This Week 11 episode of Football America previews the NFL slate, with hosts Dave Dameshek, Tony and Buddy discussing the Cincinnati Bengals' push toward the Super Bowl and the mediocre-but-surprising New York Giants. Guest Matt Verderame of Sports Illustrated joins to sort through the many quarterbacks contending this season, including Joe Burrow, Patrick Mahomes and Brock Purdy.
The conversation also covers college football conference realignment, the Chiefs' offensive line, the two-back offense trend, and Denver's surprising 7-2 start. Listeners get a look at the reasoning behind each analyst's picks and point spreads for the weekend's key games.
The show also has a long detour into the Patrick Roy versus Martin Brodeur goaltending debate, where the guest and host disagree about which goalie was superior.
In this episode Dave Dameshek, Matt Verderame
This Week 11 football preview episode on the Bengals, Giants and Chiefs was made with HappyScribe's free AI note taker technology, the same tool that produced this transcript.
Ads in this audio differ from the text. Tap the sentence you're hearing to follow along.
Synced: the text now follows the audio.
If you're not careful, you lay in bed at night and you start thinking about all the what-ifs, and at some point you just become a miserable piece of shit.
Hey, I take that personally, Dan Campbell. I like to lay in bed and do what-ifs. Get off my back. Hi and hello, my fellow football Americans. Welcome to the NFL Week 11 preview. Welcome to Football America, presented by DraftKings Sports, now, of course, in all 50 of these United States. It's episode number 101, a grand episode 100, marked by the appearance, the first appearance here on Football America, of one Dan Le Batard. I encourage you, Nade, to man that you go back and listen to that.
I hope in the meantime you're enjoying your GTA 6. I'm not just talking to 10 Daytoni as I say that. Apologies for not getting the YouTube exclusive show in on Wednesday, but be on the lookout for it on the Football America YouTube page. Coming up on Friday, Nick Costas, Major Randy social mede, your questions and comments, and some college football mixed in. Then on Monday, we'll have our show for you, as we typically do, Costas and company, breaking down what we just saw in Week 11, and then a special episode around Thanksgiving.
Live in the flesh, Dave Dameshek.
I love it. It's all happening for us. The 10 Daytoni Substack is ready to roll for you. A lot of social media commentary on Buddy Badawski's hair and the fact that he should always wear a hat. I also just learned that he's a single man, and this upsets me. This vexes me because Jesse Palmer just got the bachelor. It's a shame that Buddy Badawski didn't get that, but you know what?
Same, Paul Palmer didn't get the bachelor. Jesse Palmer.
But wait, you're not Jesse Palmer. Jesse Palmer's in my head for some reason. I don't know if that's.
Well, he is the host of The Bachelor, Dave. But Sam Hartman.
And you had to apologize to him too.
Yeah.
Just like you have to apologize to Buddy.
I wonder why he's on your mind. Yeah.
Jesse Palmer and Dave Dameshek's names both appeared in an awful announcing article earlier this week. I can't imagine Mo Dameshek's ever been prouder. Anyhow, listen. Like I say, some quick thoughts because we have to dig in on Week 11, and our guy Matt Verderame from Sports Illustrated and beyond is on his way momentarily. But first, presented. Oh, there he is. Is that the voice of Cope I hear in my ear? Do it one more time. That's where you play it there, buddy. That's when I say like.
Yeah, I was still going. Sorry, I was going over to the Jaeger button.
He was still fixing his hair. Is that what Buddy was doing over there?
Yeah, dude. That was a bat. My hat hair, my post-hat hair, you know? And I was in a coma, so obviously, I couldn't have my hat on.
Don't worry. You're a grown-up man. You're wearing a Florida Gators ball cap that's way too garish.
And an Emmitt Smith jersey.
A retro Emmitt Smith jersey. Oh, the ladies are got to be knocking your door.
Absolutely.
Hey.
Affirmative, Dave.
All right, that was a good one.
I'm working on it. You know I'll get better. We'll get better.
All right. Now, can we get serious for a minute?
Yes.
We're presented by Jaegermeister. Serve it cold or don't serve it at all. Jaegermeister, damn, that's cold. For more, visit jaegermeister.com. Drink responsibly. I want to start out by jumping back one week to your old pal Dave here, going into the Sinsay Bungles game against the Pittsburgh Steelers. Take a listen. I told you in August the Bengals were going to Super Bowl 61, but now I must put an asterisk on that. First, they need to beat the Pittsburgh Steelers. Guess what? They beat the Pittsburgh Steelers last Sunday.
And long story short, the Bengals are going to the Super Bowl, everybody. Good news for Sinsay fans. Bad news for Sinsay fans. Silbering even. Who did I predict would play Sinsay in Super Bowl 61 back in August? America's alleged team, the Dallas Cowboys. Even worse, I meant it when I said it. I'm like Victor Caillem, the guy who loved the electric razor so much he bought the company. I so believed in the Cowboys this year. I went out and got all their skilled guys on my various fantasy teams. Now, the offense has had some gangbusters weeks to go, along with a couple few inexplicable performances.
But obviously, my big misread was assuming the defense would be merely so-so instead of an outright dumpster fire. I'm also curious, why is it a dumpster fire? Like, that's the worst fire there is? I'd rather deal with a dumpster fire than a shitstorm. But among just fires, is a dumpster the worst kind? It's in like a big metal box. It seems like that would be a control burn. But like a grease fire or a fire out in a forest, those seem bad. What if you had a grease fire in a forest?
That would be the worst of all. I don't have time for this, but I think you're picking up what I'm laying down. Anywho, Christian Parker, who's still the DC, has now given up play calling to Mike Petten. And I stand by my opinion, there are several very good pieces on that defense to work with. And here's some more good news for the Cowboys. Your team should win its next two. I know. You should have beaten the Bucks with their undrafted QB2, but that's in the rearview mirror. The Tennessee Titans and the Philadelphia Eagles, more likely than not, means Dallas, who is now 4-6, will be 500 before they play at Seattle and the Rams in SoFi, then Jacksonville.
And I know that is a brutal three-game stretch, no jive. But if the Cowboys can steal just one of those, they'd be 7-8 before closing out with the Giants and At Washington. Now, you think 9-8 is underwhelming? Yeah, well, so is the whole NFC East. You know the meme of the two scary dragons and the one goofy one? Well, the East is all goofy dragons. And that brings me to an even better news for the Cowboys fans out there. The Giants, a.k.a. the 5-3-1 team in first place, might be a feel-good story to this point, but they're also thoroughly mediocre.
Check out their schedule upcoming. Jags, Niners, At Seahawks, the Browns, At the Lions. Sheesh, who let the dogs out in D, Jamis? It's at least conceivable that the combo of JJ and Jamis won't win even one of those games. But let's say they do get one of those games. That'd make them 7-7-1 heading down to Big D just after New Year's Day to settle all NFC hash. FYI, John Harbaugh isn't some play calling wizard. He's a football foreman. Sure, he's given the Giants a sense of structure and optimism, but he ain't cooking up schemes to elevate the offense.
No, that role belongs to Matt Nagy. Matt Nagy, whose greatest claim to fame remains knowing Andy Reid and Patrick Mahomes. Matt Nagy, whose offenses are a career 4-9 against Mike Petten's defenses. All this isn't to say the Bengals should be awaiting any NFC East team in the Super Bowl. But even if Dallas is a dumpster fire for the rest of the season, I think it'll be enough to survive the shitstorm we call the New York football Giants. Now, quickly, fellas, any thoughts on that? Do you agree with me, 10 Daytoni?
Yeah, I'm looking at this East and it's like somebody's got to win, right? It's the conversation we've had about the NFC South for so long. Now it's just translated over a little bit more north. And it feels like Dallas is the team, right? We already know Philly's out. The Commies are kind of in this weird purgatory, just like the Giants. And it's like, all right, if Dallas doesn't do it this year, we might have to close the window on this team with Dak and CeeDee and Pickens and Jerry in general. Like, this may be it.
Well, I just don't want to assume too much about who the Cowboys are going to beat after they lost, like I say, to that Buccaneers team in a favorable spot. I do think they're going to be 500, and I think the Giants are going to lose this week. And I think by the other side of this weekend, people will be jumping on board with what I just laid down there. Quickly, on college football, you know what? Let's bring him in right now and start the conversation. He's a rangey sports talker, including On the Game of Life. You know him from the Matt Verderame show on Patreon, that football show on the KC Sports Network, and of course, from Sports Illustrated, and hopefully from Football America.
It's our old pal Matt Verderame. What's the poop, fella? How you been?
I'm good. I'm doing well. How are you doing?
It's been too long. What are those jerseys over your left shoulder? The viewer is looking at them over your right shoulder. Are those hockey jerseys?
Those were my high school hockey jerseys. So when I played in high school, I played in the state league, and I went to a really small high school. I graduated with 43 kids. So we did not have an in-house hockey team. So the reason they're called the Gypsies was we came it was a team that combined schools from three counties that the schools that didn't have a hockey team. So you tried out and made the team, then you got to play. But yeah, those were.
You're like the Steagals back in WW2. The Steelers and Eagles couldn't field teams themselves, so they combo'd it.
Yeah, Steagals, Card Pit. Yeah. But we actually won games, so that was nice. But it was fun. It was fun. It was good. It was hard to earn those jerseys. It put a lot of pain in my body that I still feel today. So it was good.
They look like the old Canucks jerseys. Those flying V with the black and red and yellow. Those are such a great look.
Colors were cool. I always like, at first, I was like, man, the Gypsies. It's kind of a weird name. But then I loved the colors. So I was like, all right, I can get on board with it. And then we were pretty decent. So I'm like, all right, you know that's the kind of thing that you better win. Because if you don't win, you're a joke.
With that name. Yes.
You better win, right? So there's a lot of built-in motivation.
The Gypsies. Hey, I do have a hockey question for you, and I also have some football questions for you, but I can't help myself. College football's on my brain. We see it every week. I'm obsessed by the commercials that are plaguing my life every weekend. I've done a lot of good work on the Newgenics ads with Flutie and the Big Hurt. We can talk about those at another time. Quickly, I hate to put you on the spot, Verderame, but I start with you. Actually, let's just do it in chorus. Tony, Buddy, Geno, and our special guest here, Verderame, I want you all to do a chorus right now.
Ready? On the count of three, the Big Ten song that plays underneath the animation that goes coast to coast in the Big Ten. Ready? Three, two, one. I want to live.
Oh, dude, you left me on an island. That's crazy work.
I'm not saying it. I instructed you to do it. I'm the conductor.
I started it, and I thought you were coming with me, and then you just left me on an island, Dave. That was totally unfair.
All right, let's try it again. That was a good rehearsal, fellas. Now.
Check, I'm telling you right now, you couldn't pay me enough to do that. And you're not paying me at all. So there's no way I'm doing that.
I'm sorry, Dave. I'm afraid I can't do that.
Okay. The rest of you have to do it. Now, ready, set, and go. Entertain our guy. I'm an ACC man. I can't tell you I've watched a Big Ten game. Are you kidding me? I would never watch that filth. Can anybody identify what the lyrics are? I had to look them up because I knew, like, I want to live forever on a boat out in the sea.
Oh my God. No way that says that. That's what I thought it was. But then I don't know the rest.
I want a happy home for you and me.
No, no, no.
I want to touch the silver sky.
This is getting so much worse.
We'll be shining everywhere. I want to live forever. I don't care. I don't think I got that quite right. Anyway, can we.
You've lost all viewership. You've lost all viewership.
None of us can look at you either, Dave. That's the other thing.
The best part about that commercial is when they it used to be when they'd be like, here are all the Big Ten schools, right? It would all be like one general area. And now it's like the Big Ten schools, and they just start at like Eugene, Oregon.
Yep.
And then they end up in the shadowing New Jersey, and they're like, yeah, Rutgers too. What the hell? Like, it's so embarrassing. Everything's wrong with college sports, right? Like, there's just there used to be a regionality to college sports. And now we're stuck with a conference game somehow being Washington at Rutgers. That's not a conference. That's not a conference. Unless it's Conference USA at large, which then, yeah, sure, it's in the USA. But you can't be the Big Ten of 20 schools.
It's like it's in Sacramento State and the MAC. Like, the MAC used to mean something, man. The MAC used to be Ford Field on a Tuesday night, you know, for the MAC Championship. And now it's Sacramento State against UMass or something like that. Give me a scratch. That's disgusting. It all started, Matt, when Missouri joined the SEC. That's when the downfall all started. That was one of the worst things that's ever happened, not only because they decide to beat up on the Gators every year, but because that was just that was wrong. Texas A&M as well. I hated Texas A&M coming to the SEC.
The Gators have played Texas A&M more than they've played Auburn since Texas A&M, one of our legacy rivals. It's disgusting. It's terrible.
So it was nearly the inflection point was when Texas almost jumped into the Pac-12 at the time. And had they all everything would have been resolved. We would not be having the conversation. There would be four power conferences that would all feed into one tournament, and it would have been just fine. But they decided instead to do the Longhorns Network, if I remember, 15, 20 years ago, if I remember how all that went down. But also, I mean, I really think, to your point, Verderame, the last bastion now of that regionality that is so appealing, I think even to the guys out on the field, is high school now.
Now that even college football has ceded that ground with the conference alignments as they are. I mean, like.
Honestly.
Atlantic Coast Conference has teams that are literally on the West Coast in it. And otherwise, and I always laugh at the Dallas Cowboys in the NFC East. We've just sort of accepted that. But college football held on to that regionality. And now with NIL and guys coming from here, there, and everywhere, and landing on campus three months before they make a big impact, it's all.
Yeah, it's a lot of stuff. I mean, look, I know we're not going to talk about this for 20 minutes, but it's like I'm a St. John's fan of basketball. I grew up in New York. And the Big East is kind of come back together a little bit. UConn's back and Villanova. But St. John's played Syracuse here, and I had the Garden. The Garden was going nuts. I was like, you're going to tell me if you're a Syracuse fan, you really would like, yeah, it's better to be in the ACC. It's better. It's really a lot of fun when we play Stanford in a conference game, right? Like, I kind of feel gross when St.
John's plays Creighton. And it's like, all right, that's aggressive, right? That's halfway across the country. You know? Like, it's just, it's I don't look, I get why. We all get why. It's money. We all understand that. But I would argue that long-term, it's going to take money out of their pockets. It is a long-term going to actually hurt some of these schools. Not all of them. Some of them will make more money than they've ever dreamed of. Some of these schools are going to end up being the victims of it.
I think you're right, and I get that cynicism, but I have some counter-cynicism for you, which is that we love football. We're all hooked on football.
Of course.
And what it's ultimately going to lead to is you're not you know it does take away. I was thinking watching Miami try to rally against Notre Dame a couple of few weeks ago. And in the moment as that's going on, I was thinking it doesn't really make a difference if they complete this rally. They kept it close-ish, so that's enough to not knock them off of knock them out of the 12. And that's now the standard. And it's unsatisfying compared to the heat of regular season games in September on in college football. That's what distinguished it from all the other sports was the importance of every single game.
Now they've given up that, but you're still going to watch. And that's what I've realized is. I'm resentful of it, but you're still going to sit there and see Georgia play BAM and all the rest of it.
Yeah, Dave, I mean, watching the rankings come out this past weekend as a Florida fan, you're sitting there and you're like, wow, we're sitting at 24. We would be in next year, and our matchup in the first round would be Tennessee. That's a legacy rivalry. And you're telling me that Florida.
Florida's a game mind.
I know that we shouldn't be in the playoff. Like, it's ridiculous that a six and four Florida team would be in the playoff at this point. But you're telling me that we can go on the road to Knoxville to play one of our all-time rivals in a playoff game? Of course I'm going to watch that. Of course that's going to be an epic scene. It's just stupid that.
Tony.
I'm sorry to interrupt you, but Tony, did I just hear the inflection of coma buddy there?
Yeah, there was.
I'm going to watch that game.
I'm going to watch that game, right? Flatline it. No, you know, flatline it, flatline it.
Inside joke, Verderame. Buddy goes to his coma every weekend and forgets what happened.
And asks really terrible questions.
Let's take a moment here and think about all the great memories just sitting on your camera roll. It's not just you sitting on the couch watching other people run into each other on purpose. I'm talking about within your own house, your loved ones, all your friends. A few of those pictures are worth getting printed in frame, but what about the hundreds of other ones that don't quite make the cut, yet never fail to put a smile on your face? Well, I'm here to tell you about Aura Frames, which gives all those moments a place to be seen. Mo Damashek has one in her house, and now I have one here at my place too.
But obviously, if you watch the two guys play, Patrick Wah is the far superior goaltender. And that seemed to get under your skin a little bit. Explain and make your case.
Well, no, I mean, it got under my skin because you're wrong. And so, you know, I mean, when people are just blatantly wrong, it's annoying. Now, obviously, I have an inherent bias here. I grew up a Devils fan. And I grew up like my first year rooting for them was Marty Brodeur's rookie year. So I literally saw his entire curve from the start. My arguments always this. Like, obviously, he's got the wins record. He's got the shutouts record. And you're right. Like, stats sometimes don't always tell the whole story because there's a million things that go into it. Patrick Wah had great players in front of him too. Like, people always love to be like, well, Marty, they played the trap in this and that. They played the trap the early, early part of his career.
They did not play the trap in 2000. Like, they were winning Stanley Cups at that point, well beyond the trap. He had 48 wins one year when Richard Matchmichuck was his best defenseman. Like, they were far more than just a trap with Stevens and Neymar. Like, they were a great team, but Patrick Wah played on great teams. He won Stanley Cups in Montreal and Colorado. And it's not like he was stuck with a bunch of bums in front of him. He had Rob Blake, and he had Adam Foot, and he had some great defensemen in Montreal, Chris Chelios. The other side of the coin is.
'86 and '93, those weren't heavyweight teams in front of him with the Habs. They went with the Abs, definitely. I mean, definitely the.
They were really good, and they beat nobody in the finals of two years. They beat the in '86, they beat a Calgary team that shouldn't have been there with Steve Smith, but the puck in his own net. And in '93, they beat Gretzky and Friends in Los Angeles. Kelly Rudy between the pipes. Who cares?
I got to tell you, I disagree with your conclusion here, but I applaud your knowledge that he can summon like that off the cuff. Steve Smith, not football, not either football in '86.
Edmonton won the next year in '87, and Gretzky, he got the cup. The first guy gave it to him was Steve Smith. But.
Steve Smith shot the puck with about 10 minutes left in the third period, tied up with the rival.
He was going behind the net.
Behind the goal. He goes, and he tries to advance the puck to the blue line, but instead, Grant Fierce's left pad sneaks in his way, and it bonks off the pad and into the goal.
I'm going to speak for Tony here. He never lose back then. But look, my biggest argument with Brodeur is he literally, if you look at the ice in today's NHL, he is responsible for the configuration behind them because he was so dominant controlling the puck that they had to legislate him out of the game. They had to be like, you need to just stay in this little box behind you because if he's allowed to go in the corners, it's impossible for another team to thump the puck in. Like, that is to me when everybody argues about Hascheck and Wah, look, we could talk about Wah, to his credit, I'll give him this, he did create the butterfly style, which revolutionized goaltending.
Brodeur then made it the hybrid butterfly style because he went down to one knee instead of two. But nobody ever changed the game in the sense that he did with playing the puck. He was so dominant. The NHL literally had to be like, you can't do that anymore and change the configuration of the ice.
They did a great job, did the Devs, during the majority of Marty Brodeur, whether you call it the trap or otherwise. They had a great knack for being able to force the shots to come from the blue line.
Yeah, they had all things to.
That required Marty Brodeur to make a safe from distance. His great virtue, along with playing the puck, was rebound control. And that would be great for any team to have that between the pipes. But I'm underwhelmed when you compare that to how electric and acrobatic Patrick Wah was. He made saves that Marty Brodeur could dream of. But all right, it's a football show.
Yeah, I'm going to speak for Tony here. Is this hockey America or is this football America?
You're right. You're right.
This is worse than anything I've ever done when trying to get hockey into the show. 10 minutes on Marty Brodeur and Patrick Wah.
I got the pigskin here on me, and I'm waiting for us to talk about it. All right, let's do it. Configuration of the ice with Patrick Wah. Who's that? You don't even know who Patty Wah is.
You couldn't put him in a lineup with all the people you're talking about. I wouldn't know a single person.
Okay, that's fair. I'm glad you're awake from your coma. I'll count that as a win. I also want you to consider, Tony, why the college football has half stripes on it. Not all the way around.
Yeah.
Just like half stripe. So then what's the point? If you're going to stripe it, do it all the way or not at all. Now, Verderame, let's talk about your NFL specialty. And by the way, the pages in Sports Illustrated remain grand. And if you aren't checking them out, shame the devil. He makes you a smarter football fan. But if KC, the Chiefs, are your wheelhouse more than anything else, if KC doesn't reach the AFC title game, what will be the chief reason for it? Pun intended.
The tackles. The tackles. Kamil Benson has been an unbelievable story. And I would actually argue that other than Mahomes and these running backs, if they win the Super Bowl, Kamil Benson deserves as much credit as anybody because he has come in. He was not an undrafted creation. He was a rookie tryout at camp and made the team and never played left tackle in his life. But because Josh Simmons is in parts unknown, essentially, they were like, hey, man, you want to give left tackle a shot? And that's how he's been at left tackle this year.
Like, that's barely even an exaggeration of what happened. So he's been excellent run blocking, up and down pass blocking. Jalen Moore at right tackle has been pretty much the same. Up and down pass blocker, good run blocker. Their tackle situation is just not ideal. If they had Benson at right tackle and Josh Simmons playing football left tackle, that would be really quite good. But I don't think that's ever going to happen this season. And so that would be why. Like, if they don't go deep, it's because somebody just caved in their edges.
But if the Chiefs are one benefit, I don't know what the team's going to do that. Houston doesn't look like they're going to make the playoffs. Maybe it's Denver, but the Chiefs scheme well against them because they know them so well. So it's like, is it Jacksonville? Is it Cincys? Is it Buffalo? That's the one advantage. They're not playing a team that you'll look at and go, well, they're just going to kill you off the edge. I don't know which contender in the AFC that would be.
It's a great point. It's one I keep making the last couple of weeks is that the worm has turned in the push and pull of offense versus defense in pro football. It was all coming down the stretch in December, in January, and in February. It was all about which defenses were mightiest. And now it does feel like the superhero quarterbacks are striking back. As far as that goes, where is Mahomes for you? How does he look to you this year? And how does he stack up? If it is the QB league and it does come down to which superhero QB performs best, where do you think Mahomes stacks up with those other superheroes, including Allen and Burrow, who are playing, especially Burrow, playing tremendously right now?
Yeah, right now, Burrow's playing the best football in the NFL. So I think you've got to be fair and say right now, I mean, he's on pace for 5,100 yards, 51 touchdowns. I mean, he's been ridiculous. I think it's actually 5,200 yards. Look, I would say as far as Mahomes goes, Mahomes took about the first half of the first game to get going, and since then, he's been awesome. He's had 19 touchdowns, four picks. He's on pace for over 4,500 yards. They don't have a number one receiver. Like, adding Josh Downs helps them, but he's not a number one. He's like a number two. So they have a couple of twos in rice and downs, and they have Kelsey, but they don't have that elite guy outside.
He's just go, hey, just throw that guy at third and seven. It's an easy first down. I think he's played, honestly, the best he's played since he won his last MVP award in 2022. I mean, he really is letting it rip. His arm looks great. Mobility-wise, he's not running as much, but I think part of that is due to the fact they run so well now with the backs that he doesn't have to. You know, a lot of times, he'd run the ball because they just could not run. And so teams would pin their ears back and he'd take off. That's still there, but now you hand off to Emmett Johnson or Kenneth Walker, it's fine.
Emmett Johnson is kind of the secret sauce here. Emmett Johnson is ninth in the league in yards after catch. Not per catch, total. He has more yards after catch than Jamar Chase and Amon-Ra St. Brown. He's been ridiculous. So look, if you said to me, it's just up to the quarterbacks in a playoff game, I mean, I would take him over anybody based on his history. But I think right now, as far as how he's playing, I think Burrow's playing the best, and I'd probably put Mahomes right there behind him.
I do wonder, you know, if forgive me, Dan Campbell, I'm going to play a little what if, but if the Chiefs knew what they had in Emmett Johnson, do they still make the.
Signing of Walker.
You think so?
Yeah, probably just because they've always liked to have two backs. And now, to be fair, if they knew Emmett Johnson was this good, maybe you have the argument. I honestly wonder, and you'll appreciate this with somebody who likes history, I wonder if they will at some point this year go to like a two-back offense and just say, you know what? Here it comes. What are you going to do? Defend it. Because they can throw to either one of them, and they can run with either of them, inside or outside. And I wonder against teams like Cincinnati and Buffalo where their linebackers are a weak point, if the Chiefs just say, well, we're going to put two backs into the pattern every play.
What are you going to do?
Tony, let me drag you into this a little bit as well. Why do you suppose? You know, we've seen a couple teams do a little bit of two backs out there, but I mean, that was the way in the '70s into the '80s. And at some point, they just decided teams don't need a fullback. But the danger of having two actual weapons out there, I don't mean a lead back. I mean two guys who can actually hurt you, hurt the defense. Why do you suppose NFL offensive coordinators decades ago just gave up on that idea and have never returned to it?
I think it's the introduction of the air raid offense where you said you can just get four or five wide receivers out and just have them go and then force the defense to play nickel, dime, and get everybody out front. An interesting number, talking about pony, which is that 2-0 two-back no tight end formation.
I always call it pro set, but yeah.
So the Rams ran it 17 times with Blake Corum and with Kyron Williams and passed out of every single one. So it's like.
It's an interesting little wrinkle to, all right, we're going to have these guys here. You're going to be really focused on them. And guess what? We're not going to run the ball. So I'd imagine Andy Reid and Bieniemi and all the offensive minds that are there could utilize this and really take it to even the next level, running out of it, throwing out of it. Like, that's something that has been undiscovered and almost rediscovered now with Sean McVay. I wonder, and Matt, I'd love to have your insight on it. Like, is that something that you've heard maybe they'd be willing to go to, or you're just floating that theory out? I'm floating it out, but I do know that internally, I've talked to some people in the building earlier this week, and there is a thought of like, how do we get Emmett Johnson to ball more?
And I don't think you're going to do that by taking Walker off the field a lot. I mean, you might take him off a few snaps, but you know they're a team that they play a lot of two tight end sets. They really don't play much in 13 personnel. They don't play a lot of three tight end sets. Kelsey's a better blocker than people realize, but you know at his age, it's not like they want him in the trenches 25 times a game as a point of attack blocker. I think to your point, and it's correct, like I think they would go two backs and just throw the ball.
Right.
I think that's what they would do is say because you know the one thing that makes it really tough on defense is as the league went to three and four wide sets all the time. Teams front office has said, okay, so we've got to get faster linebackers, and we've got to get more corners and slot guys, and our fronts got to get lighter and faster, right? If you then bring in two backs and throw out of that.
That's right.
It puts teams in a real bind because if you can throw to both guys, as the Rams can, as the Chiefs can, that says to the defensive coordinator, okay, I should in theory play base defense, but I am not going to be able to cover the way I need to cover. And if I play base, these teams are going to annihilate me throwing the football with these guys. However, if I then say, well, I've got to play it like it's pass defense and play nickel and dime, if I'm the Chiefs, if I'm the Rams, run the football. You're going to give me a light box the whole game?
You're focusing personnel, in other words. So you're winning pre-snap, and that's exactly right.
Teams are built to play in today's NFL against 11 personnel. They're built to play against three wide receivers, a tight end, and a back. And when you can do something really effectively that goes against that, it's very difficult. So a lot of teams don't have an answer for it. And so I'll be curious to see how it develops over the course of the year.
Doesn't it also keep Kenneth Walker fresh? Like, he's got an injury right now, and he's had some injuries in the past. Like, isn't it a great idea to get Emmett Johnson to ball if he's so effective? You know you're going to have to run it in January and if they want to, if they get there in February. So don't you want to start thinking about keeping Kenneth Walker?
But that's a byproduct of sitting him against Arizona when they don't really need him, right? Like, the groin injury was something that popped up midweek. They're like, all right, we're playing Atlanta, one of the worst run defenses in the league. We'll sit him here. Oh, Arizona next up. We'll sit him again. And Emmett Johnson gets tremendous run and the experience needed for when you start playing those big boy teams come late January.
Them sitting Walker in this game, and I don't know this for a fact, but I'm pretty confident in this. If this was a game against if Buffalo was this week and not next week, Kenneth Walker's groin would magically feel better. But this is a, hey man, why don't you sit down for a week?
Yep.
Like, I wouldn't expect Travis Kelsey was dealing with a high ankle sprain. It has been for a month and a half. I would expect that, like, they're a little judicious here. You know, Trace Smith, he's coming off the concussion. He might not be legitimately cleared by Sunday. But like, Jalen Moore, could he play this week? Yeah, probably. Is he going to? Eh. I mean, this is all about for the Bills and the Chiefs because the Bills play Miami. This is all about get through this game, win the game. It doesn't matter what it looks like. Get ready for Thanksgiving night. I mean, that is the reality. And look, Walker saw the ball a ton the first month and a half of the year.
They are absolutely going to look to give him breaks where they can do it.
Verderam, we've got to move along here. We've got a lot of game picks to make, and I don't want to hold you up, but one more question before we I guess I did too much hockey talk. I'm going to have to wear this.
These things are happening.
I feel like I had a hand in the hockey talk going a little bit long there, and I'm sorry to butt in.
I'm not going to.
Everybody else. Verderam, the other factor, I would love to spend three more hours breaking down the Chargers and Fernando, the Raiders, and all the rest of it. But let's focus in on, you know, I do feel like there's, you know, the conversation, it's the slow-moving sort of car crash effect of an NFL season that we sort of like resolve certain things are finished and like the AFC West chase. I think in our brains, everybody has the Chiefs already having won it, but I think there's something to, I don't think it's everything, but I do think a little bit of the mystique was taken away from the Chiefs when the Broncos held up near the goal line in Denver a couple few weeks ago.
Week 11. There’s plenty of hope left for the Steelers. (Kidding!) But it sure seems like Joe Burrow and the Cincinnati Bengals are making moves to reach the Super Bowl. And could they meet the New York Giants? No. The Giants are the feel-good story of the year. But let’s be honest, the team is mediocre. So that leaves us with... a ton of teams that could play them with a ton of great quarterbacks like Josh Allen or Caleb Williams or Brock Purdy. The list is endless, and that’s why Sports Illustrated’s Matt Verderame joins the show to help us sort this list. There’s also plenty of Patrick Roy versus Martin Brodeur debate. We’re a football show. Right? I guess so... maybe.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices