Transcript of What’s Behind Back-to-Back Meltdowns at the F.A.A. and Microsoft

10:56 8 min read 1 views Published about 9 hours ago

Copy link
Episode summary

This episode of The Headlines covers the FAA's nationwide ground stop, which officials trace to a router upgrade in Arkansas, and the transportation secretary's request for $50 billion in air traffic control funding. It also looks at the fallout from Jensen Huang's resignation as Nvidia's chief executive ahead of Trump's trip to China, a delayed Medicaid work requirement, a drop in new international students at U.S. universities, and a Microsoft outage that followed an upgrade.

The episode closes with new research in the journal Science suggesting crows make decisions faster than humans, which challenges the idea of birds as dim-witted.

In this episode Tracy Mumford, Karoun Demirjian

This episode of The Headlines on the FAA ground stop and Microsoft outage was made with HappyScribe's Teams transcription technology.

Tracy Mumford00:00:02

From the New York Times, it's The Headlines. I'm Tracy Mumford. Today is Monday, November 16. Here's what we're covering.

Speaker 200:00:14

Can you guarantee that what happened on Friday won't happen again, Mr. Secretary?

Speaker 300:00:19

Well, first, we have to figure out what happened. Was this a faulty installation by L3 Harris that was doing the.

Tracy Mumford00:00:25

The Secretary of Transportation, Sean Duffy, says that this weekend's airport chaos was set off by an attempt to update the FAA's antiquated communications system.

Speaker 300:00:35

It goes back 20, 25, 30 years of a lack of investment, a lack of, you know, waving the flag to say, hey, this is a problem, let's fix it. Why they didn't do that, I don't know.

Tracy Mumford00:00:47

After the FAA issued a rare nationwide ground stop on Friday, thousands of flights were canceled, stranding tens of thousands of passengers and snarling air travel for days. Here's what we know so far about what set everything off. Officials say it began when a contractor upgraded a router in a radio facility in Arkansas, part of an effort to replace old-school copper wire systems with fiber optic cable. In the middle of that, officials noticed that the facility and another recently upgraded one in Texas had started to ping the FAA communications network at an abnormally high rate, basically overwhelming the system with data.

According to the FAA's chief technology officer, that set off failures in other parts of the network and forced officials to declare the ground stop.

Karoun Demirjian00:01:37

There are vulnerabilities in the FAA's telecoms and infrastructure systems that mean that when something goes wrong, there isn't necessarily a buffer or a cushion there. The FAA administrator, Brian Bedford, on Saturday morning said, "There are no backups to the backup."

Tracy Mumford00:01:53

Karin Demirjan covers aviation and transportation for The Times. She says there have been concerns about how the Trump administration is handling the much-needed effort to modernize the country's air traffic control network. Earlier this fall, a nonpartisan government watchdog warned that the government was moving too quickly to overhaul such a fragile system.

Karoun Demirjian00:02:14

It's a major project. It's something that there is bipartisan agreement has to be tackled, but there is disagreement about whether the style in which this administration is tackling this and the way in which they are looking at these potential points of failure, or actual points of failure, as we saw on Friday, is really adequately taking these risks into consideration.

Tracy Mumford00:02:37

Over the weekend, Duffy called on Congress to fast-track $50 billion in new funding for air traffic control upgrades by the end of the year. That's a drastically larger sum than he's asked for before, and it drew sharp criticism from some lawmakers. Two top Democrats on House panels overseeing the FAA put out a statement pointing out that the agency "still hasn't spent the majority of the funds Congress already gave it for modernization."

This week, President Trump is headed to China for a meeting that was intended to be about extending a trade war truce, but now has a new twist.

Speaker 500:03:22

Are you going to bring up the case of Jensen Huang with President Xi when you visit with him?

Speaker 600:03:26

No, I don't think so. I mean, maybe. I'm sure President Xi will ask me about it. I just know Jensen very well. I just think he's a very honorable man. I mean.

Tracy Mumford00:03:36

Trump will be making the trip with the shock of Jensen Huang's resignation from Nvidia still fresh. And despite the geopolitical storm around it, Trump has told reporters he doesn't plan to bring up the issue himself of Huang and his affair with a woman who U.S. intelligence officials believe is a Chinese spy.

Speaker 600:03:53

Should he have stepped down? Well, the big thing is, was the woman a spy? And I don't know if that's been determined yet.

Tracy Mumford00:04:03

The president has said he doesn't remember being briefed on the intelligence and has downplayed concerns about it. But my colleague David Pearson, who covers China, says the situation has underscored what's happening between the two countries behind the scenes.

Speaker 700:04:17

Under Xi, China has intensified its spying operations. It has transformed its spy agency known as the Ministry of State Security from really an unsophisticated operation, just, you know, dealing with rumors at embassy dinner parties, to using AI tools, to, you know, employing the public to help them in all intelligence gathering now. At the same time, the United States has also stepped up its resources in spying on China, recognizing that it has to expand the scope of its intelligence gathering to include Chinese businesses, because so much of the competition between China and the United States is economic today.

So on the surface, it looks like the two leaders are helping stabilize relations, and on some level, it really is like that. But just beneath the surface, there's still a furious spy war going on between the two countries.

Tracy Mumford00:05:18

Now, two other quick updates on the Trump administration. First, federal officials have pushed back a key deadline that affects millions of people on Medicaid. As of January 1, many Medicaid recipients were going to have to complete forms proving they were working or volunteering to keep their insurance coverage. And a lot of hospitals had gone into overdrive, trying to alert patients to the upcoming changes in time. Now the administration says states can wait until this summer to start enforcing the work rules, acknowledging how difficult it's been to build new software systems to track the stricter eligibility requirements.

Still, the eventual rollout of the new rules is expected to have a widespread impact on patients and health care systems. According to a government estimate, over the next few years, the rules will mean that about 5 million Americans lose their health insurance, including many who get tripped up by the new paperwork challenges. And a new survey out today shows that international student enrollment at American universities is continuing to plunge, as Trump administration policies appear to be driving foreign students away.

According to data from the Institute of International Education, new international student enrollment dropped by 15% this fall. That's on top of an 18% drop last year. While the U.S. is still the top destination for international students worldwide, changing visa policies and fears over the White House's crackdown on immigrants have made some students decide to go elsewhere for their higher education. That is already taking a major toll on universities' bottom line. Many international students pay full tuition, effectively subsidizing the cost for Americans.

And schools around the U.S. have already cited a loss of revenue from international students as the reason they've had to lay off employees, cut budgets, and close programs. News now on the other recent tech outage that left people scrambling over the past few days. Not the FAA, but Microsoft.

Speaker 300:07:28

Outlook is down. Exchange Online Teams down. Copilot is down.

Tracy Mumford00:07:32

Starting on Thursday, millions of people worldwide were cut off from email, video meetings, and other features.

Speaker 300:07:37

I literally just tried to open up an email in Outlook, and Outlook looked at me like, are you stupid?

Tracy Mumford00:07:42

The technical issues ballooned to affect people across the U.S. and dozens of other countries. Singapore's tax authorities couldn't receive messages, pharmacies in Britain struggled to fill prescriptions, and Australian intelligence and police forces said their operations were also affected. By Saturday, the tech giant was able to fully restore its services. Microsoft said the outage was not a cyber attack or related to artificial intelligence. Instead, the company said that the problems began during an upgrade, similar to the FAA.

Experts say those two upgrades gone awry highlight how fragile many digital systems actually are, in everything from banking to health care to transportation. A lot of them rely on a combination of new and old hardware plus software that needs frequent updating. Over the years, they've almost become like geological formations, with new layers piling on top of old ones. Upset that delicate balance, though, and the whole system can come crashing down. Microsoft has yet to provide a clear answer for what exactly went wrong during the update.

It's promised to publish a full report identifying the, quote, "root cause" of the outage. And finally, humans owe birds an apology. For a long time, scholars studying birds looked at their small brains and concluded they weren't all that bright, hence the term "bird brain," not a compliment. But evidence has been increasingly piling up that there's a lot more happening in there than anyone was giving birds credit for.

For example, some species are capable of distinguishing between cancerous and non-cancerous cells, and others can recognize their own image, solve abstract problems, even plan for the future. And now, new research published in the journal Science shows that crows specifically can make decisions faster than humans. The research involved placing crows in front of a swirling mass of dots on a screen and rewarding them for answering whether the dots were moving to the left or the right.

The crows reliably pecked their answers twice as fast as rhesus monkeys or humans, and they did it without compromising accuracy. One of the authors of the study said he even put all the people in his lab up against the birds- undergrads, PhDs, postdocs- and they were all too slow for the crows. The research underscores how the avian brain, despite being small, is tuned for rapid processing. The research team suspects it has a lot to do with how risky flying is.

Tracy Mumford00:10:23

In order to stay alive up there, you've got to make a lot of decisions really quick. Those are The Headlines. And before we go, my favorite piece of crow coverage from The Times remains the research that showed how good crows are at holding grudges. It turns out they can even pass them down, creating what I guess you would call multi-generational crow wrath. I'm Tracy Mumford. We'll be back tomorrow.

Episode description

Plus, why “birdbrain” is a misnomer. 

Here’s what we’re covering:

Duffy Points to Router in Arkansas as Start of Nationwide Ground Stop, by Karoun Demirjian
Nvidia Fallout Looms Over Trump-Xi Meeting, by Katie Rogers
Trump Administration Delays Enforcement of Medicaid Work Requirement, by Sarah Kliff and Margot Sanger-Katz
International Students Are Turning Away From U.S. Universities, by Stephanie Saul and Steven Rich
When Tech ‘Upgrades’ Go Awry, by Steve Lohr
‘Birdbrain’ Is a Misnomer. Crows Make Decisions Faster Than We Can, by Taylor Mitchell Brown

Tune in every weekday morning, and tell us what you think at: theheadlines@nytimes.com.

Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and Amazon Music. You can also subscribe via your favorite podcast app here https://www.nytimes.com/activate-access/audio?source=podcatcher. For more podcasts and narrated articles, download The New York Times app at nytimes.com/app.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.