
Hello. Pablo Toré here, host of the show Pablo Toré Finds Out from The Athletic of the New York Times, where we use journalism to investigate mysteries, like whether the richest owner in sports helped fund a no-show job for his NBA superstar, or the origin of a Secret Document that the NFL does not want you to see. Basically, we're a sports podcast that's fun, but also breaks big stories. So follow us down the rabbit Hole three times a week on Pablo Torre Finds Out.
From the New York Times, I'm Rachel Abrams, and this is The Daily. Early Monday morning, thousands of people had already gathered in what's become known as Hostage Square in Tel Aviv.
So happy right now. I stayed awake all night just to see it, everything. It's amazing that everybody's coming back.
And news broke that the first group of hostages had returned to Israel, starting in exchange for Palestinian and prisoners and detainees that was expected to begin later in the day. Over the past few days, the world has seen dramatic scenes unfold from Israel and Gaza. In Gaza, thousands of Palestinians are returning to their homes and their neighborhoods, and they're seeing firsthand the devastation that two years of war has brought.
The Jinnah al-Adma'amma.
As international journalists continue to wait for access to the strip.
.
Today, I talk with families of hostages and other Israelis in Hostage Square about this long-anticipated moment, and also with my colleagues like Isabelle Kirschner, about why the hostages have been so pivotal in the efforts to end the war. It's Monday, October 13th. Ladies and gentlemen, we welcome you to Ben Guria International Airport here in Kaladine.
In Our arrival time is approximately 9: 00.
As the ceasefire took effect in Gaza, I flew to Israel with Daily producer Claire Tennisgetter to ask people how they're feeling and what they're thinking. We just got off the plane. We haven't even been walking maybe five minutes. And all along this very brightly-lit hallway are pictures of the hostages. Within minutes of arriving, we started seeing reminder after reminder of the remaining hostages in Gaza. It lists the ages of the hostages on some of posters, and some of them are crossed out with new ages as they've, I guess, gotten older. This guy 34 crossed out, 35 crossed out. Now it's his 36. So as soon as we dropped off our luggage, we went straight to what's become the epicenter of the push to return the hostages to Israel, a place known as Hostage Square. It's a concrete public Plaza between an art museum and a public library, and it's across the street from the Israeli military's headquarters. And in the weeks and months following October seventh, this place developed into a living interactive memorial to the hostages that were taken on that day. What's going on over in this?
This is actually like a little synagogue.
There are big white canvas tents. Some of them are for shade, some of them are information booths.
The Tent of Prayer and Good Deeds. T-shirts, hats, flags.
There are little pop-up stores selling T-shirts and books and pins. The yellow ribbons. But the whole space has become a Remembrance area. Can you tell us what you're doing?
I write a message for the hostages.
Every square inch of this place seems like it has a photo of a hostage or a message for them or some memento. And there are other things that feel very specific to this place and to this war. There's a piano that anybody can come up and play because one hostage loved to play the piano. Can you describe That's what we're looking at?
It's the remaking of the tunnel.
And there's even an interactive, artistic replica of a Hamas tunnel where the hostages are believed to be held. I remember the tunnel from the last time I was in Israel, over the summer, when it felt so different. There was no hostage deal in sight. The mood was somber and despondent, angry. But now, coming back...
We're very, very, very happy this was coming to an end, and The mood was optimistic, and people were excited.
We're so happy.
So we celebrate.
So we are offering a free cake for everyone.
Free cake? Yeah. The other remarkable difference-We really have to thank America for the deal, especially Donald Trump, was that there were outporeings of gratitude for President Trump and his role in brokering the hostage deal. Can you tell me what your sign says?
Thank you, President Trump, because we want him to know that we are thanking him from the bottom of our hearts.
The square is where the families of the hostages have come since the beginning of the war, demanding that the military and the government bring their loved ones home. It's also where thousands of supporters and protesters have come to weekly rallies to show solidarity and support for those families. And so after we spent some time taking in the scene, we asked a few family members to talk to us about how they were feeling just hours before the final hostages were supposed to come home. Tell us who you are and why you're here today.
I'm the brother-in-law of Omri Miran, still a hostage for two years now.
We met Moshe Levy in the lobby of the library along the square, where families of hostages sometimes go to get away from the crowds.
It was very important for the family.
Mosha was wearing a T-shirt with a picture of his brother-in-law Omri, holding up one of his two young daughters in the air.
Omri has two young daughters. They were held captive themselves on that day with my sister, luckily rescued. And hoping that this will end. I just arrived yesterday with my sister Lishai from DC. That's where we got the good news, and we rushed back here. I'm very excited to finally conclude this chapter.
When you think of Omri, do you have an image that comes to mind?
Omri, for me, is always going to be the smiling man who made my sister happy after a difficult years. It's the love of her life. That's what I have in my mind, the smiling face, the bashful eyes, and the heart, this big heart that entered our family.
If you had to guess, what do you think the first thing Omri will want to do is when he gets home?
No, I don't want to suppose what he wants to do. He didn't have a choice for two years. And ever since we received the news, our focus is now on preparations from small things like preparing a bag. A bag. A bag to a bag for a Moui because when he arrives, he would want to see, wants to wear something that is not what terrorists forced him to wear.
Have you thought about the first thing you want to say to him?
Just a hug. Yeah. And primarily, I just want to see my sister and nieces hug him. I'm not important for that. I hope they'll have that moment, and I hope it'll be the most beautiful moment in their life.
Family members like Mosha are in so many different situations. Some Some of them are waiting for hostages they know are alive. For others, they don't know. They're uncertain, and it's unclear how much hope they should have. But still, they hope to be on the cusp of some ending.
It's a difficult day.
Another person we met at Hostage Square who had a family member go missing during the war was Ruby Chen.
I'm a New Yorker. Grew up in Flat Bush. And I met my wife in Israel, and we decided to have our home here.
Ruby and his wife raised their three kids in Israel, but would frequently travel to the US.
My eldest inherited my love for the New York Knicks, and he Eithai as being the middle son, the more rebellious one, he decided to be a Celtic fan. For the love of God, I don't know how that happened, but I feel that I failed as a father.
And when the war broke out, one of his sons, Etai, the one with the rebellious streak, was performing his mandatory military service.
And he, unlike his elder sibling that went to a technology unit, he, of course, decided to do something totally different, and he wanted to go into combat. And he joined the tanks division. And he, on that fatal October seventh, was on the border of Gaza at a base called Nahal Oz, Oz, which is in the middle of the Gaza Strip. And they were ambushed. They got hit by a few anti-tank missiles, and the tank was neutralized. And we were totally in the dark. Monday, we went to the Missing People Command Center that was put together by the police, and they said, Well, he's missing in action, meaning no one is able to identify him physically standing next to him. He wasn't in one of the hospitals. And a few days after, we got notified that he is indeed a hostage in Gaza. And we're sitting there and, Okay, do you have anything else to tell us? Where is he now? Oh, we don't know.
Okay, then we're doing- So they waited, hoping for a positive sign, desperate for information on how their son was doing.
In March 24, we got another knock on the door.
Then, a few months later, Ruby got a very different message.
Had the idea of concluding, based on intelligence, that he most likely did not survive on October seventh. And we asked, Okay, where's the physical evidence? He says, Oh, we don't have that. So we understand, I looked at the intelligence I understand that most likely, Itai is not one of the 20, but he is no less of a hostage. You know, there's the missing holidays, Thanksgiving to Hanukah to Easter. And just think of a family dinner, holiday dinner with a chair that is empty. You know, you tie going back to the Celtics, now is the beginning of basketball season. We would be sitting on the couch, thinking about and jabbing one another who has a better chance of winning the division title. And we will play NBA 2K, and he will play with the Celtics and play with the Knicks. He would, of course, beat me because he's much better at 2K than I am. And he's missing. It is just as important to us to get Itai back, and then we'll deal with the two options that we have, either being able to hug him, or it means that one chapter ended and we need to start another chapter of our family.
But we need to have that ending of this chapter.
Thank you so much. Some of the family members of the square have the answers that people like Ruby are dreading. They know that their relatives are dead, but they come here for different reasons. They come to support other people. They come out of a sense of solidarity. They come because they understand what it means to wait for these kinds of answers and to finally get them. Thank you so much. Can you tell me to start just who you are and why you're here tonight?
Okay. So my name is Karmit Palti Katir. I'm the daughter of Rami Katir, who was murdered on October seventh in Kibbutz Niroz. My mother her, Hannah Katir, was abducted from Kibbutz Niroz, and my brother, Elad, was also kidnapped from Kibbutz Niroz. My mom returned after 49 days in captivity in Gaza, and my brother, Elad, was murdered in captivity, and his body was retrieved to Israel on April 2024. When my mother came back, I remember when she was brought on a journey and she looked up and she saw me and she saw my sister, and And then I could see that she's looking about the missing faces. She couldn't see my father and she couldn't see my brother. And she asked me, Where are they? And I have to tell her, on the first five minutes she's with us, that my father, her husband, was shot to death. And that my brother, for me, it was good news. I told her, Mom, but the good news is that he's kidnapped and he's alive. And it's crazy that even considered to be a good news, but for us, it was a good news. I remember when they told us that he's dead.
So my mom, she was in the hospital at the time, and she told the officer that she wants her son, my brother, to be brought to her so she can kiss him goodbye. And then the officer was shocked and he told her, We can't bring him over. You can't kiss him goodbye because his body wasn't in a state that she could have done that. And it's awful because the sense of closure, it's not full because we don't get to have these normal phases of grief and goodbye.
Meanwhile, Karmit's mom was struggling more and more with her health, suffering from ailments related to her captivity. She steadily declined and passed away last year.
It's a huge difference between what I've been through with my father or my brother or with her, because with her, we have the opportunity and the privilege to say goodbye, to say how much we love her, to hold her hands, for her not to feel alone for a second. We didn't have that with my brother, and we didn't have that with my brother, and we didn't have that with my father. And this make this feeling of closure very different.
The people here, the families, there are so many families who are anticipating having their loved ones returned. What does that feel like as somebody that also was in that position?
I'm struggling all the time for 736 days today. I'm fighting for the release of all hostages. This is my main goal in life. And of course, I'm so thrilled that it's finally happening. But of course, emotionally, it's so complicated because tomorrow people are going to hug their loved ones, and I'm not going to have this hug forever.
How do you think the country has changed? And how much of that change is permanent? And how much will go away when the war is over?
I feel that this war has been too much and too long and too devastating, both for Israelis and for Palestinians, for Muslim people. I feel like the loss and the ruins both in Israel and in Gaza, it will take years and decades to rebuild something new. I'm not talking about the house or the homes or the neighborhoods. I'm talking about the possibility of living one next to each other. I feel like there is a crisis of trust or of confidence between the Israeli people and its leadership. I feel that in the end of the war, none of us is feeling more safe. And it's sad to say that.
Coming up next, I speak with my colleague, Isabelle Kirschner, on what the return of the hostages means more broadly for Israeli society and for the end of the war. We'll be right back. My name is Kyla. My husband and I use his email address to access the New York Times. Each day, we compete for who gets to do connections. Sometimes I log into the app and I discover that he's already finished connections that day. I'm like, Jona, it was my day. He's like, I know I just couldn't resist. You would do us a huge favor if we got to log in as a family with separate emails. I really think our well-being as a couple depends on it. Thanks for looking into this.
Kyla, we heard you.
Introducing the York Times family subscription.
One subscription, up to four separate logins for anyone in your life. Find out more at nytimes. Com/family.
Isabel, thanks so much for talking to us. We are speaking at this moment when there are enormous scenes unfolding, not just where you and I are in Israel, but also in Gaza, where hundreds of thousands of people are going back to their homes and their neighborhoods, which have been largely destroyed to try to figure out how to start rebuilding their lives. International journalists are still waiting for access to Gaza. We're not allowed in there. In the meantime, I wanted to come to Israel, where there was this seismic event happening, which is the return of the hostages. So just to start, can you remind us who are the hostages as a whole?
Sure, Rachel. So the hostages were taken captive during the Hamas led attack on Israel on October seventh, 2023. And at the time, about 250 people were taken captive and taken back to Gaza. They included many civilians, women, children, grandparents, and some soldiers. In the intervening two years of war, we've had in the past two brief, temporary ceasefires where some hostages were exchanged for some Palestinian prisoners from Israeli jails. The women and children, for the most part, were returned. Some of the younger men who were considered to be in the most vulnerable states physically were returned. What we're expecting is early Monday morning for the 20 live hostages to all be returned more or less at the same time. Then mainly men, mostly young men, mostly civilians, and a small number of soldiers. Then the remains of 26 more people who were either killed or died in captivity. Some are supposed to also be returned later in the day on Monday. But the authorities have been saying that it will be much harder to locate all the remains. Some might be buried in places that very few people know where they are, and so it could take much longer to return all of them.
Can you remind us, Isabel, how these hostage returns have worked in the past just mechanically, and what is different about this time?
Of course. In the past, what we've seen largely are these ceremonies where Hamas militants would, in a show of force, build a stage and bring out some of the hostages in small groups surrounded by masked gunmen, sometimes be made to wave to the crowd or to give little speeches. This time around, we understand that Hamas is supposed to not be holding these ceremonies. We might not see very much at the beginning, but the idea is they will be handed over to representatives of the Red Cross in Gaza. They will then be transported and handed over to Israeli military and will be brought over the border into an Israeli military base called Raim, which is in Southern Israel. That's where they usually get their initial checks to see what their condition is and are reunited with close family members You ask what's different this time. So much is different this time. I mean, for one thing, these hostages have been in captivity for two years, so nobody really knows what their condition is. We've seen some hostage videos released by Hamas over the months where some have appeared extremely emaciated and skeletal and very, very distressed.
It's very unclear what the condition will be of those coming out alive. For the Palestinians, too, the Israelis are releasing more than 200 Palestinian prisoners who were convicted of life terms for serious deadly attacks against Israelis, plus almost 2,000, about 1,700 plus detainees from Gaza who were detained by Israeli forces during the war and brought to Israel. It's a very large landmark occasion on all sides.
One of our producers, Claire Tennis-Getter and I, spent last night, Saturday night at Hostage Square, where there have been weekly rallies in support of bringing the hostages home since the beginning of the war. Last night was one of, if not the biggest crowd that has ever been there, according to a bunch of different reports. Can you talk about the significance of the hostages to the war and to Israeli society and how that's changed since the start of all of this?
Well, there's an ethos in Israel that's largely been nurtured through the Israeli military, which is a conscription army. Most people in Israel, their children or their siblings, somebody they know, their neighbors, will be serving or will have been serving in the military. The ethos, because it's a so-called people's army, particularly, has been that you never leave soldiers behind in the field. There's been a feeling that's grown over the two years as these captives have languished longer and longer, that the Israeli government had essentially abandoned these people and left them in the field. So the square has become a fulcrum of anger and frustration as successive rounds of hostage talks collapsed and ceasefires collapsed, and this war seemed to be turning into a forever war. And now, of course, you experienced a complete flip and switch in the atmosphere to actually seeing some light at the end of this and seeing the hostages about to come back and seeing this war end, which a The majority of Israelis has been calling for. I mean, in every single opinion poll for months and months and months, you've had a majority cutting across political lines saying that they favored prioritizing a hostage deal and a return of the hostages over continuing the war.
I was really struck by how many people were carrying signs saying, Thank you, Mr. President, with pictures of President Trump on them. There was one guy actually dressed as President Trump holding a sign that said, Nobel Peace Prize, indicating he should get it, which obviously a lot of people have talked about how he wants to get the Nobel Peace Prize. In the speeches that we heard, particularly in Steve Whitkoff's speech, that's the Middle East envoy for the Trump administration, every time Whitkoff mentioned Trump, the crowd would go nuts and cheer and clap. Every time Whitkoff mentioned Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, people would boo. I wonder what you make of that.
Yeah, that was quite stunning to see, actually, Rachel. I mean, the cheer that went up as Wytauff and Jared Kushner and Ivanka, Trump walked through the crowd and took the podium and the electrifying atmosphere. And yes, this massive gratitude and appreciation of the Trump administration's role and President Trump personally in getting this done. And then, as you mentioned, this extended prolonged booing that accompanied every time Wykoff mentioned Netanyahu's name. There's a lot of anger still against the government for Netanyahu's refusal to take responsibility personally for the failures, the intelligence failures, the policy failures that occurred on his watch. I think that's what you were seeing last night in the square. There was immediately afterwards a lot of discussion on the panel shows on TV about whether it was appropriate or not. But it was just a very genuine, authentic, spontaneous response, and nobody had planned it or rehearsed it. I think it was just very reflective of how people have felt here.
What are we watching for now? What are people expecting to happen next?
Yeah, that's the golden question. Nobody really knows. This deal, it was very vague. Other than the first phase of it, which is the hostage for Palestinian prisoner exchange and an increase in aid going into the Gaza Strip, as well as an Israeli pullback. There's already been an initial pullback of forces to defense line within the Gaza Strip. Beyond that, there are a lot of open questions which do raise concerns about the fragility of such a deal. I think that's why we're also seeing on Monday, after President Trump makes this lightning four-hour visit to Israel, he's then going on to Sharm El Sheik in Egypt for what he's calling a peace summit led by himself and the President of Egypt, where they've invited world leaders and the Arab partners to buttress and support this deal. I think the idea is just to create a stronger coalition as possible and as broad as possible of countries who are just going to try and make sure that this holds.
I mean, whatever happens next, clearly people, in Israel at least, are celebrating the end of the war. It feels to them like we have to reach the end of the war with this first phase. Does that seem fair to you?
Yes, I think Israelis, for the large part, are relieved after two years. There's little appetite in Israel to continue fighting. It's a very Sisypian task, really. You're in an insurgency situation, and it just seems to be a stalemate. But does it mean peace? Does it mean the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has been resolved? Absolutely not. I mean, the fundamental issues remain, but it certainly brings this two-year chapter to some close, however unclear the future looks.
Isabel, thank you so much.
Thank you.
Here's what else you need to know today. Over the weekend, President Trump said that he would pay members of the military during the government shutdown, tapping into about $8 billion of Pentagon funds. It would cover the next pay period for more than a million active duty service members, but it's not clear how long the administration could pay troops if Congress and the White House can't reach a spending deal. Meanwhile, the Smithsonian Institution said on Sunday that the shutdown has forced it to close its 21 museums and the National Zoo. Today's episode was produced by Claire Tennis-Getter, Rob Zipko, and Michael Simon Johnson. It was edited by Patricia Willens, and Ben Calhoun. It contains music by Ron Niemistow, Dan Powell, Marion Lozano, Leah Shah Dameran, and Alicia beetoub, and was engineered by Alyssa Moxley. Special thanks to Gabby Sobelman and Erin Boxerman. That's it for The Daily. I'm Rachel Abrams. See you tomorrow.
The Israeli military said on Monday that it had received the 20 remaining living hostages released by Hamas under the terms of the cease-fire deal.Rachel Abrams speaks to families of those hostages, and to other Israelis, about the long-anticipated moment, and Isabel Kershner, a Times reporter who covers Israel and Palestine, discusses why the hostages have been such a crucial factor in efforts to end the war.Guest: Isabel Kershner, a reporter for The New York Times in Jerusalem, covering Israeli and Palestinian affairs.Background reading: Read live coverage of the hostages’ return and prisoner swap.Why now? The lost chances to reach a hostage deal, and a cease-fire, months ago.For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday.
Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. You can also subscribe via your favorite podcast app here https://www.nytimes.com/activate-access/audio?source=podcatcher. For more podcasts and narrated articles, download The New York Times app at nytimes.com/app.