Transcript of The CREEPIEST Room In Middle-America leaves detectives SHOOK (*MATURE AUDIENCES ONLY*)

Sometimes the truth is stranger than fiction and today's story definitely demonstrates that. But before we get into that story, if you're a fan of the strange, dark and mysterious delivered in story format then you've come to the right place because that's all we do and we upload once a week. So if that's of interest to you, please offer to make the like button a nice fresh batch of donuts, but instead of filling them with custard, fill them with mayonnaise. Also, please subscribe to our channel and turn on all notifications so you don't miss any of our weekly uploads. Okay.

Let's get into today's story. On the afternoon of July 18, 1997, a man was driving down a road surrounded on both sides by trees in a rural part of Wisconsin called Douglas County. There were no other cars on the road, and so this guy was driving pretty fast. And as he rounded this bend in the road, something out the passenger side window on the side of the road in the grass caught his eye. He couldn't tell what it was, but it was a pretty big object.

And after he drove right past it, he just couldn't stop thinking about it, like, whatever it was, it it just seemed out of place. And so for whatever reason, this man felt compelled to actually stop and go see what it was. And so he slowed down and parked on the shoulder. He got out and began walking along the road back in the direction of this object. And as he got closer, you know, he began to see this object again in the shoulder of the road and it was sort of obscured by grass and other things so he couldn't see what it was.

But as he got closer, he saw the object was pretty big and it was all white. And as he took a few more steps and got within maybe 20 or 30 feet, he finally got a better look at this object and he just froze because the object was a man, a man wearing all white, a white suit, a white belt, white shoes, all white and he was laying on the side of the road just totally motionless. And for a second, the driver thought, you know, maybe this guy is sleeping but after taking only a few more steps and getting a totally unobstructed view at the sky, he saw there was a gaping hole in this man's chest. He was obviously dead. And so the driver turned around, ran back to his car, sped to the nearest house and called 911.

The next morning, a Douglas County detective named Stephen Long was sitting at his desk looking at the photos of the dead man in white. This murder case was less than 24 hours old, but already, this was 1 of the weirder cases that this detective had ever been assigned to. The victim had pretty much immediately been identified because he was carrying on his person, his wallet, and in his wallet was his driver's license, and so they knew who he was. But the man in white's identity actually made the whole case more confusing, not less. And Mark had no obvious ties to the area.

So what was this rich guy doing 3 hours from home dressed all in white getting shot to death on the side of the road? Like it didn't add up. The dead man was a 45 year old millionaire named Mark Foster. And Mark lived 3 hours away in Minneapolis, Minnesota, and had no discernible ties to Douglas County, and so the detective was thinking like, what is this rich guy doing here dressed head to toe all in white getting murdered on the side of some local random back road? But things only got more confusing from there.

After the medical examiner did Mark's autopsy, he told detective Long that he discovered a note inside of Mark's shoe, and the note just said, Jack Fraser isn't here, but it's Jimmy Bailey or a look alike? I hope I'm okay. Now, nobody including detective Long had any idea what this note meant. It was far too cryptic. But when they ran Jack Fraser and Jimmy Bailey's names through their database, the police discovered that both of those men, 1, existed and 2, they lived in Minnesota.

Same as Mark Foster. And so naturally, detective Long began to suspect that maybe those 2, those 2 men were connected in some way to Mark Foster. You know, maybe they were involved in his murder or maybe they were actually his killer or killers. He didn't know but it was his best lead. So detective Long decided he would just have to go to Minneapolis to try to find out more.

A few hours later, detective Long parked his car at the Minneapolis police station. He got out and walked inside the building. Waiting for him inside was the local detective who Mark had already spoken to. And so after meeting this detective, the 2 of them went into an interview room where Mark Foster's wife was waiting for them. And right away, detective Long noticed that she was very pregnant and at least 15 or 20 years younger than Mark.

But despite that, she seemed very composed. It would turn out she'd already been told about her husband's death, and she was basically resigned to the fact that she was here to try to answer questions to figure out what happened. And so the detective sat down and they began to interview her. And then when they brought up the note that was found in Mark Shue, specifically when they said the 2 names that were on that note. Jack Fraser and Jimmy Bailey.

When they said that, it triggered something in Mark Foster's wife. She immediately began to cry, and then in between sobs, she would tell the detectives that she knew who those 2 men were. She told them that she had previously had relationships with both of them before marrying Mark. And she said, after she married Mark, Jack and Jimmy became very jealous. They didn't like the idea that she had chosen Mark over them.

And so she had always felt like those 2, Jack and Jimmy, sort of had it out for Mark as a result of this romantic rivalry. After the interview with Mark's wife ended, detective Long began to think that, you know, despite this case appearing on the surface to be very odd and confusing, that perhaps in reality, it was quite simple. Maybe Jimmy and Jack were so jealous of Mark that they killed Mark. I mean based on what Mark's wife had just told them in the interview about them being romantic rivals of Mark, and also the fact that that note was in Mark's shoe and named those 2 men, it certainly seemed very possible. But over the next couple of days that detective Long began digging into this theory, that theory fell apart because it would turn out Jack Fraser and Jimmy Bailey had absolutely airtight alibis.

They simply couldn't have been the killers. Now detective Long was obviously frustrated. He felt like he really had it here, but he was not deterred. He decided his next move would be to try to better understand his victim. To this point, he'd already interviewed a lot of Mark's friends and family, but something he had not done yet was simply go to Mark's house and have a look around.

So detective Long got a search warrant, and on July 29th, roughly a week after Mark was killed, detective Long along with another detective pulled up in front of Mark Foster's large 2 story home in the middle of a quiet suburban neighborhood. Now from the outside, the home looked totally ordinary relative to its neighbors. But once they got inside the house, it was anything but. The detectives made their way up to the front door and knocked. And a few seconds later, Mark Foster's wife opened up the door and let them inside.

And right away, detective Long is looking around and he's seeing all over the walls on the first floor of the house are these graphic pictures and paintings of naked people. And then in addition to that, on some of the coffee tables and various surfaces on the first floor, right when you walk in, are all these pornographic magazines and books everywhere. And Mark's wife didn't acknowledge any of it. She acted like it was completely normal to have all this stuff right in the front part of your house. And so the 2 detectives are looking at each other as, you know, Mark's wife is leading them on this tour through the 1st floor.

And at some point, detective Long just said, hey, you know, missus Foster, why don't you have a seat on the couch and you let us take a look around your house on our own. And so she said, okay. She sat down on the couch, and then the 2 detectives, they left the living room, went back to the front of the house, and made their way upstairs. And once they got upstairs, they found the master suite and there was all this bondage gear inside. There were leather straps attached to the bed post.

There was whips and handcuffs. There was also additional pornographic material in there. But I mean, considering what the detectives had seen downstairs, this sort of felt on par for this house. And so after searching the other bedrooms and other rooms on the 2nd floor and finding more pornographic material basically everywhere, the detectives found their way back to the hallway in the 2nd floor, and they noticed there was a rope hanging down from the ceiling, and it was attached to the pull door that led to the attic. And so the 2 detectives, they walked over, they pulled the rope down, it revealed this fold out set of stairs that came down from the attic, and once those were in place, the 2 detectives began climbing up.

And once they got up there, they discovered that this attic was not a storage space like many attics are in American homes. Instead, this attic was a fully functional room that sort of resembled like a satanic dungeon of sorts. All the walls were totally jet black and there were all these burned out candles all over the place and tarot cards littering the floor. And on the back of the attic, basically all the way on the other side, there was what appeared to be an altar that sort of overlooked the entire room. And on the altar were more candles and there was a voodoo doll.

I mean it's totally creepy and the 2 detectives are looking at each other like what's going on here. And so the detectives, they climbed all the way into the attic and then slowly began walking across towards the altar. And when they got close enough to actually see the altar up close, they just froze because sitting on the altar in addition to the candles and the voodoo doll were 2 business cards, their own business cards. Hey. It's mister Bolin here.

And I am so excited to tell you all about a brand new podcast from Bolin Studios called redacted Declassified Mysteries, hosted by the incredible Luke Lamanna. From covert government experiments to bizarre assassination attempts, redacted dives deep into the astonishing true stories of uncovered secrets, lies, and deception within the world's most powerful institutions. Governments and military services around the globe have always cloaked themselves in secrecy. But history shows that when you try too hard to hide something, it only makes people more curious. Luke and his team have spent months researching these totally true and thoroughly twisted tales guaranteed to keep you on the edge of your seat.

Stories like the mind bending truth behind operation paperclip. Where former Nazi scientists were smuggled into America to advance US technology and intelligence during the cold war. Or the shocking story of Charles Manson and the CIA, revealing how a notorious cult leader might have been entangled in a web of covert operations. Trust me when I tell you, the stories are real and the secrets are shocking. Follow redacted declassified mysteries with Luke Lamanna on the Wondery app or wherever else you get your podcasts.

You can listen ad free right now by joining Wondery plus in the Wondery app or on spotify. Detective Long and his partner immediately went downstairs and confronted Mark's wife about the attic. Like, what's going on up there? Why are our business cards on your altar? But Mark's wife, the second that attic was mentioned went silent.

She refused to speak about anything to do with the attic. And so after a minute realizing this conversation was going nowhere, detective Long and his partner called for backup. And as they waited for backup, the 2 of them stepped away from Mark's wife and began speculating like, is this a cult? Was Mark a part of a cult that like ran it out of his attic? Like, what's going on here?

And are we being targeted by the cult? Is that why our names are on the altar? A few minutes later, backup arrived and they would do a much more extensive search of the property. But other than finding more pornographic materials and, you know, bondage gear, there really wasn't anything else substantive that connected Mark or his wife to what happened to Mark, or what Mark was even doing in this house. Was he in a cult?

They didn't know. And so ultimately, detective Long and his partner told Mark's wife who still is being quiet at this point that she should not leave town because they were going to follow-up with her soon. Now in fairness, detective Long couldn't tell if Mark's wife was being silent and not talking about what was going on in her house because, you know, she was complicit in some way and what happened to Mark, or if she was maybe maybe being threatened by somebody and she was afraid to talk. They didn't know. But either way, after leaving the property, after the search was over, detective Long and his partner felt like their next move was to try to learn more about cults.

They needed a a cult expert, and it just so happened there was an occult bookstore very close to Mark's house, and so they decided they would start there. And right away, their decision to go to that bookstore paid dividends, But not how the detectives expected. It would turn out the owner of that bookstore was indeed a cult expert. But much more importantly and relevant to this case, was that the owner happened to personally know Mark Foster. And he told the detectives that Mark came to his bookstore all the time.

And also, the owner said he knew a bunch of Mark's friends. And so by the time the detectives left the bookstore, they had learned a little bit about cults. But more importantly, they left with a list of names the owner had given them of known associates of Mark Foster who maybe were involved in whatever was going on in Mark's house, and so maybe they had information about what happened to Mark. The detectives were able to track down everybody on this list very quickly, and they were all young people in their twenties. And in each of the interviews they conducted, each of these young people were very open about being in what they called a religious group that they said Mark was a part of as well.

Now the detectives theorized that this religious group was very likely a cult like they believed, but they didn't call it a cult. They called it a group. But the detectives didn't let up. They kept pressing these people until eventually a new name surfaced. Greg Freisner.

Now none of these people said Greg was in charge of the cult. Instead, they just sort of said, well, talk to Greg if you want more information about our group. The detectives naturally began to wonder if this Greg person was the cult leader or maybe he was Mark's killer or maybe he was both. But regardless, it seemed pretty apparent that they needed to talk to Greg because he might have more information about what happened to Mark. It took a few days but the detectives were able to track Greg down and they brought him in for an interview.

Boy oh boy did Greg have a story to tell. Based on what Greg told the detectives, here is what happened to Mark on the day that he died, on July 18, 1997. On that day, Greg Fryisner met Mark Foster at Mark's home. And when Mark came outside, he was dressed head to toe in white. Something he would do for special ceremonies.

And so Mark, he came down the steps, didn't say a word to Greg. They went to Greg's car. Greg hopped in the driver's seat, and Mark climbed into the back seat. And before long, they took off and began driving northeast. And for hours, these 2 just drove in total silence.

Mark just stared out the window and Greg focused on driving. The only thing that happened during this multi hour long drive was at some point, Mark pulled out a piece of paper from his coat pocket and he wrote something on it. And then after staring at it, he kind of smiled and tucked it into his shoe. And then a little bit later, Greg pulled over on the side of the road in Douglas County, Wisconsin on this random backcountry road. And as soon as they pulled over, again without saying anything, Greg and Mark got out of the car and they went around to the back of the car where the trunk was.

And the 2 men are kind of stretching, you know, it's been a long drive, taking in the scenery. And then before long, Greg pops open the trunk. And in the trunk is a rifle. Neither men have any strong reaction to this. Greg just reaches down, pulls the rifle out, and Mark, calm as can be, just begins walking over to the side of the road to the shoulder.

And then once he got to the shoulder, Greg came over and stood right in front of him and just looked intently into Mark's eyes looking for the signal. And at some point after Mark kind of composed himself, he nodded at Greg. At which point Greg raised that rifle, placed the barrel directly on Mark's chest, and fired. Mark crumpled to the ground and he laid there for a second just moaning horribly, and Greg just stood over him watching until finally Mark went silent and died. At which point, Greg casually went back to his car, got inside and drove home.

The only time he stopped was to throw his rifle into a nearby river. But once Greg got home, he was overjoyed because he knew the sacred ritual he had just carried out with Mark had been a total success. It had gone exactly to plan. It would turn out Mark Foster was absolutely a member of that religious group, the cult if you will. Except he was not just a member.

He was the cult's leader, and Mark is the 1 who orchestrated his own death. However, Mark did not view his death as him actually dying. Quite the opposite.

We celebrate life as we celebrate death. Death is nothing to be afraid of. Death is a great cross crossroads. A change in attitude. A change in longitude.

A change in the way that we perceive our spirit. When we reach that portal, they'll ring some golden mountains.

He believed that what he and Greg, his most devout follower were going to do, the sacred ritual, was after Greg fires the shot into his chest and ends this body's life that his soul, his consciousness, and his power will be transferred into Greg. Basically, his soul will go into Greg. And Mark believed once this transfer happened that basically he would be immortal. That his soul would never die. It would stay in Greg and then maybe at some point get transferred to somebody else But basically he would be here forever.

The bizarre note that was found in Mark Shue, the note that he wrote and stuffed in there, that note was designed to throw police off the trail. He knew that he was having Greg murder him again for this ritual, but he wanted to make sure Greg didn't get caught. And so he wrote on the note very specifically, Jack Fraser and Jimmy Bailey. Those 2 people he hated. He hated that they had been in past relationships with his wife, and they hated him.

And so he figured if he was gonna create a scapegoat for his murder, who better than his romantic rivals? They had nothing to do with it. He just named them in that cryptic note to get them in trouble. As for all the pornography and bondage gear that was found inside of Mark's home, well, that all played a role in Mark's cult as well. He was a firm believer that the more sexy had with his followers, often multiple followers at the same time, the more powerful he would become.

As for the detective's business cards found on the altar up in the attic, those were very likely placed there by followers of Mark. So members of the cult in an effort to potentially, you know, thwart their efforts to solve the case. They might have believed that by placing those on there and performing various rituals that that somehow would prevent them from solving the case. We don't know for sure. That's the theory around why they were there.

But obviously, that didn't work because the detectives solved the case. Greg Fryisner would ultimately be found guilty for playing a role in Mark's death. He obviously was the trigger man and so he was sentenced to 10 years in prison. As for Mark's wife, although she definitely knew about the cult and may have been a participant, there was never any evidence that actually connected her to Mark's murder. And so she was never charged with any crime.

An American submarine, L 2, was hurrying to assist a Portuguese freighter, which had been torpedoed near Padstow, when she had encountered u b 65 sitting motionless on the surface. As Lieutenant Augustine Grant prepared to give the order to sink the unsuspecting enemy vessel, he paused momentarily. Through his binoculars, he could see that the German submarine was already listing heavily to 1 side in the water. He could also make out the shape of a solitary officer standing up on the ship's deck, apparently staring out to sea. Before his excited men had even finished loading their submarine's torpedo tubes, Grant observed u b 65 suddenly shake violently, as if she had been hit by a huge explosion, before she sank beneath the waves.

For the next hour, the American vessel sailed back and forth, searching for survivors, but there were none. The haunted submarine had taken her entire crew down with her to her grave, And almost 90 years would pass before she was ever seen again.

So that's gonna do it. If you enjoyed today's story and you're looking for more strange, dark and mysterious content, well check out all of our Bolan Studios podcasts. We have the mister Balin Podcast, mister Balin's Medical Mysteries, Bedtime Stories, War Time Stories, Run Fool and our newest show, Redacted. All you have to do is look up Balan Studios on whichever podcast platform you prefer and there you go. You have hundreds of hours of strange, dark and mysterious content to binge.

Thank you all very much. Until next time. See you.