Transcript of True Crime Vault: I Now Pronounce You Dead

You have dry, juckende, or zu neurodermitis-neigende Haut? Try the new Lipika Balsam AP+ Max von La Roche-Posay. The innovative Wirkkomplex neurobioma lindert Juckreiz langanhaltend bis zu 72 Stunden. Kein kratzen mehr. Entdecke wirksame Körperpflege für die ganze Familie, von 0 bis 100 Jahren. Jetzt mit bis zu 10 € Rabatt in deiner Apotheke. Der Lipika Balsam AP+ Max von La Roche-Posay. Für eine beruhigte Haut. Step into the 2020 True Crime Vault. Listen to our most gripping stories. Hi, everybody. It's Molly. I figured I would just give a little bit of background on me. It was pitch black that night. It was very dark. Looks like it is Molly Watson. Is it Molly Watson? Okay. When her body was found, they were planning a wedding, and then that wedding was less than 48 hours away. Never would have thought that I would have been going to her funeral that next week instead of her wedding. Never would have thought it. Molly Watson come in the door, then she said, I'm here to get a marriage license. A lot of things happened after that. I don't want to cry. She was about to get married, but she also had several serious relationships before that, and so had her fiancé.

Day. And somebody was living a double life with a lot of secrets. Investigators go to deliver what they believe is going to be shocking news. The shocking news was going to be delivered to them. And I'll see you guys later. April 27th of 2018. It was a Friday night. So that night me and my daughter come down through here. We figured we'd take the shortcut through. Glenn McSbaron is taking a shortcut from his mother's home there in Monroe County. Didn't really think nothing of it. Just a typical night. County Road, 9: 30. It's a gravel road. There's trees pretty much on both sides, pretty grown up around the roadway that leads back to a low water crossing. It's an area where the roadway will actually go through a creep. Very desolate, especially at that time of the year. As he's going along the road, he sees this car pulled over on the side of the road. I come up on the creek. You got to turn as you go down into it and go across it because the road curves. My headlights came over on her body in front of the car, and I had to stop out in the middle of the creek, right about here.

He finds a dead woman. When I seen her, I swear my heart stopped. I just got a little frantic, I think. I could tell she wasn't moving. 911, what's the address of your emergency? I I'm at the end of route in the 151, and there's a woman laying on the ground in front of a car. I stayed in my truck, and I called 911. I don't know what the hell is going on here. All right, sir. Would you mind if you would get out of your vehicle and check on her? Yes, I will. It's just a freaky situation. The whole time I'm standing there, I'm waiting on somebody to come out of the darkness. I had no flashlight that had batteries that was charged. I had my truck running behind me, so I couldn't hear nothing. I'm just scared, like when somebody going to come out of the woods. I need to get the ambulance out here. There's a lady laying in front of a car. I don't know if she's alive yet or what. They wanted me to make sure if she was alive or not. You can check on her. Give me an update.

That'd be greatly appreciated. Finally, they got me out of the truck, and I grabbed my handgun and walked through the water, and I just kept on the phone with them. Ma'am. Ma'am. Oh, my God. I don't think she's alive. No. I've seen if she was cold to the touch or if she had a pulse, and she did not. And I looked in her eyes and I could tell that she was gone. Her eyes are open. I swear to God, she's dead. This case takes place in the American Heartland. It's the northeastern section of the state of Missouri, Monroe County, and neighboring Randolph County. Bucolic agricultural community. Not a whole lot of industry. The prison is one of the biggest employers. That is the Amish. There are just two big areas of Amish that are in northeast Missouri. Just farm ground. I mean, just there's dairy cows, there's beef cows, there's mainly, for the most part, just farming. There's probably more animals than there are people in that county. It's most well known for being the birthplace with Mark Twain, and he wrote a lot of his stories about this idyllic landscape here in Monroe County.

Back at the crime scene, investigators are trying to identify this victim. Where my patrol car is is in the general vicinity of where we found the victim's car when we arrived on scene. Outside of the driver's door, there were what appeared to be blood on the ground. And then there were some drag marks in the gravel. And ultimately, we found a deceased female in front of the vehicle. She's wearing a pajama pants or sweat pants, as well as a tank top. Well, It was very obvious within the first few minutes to me that there was foul play involved. She was essentially shot execution style. She had been shot once in the back of the head at point-blank range. Some investigation was done as to ascertain the identity of the victim. The weight didn't match on the DOR thing. That's the only thing I thought. We initially run the vehicle registration, things of that nature. It looks like it is Molly Watson. Is it Molly Watson? Okay. We were eventually able to figure out that the victim was Molly Watson. Police wake up the family in the middle of the night with some pretty bad news.

My wife woke me up, said, Your dad's on the phone. He doesn't sound good. Something happened. I'll never forget my dad. He said, Timmy, he said, The Highway Patrol just left our house. I was like, What happened? He said, They found Molly dead in the road. I was like, What? Sandy called me at 2: 00 in the morning and said that the police had just been to their house and told them that Molly had been shot. I think she kept screaming Molly's dead, didn't she? Knowing that while he was dead was a big shock. I'm Jody Lundberg. I'm Molly's cousin. I am Patsy Dent, and I'm Molly's aunt. When she was born, I actually named her. Me and Molly were both goofballs, but she was like my best friend. Even from when we were growing up, I always looked after her. I was always Molly's protector. Hi, Hi, everybody. It's Molly. I'm not sure when she started doing the YouTube thing. And today I am just doing a general blog. But then she got the bug for it and wanted to start a weekly vlog where she would just talk about herself or what's going on in her life.

I figured I would just give a little bit of background on me. I work in education right now. I have two degrees in psychology, a bachelor's and a master's. She was so smart. She could read any book. Lots of artwork, costuming. She was really good at that. And as you can see, I was preparing to work I'm going to cry in my next costume when I decided to do this vlog. She wanted to be a singer for a long time, and she had a really good singing voice. I am going to sing the healing incantation from Tangled. Dream and glow. Let your power shine. She was one of the luckiest people I've ever known. Whenever we would walk by a pop machine, she would always push the buttons, and I don't know how it would happen, But like a pop would come out. That's what's hard, I think, for me, knowing how she passed, and one of the most unluckyest ways possible. Is it Molly Watson? Okay. Do you know how old she is now? Police want to know what brought Molly to this dark, desolate place. And even more puzz, who'd have a reason to kill her?

And I'll see you guys later. Bye. Molly Watson's body was found wearing her engagement ring on her left ring finger. When she was shot to death. Our marriage certificate was located in her car. That had her name in there, as well as her fiance's name. They were planning a wedding. Wedding of her dreams. That wedding was less than 48 hours away. The murder of Molly Watson sends a shatter through her community in rural Missouri. Everyone is asking, Why? The life she led didn't seem to be one that would end in violence. Molly had been married in her early 20s, but just after a few years, that marriage ended in divorce. But during the breakup, she was pregnant and had a son. He ended up having cerebral palsy, so he wasn't able to walk, but smart as could be. She loved Declan. She would take him to the zoo. She would take him about anywhere with her. That was just her world right there. And then she met Amber, who she started a relationship with. This is just a photo album that we had put together, Molly and I, had with Declan. My name is Amber Katie.

Molly Watson and I were in a relationship for about five years. That's Molly that Declan's laying on, and I'm right behind Molly, and we're all just napping on the couch. We actually met in kindergarten. We went to kindergarten together. We did not like each other whatsoever. I thought she was a weird little person, and she thought I was obnoxious. Amber and Molly lost touch for a long time. But years later, the kindergarten adversaries crossed paths again. We actually ran into each other downtown, Moverly, one day, and she's like, Is that you? I'm like, Yeah. And so it just kicked off from there. We actually grew a friendship there, and then things just got closer. They find they like the grown-up version of each other much more. She was just bouncy and bubb all the time. I mean, anything would make her smile, the simplest things. And they fall in love. She was actually my first girlfriend. I was her. She was married at the time. I was, too. But things weren't going well for either one of us. Molly and Amber move in together. And when Molly's son is born, they're a little family. We could talk.

We could communicate. We like doing a lot of the same things. It just seemed to click. But then Molly gets a new job. She decided to go and apply at the prison, and that's where she was going to work. Mobile Area Correctional Center. She was a Corrections Officer One. She was down in the wings that she had to do counts, search and sell, break up fights. Molly meets somebody new at the prison, not an inmate, but a lieutenant named James Addy. I thought we were doing fine, but I guess they grew close. Amber says she caught Molly and James at a motel. And I went up there and knocked on the door. She answered James Addy was getting dressed and leaving. That wasn't good. Amber says there was another encounter at a gas station. He gets out of the car, and he started to say something. I didn't give him the option. I told him, I said, You need to shut up. I said, You broke up our family. At this point, she moved back into my mom and dad's house. Amber says she's heartbroken, but Molly, apparently, is head over heels for James Addy.

I didn't have any friendship or anything to do with Molly. She had blocked me on everything, which that was fine. I mean, it wasn't a good breakup. Molly was absolutely 100 % in love with him. She would have walked the end of the Earth for him. It seemed like a pretty nice relationship. Smiling photos of them on trips together. A happy couple. It was definitely an age gap there. At first, it was weird for us, but everybody got past it. Growing up, Jim, far back as I can remember, he was always a good brother. He was a role model and example. He was in the Marine Corps. And then From the Marine Corps, he got out after Desert Storm and just created a life. This guy is a proud veteran of the United States Marines. He was even born on the fourth of July. He's got two kids. He's worked as a mechanic. He's worked in a factory and had gotten a job at the local prison where he was, like so much, he reached the level of Lieutenant. James Addy does have some history. He's been married four times. He has So many ex-wives that apparently some of his own family members say they can't keep track of everyone's names.

I loved Melanie. She was always nice, always kind, funny. It was just Melanie. The type of women that Jim liked were very Very nice, very kind. But now it's James and Molly. And they really did seem to love each other. I mean, according to Jim, it was a relationship unlike anything he'd had before. Something that he said of mutual respect between the two, that they could share anything with each other. It's something any of us would love to have in a relationship with another person. After seven years of having this relationship with James, well, she surprises her family. She suddenly announces, I'm engaged. And it was just all of a sudden, boom, let's get married now. She was all about him. Her family even described it This is what she's always been looking for. She was happier than she's ever been. She was ready for the wedding. Oh, constant. We always heard about the wedding. We were very excited about the wedding. The colors, the theme, the decoration. There's a lot of burgundy and gold. Kind of reminded me of a Renaissance-themed wedding. From Molly's perspective, it was going to be a beautiful wedding and the best day ever.

You were booked for her makeup She had been here three years ago. Yes. What did you know about Molly and the wedding and her fiancé? I remember meeting her. She was so excited. She wanted a Disney-themed, and we had been working on a wedding that was Beauty and the Beast. And so we were like, We're very familiar with doing this very Disney-themed wedding. This dress, as you will see with it on me, I show it with me wearing one ball gown, crunelen. She was very excited. Well, she had how many dresses? Two. Two dresses, yeah. Two dresses. She could not make up her mind. That's what Molly wanted to do, to have a perfect wedding. She was so excited. Very excited because it had taken a while to get to that point, I guess, of them being married. What did you make of Molly as a bride-to-be? She was really sweet. I loved working with her. A very wonderful wedding had been planned at the Stoney Creek Inn. Molly had invited her family here to come to this event. I got mine. I sent my RSVP back. The couple of times that I met her, she always had a smile on her face.

She was bubbly. She was happy. She enjoyed talking about her wedding. James was the opposite of Molly. He was very quiet, didn't show much enthusiasm. I just thought he was just a groom along for the ride. Is James looking to back out of the wedding? You see, in their text messages, Molly appears to be worried about that. Are you still sure you want to marry me with my anxiety? The NBA is happening now on ABC and the ESPN app. Right now, this season is unpredictable. We know this rookie class is special. This MVP race is tight, and this crew is the best. So for inside, primetime, showcase, finals, and everywhere in between, there's one place to call home. The NBA on ESPN, presented by State Bon. All season long on ESPN and FX is the beauty. Imagine the hottest new super drug that makes you effortlessly beautiful. From executive producer, Ryan Murphy. This is the closest to the fountain of youth anyone's ever going to get. Are there side effects? I just went in, woke up, and it looked like this. I would like the first poke. Fx is the Beauty. Now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus for bundle subscribers.

Before her life was cut short on that backcountry road, Molly was over the moon about her upcoming wedding to James Addy, but her family wasn't so sure. I asked her, What does your family think about him? And she was really hesitant, and she said, My family doesn't really like him. They've only met him a few times. He pulled in one day and Sandy was in the kitchen, and she says, Come here, come here. So we're standing in the kitchen looking out the window, and I went, Him? She likes him? And He said, Yeah. Even though Molly and James have been together for seven years, they don't really know this guy. Molly's brother even says he doesn't know James's last name. He could never look you in the eye. He He never talked to you directly. Everything was very evasive with him. He put off bad vibes to everybody. He was like a ghost that would come in and go out. But Molly was protective. It was her business. Now, Molly is finally getting married again. But some of her closest relatives send their regrets. They're not coming. That was my last message to Molly. I'm not going to be able to go.

My kids have a softball and baseball tournament that weekend. I said, But you know how I feel about weddings and funerals? I have a thing anyway that I just avoid weddings and funerals. Molly finally had convinced me. She sent me a text message. The night before she's murdered, it's actually the last one I got from her. It said, You have to be there. It won't be the same without you. And that got to me. So I told her, I was like, Okay, I'll do it for you. Never would have thought that I would have been going to her funeral that next week instead of her wedding. Never would have thought it. Late to 2017, early 2018, James Addy and Molly Watson began planning a wedding, going to the recorder's office, getting a marriage license. This one here is on the date of April 25th, 2018, James Aaron Addi, 51, to Molly Nicole Watson, 35. I'm Mark Price. I'm the Randolph County Recorder of Deeds in the County of Randolph in the state of Missouri. As a county recorder, he's responsible for recording deeds as well as recording marriage licenses. And he performed that ritual for James Addey and Molly Watson on April 25th, two days before her murder.

Security camera video actually shows Molly walking across the parking lot and coming into the building. The cameras I got in the back of my office for security filmed all that. Even on security cameras, Molly's bubbly personality is pretty obvious. She's smiling and laughing there, chatting with the guard. And you notice her phone? Apparently, she always kept that close. Molly Watson come in the door just shortly before four o'clock, and she said, I'm here to get a marriage license. And she was quite pleasant to talk to. We had a good time. And you can see James there in his uniform, showing up late, hurrying inside. And then Mr. Addy walked in the door, and he was not smiling. He was acting like this was not the place he wanted to be in. She reached right over to him and was touching his arm and stuff, and she would pat him on the back, and she would lean into him a little bit. He seemed perturbed with some of the things that I was asking him, like if he had been married before and how it ended. He was just like, Why you need to know that?

Maybe Addy just didn't like admitting he'd already been married four times before, or maybe he just didn't like the questions about his marriage to Melanie Addy, which he tells the recorder had ended in divorce six months earlier. The couple leaves the recorder's office, holding holding hands. That's just tough. It really is because she was a sweet girl. A lot of things happened after that. I don't want to cry. Judging by their text messages, it appears Molly Watson, the soon to be fifth wife of James Addy, is beginning to question just how committed this guy really is. Are you still sure you want to marry me with my anxiety? Just days before the wedding, Molly is expressing real concern that James is getting cold feet. Yes, dear. Why would you ask something like that? Because when you were talking earlier, you sounded like you were starting to doubt your decision. Not even close, dear. James is trying his best to reassure Molly that he is all in. Are you changing your mind? Not at all. Then what? It worries me that you were changing yours. I wasn't. Good. If you read the cards that James sent, this sounds like a man in love telling Molly, You are truly the love of my life now and forever.

You are my everything. I love you. I adore you. This does not sound like a guy who's nervous about getting married. As Molly is building and getting ready for the wedding and the excitement is starting to take over, there's some horrible news. James tells Mollie his ex-wife, Melanie, has just died. His ex-wife/mother of his kids was in a car accident over the holidays. And she had just passed away from the injuries. Molly was told by Jim that she was on life support for a bit. And eventually, we had to pull the plug on her. We had to let her go. This is such tragic news. And of course, it could not have happened at a worse time, just as Molly is putting the final touches on her day, her wedding day. Boom. This happens. Everything is thrown into chaos. Bride to be Molly Watson has her wedding to James Addy all arranged. She booked the location, she bought the centerpieces. She even hired hair and makeup. But you know what they say about best laid plans? The big day is right around the corner, but there are so many hitches in the wedding plans. The plan was that she had a stepdaughter who she was planning to do hair and makeup on.

Then she said, But I'll let you know when we get closer to the time because she's not sure if she really wants to be in the wedding. Hi, Crystal. This is Molly Watson. The work has just been crazy trying to get ready for the wedding. There's some last minute changes. James and Molly cut their guest list in half, and Molly leaves a voicemail saying James's daughter, Emma, won't be in the wedding party after all. I did also want to let you know that it is just going to be me getting hair and makeup done. My soon-to-be daughter has decided she and a friend are going to do each other's hair and makeup, and so we're just going to go that route. We're like, Oh, no big deal. So I didn't really think anything of it. James had told Molly, who told me that his ex-wife was involved in December in a really bad car wreck, and that she was on life support, and they didn't think she was going to make It's really nice. It's really nice. It's really nice. It's really nice. It's really nice. It's really nice. It's really nice. It's really nice.

It's really nice. With every wedding, we do a final walkthrough and detailing meeting. However, when I was reaching out to Molly to try to get that meeting scheduled, she had mentioned that James's His ex-wife had passed away from a car accident over the holidays. And a couple of weeks before Molly's death, she had actually told me that they had went in and pulled a plug on her, and she passed away. Now, this is and her role were talking, and she had just passed away from the injuries. So he had to go do a funeral stuff with his kids when we were trying to meet. On the day that Molly Watson was murdered, James Addy had dropped off centerpieces or decorations for the wedding planner and had made a payment on the wedding. He seemed just like he did in every other meeting that I met him. So this was probably the second or third time I've met him in person. Again, really quiet, didn't say much. He brought in the decor and me being a bubbly event coordinator, trying to get people amped for their big day. I'm being enthusiastic, and I do recall as I was walking him out the door, I asked if he's getting excited, and his one comment was that she was driving him crazy.

Mr. Addy made a statement that Molly Watson was driving him crazy. Deputies say they found a woman's body in the area of Highway 151 in route M Friday night. I was at home watching TV, and their pictures come up on the screen and that she was dead. It has been identified as 35-year-old Molly Watson from Huntsville. And I went, Oh, my gosh. And I hollered at my wife. I said, Carla, I think I was the one that sold them the marriage license just earlier this week. The investigation is launched throughout that night with the Missouri Highway Patrol going out there looking at this. Now police get their first big break in this investigation. And that's thanks to the guy in the pickup truck, Glenn McSparren. It was pitch black that night. It was very dark. Glenn McSparren was taking a shortcut that night to and from his mother's home and discovered Molly's body on the way back from his mother's. However, we also found out that that was not the first time he had been through the water crossing that night. About 30 minutes before he discovers the body of Molly Watson, he's driving down this same desolate dirt road in Monroe County, Missouri.

Earlier in the night, he was taking his daughter over to his mother's home and actually encountered that scene from the opposite direction. And And he saw a car come up and cut him off, put their headlights right into his view. I started to see that there was lights down here. And once I got a little bit closer, I could see that there was a car, and I thought that they wanted past me. So I pulled over to the side of the road, then I could see another car parked over on the right, facing away from me. At first, I thought somebody was stuck because the car with the lights on facing us, it It looked almost like it was spinning and like the front end was sliding back and forth. He said he saw a short white guy driving the car. An older white male in a big grandma car. Glenn McSparren described the car with the older white man as an old grandma car. Then all of a sudden, he pulled up down closer to us. I rolled my window down just a little bit, and I stuck my head over next to it, and right about then, the door came through the end of his door, and I couldn't hardly see him because of all the glare.

And I just turned my head towards the window and I said, Hey, is somebody stuck down there? And how did he say that? He said, I don't know where they're at. It's going to be a while. Glenn McSparren had a brief verbal exchange with this older white male, and the other individual indicated that Glenn needed to go around a different way. So I just backed my truck up a little bit and went back to the west. The more I thought about it, I was like, That's just something's not right. And I talked to my mom and my brother for a minute, and I told them, I said, I'm going to go back through there. And that's when he finds Molly Watson at the scene dead. Calls the police. In the hours after finding Molly, police searching in the dark find her purse and her other belongings. But they soon We realized that something very important is missing from this crime scene, something that really should be there. We all know that technology plays a big part of solving murder cases now, but at this point, police, in this case, don't have Molly's cell phone. Molly Watson its cell phone was not found at the scene of her murder.

Investigators will set out to find Molly's phone. Before the sun comes up, another important discovery comes to light. This discovery is pretty amazing. I mean, the deputy was not out searching for evidence. He was driving back to the crime scene in the dark. He's got the good sense to pick it up, and boy, is it going to turn out to be important? The crime scene is in the middle of nowhere in Monroe County, Missouri. It's remote. I mean, it's really grown up. You're driving in between trees and horseweeds down to the creek. So this is a low water crossing. You can see the roadway on the other side. It is an unpaved gravel road. It's a low water crossing, so it's muddy at point. At this muddy crime scene, right where that witness says he saw a man driving what he called a grandma car, investigators riders find remarkably well-preserved tire tracks. There were tire impressions which were along the edge of the road. There was an embankment, and there appeared to be markings that looked like two O's. What appeared to be lettering from a sidewall of a tire. There were what appeared to be double O's.

I think everybody looking thought that it was probably a good year tire. They also located a tire print just feet from Molly's body. The Missouri State Highway Patrol created a cast of a tire print in the mud near Molly's body. They did that with the hopes that in the future, they'd be able to compare it to other tires. And they take some of this evidence from the tire track in the mud in order to analyze this tire track. Could we match what we found here to any particular tire? A authorities are working hard to try to figure out who in the world would have a reason to want to end the life of this friendly, happy young woman. When they searched Molly Watson's belongings in her car, they did locate Cash still in her purse. She was wearing what appeared to be a diamond solitaire engagement ring on her left hand. Indicating that the motive might not have been robbery. So if it's not robbery, what is the motive? Could Molly herself have left a clue on Facebook? In a Facebook post that happened about a year before her death, Molly complains about an ex, but she doesn't say who it is.

She says they were trying to access her bank accounts. Let me read the post to you. I suspect it was the unstable individual who attempted to intimidate me with their service weapon by pointing it at me and threatening me when I left the relationship. I have no idea who had threatened her. I had never, ever, ever threatened her. Amber denies meddling with any of Molly's bank accounts. And keep in mind, she wasn't Molly's only ex. James and Molly had an on again off in relationship. There were other people in the picture as well. This is definitely not normal. This is not something we get in Monroe County very often. Murders, we don't get very often. Brandon Osborne was a Sheriff's Deputy with the Monroe County Sheriff's office at the time that Molly Watson's body was found. He needed to return to the Sheriff's office quickly. On his way back to the crime scene, Brandon Osborne located a T-shirt in the middle of Route M. I came upon this shirt laying in the road, went around the shirt and passed it, and then I stopped, and I'm thinking, We're close to the crime scene here. I probably better pick that up just in case.

This discovery is pretty amazing. I mean, the Deputy was He was not out searching for evidence. He was driving back to the crime scene in the dark. He spots the T-shirt. He's got the good sense to pick it up, and boy, is it going to turn out to be important. That T-shirt, we later learned had gunshot residue on it had Molly Watson's blood. We can infer that that was at the scene at some point of Molly Watson's murder, given the presence of that gunshot residue and her blood on the T-shirt. It turned out to be a very important piece of evidence. Meantime, there's an autopsy. It revealed that Molly Watson died of a single gunshot wound to the back of the head, that the trigger was pulled when the gun was flush against Molly's head, and that it was a small caliber weapon that was used to kill her. The medical examiner is able to extract a bullet from the body of Molly. The problem is this bullet is crushed beyond recognition. That's not what police want to hear when they're building a case against a suspect. Prosecutors were not able to identify a murder weapon because the bullet that they found was too damaged to be able to match it up with any particular firearms.

All we can say about the projectile is that it would be consistent with a small caliber ammunition. The 22 would be considered a small caliber firearms, along with several other calibers. Investigators are searching, and on a road leading away from the scene, County Road M, they find evidence. Along Route M, there were a couple of items of evidence that were located, including an ammunition box. It was an empty 22 caliber ammunition box. The investigators are gathering that evidence to examine later. But right now, in the middle of the night, there's something they've got to do right away. They've got to break the bad news to Molly's fiancé, James Addy. At that point, wanted to make a notification to him that there had been an incident involving Molly. The Highway Patrol Trooper does one of the more unfortunate parts of a law enforcement officer's job to go notify somebody that their loved one is dead. So they went to his house that evening. They're expecting that he's going to be devastated, that they found the body of his fiance. What they didn't realize is that the shocking news that was going to be delivered to them would change this investigation immediately.

A bright light is about to illuminate the secret life of James Addy. What has he been hiding? This is an unbelievable story. This is a story about a double life. Those lives were set on a collision course when he and Molly Watson began planning a wedding. Molly, apparently, is head over heels for James Adding. She was all about him. This is what she's always been looking for. He had told Molly that his wife died in a terrible accident. Two days before this long-awaited marriage. Oh, my God. Police found murder. It was just built and built and built, and somebody is living with a lot of secrets. A man driving along a back road in rural Missouri makes a stunning discovery. The body of a woman. So he calls the police. Is it Molly Watson? Okay. The investigators working this crime scene discover that the victim, Molly Watson, has a fiancé. His name is James Addy. He was supposed to marry Molly in two days. The Highway Patrol Trooper does a unfortunate part of a law enforcement officer's job to go notify somebody that their loved one is dead. So Sheriff Colston, along with a couple of members of the Missouri State Highway Patrol, went from the crime scene to James Addy's home.

Molly Watson was basically murdered at the midway point between James Addy's home and her home. So they go to his house outside of Mexico, Missouri, which is, let's say, 25 miles away. It's very late, the point that we're getting to his house, right around 2: 00 in the morning. Went to knock on the door. And that door was answered by James Addy, who's wearing a bathroom. As investigators go to deliver what they believe is going to be shocking news to James Addy, they had no idea that the shocking news was going to be delivered to them. While the trooper is there in the home, he makes a startling discovery. There's another woman in James Addy's house. She asks the trooper, What are you doing here? And I imagine the trooper probably felt much of the same thing. What are you doing here? The answer is not just a complete surprise. It's a shock. It turns Dinos out the woman who was there is James Addy's wife, Melanie Addy. She had not only been married to James for more than 20 years, but she's the mom of their two children, including a teenage girl named Emma, who was upstairs asleep in her own bed.

Now, this is a stunning moment since Addy had told Molly his ex-wife was dead. We definitely were not expecting for there to be a wife wife, President. She's his wife? The guy's living a complete double life. What is going on here? It was like he was stuck between a rock and a hard place. He was realizing that I've already been married for years. I have two kids with this woman, but I also have this whole other life. He knew that in two days, all of that was going to collide. This is a huge predicament for him. How do you keep How's both of these lives going? Molly knew he was married. He had told her, and she told me all this. She's like, he has a wife. He plans on leaving her once their daughter graduates high school. Why would you ask someone to marry you If you're already married, just continue on the way you were. Turns out Melanie Addi is James Addy's fourth wife. So that would mean Molly would have been his fifth marriage. Marriage, but it's really unclear how those previous marriages ended. We tried to find those previous ex-wives, but no one we interviewed for this story knew any details.

The wife, she denies any knowledge of the affair. I don't think that she knew. I guess Melanie asked who Molly Watson was, and he had to confess, Yeah, it's my lover. James Addy was interviewed apart from the other members of the home. He admits that he was cheating on Melanie with Molly, and that, yes, they had been engaged to be married. He admits early on that He had done something he should have in terms of an affair. He never said he killed anyone. Mr. Addy became visibly hot and uncomfortable during that interview. So hot and uncomfortable that he actually He walked over to his window, opened it, and put a box fan there to blow the cool air in. At first, Addy offers up an explanation of what he had been doing that night. James Addy said he was going to see a friend that night at seven o'clock. He says that he was going to pick up an avocado plant. Says that he got back home around 8: 30 that night. But Addy also admits something else to police. He tells them that he had been talking to Molly earlier that night using a phone that he kept hidden from his wife.

There was essentially a secret phone or a private phone that he only used to communicate with Molly Watson. It was a purple cell phone that he went out and grabbed and gave it to investigators, said, This is what I used to communicate. And boy, did he communicate. James Addy admits to talking to Molly Watson every a single day and volunteered that the last time he had spoken with Molly Watson was earlier in that evening and showed the police a screenshot of a 22-minute phone call from her to him. He did not indicate that she was driving or what she was doing during the period of that phone call. James Addy texted Molly Watson after she was dead. These texts were like maybe a caring fiancee would send. What did you eat for supper? I love you so much. And finally, when he has no response, he says something like, Night, night, sweetheart. I'll talk to you tomorrow. For police, everything has changed since that very first moment that they walked into the Addy's house. This man has a wife. He was sweating in the interview. He's got phone and text messages that seem ever so suspicious.

So for police, there's plenty. What do they do? They arrest They charge him with first-degree murder. Now, the trick is building a case. You doing all right, sir? Okay. Not really. I got a call from our sister, Heather, and she told me, Jim's been arrested for murder. And I'm like, No, I didn't believe it. There hasn't been a moment yet that I have thought that Jim killed Molly. And what did Melanie, James Addi's wife, think? I couldn't believe what she had to say about this incredible double life. He might have tried to kill you. Sag mal, Nikola, hast du auch immer dieses Gefühl, bei der Steuererklärung mit einem Bein schon im Knast zu stehen? Boah, nee, gar nicht. Wieso Steuer ist so die Steuer-App, mit der ich wirklich nichts falsch machen kann? Wow. Das heißt, damit ist alles sicher? Ja, genau. Wieso Steuer ist die Steuer-App, die dich versteht. Weil Steuer betrifft ja dein ganzes Leben. Arbeit, Kinder, Partner. Du kannst nichts falsch machen. Stimmt. Nice. Fühlt sich gar nicht wie Steuern an. Steuern erledigt? Safe. Mit Wieso Steuer? Jetzt kostenlos testen. For 100 days, I'm going to cross the seven continents because the answers to everything important are out there at the edges of our world.

I'm stepping into the unknown. Where are we going? To see our planet. This is amazing. As it's never been seen before. From Pole to Pole. Pole to Pole with Will Smith from National Geographic, now streaming on Disney Plus and Hulu. Show me the way. All right, here we go. I'm here with Joe Diaz on our way to Monroe County to interview Melanie Addi about this stunning story. When I look back on that drive, there was a lot of anticipation. This was going to be one of the more unusual interviews I'd done. How did you even learn about this story, Joe? I heard about this trial, and was immediately, you know, fast by how this man lived a double life. We were about to interview Melanie Addi, the actual wife of James Addi, the man who was now accused of murder. Melanie, first of all, I want to thank you for doing this because I know you've not done this before. No, I haven't. You said that you feel emotional. I do, of course. Yeah. Yeah. Anything that takes you back there is hard. It had been three years since Melanie learned the truth, but her emotions were still just under the surface as we went back to the beginning of her story.

That's me and Jim. Tell me about meeting James Addy? I was working at a convenience store, and he was a customer. He came in a lot and finally asked me out. And once you two hit it off, did he pop the question pretty soon? Very quickly. Maybe six months. That A wedding photo. You look so young, both of you. We didn't have a lot of money, and we had Ben on the way very quickly. When Ben came into the picture, man, I remember going up to their house. It was always fun. So happy. A few years later, Emma comes along, so your family is growing. It was exactly what we wanted. We had these two great kids. I was a stay-at-home mom. He went to work. It was a very traditional way to do things. I thought it was very good. I love that picture. Yeah. All of us together at Christmas time. As the years went on, Melanie admits there were problems in the marriage. There were arguments about money. James clashed with their teen son, but she says she felt her husband was dedicated to his family and very loyal, and she never suspected that he was having an affair.

Did you get any sense of whether he was contented and happy in the marriage? He seemed the same all the time. Melanie did admit that the marriage had its ups and downs, but in her mind, they had always been able to walk through whatever the issues were. This was her reality. Everything was the same. But the fact is, it wasn't. James Addy was in a completely different place. He was over it. He was done. He didn't love her anymore. James Addy, for the past seven years, had been living two lives. How was he able to separate both of these lives? He's a very good liar. At one point, he takes a trip to Florida on his own. What was that trip about? He told me it was a trip related to his work, where they were doing some training. He took the extra step and printed out what looked like a business letter, made it look official that that's what he was doing, but he was taking the trip to Florida with Molly. Another time, he takes a trip to Mexico. Right. With friends. I never really knew his work friends. Seems plausible. As I talked to Melanie, knowing where this was going, it was hard not to be a little incredulous.

But no matter what I asked, she was consistent. She said she did not know the truth about what was going on. He would get off work at 3: 00, and usually he would get home at 5: 00. And I would say, Well, why are you always so late? And that would be an argument. He didn't want to tell me anything. Any suspicions? Not about an affair? No. No suspicions about an affair meant no suspicions about what was going to happen on April 27, 2018, the night Molly Watson was killed. So let's go back then to April 27, 2018. Any strange behavior on his part? No, not at all. Nothing. He just seemed like he always did. About seven o'clock, he came in to the living room where I was and said he was going to a friend's house. Did it strike you as unusual or odd? I remember being irritated that I wanted him to just be home, and he had a hard time staying home. Do you remember when he came home? I was asleep. Melanie says that Emma stayed up long after she had gone to bed. And whatever time James Addy got home?

Well, Melanie says that she woke up at 2: 00 in the morning to the sound of his snoring. And she says she did what she normally does, move to the couch in the living room. What next? About 2: 30, I think. I saw police car lights out my window. It was very strange. I used to see that. I didn't know what was happening. She wasn't ready for everything that was about to come. She wasn't prepared that he had this whole other life that was happening without her. The police tell you-Yes. That your husband Has a dead fiancé? Yes. And he's engaged to the world? Yeah. And you're learning all of this in one night? Immediately, yeah. And you've been married for 20... 23 years. What did you think? I can't even tell you. It was just mind boggling. It made no sense at all. None. Were you angry? Were you hurt? What were you feeling? Probably just a disbelief in the beginning. It didn't seem right. This was not my life. Did you think that your husband was capable of murder? Yes. It just seemed like something he would do to fix a problem. He was a pretty selfish person.

He could be controlling and intimidating, and it could be challenging. I could see this being a way out for him. Melanie Addi begins searching her house. She searches a loft-type area above the garage garage, which she rarely went into, and found a photo album. She finds several photos of Jim and Molly together on trips to Cancun, of them together smiling, a happy couple. She found the photos of them in Florida on this trip that she had thought was a harmless business trip for him to go on, that he was actually there with his fiancee getting ready to get married. Were you asking yourself, How could I have missed this? Oh, absolutely. Every Every day. Every day. How do you not see this? I guess because I wasn't supposed to see it. So he's under arrest. He's in jail. Yes. Do you go visit him? The following week, we were both in tears. Both in tears. What is he saying to you? That he's sorry. He's very sorry for the affair, but he insists that he was not the killer, that he is not responsible for this. Was there a part of you that felt for him on any level?

Absolutely. Because I felt like, Oh, I have to take care of him. This is what we do. We take care of each other. Did you look at him suddenly as a stranger, as somebody you didn't know? I looked at him as someone I didn't want back. What would become a James Addy? If there's one piece of smoking gun evidence in this case, prosecutors say it's not a gun, it's a cell phone. Like they say, a deceased person doesn't speak, but it's almost like Molly was speaking from the grave. This is an unbelievable story. This is a story about a man who was living a double life. Those lives were set on a collision course when he and Mollie Watson began planning a wedding. Just built and built and built to the point where the guy with two lives was about to have two wives, and he had to make a choice. And when that wedding was less than 48 hours away. Two days before this long-awaited marriage. Oh, my God. She's found murder. A trial has started for a mid-M Missouri man accused of killing his fiancé. James Addy is accused of killing his fiancé, Molly Watson.

James Addy, the former our prison guard, has himself been under guard, locked up in county jail for three years until his trial begins. A female appeared out of a side room, caught me completely off guard. The lead investigator, Bradley Reem, takes the Stan. I asked her who she was. She replied, I am his wife. He testifies about that jaw-dropping moment at the Addy home when they find out that James Addy is already married and his supposedly dead ex-wife, Melanie, is still very much alive. She's standing right there. I was like, whoa. I was wondering what was going on. And he told me that I got myself involved in something I shouldn't have. When you first went to the water crossing the first time, was there another water crossing? Yes, there was. We came upon a pair of headlights down by the creek, and then I could tell there was another car facing away from me. Glenn McSperrin testifies about seeing that older white man at the crime scene. But in a blow to the prosecution, he cannot identify James Addy as the man he saw. I couldn't get a really 100% clear look at him.

I just couldn't get a good enough eyeball on him to tell for certain, Hey, that's the guy. I wish I would have. It would have made everybody's life a lot easier. But McSperrin's description of the car that man was driving, that old grandma car, police say that matches Addie's car, and then they take a good look at the tires. Prosecutors say one of the tires on Addie's car, a Goodyear tire, is just the kind that could leave a double-O impression, like the one found near Molly Watson's body. It wasn't just that double O print from the side of the Goodyear tire. Officers have something more, what prosecutors call a perfect tire print In the mud, just a few feet from Mollie's body. A state crime lab expert testifies that he compared the right rear tire on Addie's car to a cast that was made of the track that was found at the scene of the crime next to Molly's body. And what conclusion did you draw, if any, about the tire and the cast? My conclusion was that particular tire made that particular impression. Prosecutors are convinced that this tire track matches Addie's car. The defense is saying not so fast.

All right. I'd like to talk to you about this comparison that we just had that stated. There is no widely accepted scientific principle behind an examiner looking at one tire and looking at a cast and saying, They look the same to me. States Exhibit 67. Could you explain to the jury what they're looking at here? That is an empty ammo box of 22 caliber. A prosecution witness testifies bullets found in a 22 caliber rifle found in James Addy's home are consistent with Thunderbolt ammunition, the kind that came in the empty ammo box they found. Even so, that doesn't prove that that's the murder weapon. Prosecutors call a long parade of highway patrol investigators and criminalists, and then they introduce a key item of evidence. Prosecutors say it's not a gun. It's a cell phone also found out on the side of the road. We utilized a cell site simulator, and we were able to locate her phone. Molly Watson's cell phone was a vital link in the chain of evidence for prosecutors. Like they say, deceased person doesn't speak, but it's almost like Molly was speaking from the grave. Information from her cell phone did tell us that she had driven from her home to this location while she was on the phone with James Addy.

Investigators are pouring over all these text messages between James and Molly, and what they're hoping to do is reconstruct the events leading up to her killing, and maybe they'll find even a triggering moment that caused it to happen. And investigators say there's a reference to that story about Addie's wife dying after a car crash. Prosecutors say Addy texted Molly that his ex-wife funeral was happening the day before their wedding. The funeral is tomorrow. I'm sorry, Sweetness. I love you so, so much. Why would James Addy lie? I mean, why tell Molly his ex-wife, Melanie, was dead? Some speculate he hoped the story about the car crash would cause Molly to postpone the wedding and the collision of his two lives. But instead, it may have sped up his day of reckoning. Molly, at a certain point, did try to look into this and question this, according to some of the things brought up in court. Forensic searches of Molly's phones indicated that the day before she was murdered, she was looking for Melanie Addi's obituary. What is the general theme of these searches? Searching for obituary or death notices for Melanie Addi. Was obviously unable to find an obituary for Melanie the Addy.

Prosecutors make sure to point out the significance of these searches the day before the murder. They argue a theory that Molly has figured out she's been fed a pack of lies. James's wife isn't dead. He's not free to marry. This guy's a con man. So perhaps Mollet confronted James, and he decides, well, I'm just going to end it with a gun. Did James Addy have a plan to see Mollet that night? As stated here in the exhibit, the text message says, I think I'm going to see you tonight. And that was sent from James's Purple phone to Mollet. He knew. He knew what was going to happen. He knew how that date was going to end. Earlier in the evening of April 27th, before James Addy departed his home, he had sent text messages from himself to himself. Have a meeting tonight at 8: 00. Normal place. You have to be there. James Addy seems to be almost firing himself up to do something. Drastic. Don't be a again. Let's go, man. It was as if One part of him was telling the other to, Come on, we can do this. Let's go. Trying to psych himself up for something.

Obviously, now we know what it is. Don't be a man. Let's go, man. He's talking himself into it. He's getting himself ready. As the trial is getting underway, what could have or would have been James Addy's closest allies as a criminal defendant, his wife and his daughter, are now actually going to take the stand against him. Were you aware that you were on a guest list to attend your dad's wedding? I want to talk specifically right now about the evidence of April 27th, 2018. Molly's last night alive. She was home just hanging out at her house when James Addy, her fiancé, called her and said something to her that prompted her to leave the house. Grabbed her slippers, threw them on, grabbed her coat and threw it on, and told my mom and dad, I'm going to meet James here in a little bit. I'll be right back. And out the door she went. Molly was lured to this Monroe County road. A 22-minute phone call and a 22-minute drive to her death. The defendants on on the phone with her when she walks out her door. He's on the phone with her the entire drive.

For the next 30 minutes or so, police say that Addie's phones, both of them are silent. No calls, no texting. That is when he killed Molly Watson. Will you please State your name and spell it for the court reporter. Emma Addi, E-M-M-A-A-D-D-I-E. The most emotion that we saw out of James Addi was when Emma took the stand. James Addi was in tears. The evidence at trial showed that Emma Addi had actually met Molly Watson previously. James's daughter, Emma, needed a costume. And dad said that he knew somebody who did that thing. And that person was Molly, and he took me to go meet her, and she made a costume for me. James had introduced Molly as a friend from work. What was James Addy thinking? Introducing this secret girlfriend to his own daughter. And of course, the daughter has no clue what she means to him. I mean, why? Why would he do this? Did you know about his relationship with Molly? No. She articulated to the jury what she saw and heard and remembered from that night. I was still up doing homework at around 10: 00 PM, and that's around the time that dad came home.

Specifically that he got home at 10: 00, not 8: 30. On cross-examination, the defense really tries to create some doubt with timing as to when James Addy actually got home. Even though Emma says it was 10: 00, maybe he had gotten home earlier. Maybe he was in the garage working on his car. Maybe she didn't know. You'd agree with me that back in this time frame, that your dad would frequently be in the garage, correct? Yes. Emma's most damaging testimony Can you be about that bloody T-shirt. Remember the one that was found in the road near the crime scene? The T-shirt becomes so important to this case because it's a one-of-a-kind T-shirt. And here's the kicker. It was made by James Addy's daughter, Emma. Do you recognize that shirt? Yes. Right. How do you recognize that shirt? She was able to identify it because she made it as a part of one of her classes. And so she was able to affirmatively say, That is a T-shirt that I made. I know that's my shirt. She gave it to her father. I brought them home that day after the contest, and dad said that he would take one to the garage just to use his rags.

The defense offers the jury an explanation for why that T-shirt was found near the crime scene. He suggests that perhaps James Addy had given it to Molly. Is it so impossible that That one fiancé has a shirt that belonged to their fiancé? As far as your marriage with James Addy, can you describe it for the jury? Testifying next, the woman James Addy, he was relatively claimed was dead, his now ex-wife, Melanie Addy. It was good sometimes. It was bad sometimes. I thought we both tried to make it work. You were called to testify. How hard was that? It's horrible. It's just horrible. You don't want to be there. I don't want to be in a position where I'm hurting him. I don't want to do that. So in April of 2018, you were still married to Mr. Addi and living in that same home? Yes. Did you have any plans to divorce at that point? No. After 23 years of marriage, Melanie Addi had divorced James for real soon after his arrest. Within a few weeks, you filed for divorce. Oh, yes. He had always been very hard on me about how a wife should act and how a wife should be.

And then he did this. He had an affair, and that's okay. No, we were done. We were done. James Addy didn't react to his ex-wife taking the stand, but everybody else did. Anybody watching was riveted I'm going to take you back specifically to April 27th of 2018. Do you remember that day? Yes. James Addy indicated to law enforcement that he was wearing certain clothing that night. Tells them boots and a pair of gym shorts. However, later conversations with Melanie Addy reveal that those were not the clothes that he was wearing. Do you remember what he was wearing when he left? Blue jeans, a black jacket, boots. Blue jeans, boots, and a dark black-colored jacket. That jacket was never recovered during a search of the Addi home. Prosecutors also ask Melanie about that outrageous story, the one they say James told Molly that Melanie was dead. Were you in a horrible car crash in October of 2017, around Christmas or New Year's? No. And is it fair to say you did not pass away in April of 2018? That's correct. As the murder trial speeds along, a defense strategy catches some courtroom observers by surprise, and the jury delivers a verdict.

All right, then. My understanding the jury has reached a Do I have a foreperson? Yes, sir. When the jury walked in, five of the jury members looked at us. They glanced over and I thought, Okay, that was a good sign or not. My name is Richard Stuart Painter. So back in April of 2018, you were in jail at that time, is that right? Yes, ma'am. What's a case without a jailhouse snitch? But this trial had not one but two inmates who took the stand to testify against James Addy. Price-hendron and Richard Painter were two inmates in the Monroe County Jail at the time that James Addy was arrested and brought to detention there. Did something happen while you were in the jail that concerned you? Yes, it did. They were all sitting together in a common room watching television. It was just shooting the breeze. And they asked, Jim, well, what are you doing here? A conversation about a bomb came up, and it was brought to our attention that this bomb was $500,000. And that sparked our attention enough to wonder what he had done. And then the phrase was made, I put someone face down in a ditch.

The guy said he had laid someone face down in a ditch. That was about it. How the state interprets that was essentially Jim confessing professing to having done this, to having killed Molly. Like most defense attorneys in cases where jailhouse snitches are used, this attorney wants to tear it apart on cross-examination. Isn't it true that you actually aren't sure what you heard, right? I was representing him, and I can say 99% sure that that's what I heard him say. You said that you gave a statement to law enforcement, right? Yes, ma'am. Okay. And in that statement, right? You said, I'm not sure what I heard, right? If that's what I said, then that's... My name is Bradley Breen. Samantha Coven. Nathan Sheekel. Carl. Christopher Stacey. After calling nearly 20 witnesses over the course of three days. The state rests its case. Thank you, sir. You may step down. And now it's time for the defense to take its turn. All kinds of options here. They could introduce evidence, they could call witnesses, or they could put James Addi himself on the stand. Instead, they do none of the above. James Addy does not testify. In fact, as sometimes happens, the defense calls no witnesses at all.

Not putting up a case for the defense. It's fairly common because the argument is it's the state's burden to prove something beyond reasonable doubt. And I am confident that he will return the verdict of guilty. Once My client puts a witness on the stand. Now we're in competition for who is more likable, for who do we believe more. You lose the state's burden, and you take on a burden yourself. Your doubts are reasonable. Your doubts are reasonable because Jim did not kill Molly. James Addy's defense team took the stance of the state is expecting you to connect the dots, and that's not your job as jurors. Because the evidence will show that the state does not have proof beyond a reasonable doubt. They attempted to raise enough reasonable doubt about the things that weren't there. There was no murder weapon. What would be the motive of a man in love killing his fiancé? He was in love with Molly was the defense, and he was having an affair, but that didn't necessarily mean that he was the killer. Ladies and gentlemen, the defendant had a choice to make. And the evidence in this case shows us that this is the life he did not choose.

Closing arguments in this case ended up being on what would have been James and Molly's three-year anniversary. Molly Watson does not get to celebrate her three-year wedding anniversary today. But you have the power to give her justice. The most anticipated time for any jury trial is the reading of the verdict. Here, the jury deliberated about two and a half hours, the fate of James Addy, and announced they had reached a unanimous decision. All right, then. From my understanding, the jury has reached a verdict. Do I have a foreperson? Yes, sir. When the jury walked in, five of the jury members looked at us. They glanced I thought, Okay, I don't know if it's a good sign or not. The verdict reads as follows. As to count one, we, the jury, find the defendant, James Addi, guilty of murder in the first degree as submitted in instruction number six. The jury found James Addy guilty of first degree murder in the death of Molly Watson and armed criminal action. Oh, I was happy. I was so happy to hear that because my sister got justice. My mom and dad got justice. Did you feel that your husband should have been found guilty of murder?

Absolutely. Yeah. Is he a killer? Apparently. You asked me earlier what I was surprised at during the trial. During the entire course of the trial, I failed to represent anything that I brought forward. Up until this point, James Addy has fully exercised his right to remain silent through Out the trial, but now he's ready to open up and give the court his version of what he says really happened. Jim took the opportunity to really lay out how he felt about this case. There was no way that I could have done this crime. And he's going to point to someone he says is the true killer. Thank you. Have a seat. We're here today on 18AC-CR-01983, State Prison James Addi. The matter comes on today for final disposition. Two months after his conviction, James Addi is formally sentenced. Mr. Addi, having been convicted by a jury of your peers at the charge of murder in the first degree, I hereby sentence you to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole, that being the sentence mandated by law. Once sentencing is over, the judge wants to To hear from Addie. Anyone expecting regrets or remorse is in for quite a surprise.

Normally, criminal defendants keep their mouth shut. They say yes when they're supposed to, and they move on their way to get their appeal going. Addy has plenty to say, beginning by reading a love letter to the woman he's convicted of killing. Molly is the love of my life. Addy insists that Molly was the love of his life. He says he misses her terribly and would have done anything to keep her happy. Addie is now asking for a new trial. He's complaining to the judge that his defense counsel was ineffective. During the entire course of the trial, I failed to represent anything that I brought forward with. Jim honestly let his defense attorney have it. He said that he did not think that T. J. Did a great job. Can you give me an idea of what stuff you wanted him to bring forward. The cell phone records, Facebook posts that were in discovery that show that somebody else had been dead. Molly had an ex who, according to him, had stalked her, and very much so had a motive to do harm to Molly as her wedding was approaching. We reviewed all of the evidence collected during this investigation and presented the relevant and missable evidence at trial, and there was no evidence of any other person with a direct connection to Molly Watson's death.

That evidence pointed to one person, James Addy, who had the motive, means, and opportunity to take Molly Watson's life. It was the sins of the heart, I would say. He should have been a man enough to just say, I did that, and I'm sorry. It's just terrible that... I just wish he wouldn't have done that. I would like to see him and ask him, What were you thinking? Why did you do this to us? Why did you do this to you? You don't see yourself as a victim. Not at all. Molly's the victim. She's not here. She lost her life. It's so funny because here, just a couple of days ago at work, I'm a mechanic, and we have our bay doors open. And out of the blue, this balloon came right up to me. It says, We love you. We miss you. And that was my mom and dad, Molly, telling me, Hey, we're watching you. So it definitely felt good. You just think of the lyrics of that song that Molly loved so much from the movie Tangled. Bring back what once was mine. What once was mine. So many people missing her.

In late 2022, a Missouri court upheld James Addie's conviction, but he continues to pursue further appeals. You can find all new broadcast episodes of 2020, Friday Nights at 9: 00 on ABC.