This 100th episode of the Dan LeBatard Show with Stugotz covers the NFL's Week 10 results and the playoff picture, including the Patriots, Lions and Texans. Joe Burrow's MVP case, the Cincinnati offense and the Vikings defense are debated, along with the Bills, Steelers and 49ers' chances.
Dan LeBatard explains why he has lost interest in the Miami Dolphins, arguing that the team has lacked a quarterback for 25 years, while Nick Costas pushes back. Listeners also get a Laverne and Shirley-themed detour, winners and losers, and a look at how Super Bowl runners-up have fared.
In this episode Dave Damishack, Dan LeBatard, Nick Costas, Tony Collodi
This Week 10 episode of the Dan Le Batard Show was made with HappyScribe's tool for automatic transcription of recordings.
Ads in this audio differ from the text. Tap the sentence you're hearing to follow along.
Synced: the text now follows the audio.
All we have to do is, um, mediocre.
Mediocre will not be good enough. I hope I don't have broccoli in my teeth or anything. The boss is about to make his way into the studio here. Hi and hello, my fellow football Americans. Welcome to the NFL Week 10 review. Welcome to episode 100 of Football America. We're happy to have you riding along with us. We appreciate you doing so, subscribing wherever you find your audio podcasts and/or on YouTube. Leave us a comment, question, or otherwise, and we will be sure to get to that. So much big news there.
There's 10 Day Tony, and Buddy Badauski, and Geno Fuentes in their usual spots in Miami, Florida, awaiting the arrival of the aforementioned Dan Le Batard—
We have him here with us now, Dave.
Is that right? Well, wait a second. I have to say hello to somebody else first, all the way from New York City, Staten Island to be exact. It's our fella, it's Nick Costas. What's the poop with you, fella?
Hi. Uh, I prefer just New York City as opposed to Staten Island. I think it sounds way more regal when we do it like that, Dave. So just from New York City, Nick Costas. We can leave Staten Island to the side.
Look at that. It looks like he tightened up the Keanu Reeves circus speed era hairdo to look his very best for a guy who he's now, I think, a colleague of, properly, since now he is a part of the Metal Lark fold Nick Costas is. We got to go through our winners and losers of Week 10. There were many on either side of that. I think the big one in the game of life, Robert Pattinson. He is now to go along with being Batman. That's not enough. He's not only—I mean, what a dream role for any actor. He gets to be Bruce Wayne, but now he's also Bond, James Bond.
I think—I don't want to be a prisoner of the moment—I think this rivals Harrison Ford getting to be Dr. Indiana Jones and Han Solo. What do you think about that, Costas?
I—you know what I think? I think there are too many handsome men in general right now.
Yeah.
I was—and it's because Robert Pattinson is obviously very handsome. I was thinking this yesterday, watching, uh, watching the Niners-Cowboys game. Is it possible that there's too much handsome in the broadcast booth with Kevin Burkhardt and Tom Brady? I think we need someone ugly in the booth next to Brady to balance it out. It actually bothers me a little bit watching the two of them. So when I saw Robert Pattinson in the suit holding the silenced gun, I'm thinking, I—I would like to see some ugly men. There's too many handsome men right now making me feel even more insecure than I do on a daily basis when I wake up.
You understand that we're about to say hello properly to Dan Le Batard. This is like the Laverne and Shirley thing when Lenny and Squiggy would—I wish there were more on the—
I don't know what you're talking about.
Hello?
I don't get the reference.
Hello, ladies. That's how you're introducing Dan Le Batard. I don't think that's very nice. What I would say is, though, that I don't—there are some guys that I can tell from a distance, like Brad Pitt in Legends of the Fall. I—that's a handsome devil. I can see that. You know, I'm secure with my masculinity. I don't—I don't have any issue with saying that's a handsome devil over there. Now, Robert Pattinson, I don't—I wouldn't know that. If he walked by me, I wouldn't say, "Now, there goes that lady killer." I don't know that.
Stop it, dude. Dude, he's—I don't—he was in Twilight, right?
Yeah.
Like, his jaw looks like it's been chiseled out of granite. Like, it's perfect. You don't see that?
No, he's got that—no, he's got like that smushed face. I don't really—
Yeah, you're right. He's only James Bond. You're right. He's terrible.
Well, I clearly—I am wrong. I'm wearing that. Isn't that the point of why I brought it up? All right, listen. You know what? I'm not here to argue with you. I'm here to say hello in honor of our 100th episode. Very kind of him to shadow our door here in Miami, Florida, in the home that he has built somewhere in the bowels of a hotel/apartment structure there in Miami.
Luxury hotel at the center of the most vibrant city in America is what you meant there, Damon Shack. I don't know what you're talking about, but—and I don't know what you're doing when you mention Laverne and Shirley to three people you're doing the show with, and they have no idea what you're talking about. Like, is that the kind of chemistry you guys have around here?
Yeah.
Where the three of them are listening to you say Laverne and Shirley, and all three of them is like, "What is he talking about?"
So we've reached—you know what, Dan? I am grappling with exactly that. It has—it occurs to me that all of my references are now—I mean, not—they are expired and no one has anything to—
Dude, you did Brad Pitt Legends of the Fall, not like Inglourious Basterds. Like, you went—like, you went back to the early '90s for your Brad Pitt reference.
Legends of the Fall is too far back?
Oh, of course.
100%.
Dan has agreed with that, no?
Well, he's talking about handsome men who are now in their 60s. And it's like, that's not—that's not modern handsome men. And Laverne and Shirley, who might have—they might have been sex pots in the 1970s doing schlemiel, schlemazole, whatever it is that they did in a Milwaukee beer factory.
What are you guys talking about?
Nobody is interested in what it is that you're talking about, Damon Shack. That's a—
All right, which is cooler? Which is cooler, Batman and James Bond or Dr. Indiana Jones and Han Solo and Le Batard?
Stop. That's a good question.
Well, is it? Because—
Yeah.
No, because Harrison Ford created two characters that did not have any sort of history.
That's a good point.
These two have enormous history. Like, there's been nothing like this, someone who gets to be Batman and Bond. Those are five—the top five iconic characters for all time that somebody would want to play, established long before he gets to come and snort it up with his beautiful jaw.
This is exactly what I talk about all the time, that as a vain person, that were I like a blue-chip prospect at 17 running back, I would not react to USC coming knocking at the door and saying, "You can be the next in the long line of great running backs. Better to go somewhere like Oregon State where you're the one of one, where they will build statues of you and they will sing songs about you 40 years after your passing because you're the only one who ever made a difference at that place." This is exactly what you're talking about, right?
Well, what you're saying is that Harrison Ford has two characters that he birthed.
Right.
He made—he made eternal. Pattinson's just inheriting stuff that other people did, but it's the most glorious stuff. He didn't have to do anything. He didn't—he didn't have to create it, didn't have to build it. He just comes in here and enjoys the glory of being the coolest guy.
Yeah, that's—yeah, spot on. So, okay, let's get into it here while we have Dan. And again, thank you for carving out a little bit of time after doing your entire show this morning. And I heard you and the cuckoo birds operating what sounded to me, at least, like you remain under the spell or getting further seduced than you already were by the notion that the SEC is king of college football because Texas and LSU—I heard Zazlav talking about it, at least—that because the Longhorns and Tigers played an entertaining game, somehow this makes the SEC the most powerful conference.
Do I have that about right?
Uh, no. I was—I was objecting to the idea that everyone would dismiss Utah and BYU and UCLA and Texas Tech and in there some teams that don't have any losses to talk about teams that have two and three and four losses just because they play each other. Like, the SEC is getting a whole lot of credit. And one of the things that I was saying is that in my entire lifetime, Vanderbilt and Mizzou and Kentucky and South Carolina and all—they've never been any good. Mississippi, Mississippi State.
Like, my entire life, those were not the cream of the SEC, like, ever. And so to beat them doesn't mean anything. It's—to meet them before doesn't mean anything. To beat them now doesn't mean anything. They're nowhere programs, all of them. Just because you rank Kentucky in the top five doesn't mean I have to respect Kentucky.
That's absolutely right. And in the meantime, we have a Power 4 conference team undefeated. And by the way, it's not just any random Garden Variety conference. It is the conference that has won the last three national championships. Three separate programs have won the last three national championships from the same program. That same conference's undefeated team right now is being diminished by being ranked behind teams like Alabama and anyone who has even a single loss, including Georgia.
Let me ask you this, Dan, to shift gears here, because I heard you also singing songs about Mensa and everything else. But to the extent you're outwardly rooting for the Dolphins, because I think it's fairly clear, you can't hide the fact that you're rooting for the Canes. Are you still rooting for the Dolphins in 2026?
No. I'm not.
You don't have no rooting interest there?
No. Well, I'm not. I'm just not. Why? I'm not. They haven't been interesting for 25 years. Like, they're.
It's true.
It's not just that they're.
My whole life.
But it's not just that they're bad, Dave. They're not interesting. They traded what used to be a national team. You're in the Laverne and Shirley days that was the winning franchise in sports. Not football, sports. They won more often. They became a national team. They made Miami matter. The Miami Dolphins helped put Miami on the map as an international and national city. And they've been a regional team for 25 years. So they're just not interesting.
So then you really don't find them interesting?
I actually think they're very interesting this year. A lot of really good young players. You've got an awesome coaching staff. Going to get an opportunity to draft a top quarterback in the first round of next year's draft. I think you guys are building something that's going to be pretty awesome here. And I don't think it's false hope right now for the Dolphins. I think you should be excited right now. I mean that sincerely.
Oh, no. But wait a minute, though. I didn't say that they're not doing it right, and I didn't say that they didn't have reason for hope. I said this year's team is not interesting because I'm not interested. I'm not interested in seeing guys who, four years from now, are either going to become free agents or injured or maybe they'll be eternal stars, but they don't have anybody to care about yet. So you're—what you're talking about from a purely fan perspective of, like, just loving your team, yes, there is something to be said about if you love your team.
You get to see Dwyane Wade grow up from being a rookie to being something else, and there is joy in that. But I—man, I—they've got to throw somebody out there, and some of the players are going to be good, but I don't know. Douglas seems to be a fine. It seems like they do know how to draft, but I can't get enthused by them playing a bunch of close games when I don't know if they have a quarterback and I don't know if they'll ever have a quarterback. Like, how enthused can you be about a team?
I've been waiting—just do it this way. 25 years they haven't had a quarterback. You can get excited about their linebacker and their wide receivers. They still don't have a quarterback. Like, what are you trying to get me excited about? Not having a quarterback?
You get one in next year's draft, and you trust this coaching staff to make it happen. Coach Halfley's been awesome. I think you should have some blind faith right now. I mean that sincerely in the Miami Dolphins.
Are you out of your mind?
Blind faith after.
He's in Staten Island.
Blind faith.
That's right.
Blind faith after 25 years of betrayal?
But it's not—but it's not Jeff Halfley's fault and John Eric Sullivan's fault that everybody screwed this up.
I can't believe they're flawed.
It's not his fault that Hammerin won 1 and 15.
Here is what.
And Adam Gase.
Here is what's flawed in the approach, is that exactly as I said, and I really do think we had this exact conversation, Dan, at some point in the summertime. When you bring in Malik Willis, Halfley is doing no favors to Malik Willis by bringing him down there because they set him up to be the sacrificial lamb. There was no chance that any quarterback—and in fact, we talked last week, and I throw it to you, Dan, to answer this hypothetical. What is the Dolphins' record right now if Patrick Mahomes is their quarterback?
Better because they win some of these one-score games. Like.
Like what?
One or two more wins?
Well, it'd be better, but he still wouldn't be able to throw the ball down the field. I mean, I know he did that yesterday, but yeah, there would—he'd be—he wouldn't be Patrick Mahomes. Nobody would be talking about him. Like, maybe they win a couple of more games, but nobody would be talking about him as a quarterback to be feared in the playoffs or any other time. You'd only get so much better. But what Nick is saying is that you're waiting because Patrick Mahomes in four years will have a surrounding cast when you draft him. And I'm like, that's a big ask.
Hopefully.
I mean, I spent several.
Oh, man.
I mean, the best quarterback the Dolphins have.
He'd be next year.
The best quarterback the Dolphins have had in 25 years is Ryan Tannehill, and we spent seven years talking about whether he was any good. Like, that's what we did.
So what do you root for now if you are a Garden Variety Dolphins fan? Is the result now—oh, you don't want to go O for that. That's Brown's disgraceful territory. So you have a strike in the win column now, so that's out of the way. Is losing out 1 and 16 the goal here? And let's say that you do wind up with the first overall. What do you do? Jeremiah Smith? Because I think he's transformative to the Chargers and maybe even to the Titans with Cam Ward and Carnell Tate.
I think now you're getting something that that's starting to take on a vibe. I don't think if you just drop Jeremiah Smith onto the Dolphins, suddenly they become a borderline, you know, 500-ish team. Or do you go for a guy like Mestemaker in what has now become yet another uncertain quarterback draft?
I love Mestemaker at North Texas. I have no earthly idea whether he can play professional football. Like, I—and he's great at Oklahoma State, too. I have no idea. If right now people listening to this are in Miami and thinking about what the quarterback situation is, I don't know whether Mensa, if I put him on this team next year, would be anything other than a feel-good story.
Yeah.
Dan, I have a list.
Do you know how to do these projections? I don't feel like I am very good at doing the projection. I don't believe Nick is excited about the Dolphins, and I just cannot be excited about a team that doesn't have a quarterback and doesn't know it's going to have a quarterback. And I can't know whether any of the quarterbacks that they get are going to be any good. So, of course, I would want Jeremiah Smith. That's going to be good in the pros. I have no doubt that that is going to be good in the pros. I have only doubt when it comes to no matter how good this quarterback class is, who the hell is going to be good for them?
Because, again, I'm going to say this, even though they're not the ones who have done the drafting. I don't know what a good Dolphin quarterback looks like the last 25 years. I've not seen one.
Well, can I be honest with you, Dan? Dave, do you mind if I just say, because this is the first time we've ever talked so honestly.
I know. This is an exciting moment. I wanted to honor that as a matter of fact. Nick Costos has been joining us for the last month or so, and now a lot of people are enjoying it. There are some people who get into social media and say the double down of Damishack's voice with Costos's voice is a bridge way too far.
Yeah, there's still.
Or they're canceling each other out on some level. Either way, I forgive my poor manners here. Nick Costos, Dan LeBatard. Dan LeBatard, Nick Costos.
Dan, an absolute pleasure, my man. I've been listening to you for a long time. You are someone who loves joy, like most rational, normal, like, well-adjusted people do. I hate hearing you like this. No, man. Like, I feel bad for you. Like, I'm sorry for you.
This is what the Dolphins have done to us in over 25 years. This is what they do.
No, I understand that, but just take it from me as a New York Knicks fan. I never thought my team was going to win. They just won the championship. I actually think, Dan, and I understand, like, why you feel beaten down. There's good reason for it. But I think you have a really good head coach. You have a front office that killed this year's NFL draft. Like, young players to build around. You're going to have a top pick next year. I think you should have some confidence and some optimism here.
Why are you yelling at Dan LeBatard? This is your.
Because I feel bad for him. I don't want to hear him like this.
Okay. Dan.
So a couple of things. First of all, the way the two of you sound is audio, because I'm audio first, is wonderful. You sound like both of you sound like cartoon Martians.
I've heard worse.
Well, no. But if you don't look at people, I like to listen to this. So, like, Trista, Juju, you guys sound you have just very distinctive voices, and so I like that. But I'm just going to explain to you again because you don't seem to understand it. I have been for 25 years now, that's a quarter of a century, in an abusive relationship with my football team. It is dysfunction. It batters me. And while you said nothing wrong, you said nothing.
I'm a Knicks fan.
You said nothing, but you said nothing inaccurate in what you said. Yes, these people have drafted well unquestionably. Everybody will say that. I'm in an abusive relationship. Every Sunday, I come home and my team, my spouse, my partner, beats me up. And now I'm no longer interested because I'm tired of the abuse. And you're sitting here wasting my Monday talking to me about a team I already told you was not interesting. There are all sorts of interesting teams in football that you cover every week, and you're here talking to me about the spouse I'm in a battering relationship with.
I think you need to—I think you need Stockholm syndrome.
Nice talking to you, Nick. I never want to speak to you again.
I thought you could chase them off. We didn't even get to talk to them about the you. Great job, Costos.
You're welcome.
Sheesh, man.
He didn't even get to hear buddy talk for, like, 15 minutes.
Well, that's a victory at least.
That's probably what he exactly what he wanted from this experience is to not have to hear me talk.
Buddy, it's time for you to start to get ready for.
Oh, yeah? Okay.
The world-famous Coma.
I'm going to get dressed up.
Oh, boy.
We've been excited about this. Dave and I have been excited about this for quite some time here, I think.
Buddy's learned about empathy by hanging around with Dave Damishack, the world's greatest empath. And so he a few weeks.
I've learned about empathy. Do you know me? I'm the most—you think you're the biggest empath in the world. Do you know me?
Just beat it, would you? Now listen. I'm talking about my empathy. Now listen. Buddy felt like he went into a coma a couple weeks ago because he didn't know what happened in the college football Saturday. And so now he does for anybody else who may have fallen into a coma for the weekend or just now waking up. He has a weekend review for the football fan out there. In the meantime, we have much to cover there. I didn't know that Dan was going to jump in right at the top of the show. Welcome to you, Costos. Hello to you, 10-day Tony Collodi, author of the 10-Day Tony Substack.
Make sure you're checking that one out. It was another grand weekend for some and a devastating one, I feel like, for a lot of other people. And I'm not just talking about Pittsburgh Steelers fans. I told you what was going to happen.
You did.
I mean, I know I'm right more than I'm wrong about 31 pro football teams, but there is no one more right more often than your old pal dumb Dave Damishack when it comes to the Pittsburgh Steelers. I am exactly right about them, and I thread the needle when I told you in summertime, and then I told you in September and last month, and I tell it to you again now. They are a borderline playoff team. They are not a Super Bowl contender. The big winners, though, the Bengals, I mean, who now legitimately are, they were and now have proven themselves to be that.
What I said was I asked to risk this game against the Steelers and said, let's just one last thing they need to show, me at least, and probably themselves too, is they could handle a good team when things set up semi-favorably. There were some things against them, like the Steelers coming off a bye, whereas they were returning across the Atlantic. But at home, a favorable situation for them, and they took care of business and how. And I think the Jags also took care of business. And again, the Bills have a gauntlet upcoming.
They have to play the Chiefs and at Denver, and they have to play at Green Bay, and they play the Bears. So I think the number one seed, the chase for that is going to be fascinating. The Chiefs and Broncos and Bills, as I just said, the Bills are playing both those teams, so they're kind of going to cannibalize each other. I think the number one seed chase is going to come down to, I think Buffalo has a great chance because they only have the one loss at this point, but I think it's Cincinnati, Jacksonville, and Buffalo fighting it out. And 50% of the teams that get the number one seed go to the Super Bowl since they went to the 17 playoff structure.
So it is deeply important. Other winners quickly, the Titans in those alternate uniforms, whatever you call them, three words for them, Ooh, La, and La. The Vikings, a great win in Lambeau. And that makes all of us winners because it was dynamite to see Kirk Cousins do that. He is as close to a normal person as there is. He doesn't have superhuman belief. He understands he needs Justin Jefferson to play like Justin Jefferson in order for him to win games.
I think everybody can get behind that story. And shout out to my fantasy team that includes Dak Prescott, CeeDee Lamb, and George Pickens. But shout out even more to the Niners and Brock Purdy. Another dynamite performance out of that team. Costos, how say you?
On which?
On any and all. The big winners of the weekend. What rises to the top for you?
So I said on this show a couple weeks ago and on You Better, You Better and the various shows I do, like three weeks ago, like, Joe Burrow's going to win MVP. And he is on pace, Dave. And this is going to sound hyperbolic, but the facts back it up. If you take Joe Burrow's stat line right now and you extend it out over the next eight games, we are going to talk about a single season authored by Burrow that will rival some of the greatest single seasons we have seen in the history of the National Football League at the quarterback position. We're talking about the Pantheon, rarified air.
I like the way Costos, you know Costos is serious when he starts going he replaces NFL with National Football League.
I do that. I do that, right?
He doesn't just say QB. He doesn't just say QB. The National Football League at the quarterback position.
That's right.
Played by gentlemen.
Yeah, I'm a performer. Do you want me to just, yeah, you know, that thing?
No, please. Continue.
All right. He will join rarified air, occupied by 2018 Patrick Mahomes, 2013 Peyton Manning, 2011 Aaron Rodgers, 2007 Tom Brady, 1984 Dan Marino. He's on pace for 51 touchdowns, 5,280 passing yards. Now, what Burrow will be trying to do that none of those quarterbacks I just mentioned could accomplish is win the Super Bowl. None of those quarterbacks won the Super Bowl that have authored the greatest single seasons in NFL history.
And you get the sense this year, Dave, that given the team around him, and I'm going to give a little bit of credit here to Zach Taylor. Zach Taylor has scrapped the idea of the under-center offense and play action and make this more traditional. He has put his ego to the side. I think he gets credit for that. He's letting Burrow run his offense. The Bengals' offense is the Vikings' defense and vice versa. They're the two best units in the league. He's letting Burrow cook and do his thing. Cincinnati absolutely looks like a super team to me right now, Dave Damishack.
I'd sign off on that Super Bowl. Like I say, the Vikings are deeply likable and the spirit of the Bengals. I told you that a week ago, and I don't think I articulated it very I can't articulate.
By the way, do you think Dan LeBatard hates me? I've been thinking about that for the last, like, 30 seconds or so. Do you think Dan LeBatard hates me?
I don't think he loves you.
I think he considers you like a college quarterback right now. He doesn't know. Like, you're not Jeremiah Smith to him. That's fine. That's fair.
I am either, though.
That's fair. Yeah, when he came on and was like, "Why are you talking about club?"
Just call us Mesta Maker and Arch Manning from here on out for the LeBatards.
Shirley.
Doesn't understand the Laverne and Shirley? Is that Tony? Do you know who Laverne and Shirley are?
I have no idea. When you said it, I didn't know who Squiggly was. I didn't know any of the things I was told.
Tony, you've never heard of Laverne and Shirley?
Tangentially, I've heard of them, but I don't know what it is. If you put up a picture of the people, I wouldn't know who they are. Is it a man and a woman? Is it not? I don't know.
Two women, right?
You know, right, Costos?
I've never seen the show, but, like, I think I'm older than Tony. So yes, like, I have heard of Laverne and Shirley.
You just asked if Laverne and Shirley are women?
No, he said is one a woman is one. They're both women, right?
They're both women.
Yeah, they're both women.
Yeah.
They live in the basement in Milwaukee, I understand. Like, they can see the feet walking by because they're not rich. They live underneath the sidewalk, and they watch the world go by. And then their friends are they're not friends, but they also live in the building, Lenny and Squiggy. They always walk in the door at inopportune times and say, "Hello, ladies," like when they say, like, "Oh, that's the ugliest thing I've ever seen." "Hello, ladies," they always walk in. That was the big punchline. Also, Laverne would wear famously she wore an L on all her clothing. And I'm surprised nobody's ever picked up on that.
No human being ever started wearing their first maybe that's what you should start doing, Tony. You should just start wearing a ten.
Just a what? T? Oh, ten? Yeah? I like that.
I also RG3's been in the news because he wants the bailer job. I always thought it was a missed opportunity that instead of the number ten, RG3 didn't wear the number three, but Roman numeral three. One, two, three. That would have been striking and memorable, wouldn't it? Now also.
Also illegal.
Back to don't get in my way, please. Now listen. I also wanted to mention the big losers. Do you now see what I've been saying, Nick, that the oh, to finish my thought. I seemed like the big loser because I didn't articulate myself very well last week.
You should copy Laverne and be wearing an L on your shirt for loser right now.
But don't you see but don't you see, by hook or by crook, these foot-on-the-gas offenses are just delightful, especially coming off of what we saw in the late stages last season. Isn't this great stuff? Isn't this refreshing? The teams that are thriving more than any other are the ones that are just we're going for 30 or shame the devil. The Lions are a lot of fun in that regard, the Bears, and so on, right?
Well, I mean this seriously. I would say that generally, I trend towards what you're saying. Is there a chance that the most fun unit to watch in the NFL is the Vikings' defense? Putting great quarterbacks in a blender week after week. I think I have more fun watching the Minnesota Vikings play defense than I do the Bengals play offense.
Than you did last night?
And I love watching the Bengals play offense.
Nick, I'll push back on this. I'm going to be honest. The fact that they ruin every football game they're in by making it a giant slop fest by just not allowing the other quarterback to operate in the slightest.
It's crazy.
Like, I get they're aggressive and they blitz. Like, Brian Flores plays like he's playing Madden every week. It's an amazing defense. Don't get me wrong. But Vikings games aren't necessarily fun to watch. Like, I tuned into that game to watch Jordan Love deal and instead of just.
Well, jeez, buddy. Sorry you didn't get what you wanted for it. If I tuned into watching TV, I bet on they don't ruin the it's good defense, buddy. What are you talking about?
It's great defense.
Go watch 7 on 7, buddy. Go watch the Big 12 in college football. If you want to watch 51-40.
I wanted to watch Jordan Love deal yesterday and.
Yes, but he can't.
Offense, but he can't. Their defense is so good. I saw a stat this morning.
And you hate that?
That's why it's striking, buddy. That's the same thing as I told you, the Steelers it's too far to say they're fraudulent, but this stuff about this, what a defense, exactly what I told you was going to happen. They won the four games against teams that they should have beaten over the last month, and everybody then talked themselves into the Steelers as a viable contender. They're not great, and you saw Burrow hand it to them. I do think, to Nick's point, what you saw was Jordan Love is dealing, and that makes what Minnesota did, Lambeau, even more impressive.
I'm impressed by what Cincy did, but I didn't exactly buy that the Steelers were going to be able to keep up with them going into it. But anyway, I thought, buddy, you're awfully mouthy for somebody who I thought was in a coma.
For real?
No.
Yeah, where's your neck voice, buddy?
I'm slowly waking up from the coma now. I'm slowly coming out of it, and I'm hearing that.
And you had takes on the Vikings' defense?
I'm saying that Jordan Love took eight sacks. He's taken 12 sacks against the Vikings in two games this year, 13 in all of his other games. It's unbelievable.
Okay, where's the neck brace, friend? We can't get anything else.
No, I scrapped the neck brace. You guys didn't like the neck brace. I brought out the hospital guy.
But we don't like the bit.
Oh, you don't like the brace?
I like the neck brace, and I like you being in a coma.
I bet you didn't like the neck brace.
I've been into it already.
Okay, do you want me to do you want me to get started?
Oh, my God. Oh, my God. Please. Will you get into a coma so that we can finish our conversation here?
I'm going to do buddy like Homer Simpson.
I'm going to grab buddy like this, like Homer Simpson, and just strangle him.
Where's the Tony, is the neck brace there?
I don't know where he I don't know where he hid it. Let's see. Let's see if it's around here somewhere.
What's wrong with this guy? Costos and Tony. I don't know which way to lean next here. Drake May, I think in a way that Costos, you predicted that the Patriots were finished with Drake May. You must be vaguely disappointed that their season ends with, you know, if May is in fact done and it appears he is going to be done for the season. There go the Patriots' chances.
But you did foretell that before, and we agreed that that was the case. But then on the other side of things, Aiden Hutchinson, do you think that that represents the end of the Lions' realistic chances of a Super Bowl run?
Lions, 0% to win the Super Bowl without Aiden Hutchinson. And I think if you could turn back the hands of time and ask Dan Campbell, you can win this game today against the Patriots in Munich and lose Aiden Hutchinson, or lose to the Patriots and not have Hutchinson get hurt, they would have signed up to lose the game and keep Aiden Hutchinson because they still could have won the Super Bowl with Aiden Hutchinson. Now they're 0 to win the Super Bowl. And Dave, the thing that I think about is Dan Campbell, his prophetic words after they blew the NFC Championship game in San Francisco, blew the 24-7 halftime lead.
When he said it's one of the most vulnerable quotes ever in a post-game press conference, "I told the team we may never get back here." Sadly, I think he's right. I think the window might be closing on this team. The Hutchinson injury is an absolute killer for them. And just on the Patriots, I do think they're done. I also don't think you can roll with Italian James Winston the rest of the season, like the comedian Tommy DeVito at quarterback. If I'm the Patriots, we're talking about too much handsome. Like, why should Jimmy Garoppolo not be the starting quarterback for this team when they come off the bye?
He knows McDaniels. He knows the system. He's out there in free agency. You can't wave the white flag with DeVito. Like, go sign Jimmy Garoppolo today if you're the Patriots.
I think you're right. And Tony, to update where we left off last week, the list of teams that are going to that have a real shot, not ones that have talked themselves into it, but have a real shot at sneaking in the back door of the AFC playoff picture, the Browns now announce themselves with that rally against the Texans. So as much as you can try and make sense of this two-media question, are the Texans done? Are the Lions done? And where do you go from here if you're the Steelers?
Because clearly, they're not a Super Bowl contender, but because of the lack of other options, I think they still are going to make the playoffs unless maybe the Browns surpass them. And by the way, the Texans play in Pittsburgh coming up too. That could end up being a game that settles who gets the seventh seat. Sad as it is to say, 6 and 3 Pittsburgh, it seems like they're in good shape here, but they do still have some rugged games left to come. And I do not assume victory in two games against the Ravens because Lamar Jackson might be available in one or both of those, and even Jacoby Brissett could beat them 1 out of 2.
All right, I'll start here. And Nick Costos is a brilliant football mind because everything that he says, I have written down in two separate things. Nick and I don't talk over the weekend.
What about what I say?
Well, because hold on a second. Me and him have the same take.
No, he has his Laverne and Shirley notes in another notebook.
Oh, that's what it is. Okay, it's Squiggly. So the whole thing was that they live in the basement? Is that a central part of the show? Okay, whatever. Not the point. The point being that.
It sounds like it's honestly, Tony, it sounds like it's an episode of Dateline waiting to happen.
The Lions are done. I thought their pass rush was their best unit on defense. That's now cooked. That's another year that Aiden Hutchinson torpedoes the Lions' chances. I know the first time he broke his leg on somebody's foot, that's you know not his fault. This one, freak accident, what are you going to do? But it's twice now that Aiden Hutchinson closes the window shut on the Lions, even though I think they've got the best chance to beat the teams within their own division, if that makes sense. Like, the way that they play the Packers, the way that they play the Vikings, the way that they play the Bears, I'm like, oh, wait a second. The Lions still have something there.
It's just outside of that with San Francisco, with some of the other elite teams inside of the NFC, I think they're done. That's one. The Texans are an interesting case because CJ Stroud is playing the best football I think of his career, and yet the entire organization, everything around them is just collapsing at the worst moments in time, right? The defense had a bunch of guys out this past weekend. Stingley's great. Lassiter, not great, right? They have an absolute siege over on cornerback 2. So the Texans are an interesting case.
You have them. I don't buy the Browns because there's just no way that they're going to get to 11 wins, and all of them are going to be come from behind from Deshaun Watson. Like, I just can't believe that. I'm going to continue to play the math on the opposite side of that being the case every single week. Who else did you mention? The Steelers. You get embarrassed like that where Aaron Rodgers was 1 of 8 to start the game. Luckily, he didn't get that pass intercepted that went over to the left side of the boundary there. I just don't understand how a Steelers team that had looked so good walks in with the White Tiger helmets and just gets blanked out, Dave.
Like, I did not see that coming whatsoever.
Costos, you know my recurring point with the Bengals, and I have been proven wrong by the Cowboys. I thought they were going to rise up, and I really did think, you know, around halftime against the Niners, I was thinking like, man, they're killing themselves, and yet they still have a shot at winning this game, and then the Niners housed them in the second half and put it away. But in the same way, I sort of was trying to talk myself and you into the Cowboys' defense. That is the reality of the it's not an atrocity what Cincinnati throws out there defensively.
It's better than that.
Good enough.
Look, they're not the Vikings' defense, but they're also the Cowboys? I said it a couple I mean, if Christian Parker is coordinating the Cowboys' defense on Sunday, like, obviously, Jerry Jones is crazy. You'd have to be beyond crazy to keep this guy. I said like a month ago, his name should be Atheist Parker because watching the defense makes you lose faith in God and religion. Like, here's my question for you, Dave, which is.
Oh, anyway, I can.
It was a good line. Which is your favorite? Because there are many good choices. What is your favorite Cowboys defensive lowlight from yesterday? Mine would be Von Miller chasing Christian McCaffrey on the touchdown that put the game away. Like, imagine if you're Christian Parker saying, "We are going to guard Christian McCaffrey out of the backfield with 37-year-old Von Miller," which would be like an NBA coach deciding, "Let's guard Victor Wembanyama with Mugsy Boggs and see how it goes." Like, how is this the choice that you make?
It makes no sense. I'm done with it. I don't want to hear about the Dallas Cowboys anymore.
I love the glass half full view. Wait, who was that? Now I can't remember who was on the call for that game.
It was Brady and Burkhardt.
It was Brady. Brady's like, "Oh, just the perfect call at the perfect time." Like, yeah, I guess if Von Miller's trying to cover anybody, Von Miller can't cover me. I guess that is the perfect call.
And all Brady does, have you noticed this? Like, while Burkhardt's calling the play, all Brady does is make noises.
Yeah.
Like, the play like Dak Prescott will throw the ball to Pickens. The ball's in the air, and Brady will just be going, "Oh, oh, oh."
He's the new Tony Romo. Nobody's picked up the mantle that Tony Romo left, which is, "Let me just make some interesting noises as the ball's in the " I don't know.
The puffy cheeks and the auburn dyed hair? I mean, I don't want to go.
Is Burkhardt better looking than Brady?
I was just about to ask you about that, but Brady, the thing with the dying of hair, like, I don't want to have gray hair either, but if the alternative is the dye any guy who dyes their hair, you immediately can tell they're dying their hair.
So what? So what?
Because it looks weird. If I can tell you're doing it, then what's the point of doing it?
I'm getting grays in my hair now. If I go like fully gray, I'm absolutely going to dye my hair, and I don't care who knows it.
Okay, well, it's a weird thing for you to say.
You can't be that mean to you say you're a mean, but like, it's not about fooling. I'm doing it for me. I don't care.
So the man looking back in the mirror isn't going to be like, "Come on, you're better than this."
No, I.
Like, I'm like orangey brown hair.
I assure you of this. I assure you of this. I am not better than that.
Tony, what do you think about Costos' now recurring assertion that Kevin Burkhardt is handsome? It has never crossed my mind.
Me neither.
That Kevin Burkhardt is a good-looking guy.
I have Kevin Burkhardt as an NPC, just a guy that I'm like, "Oh, okay, he's a human." Okay.
Yeah. I mean, he's like a 6.
Yeah, he's like a normal guy.
He's not an unattractive man.
Kevin Burkhardt's a handsome guy.
I see him at the LA Fitness. He's got a cut-off shirt. I'm like, "Okay, well, whatever. He's trying to do something, I guess."
If you saw Tom Brady, would you necessarily think like, "Oh, my God, if you'd have known that he was Tom Brady and he was famous"?
No, compare him to me. You think Kevin Burkhardt's more handsome than I am? Because you'd be wrong if you did.
No, the Mediterranean leather on Dave Damishack is way better.
Dave, Dave, Dave, I have to tell you, every single week your face looks more and more like a catcher's mitt.
I don't know why. You know what? I keep getting the orange thing, and when I look at my I'm looking at the monitor now, and I do appear orange, but I promise you, I am not.
It's not just orange, dude. You look weathered.
I don't look weathered, you bro.
You do.
I don't.
At least gave you Mediterranean.
Great, you can insult me. I'm going to be like, "Great, you're right. You're the one that's being defensive."
Well, you didn't answer the question. Do you think Kevin Burkhardt's a more attractive man than I am?
Yes.
That's inaccurate. I think if you pulled I think if you pulled the world, Dave Damishack would come out the champion of that one.
Whatever you need to help you sleep better at night.
I don't need anything to help me, so I don't need your opinion on Kevin Burkhardt.
And I got to tell you something. Based on some of those catcher-mitch wrinkles you got going on, you could use a couple more hours of sleep, I think.
Listen, I've reached an age of distinction. I'm not going to apologize for that, and I'm not going to do like pretty boy Brady and apparently you in about 6 months to 18 months start dyeing my hair.
Damn. That cut a little deep. That hurt my feelings a little bit, if I can be honest. 6 to 18 months? I hope I have a little more time.
Tony, what's the correct answer? Burkhardt or Damishack?
It's you. It's the again, you put this guy in the middle of just a beautiful mountainous area over in Tuscany, and I think he's an Italian guy.
Put me on the runway of Milan. I fit right in.
Wow.
You wouldn't know.
Milan, Pennsylvania?
Terrific. All right, listen. Let's get to it now.
Who's laughing at all my jokes? I appreciate it. I just want to say.
A guy in a coma.
I don't know who that is.
A guy in a coma. That's who. Let's get to him right now. It's time for Buddy Badalski's coma review of the weekend. This is in case you had other things to do. By the way, girl dad, Dave Damishack, watched the IU USC second half from the airport hotel because our little girlie was in a dance competition, and she did great, great stuff. Her team finished in third place. We were very proud of her, and I was very proud of Charlie Becker and the Hoosiers for pulling out a victory against a game USC bunch that was fighting for their lives.
Far be it from you to make it about you, but yes.
What should I do? Should I describe the dance number? Would that interest you?
I do the same stuff on my show. I just think it's funny.
All right, let's get to it then. Buddy, I'm a proud father of my child. I'm not proud of myself for having participated in the creation of a female child.
You did say you're a girl dad, though.
I was doing that, ironically. All right, let's get to Buddy Badalski.
Such a good joke it needed to be explained.
Oh, look, the coma guy's laughing at you. All right, take it away. Take it away, Buddy Badalski.
All right, I have an OLI this week, Dave. OLI. The Rams have Aaron Donald and Miles Garrett and are only 6 and 4.
Oh, God.
Number 5.
Why was it so hard for you to read your own words?
Also, it looks like he's just wearing a purple crewneck and not a hospital gown.
No, I'm wearing a hospital gown.
But it is pretty good.
My ass is out behind this. You can't see it. I'm wearing a hospital gown.
Thank God.
Number 5. I'm glad you guys talked about this one. Aiden Hutchinson ended the Lions' Super Bowl's chances doing what? Number 4. Josh Downs unlocked Patrick Mahomes.
Okay, can I just can we just stop it for a second? Listen.
Josh Downs?
Oh, hold on. Yes.
You read it.
We love to emphasize. You need to emphasize the right words.
Josh Downs unlocked Patrick Mahomes?
It's got to be Josh Downs unlocked Patrick Mahomes.
Patrick Mahomes?
Yeah, he's right.
There you go.
Thank you.
There you go.
All right, next one. Number 3.
Buddy can't read.
He's in a coma. Buddy is also adding S's to words that don't have S at the end of them.
I'm coming out of a coma.
Not only that, he's trying to find the heartbeat monitor. He loses it halfway, so it's delayed.
I'm doing it already.
Tony, can you help the guy out here, please? He's trying to find it.
He's handsy with the button.
All right, go ahead. Number 3. Joe Burrow had 245 yards before Aaron Rodgers had a completion?
That's the flat line. The flat line is good.
You see how much better I am than him?
That was good.
That was supposed to be till the end. All right, number 2. The Cowboys had who covering Christian McCaffrey with the game on the line?
You went too high there.
The flat line is great.
Tony loves the flat line.
You went too high there. You got to build it up. You don't have any breath at the end.
Okay, yeah, yeah, yeah.
It's a neck bracelet. Come on, man.
Dude, this thing is very uncomfortable.
Come on, play through it.
It makes my neck hurt.
Tough guy's play through it.
All right, you want to be in content, keep the damn neck brace on.
All right.
And read the paper, okay?
Number 1. Oh, good. Some things never change. Kirk Cousins is a Viking.
So I guess.
At least some things never change.
You planned on doing that in Deadpan because you thought it would be funny at the end, right, and not doing the voice.
I was working on.
I wanted him to drown.
I wanted him to drown at the end.
I was working on how to get that line out all day yesterday.
Dave, can I be honest here? Do you know who I blamed?
Couldn't get it out right.
I blamed Tony. This is Tony's fault.
What? What did I do?
Tony, he's sitting there. He's drowning next to you. This is your teammate. Can you help the guy out before we go on the air? Help him mark up his copy. Tell him the right words.
I had it right. I had it right. I did it this morning for Gino.
I told you he had it.
I had it right for Gino this morning, and I.
So it's a Gino problem.
Now you throw your other teammate under the bus.
No, I'm saying I did it for Gino this morning, and I had it right. And then I delivered it on air, and I totally botched the delivery of the punchline, which is that, "Oh, I came out of a coma, and Kirk Cousins is still a Viking." That was the joke.
Yes, yes, yes, yes. We got the joke.
Yeah, that's why I didn't do anything and just let you drown there.
All right.
You know what?
Do I leave the gown on the rest of the day?
LeBad? LeBad is for anybody, but I don't think Buddy is.
Oh, I love LeBad.
So he's the only.
Who can get in their way before they get to Super Bowl 61?
Well, here's the way I'll phrase it. To any fans out there of the Niners, the Seahawks, any of the teams in the NFC North, specifically the Chicago Bears, I'm pausing dramatically to make my point. At some point, I will say National Football League over the course of this answer.
Oh, I'm excited.
I don't think we'll get to quarterback, but especially fans of the Chicago Bears, I'm going to ask you to do something you are not going to want to do, and that is, in 10 days' time, on Thanksgiving Eve, when the Green Bay Packers visit the Los Angeles Rams, you all need to root like hell for the Green Bay Packers, even the Bears fans, the Vikings fans, and the Lions fans. Because come playoff time, you don't want to see the Rams as the 6th seed or the 7th.
You would much rather see Jordan Love and the Green Bay Packers. National Football League quarterback.
He is a great thrower of the football. He is a great the idea that when people include the word football as an adjective, like that was a great football play, yeah, that's what we're all looking at. We all understand that this is the activity that we're all gathered around is football. You don't need to include that. But either way, great stuff is always from the great Nick Costos. We appreciate him jumping in there. Do you feel like it went okay ultimately with Dan?
Yeah.
You do? Okay.
Yes. Yes.
Tony.
The one thing, Nick, the one thing you'll learn about Dan is Dan does not care for the minutiae of the young player's good head coat. He doesn't care about that. So you got to give him like the big picture stuff. You know what he would have taken a huge chunk of the apple out on? San Francisco, Patrick Mahomes getting back to being a Super Bowl fan.
Well, I mean, I don't host. Damishack brought it up.
Hey, look, I'm just telling you. I know the man. I've been with him for six or seven years. Dolphins minutiae, he's always out on. So maybe next time.
I would love to hear you know what? The question I really would have asked him, I had a whole thing of fan-based questions ready to go for him. But the one, because he was talking about Mensah and one of the great U quarterbacks of all time, where does he rank Mensah, and who is the best quarterback from the U of all time?
I think he would say Mensah. You can give us an answer.
Yeah, I think Mensah number one. I'm single seed at the height of his powers. Who was the best? Not body of work.
Tesseverdee won a Heisman.
So did Gino.
Mensah might.
So did Gino Toretta.
So did Toretta. So Mensah.
Kosar came out of nowhere to win the national championship as a sophomore.
He did.
Mensah might be the answer.
You think Bernie might be the answer?
He might be the answer. Honestly, is Ken Dorsey the answer?
Kenny was aided by the best team in college football history.
But I mean, but still, he still won, though.
Yeah.
How about Steve Walsh? Same description.
Yeah. I think right now, he would probably put Mensah number one, just from.
Ask him that, Tony. Why don't you ask him that and get that on camera, and we'll play it back here.
Carson Beck took Miami to the championship game last year. That was pretty good.
I know.
I did Ken Dorsey.
If you're not first, you're last. And really, that drop off from one all the way down to two is never more severe than Super Bowl champ versus Super Bowl runner-up. I'm not putting that evil on the Patriots. This is just what happens to the NFL's second-place finisher this millennium. They say comedy is tragedy plus time, but I gather Boston sports fans are not going to be laughing till they see Drake May again sometime, I don't know, autumn of '27. In the meantime, 2026 has been real sad since New England barely beat Jared Stidham a mile high.
After that day, of course, everyone remembers his infamous run-in with a certain media member. Is this a must-win game?
A must-win? Yeah, I think every time we go out, it is a must-win game.
Oh, no, I wasn't talking about Vrabel having a run-in with me. I was talking about Vrabel, and it doesn't matter. What does matter is the Patriots didn't win that must-win game, and now Vrabel's hiding his emotions in drink. It's a sad tale, no matter how many times you see it. But here's some sobering information for any team that makes it all the way to the world's biggest game and loses. Since the year 2012 of 26 Super Bowl runners-up have missed the playoffs entirely, 10 finished with losing records, and only one got back to the Super Bowl.
Yes, a deep playoff run is very exciting in the moment, of course, but over the longer arc of time, you can make a case that it's worse to get to the Super Bowl and lose it. If you don't believe me, ask the early '90s Buffalo Bills. They pulled off one of the most unrepeatable spectacular feats in sports. They reached four straight Super Bowls, and somehow, because they didn't win one of them, they're treated as a punchline. And forget about Jim Kelly. Even Tom Brady's Super Bowl losses are held against him by some in the great never-ending QB debate.
Those people are wrong, but they'll point to Joe Montana's perfect 4-0 Super Bowl record as proof he was somehow more clutch than Brady. But of course, all that really tells you is Montana lost way more than Brady did in the conference playoffs. And the '70s Steelers are the 20th century's greatest dynasty for only one reason, because they beat the Cowboys in two Super Bowls. But that's deep in the rearview mirror, stuff like Laverne and Shirley. More recently, four of the last seven Super Bowl losers missed the playoffs altogether.
And the last two, San Francisco and Kansas City, both went 6-11. What's it all mean? I don't know. But Patriots fans might want to start drinking some turpentine and honey to get through this rough patch. Anywho, that's it for the show. Tony, final thoughts? I thought you were great today.
Tony had to leave.
Tony had to leave the room. Yeah, sorry. All right. Oh, look, who's up and about? You really missed this coma guy a little earlier. He was crazy, but we'll review you.
Was he good? Did he do a good job?
I don't know. I think I might be going into a coma, or my ears might be going into a coma, so I just better wrap the show up. Do drop us a line. We will be back with a YouTube exclusive with Costos on Wednesday. We have been doing that for the last couple of weeks, and with great returns, we appreciate that. And then on Thursday, right after the Le Batard show ends, we will go live and get you right for NFL Week 11. Until then, thanks so much, my fellow football Americans. It's been a thin slice of heaven.
Week 10 is in the books. Teams who we thought were playoff-bound at the start of the season are now on the outside looking in. So lots of tough sledding ahead for the Cowboys, Patriots, Raiders, and Texans. Meanwhile, Patrick Mahomes looks like he’s back to MVP form. Joe Burrow looks like the MVP of the season. Poor Aidan Hutchinson celebrated so hard that his ACL popped. Oh, and we buried the lead, but Dan LeBatard joins the show to help us celebrate our 100th episode! Truth be told, we didn’t think we’d get here, but we’re glad you did your part to carry us over the finish line.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices