Transcript of Hamas Agrees to Trump Plan, Shutdown Day 4, Medicaid Cuts

Hamas says, yes to President Trump's ceasefire proposal, but still wants to negotiate some conditions.

Israel said it's ready to implement the plan. Trump has told Israel to stop the bombing in Gaza. I'm Scott Simon.

I'm Ayesha Rosca with Up First from NPR News. It's day four of a government shutdown. The Democrats refuse to budge in a Senate vote yesterday.

They want Congress to increase health care benefits.

Medicaid covers health care for many people with low income, kids and adults.

Three and five nursing home residents in the US also rely on Medicaid.

And they may be some of the first to feel the pain as states slash the programs.

We'll hear from some people who are directly affected.

So stay with us. We have the news you need. Start your weekend.

On the Through Line podcast from NPR, immigration enforcement might be more visible now, but this moment didn't begin with President Trump's second inauguration or even his first. A series from Through Line about how immigration became political and a cash cow. Listen to Through Line in the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. On the next Through Line from NPR.

People have real ethical and moral quandries about this.

People are uncomfortable from the very beginning.

The business of migrant detention.

Listen in the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Every year in the US, about a thousand people die in jail, many of them awaiting trial. This isn't a problem that someone else has to deal with. We all are at risk for dying in jails. In a special series, we'll look at why people are dying in jail and how to prevent it from happening on Here and Now, Any Time, a podcast from NPR and WBR.

Hamas says it's ready to release all remaining hostages in Gaza, living and dead.

The militant group said yesterday it accepted President Trump's ceasefire proposal, but still wants to negotiate some of the conditions. Npr's Emily Fange joins us now from Tel Aviv. Emily, thanks for being with us.

Hey, Scott. It's a pleasure.

It seems like it could be a serious step toward actually ending the two-year war. Is it? And what's in the plan?

Yes, you're right. It is. You have Israel, you have Hamas, you have major Arab countries like Qatar and Egypt, and then, of course, the US who proposed this current formulation, all signing on to the basic principles of this plan to end the war. Now, the basic outline of this plan is not a new one. Hamas has said it's going to return all hostages living in dead within 72 hours. Then Israel is supposed to stop its in Gaza, and then Israel, the US, and Arab countries, working with Palestinian leaders, figure out a day after plan to govern and rebuild the enclave. What is new is there's been so much pressure mounting on all sides, and that has created this potential breakthrough. A person briefed by an Israeli official told NPR today that Israel's military has been ordered to reduce their activity in Gaza to, a minimum and only for defensive actions.

But no ceasefire yet, right?

No. In fact, NPR's Anas Baba, who is in Gaza, and he's been there for the entirety of this war, says there was still shelling that continued overnight. There were at least three strikes this morning. Israel's military said Gaza City, which is the strip's most populous urban center, is still off limits. Remember, Remember this week, it had given Palestinians there a last chance to flee, saying that anyone who remained would be considered a militant. And I want to sound a note of caution. There is still a chance that this proposal falls apart.

And Emily, why Isn't the plan implemented right away?

Hamas has come back and said they accept the first phase, but officials with Hamas have said they need more details on the exact timetable and process for how and when Israeli forces would withdraw from Gaza, and when Israel would let more food and aid in. And then there's the big question of who governs Gaza. Under the American plan, an international board of experts that would be headed by President Trump and includes the former British Prime Minister, Tony Blair, would initially run the believe. And Hamas would have no role at all. But let's listen to this interview that Osama Hamdan, a senior Hamas official, gave to Al Jazeera last night.. So Hamdine says here, Hamas will not accept the affairs of Gaza to be run by a non-Palestinian party. And then he went on in this interview to say Hamas is fundamental to resolving issues facing any future Palestinian state. And that all clashes with US and Israeli assertions that Hamas would have no presence and that its fighters should leave Gaza. Earlier this week, another Hamas official named Mohamed Nassal also told Al Jazeera, the group is not reviewing this American plan with a, quote, black or white mindset.

So they very much see this proposal as a work in progress and not a final agreement. And the question is now whether the US and Israel can accept or perhaps even ignore for now these proposed revisions from Hamas and move forward to at least the first step to get the hostages back ASAP.

And how is Hamas's response being received in Israel?

There's cautious optimism. Israel's main opposition leader says he backs the proposal as well. Many of the families of the hostages have been lobbying for an end to the war for a month so they can release the hostages and get them back. They've lent their support to this first phase of the proposal, but there's so much distrust, including a worry that Hamas is stall for time. Officials with the group are saying, in order to exhume some of the hostages' bodies, they need maybe more than the three days that have been allocated to retrieve these people's bodies in a warzone.

Emily Fung in Tel Aviv. Thanks so much.

Thanks, Scott.

Is day four of a government shutdown. And since Tuesday, the Senate has taken up the same votes to fund the government temporarily by continuing resolutions.

They still don't have the votes, but is there an agreement even on the distant horizon? And for our Congressional Correspondent, Barbara Sprunt, joins us. Thanks for being with us.

Hey, thank you.

The Senate yesterday failed once more to advance competing plans to extend federal funding and end the shutdown. How are those plans different again?

Well, one is a GOP plan that has already passed the House. It would fund the government through November 21st. Then there's a Democratic counter proposal as well. That would fund the government through October, and it includes an extension of health care tax credits that were boosted up during the pandemic. Those are on to expire at the end of the year. Now, Republicans have said they'll negotiate on that point, but only after the government is funded. Even then, Senate Majority Leader John Thune has said it would not be a simple process.

We can't make commitments or promises on the COVID subsidies because that's not something that we can guarantee that they're the votes there to do. There were a few Democrats who did support the Republican proposal this week. Has there been any more movement or are the numbers tight? Okay.

No, they are not. It has been the same as that first vote where we saw two Democratic senators and one independent joining Republicans. In fact, there's been so little movement on any negotiation between the two parties that the Senate isn't even expected to stay over the weekend and do more votes. Here's Thune yesterday when asked about the possibility of weekend work.

Hopefully, over the weekend, they'll have a chance to think about it.

Maybe some of these conversations start to result in something to where we can start moving some votes and actually get this thing passed.

The impasse is essentially this. Because the Senate needs Democrats to reach that 60 vote threshold to pass this bill, Democrats, who, of course, have very little power as the party in the minority, say that demanding that there be some negotiations between the two parties is appropriate. Unsurprisingly, Republicans do not share that view. They say Democrats are holding the American people hostage via this shutdown.

Of course, in the meantime, the White House is proceeding with to cut programs and spending. Often, it seems in areas with lots of Democratic voters. What is the argument they make here?

Well, this is very much in line with the administration's thesis when it comes to its role in cutting programs and government workers. Items on the chopping block include some transportation projects in New York, the home state of both the House and Senate Democratic leaders. Press Secretary, Caroline Levit, told our colleague, Stevenski, yesterday that the administration views that as minority leader Chuck Schumer's fault.

They can't show up to work right now. So that project is currently temporarily halted because of Chuck Schumer's shutdown.

So Chuck Schumer did that to himself.

He did that to his constituents in New York.

And how do Democrats respond?

Well, Democrats have called this an intimidation tactic. They blasted a plan from the White House's budget arm to fire federal workers instead of temporarily furlowing them, which is usually what happens in a shutdown. Independent Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont said he thinks that plan will backfire.

The idea that you have a president who says, Hey, your state voted against me, we're going to cut money from you.

That is not only illegal, not only outrageous, it is unconstitutional.

Democrats like Sanders insists these cuts are illegal, but it's an open question right now. There are several active lawsuits challenging the administration's cuts to congressionally approved spending.

And here's Barbara Sprunt. Thanks so much for all your reporting.

Thank you, Scott.

We're in a federal government shutdown over Affordable Care Act tax credits.

Meanwhile, state governments are beginning to make cuts to their Medicaid programs. That's the public health insurance that covers more than 70 million Americans.

Those cuts are likely to continue regardless of how the shutdown ends. We're now joined by Bram Sable-Smith, reporter with our partner, KFF Health News. Thanks for joining us.

Happy to be here.

For those who might not be familiar with the benefit, can you briefly tell us what Medicaid usually pays for?

So Medicaid is a joint program between the feds and the states. We I don't really think of it as covering adults and kids with lower incomes, but it also pays for longer term services like in-home care for people with disabilities and also nursing home care. Three and five nursing home residents in the US rely on Medicaid. It's a large program. It typically makes up around 19% of the spending from any given state's general fund. Many states are facing budget shortfalls, and they're looking to slash their Medicaid programs to make due.

These programs are pretty tightly funded to start with, right? I mean, what is there to slash?

Right. Well, so far this year, two states have forced every medical provider that accepts Medicaid to take a pay cut. So, Idaho announced a 4% across the board cut in September. And most recently, North Carolina, on Wednesday, cut pay by at least 3%. Primary care got an 8% cut, and specialty care saw a 10% cut.

That sounds like a lot. I mean, what effect do those pay cuts have on people's access to health care?

Well, when you cut payments to doctors and to nurses and to physical therapists, they become less likely to accept patients that have Medicaid coverage.

Okay. Is that already happening in states that cut payments?

Yes, it is. I spoke recently to Alessandra Fabrello. She lives in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, and she's a medical caregiver for her son, Isidore, who's now 18. He experienced a rare brain condition as a baby that kills brain tissue, and he's needed round-the-clock care ever since.

He struggles to survive every single day. It is almost impossible to explain what it takes to keep a child alive who should be dead.

Medicaid is supposed to pay for him to get that care at home. Otherwise, he'd have to live in a hospital. But even before this rate cut, Alessandra said it's been extremely difficult finding in-home medical providers who take Medicaid. Take physical therapy, for example.

He doesn't receive any therapy. He qualifies for therapy, but he doesn't receive any in-home therapy because we cannot find providers because of the reimbursement rate as it is.

Medicaid already paid way less than private insurance, so not many providers take it. Now with these new cuts, even more providers are dropping out. For the past year, North Carolina's Medicaid program paid Alessandra herself to take care of Isidore. It's her main source of income, and now she's facing a pay cut, too.

Are we going to see cuts like this in other states across the country?

Well, we don't know yet what other states plan to do, but these cuts in North in Carolina and in Idaho really could be an indication of things to come elsewhere. There's a perfect storm brewing right now. State budgets are getting squeezed. Medicaid costs are going up. Some states are cutting taxes. Federal COVID relief dollars that states were using to patch budget holes in the past fully dried up this year. Of course, President Trump's signature budget legislation is going to cut federal spending on Medicaid by almost $1 trillion over the next decade. States will have to make that up or cut services. These provider pay cuts are an example of how states will begin to manage those shortfalls.

Well, we will continue monitoring the situation, as I'm sure you will, too. That's Bram Sable-Smith. He's a reporter with our partner, KFF Health News. Thanks so much for your reporting.

Thanks for having me.

That's up first for Saturday, October fourth, 2025. I'm Scott Simon.

I'm Ayesha Rosco.

Dave Mistich, produce today's podcast with help from Elaina Touric, Ryan Bank, Fernando Naro, and Andy Craig. Our editor has been Hadeel Halshalchi, along with Keltie Snell, Deepar Vaz, Ed McNulti, Diane Webber, Taranil Jim Caine, Miguel Macias, and Eric McDade. Fernando Naro, Director.

Our Technical Director was Zovan Genhoven, with engineering support from Nisha Hynes and Ted Meebaing.

Our Senior Supervising Editor is Shannon Rod. Z. B. Stone is our executive producer, and our Deputy Managing Editor is Jim Caine.

Tomorrow on the Sunday Story, NPR's Mary Louise Kelly helps explain America's shifting role around the world.

And there is so much more on a device called the radio. So find your local NPR station at stations. Npr. Org.

We're still here. We're still here.

And stronger and more dedicated than ever.

Yes.

Want to hear this podcast without sponsor breaks? Amazon Prime members can listen to Up First sponsor-free through Amazon Music. Or you can also support NPR's vital journalism and get Up First Plus at plus. Npr. Org. That's plus. Npr. Org. Here at Life Kit, we take advice seriously. We bring you evidence-based recommendations. To do that, we talk with researchers and experts on all sorts of topics, because we have the same questions you do. Like, What's really in my shampoo? Or, should I let my kid quit soccer? Or, what should I do with my savings in uncertain economic times. You can listen to NPR's Life Kit in the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Shortwave thinks of science as an invisible force, showing up in your everyday life, empowering the food you eat, the medicine you use, the tech in your pocket. Science is approachable because it's already part of your life.

Come explore these connections on the Shortwave podcast from NPR.