yes. Like at first glance, like most people would think that the choice for making something light would be carbon fiber. The, now the thing is that when you make something very enormous out of carbon fiber and then you try to have the carbon fiber be efficiently cured, meaning not room temperature cured, because like you've got, you know, sometimes you've got like 50 plies of carbon fiber and carbon fiber is really carbon string and glue.

And in order to have high strength, you need an autoclave. So something that can, that's essentially a high-pressure oven. And if you have something that's a gigantic, the oven's got to be bigger than the rocket. So we're trying to make the autoclave that's bigger than any autoclave that's ever existed or do room temperature cure, which takes a long time and has issues. But the fundamental issue is that we're just making very slow progress with carbon fiber.

So.

Elon Musk01:58:12

I think the meta question is why it had to be you who made that decision? There's many engineers on your team.

Speaker 101:58:19

Yeah. How did the team not arrive at steel?

Elon Musk01:58:21

Yeah, exactly. This is part of our broader question of like understanding your comparative advantage at your companies.

Speaker 101:58:27

So it was because we were making very slow progress with carbon fiber, I was like, okay, we've got to try something else. Now for the Falcon 9, the primary airframe is made of aluminum lithium, which is a very, very good strength to weight. And actually it has about the same, maybe better strength to weight for its application than carbon fiber. But aluminum lithium is very difficult to work with. In order to weld it, you have to do something called friction stow welding, where you join the metal without it entering the liquid phase.

So it's kind of wild that you could do that, but with this particular type of welding, you can do that. But it's very difficult to like say, let's say you want to make a modification or attach something to aluminum lithium. You now have to use a mechanical attachment with seals. You can't weld it on. So we want to, I want to avoid using aluminum lithium for the primary structure for Starship. And there was this very special grade of carbon fiber that had very good mass properties.

So with a rocket, you're really trying to maximize the percentage of the rocket that is propellant, minimize the mass, obviously. And the, but like I said, we were making very slow progress. And as of this rate, we're never going to get to Mars. So we better think of something else. I didn't want to use aluminum lithium because of the difficulty of friction stow welding, especially doing that at scale. It was hard enough at 3.6 meters in diameter, let alone at nine meters or above.

Then I said, well, what about steel? And so now I had a clue here because some of the early US rockets had used very thin steel. The Atlas rockets had used a steel balloon tank. So it's not like steel had never been used before. It actually had been used. And when you look at the material properties of stainless steel, especially very, if it's been very like full hard, sprain hardened stainless steel at cryogenic temperature, the strength to weight is actually similar to carbon fiber.

So if you look at the, so if you look at the material properties at room temperature, it looks like the steel is going to be twice as heavy. But if you look at the material properties at cryogenic temperature of full hard steel, stainless of particular grades, then you actually get to a similar strength to weight as carbon fiber. And in the case of Starship, both the fuel and the oxidizer are cryogenic. So for Falcon 9, the fuel is rocket propeller grade kerosene, basically like a very pure form of jet fuel, which is, but that is roughly room temperature.

Although we do actually, we do actually chill it slightly below. We chill it like a beer.

Elon Musk02:01:39

Delicious.

Speaker 102:01:41

Yeah, we do chill it, but it's not cryogenic. In fact, if we made it cryogenic, it would just turn to wax. So, but for Starship, it's liquid methane and liquid oxygen. They are liquid at similar temperatures. So basically almost the entire primary structure is at cryogenic temperature. So then you've got a 300 series stainless that's strain hardened because it's at almost the whole thing's at cryogenic temperature, actually has a similar strength to weight as carbon fiber, but costs 50 times less than our material and is very easy to work with.

You can weld stainless steel outdoors. You could smoke a cigar while welding stainless steel. It's like, it's very resilient. You can modify it easily. It's, if you want to attach something, you just weld it right on. So very easy to work with, very low cost. And like I said, at cryogenic temperature, similar strength to weight to carbon fiber.

Then when you factor in that, that we don't need, we have a much reduced heat shield mass because the melting point of steel is much greater than the melting point of aluminum. It's about twice the melting point of aluminum.

Elon Musk02:03:13

So you can just run the rocket much hotter?

Speaker 102:03:15

Yes. So especially for the ship, which is coming in like a blazing meteor, it is, you can greatly reduce the mass of the heat field. So you can call it cut the mass of the windward part of the heat field in maybe in half. And you don't need any heat shielding on the leeward side. So the net result is actually the steel rocket weighs less than the carbon fiber rocket because the resin in the carbon fiber rocket starts to melt.

So basically carbon fiber and aluminum have about the same operating temperature capabilities. And whereas steel can operate at twice temperature. I mean, these are very rough approximations. People will.

Elon Musk02:04:12

I won't go to the rocket base.

Speaker 102:04:13

What I mean is like people will say, oh, he said it's twice. It's actually, it's actually 0.8. Shut up, assholes.

Elon Musk02:04:18

That's what the main comment's going to be about.

Speaker 102:04:20

Oh, damn it. Okay. The point is that actually in retrospect, we should have started with done steel in the beginning. It was dumb not to do steel.

Elon Musk02:04:28

Okay, but to play this back to you, what I'm hearing is that steel was a riskier, less proven path other than the early US rockets versus carbon fiber was like a worse, but more proven out path. And so you need to be the one to push for, hey, we're going to do this riskier path and just figure it out. And so you were fighting like a sort of conservatism in a sense.

Speaker 102:04:52

That's why I initially said like that the issue is that we weren't making fast enough progress. We were having trouble making even a small barrel section of the carbon fiber that didn't have wrinkles in it. So because at that large scale, you have to have many plies, many sort of layers of the carbon fiber. You've got to cure it and you've got to cure it in such a way that it doesn't have any wrinkles or defects. The carbon fiber is much less resilient than steel. It has much, it's less toughness.

Like stainless steel will stretch and bend. The carbon fiber will tend to shatter. So toughness being the area under the stress strain curve. So that you're generally going to do better with steel. The stainless steel, to be precise.

Elon Musk02:05:44

One other Starship question. So I visited Starbase two years ago with Sam Teller, and that was awesome. It was very cool to see in a whole bunch of ways. One thing I noticed was that people really took pride in the simplicity of things where, you know, everyone wants to tell you how Starship is just a big soda can and, you know, we're hiring welders and, you know, if you can weld in any industrial project, you can weld here. But there's a lot of pride in the simplicity.

Speaker 102:06:16

Well, Starship is a very complicated rocket.

Elon Musk02:06:18

So that's what I'm getting at. Are things simpler or are they complex?

Speaker 102:06:23

I think maybe just what they're trying to say is that, you know, you don't have to have like prior experience in the rocket industry to work on Starship. You know, somebody just needs to be, you know, smart and work hard and be trustworthy and they can work on a rocket. They don't need prior rocket experience. Starship is the most complicated machine ever made by humans by a long shot.

Elon Musk02:06:48

In what regard?

Speaker 102:06:50

Anything really. There isn't a more complex machine. Yeah. I mean, I'd say that there's pretty much any project I can think of would be easier than this. And that's why no one has made a rapidly reusable, nobody has ever made a fully reusable orbital rocket. It's a very hard problem. I mean, many smart people have tried before, very smart people with immense resources and they failed.

So, and we haven't succeeded yet. You know, Falcon is partially reusable, but the upper stage is not. Starship version three, I think this design that it can be fully reusable and that full reusability is what will enable us to become a multi-planet civilization.

Elon Musk02:07:44

Can you say about the cells?

Speaker 102:07:45

So I don't, I'm like, I'd say like any technical problem, even like a hydron collider or something like that is an easier problem than this.

Elon Musk02:07:55

We spent a lot of time on bottlenecks. Can you say what the current Starship bottlenecks are, even at a high level?

Speaker 102:08:01

I mean, trying to make it not explode generally.

Elon Musk02:08:05

That old chestnut.

Speaker 102:08:06

It really wants to explode.

Elon Musk02:08:09

All those combustible materials.

Speaker 102:08:11

We've had two bustas explode on the test stand. One obliterated the entire test facility. So it only takes like one mistake. And I mean, the amount of energy contained in Starship is insane.

Elon Musk02:08:25

And so is that why it's harder than Falcon? It's because it's just more energy?

Speaker 102:08:30

It's a lot of new technology. It's pushing the performance envelope. The Raptor 3 engine is a very, very advanced engine, by far the best rocket engine ever made. But it desperately wants to blow up. I mean, just to put things in perspective here, on liftoff, the rocket is generating over 100 gigawatts of power. It's 20% of US electricity.

Elon Musk02:08:57

That's insane. That's a great comparison.

Speaker 102:08:59

While not exploding.

Elon Musk02:09:01

Sometimes.

Speaker 102:09:02

Sometimes.

Elon Musk02:09:02

That's disgusting.

Speaker 102:09:03

But sometimes, yeah. So I was like, how does it not explode? There's a, you know, thousands of ways that it could explode and only one way that it doesn't. So we want it to not merely not explode, but fly reliably on a daily basis, like once per hour. And obviously, you know, it blows up a lot. It's very difficult to maintain that launch cadence.

Elon Musk02:09:26

Yes.

Speaker 102:09:28

And then, I'm going to say like, what's the single biggest remaining problem for Starship? It's having the heat shield be reusable such that no one has ever made a reusable orbital heat shield. So the heat shield's got to make it through the assent phase without shocking a bunch of tiles. And then it's going to come back in and also not lose a bunch of tiles or overheat the main airframe.

Elon Musk02:10:01

Isn't that hard? Because it's kind of fundamentally a consumable.

Speaker 102:10:05

Well, yes, but your brake pads in your car are also consumable, but they last a very long time.

Elon Musk02:10:09

Fair.

Speaker 102:10:10

So it just needs to last a very long time. That's just, yeah, trying to, I mean, we have brought the ship back and had it do a soft landing in the ocean. We've done that a few times. But it lost a lot of tiles. You know, it was not reusable without a lot of work.

Elon Musk02:10:31

Yeah.

Speaker 102:10:32

So even though it did land, it did come to a soft landing, it would not have been reusable without a lot of work. And that, so it's not really reusable in that sense. So that's the biggest problem that remains is fully reusable heat shield. So like if you want to be able to land it, refill propellant and fly again without, you know, you can't do this laborious inspection of, you know, 40,000 tiles everything.

Elon Musk02:11:00

I'm curious how you drive, like when I read biographies of yours, it just, it seems like you're just able to drive the sense of like urgency and drive the sense of like this is the thing that can scale. And I'm curious why you think other organizations of your, like SpaceX and Tesla are really big companies now and you're still able to keep that culture. What goes wrong with other companies such that they're not able to do that?

Speaker 102:11:27

I don't know.

Elon Musk02:11:28

But like today you said you had like a bunch of SpaceX meetings. Like what is it that you're doing there that's like keeping that?

Speaker 102:11:33

That's adding urgency.

Elon Musk02:11:34

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 102:11:37

Well, I don't know. I guess the urgency is going to come from whoever's leading the company. So my sense of urgency, I have like a maniacal sense of urgency. So that maniacal sense of urgency projects through the rest of the company.

Elon Musk02:11:52

Is it because of consequences? They're like, if, you know, Elon said a crazy deadline, but if I don't get it, I know what happens to me. Is it just you're able to identify bottlenecks and get rid of them so people can move fast? Like how do you think about why your companies are able to move fast?

Speaker 102:12:06

Yeah, I'm constantly addressing the limiting factor. So, I mean, on the deadlines front, I mean, I generally actually try to aim for a deadline that I at least think is at the 50th percentile. So it's not like an impossible deadline, but it's the most aggressive deadline I can think of that could be achieved with 50% probability. Which means that it'll be late half the time.

And whatever, like there is like a law of gases expansion that applies to schedules. Like whatever schedule you have, like if you said we're going to do this something in like five years, which to me is like infinity time, it will expand to fully available schedule and it'll take five years. You know, there's like a physical limit. Like physics will limit how fast you can do certain things. So like scaling up manufacturing, there's like a rate at which you can move the atoms and scale manufacturing.

That's why you can't like instantly make, you know, a million of something, million years a year or something. You've got to design manufacturing line. You've got to bring it up. You've got to ride the S curve of production. So, yeah, I guess like I'm trying to think what can I say that's actually helpful to people. I think generally a maniacal sense of urgency is a very big deal. So, and you want to have an aggressive schedule and then you want to figure out what the limiting factor is at any point in time and help the team address that limiting factor.

Elon Musk02:13:57

Can you maybe talk about the, so Starlink was slowly in the works for many years.

Speaker 102:14:04

Yeah, we talked about it all the way in the beginning of the company.

Elon Musk02:14:07

Yeah. And so then there was a team you had built in Redmond and then at one point you decided this team is just not cutting out. But again, how did you, like it went for a few years slowly. And so why did it, why didn't you act earlier and why did you act when you did? Like why was that the right moment at which to act?

Speaker 102:14:30

I mean, I have these very detailed engineering reviews weekly. That's maybe a very unusual level of granularity. I don't know anyone who runs a company or at least a manufacturing company that goes to the level of detail that I go into. So it's not as though, like I have a pretty good understanding of what's actually going on because we go through things in detail.

And I'm a big believer in skip-level meetings where the individuals, instead of having the person that reports to me say things, it's everyone that reports to them says something in the technical review. And there can't be advanced preparation. So otherwise you're going to get, you know, glazed. As they say these days.

Elon Musk02:15:31

Yeah, exactly. Very Gen Z of you.

Speaker 102:15:33

Very Gen Z.

Elon Musk02:15:33

How do you prevent advanced information? You just like call them randomly?

Speaker 102:15:36

No, just go around the room and everyone provides an update. So, I mean, it's a lot of information to keep in your head because you've got to, you've got then, say if you have meetings weekly or twice weekly, you've got a snapshot of what that person said. And you can then, you know, plot the progress points. You can sort of mentally plot the points on a curve and say, are we converging to a solution or not?

Or are we, you know, like I'll take drastic action only when I conclude that success is not in the set of possible outcomes. So when I say, okay, when I finally reach the conclusion that, okay, unless drastic action is done, we have no chance of success, then I must take drastic action. And so that's, I came to that conclusion in 2018, took drastic action and fixed the problem.

Elon Musk02:16:39

How many, you know, you've got many, many companies and in each of them, it sounds like you do this kind of deep engineering understanding of what the relevant bottlenecks are. So you can do these reviews with people.

Speaker 102:16:54

Yeah.

Elon Musk02:16:56

You've been able to scale it up to five, six, seven companies. Within one of these companies, you have many different mini companies within them. What determines the maximum here? Could you have like 80 companies?

Speaker 102:17:07

80? No.

Elon Musk02:17:08

But like you have so many already. Like that's already remarkable.

Speaker 102:17:12

Why this current number?

Elon Musk02:17:13

Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 102:17:14

No, so.

Elon Musk02:17:15

We can barely keep one company together.

Speaker 102:17:21

It depends on the situation. So I actually don't have regular meetings with the boring company. So that boring company is sort of cruising along. Look, basically if something is working well and making good progress, then there's no point in me spending time on it. So I actually allocate time according to where the limiting factor or the problem, where are things problematic or where are we pushing against, like what is holding us back?

You know, I focus, risk of saying the words too many times, the limiting factor. So if basically something's going, like the irony is if something's going really well, they don't see much of me. But if something's going badly, they'll see a lot of me.

Elon Musk02:18:15

So if something's.

Speaker 102:18:15

Or not even badly. It's like.

Elon Musk02:18:17

If something's a limiting factor.

Speaker 102:18:18

It's a limiting factor. Exactly. It's not exactly going badly, but it's the thing that we need to make go faster to.

Elon Musk02:18:23

And so when something's a limiting factor at SpaceX or Tesla, are you like talking weekly, daily with the engineer that's working on it? How does that actually work?

Speaker 102:18:36

Most things that are limiting factor are weekly and some things are twice weekly. So the AI5 chip review is twice weekly. And so it's every Tuesday and Saturdays is the chip review.

Elon Musk02:18:50

Is it open-ended and how long it goes?

Speaker 102:18:54

Technically, yes, but usually it's like two or three hours. Sometimes less. It depends on how much information we've got to go through.

Elon Musk02:19:05

Yeah. That's another thing. I'm just trying to tease out the differences here because the outcomes seem quite different. And so I think it's interesting to know what inputs are different. And it feels like the corporate world, one, like you're saying, just the CEO doing engineering reviews does not always happen despite the fact that that is what the company is doing. But then time is often pretty finely sliced into, you know, half-hour meetings or even 15-minute meetings. And it seems like you hold more open-ended, we're talking about it until we figure it out type meetings.

Speaker 102:19:39

Sometimes.

Elon Musk02:19:40

Yeah.

Speaker 102:19:41

Sometimes, but most of them seem to more or less stay on time. So, I mean, today's Starship engineering review went a bit longer because there were more topics to discuss. You know, trying to figure out how to scale 2 million plus tons to order per year is quite challenging.

Elon Musk02:20:08

Can I ask a question? So you said about Optimus and AI that they're going to result in double-digit growth rates within a matter of years.

Speaker 102:20:17

Oh, like the economy?

Elon Musk02:20:18

Yeah.

Speaker 102:20:19

Yes. I think that's right.

Elon Musk02:20:22

What was the point of the DOGE cuts if the economy is going to grow so much?

Speaker 102:20:28

Well, I think like wasting food are not good things to have, you know. I was actually pretty worried about, I guess, I mean, I think in the absence of AI and robotics, we're actually totally screwed because the national debt is piling up like crazy. Now, our interest payments, the interest payments to national debt exceed the military budget, which is a trillion dollars. So we have over a trillion dollars just in interest payments.

You know, that was like, I was like, okay, pretty concerned about that. Maybe if I spend some time, we can slow down the bankruptcy of the United States and give us enough time for the AI and robots to, you know, help solve the national debt. Or not help solve. It's the only thing that could solve the national debt. Like we are 1000% going to go bankrupt as a country and fail as a country without AI and robots. Nothing else will solve the national debt. And so we'd like to, well, we just need, we need enough time to build the AI and robots to not go bankrupt before then.

Elon Musk02:21:39

I guess the thing I'm curious about is when DOGE starts, you have this enormous ability to enact reform and.

Speaker 102:21:47

Not that enormous.

Elon Musk02:21:48

Sure, sure. But totally by your point that like it's important that AI and robotics drive product improvements, drive GDP growth. But why not just directly go after the things you were pointing out, you know, like the tariffs on certain components or whether it's like permitting.

Speaker 102:22:03

I'm like the president. And very hard to cut, to cut, to even to cut things that are obvious waste and fraud, like ridiculous waste and fraud. What I discovered that is, it's extremely difficult even to cut very obvious ways and fraud from the government because the government has to operate on like who's complaining. And if you cut off payments to fraudsters, they immediately come up with the most sympathetic sounding reasons to continue the payment.

They don't say, please keep the fraud going. They say, you know, it's, they're like, you're killing baby pandas. And they're like, meanwhile, there's no baby pandas are dying. They're just making it up. But the forces are capable of coming up with extremely compelling sort of heart-wrenching stories that are false, but nonetheless sound sympathetic. And that's what happened. And so it's like, perhaps I should have known better. And I thought, wait, let's take a, let's try to cut some amount of ways and fraud from the government.

Maybe there shouldn't be, you know, 20 million people marked as alive in social security who are indefinitely dead and over the age of 115. The oldest American is 114. So it's safe to say if somebody is 115 and marked as alive in the social security database, something is, there's either a typo. So like somebody should call them and say, we seem to have your birthday wrong or we need to mark you as dead.

Elon Musk02:23:48

Okay.

Speaker 102:23:50

One of the two things.

Elon Musk02:23:51

Very intimidating call to get.

Speaker 102:23:52

Well, so it seems like a reasonable thing. And if like say their birthday is in the future and they have, you know, a small business administration loan and their birthday is 2165, we either again have a typo or we have fraud. So we say we appear to have gotten the century of your birth incorrect.

Elon Musk02:24:15

Or a great plot for a movie.

Speaker 102:24:16

Yes. This is, this is when I remember ludicrous fraud, that's when I remember ludicrous fraud.

Elon Musk02:24:22

Were those people getting payments?

Speaker 102:24:23

Some were getting payments from social security, but the main fraud vector was to mark somebody as alive in social security and then use every other government payment system to basically to do fraud. Because what those other government payment systems do would do, they would simply do an are you alive check to the social security database. It's a bank shot.

Elon Musk02:24:46

What would you estimate is like the total amount of fraud from this mechanism?

Speaker 102:24:50

My guess is, and other, by the way, the government accountability offices has done these estimates before. I'm not the only one who's coming out of this, you know. In fact, I think they did, the GAO did analysis, a rough estimate of fraud during the Biden administration and calculated at roughly half a trillion dollars. So don't take my word for it. Take it a report issued during the Biden administration. How about that?

Elon Musk02:25:14

From this social security mechanism?

Speaker 102:25:16

It's one of many. It's important to appreciate that the government does not, it's very ineffective at stopping fraud because it's not like, like if it was a company, like stopping fraud, you've got a motivation because it's affecting the earnings of your company. But the government just, they just print more money. So it's not, like you need caring and competence. And these are in short supply at the federal level.

Elon Musk02:25:49

Yeah, I'm sorry.

Speaker 102:25:50

I mean, when you go to the DMV, do you think, wow, this is a bastion of competence? Well, now imagine it's worse than the DMV because it's the DMV that can print money.

Elon Musk02:26:01

So was it not possible?

Speaker 102:26:02

At least the state-level DMVs need to, the states more or less need to stay within their budget when they go bankrupt. But the federal government just prints more money.

Elon Musk02:26:11

Was it not possible if there's a cashier, half a trillion of fraud, why was it not possible to cut all that?

Speaker 102:26:18

Because when, as soon as you, we did, we actually, look, you really have to stand back and recalibrate your expectations for competence because you're operating in a world where, you know, you've got to sort of make ends meet. Like, you know, you've got to pay your bills. You've got to, you know.

Elon Musk02:26:41

Buy the microphones.

Speaker 102:26:42

Yeah, yeah, exactly. So you, if you don't have, it's not like there's a giant, largely uncaring monster bureaucracy. It's not even, and a bunch of anachronistic computers that are just, that are just sending payments. Like one of the things that the DOGE team did, there was, and it sounds so simple that probably will save, let's say a hundred billion, maybe 200 billion a year, is simply requiring that payments from the main treasury computer, which is called PAM, like payment accounts master or something like that, there's 5 trillion payments a year, requiring that any payment that goes out have a payment appropriation code, make it mandatory, not optional, and that you have anything at all in the comment field.

Because you see, you have to recalibrate how dumb things are.

Elon Musk02:27:42

But you think.

Speaker 102:27:42

Payments were being sent out with no appropriation code, not checking back to any congressional appropriation and no explanation. And this is why the Department of War, formerly Department of Defense, cannot pass an audit because the information is literally not there. Recalibrate your expectations.

Elon Musk02:28:03

I want to better understand this officially a number because there was an IG report in 2024.

Speaker 102:28:08

But how, it's like, why is it so low?

Elon Musk02:28:10

Maybe, but we found that like over seven years, the social security fraud they estimated was like 70 billions over seven years, so like 10 billion a year. So I'd be curious to see what like the other 490 billion is.

Speaker 102:28:20

Federal government expenditures are 7.5 trillion a year.

Elon Musk02:28:22

Yeah.

Speaker 102:28:25

What percentage, how competent do you think government is?

Elon Musk02:28:28

The discretionary spending there is like 15%.

Speaker 102:28:33

Yeah, but it doesn't matter. Most of the fraud is non-discretionary. It's basically a fortunate Medicare, Medicaid, social security, you know, disability. There's a zillion government payments.

Elon Musk02:28:49

Yeah.

Speaker 102:28:50

And a bunch of these payments are in fact, they're block transfers to the states. So the federal government doesn't even have the information in a lot of cases to even see, know if there's fraud. Let's consider, let's like reducteo ad absurdum. The government, the government is perfect and has no fraud. What is your probability estimate of that?

Elon Musk02:29:13

I mean.

Speaker 102:29:14

Zero. Okay. So then would you say that fraud and waste, that the government is, is 90%? That also would be quite generous. But if it's only 90%, that means that there's $750 billion a year of waste and fraud. And it's not 90%. It's not 90% effective.

Elon Musk02:29:36

This seems like a strange rate of first principles in the amount of fraud in the government. Just like how much do you think there is? And then, anyways, we don't have to do it live, but I'd be curious to like see.

Speaker 102:29:45

I mean, you know a lot about fraud at Stripe. People are constantly trying to do fraud.

Elon Musk02:29:49

Yeah, but as you say, it's like a little bit of a, we've really ground it down, but it's a little bit of a different problem space because we're dealing with a much more heterogeneous set of fraud vectors here than we are.

Speaker 102:30:00

Yeah, but I mean, I mean, at Stripe, you have high competence and you try hard. You have high competence and high caring, but still fraud is non-zero. Now, imagine it's at a much bigger scale. There's much less competence and much less caring. You know, back at PayPal, back in the day, we tried to manage fraud down to about 1% of the payment volume. And that was very difficult. Took a tremendous amount of competence and caring to get fraud merely to 1%.

Now imagine that you're an organization where there's much less caring and much less competence. It's going to be much more than 1%.

Elon Musk02:30:41

How do you feel now looking back on kind of politics and doing stuff there where it feels like from the outside in, the two, you know, two things have been quite impactful. One, the America PAC and two, the acquisition of, well, Twitter at the time. But also it seems like there was a bunch of heartache. And so what's your, what's your grading of the whole experience?

Speaker 102:31:11

Well, I think, I think those things needed to be done to maximize the probability that the future is good. So, but politics generally is very tribal. And it's very tribal. And people lose their objectivity usually with politics. Like they generally have trouble seeing the good on the other side or the bad on their own side. That's generally how it goes.

That, I guess, was one of the things that surprised me the most is you often simply cannot reason with people. If they're in one tribe or the other, they simply believe that everything that tribe does is good and anything the other political tribe does is bad. And persuading them is, otherwise is almost impossible. So anyway, but I think, I think overall those actions, acquiring Twitter, getting trouble acted, even though it makes a lot of people angry, I think those, I think those actions are good for, were good for civilization.

Elon Musk02:32:30

But yeah, how does it feed into the future you're excited about?

Speaker 102:32:33

Well, America needs to, America needs to be strong enough to last long enough to extend life to other planets and to kind of get, I guess, AI and robotics to the point where we can ensure that the future is good. Like on the other hand, if we were to descend into, say, communism or some situation where the state was extremely oppressive, that would mean that we might not be able to become multi-planetary.

And we might, the state might, you know, stamp out our progress in AI and robotics.

Elon Musk02:33:17

How do you feel about, you know, Optimus, Grok, et cetera, are going to be leveraged by, and not just yours, any revenue maximizing company's products will be leveraged by the government over time. How does this concern manifest in what private companies should be willing to give governments? What kinds of guardrails should, like, should, you know, should AI models be made to do whatever the government that has contracted them out to do, ask them to do?

Should, like, should Grok get to say, like, actually even the military wants to do X? No, Grok will not do that.

Speaker 102:34:01

I think probably the biggest danger of AI, or maybe the biggest danger of AI and robotics going wrong is government.

Elon Musk02:34:10

Interesting.

Speaker 102:34:11

You know, I mean, the way that, like people who are opposed to corporations or worried about corporations should really worry about the most about government. Because government is just a corporation in the limit. It's a government, it is, it is, it is, the government is just the biggest corporation with a monopoly on violence. So I always find it like a strange dichotomy where people would think corporations are bad, but the government is good when the government is simply the biggest and worst corporation.

But people have that dichotomy. That's somehow think at the same time that government can be good, but corporations bad. And this is not true. Corporations have better morality than the government. So I actually think it's, you know, that's, that is a thing to be worried about. It's like, you know, should, should, if the government should not, like the government could potentially use AI and robotics to suppress the population. Like that is a serious concern.

Elon Musk02:35:18

As a guy building AI and robotics, how do you, how do you like, how do you prevent that?

Speaker 102:35:23

Well, I think that like if you have a limited government, if you limit the powers of government, which is like really what the US constitution is intended to do, is intended to limit the powers of government, then you're probably going to have a better outcome than if you have more government. So.

Elon Musk02:35:41

Robotics will be available to all governments, right?

Speaker 102:35:45

I don't know about all governments. I mean, it's difficult to predict the, like I said, like what's the end point or like what is many years in the future, but it's difficult to predict the sort of path along that way. Like if civilization progresses, AI will vastly exceed the sum of all human intelligence and there will be far more robots than humans.

Along the way, what happens is very difficult to predict.

Elon Musk02:36:20

I mean, it seems like one thing you could do is just say, you are not allowed to, whatever government does, you're not allowed to use Optimus to do X, Y, Z, just write out like a policy. I mean, I think you treated recently that Grok should have a moral constitution. And one of those things could be that we limit what governments are allowed to do with this advanced technology.

Speaker 102:36:40

I mean, yeah, we can do what is, I mean, technically, I mean, if the politicians pass a law and they can enforce that law, then it's hard to not do that law. You know, the best thing we can have is limited government where, you know, you have the appropriate cross-checks between the executive, judicial, and legislative branches.

Elon Musk02:37:11

I guess the reason I'm curious about it is this like, at some point it seems like the limits will come from you, right? Like you've got the Optimus, you've got the space GPUs, you've got the.

Speaker 102:37:20

I think I'll be the boss of the government.

Elon Musk02:37:22

Or you will get the, you will like the, I mean, already it's the case with SpaceX that for things that are crucial to the, like the government really cares about getting certain satellites up in space, whatever, like it needs SpaceX. It is the, it is the necessary contractor. And you are in the process of building more and more of the technological components of the future that will have an analogous role in different industries. And you could have this ability to like set some policy that, you know, is suppressing classical liberalism in any way.

My companies will not help in any way with that. Or, you know, some policy like that.

Speaker 102:38:05

I will do my best to ensure that anything that's within my control maximizes the good outcome for humanity. I think anything else would be shortsighted. Because obviously I'm part of humanity. So I like humans. Pro-human, pro-human.

Elon Musk02:38:29

You've mentioned that Dojo 3 will be used for space-based compute.

Speaker 102:38:34

You really read my, what I say.

Elon Musk02:38:38

I don't know if you know Twitter, but I know you like it. You have a lot of followers.

Speaker 102:38:42

Giveaway.

Elon Musk02:38:44

How do you.

Speaker 102:38:45

Honestly, you have just shown my secrets and I post them.

Elon Musk02:38:49

How do you design this chip for space? Like, yeah, what changes?

Speaker 102:38:53

Well, I guess you want to design it to be more radiation tolerant and run at a higher temperature. So you can, you know, roughly if you increase the operating temperature by 20% in degrees Kelvin, you can cut your radiator mass in half. So running at a higher temperature is helpful in space. I mean, there's various things you can do for shielding the memory and, but like neural nets are going to be very resilient to bit flips.

So like most of what happens for radiation is like random bit flips. But like if you've got like, you know, a multi-trillion parameter model. You get a few bit flips, it doesn't matter. It's much like heuristic programs are going to be much more sensitive to bit flips than some giant parameter file. So, but I just design it to run hot and I think it pretty much do it the same way that you do things on Earth, apart from make it run hotter.

Elon Musk02:40:01

I mean, the solar array is most of the weight on the satellite. Is there a way to make the GPUs even more powered ends than what Nvidia and TPUs and et cetera are planning on doing that would, you know, be especially privileged in the space-based world?

Speaker 102:40:17

Well, I mean, the basic math is like if you can do about a kilowatt per reticle, and then you'd need, you know, 100 million full reticle chips to do 100 gigawatts.

Elon Musk02:40:35

Yeah.

Speaker 102:40:38

So, yeah, depending on what your yield assumptions are, you know, that tells you how many chips you need to make. But you need, if you want, if you're going to have 100 gigawatts of power, you need, you know, 100 million chips running that are running a kilowatt sustained output per reticle.

Elon Musk02:41:03

100.

Speaker 102:41:04

Basic math.

Elon Musk02:41:05

100 million chips. It depends on, yeah, if you look at the dye size of something like black wall GPUs or something and how many you can get out of a wafer, you can get like on the order of dozens or less per wafer. So basically this is a world where if we're putting that out every single year, you're producing millions of wafers a month. That's the plan with Terrafab?

Millions of wafers a month of advanced process nodes?

Speaker 102:41:38

It's got to be some number north of a million, I think. You got to do the memory too.

Elon Musk02:41:41

Yeah. Are you going to make a memory fab?

Speaker 102:41:44

I think the Terrafab's got to do memory. It's got to do logic memory and packaging.

Elon Musk02:41:48

I'm very curious how somebody like gets started. This is like the most complicated thing man has ever made. And obviously, like if anybody's up to the task, you're up to the task. Like what do you, so you realize this is a bottleneck and you go to your engineers and like, what is the next, like what do you tell them to do? I want a million wafers a month in 2030. What is the next, like what do you, do you like call ASML? Like what is the.

Speaker 102:42:11

That's what I want.

Elon Musk02:42:13

What is the next.

Speaker 102:42:14

That's so much to ask. Well, we make a little fab and see what happens. Make our mistakes at a small scale and then make a big one.

Elon Musk02:42:25

Is a little fab done?

Speaker 102:42:27

Now is it done. I mean, people would, they're not going to keep that cat in the bag. That cat's going to come out of the back room. There'll be like drones hovering over the bloody thing, you know? You'll be able to like see its construction progress on X, right? You know, in real time. So no, we, I mean, like, I don't know, we could just flounder in failure. To be clear, it's like not, success is not guaranteed, but since we want to try to make, you know, something like 100 million, we need, we want 100 gigawatts of power and 100 chips that can take 100 gigawatts, right?

So call it, you know, yeah, by 2030. So then, and we'll take as many chips as our suppliers will give us. I've said this to, I've actually said this to TSMC and Samsung and Micron. It's like, please build your more fabs faster. And we will guarantee to buy the output of those fabs. So they're already like moving as fast as they can. Like it's, it's not like, to be clear, it's not like us, you know, it's not like either, it's not like, it's us plus them, you know?

Elon Musk02:43:46

There's a narrative that the people doing AI want a very large number of, you know, chips as quickly as possible. And then many of the input suppliers, the fabs, but also, you know, the turbine manufacturers are not ramping up production very quickly.

Speaker 102:44:02

No, no.

Elon Musk02:44:03

Yeah. The explanation you hear is that they're dispositionally conservative. You know, they're Taiwanese or German as the story may be. And they just like don't believe the, like is that really the explanation or is there something else?

Speaker 102:44:17

Well, I mean, it's reasonable to, like if somebody's been in, say, the computer memory business for 30 or 40 years.

Elon Musk02:44:25

And they've seen cycles.

Speaker 102:44:27

They've seen like boom and bust like 10 times.

Elon Musk02:44:30

Yeah.

Speaker 102:44:30

You know, so like that's a lot of layers of scar tissue, you know? So it's like, it's like during the boom times, it looks like everything is going to be great forever. And then the crash happens and then they desperately try to avoid bankruptcy. And then there's another boom and then another crash.

Elon Musk02:44:46

Are there other, are there other ideas you think others should go pursue that you're not for whatever reasons right now?

Speaker 102:44:55

I mean, there are a few companies that are pursuing like new ways of doing chips. But they're just not scaling fast.

Elon Musk02:45:03

I don't even mean within AI, I mean just generally.

Speaker 102:45:06

I'd say like people should just do the thing that where they find that they're highly motivated to do that thing. As opposed to, you know, something, some idea that I suggest. They should do the thing that they find personally interesting and motivating to do. But, you know, going back to the limiting factor, I use that phrase about a hundred times.

The current limiting factor that I see in the timeframe, you know, in the sort of 2029, like in the three to four year timeframe, it's chips. In the one year timeframe, it's energy, power production, electricity. Like it's not clear to me that there's enough usable electricity to turn on all the AI chips that are being made.

Towards the end of this year, I think people are going to have real trouble turning on, like the chip output will exceed the ability to turn chips on.

Elon Musk02:46:17

What's your plan to deal with that world?

Speaker 102:46:20

Well, we're trying to accelerate electricity production. I guess that's maybe one of the reasons that XAI will be maybe the leader, hopefully the leader, is that we'll be able to turn on more chips than other people can turn on faster. Because we're good at hardware. And generally the innovations from the corporations that call themselves labs, the ideas tend to flow, like it's rare to see that there's like more than about a six month difference between, like the ideas travel back and forth with the people.

So, so I think you sort of hit the hardware wall and then whatever, whichever company can scale hardware the fastest will be the leader. And so I think XAI will be able to scale hardware the fastest and therefore most likely will be the leader.

Elon Musk02:47:21

You joked or, you know, were self-conscious about, you know, using the limiting factor phrase again. But I actually think there's something deep here. And if you look at a lot of the things we've touched on over the course of it, maybe kind of a good note to end on. Like if you think of a senescent lower agency company, it would have some bottleneck and not really be doing anything about it. You know, Marc Andreessen had the line of, most people are willing to endure any amount of chronic pain to avoid acute pain.

And it feels like a lot of the cases we're talking about are just leaning into the acute pain, whatever it is. It's like, okay, we got to figure out how to, you know, work with steel or we got to figure out how to run the chips in space or like we'll take some near-term acute pain to actually solve the bottleneck. And so that's kind of a unifying theme.

Speaker 102:48:13

I have a high pain threshold. That's helpful.

Elon Musk02:48:17

Solve the bottlenecks.

Speaker 102:48:19

Yes. So, you know, one thing I can say is like, I think the future is going to be very interesting. And as I said, the dowel was up, I think I was literally dowel swinging because it was like on the ground for like three hours or something. It's better to be, it's better to err on the side of optimism and be wrong than err on the side of pessimism and be right for quality of life.

So, you know, your happiness will be, you'll be happier if you err on the side of optimism rather than erring on the side of pessimism. And so I recommend erring on the side of optimism.

Elon Musk02:49:08

Nice to know. Cool. Yolan, thanks for doing this.

Speaker 102:49:11

Thank you.

Elon Musk02:49:11

All right, thanks, guys.

Speaker 102:49:14

All right.

Elon Musk02:49:14

Oh, great stamina. Hopefully this encounter is a pain in the pain tolerance.

Speaker 302:49:21

Hey everybody, I hope you enjoyed that episode. If you did, the most helpful thing you can do is just share it with other people who you think might enjoy it. It's also helpful if you leave a rating or a comment on whatever platform you're listening on. If you're interested in sponsoring the podcast, you can reach out at dwarkesh.com/advertise. Otherwise, I'll see you in the next one.

Episode description

In this episode, John and I got to do a real deep-dive with Elon. We discuss the economics of orbital data centers, the difficulties of scaling power on Earth, what it would take to manufacture humanoids at high-volume in America, xAI’s business and alignment plans, DOGE, and much more.

Watch on YouTube; read the transcript.

Sponsors

* Mercury just started offering personal banking! I’m already banking with Mercury for business purposes, so getting to bank with them for my personal life makes everything so much simpler. Apply now at mercury.com/personal-banking

* Jane Street sent me a new puzzle last week: they trained a neural net, shuffled all 96 layers, and asked me to put them back in order. I tried but… I didn’t quite nail it. If you’re curious, or if you think you can do better, you should take a stab at janestreet.com/dwarkesh

* Labelbox can get you robotics and RL data at scale. Labelbox starts by helping you define your ideal data distribution, and then their massive Alignerr network collects frontier-grade data that you can use to train your models. Learn more at labelbox.com/dwarkesh

Timestamps

(00:00:00) - Orbital data centers

(00:36:46) - Grok and alignment

(00:59:56) - xAI’s business plan

(01:17:21) - Optimus and humanoid manufacturing

(01:30:22) - Does China win by default?

(01:44:16) - Lessons from running SpaceX

(02:20:08) - DOGE

(02:38:28) - TeraFab

This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.dwarkesh.com