Transcript of True Crime Vault: From Classroom to Captive

This is the 2020 True Crime Vault.

He told you you had to go.

He said if he couldn't have me, he'd kill himself.

Were you afraid he would kill you? Yeah.

They talked about hiding bodies and killing other people.

I knew you knew then.

I wasn't getting out of this.

There are new clues tonight about that Tennessee team. The first confirmed sighting of him. He was a teacher at this school.

Kidnapping a 15-year-old girl.

Tonight on 2020, the nationwide manhunt and girl hunt that transfixed the country. That 15-year-old Tennessee student on the run with her 50-year-old teacher, a married father with children. Did you know this whole time, all this is going on that everyone, I mean, all of America was looking for you.

She's like, If I've got back by 6: 00, call the cops.

But tonight, what you've never heard before, her story.

He can say all day long that the devil made him do it, but he is the devil He himself made him do it.

The interview her school may not want you to hear.

They knew, and they know that they knew, and I really hope they feel guilty about it. You don't have to be a rocket scientist to go, There's trouble brewing in his classroom.

Now, she's revealing all new details from those 38 days on the road.

He called me his wife sometimes. I was going to live with him until I died.

Creating new identities as John and Joanna, living, hiding, in a commune.

He got very angry. It was a unanimous decision. We didn't want them here.

Then, the end of the road in a deserted cabin.

I thought this was going to be the end. He's going to shoot somebody. Now, fighting him is over.

She's still fighting a town that doubts her. Some people question whether or not you went willingly. Good evening, and thanks for joining us. I'm David Muir. I'm Amy Robach, and this is 2020. It was one of the biggest stories of the year, the girl who went from classroom to captive. Until Still now, we have not heard from the young woman who went missing. But that all changes right here tonight. Here's ABC's Eva Pilgrim on this story from the start. Tonight, we are heading to rural Kolioca, Tennessee, where this strange and heart-wrenching story begins. Most people know everyone else who lives there. If there are six degrees of separation in the world, there's only about one degree of separation here. In this farming community of about 5,000, you'll find a post office, gas station, and not much else. It's very small, very small there.

Nothing ever happens there. I don't know. New tonight.

Until, of course, it does. 15-year-old girl and 50-year-old at the center of a nationwide Amber alert. It's been a year and a half now since 50-year-old high school teacher Tad Cummins ran off with his 15-year-old student. Today, some squarely blame him.

The guy's barbed, he should be drug out in the streets and be...

Others aren't so sure.

I think they took advantage of each other in a way, a weird way.

We've heard a lot of people say, Well, she went willingly.

She probably did. Got pulled in just as well as she got pulled in.

Many have made up their minds, both in this small town and across the country. And it's to them that Elizabeth Thomas, now 17, wants to speak to directly tonight. Why talk now about what happened?

Because I think it's time to It's a year later.

People saw the story play out.

They think they know what happened, and they think that I'm a whore. They think that I like old men, and that's not the case.

Before fate brought Elizabeth into Tad Cummins' class, she had been homeschooled her whole life.

She was somewhat of a tomboy. It played really rough. She could switch to being really nice and sweet.

Page Griffith told us at the time of Elizabeth's disappearance that she had been a surrogate mom, and her daughter, Erin, was Elizabeth's close friend. She'd come to my house, and we would talk and watch TV, eat junk food, and we just hung out together. That's Elizabeth on the left, play fighting with Erin in the back of a car. Yeah, you were.

No, I wasn't. Yeah, you were. Wasn't his name just-No.

Her sister, Sarah, gave me a tour of Elizabeth's bedroom. It's my sister's like this. During the day she went missing, it told its own story of an adolescent caught between two ages. Is. That's her Xbox? On the one hand, the teen who bought herself an Xbox with money from her after-school job. She just stayed up playing games. On the other, a child.

She made this baby.

Still enchanted by princesses and ponies. Yet the Home Movies, Smiles, mask what Elizabeth says is a dark reality.

We had a lot of stuff going behind closed doors that shouldn't have.

Abusive? Very. Violent? Very. Physically violent? And no escape because you were homeschooled.

The abuse so severe, she says, the kids finally report their own mother to Child Protective Services.

Kimberly Thomas is removed from the home and is facing multiple counts of child abuse and neglect. She denies the charges, telling a local TV station.

I'm not guilty of those.

How did you find out what was going on at home?

There's two Sheriff deputies in my yard.

Their father, Anthony Thomas, often working around the clock as an exterminator to support his five children, insisting, when we spoke to him last year, that he didn't know how bad things had gotten at home. It's hard for you to talk about, isn't it? Yeah. You don't like to think about what was happening.

So I got to take a break. Yeah.

Their mother's removing approval is a welcome relief, but soon, Elizabeth is pushed into the teenage shark tank known as high school.

First thing they did was call me ugly once I came to school. I mean, it's just boys being stupid, but I just stayed to myself.

Was it easy making friends?

I mean, they all had their little cliques. You can't really disrupt that.

Elizabeth eventually finds one person she thinks she can trust. A popular and friendly health teacher, Tad Cummins.

And that, ladies and gentlemen, is how my doctor made it. She was in his class, health, and he began to help her make this transition from homeschool to public school.

Fifty-year-old Tad Cummins is quite the charmer. Mara County district Attorney, Brett Cooper, went to high school with him.

It was funny, a cut-up, pretty outgoing guy.

So you knew him. You saw him around.

He and Jill, his wife, they were high school sweethearts and married the year they graduated high school.

They've been together the 31 years since. His wife, Jill, spoke to us when this first happened.

God is the center of our marriage and our in life. Our faith is the most important thing to us. I think it was to him, too, and it still is.

Cummins had even done mission work in the rainforest of Panama. He teaches Sunday school and sings in the church choir. What was it like growing up with him?

He was your all-American dad. No matter what we were going through, he was the one you could call and we'll fix it.

Tad Cummins flourishes in the classroom. The difference in. Watch this YouTube video of him teaching how to perform CPR.

See the difference so that I'm actually taking my weight off of it. He was the cool teacher. Everybody loved him. He was everyone's friend, everyone's mentor, helped so many people through so many things.

For Elizabeth, he's an encouraging adult role model, showering her with attention, even gifts.

He gave me a Bible, and it was just something from him.

That kindness even extending outside the classroom, taking Elizabeth to church on Sundays with his wife. Why did he decide to take her to church?

Our preacher's wife was going to be talking about abuse and how to get past it, get over it, and decided to invite Beth. We were helping her, I thought.

Did you ever think anything of their interactions together?

It was like a father-daughter relationship. It's the way I saw it, too. It's the way he would explain it. In fact, I called her our third daughter sometime.

It all seems benign until that one day in the school cafeteria.

I was standing there with a few friends, and then they said, Are you hungry? And I went, I don't have a soul, or if I did, I'd be hungry or something like that. And then he came to me and he pointed at me and said, My soul sees your soul.

Was he trying to scare her or seduce her? Coming up a health teacher, grooming a young student, what would be his next move. Did you tell somebody? No.

Why? I don't want to tell my parent that a grown man kissed me, and I don't want to tell friends that a grown man kissed me.

Stay with us. This is the time of year I know personally, I've got to be smart about eating because when the weather is cold, it is very easy to just sit indoors and eat empty calories all day. We all know how important nutrient-dense foods are, but they don't have to be boring. Cookunity is the way to get fresh flavors delivered fresh, not frozen, to your door. If you're careful about your diet, they've got options specifically balanced for keto and gluten-free diets. Even if you're taking these GLP-1 drugs, they've got a plan centered around them. Because they've got such a wide variety of meals curated by big deal chefs, you actually look forward to eating stuff that's good for you. Imagine it's restaurant-quality food for as little as 11 bucks a meal. Crush your health goals with nourishing, convenient, chef-crafted meals delivered straight to your door. Go to cookunity. Com start or enter code start before checkout for 50% off your first week. That's 50% off your first week by using code start or going to cookunity. Com/start. Coming to ABC and Hulu.

Amanda Reilly was a mother, wife, speaker at her church. And then she got diagnosed with cancer. A beloved young Christian woman fighting a battle undeserved. We thought she was God's gift, but she was a liar. Why would somebody fake cancer? From the number one, Smash It podcast.

It was only a matter of time until Amanda's whole world came tumbling down. You're not going to believe this. Scamanda. New episodes, Thursday nights on ABC and stream on Hulu. Church The outgoing family man Tad Cummins seemed like a model citizen, but look closer and you'll find some cracks in that wholesome and happy façade.

Tad was a bully about things.

Chandler Anderson worked with Cummins back when Cummins worked as a respiratory therapist at a local hospital.

He would say things like, You're stupid. You shouldn't be in the ER. In front of other people? Oh, yeah, in front of other people. I have seen Tad be told no previously, and I've the rage and anger he gets.

Anderson says Cummins had a problem with authority. He didn't have enough of it. He says that's why Cummins switched careers and took a big pay cut.

If money is not the central issue in feeding your ego is, that's what he chose. That's why he became a teacher. Who tells a teacher no? Certainly not students.

And certainly not a student like Elizabeth Thomas, still reeling from the abuse she says she suffered at home and who believes she's finally found an adult she can trust.

He made me feel like I didn't have anyone else, and no one really cared about me like he did.

Jason Watley, the Thomas family attorney, spoke to us after Elizabeth went missing.

He was specifically grooming this child for a very specific purpose, and that was a relationship. He chose a girl that was clearly having issues because she went to him for, quote, unquote, counseling. She was the perfect victim. I I was feeling real low, and I was wanting to get on antidepressants and try to go to a therapist, and he told me no, and not to do it because it changed who I was.

So he convinced you not to get help? Yes. What did he suggest you do instead?

Come to him. I think it's another example of showing to the community, to his wife, to everyone else, I'm trying to help this child. She comes to me at school. I counsel her. I'm going to make her a better person. We know that's phony.

As part of the seduction, Cummins portrayed himself as an international man of mystery.

Apparently, he told a lot of tales about his fictitional background. He's a CIA operative. He's an FBI agent. He's a millionaire. He would describe it as he went in and he killed people, and he saved people, and he killed Bin Laden.

He was telling you he did all of these crazy things?

And I knew that it wasn't real.

How did you view him at that point?

Kind of like a guardian or a mentor.

But Tad Cummins seems bent on bulldozing the boundaries of appropriate behavior. How are you guys communicating?

We did via Instagram.

Cummins posts, You're all my heart ever talks about. It was love at first sight, at last sight. Then there's Elizabeth's response, I look forward going to school just to see you. I love you.

Most of them from him would be sexual text.

He would sexually text you?

Yes, like sexting.

But their verbal communication is just as cringeworthy. Especially when they're alone in his classroom, which is becoming an alarmingly regular occurrence.

I can't remember the conversation. And then next thing I know, he said, You look pretty nice naked.

When did he take it from saying things like that to to something more?

Whenever he first kissed me, that was whenever I realized this is getting too far.

In his classroom? Yes. Did you tell somebody?

No. I didn't want anyone to really know. I was scared of what would happen if anyone did know.

From there, she says it would escalate to unspeakable things that would take place in his classroom closet.

He'd open up the closet door and he'd look at me a certain way, and I knew if I didn't go, that he'd be upset, and I was afraid to see him angry, and I've seen him angry since then, but he doesn't take no well.

At least one other student is afraid, too. A student reported seeing Elizabeth Thomas kissing Tad Cummins inside of his classroom.

The student was very disturbed by what she saw, and she immediately went to report it to school officials.

The school investigates, but Elizabeth denies everything.

The reason that children that are being abused by teachers will not admit that something happened is fear, because he's now guilt-tripping her regularly. You can't tell anybody, you'll be ruined, your reputation in school will be ruined, I'll be fired.

Curiously, the school takes an entire week to alert police. And during that investigation, for some reason, Elizabeth says the school allowed her to go on a class field trip unprotected.

He was the only chaperone there.

He was the The only chaperone. There were no other adults there.

No other adult. Other than the bus driver, but he was on the bus at all times.

Elizabeth says he took the opportunity to proposition her for sex, but she refused. The school finally tells Cummins and Elizabeth not to contact each other. Cummins then tells detectives their relationship is that of a father figure at school and denies ever kissing her. Five days later, after the school reprimands him for allowing Following Elizabeth to come back to his classroom, Cummins is suspended. How did he explain it to you?

That it was either someone telling a lie or thought they saw something that they didn't, and then it absolutely did not What happened? I had no reason not to believe him. 31 years of marriage with no problems. Why would you not believe him?

When all the students found out this was happening?

There was a lot of names and teasing that came around and a lot of bullying laying outside and inside of school.

How did they feel towards Tad as all this was happening?

They felt like I ruined his life.

Did the teachers know about what was going on?

A lot of them were made aware, and they also did a lot of the teasing and a lot of the name calling.

The teachers were doing the teasing? Yes.

A lot of them were.

Meanwhile, Cummins, now in exile from the school, begins acting strangely at home.

He always made the coffee the night before we would go to bed, and he started telling me how to make the coffee. And I was like, Why are you telling me this? And I was in tears because I thought that he was afraid he was going to go to jail.

He was planning to go somewhere. Apparently, the teacher had convinced himself and his favorite student that there was only one way out with each other on the open road. He told you you had to go.

He said, If he couldn't have me, he'd kill himself. Anytime he threatened himself, he threatened my family.

When 2020 continues, news. It is a quiet Monday morning near Columbia, Tennessee, and Jill Cummins says she and her husband, Tad, spent an otherwise uneventful weekend, out to eat, a trip to the movies, church on Sunday.

We were together all the time. We spent lots and lots of time together, but everything was normal between us.

But of course, everything is not normal. Cummins has been suspended from the Kolioca Unit School for inappropriate conduct with 15-year-old Elizabeth Thomas. You could cut the tension in their home with a Tennessee steak knife.

We were both so stressed during those five weeks. We would cry about it, pray about it.

But as hard as he pray, Cummins still can't shake the obsession with his young student, even forcing her to send him secret messages through social media.

Any time that I wouldn't post for a few hours, he would go crazy and say that I was cheating on him, saying if he found When I found out that I was with another boy, he'd kill him. And so he cobbles together this plan to run off.

He borrows Jill's car, a silver Nissan rogue, saying he needs it to go to an out-of-town job interview. He took your car.

He did because he was going out of town. Not far, but far enough that he didn't want to drive the Jeep, and he took the road.

Back at the Kolioka Unit School, Elizabeth says she is under siege. Her fellow students are claiming her for Cummins suspension. Turns out Cummins is blaming her, too. No longer Mr. Nice guy, the teacher issues a deadly ultimatum, Go on the run with me or else.

So he started calling my phone. Sometimes I'd be threatening to kill himself or ending someone else's life if I didn't go.

Did you feel trapped?

I did. He threatened to shoot himself or use the guns.

Elizabeth says she reluctantly agrees to leave with Cummins on a ride to nowhere. In this surveillance video obtained by 2020, Elizabeth can be seen leaving her home. You meet him at the Shonies? Yes.

I felt really bad about leaving, and I didn't want to leave, but I knew if I didn't, something would happen. So I went to Shonies at eight o'clock. He was supposed to be there, and he was late. I left a bag on the ground.

The student is smarter than the teacher thinks she is because in the bag is a small clue. Elizabeth says Cummins tells her to write a note, a note she writes in a way she hopes will tip off authorities.

He told me to write that I was going to New York. That way it seemed like the police would go up there. He thought they were dumb, but they weren't.

And that was his plan? That was his plan.

But I wrote that I was going to New York City, and I made it sound unbelievable. So they knew I was going the opposite way.

And she's got another shrewd move up her sleeve, signposting her precarious predicament for her sister, Sarah.

I just told Sarah that I call the police if I'm not home by 6: 00.

That was another clue.

I just wanted the police to be called because I knew once I got in that car, I wasn't getting out.

At 8: 32, Cummin stops at a local gas station and fills up his tank. He then picks up Elizabeth at the Shonie's restaurant.

But as soon as we went to go leave, he set a gun in the middle console, and I knew that I wasn't getting out of the car.

He immediately pulled the gun out.

The gun set in the middle console.

And you knew then.

I wasn't getting out of this.

It's around 10: 00 PM that night. Elizabeth's frantic father has spent hours searching for his missing daughter, and he calls the local sheriff as thoughts of the kissing incident raced through his head.

I said, You guys need to hunt down Ted Cummins and see if he's in town, see where he is.

Cummins' wife, Jill, has also called the sheriff. An arrest warrant is issued, and Cummins officially becomes a wanted man. The TBI issued an Amber alert for Mary Katherine Elizabeth Thomas. Their disappearance and ensuing cross country track would flummox authorities for well over a month. The details and the direction their journey took being told by Elizabeth for the first time here tonight. So there's Nashville.

I think we took 65 down. Okay. Columbia is right here, I think. You made me throw my phone off a bridge, and his phone as well. That way, the police couldn't track us. And then he disconnected the GPS by a screwdriver in the glove compartment, and he broke off the front. And then he unhooked the radio. It was like a kid I had to stay in the car with him at all times. In Decatur, I'm pretty sure, is where we stopped by this big hotel, and there was an abandoned van, and he took their license plate, and then we began driving to Mississippi.

Do you stay Mississippi? Yes.

One night.

One night. Just a hotel. Two beds, one bed?

One bed.

Did you have to sleep next to him? Yes.

At the hotel, I would shower every morning because I felt dirty and disgusting every morning. And he didn't help that at all.

When you say he didn't help that, what do you mean?

The things he would make you do. It wouldn't help the way that I was feeling. I'd just try to shower to get away from him, but sometimes he wouldn't let me shower alone. It's had to be in the same space with him at the exact same time.

Was there any moment that you thought, maybe I can run out of this room while he's sleeping?

He made me sleep naked, and my clothes would be put somewhere else. He was a light sleeper, so if I moved, he'd be awake. And I couldn't even use the bathroom at night without him having to stand right there.

And this whole time, as this is all happening, how was he treating you?

He was really mean and said hurtful things a lot of the time. He called me his wife sometimes, and he said that we were going to get married, and I was going to live with him until I died.

Day after day, night after helpless night, Elizabeth says Cummins is in complete control. The threat of his firearms ever present. He's even controlling what Elizabeth can eat.

I wasn't allowed to eat hamburger buns or things that had high calories or something that was too much. I mostly was allowed to eat salad.

Why was he making you eat this way?

So I'd stay small. He told me that he likes skinny girls, and I ate what he'd hold me to because if I didn't, I wouldn't get it at all.

Did you ever stay more than one night anywhere?

I'm just going to dot each place that we stayed the night. I know, I think we stayed three nights in Colorado. So I'm going to say right here. I know we went to Aspen. And then Utah, that's where he started buying alcohol.

He started buying alcohol?

Yeah. For me because I was having problems, and he was done dealing with them. I don't want to do stuff with them anymore. I was just done, and he didn't want that.

Their journey takes them across nine states all the way to California.

From each state that I took, I had rocks, and I'd write what county or wherever we were, and then what state. That way, if Nye got rescued, he could be charged for each one that he was in.

When we come back, authorities are closing in, and Cummins hatches yet another insane plan, a plan to paddle south of the border.

The waves were getting really bad. The boat would nearly go under. Were you scared? I was terrified because the boat kept going down.

Stay with us.

He gave me a calendar, and I used it to mark down where we were and where we were at. And I used it every day. And then I just stopped marking because I didn't think we were ever going to leave.

No longer counting the days until she is found, Elizabeth Thomas is losing hope of ever seeing her family again. Did you know this whole time, all this is going on, that everyone, I mean, all of America was looking for you?

I saw it on Fox News one time in the hotel. A manhunt is underway I remember it was a girl announcing it, a nationwide Ambler alert. I knew it was for me.

Meanwhile, back in Tennessee, Tad's abandoned wife, Jill, is quickly coming undone.

Please do the right thing and turn yourself into the police and bring Beth home.

With the entire country on high alert, Tad Cummins, now perhaps the most wanted man in America, panics and decides to go to a place many a fugitive have gone before, Mexico.

You wanted to go to Mexico because apparently that's free land. He wanted to go to try to go to Panama because that's where he was before on mission trips. Yeah, this is, as you can see, we're coming out here. There's good waves. This is an easy 4-8 foot swell real close together.

Brian Zolka is the owner and captain of Elgado Sports Fishing, a charter boat company located about 20 miles from the Mexican border. Is it easy to take a boat from here into Mexico?

No, it's not. You have to have the right boat, you have to have the right weather, you have to have the right in navigation. Otherwise, you're not going to make it.

Turns out Tad Cummins would have none of those things.

So he got a kayak, and he wanted to kayak all the way to Panama.

Yep, you heard correctly. He takes a humble man-powered kayak. Clearly, not a geography teacher, Elizabeth says Cummins devices a plot to paddle some 3,000 nautical miles to Panama. You were in the kayak with him. Yes.

The waves were getting really bad to where once they'd hit the bottom of the boat, the boat would narrowly go under. Whichever way you tried to go, it'd pull you the other direction.

Were you scared in the water? I was terrified because the boat kept going down. At what point did you decide, Okay, this is a bad idea. I'm turning around.

Whenever one wave nearly killed us, took us over. Once we finally got out of it, I was so happy.

What did he do then?

He decided we were going to go to a commune.

So which commune did you go to then?

To Black Bear. Because nobody would recognize us. It was the last free place on Earth, or where people come to be free or something like that.

How did he know about that?

He looked it up, and it said Black Bear Ranch was the closest one in California. Black Bear Ranch, a remote commune deep in the woods of Northern California, is located so far off the grid, it feels like another world. We're an off-the-grid homesteading community. We don't have any television, radio, cell phone, Internet.

There's no newspaper delivery or other contact with the outside world besides what comes in and out of the driveway. The reclusive residents are reluctant to let us use our cameras, only allowing us to shoot this video on their older model iPhone. Those are chickens up there?

Yeah, chickens and ducks.

Our guide, who goes by the name April Showers, gives us a tour and talks all about the peculiar couple who introduced themselves as John and Joanna. They tell everyone they are 44 and 24 years old.

Several weeks ago, this couple arrived and they failed to identify their true selves and identities. I knew that once I was at Black Bear Ranch, I couldn't go anywhere. There was literally nobody out there.

They take the pair in, giving them a bed here in the main house, and sharing their food.

They liked me a lot. A lot of them did. It was because I didn't argue. I cleaned up after myself. I didn't make too much noise. I was quiet.

And while Tad Cummins has left so much behind him, one thing he hasn't shed is his hot temper.

He brought that into our sacred space, this terrible behavior and acting on the wrong impulse and a perverted instinct, I would say.

So they didn't fit in here very well. No, they didn't fit in here very well. Very quickly, things go south at Black Bear. Elizabeth and Cummins are kicked out. Turns out Cummins didn't have much of a communal spirit.

He got very angry and almost blew a gasket.

That's pretty scary.

Yeah. He blew a fuse right there. He got mad and took out his knife and then dropped it on the ground, started screaming at April. I thought this was going to be the end. This is where he's going to shoot somebody.

It's a risky proposition, alienating the peaceful residents of this commune with so little to their name and so much at stake.

Do you have food? Eggs and two oranges, actually.

You had eggs and two oranges? Yeah. And $10?

Yeah. Nothing in sight.

Out of hope and full of desperation. Who's going to find me? Elizabeth heads back down that hellish hill, never in a a billion years expecting to meet her unlikely hero. I saw a photo of the guy, and I was like, That's definitely him. When 2020 continues.

He told me to stay in the car and put sunglasses on and keep my head down.

It's now 36 days since Tad Cummins and Elizabeth Thomas disappeared from Tennessee.

He didn't want people to be able to recognize me, and he would wear sunglasses, try to do the same.

Cast Out of Paradise, a. K. The Black Bear Commune in Northern California, running out of options, a Desperate Cummins sets off for the nearby village of Cecilville. Said they were from Colorado. Cummins sees a familiar face, Griffin Berry. It turns out Griffin had given Cummins gas and directions to the Black Bear Commune a week earlier. Did you remember them? No, I couldn't remember his name.

I was like, What's your name again? You know what I'm saying?

He's like, Yeah, we had a house fire. I think he lost his job. They're just trying to start a new life. But I was like, I'll help you out. I put him in the cabin. Griffin, Ironically, a native of Nashville, Tennessee, is the caretaker of this forested California property and gives the couple he thinks is just down on their luck a place to stay. Can you show us the cabin that you're in?

Yeah, for sure.

It's It's at the end. So this is where they stayed? Yeah. And those bottles? These are the straw bottles. So that's what they were using to have clean water?

We had a little foam mattress thing that he laid on. And then we had this thing that we grabbed from Black Bear Ranch, which is like a seat padding that I laid on. And he pushed them together, and we had a little comforter. The wood cabin is unfinished and has no heat or insulation.

It does little to keep out the cold.

It was really cold in California. It got real cold at night, especially.

To make some extra money, Griffinbury puts them to work collecting river rocks for a masonry project. When I was trying to strike up a conversation, I picked them up in the morning. I was like, What's your name? And she was like, Johanna. It was almost with an accent. The quiet girl and weird accent seem odd. So strange that Griffin tells a neighbor nearby. Something seems off. I was like, That girl won't talk to me, really, or anything. That night, the same neighbor makes a startling discovery, finding this Amber alert. I saw a photo of the guy, and I was like, That's definitely him. Then what did you guys decide to do?

He went in, called the police.

Finally, police have the tip they've been hoping for. Authorities race to that small town in Northern California, and a SWAT team surrounds the cabin.

I came out of the cabin, and it was an early morning. I think he went to go wash out our dishes from the night before, but then I saw someone up on the hill.

As the sun is rising, Elizabeth spots a camouflage hat.

I knew it was the police And as soon as he walked over there, he walked around that bush. And then all you hear is, hands up, it's over.

That's what they said to you.

They said, put your hands up, get on the ground.

38 days after Elizabeth left her home in Tennessee, she is finally rescued. The day that the police show up.

That was the best day of my life.

The police pounce on Cummins, but before he's led away, he whispers to Elizabeth, still trying to exert control over his would-be teenage bride.

He said not to tell them that we have done anything, that he forced me to go, say that I went willingly, say that he was trying to protect me.

That was his story. He was trying to protect you.

He was, and he told me to go along with it. I could tell you that her mood that was escalated.

It was a very dramatic experience for her.

It was a roller coaster of emotions for her.

Did she even feel relieved at all? I really don't know. Elizabeth says it's important for her to now reveal what she endured, no longer afraid of what her teacher can do to her.

I know he's a bad man, and I blame myself a lot, but now I know that he's at fault. He himself made him do Other people don't choose your actions, you do.

Less than 24 hours after being found, the already well-traveled Elizabeth is on a plane for the very first time heading home to Tennessee. What was that like?

Overwhelming. A lot to take in, and so many people bombarding you with so many questions.

They have perceptions of what they think you're like and what you've done. Yeah. Elizabeth enters inpatient counseling, and for her family, relief is replaced with anger at the adults who they say let her down. Still to come, the tables have turned. Silenced, no more. Elizabeth takes aim at her school.

Why didn't they notice? They knew, and they know that they knew. Can you just tell us why you didn't call authorities right away when you found out about the Tad Cummings incident?

Do you have any comment? What that school is telling 2020 tonight. Next.

I came back to Tennessee, and the FBI and the TPI were there, and they were trying to joke around with me, making things a lot easier for the transition home.

April 21st, 2017, after 38 days he's on the run, Elizabeth Thomas safely back in Tennessee. Her family begins to demand answers. How could this have happened at their daughter's owned school?

Did the school drop the ball? That's an understatement, in my opinion.

And they're now suing the school board for failing to protect her from Tad Cummins.

To this day, the school board nor the school has not even apologized for not even letting me know.

Last year, we tried to get some answers of our own from school principal Penny Love. Here she is on her Twitter page, that big smile front and center. But we find someone not so willing to smile for the camera or even get out of her car. Can you just tell us why you didn't call authorities right away when you found out about the Tad Cummings incident? Do you have any comment? And even though her school took a full week to call police after Tad Cummins was seen kissing his 15-year-old student in his classroom, Principal Love spared no time calling the cops on us. Off the property. All right, we're going. As for that lawsuit, the school board referred us to the response it filed in court, that it denies it failed any of its obligations or permitted conditions to empower a predator and blamed what happened to Elizabeth solely on Tad Cummins.

Why didn't they notice?

Elizabeth insists adults around her could have saved her from those 38 days of horror.

They knew, and they know that they knew, and I really hope they feel guilty about it. I pray that one day they might say something and speak up that they knew. If they don't, that's great shame on them.

As for Cummin's wife, Jill, some question whether she could have done more. They see that you knew her, that you interacted with them, and they say, How did she not know something was up?

No one knew.

So You never suspected anything? No. Not once? No. Tad Cummins pleaded guilty earlier this year to transporting a minor across state lines for sex and faces at least 10 years in prison.

He can say all I don't say it long, but the devil made him do it, but he is the devil.

You had to see him in court. I did.

And I made that choice. And I wanted him to know that I'm stronger than what he thinks I am, that I'm not his puppet anymore.

Today, Elizabeth is 17 teen, back in her hometown in Tennessee, and still living under that small town microscope. Do you feel like people judge you?

They do. A lot of them do. We tend to sometimes blame victims. When something as horrible as this happens, the person that it happens to is not the shameful one.

Elizabeth is focusing on what she can, moving on, which for her means being like any other teenager. She works at a coffee shop, has a boyfriend and a new puppy, spends her free time at the local Sonic, and is working towards her GED. What are your dreams for your life?

To have a family and protect them, make them have a better life. I'm a stronger person than I was, and I'm not afraid.

Strong and not afraid. 2020 reached out to Tad Cummins' attorney to comment about tonight's interview. They declined to comment. Tad Cummins and his wife are now divorced. We do know that his sentencing is later this fall. In the meantime, that is 2020 for tonight. Thanks for watching. I'm David Yee. I'm Amy Robuck. For all of us here at 2020 in ABC News, have a great night. You've been listening to the 2020 True Crime Vault. You can find all new broadcast episodes of 2020 Friday Nights at 9: 00 on ABC.