Steven Bartlett talks with Harvard geneticist David Sinclair about how eating habits may shape the pace of ageing. Sinclair argues that adversity such as fasting and exercise triggers cellular repair, and he explains the role of sirtuins and NAD, the molecule that fuels them.
They discuss NMN supplements, practical ways to begin a fasting window of around 14 hours, the case for multi-day fasts, and why Sinclair is sceptical of long-term ketogenic diets. The conversation closes on polyphenols in plants like blueberries and matcha, which Sinclair presents as a way to mimic some benefits of fasting through food.
In this episode Steven Bartlett, David Sinclair
This episode's transcript on fasting, NAD and cellular ageing with David Sinclair was made with HappyScribe's meeting transcription technology.
Ads in this audio differ from the text. Tap the sentence you're hearing to follow along.
Synced: the text now follows the audio.
Um, I have got this. You told me to— to bring my weighted vest and this neck brace.
Oh my goodness.
I think I put it on the wrong way.
Any— anyone listening, Steven's putting on a very heavy jacket right now with lead weights and a strap around his neck to limit his neck movement.
Oh, wow. That's a lot. Listen, so I'm— I just put on a 20, I think it's 20 kilogram, unless I'm weak now, um, jacket and a neck brace. And ahead of this conversation, my team told me to get one of these. What is the analogy here that you're creating? This is very—
It's bad, right?
It's hard, yeah.
Right. Imagine feeling like that for a decade. That's old age. You're feeling tired, weak, you can barely hold your body up, you can barely move your neck. It would be painful. You're not in pain yet.
Right.
But most people in their 80s have some sort of disease and aches and pains. Try doing that for another 10 minutes, maybe. How long can you keep that on?
I'll keep it on for another 10 minutes. But so why is this? Because it just— it's weight and immobility. I can't move my neck the same. My shoulders feel heavier. How is this a relevant analogy to aging? Because it just kind of feels like immobility and weight.
Uh, well, I have to come over there and use this pair of scissors to be stabbing you as well, so you can feel pain as you move as well. That's part of old age. It is not a fun thing, being old. And most old people, the reason that they don't love life anymore is because they feel like you do. Or worse. Not to mention the fact that they're— you need to put Vaseline on your eyes, earplugs in your ears if you want to know what it's like being old.
Oh, God, it's not nice.
Or even worse, shut your eyes and you can never open them again. That's what it's like for those patients that we hope to cure blindness in.
If— if I'm going to ask you a really tough question, which is, if I put a calculator in front of you right now.
Yeah.
And you had to hit a number on that calculator and then hit enter, and that was the age that you were going to live to.
Yeah.
And you had to make that decision now.
Yeah.
What number would you hit on that calculator?
Infinity.
Really? So you'd do, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.
There's no day if you're healthy where you want to die. Even if you're 100, 120, if you have friends, family, loved ones, you're healthy, would you say, "Okay, tomorrow I'm ready to die"?
No.
No.
Unless there was some kind of psychiatric issue or something.
Exactly. Right? So that's my point, is when people say, "Oh, when I'm 80, kill me," that is bullshit. That's— excuse my language.
It's fine.
Am I allowed to swear on this?
No, of course you can.
Um.
Sorry, we're going to have to beep it for the kids, I guess.
It's only when you're sick or you have depression that you want to leave this world. Otherwise, life is a joy for most people in the world. Not everybody, and we have to fix that as well. But for most of us, being alive is the greatest gift of any, you know, collection of atoms. Consciousness is even greater. And why would you want that to end? Who would choose that if they had the alternative to be with family and friends?
Interesting. I say that's interesting because I have always assumed that I wouldn't want to live forever. But the— when you asked me if I was healthy and I had my friends and family and I was doing things that I loved professionally, would there come a day where I would choose to go now? No, there wouldn't. Just like there hasn't come a day in the last 33 years where I've chosen to go now.
Mm-hmm. Exactly.
Do you think it's going to be possible in the next 50 years for us to live forever?
I'd be shocked if that happened. But I've been shocked my whole career at how fast this technology is moving. And now with AI, things are going so fast, my head's spinning. So I'd be happy to be proven wrong. But I'm skeptical that we could live forever, in my lifetime at least. But as I said, you're probably going to live— you are going to live into the 22nd century. We can't imagine what the world's going to be like then.
And AI has really changed this equation.
Oh, absolutely. We're doing things in my lab that would have taken 160 years before. And quite literally billions of dollars on a $10,000 budget.
Well, I guess I better make it to 2040. So let's talk about fasting and food and nutrition and go a little bit deeper on that. I've had so many conversations over the years about this subject of fasting. But as I was reading your research, you really do feel that fasting, just eating less often, is one of the most important things that we can all do for longevity.
I do. I do, and I practice it as much as I can, though it's challenging in a world that's full of abundant food. But yes, we've known for thousands of years, the ancients are not dummies. They could witness what happens when you fast. Clarity of mind, long-term health, they could observe the difference between the gluttons and the people that fasted for religious reasons. It's obvious, but there's certain ways to do it. Fasting doesn't include malnutrition. You have to do it with abundant, you know, vitamins, minerals. You want to make sure that you have adequate nutrition.
But I think three meals a day is craziness. It turns out this idea, breakfast is the most important meal of the day, is marketing from the early 20th century by companies I will not name. But it was breakfast cereal. Breakfast is not the most important meal of the day for most people, especially adults. Especially if you're not hungry when you wake up. There's no point in eating if you're not hungry in the morning. I'm one of those people. So I've skipped breakfast. How about you?
Yeah, I'm the same. I'm the same. I don't eat. My first meal today was 3 p.m. because I had a podcast until, you know, 2 p.m. So which is typical for me. I just don't get hungry in the mornings. Because of the marketing, though, for breakfast, sometimes I've said to myself, "Oh, you should eat," and I'll make myself eat. But it's very, very rare. I'm notoriously— people know that I'm notoriously a late eater. 4 p.m. sometimes, 5 p.m. if I'm in the office.
How are you feeling with that heavy vest on?
It's heavy, David. I've got to be honest. It's not— I'm finding myself, like, trying to find a comfortable position.
Yeah, it's tough being old. And by the end of it, you will be so convinced that this research is important. Because to live like that.
It's not going to.
In most people, life is not worth living. I put a suit, a very heavy suit like that, but on the arms as well, not just the body. And he had the earmuffs and the eyes. This was the governor of Massachusetts. 15 minutes in that bodysuit, and he was crying. Not because he was in pain, because he, as he said on stage, it was the first time in his life he understood how his father feels and could be empathetic. We young people, I'm relatively young, 56, you're very young, 33, we have no idea what it's like to be old.
It can be horrific. So why wouldn't we do the right things, like fasting, exercising, so we can get an extra 10 years, 20 years, maybe longer, of healthy life?
It does also give me a lot of empathy for people that have a bit more weight on them as well. Because of, you know, if I was— if I weighed that much, I don't know if I'd be very active, to be completely honest with you.
Exactly. And you're in pain too, don't forget. Every joint can be hurting. How do you feel taking that off?
Much better.
Right.
Free, like I want to jump.
So let's hope, pray, wish that these technologies that I'm talking about today work. Because that could be what it feels like to be rejuvenated when you're 80.
I hope so. And to close off on this point of fasting, why does it help extend my life?
Yeah.
Just eating less.
Part of it came out of research in my lab, but of course many others I need to give credit to. But in my lab specifically, what we worked on initially when I started, we studied yeast cells. Little microscopic cells that, as everyone knows, we use to make beer and bread and champagne. These yeast cells live about 10 days and then they die. And we used yeast as a model for aging. And what we discovered with yeast cells, which turns out to be true in our bodies, is that adversity, as long as it's not killing these cells, is good for you.
It's called hormesis. It's the technical term for what doesn't kill you, makes you stronger and live longer. Adversity mode is what we're aiming for. The opposite is abundance mode, which is what modern life is all about. Popcorn, movies, wheels on your suitcase, sitting down all day. It's— we're in an abundance world. So adversity is something we don't often feel. We have to work at it. Fasting is adversity. Exercise is adversity. Cold plunges, saunas, adversity.
Adversity mimics. They're not really threatening your life. What happens at the cellular level is that those cells, they get freaked out. They're worried that these times of adversity could kill us. So they fight back. They turn on repair systems. They turn on recycling systems. They turn on DNA repair systems that help slow down aging. So in this modern world, when we have total abundance, we don't have to exercise, we don't eat three meals a day, we get overweight, we don't sleep much, we have air conditioning in summer, we're actually aging faster than we need to because our bodies are not fighting aging like they do when they feel adversity.
Your team discovered, I can't say the word, serotonin?
Oh, well, I was one of many scientists in the 1990s. I was part of a team called Sertuins. Yeah.
Sertuins.
Yeah. In yeast, actually. That's right. That's a good story. I went to the U.S. to figure out why we get old. But I didn't choose to study humans because I figured if we can't figure it out for little yeast cells, we'll never figure it out for humans. So I went to MIT. My professor was Lenny Guarantee. I went to his lab and I said, "I'm not going. I'm not leaving." The goal was to, in my mind, was to figure out, are there longevity genes? At that time, most people thought that there were aging genes that caused aging, death genes.
That doesn't make any sense to me. Our bodies would have longevity genes that give life. So in yeast, I went searching for them. And out of that work came two things. The first is Lenny and I, my professor and I, published in the journal Cell, which was a massive big deal in those days, still is, but it was my first time. The first evidence for a cause of aging for any species. We figured out why yeast cells get old. Do you want to guess?
Why do yeast cells get old?
Have you been paying attention? What does the information theory of aging say?
I was going to say they have an identity crisis, but.
They do!
How would we know if they're having an identity crisis?
Oh, you can measure the identity of yeast cells. They have an identity. It's called their mating type. The main identity of a yeast cell is they are either A type or alpha type, male, female. And the hallmark of a yeast cell that's old is it loses its A and alpha identity and gets an identity crisis. It doesn't know what sex it is and it doesn't mate anymore, becomes sterile. So when I arrived at MIT in 1995, we knew that the hallmark of an old yeast cell, besides it being a bit slow and bigger, is that it became sterile.
It had an identity crisis. So we figured out that broken chromosomes distract the sertuin defenses and that causes aging in a yeast cell. But we didn't know in the '90s that that was going to be true for us as well. It took another decade or two to figure that out.
And how does this link to eating all the time?
Yeah. So sertuins are proteins that actually are attracted to DNA. They actually associate with it and they protect the DNA from getting damaged.
Okay, like bodyguards.
Yeah. And they repair broken chromosomes. Right? It's all coming together now. But they also get distracted. So look, a sertuin's normal job, if there's no crisis, is that they turn genes on and off. They are epigenetic regulators. They control the epigenome. They tell a cell what type it is. Nerve cell, skin cell, right?
Like a conductor.
Thank you. Conductor, exactly. But the conductor becomes demented over time. What happens is when you have a chromosomal break, the sertuins panic, they leave the DNA, what they're supposed to be doing, controlling the cell's identity, and they go and they repair the DNA. That's their other job. They have two jobs, identity and repair. So when you have this break, the sertuins go away, they repair the problem, but they don't all go back in the next few minutes. It's very quick.
They don't all go back to where they started. So you've got like this tennis match that the sertuins are the balls and they get hit over to the break, then hit back. Most of them find the genes that they should go back to, but they don't all do that. And that total game of tennis, or ping pong if you like, is what I believe causes the identity crisis and aging itself causes aging in yeast cells. It's why yeast cells don't live longer than 10 days. And I believe it's why we struggle to live beyond 80 or 90.
So if I'm eating all the time, then those sertuins, they're not going to be doing their job as the conductor, making sure I know the identity of my cells. They're going to be doing repair stuff. So I'm going to age faster.
Yes, and the breakthrough happened in the lab as I was just leaving to go to Harvard. I got a job at Harvard when I was 29, super excited. And just as I was leaving, there was a big breakthrough that they actually kept it secret from me because they were worried I was going to work on it when I left. And in fact, my professor tried to prevent me from working on it when I left. On sertuins in general, it's crazy to think about. But what they discovered was that there's a metabolite, a molecule that goes up and down with food and up and down with sleep called NAD.
We have lots of it. There's grams of it in our body. It's one of the most abundant molecules in the body. It's very ancient. It's in yeast, it's in us. And what they found was that sertuins, to control genes and to repair DNA that's broken, they don't do it unless there's NAD. It's the catalyst. It's the fuel for their reaction. They need NAD. And when we're young, we have lots of NAD. So it works well. The sertuins control the information on the genes and they repair the DNA very well because they've got lots of NAD to carry out their work.
These are enzymes. They work. They do things. As we get older, by the time you're 50, about my age, you have half the levels of this NAD molecule. My body is making less NAD and it's also destroying the NAD faster than when I was 20. That's a problem. And so what we found was that when we fast the yeast or we fast a human, NAD levels go up again. So fasting raises NAD and makes the sertuins young again, essentially. And that preserves the epigenome and it also repairs the DNA better.
So can I just drink NAD?
You can drink NAD and not much would happen.
How do I take NAD?
So NAD can be taken as a supplement, which is a precursor to NAD. It's better to take the precursors.
A precursor meaning something that creates it.
Exactly. There's one called NMN, not to be confused with M&M's, which will probably not make you live longer. And there's another one called NR. NMN is directly converted into NAD. You put two NMN's together, you get NAD in the cell. We know this for a fact. This isn't speculation. When you give a human NMN by swallowing it, a gram of it, you typically double the amount of NAD in your body. And we believe, and we have some evidence now in human clinical trials, that the sertuins are imparting health benefits, reestablishing the epigenome, lowering body weight, improving inflammation, and even changing cholesterol levels in a positive way in humans.
So, I mean, I'm assuming you take NMN.
I've been taking NMN and admitting that publicly for a while now. And my father, who is an even more advanced experiment at 86. So yes, we've been taking it for over a decade now. And we're still alive. So so far, so good.
So far, so good. I do want to get into, and I will ask you in a second about the supplement stack that you would recommend for the average person. But that's good to know. But just to close off on this point of fasting, is there a particular type of fasting method that you would recommend for someone who's trying to improve their longevity? Because there's so many that I hear, 16 hours, five days.
I'm a scientist, so I go with what's proven. I'm not selling anything. So what the science says, first of all, is that there isn't one size fits all for everybody. It often depends on what you can do personally. It's challenging to do this, right? You'll feel hungry for the first two weeks you try it. So I would suggest the way I do it is I start by skipping one and then maybe one and a half meals, like what you do. Try to go without a meal until three, four o'clock if you can.
Maybe not the first day, right? If you do that the first day, you'll say, "This is crazy. I'm going to grab a snack." And you won't do it. So go slowly. Build up to it. So the first day, I would say, just don't eat breakfast and maybe have a snack mid-morning. A week later, try to go without breakfast completely until lunch. And eventually work up to what you do and I do, which is eat a very late lunch, if not go to dinner. What you get with that is obviously not eating in bed, hopefully. So you've got the night fast starting, what would it be, 7 p.m.
roughly? When do you finish dinner?
Oh God, no comment.
Okay.
It's usually pretty late. Last night, it was, you know, this is probably why I don't eat very early the next day. Last night would have been about, I'm going to say, 10 p.m.
Okay.
It was super late. That's an extraordinary example. Usually it would be 8 or 9 p.m.
Okay, but you've got at least 13, 14 hours, which is good.
Yeah.
Try to aim for 14 hours. Some people go 16 hours, but that's a good start for fasting. And hopefully you can do that most days, five days a week. That's great because that means that you're turning on your sertuins, raising your NAD, your exercise as well. So that's also added into it. One thing that I've started doing is fasting for longer than just 14, 16 hours. I try maybe once a month to go for three days without eating.
Why?
Because there's a type of cellular recycling that doesn't happen within the first 16 hours. You will enter ketosis, so your body will start to change its metabolism to produce what's called ketone bodies. But the true real deep cleansing of old proteins and damaged proteins happens after two and a half to three days. And it's called chaperone-mediated autophagy.
Autophagy.
Autophagy is the word for auto-self-eating. And it really kicks in with an extended fast.
What's the evolutionary reason for that? What's going on there? Why does it take me two and a half days for this deep clean to happen?
Because your body doesn't want to do it. It costs a lot of energy and having to remake body parts is energy expensive. And our body tries to conserve energy as much as possible. When you're fasting, what it needs to do is to use your body as fuel. So it'll start breaking down proteins for fuel that you need. So first of all, what'll happen is in the first few hours, you use glycogen from your liver. Your liver makes glucose. You'll feel a little bit hungry, but you'll eventually be fine. Then once you run out of glycogen, then you're going to start breaking down fat and making ketones.
That's when you start to get a bit of bad breath from that. But you feel great. When you're in between about 15 hours and 24 hours, that's when you get a lot of ketones. And your brain uses those for fuel. So you'll have a sharp mind, can remember things, you can focus on work if you ever get there. Beyond that, you need to break down fat. And that is when your body is starting to do that. But ultimately, what happens after three days is your body says, "Hey, I'm going to start breaking down protein as well."
And I wouldn't do that often because I don't want to break down a lot of protein, but your body will start to turn over old proteins preferentially. And a little bit of that, that's why I do it maybe once a month, has been shown, at least in animals, to be not just healthy, but life-extending.
On that point of ketosis, I like being in a state of ketosis. I kind of cycle in and out of it during the year because I get so many of the cognitive benefits. I'm more articulate on the podcast. I can think better. I feel better. I feel more focused and more attentive. Is ketosis, is the ketone diet, the keto diet a healthy diet in your view? What are the benefits of it? Is it something that you think is natural to be recommended?
Well, I don't mind being controversial, but I do speak the truth. There's not a lot of evidence that long-term the ketogenic diet is healthy. It certainly doesn't correlate or associate with longevity. Short-term, okay. It does help people lose weight, no question. But I am rather concerned for people that don't have a balanced diet with an input of plant material, which has molecules that are unique to plants and you won't find in high-processed foods or meat.
The evidence, speaking as a scientist, is that the long-term ketogenic diets are not going to be longevity-inducing. The evidence is more having a lean diet with a focus on plants that are not overcooked and not ultra-processed. That one is undoubtedly the healthiest if you can do it.
Do you eat meat?
I do eat meat, but not like I used to. I used to think that a meal was not a meal unless I had a piece of meat there and then the vegetables were the decoration. And I'd begrudgingly eat the green stuff. I've been flipped totally. Serena, my partner, Serena Poon, is not just a nutritionist, but a longevity expert for the last 26 years. And so she came to my apartment, which is now our apartment, and she just cleared out all the food that I had. Pretty much everything was either toxic or just not healthy.
It was ultra-processed. She said, "What are you eating? That kind of peanut butter, full of sugar." So she's taught me how to live healthy. And so now I rarely eat meat. I rarely drink alcohol. I focus on really fresh, high-quality, preferably organic foods because I don't want pesticides and I don't want other contaminants. But I do know organic can be more expensive.
Why not meat?
So animals, unfortunately, don't make what are called polyphenols, which are a type of molecule that I believe and have evidence turns on the sertuins and other pathways, biochemical reactions that delay aging. So sertuins are just one of a few enzymes that control aging. We know this. There are sertuins, there's mTOR, which responds to aminos, and another one called AMPK. So those three pathways are altered in just the right way by molecules found only in plants.
Well, and a small extent in fungi, but not in meat. So if you're not eating a lot of vegetables or fruits, you're not getting these molecules. They're like medicine as food. So right here, I hope you don't mind me mentioning that there are some food in front of us. And I'm looking at blueberries here. Blueberries are packed with polyphenols. It's one of the reasons they have purple color is the polyphenols have the color. And as Serena would tell you, "Eat the rainbow." I call it xenohormesis, which is not as attractive.
But xenohormesis is the same idea as eat the rainbow, that by eating plants that have a lot of these molecules that are often produced by stressed plants, you get the benefits.
When you get stressed plants.
So plants will be stressed just like we are. If you don't give them enough water, food, too much sunlight, not enough sunlight, in their defense, they make polyphenols. There's a whole bunch of them. Resveratrol, fisetin, quercetin, there's hundreds. This one has anthocyanidins. That's the color. These activate these adversity responses in our cells. The sertuins will get activated by molecules in this blueberry.
So if I eat this blueberry, those conductors that conduct some of the aging process you talked about, making sure my cells don't have an identity crisis, fixing the negative stress that's going on in my cells, they will be benefited by eating this blueberry?
Yeah. It's like a free hack, right? You can eat something that's yummy, but you're also getting the benefits by mimicking fasting and exercise in your food as well. The sertuins don't just need NAD. That's the gas pedal. That's the petrol for those of you in the British world and Commonwealth. The fuel for sertuins is NAD. The accelerator pedal are the polyphenols in fruits and vegetables like resveratrol, quercetin, which we know when you give them to sertuins, they get hyperactivated.
And when you say eat the rainbow, you mean eat colorful-looking food?
Because that's an easy way to remember how to eat foods that have the most polyphenols. I'll give you a really good example, Steven. Serena put me on to green tea matcha, right? So matcha tea, if you haven't tried it, I'm sure you've tried it. But those of you who haven't tried it, I highly recommend it. It tastes great. The reason for it, switching from coffee mainly to matcha in the morning for me, is that it's full of polyphenols. Why is it full of polyphenols? It's not just because it's green tea, which is not naturally healthy, but the growers of those plants in Japan, typically, they shade the plants before they harvest.
Shading the plants stresses them out. Plants need light. So they don't just make more chlorophyll, which produces the deep green color in the tea, but the polyphenols are super high. And through trial and error over thousands of years, the Japanese figured out that by shading the plants, giving them this mild hormetic stress, it makes them not just extra tasty, but extra healthy.
What you just listened to was a most replayed moment from a previous episode. If you want to listen to that full episode, I've linked it down below. Check the description. Thank you.
What if the way you eat is quietly deciding how fast you age?
David Sinclair is a Professor of Genetics at Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading researchers on ageing and longevity, and the author of the New York Times bestseller Lifespan: Why We Age and Why We Don't Have To.
In this moment, David gives Steven a first-hand taste of what old age really feels like, and challenges what most of us assume about how long we'd actually want to live. He reveals the tiny "bodyguards" inside your cells that decide how quickly you age, the fasting window he aims for, the popular diet he's sceptical of, and the simple morning swap he made for his longevity.
Listen to the full episode here!
Spotify: https://g2ul0.app.link/Rti2UtFW26b
Apple: https://g2ul0.app.link/Xpy2vxLW26b
Watch the Episodes On YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/%20TheDiaryOfACEO/videos
David Sinclair: https://sinclair.hms.harvard.edu/people/david-sinclair